r/Alcatraz • • Feb 02 '12

Overuse of the ratcheting door sound effect

0 Upvotes

Dear Alcatraz makers:

I get it. The show involves two timelines and switches back and forth between them multiple times per episode. You need some way of telling the viewer that is happening.

Here's the thing though: that cell door ratcheting closed and then slamming shut? It would be cool to use it once per episode, to kind of prime the pump and tell the viewer which timeline is which. Extra points if you had the camera looking into a cell (as you often do).

Using it on nearly every transition though is just making me hate it. At this point I can tell at a glance which timeline you are in, and I'm not even paying that much attention. New viewers will get it, but if you keep up annoying stuff like this then there won't be any new viewers, right?

Sincerely,
Guy who likes the show but hates annoying repetitive stuff

update: I counted the uses of the sound effect in episode 5: 9 times, including once at the end of the intro credits. 6 times before the half-way mark of a 42 minute episode, so that door is ratcheting closed about every 3-4 minutes in that half.

If it doesn't bother you? More power to you. I wish it didn't bother me. It is overused.


r/Alcatraz • • Feb 15 '12

The only thing that irks me about Alcatraz

0 Upvotes

is how inaccurate the show is when it comes to San Francisco. Im a 4th generation native in SF, and its little things i notice that kinda piss me off. certain locations that dont exist, real places being called the wrong thing etc.

Rebeccas character isn't a detective, in the SFPD theyre called Inspectors. they cant get the SFPD uniforms right, but they can get some of the patrol cars right. which is weird, because they make it seem like we use two different designs.

it may seem like nothing to most people, but im sure people who live in cities where other shows are based have these problems. if ya'll want specifics, lemmi know, and ill try and tell you what ive noticed.

this is also my first mainline submit, so sorry if somethings wrong with it. im still learning my way around reddit


r/Alcatraz • • Jan 23 '12

I have serious reservations about this show and I'm not quite sure if I should continue watching it. Advice please.

3 Upvotes

After watching the first 2 hours of the show, I can see myself becoming a huge fan... but here's my concern - There were so many questions left unanswered with Lost, I fear that the same will be true with this show as well. I'm watching the show, trying to pick up on clues that may become relevant 20 episodes down the road, but in the back of my mind I have a nagging suspicion that many of my questions will never be answered... thus, do I really want to invest my time into a show that will leave me dissatisfied at the end? #firstworldproblems


r/Alcatraz • • Feb 28 '12

Alcatraz Omission

Thumbnail
keswickpinhead.deviantart.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Jan 21 '12

prison at the end of episode 1

0 Upvotes

I'm pretty sure that was the same set from star wars return of the jedi. like the blast doors i mean. what do yall think?


r/Alcatraz • • Mar 28 '12

I wish we could talk about Jorge Garcia's weight. I appreciate his work, and I don't want to make jokes.

6 Upvotes

For what it's worth, I'm fat. I work out, but it's a constant issue. I'm not sure this is relevant, but I sympathize personally with the condition.

I loved him in Lost. I want all the best for him. The first time I saw him on Alcatraz, my heart fell. Maybe my visual estimate is inaccurate, but it seems to me he has gained close to 100 lbs. since his days on Lost.

I think his weight is an issue in the ratings for Alcatraz. I understand I'm likely to get voted down just for bringing this up, but I'd still like to hear your thoughts.


r/Alcatraz • • Feb 06 '12

So i'm not saying i did, but...

Thumbnail
qkme.me
15 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Jan 29 '12

Guys, I think I figured out Alcatraz.

0 Upvotes

They need to catch all of the '63 so that Hurley can pick a new protector of the Island.


r/Alcatraz • • Mar 06 '12

I keep giving Alcatraz a long leash, though I'm not sure it deserves it.

Thumbnail
cliqueclack.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Mar 05 '12

What was Hauser's plan before Madsen and Soto came along???

3 Upvotes

This is another complaint about lazy writing...

Madsen and Soto happen to almost literally stumble into Hauser's life RIGHT before the 63's began to reappear. And after much hoo-haw, they convinced Hauser to let them in on the action. Very convenient timing.

What the hell was Hauser planning on doing before they came along? Old man going to go after all the 63's on his own? Madsen and Hauser seem to do all the work catching the bad guys. As far as I can tell Hauser would not have caught a single bad guy if he was by himself.

Lazy. Writing.


r/Alcatraz • • Jan 25 '12

Theory from episode 3 (spoilers)

3 Upvotes

So after reading one of the articles on here I had a thought. What if the reason they were getting so much blood from the prisoners was to make clones. And our hero's grandfather had special blood that could be used for anyone perhaps. Or he was the elected guinia pig of Alcatraz. Also was it just me or did the doctor in present time look almost robotic. It could just be the room but he looked to pristine.


r/Alcatraz • • Jan 17 '12

I have a comment I would like to make...

0 Upvotes

I really hope that this show will go into detail and explain EVERYTHING. After Lost, I really can't stand a show that doesn't give definite answers. (Even though I know it was just really Jack's purgatory and what not.) Does anyone else agree?


r/Alcatraz • • Jan 17 '12

How the series will end

9 Upvotes

It was all just the story to a new comic book Jorge Garcia's character is writing.


r/Alcatraz • • Jan 25 '12

one does not simply

Thumbnail
quickmeme.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Feb 08 '22

If Alcatraz was made today, would Dwayne The Rock be in it?

3 Upvotes
11 votes, Feb 11 '22
6 Yes
5 No

r/Alcatraz • • Jan 18 '12

Something that bothered me about the first few minutes of pilot, but then I thought 'hmmm.' (Theory)

Thumbnail
imgur.com
13 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Feb 08 '12

This is driving me nuts: why aren't the prisoners being interrogated?

0 Upvotes

The worst part is that Rebecca doesn't even try. "Ok, so we are capturing time traveling criminals that are obviously following some kind of plan and are in possession of some weird keys, kbye!" WTF


r/Alcatraz • • Mar 06 '12

Alcatraz Ep. 1.10 “Sonny Burnett” – A Review | Alcatraz Investigation

Thumbnail
alcatrazinvestigation.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Mar 26 '12

Alcatraz Scoop: Tommy vs. Rebecca and 6 More Spoilers from the Season Finale

Thumbnail
tvguide.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Mar 27 '12

Why do none of the inmates have argyria?

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Sep 01 '12

The show was awesome, but it had it's flaws

0 Upvotes

I recently picked up the show and watched it in about two days.

I was enthralled by what caused the disapperance.

However I think that was the problem, that was really all that grabbed me.

I didn't really ever care about doc, guy from Jurassic Park and blonde detective. They had no real substance.

With every episode focused on the alcatraz inmates I ended up caring and empathising about them way more than I could about the "main characters".

Plus the writing was fucking terrible in places.

It hurts that I'll never know what'll happen to blonde detective and the scientist guy laughing, but I'll live.


r/Alcatraz • • May 10 '12

Alcatraz is cancelled, but with that JJ Abrams is airing a new TV show, Revolution. Sub here

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Sep 13 '21

Henri Young Trial.

0 Upvotes

He was defended by a young James McGuinness, who put Alcatraz on trial. (Don't look at Murder In The First as a documentary by the way)

Whatever happened to Mr. McGuinness after the trial?


r/Alcatraz • • Sep 25 '13

:(

0 Upvotes

r/Alcatraz • • Mar 06 '12

:Kappauser:

5 Upvotes