First, make sure the baby is no longer a baby. This is important. Babies are notoriously difficult to reason with. They interrupt, refuse to listen, take everything personally, and have been known to shit themselves rather than concede a point. Which, admittedly, doesn’t distinguish them from certain adults, but at least the babies have an excuse. Wait until yours has grown up. Ideally, until it has spent several decades attempting to understand itself. Until it has acquired a reasonable vocabulary, a mortgage perhaps, a dodgy knee, a few failed relationships, and an irritating habit of asking questions about its childhood. Then, when the former baby tells you that something which happened in infancy may have affected the rest of its life, look it squarely in the eye and say:
“But you can’t possibly remember that.”
Boom! Got ‘em! The beauty of this argument is that it requires no knowledge whatsoever of the subject under discussion. You needn’t know anything about attachment, infant development, the nervous system, or indeed the baby in question. All you need is an unwavering belief that anything a person cannot consciously remember cannot possibly have affected them. Which does, admittedly, throw your own birth into some doubt. But we’ll come back to that. Now, should the baby persist, and they often do, particularly the adopted variety, you’ll need to deploy the second line of defence.
“If nobody had told you, you would never have known.”
Magnificent! An absolute triumph of logic. It’s no different to when someone breaks their leg while unconscious. Clearly they haven’t suffered an injury until someone tells them about it. As we know, the bone simply awaits confirmation. I think we should also dispense with quite a lot of early childhood care. Why bother comforting a distressed infant when it won’t remember being distressed? Why worry about a baby’s emotional environment? Why all this fuss about holding, soothing, responding, bonding? They won’t remember a bloody thing. Think of the savings!
Of course, the awkward thing is that we’ve spent decades being told that the earliest years of childhood are among the most important in human development. I admit, it’s tricky. The ‘woke’ hot potatoes of personality, emotional regulation, attachment, and trust. The period when a small, helpless human being begins learning whether the world is a place in which someone comes when they cry. Entire professions have been built around the importance of these years. But there’s good news. Apparently, none of this applies to adopted children. An extraordinary biological exception. The adopted infant, it seems, is impervious to early experience, provided nobody mentions it later. I wonder why somebody hasn’t published a paper. I feel a submission coming on.
Now, here’s where things become particularly entertaining. You must never allow the adoptee to confuse the issue with their own experience. They may tell you they struggled to bond with their adoptive parents and that relationships have been difficult. It’s likely they’ve spent decades trying to understand a feeling of disconnection they couldn’t name, long before they knew enough about adoption to begin questioning it. This is all terribly inconvenient. Your job is to explain that they’re imagining things. There are however a veritable cornucopia of responses from which to choose. You can mention they’re exaggerating or dwelling on the past, or my personal favourite, that they should be grateful.
Gratitude is a wonderfully versatile instrument. It can be used to end almost any uncomfortable conversation without actually addressing it. When a friend’s house burned down recently I had to remind them that despite losing everything.. at least the fire brigade showed up. Be grateful for small mercies. But back to our baby. Always point out that their adoptive parents loved them without knowing if they did and remind them that they were chosen.
Ah yes, chosen. What a splendid little word. We’ve been dining out on that one for generations. It’s rather like telling someone who has lost a leg how fortunate they are to have been given a prosthetic. Never mind the missing limb, just look at the craftsmanship! And the beauty of being chosen is that it neatly disposes of anything that might have happened beforehand. A sort of emotional amnesty. All previous events are hereby declared null and void, and the child may proceed with its new life, presumably without the inconvenience of having had an earlier one.
It also has the rather wonderful advantage of making the adoptee’s gratitude compulsory. After all, someone chose you. The least you can do is avoid mentioning anything that might spoil the occasion. I wonder sometimes if people realise how peculiar this sounds to those of us who have lived it. As though being loved by one family means we couldn’t possibly have experienced the loss of another as though the two things can’t exist together. And I’ve always been intrigued by the apparent ability of love to travel backwards through time. If only I’d known. There are quite a few things in my life I’d have liked to send a little happiness back to. Perhaps I could have posted some to my three-month-old self, care of the children’s home.
But there’s another technique for winning an argument with a baby, and it may be the most effective of all. Don’t acknowledge that there’s an argument to be had in the first place. I recently read something written by an adopted woman whose husband simply doesn’t believe that her early experiences could have affected her. His reasoning was that if nobody had told her she was adopted, she’d never have known. Therefore, presumably, she couldn’t have been affected.
Brilliant, isn’t it? I can only imagine the medical breakthroughs awaiting us if we apply this logic more widely. Unconscious patients could simply be sent home. Why bother treating something they couldn’t remember happening? And those pesky childhood experiences we’ve been studying for the better part of a century? A complete waste of everyone’s time. The thing that struck me wasn’t so much that her husband didn’t understand preverbal trauma. To be fair, it’s a complex subject. Even those who study it don’t agree on everything, and there are plenty of questions about how particular early experiences influence later life. No, what pissed me off was his absolute certainty.
He wasn’t fucking there! He didn’t experience her infancy, her childhood, her relationships or the years she spent trying to make sense of herself. He hasn’t occupied her body or mind for so much as a moment. But apparently he’s in a better position to explain her life than she is. I’d quite like that kind of confidence. Imagine the time I’d save if I could reach definitive conclusions about other people’s lives without the tiresome business of knowing anything about them. Here’s what really got to me. She wasn’t asking him to become a therapist or write a doctoral thesis on attachment and she wasn’t asking him to agree with every conclusion she’d reached. She didn’t ask him to fix something that happened decades ago. She said it would be lovely to feel understood. Even a little. Even a little. Christ!
Asking the person she shares her life with for the tiniest bit of recognition, and somehow even that’s a bridge too far.
I do wonder how we arrived at this peculiar arrangement in which people with absolutely no experience of being adopted have become so remarkably knowledgeable about what it’s like. It’s quite an achievement really. Ask someone what it’s like to be born to one mother and raised by another. They probably won’t know. Ask what it feels like to have two birth certificates, or to discover that the name you’ve lived with wasn’t the first one given to you. Ask them what it might mean to have the beginning of your life recorded by people you may never have met. They’ll probably look at you rather blankly. Perfectly understandable. But ask whether any of these things could have affected you and suddenly they’re positively encyclopaedic.
‘You were too young’, ‘you don’t remember’, ‘you should be grateful’, and, of course, the perennial favourite, ‘You need to move on’
It’s an extraordinarily efficient system. First, know nothing about someone else’s experience. Then, explain it to them. And if they disagree, remind them that they’re being rather difficult about the whole thing. I sometimes feel we’ve been remiss in allowing adoptees to have opinions about their own lives. We really should have consulted everyone else first. Perhaps we could establish a committee. A panel of the suitably untroubled, appointed to determine which of our experiences are legitimate and which are simply the product of our overactive imaginations. We could call it The Ministry of Things That Couldn’t Possibly Have Happened.
Now, before anybody starts sharpening their pencils to write me an indignant letter, I’m perfectly aware that not every adoptee considers their adoption traumatic. I’m also aware that not every difficulty in an adoptee’s life can be traced back to infancy, and that not every relationship failure is evidence of some deep, unresolved wound. Believe it or not, we know this. We really do. You don’t need to keep explaining it to us. Many of us have spent decades examining these questions, sometimes with professional help, sometimes with other adoptees, and often in the rather less comfortable company of our own thoughts at three in the morning.
We’ve questioned our memories, our interpretations, our assumptions and the stories we were told. Some of us have changed our minds more times than we care to admit. Some are still changing them. And then along comes somebody who has given the matter approximately seventeen seconds of thought and announces that we’re all making a fuss about nothing. Seventeen seconds! I’ve spent longer than that trying to decide whether to have a second biscuit. I usually have the second biscuit.
What I find particularly baffling is why some people feel so personally inconvenienced by another person’s account of their own life. We’re not asking you to relinquish your childhood, surrender your family, or confess to some crime against humanity. We’re simply telling you something about ours. Why is that so threatening? Why does an account of someone else’s loss seem to require such an urgent defence of everything that came afterwards? Surely it’s possible for a child to have been loved and to have experienced loss. For an adoption to have provided safety and stability while still involving separation. For an adoptive parent to have done their very best and for an adoptee to carry questions that love alone couldn’t answer.
I don’t see why these things should be mutually exclusive. But apparently, for some people, they are. Perhaps it’s easier to have a single version of events. A good thing happened, therefore nothing bad could have happened. Everybody lived happily ever after and anyone suggesting otherwise is being ungrateful. It’s a lovely story. I just wish people would stop insisting that it’s mine.
The more I’ve thought about Skye’s post, the more upset I am. The whole thing stops being quite so amusing. I’m not going to pass judgment on her husband or decide whether he’s a good man, a bad man, or claim his understanding of human development might benefit from a little updating. What hits me in my core is the thought of her having to make a case for her own experience to someone who knows her so intimately.
I wish people would sit with that and imagine that for a moment. You’ve spent years, perhaps most of your life, trying to understand certain things about yourself. You’ve finally found some language for them. Maybe you’ve read something that helps explain an old feeling. Perhaps you’ve met other people who describe experiences remarkably similar to your own. And you want to share this with the person you love. Not because you expect them to understand everything, but because you want them to know you a little better. And they tell you, effectively, that you’re mistaken.
That if nobody had told you about your adoption, you wouldn’t have known. Case closed. So you find yourself explaining it again. You look for articles, research, books or videos. You try different words. You hope that perhaps this time you’ll find the right way to say it. Eventually, you go online and tell a group of strangers how lonely it feels not to be understood. And when those strangers listen, you thank them. For allowing you to feel heard. Imagine being so accustomed to having your experience questioned that being listened to feels like something worth thanking people for. I’m not sure I have a joke for that.
So, to those of you who find all this adoption business rather tiresome, who think we’re dwelling on the past, inventing wounds, or making rather too much of something that happened before we could even talk, I have a modest proposal. The next time an adoptee tells you something about their experience that you don’t understand, why not try simply not understanding it? I know. Radical stuff. You could even admit as much. “I’m not sure I understand.” You could ask them to tell you more or you could listen without immediately preparing your response, which I appreciate may be difficult for those of you accustomed to having the final word.
You don’t have to agree with every explanation they offer and you don’t have to accept that all adoptees experience the same things, or that everything that goes wrong in their lives has its origins in adoption. But you could at least entertain the possibility that the person standing in front of you might know something about their own life that you don’t. I realise this may come as something of a shock. You’ll recover.
And while you’re at it, perhaps ask yourself why you feel the need to contradict them in the first place. Why does their account of their experience have to be less real than your opinion of it? What exactly do you stand to lose by acknowledging it? Because I can assure you that we lose something every time you don’t. Not an argument. Frankly, most of us have had enough arguments about adoption to last several lifetimes. We lose an opportunity to share something of ourselves with you. To be known a little more fully by someone whose opinion, friendship or love might matter enormously to us. And that isn’t quite such a small thing, is it?
There’s something else I’ve been thinking about, and I suspect it’s the part that ought to concern you most. What happens when someone you love repeatedly tries to tell you something important about themselves, and you repeatedly explain why they’re wrong? At first, they’ll probably try harder. They’ll find different ways to explain it. They’ll send you things to read, share a video, tell you about a conversation they’ve had with someone who understands. They might even practise what they’re going to say, hoping this time they’ll find the words that make it click. And when it doesn’t, they’ll often assume they haven’t explained themselves properly. So they’ll try again. And again. Until one day, they won’t.
Not because you’ve convinced them. Not because they’ve decided you were right all along. And certainly not because whatever they were trying to tell you has ceased to matter. They’ve simply grown tired of trying to share something with someone who doesn’t want to receive it. And perhaps, in the beginning, you’ll hardly notice. There might even be a rather pleasant improvement in the atmosphere. No more awkward discussions about adoption. No more uncomfortable questions. No more articles appearing in your inbox or conversations that seem to go round in circles. Wonderful! Peace at last.
You might congratulate yourself on having finally helped them move on. But I wonder if you’ve considered what that apparent peace has cost. Because they’ve not necessarily stopped thinking about those things. They haven’t stopped feeling them. They may still be having those conversations, only now they’re having them with someone else. Perhaps a friend, a therapist, or a stranger on the internet who happens to know what they’re talking about. They’ve just stopped having them with you. And that’s how it begins, I think. Not with some dramatic falling-out or grand declaration that a relationship has become impossible. It’s rather more ordinary than that. They simply begin to edit themselves.
A thought occurs to them, and they decide not to share it. Something reminds them of their childhood, but they don’t mention it. They read an essay that moves them deeply, but instead of sending it to you, they send it to someone else. A little less of themselves enters the conversation each time. You may not notice what’s missing. After all, you weren’t particularly interested in those parts of them to begin with. But they notice. They know which subjects to avoid. Which feelings will be questioned. Which thoughts will be met with a sigh or an eye-roll or another reminder that they ought to be grateful.
And perhaps the saddest thing is that this can happen between two people who genuinely love each other. You can share a home, a bed, a life, and gradually discover that some of the most important parts of who you are have no place in the conversation. I wonder how many people have done this without realising it. How many have mistaken the eventual silence of someone they love for evidence that they’ve finally come to their senses. Because perhaps the hardest thing about being unheard isn’t that someone doesn’t believe you.
It’s that, eventually, you begin leaving parts of yourself out of the conversation.
And if you do that often enough, for long enough, I wonder how much of yourself can disappear before the person who claims to know you is really only acquainted with the parts you’ve learned are acceptable to them. That’s a rather uncomfortable thought, isn’t it? To discover that someone you love hasn’t become happier, or more settled, or finally stopped dwelling on the past. They’ve simply stopped telling you about it. Not because there’s nothing left to say. But because they’ve learned there’s little point saying it to you.
Perhaps one day, when you remark on how much better things seem now that they’ve stopped going on about their adoption, you might pause for a moment and ask yourself: have you actually helped them find some peace, or have you simply become someone they no longer trust with the truth of who they are?
Anyway. Congratulations! You’ve won your argument with the baby. The baby has grown up now. And learned which parts of themselves to keep from you.
Jonathan