I just completed AW2, and I loved the plot, graphics and overall ambience. The world and its representation perfectly pulls off a mixture of mystery, drama, horror and even slapstick-esque-comedy. But. But.
I have literally no idea what they were attempting to do with this game's combat system. In 9 out of 10 engagements in the game, my gut reaction to every fight was "let this shit end, so I can get back to the story and exploration where I actually have fun and want to know what's going on". There's just so much wrong with this game's combat loop that I'm not even sure where to start.
THE FLASHLIGHT
For whatever reason, this mechanic was completely ruined from the first game. There, you could remove the darkness from enemies without boosting the flashlight on them. In AW2, this is no longer the case. This means that **there is no tactical decision whether to use the flashlight boost -**you simply must use it. What is worse is that the batteries are drained incredibly quickly, making it feel like a really annoying gimmick as well.
Often, playing with mouse and keyboard, I would miss part of the flashlight boost since it also does not properly aim where I point it (and shows no targeting reticule). All in all a pretty awful mechanic which was done much better in the first game. I also never ran out of batteries, since enemies would keep dropping them if I ran out. That means it was pretty pointless to have the batteries as a resource in the first place. Why not just charge the flashlight by repeatedly tapping a key, or have the boost on a cooldown? Very awkward mechanic.
ALAN IS TIRED
Both Alan and Saga control slowly, deliberately and a little jerkily. When you are exploring or talking to people, this is not an issue - it feels intentional and helps the investigative mood. But oh boy does it become an issue when you're in combat. Now, some attacks are unavoidable, because your dodge has no iframes (it works like dodging in real life, in other words), which gameplay balance -wise is not a huge issue, but it feels like ass to be on the receiving end of an attack since you simply cannot move effectively in many situations.
The enemies teleport like mad, attack with unexpected patterns and frequently shrug off injuries (I once shot a wolf point-blank with a shotgun and it literally did not react at all). I mean sure, you can always argue that enemies not reacting to your guns is because of the darkness, but that still won't change the fact that ineffective weapons simply do not feel satisfying to use.
TOO MANY GOODIES
I played on standard difficulty. I was surprised that the player character has relatively little health, which is great for tension... or it would be, if there wouldn't be so many safe rooms, explosives and automatic checkpoints. Death loses its meaning because you never really need to backtrack in this game if you die - which is good in the sense that you will never become stuck for long - but it also makes the combat seem kind of pointless. Die in combat? Just do that same combat encounter immediately. Yay!
I'll be the first to admit that I wasn't really that good at this game's combat. Somehow, it never "clicked" for me. It just feels janky, like the character doesn't fully do what I command them to do. Despite this, by the endgame, my shoebox was full of explosives and healing items. These vast supplies AND the frequent save points removed all tension from the combat for me. It was nothing but annoying stopgaps on the way to see more of the story.
IT'S ALL THE SAME
Most of the game's combat encounters only include shadow dudes who want to melee you. There are wolves, the drowned ladies, and bosses are also all quite unique. But for this much combat, a little more variety would have gone a long way.
HOW COULD THIS HAVE BEEN IMPROVED?
There are basically 2 appropriate combat design directions that can be taken for a horror/detective/mystery game like AW2. The game doesn't really do either of them, at least not properly. The first one is power fantasy and the second is tense horror.
In a power fantasy, your character must feel powerful and be very capable. This was essentially how combat worked in the first Alan Wake (and how it typically works in other Remedy titles, most notably Max Paynes). This would have necessitated far better movement, faster reloads and a less janky flashlight. This approach probably wouldn't have been the right one for AW2, since there's such a massive focus on tension and horror.
But in tense horror (think Resident Evils, Signalis, Silent Hill etc.) the player above all must be allowed to fail, but the failure must be unlikely. AW2 fumbles both of these: you can't really fail (there are too many safe rooms and supplies, and even avoiding enemies is too easy for Alan) and dying is too easy (you have little health) which means that taking risks can quite easily kill you. Die enough times, death becomes trivialized. So what should they have done? Increase player health, drastically reduce loot drops, make enemies slower and teleport less (or at all, unless if it's a special enemy type), remove a safe house or two, and above all make the non-boosted flashlight a possible option against enemies (but ineffective).
As it stands now, AW2's combat doesn't make me feel powerful, it often doesn't feel fair, your character moves like a 70-year-old grandma, and it doesn't punish you as much as it should. Respawning enemies are also a drag in a game where you explore previously visited areas this frequently, but I personally think that's only a minor issue in this game.
CONCLUSION
I really enjoyed AW2. It's a great story and a unique artistic vision. But the combat is a letdown. I never could get into that part of the game. I never found enjoyment with it. This was pretty surprising for me since I enjoyed both Max Paynes and Control. This just always felt "off".