r/AdvancedRunning • • Mar 02 '24

Training ‘Polarized model’ not most effective for the average runner

0 Upvotes

The so-called polarized model is quite popular these days. However, I wonder if it truly is the most effective approach for the average runner.

Personally, I don’t believe so. When 80% of your training consists of slow running in zone 1 (focused on fat metabolism), you risk spending many hours each week plodding along without maintaining elasticity or optimizing running economy. Additionally, most average runners have a 50-50 distribution of slow- and fast-twitch muscle fibers. The latter are partly aerobic, so why emphasize training the aerobic slow-twitch fibers and neglecting your extra aerobic fast-twitch engine?

To recruit these fast-twitch fibers and activate them using carbohydrates and lactate as fuel, you need higher intensity training in the high-end aerobic zone. The reason this high-end aerobic area is skipped in polarized training is – according to those who advocate it - that “it is too slow to achieve a major training effect, but too fast to get through unscathed.” I don't agree.
What are your thoughts?


r/AdvancedRunning • • May 14 '20

nSuns Challenge

0 Upvotes

GoFundMe for nSuns

For those out of the loop, here is an interesting post that resulted in the ban of a multitude of individuals. These individuals questioned the fitness capabilities of popular reddit user nSuns.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Fitness/comments/ghda5h/concurrent_training_deadlifting_6_plates_and/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

To turn this negativity into something good- I propose we raise money for a charitable cause! With the unprecedented times, there are many people and organizations in need. nSuns has a vast following, and could find a way to comfortably complete his capabilities for us on video. I’m confident we could get our reddit community, as well as the broader fitness community to come together and raise $5000+ for the charity of nSuns choosing.

16:34 5km. 4:55 mile. Along with his 370 bench and 592 deadlift.

Quite understandably, he is concerned with keeping his identity private. However I believe we can find a way to alleviate his concerns.

We will allow nSuns to choose a neutral location. Whatever state or province he chooses. There will only be 2 spectators allowed. A member of his choosing, whom he trusts to film. A mutually agreed upon non partisan member of whatever city he chooses to run in. Perhaps nSuns is religious and he’ll accept a local pastor to be the bystander. Perhaps he trusts the local mayor? He will complete the runs and lifts over a 2-3 day period. We will cover hotel expenses. I’d suggest it take place a couple hours from his house for privacy reasons- as he may be a future fitness celebrity after he completes this. nSuns may even want to blur his face in said videos.

We will foot the bill for travel expenses of him and his trusted associate. The track will need to be surveyed to be 400m.

Open to other suggestions.

Let's make some magic happen fitness community!

TLDR, We donate to a charity of nSuns choice if he can prove his accomplishments.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Sep 23 '23

Health/Nutrition Covid vaccine

6 Upvotes

Just curious how getting the covid vaccine impacts your training. I'm 35M and got the most recent Moderna shot, and there is of course always a very slight risk of myocarditis (plus other side effects of tiredness, malaise, etc).

How much time do you take off? Do you go right back to 100% after a day or two of feeling fine again or have you taken it easy for longer? No time off? Just curious on some thoughts.

Note: I have to get the vaccine, as do many others (and have already gotten it). If you have anti-vaxx opinions, please don't bother posting. I'm just curious how much time I should consider taking off, if any, based on others experiences - I wasn't running nearly this much during my last jabs.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Jan 31 '21

Results Bodybuilder Nick Bare just ran a 02:56:27 marathon at 200lbs body weight.

0 Upvotes

In the original post I wrote that it's probably an unofficial world record at that weight. Many redditors here wrote their objections and gave examples of better performances. So it turned out it is not. Training volume was around 80-90km a week. https://www.youtube.com/post/UgyQI9BEoYRQcal4blV4AaABCQ


r/AdvancedRunning • • Sep 05 '20

Training CCW Chafing Help

14 Upvotes

Chafing and Running

Hello, I’m a female who runs 40-50mpw. I used to carry (M&P Shield .40) while running in a BravoBelt belly band in a back carry position, but the back strap/grip area is exposed and chafes me quite a bit, so I stopped carrying at all. Really want to find a solution. I also have a Glock 9mm but don’t prefer to carry it as it doesn’t have a manual safety, and I carry with a round chambered.

I’ve done microfiber cloths between my back and the grip, and while it works, it would be a nightmare if I needed to draw. A corset looks like a great option, as it goes high enough to cover the grip, but doesn’t seem optimal for exercise, nor is it very cost effective. Leggings seem like a good option, but again, really expensive given I run 5-6 days per week and don’t want to have to outlay for 3-4 pairs for rotation.

I posted on the CCW subs but am getting a lot of suggestions from people who don’t actually run, so was hoping someone here had suggestions??

Also, I run in leggings and a tank top and live in South Texas where it’s effing scalding constantly. Last ditch effort will be to try a compression tank or something under the belt but ugh. So hot.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Mar 29 '23

General Discussion Pet Peeve - Nobody Answers the Actual Question

0 Upvotes

Why does it seem like everyone on this sub never wants to answer someone's questions, and they only want to shame them for not training enough, or running enough MPW, or that their training plan is insufficient. Countless times I have seen an OP specifically state that they are time constrained, or another reason why they cannot solely bump up MPW, and they just get berated in the comments, or people do not want to offer any suggestions - they only than to put them down. Two cents for the day.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Aug 28 '20

Tips on finally breaking 35:00 in 5k?

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I am trying to break 35:00 over 5k. The route I have planned is fairly straight and downhill about 1000'.

About me/my training:

-5"8/25/M/140lbs -History of shin splints -I've been running a 4.86 mile loop about 3 days/week for 3 months (HR 180), and I play rec league soccer on Sundays (goalie) -For cross training I do 30 pullups and 60 pushups every other day -I alternate between 2 different pairs of Asics gel Kayano and use a Garmin forerunner to track my cadence (192)

I'm frustrated I cannot get 35 min. I feel like my training is on the same level as some 17:30 guys, but my shin injuries hold me back. Hopefully this downhill route helps.

Any tips on where I can squeeze out a few more seconds would be appreciated!

Thanks


r/AdvancedRunning • • Jan 14 '24

General Discussion How cold is too cold to race

5 Upvotes

We’re getting the first really cold temps in some parts of the US this week, and I know a few people with races this weekend.

What’s the cutoff for canceling a race for cold temps?

What about if you’re a race director in a place where you know that the local runners aren’t acclimated at all yet-for example somewhere that’s had temps no lower than high 30F so far this season, but the morning of your race it will be single digits? (Because I realize a race in Minnesota when temp is 15F may be just another day for runners…but in Georgia it’s something that rarely happens…)


r/AdvancedRunning • • Oct 25 '24

Gear Apple Watch 10 for serious runner?

1 Upvotes

Would love to hear from anyone who daily drives AW10 and does all runnings in them (better if coming from the Ultras). I've had two generations of Ultras and while I love the functionalities, they are too bulky and a bit inconvenient, AW10 feels so much more comfortable on wrist.

I'm pretty clear about all the technical differences (with regards to runners, lack of the button, battery, no precision start, no dual band GPS, etc.). But want to hear real life user experience in them and whether you are happy with it (or see meaningful gap between Ultra1/2).

For reference, I run 80kpw/50mpw and rarely do more than HM or over 2 hours runs. Don't need them for the sleep either. So battery is not a huge concern for me.

Thanks!

EDIT: Typo correction; Don't intend to start a debate of AW vs other brands here (purely personal preference to stick to AW here). But welcome any comment if you want to articulate why AW (Ultra or otherwise) doesn't work for serious runners


r/AdvancedRunning • • Oct 13 '25

Training Don't "practice fuelling" for a marathon

0 Upvotes

Ok now that I've got the clickbait out of the way, I'm just here to reframe how you think about mid-run fuelling. Yes, obviously you should use specific fuelling strategies on race day that you have practiced before. But it goes much further than that! 

Fuelling more is the lowest hanging fruit for 90% of runners*. Everyone by this point knows that you need to be taking in calories to perform your best in a marathon - you run low on glycogen in your muscles and liver as the race goes on, so you need to have glucose floating through your veins for your muscles to utilize. But you don't need to wait until your body is almost depleted to be taking in calories. The deeper into your glycogen reserves your body goes, the harder it makes recovery, and the harder it makes generating the same amount of forward power (making you slow down late in runs).

The running world is far behind the triathlon and cycling world on mid-effort fuelling. Ask any competitive cyclist, and they're taking in a LOT of carbs on most rides, at the very least every workout ride. Running makes it harder because of the up-and-down motion of your guts, but the underlying principle is the same - at a high effort, your body is using a higher proportion of carbs relative to fat, and it speeds up recovery a lot if you have external carbs floating around the bloodstream.

Getting back to the clickbait title, your fuelling for the marathon shouldn't be *higher* than what you typically do in training. Ideally you'd be somewhere 70-90g/hr during the race, and train higher than that for harder efforts (eg 100g/hr). If you only "practice" fuelling on long runs, you're gonna get some of the benefits of course, but you'll also open yourself up to stomach issues during those key efforts. Fuel aggressively on basically any run that isn't an easy run! Then you get to long runs and your fuelling is nothing new, it will actually help you, and you can focus on things other than stomach cramping or shitting your pants. **This isn't "practicing fuelling", it's bringing yourself up to a better standard of fuelling that you maintain for the race. You don't "practice running with good form" and run sloppily every other time, hoping you can run with good form on race day**. I'll also add this goes for fluids too, though specific amounts depends a whole lot on conditions. I'll also caveat that you **should** actually practice your exact marathon strategy at least sometimes to prepare - sugar water is a great training tool but different fuels will treat your body differently. But the carb rate should be pretty well locked in!

For my qualifications for this post, I just cut down from 2:36 to 2:32 in the marathon, averaging 58 miles per week over the last 12 weeks of the build. (2:36 this spring, ran 2:39 in December and 2:40 Dec 2023). I focused on fuelling 100g/hr during every workout, LR, and MLR (so 4/6 runs per week, sometimes easy runs too). I'm not here to sell a low-mileage program or anything, just to illustrate that focusing on fuelling as a part of recovery allows you to run harder workouts that give you more benefits. But also don't just take my word for it, do some research for yourself!

For specifics, I use Carbs Fuel gels, which are $2 for 50g/200cal. That works for me, but before I found those I used Gu, SiS, Gatorade powder from Amazon, literal table sugar, whatever you can get. Bringing a bottle with 100g of table sugar in water on an hour run will work pretty much the same as the gel strategy and is dirt cheap at the grocery store. 

I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on fuelling! It seems like the high carb revolution is happening but hasn't made its way fully into training for most people yet. 

*I made this stat up, but it feels about right!


r/AdvancedRunning • • Sep 28 '23

Health/Nutrition Lets talk caffeine doping

2 Upvotes

I drink coffees (but, given races are generally early morning, only one or two before).

Caffeine is obviously a performance enhancing drug.

Who takes caffeine, how do you take it, when do you take it, how have you dealt with side effects, how much do you take?

Im not talking about a single maurten 100CAF, im more talking about hundreds of mg.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Sep 29 '26

Health/Nutrition Legal Supplements for Marathon Trials

3 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm chasing the OTQ dream and have been thinking a lot about supplements to aid my training. I've personally never been a user of supplements although now that I'm running my highest mileage weeks ever, back to back, I'm wondering if there's something more I could be doing to squeeze some extra juice out of myself.

I'm currently running 90 miles per week, two workouts per week, and one quality long-run. I've run 01:04:50 in my most recent half marathon and now I'm shifting my training for the trials. That being said I believe I need to take supplements that are NSF certified. I recently went to my local target and couldn't find anything officially certified using the NSF app so I'm curious, what do y'all take? Is there a place I should be ordering supplements online (i.e. vitamin D, vitamin C, fish oil, etc ...).

I'm not looking to overdo anything but I'd love some help in finding the right balance of supplements to aid my training while ensuring I'm consuming something that's legal for USATF.

Thanks all!


r/AdvancedRunning • • Jun 14 '19

General Discussion The whole sub 2 project isn't that inspiring to me. Change my mind.

0 Upvotes

This is a VERY hot take and I expect the down votes to come pouring in, but the whole sub 2 initiative isn't that inspiring to me. Yes, it would be awesome to see someone do it, it would be great for the sport and prove again that humans are without limits. But to me, what's more inspiring is seeing a race like the 2018 Boston Marathon where Yuki Kawauchi grinds out a 2:15 in horrendous conditions. Those kinds of races where it's more pure to the sport and you don't care about what shoes you're wearing or what the weather is like are so much more inspiring to me than watching Kipchoge get a whole 1st class experience with pacers, perfectly designed 4% shoes, perfect everything in order to break 2 hours. I just feel like races back in the old days of running where Bill Rodgers and Alberto Salazar in 1982 are battling in the heat of Boston and have regular shoes and no special Maurten gels are so much more inspiring to me than watching Kipchoge getting everything but his training handed to him.

I don't mean to disrespect Kipchoge at all, he's a monster and trains harder than anyone out there, but I just feel like if he breaks 2 or not, I won't be as inspired as if I watched him grind out a 2:07 on an uphill course or something. I don't care about the time as much as the race effort.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Apr 22 '24

Training If you could run more than 160kms a week would you do it?

0 Upvotes

(Really trying not to do a 'look at me post'. I consider myself average in speed but above average in durability and just am curious in what people think about super-high milage.)

Since last August I've been up-ing kms and currently run 160 kms a week. Currently, I'm targeting a marathon at anything under 3:30.

I currently run 23 kms per day 7 days a week in very minimalist shoes (Saguaro-$60.00 barefoot shoes)

50% of these runs are with a training partner who runs 1:30 per km slower than my easy pace. On these days I do 8-10 with her then finish 10-8kms alone at moderate pace.

50% of the runs are by myself doing the full 18kms at moderate effort (zone 2-3). I live in a VERY hilly area, so am getting 2,000m of elevation gain at minimum per week. There is no way to avoid this.

Immediately after my longer runs each day I do 5 km of barefoot intervals on a grass soccer field which I do at multiples of 200m reps at 3:30 km pace.

I haven't been doing long runs, because I've been ticking up weekly kms whenever I felt ready since last August.

I have no fatigue, body is fine, and recovery is good.

My speeds at moderate effort are slowly coming down with time.

Should I just keep ticking up kms? I don't seem to have any durability problems. And I'm not someone that pushes to exhaustion or forces hard efforts.

Basically, if you could run above 160kms a week would you do it?


r/AdvancedRunning • • 28d ago

Open Discussion Hot Take: carbon supershoes are not for everyone

0 Upvotes

Just wanted to share the results of my decidedly non-scientific n=1 experiment with a super-shoeless marathon.

For context, prior to this year my marathon PR was 3:03:30, in 2017. Since then I've run 4 more marathons, all of which ended with debilitating calf cramps. Until this year, all of my marathon times were hovering around 3:09ish. And this was despite each time being in solidly sub-3 shape, having great fueling, and race times at shorter distances supporting 3 hrs as a realistic goal. Every single time, around mile 20-23, I would start getting the calf twitches that tell you they are about to seize up. And then they would, and then it'd be game over. The worst was in 2025 Chicago, where my cramps hit at mile 13. This year I got in the best shape of my life and ran the Eugene Marathon with training that supported 2:55. I tracked on pace until mile 20, and yet again my calves did me in and I limped into a 3:02 finish. It was rough to watch 3 hours slip away out of my grasp in the last 2 miles of the race.

Looking back, a puzzling thing for me was that I never experience calf cramps in training, and it would only happen on race day. I'm one of those people who likes to save race shoes for race day, so I hypothesized that maybe the common denominator is my race shoes. In normal non plated shoes, I was accustomed to feeling fatigue in my quads, hams and glutes after a hard workout, but the race shoes (vaporfly 2 and AP3) seemed to focus all the stress on my calves. The last straw was a half marathon in Sept, where though I was happy to run a PR wearing my AP3, I started getting the "don't go any faster than this or I'll cramp up on you" in the final mile.

My most recent marathon was last Sunday Oct 11. I decided to run my last few long runs in the non-plated but plenty fast Megablast, and felt no speed penalty compared to my AP3. I wore the Megablast on race day, and for the first time since 2017, I finally finished a race with NO cramps. Also ran an even split race which was a first for me too. Oh and yes I finally broke 3.. 2:58:50!! At age 47.

Now I'm not trying to say carbon shoes are bad and that everyone should go out and get the Megablast. For me it was about being willing to question conventional wisdom and pay close attention to patterns in my running history.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Mar 27 '25

General Discussion World Marathon Majors - ugh

34 Upvotes

I have done a few of the WMM and someday may do NYC but is very doubtful I will ever get the 6-star (or is it seven now?). It seems to me that the WMM have lost the "cool" factor in certain running circles. Every influencer can just buy their way in these days. Now with expansion plans of the majors just undermines the prestige.

Also:

1 Over-commercialization The Majors have become massive commercial spectacles. Corporate sponsorships, expo hype, expensive merchandise, and VIP packages often overshadow the grassroots running culture.

Many runners feel like they're paying for an "experience" rather than a pure, competitive race.

Some races (looking at you, NYC) have registration fees that have skyrocketed.

2. Lottery System & Accessibility For many Majors, it's no longer just about being fast. You're at the mercy of lotteries, charity spots with hefty fundraising minimums, or tour operators.

Even Boston, once purely merit-based with time standards, now has rolling cutoffs making it harder to qualify even if you technically meet the standard.

3. Crowded Fields The sheer size of the fields (40,000 to 50,000+ runners) means that for non-elite or sub-elite runners, it's hard to run freely.

Bottlenecks, crowded water stops, and even jostling for space at the start can be frustrating if you're trying to run a personal best.

4. Less Focus on the Competitive Spirit Some feel the Majors cater more to "bucket list" runners than competitive amateurs.

The narrative often leans more on participation and "experience" rather than the joy of racing hard, competing, and fast times.

5. Overhyped vs. Underappreciated Local Races Many experienced runners discover that smaller, well-organized marathons offer flatter courses, cheaper entries, less stress, and a more welcoming or intimate vibe.

They might opt for niche marathons like CIM (California International Marathon), Grandma's Marathon, or fast European marathons where they can actually focus on racing without all the distractions.

6. "Six Star" Trend Fatigue The Abbott Six Star Medal challenge (completing all six majors) is a huge motivator for some, but others see it as turning racing into a checklist rather than a love for running itself.

Some experienced runners see it as "marathon tourism" more than serious racing.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Jun 01 '25

General Discussion How do you approach and structure your training?

0 Upvotes

Hey fellow runners! I had an interesting convo with some friends the other day about how we each approach and structure our training. What we learned from our small sample size is that we all do things completely differently.

This made me really curious about how others approach training. Just 5 quick questions. Would love to hear your answers:

  1. How do you currently plan your training? A. I follow a structured plan (coach, online, book, etc.) B. I loosely build my own plan C. I run based on feel D. I use Strava, Garmin, or another app to guide me E. I go through phases—it changes often

  2. What’s your biggest challenge with consistency or progress? A. Staying motivated B. Knowing what to do week to week C. Avoiding injury or burnout D. Time and life getting in the way E. Hitting a plateau

  3. Where do you usually go for structure or ideas when training for something specific? A. Online plans or downloads B. Books or training guides C. Strava/Garmin-style apps D. Friends or running groups E. I just figure it out as I go

  4. How important is it that your training fits your goals and schedule? A. Extremely important B. Somewhat important C. Not that important D. I don’t think about it much

  5. Is your current training approach working well for you? A. Yes – it’s dialed in B. Mostly, but it could be better C. Not really – I’m figuring it out D. Definitely not

Appreciate anyone willing to reply—happy to share a summary of the most common answers if there’s interest!


r/AdvancedRunning • • Oct 04 '23

General Discussion Tracksmith getting destroyed after posting this on Instagram

55 Upvotes

Tracksmith posted this yesterday on Instagram releasing their BQ Singlet. Definitely triggered a lot of people who didn't make the cutoff time this year as well as every day runners who are not identified as 'fast' runner in stereotypical concept. Such a bad move marketing vise knowing people are frustrated by the cutoff time not even a week ago. I heard people saying Tracksmith gives them only open to fast runner vibe. This is definitely not a good look for them.

Feel this sub has a lot of 'fast' runners (no offense at all). Wonder what people's perspectives are.

Post attached below:

“This is not a jogging race.”
When entries opened for the 1970 Boston Marathon, the co-race directors issued this stern edict. Perhaps unknowingly, they were writing the first chapter in a decades long story of amateur excellence. The BQ is not just a time. For many runners it represents the culmination of thousands of lonely miles; months of waking up in the darkness to get the workout done; and the defeat of the fear that they were chasing an impossible dream.
We launched the first BQ Singlet in 2015 and every year we've worked to improve the technical features. This year, we wanted to make sure it’s something special for qualifiers only. Hard to get, harder to earn, the 2024 BQ Singlet is reserved for runners who have both qualified and registered for the 2024 Boston Marathon.
Learn more and reserve your spot in line to buy a BQ24 Singlet today via the link in our bio.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Oct 05 '22

General Discussion World Marathon Majors - why?

0 Upvotes

With London and Berlin taking place recently, and the Tokyo ballot being drawn, there has been a lot of chat about the World Marathon Majors and getting a 6 star medal.

Am I the only one who doesn't see the appeal? I get wanting to do overseas marathons, but the amount of travel involved seems excessive, and they aren't places I'd necessarily choose to visit.

I'm in the UK, so London is a biggie. Berlin isn't too far to go, and it's a fast course. Definitely feasible for a weekend away.

However, to complete all the majors, you'd have to make 3 trips to the US. Chicago being on the list makes very little sense to me.

There is a whole world of Marathons out there - why do people focus on these 6?


r/AdvancedRunning • • May 05 '25

General Discussion With tourism to the USA tanking, will this impact participation rates for their 3 majors?

0 Upvotes

Intentionally putting politics aside for a moment, air arrivals to the USA are currently down by 13.5% year on year and land visits from Canada are down 31.9%.

I hypothesise that those who have qualified for Boston, Chicago and New York are unlikely to bail due to outside factors as they've worked hard to qualify. Also there's probably a strong enough domestic demand to pickup the slack given there's already an overflow of demand for marathons.

However, I also hypothesise that there might be either more ballot places available than usual during the next qualification rounds and also possibly less 'qualifiers' getting knocked back.

Curious what others think.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Feb 23 '25

Elite Discussion Citius Mag & Shelby Houlihan

0 Upvotes

Does Citius Mag’s (lack of) coverage of Shelby Houlihan this season - and especially at USATF Indoors - read as disingenuous and immature to anyone else? Unfortunately, track and field (and running writ-large) does not have very many news sources. Problems with Letsrun and Flotrack are well documented, and I think Citius Mag is seen as many as the go-to, especially for live updates and meet results. Heck, their tagline is “CITIUS MAG | Running + Track and Field News.”

Since Houlihan has returned from her ban, I don’t think she has been mentioned once across Citius’s Instagram or Twitter feeds. Today’s Instagram posts - functionally live updates from the meet - have posts congratulating Hiltz (first) and Morgan (third), deservedly so. But as far as I know, Houlihan has now qualified for Worlds. Will they cover it if/when she races for Team USA?

Most recognize that the situation is thorny, and it’s clear from their actions that Citius does not “approve” of Houlihan, but reporting on an event is not an endorsement, and incomplete coverage of meet(s) is almost as frustrating as no coverage at all.

Just my $0.02 from a very neutral observer of the women’s professional landscape.

Edit: As another poster pointed out, they did post an interview with her on their YouTube page.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Feb 05 '25

Training Norwegian singles vs. polarized training in a 2014 comparison study

3 Upvotes

There's been a ton of interest in the Norwegian training method because of the fantastic success of its stars. Even if it works for Olympians, It's not clear that it's great for everyday hobbyjoggers. An older study in 2014 (full text) seems to shed some light on this question. I'd summarize it as follows:

Study cohort: 30 male athletes (~35 years old, averaging 40:00 10K time), training for their next 10K.

Intervention: They are randomized to either "80% easy / 20% hard" training, or "45% easy / 35% medium / 20% hard" training, where medium corresponds to Zone 3 in a 5-zone model. Either way, both groups average 30 miles per week or 4 hours of running, and train for 10 weeks.

Results: On race day, the 80/20 group improves by about 2 minutes, whereas the easy/medium/hard group improves by about 90 seconds. The study does some statistical dissection about whether or not this result is "significant" but at face value it seems like 80/20 training is better.

====

How do advocates of the Norwegian singles method explain this older study? It's not "true" Norwegian singles because there's hard running? Group isn't elite enough to see a benefit? Study isn't long enough to see a benefit? I think these are valid criticisms but walk away from this thinking that for a non-elite runner like myself, polarized training is probably better, and I should do these Norwegian intervals mainly if it feels like "fun," not to run faster per se.


r/AdvancedRunning • • Sep 23 '26

Training Copying Clayton for BQ Attempt

5 Upvotes

I wanted to hop on and post a little of my experience copying Clayton. I am a 35M targeting 2:55 in a mid-December marathon here in North Texas, hoping that will give me enough buffer for a 2028 BQ. I've run 15:38 5k on a very downhill course in my early 20's, and 3:06 at St. George in my late 20's. Prior mileage highs were 55 a couple times. Two years ago I dipped under 84 in the half on the same course where I will attempt 2:55.

Due to where I live both route-wise and weather-wise I am 100% treadmill based. I spent all summer working up to 40ish miles/week and got to the point where I could also run 9 miles in 63 minutes on the treadmill. I also spent the summer experimenting to figure out my caffeine and fueling preferences, since I didn't fuel at all at St George. I've learned that I can tolerate 300-400ish mg of caffeine for a long run and about 60g carbs/hour. I like to take a sip of Precision Fuel gel every ten minutes or so, which will line up nicely with the fueling stations at my marathon.

The most intimidating thing so far has been committing to a time goal. The last time I trained for a marathon, I only wanted to finish. That said, I'm a big Clayton Young and Ed Eyestone fan (I took Jogging 101 from him in college, and he is a genius, and so so nice), so I took the prior Copying Clayton workouts posted here and plugged them into AI to try and calibrate everything for my goal pace (6:40/mile).

First week key workouts: 6 fatigue miles (6:50 pace) 3xmile @ 6 flat. Had to bail after second mile, it was really hard. 6 miles at MP-split it into 3/2/1. Long run of 12 miles with 2 at MP. Hit 50 ish miles this week.

Second week key workouts 2x3 miles at 19@2, 3 min, 19:04. Felt really good. 2xmile, 2x.75, 2x800. Had to split the .75's up, but otherwise felt good. started at 6 flat ish for the 2xmiles and tried to increase pace each rep. Lonf run of 14 miles with 3 at MP. Hit 54 miles this week.

Third week key workouts: 6 miles at MP (nailed it, 39:48). 10x1k w/1 min rest starting at 4:03 and working my way down to 3:43. 3:55 average. 16 mile long run with last mile in 6:43. 45 miles that week due to achilles issues.

Fourth week (current). Key workouts: 8 fatigue miles at 6:58, ten minutes rest, 3xmile with 3 min rest at 5:59, 6:02, 5:53. Today did 4x2 miles w/3 min rest at 12;41, 12:44, 12:42, 12:34. 18 mile long run on Saturday with 4 miles at MP.

I'm really enjoying the Clayton Young/BYU method so far. It's been fun to try and copy it. Positive signs so far have been easy recovery from long runs and getting more comfortable at MP. Things to work on: stay healthy, add some hill work into the intervals since race day is mostly flat but not totally, and continue gut training. I hate carrying the gels, so it's been nice to stash them on the treadmill deck.

We will see if smarter, better fueled me on a flat course can run faster than younger, dumber me on a downhill course!

Cheers!


r/AdvancedRunning • • Oct 15 '25

Open Discussion Does anyone have experience working on their race line? (e.g. running the tangents)

2 Upvotes

Recently raced a half marathon and picked up a 2 minute PB. Very happy with my result but I'm always looking for the next aspect to improve. According to my watch GPS* I covered around 21.3km - 1% further than I needed to. It feels like a good 50 something seconds on the table to chip away from for the next race, without even thinking about improving fitness.

I'm guessing this is made from the general crowd weaving that's required and probably from not taking corner routes efficiently - tbh I've never paid much attention to it until today.

Has anyone tried to work on this before? What did you work on to improve it? Was the effort of concentration in picking smarter places to weave through and pick your tangents precisely worth the trade off?

(* Yes I know, GPS is not accurate, but it seems like enough of a discrepancy to be something)