r/Advancedastrology • • Oct 31 '25

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Analysis of Chris Brennan's "No, Your Sun Sign has not Changed" rebuttal against the recent NYT article "Your Sun Sign is 2000 years out of Date".

19 Upvotes

The recent article by the NYT “Your Sun Sign is 2000 Years Out of Date” seems to have gotten the better of Chris Brennan.  As today’s foremost authority on Hellenistic astrology (with an audience of 238k subscribers!) his reaction to the challenge was important. Unfortunately, our premiere guy missed an opportunity to further the discussion, and instead took a defensive tack with unintended consequences. 

In his recent Astrology Podcast entitled “No, your sun sign hasn’t changed”, Brennan delivered a calm rebuttal to the article with his signature academic / saturnian style; very respectful-like. But, he also expressed emotional displeasure, frustration and a feeling of wrongdoing by the NYT. He was annoyed by the article, which he claims to have ‘debunked’ as being wrong, and he effectively accused the NYT writer of malfeasance. 

To be honest, I have liked Brennan but I wasn’t impressed by his response to the NYT article. 

Big time influencers like him have power over what people in the astrological community are thinking, saying and doing; all the more so because of his presentation as an academic scholar and authority figure. By responding defensively and dismissing the NYT article as bunk, he has inadvertently promoted a sort-of intolerance for information sharing between astrological and astronomical knowledge cultures.

Since the NYT article and Brennan's response to it, I have observed a growing number of hard-headed ancient astrology enthusiasts circling their wagons on Reddit, shutting down conversation that is outside of their astrology wheelhouse. Fundamentalists seem to be ganging up, downvoting any discussion they disagree with, be it over arguments of constellations versus zodiac signs, western astrology versus vedic, tropical versus sidereal zodiac or whole sign houses versus placidus. 

Occasionally, comments have been removed by mods who apparently do not allow even a whiff of any Vedic conversation to leak into their generically named “/astrology” sub (astrology being an umbrella word for any study of the stories told by stars, perhaps the sub should be renamed to reflect its restrictions, ie. ‘Tropical Astrology Only’ or ‘Hellenistic Astrology Only’; rather than simply r:/ astrology, but I digress....

Anyway, Brennan's automatic write off of the mismatch between constellations and sun signs as merely an unimportant inconvenience seems at odds with his older thinking.

In his 2018 Astrology Podcast entitled “The History of Astrology from Ancient to Modern Times”, Brennan wraps the lecture by sharing that while the Hellenistic techniques unveiled so far by Project Hindsight’s translation project have been invaluable, there is still room for advancement and modernization of ancient techniques. He states that today’s revival of ancient astrology will lead to the emergence of a new kind of astrology, and understands that change will continue to happen as information is transmitted over time. It's important, he said, that we have serious dialogue about what each tradition has to offer. The embrace of Hellenistic traditionalism doesn’t require the rejection of other aspects of astrology, and we should avoid fundamentalism, he said. 

But to me, his dismissal of the article and avoidance of a deeper discussion denies the even the remote possibility of any synthesis between eastern and western traditions. It it seems a bit….denialist? Fundamentalist? His response to the article also smacked of personal hurt and defensiveness; he took the NYT article personally instead of just answering professionally.

In my opinion, the NYT article wasn’t even necessarily a swipe at us who believe in astrology, as Brennan felt it was. To me, it presented an educational opportunity for the HUUUUUUGE new audience of astrologers, many of whom probably hadn’t yet realized the difference between constellations and signs prior to that article.

Has anyone else noticed that today's groundswell of new astrologers can be loud in their certainty that Hellenistic whole-sign astrology is the correct astrology?  Social media is absolutely flooded with pop-astrologers, and the tropical whole-sign approach is the only possible way they can continue delivering horoscopes to the masses, a lucrative business. The astrologers with the biggest microphones are the biggest defenders of Hellenistic Whole-Sign-House Astrology. A kind of ‘astrology industrial complex’ has emerged. This is as a double-edged sword. Good because it makes astrology accessible to the masses when it wasn't before, and bad because the astrologers with the biggest microphones are unlikely likely to embrace anything that may threaten their livelihood.

So, what exactly is so wrong with the NYT having published factual, scientific information that zodiac signs and constellations are no longer in sync? Why is expanding that awareness to the groundswell of newbies (who are both delivering and consuming horoscopes) a bad thing?  Knowledge is power. Asking questions is good. 

So does realizing that there's difference between constellations and zodiac signs muddy the waters for some astrologers? Certainly.  Does it threaten the source of steady profit by today’s astrologers who are routinely delivering 12 rising-sign horoscopes (among many other astrology offerings!) Maybe. Maybe that’s the problem.

Academic astrologers like Brennan should strive to keep the discussion open though, so that we might be able to expand our understanding, or even synthesize information from two different traditions.

But then again, it's not MY livelihood that depends on having to defend tropical whole sign astrology...


r/Advancedastrology • • Mar 24 '25

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance The Paradoxical Nature of Modern Astrology

0 Upvotes

One of the pinnacles of modern astrological belief is that it somehow exists in a parallel universe that affects this reality, yet simultaneously exists outside the laws of nature that govern this reality. Modern astrology treats the planets as mystical archetypes that shape our experiences, but rejects the idea that they move within the same physical, mathematical, and observable framework as everything else in the universe.

This shift has led to a bizarre trade-off: instead of viewing astrology as a predictive, statistical analysis of probability, knowledge of natural laws has been exchanged for mystical woo-woo based entirely on how someone feels in the moment. The sky no longer dictates events—it’s just a mirror for endless self-reflection.

But here’s the thing: astrology didn’t start as a self-help tool. It was never meant to be an emotional crutch or a validation mechanism. It was developed by scholars who were mathematicians, astronomers, and political strategists. The very same authors who wrote the original source texts on astrology also wrote books on math, science, and governance. They weren’t pulling interpretations out of thin air—they were mapping patterns, tracking probabilities, and making real-world predictions about weather, disease, war, and political shifts.

Somewhere along the way, astrology lost that predictive rigor and became a playground for self-analysis. And sure, self-reflection has value. But at what point does self-awareness cross the line into narcissistic navel-gazing?

🚩 Red flags of chart obsession in modern astrology:

Hyper-fixation on placements (“I can’t succeed because my Saturn is in the 12th”)

Blaming everything on transits instead of making real-life choices

Using astrology exclusively for personal identity rather than applying it outwardly

Constantly checking your chart for daily decisions instead of just… living

Making astrology your entire personality

Traditional astrology forces you to engage with the world—to see history, politics, and the unfolding of time as a structured system of cause and effect. It demands that you pay attention to cycles, data, and real-world consequences.

You can either use astrology to hype yourself up with spiritual narcissism and Jungian psychology, limiting it to personal self-reflection, (nothing wrong with that but there is a line between awareness and obsession) enforcing hierarchical belief systems and stereotyping… or you can use it as a tool to understand the magic and mystery of the world we actually live in—right here, right now.

The choice is yours. You can believe astrology doesn’t follow any natural laws because you don’t want to admit you don’t actually know what those laws are.

Or you can use astrology as a tool to discover all the Mysteries of this world - and hell maybe even Life, the Universe and Everything. Who knows? I sure don’t. But I’d rather at least try finding out those answers instead of just writing it off as impossible.

Mars opposite Pluto man, Im too competitive for that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Full disclosure: Yes, I used ChatGPT to organize my rant into something more coherent lol yall should be glad ChatGPT exists for people like me with Mercury in Pisces and a penchant for passionate tangents. I don’t think in words, I think in pictures, concepts, images that move.


r/Advancedastrology • • Nov 16 '23

Traditional Techniques + Practices Exalted vs. Fall (my take, and a sorta rant I guess)

2 Upvotes

I really hate the whole "strong" or "weak" interpretation of a planet based on its essential dignity by sign. If you think a Moon in Scorpio is WEAK in their use of their Moon energy because it's in fall, you haven't met a Moon in Scorpio cause dang... they can control people with that moon, which indicates strength to me. These people absolutely get their moon needs met. Honestly in this sense, the fall placements are probably the strongest.

Case in point, Meghan Markle, Kylie Jenner, and Kim Kardashian all have Venus in fall (in Virgo). But they're all very successful with Venusian things right? Because their Venus is the most base, most earthly, and least likely to be trying to satisfy some higher purpose beyond their own Venusian desires.

Kylie also has Moon in Scorpio, and yet is the most loved child by her mother. lol. Is her moon weak? Umm, I don't think so. She knows how to manipulate even her own mother into focusing her mom's attentions on her. Anyhoo... what do you all think?


r/Advancedastrology • • May 02 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Why do so many astrologers struggle with understanding Uranus, Neptune and Pluto?

7 Upvotes

These planets are very powerful in my chart. The things they hold and what they rule is like an easy second language to me.

I’m not saying that other astrologers provide inadequate information with the outer celestials, I’m saying they only bring up surface level topics when it comes the realms/dimensions these celestials control…

From Sun to Saturn everyone is an expert! Yet, when it comes to these planets it’s like there’s some internal struggle to interpret the full of effect of these planets.

Then you have the quirky astrologers that either speak in linear fashion with 4 hour videos that are a nails on a chalkboard pain if you don’t speed up the video, or the ones that only speak in poetry, word salads, or that one lady that talks like she’s speaking to 12 year old children… Can it not just be stated plainly?

Could I just be in my head, or is anyone understanding where I’m coming from? One thing that’s easy for me to separate these planets from the signs the rule and look at them like infinity stones from Marvel. I don’t need Pisces, Aquarius or Scorpio to digest the concepts or archetypes.

Thoughts?

Edit: Here’s a sliver of something I just wrote up today on my understanding of these planets… I tend to look at them as if they’re my neighbors right next to me.

Neptune, Uranus and Pluto…

Rule #1 these planets were not discovered as late as history teachers tells us. They’ve been discovered and around far more earlier than people know. Because of such all one has to do is look at the transits of each of these planets and see the effect they’ve had on the collective from the earliest of times until now… You can find this information in books regarding UFOs and Books on Hypnotic regressions interviews. It also exists in pictures and text of other mythologies. I will not tell you where exactly to find these bits and pieces of information. I want you to get off your ass and find them yourselves so that the journey you take will lead you in all types of directions of original learning.

Rule #2 This is coming from a creative mind that remains original, non conforming, doesn’t appeal to authority, and has a growth mindset. This is a mind that takes everything, from scientific to pseudoscientific, concrete to abstract, reality to insane into account as a means to create a catalyst for the improvement of occult practices…

Moving forward!

Starting off with Neptune! The reason people say Neptune is so difficult to understand is due to the fact that how it operates as a celestial body doesn’t make sense using mainstream logic and rationality to explain it. It’s a higher octave planet that rules the dimensions of higher spirituality and other things that astrologers pointed out. It operates as an ability to go beyond this realm and to tap into other higher realms. This is how Neptune dominant people get their imaginations and creative craft, from a world that’s not immediately around us, sometimes it could be channeling as well. It oozes into their body language, personality and soul as they walk towards though life. A huge reason why so many people struggle with Neptune and its boundless state is because that’s how it has to operate in order to function… It does create fog and illusion because it can have a great ideal in just about anything. It sees the light and hope even in its own death if not used correctly or in a healthy manner, it’s that boundless without conditions, it’s how it naturally behaves. That’s the power of having unconditional love and a higher ideal, both of which is ruled by Neptune. It also rules a certain level of genius like the other celestials, because like I said earlier it pulls information from a world away from here. Having true innate compassion and empathy along with multiple forms of senses outside what is scientifically proven or normal is also ruled by Neptune. This is not a planet that needs humanity to believe in its powers in order to function, it will function regardless just like all other planets, points and asteroids in astrology… Furthermore, think about it… in order to have faith or to have imagination you have to believe or communicate with something that’s not immediately in front of you, Neptune and Jupiter helps you achieve that goal.

Now Uranus, higher octave of Mercury. I’m not sure why this one is very hard to understand given the fact that it has everything to do with the Profoundly Gifted community of geniuses today that you can study. Uranus is very similar to mars but in an intellectual swagger and rebellious way. Instead of using guns and swords or extreme forms of violence it will use electricity and shock factors to get it point across. The outcome can be pleasant or disastrous, just like the path and the target of a lightning bolt which is unexpectedly quick. It helps with bringing out true originality of the mind as it pulls information about subjects from a world of originality, a world where if something already exists or has been done then it’s not from the world of originality. This dimension of creative ideas is like a place where Uranus can pull and use by bringing back to the 3-D world and making something of it happen in the future like pulling a fish out of water to make things simple. Uranus also doesn’t like bullshit that authority figures use to build or destroy humanity so it comes up with rebellious and genius ways of overthrowing that. Some times it’s not always beneficial what Uranus pulls out of the hat, but it was always be original. Uranus doesn’t have feelings towards being a conformist or being liked. Uranus likes itself so much that it truly could not give any damn about the validation of other planets. I’d like to say Uranus is the Robot or Mystical sage planet because it doesn’t have feelings like humans or animals do, yet contradicting behavior like being a humanitarian exists with this planet. What’s more is this is the planet that’s the wild card of all planets, it’s unpredictable nature will always have you on the edge of your seat or on guard because you can not study or train for whatever Uranus spews out, you can only deal with the aftermath. Uranus truly is the outsider and cares not much of being neurodivergent but the state of existence and what I can do to improve it. We are talking Mad scientist vibes here!

Pluto- God of the underworld. Plain and simple, pretty much everything under the surface, but Pluto has more. Just like Neptune it gives you emotions most don’t feel when it comes to an event, task or person that drives you to overcome the pain and transform or if you don’t move your emotions will rot your health and you’ll start to die early. It compels you to eradicate what’s detrimental with sheer force of drive or emotional distress which leads to murderous obsession… It’s biggest priority is power in all shapes and forms, given its drive and x-ray like vision it will look for power dynamics in all situations from beauty to hierarchies, from family to government, from speech to stature… Power is used in a variety of ways and when you have a prominent Pluto or Pluto placements then you’ll see them as if they are standing in front of you. Criminal activity and cruelty are things ruled by Pluto because it’s the ultimate planet of extremes, the planet of “by any means necessary”… Power is a very taboo subject in society because it’s something not everyone can have in its entirety, but can be used in minuscule efforts by everyone. Another reason Power is taboo is because power I what you can take, not what you can build or what’s given to you by someone else. Power exist for only the most determined souls to take. Power is not held or controlled by any mere human. Moving forward, Pluto also rules taboo subjects and interpersonal topics involving people’s demons in their closets or their shadows. It has much influence on people’s dark side that everyone has… Pluto is very, very similar to Saturn. You get what you put in… I have another post about this subject on my profile talking about how certain planets doesn’t give you flowers unless you’ve planted and catered to them for years on end, that’s how Pluto works. If you don’t do shit, you decay. Do more that’s expect, get rewards bigger than your expectations. Pluto has no time for laziness, bullshit, or manipulation as it can see everything that’s going on and has no mercy disciplining his own children (Scorpio-Sun,Moon,Rising, aspects to personal planets, or Pluto in 1st or 10th house) even if it means they have to lose everything including their own lives. Saturn is brutal in this regard too but he keeps you alive while you have nothing but resentment, low self esteem and bitter depression.


r/Advancedastrology • • Feb 17 '23

Educational Deborah Houlding: The Sign, the Whole Sign, and Nothing But the Sign , now free , enjoy

Thumbnail
vimeo.com
0 Upvotes

r/Advancedastrology • • Jan 22 '26

Chart Analysis Chart Analysis Question - AI and ChatGPT

0 Upvotes

Hello!
Would anyone here consider doing a chart analysis of ChatGPT? (I searched the sub history and couldn't find anything existing, please remove or let me know if someone has already done this)

Chat GPT was launched to the public on November 30th, 2022. Siri, Alexa and Google Assistant were public predecessors but there was an obvious level of sophistication with ChatGPT that wasn't out there prior. From my understanding this marked a shift / beginning of AI as we currently know it. Here is a good resource for timing and recent history around these technologies: https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/november-30/chatgpt-released-openai

Edit to add chart:


r/Advancedastrology • • May 30 '26

Predictive Chart rectification from major event/ anything I’m missing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I have been trying to rectify my dad’s chart, and I finally have a big event with a specific date.

Using whole signs as I just want to refer to houses for now.

But basically on 30th May, around 1am, his garage filled with all of his life’s work and everything personal to him went up in flames. Huge battery fire we suspect. All of it gone, his whole life gone basically.

Now I’ve always suspected he’s an Aquarius or cancer rising mostly because my sister looks spitting image of him - and she’s cancer sun and Aquarius rising.

Aquarius rising makes sense here - mars in 4th (house fire?) square to his Uranus and Pluto in 8th (he should get an insurance payout for this). I also see Pluto potentially somewhere around his ASC although I haven’t rectified that exactly but it makes sense. Huge transformation of who he is - he was a cluttered hoarder and now it’s all gone.

I saw that transit mars on ASC is also a give away for rectifying based on big events but I’m not sure he’s a Taurus rising. Because I’m a Taurus rising and he just couldn’t be. Intuitive feeling he’s not.

It’s also Sag full moon today, should I be taking that into account?

Would love to hear any insights based on this big fire event, I feel like I finally have something to go off. Thanks in advance!


r/Advancedastrology • • Jan 08 '25

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance What’s with teeth and astrology?

28 Upvotes

What’s with the teeth? Aries and their big ass chiclets, Capricorn and that gap, Gemini and those baby teeth (and sometimes small gap), and Virgo with those two rabbit ass front teeth. Is there some sort of explanation for tooth features in astrology? Or is there like a Vedic explanation that I don’t know of?


r/Advancedastrology • • Aug 26 '25

Conceptual Hypothetical chart for Chani (just for fun)

Post image
0 Upvotes

So, I know Chani hasn’t ever shared her chart (totally respect that). But based on her books + podcast comments, I tried to sketch out a possible rectification. Curious what others think.

👉 Hypothesis: Sept 3, 1975 – 1:00 AM – Lund, BC (Cancer rising, Virgo sun, Leo moon)

Key placements:

Sun Virgo (10°) 3H

Moon Leo (5°) 2H

Asc Cancer (7°)

Saturn Cancer (28°) 1H

Jupiter Aries (24°, Rx) 10H

MC Pisces (5°) (+ Venus Leo Rx 2H, Mars Gemini 12H, Uranus/Pluto Libra 4H, etc.)

Why this chart?

Her first astrology encounter was someone calling her “judgmental” → classic Virgo sun.

Big hair + presence = Leo moon vibes.

Book mentions being a “late bloomer” → Saturn rising.

On a pod she said she first got into astrology during her Jupiter return + her 9H is “very Jupiter” → Pisces 9H.

She also said she “became a parent” when Jupiter crossed her 10H (and “it wasn’t in Cancer, lemme tell ya”) → fits Aries Jupiter in the 10H.

Questions for y’all:

Do you buy Cancer rising, or does Leo rising feel more right?

Any other placements you’d swap to make sense of her Jupiter/9H remarks?

Has anyone else tried rectifying her chart, or another celebrity chart?


r/Advancedastrology • • Feb 14 '25

Predictive Guessing what movies and shows will come in the Neptune in Taurus Era.

1 Upvotes

Neptune represents the art like films, TV, etc. I'm actually wondering what themes we could see in movies starting in March 23, 2039 when Neptune goes into Taurus. We might see some Taurean themes in place for a lot of movies. Even family movies would be a victim of these new themes. Because Taurus is ruled by Venus, the 2040s will have a tangible knowledge of the physical world in owning what's grounded. This is my prediction. What are your other predictions for this future season?


r/Advancedastrology • • Mar 07 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Everyone or almost everyone who is famous or rich has the sun at home 10

0 Upvotes

Hello, I have noticed that all the famous and rich (or at least a vast majority of them) are born with sun in the 10th house, I imagine that this will not be an accident in most cases and that it will be deliberate, as many come from dynasties of money with the same astrological configurations.

For those who do not know the 10th house is the house of the public face, your profession, etc. and sun in 10th house is a very good position for success in your profession, in society, etc.

I have 2 theories:

  • They purposely plan the births to have the children at that time so that the children will do well in life.

  • The public birth charts of these people are false, the real ones are kept private.

What do you think is the most accurate possibility, do you think this people force the birth at midday?, do they hire services that help you plan when a person should give birth, have sex, etc, so the children will have the best natal chart?, if yes: where?, do you think these people do that?, I have some personal interest in this topic.

Thank you very much.

Note: this is the website where I check the natal charts:

https://allfamous.org

In this website you can see like (almost) everyone

Probably there is more but this is the one I know.

Note 2:Also there is the possibility that the women and men of those families have a genetic material that makes them have a tendency to give birth at noon, they know it and that's why some dynasties like kings only mixed among them. This is option that have no relation with astrology, but could be.

Edit: this website it is not good, I was so angry that even I have blocked the domain with an extension called: "block these urls domains"


r/Advancedastrology • • Jan 25 '25

Beginner Question (Mod Approved) If reading in Placidus: I’ve noticed that in some people’s charts, certain houses are really big while some are tiny. Why is that?

3 Upvotes

For example, if looking at my chart in Placidus, the houses are about the same size each and look pretty even. In my boyfriend’s chart, his 7th house is huge, almost double the size of my houses. Then, his 10th house is tiny, with hardly any room for a placement.

Why is that?


r/Advancedastrology • • Dec 20 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Anybody else notice the Sun / Jupiter conjunction Cancers with domiciled Saturns tend to throw the stereotype of depressive completely out of the window?

0 Upvotes

I have personally been on many astro sites and it seems there are a few early 90's crabs about with this configuration, they tend to be Earth / Water biased, they tend to be very keen observers of all stimuli and are not really truly conservative or liberal, they also tend to be rather free in their expression in all areas, other than truly trying to hurt someone.

Like for example there is one very tenacious crab who spent years being banned but rebirthing themselves over and over to take part in their pursuit.

https://astrologyweekly.com/ Like just look around and you will find stand out rather "Extra" posts by a crab, they are mostly, Saturn, nodal axis, Cancer and themes about challenging what is accepted.

If that's not cardinal I don't really know what else is.

These crabs all have Saturn & Pluto domicile so I would think transformation and being able to change on the fly and regenerate are strong in them?


r/Advancedastrology • • Jan 06 '25

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance They say Aquarius is the sign of intelligence but…

0 Upvotes

Aquarius is the sign known for intelligence and innovative thinking, however…if you look at the charts of famous scientist and tech leaders (Albert Einstein, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Bill gates etc.) Most of them are majority water placements.

When I look at (Influential Aquarius) Majority of them are buisness leaders or politicians. I thought this was kind of odd discovery but I know a majority of Aquarius suns are actually capricorns in Vedic astrology.

If anything it seems like Pisces is the brainiac of the zodiac sign, not Aquarius.


r/Advancedastrology • • Oct 06 '21

Pluto in Sagittarius generation vs Pluto in Scorpio

6 Upvotes

This is strange, but I am surprised at how Pluto in Sagittarius has turned out and I couldn't have predicted it. Honestly, I hated Y2K and did not enjoy the music or culture of the time they were born in. Some of the criticism they've leveled at millennials (Pluto in Scorpio) seems apt:

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/laurenstrapagiel/gen-z-mocking-millennials

Pluto in Sagittarius was born in a time of prosperity and expenditure, but Gen Z is famous for being financially conservative and prudent, maturing and growing up very quickly (I see so many posts by people like Joel Rivera that are like "I've grown so much in this month"), interested in entrepreneurship, teaching themselves online and being self-starters, feeling pressure to succeed, but also openly dealing with free-floating anxiety and being very conservative/wary about forming romantic relationships/not prioritizing impressing potential sexual partners with their appearance, but rather doing it for themselves or instagram. I often get a bit of whiplash from how Sagittarius hurtles toward the future (I have Saturn in Sagittarius) and how they now consider someone in their 30s geriatric and middle aged, whereas the orthodoxy before was that one bumbles through their 20s and the 30s is a golden time.

I'm also surprised by Pluto in Scorpio, they were meant to be intense and durable, the generation that joined the American Revolution had Pluto in Scorpio. But, these grew up during a time of prosperity and progress to parents who were trying out the Dr. Spock method among others, since they didn't experience privation as kids, they were ill equipped to survive the recession. They're famous as useless, spineless millennials who chased travel and jobs that would fulfill them emotionally (while gen z tends to punch through barriers in music and entertainment, actually getting those jobs that they love.) I do notice that even if their parents got divorced, they are attempting marriage and children. I have Pluto in Scorpio and Saturn in Sagittarius, I came to "expansion/travel/higher education" late, but I am discovering that I'm an old baby who wasted a lot of time and is incapable (Mars in the 12th in Capricorn).

tl;dr What is your opinion of how Pluto in Sagittarius and Pluto in Scorpio actually turned out? And what is the difference between them? And can they find common ground?


r/Advancedastrology • • Jun 28 '25

Tools + Software ChatGPT has crossed a new threshold: Chart Calculation

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just asked ChatGPT to calculate a chart from birth data and the results were almost impeccable.

https://chatgpt.com/share/685f58a0-00b0-8005-91a0-e6fe337daff0

I directly compared it to calculating the same chart through the Swiss Ephemeris, accessible through Astro.com [image]

Everything was correct, except with a calculation of the Node. I then walked it through its error.

Considering 2 1/2 weeks ago ChatGPT could not calculate a chart from birth data alone, it shows how rapidly it is improving by leaps and bounds. In large part based on the efforts of those of us with advanced astrological knowledge who have been working with it and its developers to improve its abilities. Perhaps this upgrade of knowledge hadn’t happened yet yesterday, but it’s here now.

However, I continue to firmly stress this:

I do not recommend anyone use ChatGPT for astrology unless they have sufficient knowledge to independently verify every single item discussed. Not just degrees and signs, but aspects, interpretations, and far beyond.

Everything must be verified on a continual basis.

Another important factor is developing the skill to optimally prompt ChatGPT. It makes all the difference in the world in terms of results and usefulness for the user.

This is from the current free version of ChatGPT, 4o.

(My question about Skyfield Library was because of when I first asked the same question of the 4.5 research model, it said it could not complete the task due to not having access to it. It then recommended that I instead go to astro.com, astro-seek, or acquire Solar Fire to calculate the chart myself, then report back the resulting calculations for if to interpret — so kudos to it for making those solid recommendations. Seems 4.5 hasn’t had the same update as 4o, but I’m not surprised considering it’s a research model).

*I chose a chart at random in my saved database.

The next year to two years is going to be a game changer.

My request of ChatGPT’s developers is that they cite the sources for their results, without prompting, encouraging promotion to bring new faces to visit their websites, purchase their books, consultations, and subscribe to their videos.

It currently does so, but it must be prompted.


r/Advancedastrology • • Feb 23 '24

Conceptual Did Jesus Christ tilt astrology from sidereal to tropical?

9 Upvotes

I'm new to astrology but I have an advanced question: I've been exploring the differences between sidereal and tropical. I had a download that feels true but have no resources to explore it further:

Sidereal is the fixed, as we know. It's almost mathematical. Tropical is not. It's predicated on the equinoxes. Thus, in short, folks often call tropical "sun based." So:

Did the arrival of Christ — a Sun god, the Son of Man, and so forth — actually shift us into the western system? Which is to say—in the spirit of Behold! I make all things new! — was the part of the power of this Piscean messiah that he literally tilted our astrological system to reflect the source of his truth?

The interpretative faculties of tropical astrology feel more Christian to me—there's a subjectivity but also a poeticism. It's not Vedic in its mathematical accuracy, but as such it more personal. Almost personal the reality of the sun rising and falling each day. Christ made the whole universe more immediate.


r/Advancedastrology • • Oct 16 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance When does Pluto start its work?

0 Upvotes

I am told Pluto is about to bring us great unveilment of secrets and resulting upheaval. Which seems appropriate for the times. When does Pluto's reign start? When does it end?


r/Advancedastrology • • 27d ago

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Eye surgery during venus retrograde

0 Upvotes

i’ve had a chalazion for about a month now. it’s painless i should add.

it’s caused me great emotional distress. it’s gone down a lot but it’s still here. i recently learned that i can have a surgical procedure done that would drain it and it would heal in a week or so. i’ve seen some people praise the surgery while others have had bad results and permanent eyelid damage.

i really don’t know if i should get this procedure done during the retrogrades. my birthday is on november 13 and i’m not even excited for it anymore.


r/Advancedastrology • • May 16 '25

Conceptual Sun-Moon aspects and inner dialogues/ emotional intelligence

8 Upvotes

So I have always been curious how to pick out a lack of emotional intelligence (or empathy) in a chart. I’ve noticed people who have a strong or consistent inner dialogue are way more emotionally intelligent or tuned in with themselves. I started with focusing on aspects to the native’s Moon placement (or lack thereof), and I think it’s Sun-Moon aspects that are going to be the most key when it comes to this.

I’ve noticed that:.

1.) Harmonious aspects between Sun/Moon (Trines/Sextiles): Likely to have a more constructive inner dialogue than others, and are very emotionally intelligent if they want to be. This is of course not the case all the time because their Sun or Moon could be afflicted by other placements, but this is just a general idea and should still be applied on a case by case basis. In any case, They might be described as people who are “wise beyond their years” or “mature for their age”. They are more likely to be capable of introspection, able to analyze their actions objectively, able to view their actions from an outsider’s POV, ability to make changes IF they want to. That’s where free will comes in which isn’t seen in a chart. Someone might have a harmonious Sun-Moon aspect but they might not feel any desire to be introspective even though they are perfectly capable of it.

2.) Tense aspects between Sun/Moon (Squares / Oppositions): These people are a little more complicated. It’s not that they’re incapable of introspection, because they are, but they always kinda miss the mark. They have an active inner dialogue, but it might not be very constructive for them. They have the potential to be very emotionally intelligent, but it might come with some extra work. For example (and this is just an example I know not everyone with this aspect will be exactly the same), someone with their Sun squaring their Moon might be that kind of person who you might describe as “they have good intentions they just aren’t aware of how toxic they’re actually being”. They might be someone who had a hard childhood— maybe they were abused or bullied, and they’ve always felt like the world was working against them and they’ve been let down by everyone. They might be someone who goes into a helping profession (therapy , social work, etc) in an effort to both understand themselves, and also to help others because they don’t want others to feel the way they did growing up. The ability to be empathetic alone can be a level of emotional intelligence that a lot of people don’t have. They might truly have a very pure heart and pure intentions, but they might also be stuck with an inner dialogue that is not constructive for themselves that creates a victim mentality. These are the people who tend to project their trauma on others without realizing it. They might be aware that they have mental trauma that is affecting their life in some way, and they want to be better, so they seek out mental heath services and get diagnosed with anxiety or depression or bipolar. They now understand that there is a mental illness that can explain a lot of their experiences. However, they are not realizing that the traumatic event is long in the past, and at this point it is actually themselves bringing issues onto themselves, like a self fulfilling prophecy. They could be very emotionally demanding or controlling which could very well push people away, and when people pull away, their inner dialogue is saying “oh now they’re just abandoning me, just like they all do”. Fear of abandonment turns into being even more controlling and emotionally draining when the next person comes around, and it creates a vicious cycle. These people probably really don’t want to hurt anyone and they really are connected to themselves in some way, but they feel so confused at why people keep leaving them. I think these people are still capable of being 100% self aware and taking accountability , realizing the part they play in any given situation, but I think it’s going to take some extra soul searching to do so. Their untrained inner dialogue might say “Okay let’s figure out if I did anything wrong in this situation”, showing that they are open to the idea being wrong. Then they conclude, “Nope I didn’t do anything wrong and they left me because they are a traitor”. This doesn’t mean they aren’t capable though, the ability is there, they just have to train their inner dialogue to be more constructive and willing to take accountability. They are ultimately just as capable of being introspective as anyone else, it’s just probably going to be part of a growth journey they were destined to undergo in this lifetime.

3.) Someone with no aspects between Sun-Moon: These are the people who are going to be quite difficult to be in a close relationship with (romantic or platonic or even familial). They really might not even have an inner dialogue, especially if the Moon is completely un aspected at all. In my experience, they are far less likely to be emotionally intelligent. These people do not have really any connection between themselves as a person and their emotions — no connection between the ego and id , if you will. If you compare them to someone (Person A) who has a harsh aspect between their Sun and Moon, the difference is that Person A does have a connection to themselves, it just might not be a connection that serves them well. Person A is likely to sit down and review a situation, even if they come to the wrong conclusion. Person A is likely to seek out professional help, and the professional help may or may not help. Person B, with 0 Sun - Moon aspects, really might not even review a situation. For example, they can be someone who frequently cheats on their romantic partners, but doesn’t ever question their own actions or why they constantly do that. They’re probably a very avoidant kind of person because they are not very capable of talking about their emotions because they have no idea how to even channel their emotions. I believe someone with this in their birth charts are just less likely to be emotionally intelligent because of a lack of inner dialogue , aka a lack of connection between themselves and their emotions.

I’m also aware that there is a lot of nuance to all of this , and that the whole chart must be taken into account at the end of the day. For example I am an very emotionally intelligent person with Sun trine Moon (Moon is my chart ruler), but my Moon is afflicted by a direct opposition to Jupiter and my Sun is afflicted by a conjunction with Mars so my emotional intelligence journey was a bit complicated to say the least. I definitely caused problems for myself and projected on people a lot, and I had a lot of growing up to do. However, all things considered even at my worst I was always still way more emotionally intelligent compared to most people, so my Sun trine Moon was still very prevalent in the background.

Likewise, my boyfriend has Sun trine Moon, but he has way more intense afflictions to both his Sun and Moon, and he is just now learning how to talk about his feelings and is in therapy for the first time as an almost 30 year old. He really never knew what emotions were before meeting me 3 years ago. You BET I forced him to learn what they are …. LOL my Virgo Moon is not about to be with someone who can’t talk about their emotions. Haha— but therapy has been really helpful for him and he’s finally been able to channel that harmonious Sun trine Moon and he is so much more in tune with himself than either of us ever thought possible and it’s like his inner dialogue came out of hibernation.

I have a friend who has her Moon squaring , well, the rest of her placements lol in an Aquarius stellium. She has some SERIOUS baggage but she is so selfless and cares endlessly for the people around her, like if you call her at 2 AM saying you need a friend, she will show up 10 minutes later with McDonalds and ice cream. However she is being kind of terrible and toxic to her boyfriend, threatening to hurt herself if he leaves, etc… she has a therapist, she knows it’s wrong to do that and she wants to stop hurting people but she doesn’t understand how to stop being toxic. It’s a work in progress for her.

So I know there’s going to be a lot of nuance to all of these aspects, but I think despite all the nuance there is still a truth to the relationship between the Sun and the Moon and someone’s potential or lack thereof to be emotionally mature and have a constructive inner dialogue.

Edit to add: I am not emotionally attached to any theories of mine or patterns I notice, I am more than open to a discussion of someone were to have a different perspective on this matter, that’s why I post here! I don’t want to be confined to my own interpretation of things as I am only one person with one experience.


r/Advancedastrology • • Mar 23 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Natal placements dont make women intimidating to men

0 Upvotes

If you're a woman and have heard that you come off as intimidating to guys, know that it's not about your natal chart. Or astrology. That whole "intimidating" thing isn't written in the stars—it's about society's rules and how some people are raised to see things. Thinking that your zodiac sign or placement makes you too much for some to handle is ignorant (chill, thats not the same as stupid). That's not how it works. It's really about the outdated expectations and hang-ups whoever is telling you that is bringing to the table, not anything in your chart.

Astrology has all energies: assertive fire, emo water, mental air, and practical “doing” earth. These energies don't give af about your gender—they're part of every HUMAN, mixed in unique ways that have nothing to do with your body's biology.

Being true to yourself, showing the world who you really are, that's on you and the environments that you were raised in and are in currently, not just astrology. Astrology lets you know what tools you have, your traits and tendencies, but it's not handing out personality traits based on whether you're a man or a woman. Stop dragging astrology into places its not meant to be. Thats how it continues to get laughed at and banned when it could be a useful tool. Learn what astrology really is.


r/Advancedastrology • • Mar 29 '24

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance What's everyones take on star children in astrology?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Has anyone seen a chart that reflects placements of a star child? A certain child in my close circle has been referred to as a star child by separate intuitives at different times in life. I have heard of star children but never thought to see it in a chart until now. What are your thoughts on this?

I've added his chart to jar memories as I'm not sure how common this is.


r/Advancedastrology • • Oct 08 '22

Conceptual If you want to know your last death time this will helps.

0 Upvotes

I don't know if you belive reincarnation (i don't) but i heard something new. Find your pluto degree & sign in your natal chart and try to go to your asc point from backwards... This is the time you were death date in your last reincarnation... Let say you have 24 degree libra pluto. Your asc is 23 aquarius. Go back and you will reach year 1794 and exact day. I found it funny and google the name who dead these day. It was maximillan robespiere... The funny part is... I always wondering what if a man kill all of corrupted politics in the country since i was kid. I learned from that man what will happen... :)


r/Advancedastrology • • Apr 11 '25

Modern Techniques + Practices Rethinking Planetary Rulership: A Consciousness-Based Approach to the Zodiac

13 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I've been working through some ideas over the past several months and would love to engage in some open, civil discussion with fellow astrologers here. I know many in this community lean toward traditional techniques, and I want to preface by saying I deeply respect the foundations of traditional astrology. That said, my current practice leans more modern, and like any other “-ology,” I believe astrology evolves as our collective consciousness evolves.

Lately, I’ve been exploring a foundational shift in how we understand the zodiac—not just as a circle of signs, but as archetypal essences of consciousness. In doing so, I’ve started to see the signs, planets, houses, and aspects as four distinct but interconnected variables, each representing a unique side of archetypal consciousness.

This line of thinking led me to revisit the rulership system, which has always raised questions for me. Specifically:

  • We have 12 signs, 12 houses, and when distinguishing waxing/waning, 12 aspects.

  • But only 10 “modern” planets.

  • Why do Mercury and Venus each rule two signs that seem archetypally quite different? Gemini (Mercury) squares Virgo (Mercury), and Libra (Venus) quincunxes Taurus (Venus). There’s a sort of cognitive dissonance there, and it’s one I’ve felt since the beginning of my studies over a decade ago.

For a while, this very inconsistency is what drew me to traditional astrology, where the symmetry of rulership felt more consistent. But as the years passed and my understanding evolved, I've begun experimenting with a 12-planet system. After conducting a number of case studies, I’ve been struck by its clarity and consistency.

Here’s the gist:

  • I propose that Ceres (discovered in 1801) is the more resonant planetary archetype for Taurus.

  • And that Chiron (discovered in 1977) has been misunderstood as the “wounded healer” (Pluto's got that transformational role covered well) when in practice, I find Chiron functions more as a chronic fixer or meticulous practitioner—a persistent, unrelenting drive to assess, adjust, and skillfully refine.

A few examples to illustrate:

Ceres – J.P. Morgan
When I first started considering Ceres as a significator of stability, resources, ownership, preservation, and acquisition, I asked myself: Who embodies this consolidation archetype? My first thought: J.P. Morgan. He was a powerful American banker who dominated the financial industry, created the first billion-dollar corporation (U.S. Steel), and played a pivotal role in stabilizing the U.S. economy during crises. He was also known as a “robber baron”—a figure who monopolized industries, crushed competition, and influenced government power.

So imagine my reaction when I pulled his chart and saw: Ceres cazimi in Aries**, in his 2nd house.**
The symbolism here is striking. His legacy was defined by personal acquisition, control of resources, and financial dominance—textbook 2nd house and Taurus themes, expressed through the assertive and pioneering nature of Aries, with Ceres at the heart of it.

Chiron – Jennette McCurdy
Jennette McCurdy rose to fame as a Nickelodeon star, publicly seen as bold, funny, and confident. But privately, she lived under the strict control of an emotionally enmeshed and abusive mother—a reality she shares in her memoir I’m Glad My Mom Died.

In her chart, Chiron conjuncts her Leo Ascendant, suggesting that her entire self-image was filtered through a lens of chronic self-correction. This wasn’t just insecurity—it was a relentless drive to “fix” how she was seen. Her Moon/Mars in Taurus in the 10th forms a waning square to Chiron, and this combo speaks volumes:

  • The Moon = mother, emotional needs

  • Mars = bodily autonomy and assertion

  • Taurus = comfort, safety, consistency

The square to Chiron indicates her instincts and actions were in tension with how she had to appear in order to survive. She describes being trained to “smile right,” “say the right thing,” even suppress her appetite and natural expressions to meet her mother’s demands. Chiron here isn’t just wounded—it’s perpetually editing. And that Chiron–Ceres opposition? Couldn’t be more symbolic.

I recognize that Ceres and Chiron aren't new to astrology, and that many still don’t use them due to their astronomical classifications or a perception that they’re "minor" players. But all celestial bodies were once just “wandering stars,” and I think it’s worth re-evaluating what these energies actually do in practice—especially if we want our tools to match our evolving understanding of consciousness.

I know this perspective is a bit disruptive to current models, and I don’t expect everyone to agree—but I’d love to hear your thoughts. If you're curious, I’ve written more on this theory (with additional examples) on my Substack. But mostly, I just wanted to open up the floor for respectful, curious conversation because I know I won't get anywhere working with my theories if I don't' start putting them out there! Appreciate your time and thoughts <3


r/Advancedastrology • • Jan 27 '25

General Discussion + Astrology Assistance Natal charts and love languages?

1 Upvotes

Say I wanted to do a chart interpretation for someone and I want to determine what their love language is. What placements would I look at?

I was thinking rising sign/ 1st house since it’s outward behavior. Then chart ruler? Maybe one’s Venus placement, the house ruler, Venus’s dignity?

I could be totally wrong here. What else would I look at?