r/Advancedastrology • u/Key_Cheesecake_2455 • Oct 31 '25
General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Analysis of Chris Brennan's "No, Your Sun Sign has not Changed" rebuttal against the recent NYT article "Your Sun Sign is 2000 years out of Date".
The recent article by the NYT “Your Sun Sign is 2000 Years Out of Date” seems to have gotten the better of Chris Brennan. As today’s foremost authority on Hellenistic astrology (with an audience of 238k subscribers!) his reaction to the challenge was important. Unfortunately, our premiere guy missed an opportunity to further the discussion, and instead took a defensive tack with unintended consequences.
In his recent Astrology Podcast entitled “No, your sun sign hasn’t changed”, Brennan delivered a calm rebuttal to the article with his signature academic / saturnian style; very respectful-like. But, he also expressed emotional displeasure, frustration and a feeling of wrongdoing by the NYT. He was annoyed by the article, which he claims to have ‘debunked’ as being wrong, and he effectively accused the NYT writer of malfeasance.
To be honest, I have liked Brennan but I wasn’t impressed by his response to the NYT article.
Big time influencers like him have power over what people in the astrological community are thinking, saying and doing; all the more so because of his presentation as an academic scholar and authority figure. By responding defensively and dismissing the NYT article as bunk, he has inadvertently promoted a sort-of intolerance for information sharing between astrological and astronomical knowledge cultures.
Since the NYT article and Brennan's response to it, I have observed a growing number of hard-headed ancient astrology enthusiasts circling their wagons on Reddit, shutting down conversation that is outside of their astrology wheelhouse. Fundamentalists seem to be ganging up, downvoting any discussion they disagree with, be it over arguments of constellations versus zodiac signs, western astrology versus vedic, tropical versus sidereal zodiac or whole sign houses versus placidus.
Occasionally, comments have been removed by mods who apparently do not allow even a whiff of any Vedic conversation to leak into their generically named “/astrology” sub (astrology being an umbrella word for any study of the stories told by stars, perhaps the sub should be renamed to reflect its restrictions, ie. ‘Tropical Astrology Only’ or ‘Hellenistic Astrology Only’; rather than simply r:/ astrology, but I digress....
Anyway, Brennan's automatic write off of the mismatch between constellations and sun signs as merely an unimportant inconvenience seems at odds with his older thinking.
In his 2018 Astrology Podcast entitled “The History of Astrology from Ancient to Modern Times”, Brennan wraps the lecture by sharing that while the Hellenistic techniques unveiled so far by Project Hindsight’s translation project have been invaluable, there is still room for advancement and modernization of ancient techniques. He states that today’s revival of ancient astrology will lead to the emergence of a new kind of astrology, and understands that change will continue to happen as information is transmitted over time. It's important, he said, that we have serious dialogue about what each tradition has to offer. The embrace of Hellenistic traditionalism doesn’t require the rejection of other aspects of astrology, and we should avoid fundamentalism, he said.
But to me, his dismissal of the article and avoidance of a deeper discussion denies the even the remote possibility of any synthesis between eastern and western traditions. It it seems a bit….denialist? Fundamentalist? His response to the article also smacked of personal hurt and defensiveness; he took the NYT article personally instead of just answering professionally.
In my opinion, the NYT article wasn’t even necessarily a swipe at us who believe in astrology, as Brennan felt it was. To me, it presented an educational opportunity for the HUUUUUUGE new audience of astrologers, many of whom probably hadn’t yet realized the difference between constellations and signs prior to that article.
Has anyone else noticed that today's groundswell of new astrologers can be loud in their certainty that Hellenistic whole-sign astrology is the correct astrology? Social media is absolutely flooded with pop-astrologers, and the tropical whole-sign approach is the only possible way they can continue delivering horoscopes to the masses, a lucrative business. The astrologers with the biggest microphones are the biggest defenders of Hellenistic Whole-Sign-House Astrology. A kind of ‘astrology industrial complex’ has emerged. This is as a double-edged sword. Good because it makes astrology accessible to the masses when it wasn't before, and bad because the astrologers with the biggest microphones are unlikely likely to embrace anything that may threaten their livelihood.
So, what exactly is so wrong with the NYT having published factual, scientific information that zodiac signs and constellations are no longer in sync? Why is expanding that awareness to the groundswell of newbies (who are both delivering and consuming horoscopes) a bad thing? Knowledge is power. Asking questions is good.
So does realizing that there's difference between constellations and zodiac signs muddy the waters for some astrologers? Certainly. Does it threaten the source of steady profit by today’s astrologers who are routinely delivering 12 rising-sign horoscopes (among many other astrology offerings!) Maybe. Maybe that’s the problem.
Academic astrologers like Brennan should strive to keep the discussion open though, so that we might be able to expand our understanding, or even synthesize information from two different traditions.
But then again, it's not MY livelihood that depends on having to defend tropical whole sign astrology...



