r/Alcatraz • u/tedtutors • Feb 02 '12
Overuse of the ratcheting door sound effect
Dear Alcatraz makers:
I get it. The show involves two timelines and switches back and forth between them multiple times per episode. You need some way of telling the viewer that is happening.
Here's the thing though: that cell door ratcheting closed and then slamming shut? It would be cool to use it once per episode, to kind of prime the pump and tell the viewer which timeline is which. Extra points if you had the camera looking into a cell (as you often do).
Using it on nearly every transition though is just making me hate it. At this point I can tell at a glance which timeline you are in, and I'm not even paying that much attention. New viewers will get it, but if you keep up annoying stuff like this then there won't be any new viewers, right?
Sincerely,
Guy who likes the show but hates annoying repetitive stuff
update: I counted the uses of the sound effect in episode 5: 9 times, including once at the end of the intro credits. 6 times before the half-way mark of a 42 minute episode, so that door is ratcheting closed about every 3-4 minutes in that half.
If it doesn't bother you? More power to you. I wish it didn't bother me. It is overused.