r/AlanWake • • Jun 27 '24

Discussion Anyone else underwhelmed with Nights Springs? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I hope I don’t get hate but I found the new DLC so disappointing, especially the lack of new environments and an actual expansion of the game (not just reskinning of the existing maps). I can’t help but compare it to the Control DLCs which I found much better and more interesting. I really hope they redeem themselves with Lake House, as AW2 is one of my favorite games ever and am dying for more lore.


r/AlanWake • • Dec 20 '23

Discussion I was wrong about Alan Wake 2 Spoiler

34 Upvotes

I previously made a post about how Alan Wake 2 was a boring game, I hadn't played the first Alan Wake but had played Control multiple times. I just finished Alan Wake 2 and have just started the final draft.

Alan Wake 2 is a modern masterpiece of story telling and game play and I take back anything negative I said about it previously. How the hell did a silly campy top down RTS game win game of the year over this actual masterpiece. Madness.

I'll still play BG3 eventually but man Alan Wake 2 should have been game of the year


r/AlanWake • • Oct 21 '23

General Finally High PC reqs

0 Upvotes

Someone finally had balls do do it, and give high spec insane looking game we deserve, stop trying to cry that is too high on ur 1080ti , its insanely out dated and DEV finally pushed for new gen, so hype


r/AlanWake • • Oct 07 '26

Discussion Alan Wake 1; A great story held back by mediocre gameplay Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just beat alan wake 1 and what started as a 5/10 game became a 7/10 game at the end.

Lets go through the pros first.

  1. The story
    Holy what a story. As a big fan of literature in the same vain as what the game is trying to emulate, I absolutely adored how good the story is, how much it plays off of writing tropes and subverts them as well, such as the twist that the therapist is actually lying to wake and he isn’t just making this up.
    I also adored the character writing too, Remedy clearly wanted to build up Bright Falls to be as much as a character as each person inside of it and my goodness did they succeed. The radio host, the diner, Odin and Tor, Cynthia Weaver, Sheriff Breaker, the drunk guy in the prison. Every character introduced gives life to the story, making Alan Wake feel even more isolated yet simultaneously connected.
    Additionally, the manuscript is such a cool fucking idea. Picking up a script, reading it and then 30 minutes later seeing it happen was so interesting to me, and i loved how it almost acted like “meanwhile” breaks to other characters, personifying them more. It especially does this for nightingale and despite him being only really in 4 scenes you really get a feel for who he is and his character by the manuscript pages. I love how it served as character writing and story foreshadowing.

  2. The Presentation.
    Night Springs, Radio shows, Manuscript pages, “Previously on” and unique songs for each ending of the “episode”.
    So much love was poured into making this game feel like a tv show you’d watch or a book you’d read and by god does it deliver. So many of these little things that relate to the story or add world building make this games presentation absolutely top notch. I loved the previously on sections too even just practically, it made dropping and picking up the game super easy.

  3. The visuals
    I played the remaster and graphically, this game looks amazing. Obviously the textures are dated but i like the charm it adds, however the real standout is the lighting. Day time sections in Bright Falls look peaceful and cosy, whereas the night is this dark shadow contrasted by whatever light you can find. The darkness especially looks amazing, the torch illuminating your path and sometimes being the only thing you can see was so impactful to the games tension.
    A detail i loved was that you can see the torches light peeking through slits of a wooden beam and it just really added to this visual clarity.

The cons.

  1. The first quarter.
    This is one of those few games where the beginning is actually the worst part. Those first two missions are a fucking slog to get through, and a lot of it has to do with how little you have access to.
    It is Day time segment, cutscene, go in the forest at night, cutscene, go in the forest at night, cutscene, go in the forest at night, cutscene and then “previously on alan wake”.
    The entire game is like this but i bring mention to the first quarter especially as by this point the story hasnt bared its fangs yet, and the gameplay is very monotonous. You get a revolver, level 1 flashlight and maybe a shotgun. That’s it. It also doesn’t help that this was incredibly easy too.

  2. Level design
    This is a bit of a catchall term.
    Every level is like 15% - 40% too long.
    Pretty much the entirety of the base games level catalogue always feels like it drags on for a bit too long, i always felt that I was ready for the level to be over before it actually was over.
    Additionally, enemy spawns were kind of annoying. In the first half of the game it was pretty consistent that they’d spawn behind you, which really killed the pacing even further.
    Now the worst of this is in that first quarter, it by far has the most boring gameplay loop, the least interesting story beats, and the longest feeling levels. As soon as you pick up the flares the game really starts to get going and by the last mission I was actually very engaged into it. But it still is a problem throughout the whole game. A 10 hour playthrough honestly could have been 7 and not much would have changed.

  3. This shit too easy.
    The entire time I was thinking to myself “If this game had survival horror-like resource management it would be so much more engaging”, because pretty often i would have maxed out batteries, revolver ammo and never be out of shotgun / flaregun. Enemies are a challenge when the level design compliments them but often times it kind of doesnt so theyre pretty simple. Hold down left trigger, press right trigger when done.

The interesting

The Light mechanic is incredibly cool. Having to actively dodge an enemy until theyre ready to be shot at is so unique and whilst above i did say the game is too easy, when it puts you tight quarters without much space it really adds to this tension. A big guy with an axe is slowly walking over to you and the best you can do it stare at him until you can finally shoot him, it creates such great moments. The diner in Special Episode 1 is probably the best example of this, you have to duck and weave a lot of enemies in such a tight space just to get a chance at taking shots, and with such poor gear it was a great highlight.
Speaking of…

the special episodes.

The Special Episodes are the best part of the game. Everything i said about the flaws? Gone.
It is always challenging but never bullshit, it gives you enough tools and you actually need to use them often. Both episodes are perfectly paced and they also both have such cool set pieces and story.
It is similar to how games like Elden Ring and Cyberpunk have these incredibly dense dlc’s with all the good and not as much of the bad, a perfect condensation of the gameplay and story without bloating.

To conclude,
Alan Wake 1 tells an amazing story with beautiful presentation by people who clearly love fiction of all kinds. It plays upon the tropes in fun ways with great characters and a fun plot that always had somewhere interesting to go.
Unfortunately this stands on a game with a gameplay loop that isn’t quite there. Levels are always too long, the game is too easy and by the time it finally hits its stride you have the last episode and the two special episodes.
I would recommend Alan Wake the same way i’d recommend a 7/10 tv show; watch an episode or two in bed with popcorn and a hot chocolate


r/AlanWake • • May 15 '24

I gave AWII an honest shot, and well... Spoiler

3 Upvotes

So, I haven't been able to play AWII up until now because I simply don't own a Series X or game on PC (I still game on a base Xbox One and 360). I'm a massive fan of the original game and the American Nightmare digital add-on. I even purchased the novelization of the original game, and downloaded the little live action mini series they made years ago. I stayed away as much as I could from playthroughs on YouTube as I didn't want to be spoiled in terms of story or gameplay. Happily, a friend of mine who owns both a Series X and the game let me take a spin on the game from the beginning. I felt so excited to sit down and play it, especially after hearing the rave (non-spoiler) reviews it got. I played for about three and a half hours before choosing to hang it up.

Now, before I say anything more, I just want to say that these are merely my own feelings, thoughts and opinions on the game. If you loved the game, I genuinely am glad for that. Not all games are going to appeal to everyone, and the decisions and changes Remedy made for the sequel were what they thought was best.

That being said, as much as it pains me to say, after giving it an honest chance, I find it simply is not for me. To be completely honest, I didn't like much of it. There were a few things I did like, such as the Dark Place version of NYC, and especially the updated version of Bright Falls, as the town itself was one thing I adored about the original game. Watery was also a welcome addition. And Coffee World flat out cracked me up. And I also liked the updated look of Wake, and the character of Alex Casey.

But that's about where my likes end. I will try and avoid any spoilers in my own personal criticisms. But, the massive change in tone from the first game was one thing I honestly didn't like. I very much liked the, what I can only describe as Action-Horror style of the original, over the flat out Horror style of AWII (And I say that as a horror writer myself!) Maybe it's simply because I've played the original since I was 20 years old in 2010 to now, but it was just too jarring for me. The best way to phrase it, was that it felt like it was trying to emulate the Resident Evil remakes too much. I also missed the cliche, somewhat cheesy 70s and 80s movie tone the original had as it went more serious. To me, that sort of sucked the fun out of things. The same with the whole concept of the cork board and connecting pictures together. With either Alan or Saga. It just wasn't my personal cup of tea. It slowed things down too much.

I also disliked the change in combat. Many people found the combat of the original to be tedious, but I personally liked the swarming enemy mechanics. I like the rush of panic as you swing Alan around, pointing the flashlight and trying to land your shots. Making the enemies much harder and fewer just felt less engaging and tense to me, and making them venerable bullet sponges also wasn't that enjoyable to me. In addition, I also missed the driving segments that the first game had. Again, I know others didn't enjoy them, but I personally did. Getting behind the wheel and ramming into the Taken was a highlight for me.

One other thing I wasn't a fan of either, was adding a new, playable character. I won't delve into this too much, as way too many people have muddied the waters over this as I've stumbled across YouTube videos with titles about it. Suffice to say, the actress who portrayed Saga Anderson did a great job, but, if it makes sense, in a game called Alan Wake II, his character was the one I wanted to play, not another, even if it was chosen for story direction.

Beyond that, I also missed the licensed soundtrack that the first game had. It made the game, to me at least, feel more connected to the real world, which always helps increase immersion. Plus, a game filled with songs by artists I love such as Roy Orbison, Poe, The Black Angels, Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds and more just was all that and a bag of chips. Plus, to be honest, I wasn't a big fan of the new rendition of the in game band Old Gods of Asgard. The original songs sounded genuinely like ones a 70s rock band would have put out 50 years ago; the ones I heard didn't. Maybe I didn't get far enough in to the game to find they were supposed to be new songs that the Anderson brothers recorded, but still.

Honestly, I think I would more have preferred the version of Alan Wake II we were supposed to get 11 or 12 years ago, before it was shelved. I watched that footage back again when I returned home tonight, and found myself enjoying watching it more than what I played.

Again, if you did enjoy the game, I am truly happy for you, as it makes all your lives that much more enjoyable. Please don't let my negative reaction detract from your positive one! Enjoy the game!

But, for me?

I think I'll just stick to playing the original and American Nightmare.


r/AlanWake • • Nov 03 '23

Discussion Imagine dedicating an entire level (29 mins) for a cringeworthy music video…. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Way to go.

Creating a “mid” horror game is one thing, game is far from a “piece of art” or GOTY like everyone is saying! (Guess you guys are easy to please🤷) but then dedicating tons of playtime and budget for a fucking music video segment?? What is wrong with remedy?

Not only is the real-action videos cringeworthy enough, but having a full blown rock song (which sucks ass btw) and forcing the players to walk around and watch that shit? Not only does it break ANY horror feel and immersion this game had going for it, but it downright made turn off the game and uninstalled it.

At least make it optional for people who was expecting a horror game. Not a fucking shit music video. I paid for this you know.

Cant wait to see max payne dance his way through the remakes with disco lights and rock music around him.

Also cant wait to see the Control 2 with music videos longer than the game it self. Because clearly remedy is living for this cringeworthy shit.

MAKE. IT. OPTIONAL!!!

I said my piece.


r/AlanWake • • Oct 27 '24

I'll probably catch flak for this, but I absolutely hated The Lake House from a gameplay perspective. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Liked the aesthetics overall, thought the story was short and I appreciate it didn't artificially lengthen itself, but the gameplay has so many problems I don't think I'll ever touch this again. Where to begin...

Instead of learning from Alan Wake 2's mistakes and its worst aspect, the dumb random jumpscares, Remedy decided to double down on jumpscares. Now we don't just get Alan Wake jumpscares, we also now have Slenderman jumpscares. And now we have Inception music along with it too! Except it's not just a jumpscare, it's also an automatic unpredictable grab attack that will kill you if you don't have much health...

I was straight up stuck in the maze for like an hour constantly reloading because I was low on health, I was getting empty container after empty container finding no health. Six times in a row, a Painted nemy would jump out of the same wall, grabbing me and instantly killing me. Maybe I'm blind, but I see no sign the Painted enemy is there ready to grab me. I tried to fire a launcher into that wall, did nothing. Then, seventh time, the enemy suddenly wasn't there. How fun, you have a chance of dying to a random event.

Not sure if the intention is to run past all Painted enemies, because the launcher ammo is so scarce that if you kill 2 Painted while backtracking for collectibles, you will not have enough to get through the maze. The maze only gives you 1 round at the start, and up to 3 Painted would regularly spawn in the maze, so I basically just had to make a run for it. The base game didn't have this problem of running past encounters because there was always enough exploration to regain your resources. Here that's not the case, exploration gives you almost no resources and you have fewer tools to use. I'm really not sure what the game expects of me, it gives me a weapon to kill the Painted but then makes the ammo so scarce that if the game decides to spawn too many Painted, you literally cannot kill them and just have to make a run for it.

Overall, I enjoyed The Lake House and I'm glad I experienced it, but I never want to touch it again.


r/AlanWake • • Dec 17 '23

The lack of autosave is ridiculous and dumb

2 Upvotes

I've been soft locked numerous times, and the only solution is to force close the game and lose 25 minutes worth of progress. Other developers seem to have enough sense and understanding that their games will break or hangup throughout the game, which is why the reload from checkpoint feature is so useful.

This system they've employed is inherently disrespectful to the players time because the only to initiate a save is through the Witch's cabin. Whatever, I'll be back whenever they decide to fix these critical bugs and the lip-syncing. What a joke, no wonder it only cost $25.


r/AlanWake • • Jul 28 '25

Discussion I don't understand the combat design of Alan Wake II Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I just completed AW2, and I loved the plot, graphics and overall ambience. The world and its representation perfectly pulls off a mixture of mystery, drama, horror and even slapstick-esque-comedy. But. But.

I have literally no idea what they were attempting to do with this game's combat system. In 9 out of 10 engagements in the game, my gut reaction to every fight was "let this shit end, so I can get back to the story and exploration where I actually have fun and want to know what's going on". There's just so much wrong with this game's combat loop that I'm not even sure where to start.

THE FLASHLIGHT

For whatever reason, this mechanic was completely ruined from the first game. There, you could remove the darkness from enemies without boosting the flashlight on them. In AW2, this is no longer the case. This means that **there is no tactical decision whether to use the flashlight boost -**you simply must use it. What is worse is that the batteries are drained incredibly quickly, making it feel like a really annoying gimmick as well.

Often, playing with mouse and keyboard, I would miss part of the flashlight boost since it also does not properly aim where I point it (and shows no targeting reticule). All in all a pretty awful mechanic which was done much better in the first game. I also never ran out of batteries, since enemies would keep dropping them if I ran out. That means it was pretty pointless to have the batteries as a resource in the first place. Why not just charge the flashlight by repeatedly tapping a key, or have the boost on a cooldown? Very awkward mechanic.

ALAN IS TIRED

Both Alan and Saga control slowly, deliberately and a little jerkily. When you are exploring or talking to people, this is not an issue - it feels intentional and helps the investigative mood. But oh boy does it become an issue when you're in combat. Now, some attacks are unavoidable, because your dodge has no iframes (it works like dodging in real life, in other words), which gameplay balance -wise is not a huge issue, but it feels like ass to be on the receiving end of an attack since you simply cannot move effectively in many situations.

The enemies teleport like mad, attack with unexpected patterns and frequently shrug off injuries (I once shot a wolf point-blank with a shotgun and it literally did not react at all). I mean sure, you can always argue that enemies not reacting to your guns is because of the darkness, but that still won't change the fact that ineffective weapons simply do not feel satisfying to use.

TOO MANY GOODIES

I played on standard difficulty. I was surprised that the player character has relatively little health, which is great for tension... or it would be, if there wouldn't be so many safe rooms, explosives and automatic checkpoints. Death loses its meaning because you never really need to backtrack in this game if you die - which is good in the sense that you will never become stuck for long - but it also makes the combat seem kind of pointless. Die in combat? Just do that same combat encounter immediately. Yay!

I'll be the first to admit that I wasn't really that good at this game's combat. Somehow, it never "clicked" for me. It just feels janky, like the character doesn't fully do what I command them to do. Despite this, by the endgame, my shoebox was full of explosives and healing items. These vast supplies AND the frequent save points removed all tension from the combat for me. It was nothing but annoying stopgaps on the way to see more of the story.

IT'S ALL THE SAME

Most of the game's combat encounters only include shadow dudes who want to melee you. There are wolves, the drowned ladies, and bosses are also all quite unique. But for this much combat, a little more variety would have gone a long way.

HOW COULD THIS HAVE BEEN IMPROVED?

There are basically 2 appropriate combat design directions that can be taken for a horror/detective/mystery game like AW2. The game doesn't really do either of them, at least not properly. The first one is power fantasy and the second is tense horror.

In a power fantasy, your character must feel powerful and be very capable. This was essentially how combat worked in the first Alan Wake (and how it typically works in other Remedy titles, most notably Max Paynes). This would have necessitated far better movement, faster reloads and a less janky flashlight. This approach probably wouldn't have been the right one for AW2, since there's such a massive focus on tension and horror.

But in tense horror (think Resident Evils, Signalis, Silent Hill etc.) the player above all must be allowed to fail, but the failure must be unlikely. AW2 fumbles both of these: you can't really fail (there are too many safe rooms and supplies, and even avoiding enemies is too easy for Alan) and dying is too easy (you have little health) which means that taking risks can quite easily kill you. Die enough times, death becomes trivialized. So what should they have done? Increase player health, drastically reduce loot drops, make enemies slower and teleport less (or at all, unless if it's a special enemy type), remove a safe house or two, and above all make the non-boosted flashlight a possible option against enemies (but ineffective).

As it stands now, AW2's combat doesn't make me feel powerful, it often doesn't feel fair, your character moves like a 70-year-old grandma, and it doesn't punish you as much as it should. Respawning enemies are also a drag in a game where you explore previously visited areas this frequently, but I personally think that's only a minor issue in this game.

CONCLUSION

I really enjoyed AW2. It's a great story and a unique artistic vision. But the combat is a letdown. I never could get into that part of the game. I never found enjoyment with it. This was pretty surprising for me since I enjoyed both Max Paynes and Control. This just always felt "off".


r/AlanWake • • Aug 13 '26

Screenshot Just finished Alan Wake 2 and honesly one of the best looking games (if not the best) Ive ever played 8/10. Cut 2 points for the booring ass mind place

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/AlanWake • • Oct 02 '23

The thermos distribution is a complete mess and they should feel ashamed for this

3 Upvotes

I’ve been aware of the Finnish shop for days and didn’t order thinking the shipment would be cheaper on Amazon as soon as the thermos are available there, as promised. Now they’re sold out on the only website that ever sold them, which didn’t even have a single non-Finnish version of its online store.

What a mess. The amount I refreshed that Amazon website, all for nothing. Fuck this


r/AlanWake • • Jul 02 '24

Discussion Alan Wake 2 vs Baldur's Gate III

0 Upvotes

Edit: I apologize if this upset any BG fans. I do understand that these games (and games in general) cannot be compared and that game awards tend to be biased/political. I posted this just after having learned that AW2 wasn't even mentioned at the Gayming Awards 2024 (whereas BG took GOTY among others) for which I couldn't find the reason. Thank you to everyone who posted their opinion (especially to all of you who had a kind attitude), I'm happy to see how mature and positive this community is.

Not to ruffle any feathers but am I the only one who thinks the wins awarded to AW2 were criminally few compared to the likes of BG3?

I've been interacting with BG minimally (it just didn't have as big a draw for me as Alan Wake), while I've been a fan of AW for several years now. It's probably like comparing apples and oranges - yet, when one checks their awards nominations and wins, it's pretty apparent how much better BG did in that area.

I find this very disappointing. I think AW was equally (if not more) impressive and innovative, and even if they both deserved GOTY, AW should have received more awards, especially for music. The cast was also marvelous, and it's sad to see how few awards they got for the roles they played compared to BG.

Just one of the many examples here.


r/AlanWake • • Dec 28 '23

Goodbye Alan Wake ❤️ Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Hello first time posting long time lurking

So let me just start with saying I'm a huge huge fan of Remedy, and love the original Alan Wake and 2, but this will be my last Alan Wake I will not be buying the Expansions I will probably watch someone play it. Thing is I was very enthusiastic to play through the game a million times but I have this thing when I get scared suddenly(jumpscares) my heart starts hurting it feels like when you pull a muscle. It sucks because even after all this I freaking love this game when I completed the chapter and the game last night I felt nothing but love for it, but for my sake this will be the last time I probably play Alan wake 2 + whatever comes next. I would love if there was an option to turn off the jumpscares volume at the minimum but regardless glad I completed this beautiful game, and will always follow what anything Remedy does heck I might just buy the expansions to support them and not play them but instead watch some loud streamer play through it.

Edit: After reading most of your comments I will see a doctor as soon as I'm stable enough, unfortunately I dont have insurance. For now I'll take peoples advice and try it with hyperacusis mode and see if it works.


r/AlanWake • • Mar 31 '24

Discussion Sweet Baby inc. (NOT a hate post) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Ok I know it's a really hot topic right now, but I had a thought and was wondering what other people thought. Hopefully it can remain civil.

Without trying to throw shade at SBI, why do you think they were hired for Alan Wake 2?

I feel like Remedy has always done a good job with representation, and being respectful towards their characters. Of all the companies that might need help with such things, they don't quite seem like it.

It makes me wonder, was hiring sweet baby inc. possibly a condition to their funding? Were they just trying to be super careful? I can't wait wrap my head around it.


r/AlanWake • • Nov 08 '24

Discussion Alan Wake 1 and 2 are what I thought “Twin Peaks” was going to be like… Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I know that Sam Lake has stated that he is a big fan of Twin Peaks, and I can see a lot of the references in his work.

This maybe an unpopular opinion but I believe Sam did Twin Peaks better?! In regards to the Remedyverse so far, the direction the series has taken has been more consistent and cohesive than the series, movies, etc of the Twin Peaks story.

It definitely is a “Twin peaks walked so Alan Wake could sprint” situation in that without Twin Peaks you wouldn’t have the other.

That being said where I felt disappointed in David Lynch’s decisions with Twin Peaks. The direction they have gone with Control, Alan Wake I find refreshing and even though confusing at times, much more worth the pay off and build up of narrative.

I guess I’m wondering if anyone agrees? Loved both series for similar or different reasons? Think Twin Peaks superior?


r/AlanWake • • Oct 08 '26

Discussion Alan Wake 2 > Control Resonant Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Dont get me wrong. Control Resonant is a fantastic game. But it fell short of the remedy experience that i wanted.

I couldnt shake the fact that i got more out of my 7 hours with my first playthrough of Alan wake 2 over the 30 i had with resonant.

The world was cool af, combat a bit meh, characters were also lacking. I didnt feel that much weight in the story as well. The patterning is amazing for a few hours, but it gets a little samey near the end. And we fight literal flying gears in the end.

Just goes to show how much Sam Lake adds to these projects. Still had fun, but not Remedy games mind blown.


r/AlanWake • • May 12 '26

My boyfriend started Alan Wake 2 and the real Dark Presence is the PS5 build Spoiler

0 Upvotes

My boyfriend recently started playing Alan Wake 2 on PlayStation 5, and he’s been running into bug after bug. NPCs keep getting stuck in geometry/textures, weird pathing issues happen pretty often, and overall the build feels surprisingly unstable.

The strange part is that I played the game around launch and don’t remember having these kinds of problems at all. My experience back then was much smoother.

Has anyone else noticed this recently on PS5? Did something happen with one of the newer patches, or is he just extremely unlucky with bugs?


r/AlanWake • • Feb 11 '24

Disappointed in Alan Wake 2 Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Finished Alan Wake 2 couple days ago and to be honest wasn't really that impressed with the game. Graphics and story were great but I feel like the gameplay was pretty average and I don't like that they made the game survival horror. The first game I find was way better. Story was a bit more in depth in the second game but I absolutely HATED the investigation board. It was so boring and most of it seemed extremely unnecessary and we were forced to do it. Like I feel the game was decent but honestly felt like it was a bit boring and I expected more. Would like to hear others thoughts on it. Went back to finish Control now to get all up to speed on the other bits of the story.


r/AlanWake • • Feb 02 '26

Question Alan Wake 2 is so good that... Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I'm seriously considering buying the remaster Alan wake
If someone asked me "Do you recommend Alan Wake 1 to start?", I'd say NO!
It's a boring, tedious game and a shooter with an incredible atmosphere, but it was a failed experiment from Remedy for me!
Some people love it, but I hate it.

However, Alan Wake 2 has impressed me so much that I'm even tempted to buy the remaster, even though I understand they didn't add any improvements from American Nightmare, which for me was a huge mistake because that expansion's gameplay upgrades would have made the original so much better...But I don't know...
Did you guys buy it? Is it just the same as the first one but with Alan's skin changed?


r/AlanWake • • Aug 12 '24

Just finished Alan Wake 2 and man i loved it. But i do have some complaints. The sense of direction annoyed the hell outta me most of the time, and usually That really took me out of the story. Spoiler

10 Upvotes

Everything felt heavily inspired by Twin Peaks the Return. I loved the horror elements but sometimes i wished i got a hint of where i needed to go, i looked like crazy on the map. I love a puzzle now and then but it drove me crazy having to look for a walkhtrough to contine


r/AlanWake • • Apr 07 '26

Discussion [AW2] A fan-favorite moment did not resonate with me but a less discussed one did Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So, Herald of Darkness...

Technically, it's a good song (I am especially fond of the chorus), but I don't think the musical sequence in the game was all that good, honestly. I really enjoyed the initial talk show segment (interview) so it's not like I am totally opposed to wackiness. I just feel HoD didn't naturally fit the story, like they wanted to "force" a musical moment on Alan's side without really judging if it fit the tone or if it made sense. I know the justifications, the lore - I 100%d the game - but I am still puzzled at why people are so fond of this moment beyond "it's creative and goofy".

Meanwhile, I absolutely adored the Dark Ocean Summoning moment. It's the opposite of what I described: it fits way more naturally into the story, doesn't drag (unlike HoD), is generally better to listen to (only loses to HoD in terms of chorus, rest DoO is better) and provides a perfect blend of high-stakes gameplay with immense narrative pay off, becoming one of my favorite moments in the medium.

Really, the *only* small thing that would have made it perfect for me was everything around the stage calming down, at the end of the song, as Alan himself walked right out of the waters of the lake (not like parting the waters but as if he was crossing a swirling portal in the lake itself). But I digress, the narrative choice they took was fine too!

I think if the game had ended shortly after the summoning, it would have done so after a very satisfying crescendo. By prolonging it a few more chapters, it lost some steam and didn't manage to recover again, even if it wasn't bad still.

Does anyone else not resonate with Herald of Darkness?


r/AlanWake • • Nov 02 '23

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Alan Wake 2 was a big let-down Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Last night finished playing Alan Wake 2. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed revisiting Bright Falls and I've been waiting for 13 years to get my hands on. But there are some things that Alan Wake 2 did WORSE than the last game. The whole plot was a bit off, the Murder mysteries of Alan Wake in Dark Place are so out of context.

First of all, Bright Falls and all the locations are meh. The world seems very small and we're 2 generations ahead of Xbox360. Where's the Lover's Peak, the Elderwood National Park and the other magnificent places we visited in the first game? Now it's only the Bright Falls waterfront and the Watery, the environment are just meh it's only forests. Even the Dark Place on the DLCs was very different and not just a NY plaza.

Second, most of the iconic game 1 characters have new voice actors including Rose. Where's Barry?

Third, Mr Scratch didn't seem like an antagonist throughout the game. American Nightmare made it very clear and formed a very specific portrait of the character, where we only get a glimpse of it on the Zane hotel room while playing "The Happy Song".

Fourth, I think that music-wise the game is poor. It has some very good tunes, but Petri Allanko's tunes for the first game are top-notch. Where's the iconic "The Clicker" that was on every Alice Scene?

Last but not least, why change some of the iconic places like the Alan Wake's NY apartment?

Ending also felt like a big rip-off, and the whole ending sequence as a whole


r/AlanWake • • Oct 20 '23

Discussion Are digital only releases as bad as we think?

2 Upvotes

I love collecting physical games.

But Here’s some facts.

  • In 2022, 94% of all games sold were digital.

  • Meanwhile, 72% of all console games sold were digital.

If only 28% of console games sold are digital, how does everyone online seem to be complaining about not wanting or supporting digital games?

I think it’s likely that one physical game sold is being played by 3-4 players on average. So sales are lower, but gamers affected are more or less similar.

However, studios are likely losing money on these physical releases. An average AAA game budget just in 2010 was roughly $20M while today they average > $60M. Game prices on the other hand have only increased from $60 to $70.

Does it not make sense that studios don’t want to support physical games because we won’t buy them for $100 and if they sell at $70 they’re probably taking away from the revenue they would’ve made from digital sales.

I love collecting physical media but I can’t help but empathise with studios for trying to move away from them.

What do you think?


r/AlanWake • • Jan 21 '24

Just finished Alan Wake 2. I don’t understand the universal praise. Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Let me first say the game has insanely high production value. The graphics are stunning, the lighting effects are often stellar, I think the mixing of live action is done well. It would be hard to argue with those aspects. The rest of the game? I think it’s average at best.

The combat is repetitive with very little enemy variety or mechanics to make the fights interesting. Almost all enemy encounters play out the same way, with a few exceptions.

The Mind Place is a unique mechanic at first, but given you can’t place evidence in the wrong place it just starts to feel like a chore. The questioning mechanic is also quite drawn out and doesn’t feel like you’re being a detective but rather following ‘click here to progress the story. Now click here to progress it a little more.’

Movement in the game is SLOW. Traversing these maps is a slog, and the fact that you have to retrace your steps so many times only makes it worse. Why does Alan have to go back to the hotel so many times? He’s in an alternate dimension, it would’ve been great if they made use of more unique locations.

The story isn’t as brilliant as many make it out to be. It’s one of those convoluted, psychological, “deep” stories that ultimately follows familiar tropes about darkness and light. I wasn’t moved by it or compelled beyond the first few chapters when it was all new to me. I think the game’s story failed to deliver on the potential it had early on with Saga finding the first few pages of the manuscript and learning about the Dark Place. I think the highlight of the story is everything with Saga and Nightingale at the beginning.

One other element that really bothered me was the director being in the game. Look, I get it, have a cameo. That’s cool. But by the end it became a self indulgent mess. It’s seems to me Sam Lake wants nothing more than to be a movie star and have his face be known. Seriously the theatre level had his face plastered on every corner of the building. All the ‘misty detective’ moments. The live action shots. The musical sequence that featured him heavily. Imagine if Neil Druckmann had done this in TLOU. He would have received endless shit for it (and rightfully so).

Is this a straight-up bad game? No. But is it an unequivocal masterpiece? Also no.

That being said, if you loved it, more power to you!