An agony column for the comfortably certain | Episode 02
Dear Agony Uncle,
I met an adoptee the other day, and naturally my curiosity was aroused. I proceeded to ask questions such as âdo you know your birth family?â, âwhy did they give you up?â and âis your sibling your real sibling?â
The baffling thing was, the adoptee seemed to become increasingly uncomfortable with my line of questioning, and that made me feel offended. I was being perfectly nice, I even complimented her parents for being so generous as to adopt her.
Surely that entitles me to straight answers to simple questions? Seems an ungrateful way to repay her parents really. Iâm actually getting quite lathered up just thinking about it.
Are all adoptees like this?
In a tizzy in Tamarama
[u/ACtdawg]
Dear Tizzy,
Good heavens. What an appalling encounter. I can scarcely imagine the humiliation of having your perfectly reasonable interrogation of a complete stranger met with anything less than enthusiastic cooperation. Whatever happened to common decency?
You approached this woman with genuine curiosity, generously offered your assessment of parents you've presumably never met, and asked a series of intimate questions about the circumstances of her birth and family relationships. And she became uncomfortable? The cheek of it!
I'm afraid this is becoming increasingly common. People nowadays seem to believe that their personal histories are somehow personal, an extraordinary development which threatens to undermine the very foundations of polite society.
After all, what is the point of someone being adopted if the rest of us aren't entitled to know all about it? Your questions were perfectly reasonable.
"Do you know your birth family?" An excellent opener. It establishes immediately that you're interested in the circumstances of her existence rather than, say, her name, occupation, or whether she's enjoying the weather.
"Why did they give you up?" Another splendid question, particularly as the person least likely to have been consulted about the decision is now being asked to explain it. And "Is your sibling your real sibling?" is, frankly, inspired.
It's important to establish which family members are genuine and which are merely decorative. A sibling with whom one has shared thirty Christmases, a bathroom, childhood secrets, and perhaps the occasional black eye may appear perfectly authentic, but without the appropriate biological certification, one can never be too careful.
I was also delighted to learn that you complimented her adoptive parents on their generosity. What a gracious gesture. It's always reassuring to know that someone who has never met your family is nevertheless prepared to pass favourable judgment on the circumstances of its formation.
I'm sure she found that immensely comforting. But I must confess, Tizzy, that one aspect of your letter troubles me. You mention becoming offended when the adoptee appeared uncomfortable. This is entirely understandable, of course. Few things are more distressing than discovering that a stranger's personal boundaries might interfere with one's afternoon curiosity.
But have you considered that you may have been insufficiently thorough? Perhaps you should have asked whether her birth mother loved her. Whether she felt abandoned. Whether she has ever considered that she might have been better off elsewhere.
And, while you're at it, whether she knows how lucky she is. One can never have too much information about the private circumstances of someone one has only just met. There is, however, another approach. I hesitate to recommend it, as it has the unfortunate disadvantage of requiring a little restraint.
You could simply allow an adoptee to decide which parts of their life they wish to share with you. I know. Preposterous. It would mean accepting that your curiosity, however sincere, doesn't automatically entitle you to someone else's history.
You might even have to consider that what feels like an innocent question to you could touch upon something painful, complicated, or simply none of your bloody business. A dreadful prospect. Still, you ask whether all adoptees are like this. The answer, I'm afraid, is no.
Some will answer your questions quite happily. Some won't. Some may welcome your curiosity, while others have spent so many years fielding questions from strangers that they've become rather tired of explaining their existence. And some will smile politely, answer everything you ask, and go home wishing they'd had the courage to tell you to mind your own business.
Which is perhaps the most unfortunate part of the whole affair. You may leave the encounter feeling that you've learned something fascinating about an adoptee. While the adoptee leaves having learned something rather less flattering about you.
Do try not to take it personally. After all, you were only being nice.
Yours in certainty,
The Agony Uncle