r/Agatha_Christie • • Dec 20 '19

This sub is more dead than all victims of Agatha Christie .

26 Upvotes

So let's revive it . Here is an improvised survey:

  1. Which murder or murderer do you consider was the smartest.

  2. Who is better Miss Marple , Hercules Poirot or other detective( from Agatha Christie stories)

  3. Who is better Sherlock Holmes , Hercules Poirot or Jane Marple?

  4. The most intersting or exciting work of Agatha Christie.

  5. The most boring Agatha Christie book.

  6. Hercules Poirot 1989-2013 series or Miss Marple 2004-2013 series?

Please answer in the comments !


r/Agatha_Christie • • May 11 '17

David Suchet, the best "TV" Poirot to date.

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • May 26 '19

And so it ends... 😭

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Mar 27 '19

Reading this very old copy of Third Girl. My first go with Poirot is almost at the end😭

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Sep 07 '17

I read all of Agatha Christie's novels last year, and made this handy spreadsheet (recommendations etc.)! Ask me anything!!

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
19 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Nov 12 '19

Agatha Christie: "A Mother's Love for Her Child is Like Nothing Else"

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Feb 06 '20

Agatha Christie's Poirot TV Series

13 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I posted this same thing over on r/agathachristie as well, which posts a bit more than this subreddit so if you don't follow it and you like Agatha Christie related topics I suggest you do.

Anyway, to the point, What is everybody's thoughts on the 1989-2013 television adaptation of Dame Agatha Christie's Poirot books? I know there is a popular critique that it altered her work too much (Specifically Seasons 9-13), and "pandered to gay audiences" e.g working in homosexual sub-plots or as major plot points (Cards on the Table, Five Little Pigs, Hallowe'en Party etc.). Here are some questions you can feel free to answer if you want.

  1. Did you like the alterations made?

  2. Do think any episodes outshone the books they were based off or, any that didn't do the base material any justice?

  3. Favourite episodes?

  4. Least favourite?

  5. Specific critiques?

  6. Do you have a preference for seasons 1-8, or 9-13?

I'll give my thoughts on it now to get the ball rolling :)

  1. Personally, I really liked the television series, mostly 7-13 because the books that were adapted had a darker tone to them, and even though people didn't like that they added gay storylines, I felt it added an unexpected element that helps to surprise viewers who have already read the books, and gives them something new.

  2. I really liked the way they did After the Funeral. Reading the book, I immensely liked the atmosphere of it, but at times felt myself getting bored, and was a little disappointed with the ending. However, the episode just kept me on my feet the whole time and Monica Dolan's portrayal of Miss Gilchrist was amazing! I was honestly sympathising with her the whole time and the end had me heartbroken for some reason. Also, I thought The Clocks was done brilliantly, as I enjoyed the darker feel to it and the whole spy element being introduced from the start, as I thought it seemed kind of out of place and really rushed at the end of the book. One episode that completely let me down was The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, really just boring, to be honest, and nowhere near as great as the book was, they revealed who the killer was to begin with so there was no shock at all, but then again it would be kind of hard to do in television format.

  3. Like I said, really enjoyed The Clocks and After the funeral, as well as Dead Man's Folly, Cat Among the Pigeons, Death in the Clouds, Lord Edgware Dies, and Death on the Nile. The Labours of Hercules was a great episode as well in my opinion, but then again I wasn't really a fan of the short stories beforehand, so I thought that reducing it into one episode was good.

  4. One of my least favourite episodes was The Big Four. Whilst the book was a bit of a mess to begin with (it was really seemed like a few short stories stitched together to become a novel), I absolutely HATED the ending of the episode revealing it was all an act for some lame guys crush. Was loving the vibe of the episode right up until the denouement though. Also thought Taken at the Flood, Sad Cypress and Murder in Mesopotamia were dreadfully boring.

  5. I thought that seasons 1-8 were a bit too "camp" to put it bluntly and kind of distracted from the whole murder mystery aspect of it, specifically the way Miss Lemon, Hastings, and Inspector Japp were written to be unnecessarily comedic; I did however like it when they returned for The Big Four. I'd say I prefer 9-13 when Hastings wasn't around as much, he just seemed to be too comedically stupid for me, and I thought the three supporting cast members wouldn't been better used sparingly like Ariadne Oliver was, and not all three of them at once.

  6. I think David Suchet does a great job playing Poirot, easily my favourite. Reading the books, you can tell Christie is getting tired of the character, as he appears less and less in the novels, but watching the later series I couldn't get enough of him. Love Zoe Wanamaker's portrayal of Ariadne Oliver, as she was one of my favourites in the books. It's also fun to watch through and notice actors and actresses who went on to become famous(ish) after being in Poirot.

So anyway that's my thoughts on Agatha Christie's Poirot, sorry for the huge post lol, just trying to revive this subreddit and hear other users opinions on the topic.


r/Agatha_Christie • • May 14 '17

Ranking Every Episode of Agatha Christie’s Poirot

Thumbnail
thetalkingllama.wordpress.com
11 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • May 13 '17

What is your favorite Agatha Christie book and why?

10 Upvotes

For me it would have to be Hercule Poirot's Christmas. I do like The Murder of Roger Ackroyd because of that book's stunning twist, however I kind of feel that Hercule Poirot's Christmas is a much better story. The characters seem to be a bit more interesting, and the plot twist is even more effective than the Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

So what is your favorite book from the Queen of Crime Fiction?


r/Agatha_Christie • • May 13 '17

What was the worst adaptation of an Agatha Christie story?

9 Upvotes

For me it would have to be The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. I loved the book with its famous twist, but seeing it on the small screen just felt all wrong. They completely changed the ending, deleted a character or two, plus they lost the main twist of the story. They should have still had Ackroyd narrate it, not Poirot.


r/Agatha_Christie • • Sep 17 '17

TIL that Annabelle and Agatha Christie's short story 'The Dressmaker's Doll' are eerily similar in their storyline of the doll.

8 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Jun 25 '17

Miss Marple and the Case of the Missing Pickled Shrimp

8 Upvotes

In The Thirteen Problems and the Sleeping Murder, it is mentioned that Miss Marple knew why a woman in her village had a gill of pickled shrimp missing from her string bag. Was there any mention of how it went missing?


r/Agatha_Christie • • Jun 01 '17

Murder On the Orient Express

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • May 16 '17

Has anyone seen the David Suchet Poirot on blu ray?

8 Upvotes

If so how did it look? Was it worth getting in your opinion or not? Because I am thinking of getting it.


r/Agatha_Christie • • May 31 '18

Why did Poirot have to leave Belgium when war broke out?

7 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Mar 23 '18

Has anyone read all of Agatha Christie's novels? How did it feel? I am about 22/75 of the way there

7 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Feb 09 '18

Who do you like best, Miss Marple or Hercule Poirot?

7 Upvotes

I say Poirot all the way!


r/Agatha_Christie • • Jul 25 '17

Agatha Christie quotes with original HD pictures

Thumbnail
hoopoequotes.com
7 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Jun 20 '17

Fans must find: Agatha Cristie audio book as read by Christopher Lee

7 Upvotes

Was looking for Christopher Lee's autobiography on audiobook when I discovered that he did a series of Christie's novels as well.

If you love Lee's amazing voice and delivery, then you must find them. won't share any pirated links, sorry.

Here's a sample: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7uSTnvwU6XY


r/Agatha_Christie • • May 13 '17

How to tackle 66 Agatha Christie Detective Novels Before 'Murder on the Orient Express'

Thumbnail
ew.com
7 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Dec 22 '18

Scott Lord Mystery: Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None, 1945

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • May 13 '17

Agatha Christie's 'Witness for the Prosecution' unfolds on Bristol stage

Thumbnail
theintell.com
6 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Mar 15 '19

In After the Funeral (Funerals are Fatal), how many siblings did Richard Abernethie have? The book said that his father had seven sons and daughters, but I counted 8 people here in the first chapter (I haven't read this book yet so please don't tell me spoilers!)

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Agatha_Christie • • Mar 17 '18

Having trouble understanding this passage from _Poirot_Investigates_

5 Upvotes

Hoping someone with better knowledge of French and the period can help me out. From Chapter 5, "Million Dollar Bond Robbery"

"If it were not for mal de mer, and the difficulty of practising the so excellent method of Laverguier for a longer time than the few hours of crossing the Channel, I should delight to voyage myself on one of these big liners,”


Thanks in advance!


r/Agatha_Christie • • Dec 06 '17

Just finished watching the last episode of “Poirot” ;_; Happily, I have “Marple” to fill the void. But where to go after I finish Marple?

5 Upvotes