r/AdvancedRunning • u/KlaasLok • Mar 02 '24
Training ‘Polarized model’ not most effective for the average runner
The so-called polarized model is quite popular these days. However, I wonder if it truly is the most effective approach for the average runner.
Personally, I don’t believe so. When 80% of your training consists of slow running in zone 1 (focused on fat metabolism), you risk spending many hours each week plodding along without maintaining elasticity or optimizing running economy. Additionally, most average runners have a 50-50 distribution of slow- and fast-twitch muscle fibers. The latter are partly aerobic, so why emphasize training the aerobic slow-twitch fibers and neglecting your extra aerobic fast-twitch engine?
To recruit these fast-twitch fibers and activate them using carbohydrates and lactate as fuel, you need higher intensity training in the high-end aerobic zone. The reason this high-end aerobic area is skipped in polarized training is – according to those who advocate it - that “it is too slow to achieve a major training effect, but too fast to get through unscathed.” I don't agree.
What are your thoughts?