r/AlanMoore • u/Landon1195 • Jun 09 '25
r/AlanMoore • u/[deleted] • Jul 24 '22
where to download alan moore storytelling coures online maestro for free?
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • Oct 08 '25
A quick reminder that Watchmen lies to you
I was browsing r/watchmen and came across a “Hot Takes” thread where my ‘name’ came up (I’m banned there) and felt it was time to remind some Moore fans that Watchmen straight lies to you.
Let’s play a game.
Google the following: “What year did Sally Jupiter marry Larry Schexnayder?”
Every source will tell you 1947. Because that’s the year that Hollis Mason claims it happened in his autobiography. He makes this claim twice. 1947.
Yet if you see Larry’s letter above where he actually proposes, it is dated 1948.
This is not a printing error.
Now…this may seem like no big deal, and really it isn’t…’47, ‘48, who cares right?
However, this is just one small example from many that I have found in this book.
Stop gobbling up Moore’s lies.
(P.S. Larry Schexnayder IS Hooded Justice.)
r/AlanMoore • u/Arbak_m • May 24 '24
For anyone struggling with handwritten scribbles in Providence - use ChatGPT 4o to transcribe!
Alan Moore's Providence is fantastic, both the comic parts and the text. Contrary to what some might say, the diary notes are not skippable as they often contain important pieces of info, but they can be a drag to read. Especially in later volumes, there are 10-20 pages of it, making it time-consuming and like decrypting homework.
Fortunately, the latest OpenAI model can transcribe any handwritten text with minimal mistakes—just a few misinterpreted letters here and there, nothing that breaks the overall meaning.
Sample: Imgur link
Hope this will save you time as well and make reading a breeze again!
Note: PDF consisting multiple pages didn't work, at least in chatGPT. So just have to upload images/screenshots one by one and can read right there.
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • May 17 '26
The Final Argument - Larry Schexnayder is Hooded Justice
Alright ya’ll, this is it. My final post at r/alanmoore.
You will no longer hear from me after today.
The case that I have presented makes much more sense than Rolf Muller as Hooded Justice. In fact, if we believe Hollis Mason, then it is impossible for Rolf Muller to be Hooded Justice. I explain in my final argument.
Don’t let Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons fool you any longer. The gag should finally come to an end.
Cheers! I wish you all the best, genuinely!
r/AlanMoore • u/[deleted] • Aug 04 '24
What are the best Alan Moore movies you can suggest?
I have only seen the constantine movie and show and the killing joke
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • May 01 '26
Alan Moore says there was only one timeline goof in Watchmen.
In the past, I have brought up timeline “blunders” but also asserted that I did not believe they were truly mistakes. I believed they were inconsistencies made in universe, not by the author’s hand out of universe.
Most of you just laugh at me and say “Bro Alan Moore isn’t infallible.” even though I never even make that claim.
Well, here we have Moore from a 1988 Roundtable discussion where Moore says that after looking it over, he only found one true mistake and that was giving Laurie two birthdates.
So this means…
When Hollis Mason consistently gets dates and times wrong…Sally and Larry’s wedding, Hollis calling himself 46 in 1960 when he should only be 44 in 1960, etc, as well as other timeline discrepancies I’ve found…
These mistakes are actually a story detail, not an error of the author.
I am so glad to have this handy as I will probably be linking this thread out a ton in the future.
You: Alan Moore probably just goofed.
Me: According to him, no he did not.
r/AlanMoore • u/Sharp_Eye5711 • Dec 06 '23
Alan Moore & Eurocentrism Spoiler
Before I begin, I am just discussing the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen comics. I am citing YouTubers KyleKallegrenBHH, heybuwan, and BlackAutMedia for a lot of what is in here.
I am Chinese American, and I have not read Moore's other works yet, but now, I'm not sure I want to.
Ready?
Here we go.
I think Moore's problem when writing POC is lazy arrogance. He's very Eurocentric.
I find this in a lot of British writers is that they approach other cultures (many of which have been victims of British Imperialism) with a lazy arrogance, and they just use it as set dressing without any deeper thought.
EX: SUN WUKONG. The Great Sage Equal to Heaven, who ascended to Buddhahood, has been killed and is now a stuffed attraction.
It's funny how Moore hates on Rowling (which is justified), but he makes the same mistakes as Rowling in writing POC and non-British cultures.
Rowling: "I'm just going to lump all of Africa into one school cause I don't know how many people live there or the differences between them. I'm just going to lump all of Asia into one school in Japan, I'm sure they're forgiving for Japan's WWII war crimes against them. I'm going to give non-British characters nonsensical names that are based on word association."
Moore: "I'm going to use racist caricatures as characters in my story, but only as Big Ads, but backup support characters. I'm going to include Arabs and Chinese characters in my story, and all of them are going to be ugly men obsessed with SA the only white woman here. These people live in dirty slums, and Chinatown in Britain is a hub for crime and rats of both kinds. Chinatown is filled with gangs and foreign magicians who are working to destroy the Empire. I'm also going to make the only non-white hero an angry Indian who's only major characteristic is hating on the British Empire."
If you want an obvious example: the Golliwog.
Moore: "The idea that it is not the place of two white men to ‘reclaim’ (although I’m not certain that’s exactly what we were doing) or otherwise utilise a contentious black character, unless I am to understand that this principle only applies to white men using black characters, would appear to be predicated upon an assumption that no author or artist should presume to use characters who are of a different race to themselves."
Moore has tried to defend his presentation of the character, but he's getting it wrong when he says the problem is the white man writing black people (which is a major problem that needs to be fixed). The problem here is that he is using a racist caricature for set dressing, and is doing nothing with him except as a helpful tool for the main White British couple. He could have given the Golliwog an opportunity to be a character of his own, but all he gives is a basic backstory: the Golliwog is an alien from an enslaved race.
And the thing is that you can use a racist caricature for the basis of a character and then deconstruct it successfully.
For example: Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' Splinter/Lou Jitsu/Hamato Yoshi is a 'rat', which is a slur used against East Asians. Lou Jitsu serves as a satire/critique of the Hollywood exploitation of East Asian actors and martial artists for white entertainment. Splinter's entire arc is about Americans exploiting him for what he can do for them, and him eventually coming to his own.
What differs Splinter from the Golliwog is that Splinter is given the actual time and effort to grow and be a character. The Golliwog was just a one-note gag character, who is only explained in a footnote.
Look at Nemo. He is a Sikh Indian, but we don't see his race outside of the context of the British Empire. Whenever his race is brought up, it's for Nemo to spew justified contempt for the empire and Western practices (divorce), but that's it. We don't see him practicing Sikhism, or his opinions on cultural hubs (Chinatown) where immigrants can make a safe place in a foreign country that tries to exterminate them. Even the Nemo miniseries is about how his family line benefits Europe.
Compare that to Pavitr Prabhakar from the Spider-verse. Just in his introduction, Prabhakar only throws shade at the British imperialism and occupation once and at the end, and the rest of his intro is dedicated towards his daily schedule, his love of animals, his Maya Auntie, his love of chai, his dismay at the use of the term "chai tea", his girlfriend, etc. Later, we learn he hates Western culture cliches about India ("Don't Eat, Pray, & Love me, bro!).
What differs Pavitr Prabhakar from Nemo is that he has a life outside of hating on Britain.
Moore's presentation of Arabs is just disgusting.
In the original book, Nemo is part Arab, and he takes great pride in his mixed heritage. He is a descendant of Tipu Sultan of Mysore, a Muslim ruler invented and used rockets and developed automatons.
Moore had the chance to be diverse and accurate, but decided to retcon an iconic antihero and make him a rage-filled bigot.
Also, the fact that the men are trying to SA Mina is both misogynistic and racist. Many racist terrorist groups justify their murders and crimes by saying "we're protecting white women" (which is BS. Look at the KKK and Madge Augustine Oberholtzer). I also want to point out how we find Alan Quartermaine in an opium den, like the "Arab opium" is corrupting his "strong white spirit".
Don't even get me started on Q'mar.
I don't even want to know what Moore was thinking when he picked FU MANCHU as the Chinese Kingpin.
Moore did not humanize the Chinese immigrants. To him, Chinatown is a rat-infested slum filled with rat-faced men who are engaging in black magic in the midst of a gang war. The only Chinese British character that is portrayed positively is the one who helps the White British heroes fight his countrymen, the group that is inadvertently helping a madman destroy Chinatown.
Apparently, Moore can't be bothered to research Africa, and Ayesha is the only "African" we have to reference. Moore's "Africa" is a mix of Egypt and Saharan Desert, which is lazy and depressing. Moore could have used Ayesha to deconstruct the racist hierarchy where white people rule over POC, and how certain evils persist past generations and give Janni and extra motivation for hating Ayesha, and she could have shared her father's hatred for colonizers.
What's also weird is how Alan uses only men to represent cultural groups. Yes, we get Janni Dakkar, but it feels more like she's the exception than the rule. At least Rowling included more than one woman of color (that's not a high standard to measure by, but please do more than the barest bare minimum). Cho Chang is obviously an oriental character, but at least she has some (superficial) substance. The Patil twins are also oriental, but they have relationships and likes and dislikes that provides the barest characterization that Moore is desperately grasping for.
TL;DR: Moore is Eurocentric and it shows heavily. Other writers have done what he's attempted and did it better. Apparently, Rowling may be better at writing racial representation than he is.
KyleKallegrenBHH made a video about it. I'll link it down below.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wga87CDRyog
EDIT: Ok, I read the comments, and I realize that what I posted wasn’t really phrased correctly and was insulting. I decided to clarify on some things.
Since this post, I have decided to look into Watchmen and the Killing Joke, and I don’t think Alan Moore is a bad writer. I just think that when he neglects certain details, it came be problematic. I’m not trying to attack you or say you should cancel him, and I am happy for you if his work is what helped you in a dark period of your life. I just don’t believed he should be praised as the only person who “sees the truth”.
I decided to specify that I was Chinese, since due to previous online discussions about a similar topic, I was accused of being a white woman who was anti-representation. I apologize that I didn’t previously give the context for my statement.
My main problem with the elements I mentioned could be attributed to my personal preferences and the lack of time within the narrative. Maybe if some story elements were given more time to breathe, Moore could have explored some concepts more thoroughly. He does have interesting ideas and very valid argument about the entertainment industr.
I know that the Spider-Man and TMNT franchise are both problematic in their history of representation and orientalism. They were just the closest analogies I could think of at the moment. I will admit that this post was not very thought out, and I’m sorry that I failed to account for other opinions and fiction.
When I make the comparison to Rowling, I am not lauding her. I think her racism is a lot worst that the average one’s because she fundamentally doesn’t understand what racism is. What I wanted to say was that by introducing women of color in her work, she managed to unintentionally portray POC as more than monoliths of violet men who want to harm white women. From reading Watchmen, I do think that Alan Moore understands how to write racism and other systemic problems better than Rowling, but in LXG, it felt that he eventually sidelined them for a meta-narrative.
My problem with Moore’s approach of POC is that he never balanced it out. It feels like Hollywood representation of LGBTQ character, how a majority of them are white cismale homosexuals, and there is only one gay couple, the rest of the world is straight. Moore doesn’t balance out Fu Manchu with another Chinese character, and in some instance, he ignored some more problematic stuff. The Avengers were made with the intent to show a 60s fantasy, meaning one of the production guidelines was no POC, and it featured some orientalist costumes and characters in certain episodes. The fact that Moore never showed this felt inaccurate to me.
r/AlanMoore • u/OhShuxTarzan • Oct 25 '23
Didn’t like the first watchmen book
So, I’m somewhat new to Alan Moore. I’ve read from hell and several of the league of extraordinary gentleman series and really loved them. Today I stopped into a book store and got before watchmen: Comedian and Rorschach and ripped through the book. Long story short, I thought it was really pointless compared to other books in the Moore universe. Although I enjoyed Rorschach, I guess.
I wanted to pick up watchmen but I’m thinking it just might not be my thing based off the first book. Anyone else have this experience? Maybe I’ll just go right to V for vendetta instead.
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • Mar 28 '26
Mothman was Moloch Part 2 - KEY detail added
Awhile ago, I posted about how Mothman was actually Moloch (https://www.reddit.com/r/AlanMoore/s/OuhR1pRt0Z) in the comic book ‘Watchmen’.
Though the Minutemen would inspire true vigilantism in their protege, The Comedian, as well as the generation following them, the original group was nothing but cosplaying (again, save for Eddie).
When I made that post, I missed a key detail that further proves the two are the same.
In picture 1, we see that Mothman and “the John” who sleeps with Rorschach’s mom are the same exact person. Same face, same hair. Exact.
In picture 2, we see the design of the John’s socks and his liquor of choice.
In picture 3, we see Eddie digging through Moloch’s drawer for alcohol, and we see that the sock design and alcohol of choice are EXACTLY the same as the sock design and alcohol of choice of the John.
In picture 4, we see Rorschach’s sock design which looks nothing like the sock design for Moloch/the John, so you can’t say “I bet Gibbons drew all socks like that.”
No, he did not.
I didn’t include a picture 5, but there’s all sorts of examples of liquor in the book that DO NOT look like the bottle that Moloch/the John use. So again, Gibbons intentionally drew those the same.
I don’t know why this community or r/watchmen is afraid of the truth.
For 40 years, you have been bamboozled. If some of you smart folks (you’re probably all smarter than me and I’m not being facetious) would actually entertain this, then maybe we as a community could figure out exactly what Moore and Gibbons were holding back.
Blah.
r/AlanMoore • u/[deleted] • Jun 09 '20
HBO's Watchmen | A Thermodynamic Disaster
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • Dec 13 '25
The Documented Lies of Hollis Mason
Hollis Mason.
The rock. The one who ties it all together. The one true hero amongst… less than.
Hollis Mason brings a certain old timey charm to Watchmen that feels familiar, comfortable. His book is an extremely fun read and is one of my favorite parts of Watchmen.
But here’s the thing. Hollis exaggerates. A lot. He’s also quite clever. He extends the truth sometimes, but other times outright contradicts himself. Is he a malicious liar, or does he simply fumble the facts?
No matter how you slice it, he does not tell The Truth.
And we know this because we have eyes that can see.
PART 1 - ‘Under the Hood’
First, let’s talk about the “sleight of hand” tricks in Hollis’ book. I have three examples, one being Hollis’ opening in the book and the other two being some of his photos, all three examples tricking your mind. Though the last two examples are symbolism from Moore/Gibbons, these are still valid.
Let’s look at Hollis’ opening in ‘Under the Hood’ (Picture 2).
Here he talks about how he was unsure of how to open his book and he talks about Denise, a woman who works at the local grocery store. Denise has written 40+ novels yet hasn’t published a single one. Hollis describes her doing the mundane task of fixing price tags on a box of detergent while asking her advice on how to start his novel. He describes her answer as being ‘bored with benign condescension’ while he sarcastically talks up her pearls of accumulated wisdom.
Her answer being “talk about the saddest thing you can think of”, Hollis thanks her in the book and actually dedicates the book to her before moving on to the next part - the story about Moe Vernon.
Now this is really quite clever but Hollis is pulling a trick on us. Though Moe Vernon’s story is sad, how did Hollis actually open up the book?
Not by talking about Moe Vernon, but by talking about Denise. A woman who has spent a great amount of time writing novels that go unpublished while her days are filled with the mundane. Even when the conversation veers towards something she loves, she’s bored of it.
That is pretty fucking sad.
Do you see how Hollis tricked you here?
Moe Vernon’s story is sad, sure, but Moe Vernon had a great life. Owned his own business, had a tremendous sense of humor, and until his last day on Earth, every day until then he felt safe and comfortable.
Denise sits around fixing price tags on the daily in a business she doesn’t own, writing books no one will ever read, and when asked about one of her favorite subjects she is bored of it.
Hollis tricked you. You didn’t care, maybe you still don’t, but he tricked you and that’s important.
Moving on, picture 3, we see a couple of photos from ‘Under the Hood’.
Notice both photos appear to have someone holding an item but upon closer inspection, someone else is holding said item.
First photo it looks like Hollis’ father is holding a play spider but it’s actually Moe Vernon holding it.
Second photo it appears as if Hooded Justice is holding a mistletoe but it’s actually Eddie Blake holding it.
This can’t possibly be Hollis’ fault in-universe, but it’s Moore/Gibbons’ way of telling the reader “There’s something weird going on with this autobiography. Something may look a certain way the first time you read it or see it, but try to look at it again.”
And we get exactly that with the opening in ‘Under the Hood’. Hollis says that Moe Vernon’s story is the saddest thing he’s ever heard but that’s not how he opened up the book. From the first paragraph, Hollis shows us his ability to misinform and trick his reader. You. You’re his reader. You are who he is tricking.
Let’s move on.
Picture 4, we see Moe Vernon. He has exactly two chins in this picture with two shadows below each chin. But two chins all day. You can see this with the eyes that you have. Go ahead, look at him. Two chins.
How does Hollis describe Moe Vernon? Hollis says he has three chins. Not two, the correct number of chins that Moe has, but three.
This example shows us that Hollis has the ability to exaggerate. Is it “malicious lying” ? No. But it’s not The Truth.
Does Watchmen live or die based on the number of chins Moe Vernon has?
Yes. It does.
You may not give a flying fuck about the minutiae of Moe Vernon’s chin but that is not the point. The point is SIMPLY that Hollis Mason isn’t telling you the truth. The topic does not matter. The fact that Hollis misinforms you does matter.
Picture 5, at one point Hollis tells us that Fred Motz and Beatrice Vernon had an affair and cleaned out her joint account shared with Moe Vernon, and they high tailed it to California to start a new life with that money across the country.
But then later Hollis claims that Fred Motz would eventually get his job back at Moe’s. After Moe killed himself, Moe’s brother took over the business and apparently rehired Fred according to Hollis.
But how is this possible? Sure, the reader can make some leaps on Hollis’ behalf and fill in the gaps. If Fred Motz gets his job back in New York, that MUST mean that things didn’t work out in California with Beatrice. But Hollis never states this.
This example shows Hollis’ ability to contradict himself or outright lie…or simply omit information.
Is it possible that Fred Motz did come back? YES! But that’s not the point.
As the narrator, Hollis has a responsibility to guide us and he’s not doing that here.
Why is Fred Motz back? Things didn’t work out with Beatrice? Things did work out with Beatrice but ya’ll just wanted to come back? What’s the deal with Moe’s brother rehiring him? Isn’t Moe dead because of him kinda? What, was there bad blood between Moe and his brother? Or is Fred like the best mechanic on the entire East Coast?
We don’t know. Because Hollis doesn’t tell us.
Hollis not telling us things is probably his and Alan Moore’s greatest shared sin in Watchmen but moving on..
In pictures 6 and 7, we see Hollis state that Larry Schexnayder and Sally Jupiter got married in 1947 but we see a letter from Larry to Sally that’s dated Feb 1948, and it’s the letter where Larry proposes.
So who’s wrong here? Hollis trying to remember dates and times from 15 years previous (Hollis’ novel is written in 1962, a decade and a half after the wedding) or Larry who is writing a letter in his present time, presumably 1948?
I think Hollis misremembered, and nowhere else in the entire comic book does it give a date for Larry and Sally’s wedding.
So this example shows us Hollis’ ability to misremember/fudge up dates.
Picture 8.
Hollis Mason makes a claim. “Hooded Justice is the biggest man I’ve ever seen.”
Now. Look at the picture.
Forget Hollis’ claim. Scrub that from your mind.
Is there ANYONE in that picture that is noticeably bigger than anyone else?
If you scrub Hollis’ claim from your mind, using your own eyes, who would you say is the biggest?
And it doesn’t matter what you answer. Even if you eventually believe HJ to be the biggest using your eyes, that’s not a conclusion that comes to you with a snap of your fingers.
To me, Captain Metropolis appears to be the tallest. As for width?
Compare Hollis Mason’s gigantic yams all laid out for the world to see, compare those to Hooded Justice’s teeny tiny legs.
I’m exaggerating, obviously, and I shouldn’t in a thread that I consider pretty serious.
Throw this picture in whatever AI garbage you use and ask it “Who is the biggest character in this picture?”
I’m greatly interested in those results.
The fact is Hooded Justice isn’t the “biggest” anything. He’s not. If he is, then barely.
You can see that with your eyes.
PART 2 - Meeting Hollis Mason
Maybe this should’ve been part 1 but non linear is fun too…
Picture 9. We meet Hollis Mason for the first time shortly before his book of lies sinks its teeth into us.
Can you spot all of Hollis’ lies and mistruths on this page? It’s like ‘Where’s Waldo?’ except there’s a bunch of Waldos and they’re all lying to you.
Panel 1. He lies to Dan about running into the Screaming Skull.
We know this because Adrian tells us “all the major villains are dead” in Picture 10.
Though Adrian is a liar himself, we know he is fiendishly telling the truth here because he has just killed the last major villain in Moloch.
Panel 3. “You must’ve been bored as hell.” In order to fish for compliments from Dan, Hollis will openly falsely accuse Dan of feeling boredom. Thankfully Dan calls him on his bullshit by telling Hollis that he knows better than that. Yes, you do know better Hollis.
This is no big deal, sure, but it’s important.
Dan is literally calling out Hollis on his fabrication and telling him that he knows better. Literally written on the page for you to see.
Panel 4. “Us retired guys gotta stick together.”
Hollis along with the rest of the Minutemen forced Silhouette into a dishonorable retirement and then abandoned her to her fated murder as seen in Picture 11.
Then again, Hollis did say “us guys” so not really lying. Maybe Hollis just doesn’t see women as being equal to “us guys”. Hypocrite or worse? You decide!
Panel 5. Bullshitter keeps Bullshitting.
Dan literally says “WILL YOU STOP WITH YOUR LIES?!”
No, Dan doesn’t literally say that. He just says “stop bullshitting” because that’s what Hollis does, he bullshits.
Panel 6. Hollis makes a claim that his left hook is the left hook that took out Captain Axis.
In picture 12, we finally see Hollis in action in the old days.
He IS using his left hook to knock someone the fuck out but it’s not Captain Axis. In fact, Captain Axis is directly behind Hollis while Hollis uses his left hook to knock out the Screaming Skull.
Sure, Hollis probably used his left hook several times, but he talks up using it against Axis and that is not what Moore/Gibbons show us.
These are all very little things that ultimately don’t matter (except for the Hooded Justice claim).
However, if Hollis can get all of this wrong, then we cannot believe him about anything unless it is backed up by a second source.
Hollis Mason doesn’t tell the truth.
r/AlanMoore • u/[deleted] • Sep 16 '24
The Boys and others prove that the comic book industry took the wrong lessons from Watchmen and the Killing Joke.
The Boys comic book and TV show are probably the worst offenders when it comes to this it is extremely shallow, and whatever point it tries to make has been made by Watchmen and much better, it started as a parody of the MCU, but in the end, it's exactly like it even worse with multiple spin-off shows it's not so subtle and infantilized and sanitized portrayals of actual issues of the real world, it offers nothing but shock value. These new properties don’t understand what made superheroes so popular in the first place. Secondly, they are for children, and yes, adults can enjoy them also, but when you have to change everything about the genre so that adult readers don’t feel like children these stories miss the point.
r/AlanMoore • u/EffMemes • May 05 '26
Did you know that Nepenthe Gardens is located in Colma, California?
Just uncovered this gem, and found it pretty interesting.
At the beginning of issue 2, Sally refers to the California town she’s in as “The City of the Dead.” She says this while we are being shown a cemetery back in New York.
Laurie responds as if Sally is speaking figuratively. After all, Sally is in a rest home and she is getting older. Since Laurie believes Sally is speaking figuratively, we the reader also believe it.
But Sally is being quite literal.
Colma, California started off as a Necropolis. Apparently San Francisco and other neighboring towns needed a place to put their dead and Colma became the chosen one. San Fran and other places started even transferring their dead to Colma. I’m simplifying this, if you want the exact history, Google’s got you covered!
It is known as “The City of the Dead”, or “The City of the Silent”, or “The City of Lost Souls”.
It’s crazy that, if you were to Google “what town is the fictional Nepenthe Gardens located in Watchmen”, Google will not tell you a town. Because the surface reading doesn’t give it to you.
If you want to know where Sally is, then you have to actually work for it.
Which goes for the majority of the plot and character motivations in Watchmen.
It’s also interesting that Laurie doesn’t take Sally at her word, and because Laurie doesn’t, we don’t. But we’re wrong. We’ve been cleverly manipulated by Alan Moore here.
Anyway…
Now you know where Sally lives! You’re welcome.
r/AlanMoore • u/[deleted] • Feb 16 '25
Why heroes from mangas never got the "inherently fascist" criticism that is so popular with american comic books?
Regardless if we agree or don't (I personally disagree), "superheroes are inherently fascist" is a common and popular criticism that we see with some frequency.
The criticism doesn't really reach heroes from Japanese comic books, however. We will really never see any "My Hero Academia is a fascist manga" opinion out there, and even if we did we would never get the positive response that "DC Comics/Marvel Comics are fascist" usually gets. It's also hard to imagine anyone saying that Killua Zoldyck should just donate money instead of beating up goons that we see so often with Batman and similar.
Are there fundamental differences between American heroes and Japanese heroes that casts some light on why one is "inherently fascist" and the other is not?
r/AlanMoore • u/Alarming_Draw • Apr 10 '22
HUGELY disapointed to learn most of From Hell is based on a cheap tv movie that came out the year BEFORE the comic was released...
Was always one of my favourites-now I discover most of it, the characters looks and design, comes directly ripped off from a cheap tv movie that starred michael caine, released a year BEFORE the first part of From Hell was ever written...
How is it I've been a fan for so long, know so much about him/the subject, yet have never read of this before?
r/AlanMoore • u/Few_Pride_5836 • Nov 30 '24
Lack of self awareness in the Bumper Book of Magic
I'm a big Alan Moore but there are sections in his book which are unintentionally amusing. There's a part where he writes that quantum physics gets abused by the new age community. Dude, that's what you've been doing throughout the book. Lol.
r/AlanMoore • u/ACinematography • Feb 06 '21
4K | The Cinematography of V for Vendetta
r/AlanMoore • u/Chemical-Plankton420 • Oct 31 '24
Just found out about the Neil Gaiman scandal. Has AM chimed in on this? These allegations appear legit, only NG says everything was consensual. It’s a revolting set of accusations. AM doesn’t seem like the type to associate with an aggressive sexual predator. But he has.
r/AlanMoore • u/magnanimousrex3 • Oct 01 '26
Comparing Alan Moore's Watchmen (1987) and Zack Snyder's Watchmen (2009)
r/AlanMoore • u/Foreign-History959 • Oct 16 '26
Master Builder's "YOU" vs the devil in Mansoul
My name is Christian Mumford & I am an Alan Moore fan - I started with his Swamp Thing & Miracleman & Watchmen in the 80s because my burning ambition at 22 Acacia Avenue was graduating Joe Kubert School in 1995 which I did. It landed me jobs too - the rest is a fanciful tale of wild nightmares & dream dragons & city people in the Roadhouse blues in the boonies with secret agents & soldier boys. Thus my art & writing is a far cry from realism and is more akin to alchemy & gnostic practice and my sphere of influence is a cobweb of distro deals in print and a dream come true & artist ambition fulfilled with passion & poets life though that's a joke I think is a Full Moon burning of my poetry & art during Jihad.