r/AccursedKings • • Jan 30 '26

I found a problematic passage

0 Upvotes

Loving the book series. Currently in Book 2. And the Chapter "Vincennes" (Book 2, Part 3, Chapter 2) starts with an analogy of Middle Age situation in the current world. Granted, Druon meant mid to late 20th Century. However, he basically limited this view to the Arab World, somehow linking it to religion. It seems to suggest a sortl of superiority of Christianity over Islam.

I follow the analogy and agree with it. I just disagree with the cultural and geographical framing. Could be easily extended to areas of Equatorial Africa, Latin America, India, Southeast Asia or even West Virginia


r/AccursedKings • • May 03 '17

Should Accursed Kings be recommended to readers of fantasy?

2 Upvotes

Or: What would Druon have thought of his work being sold to and read by the elves and goblins crowd?


On one hand, many of the characters believe in the Jacques de Molay's curse, and explicitly connect it to the untimely deaths of Phillip and Nogaret. And in his final hours, Marigny accepts his fate as justice for his part in the dispossession of the Templars. As I've noted elsewhere, Druon's characters believe in magic in a world where observable phenomena can be explained by science; while many characters of Westeros don't believe that magic is real in a world with dragons and zombies. Looked at side-by-side, the line between historical fiction and low fantasy starts to look very thin.

And the influence of this series on A Game of Thrones is patently obvious, even beyond GRRM's statements to that effect. Through ASOIAF to HBO's Game of Thrones and beyond, Druon's books are likely to exert an influence on modern fantasy and speculative fiction for some time to come.

However, one could note that the ahistoricity and sentimentality of Tolkien's most popular writing is way out of sync with Druon's full-bodied humanism. One might suspect that Druon would see Lord of the Rings and its progeny as books for juveniles, not written for an audience interested the administrative policies of kings dead for 600 years.

And, of course, there's no magic in 14th century France, full stop. Perhaps the low fantasy and speculative fiction genres must require some forces that are beyond human understanding if those genres are to mean anything at all.


  • Do you recommend Druon's Accursed Kings series to your friends? To which readers would you recommend it?

  • If you worked in a bookstore, and you wanted browsing readers to discover this series, would you shelve this series in the Fantasy section, or in Historical Fiction?


r/AccursedKings • • Feb 27 '22

Does it get grander?

6 Upvotes

Currently nearly finished the first book. I like it well enough. It's solid and I like rlthe period. My issue comes with its link to George R R Martin. It's not complicated nor are the characters overly fleshed out. Again I presume everyone reading this is a fan and Id say I am and will finish the series no doubt...

I'm wondering if the Martin forward has just got my expectations up or maybe it grows? I think my Kindle says it's only 350 pages that's light.

P.s... When he says archers is it soldiers?


r/AccursedKings • • Apr 26 '18

If you liked The Accursed Kings, I recommend Sharon Kay Penman's Plantagenet series on Henry II of England and Richard the Lionheart.

6 Upvotes

Like Duron's novels, you've got extended families fighting among themselves, plenty of backstabbing from corners you least expect it, unsteady lines of succession, the Anglo-French rivalry (but from the other side of the channel), and the story of how a dynasty can rise and fall in a few decades.

The novels are technically written so that they're all stand alones, but the order is as follows:

  • When Christ and His Saints Slept: details the civil war between Empress Matilda and Stephen of Blois

  • Time and Chance: more or less the first fifteen years of Henry II's rule, with the main themes being his rivalry with Thomas Becket, his marriage with Eleanor of Aquitaine, and the seeds being sowed for his sons to revolt

  • Devil's Brood: the second half of Henry's reign. Details the Great Revolt of 1173-4, the deaths of two of his sons (which have enormous consequences for the future), his marriage with Eleanor falling apart, and Philip Augustus playing Richard against Henry.

  • Lionheart: goes into Richard's involvement in the Third Crusade. The main characters in this one besides Richard are his sister Joanna (widowed Queen of Sicily), Philip Augustus (they hated each other), Saladin, and his wife Berengaria of Navarre. There's also John, destined for a life of intrigue.

  • A King's Ransom: Richard falls into the hands of the Duke of Austria and the Holy Roman Emperor on his way back to England, and they demand an enormous ransom for his release.

Personally, I found these novels pretty historically accurate (Penman pays good attention to detail) and the characters just as moving as those in Game of Thrones or The Accursed Kings. Anyone else read these?


r/AccursedKings • • Jul 25 '26

The Book on Clemence de Hungary’s Son

Post image
6 Upvotes

The affix is from the fourth book: the royal succession. It promises a second series of the accursed kings but I couldn’t find anything.

Does anyone know has he ever written this spin off-ish story?


r/AccursedKings • • Jun 15 '25

Five books in why isn’t everyone talking about this series all the time?

15 Upvotes

And is it true we are getting a new television version?


r/AccursedKings • • Dec 14 '22

Question on the 3rd / 4th book

5 Upvotes

I just completed the 3rd book, and now I am about two chapters into the 4th. I’m somewhat confused on who the Cardinal(s?) are/is. I feel like it was explained but maybe I just didn’t get it. I’m confused on everything about them, is it one person or a group, where did they come from, what do they do and who’s side are they serving / who they got beef with

Sorry if this was easy to grasp but for some reason I just am not getting it.


r/AccursedKings • • Jan 03 '25

The team behind the most recent Count of Monte Cristo film is set to re-adapt the books. Production should start next year!

Thumbnail
variety.com
4 Upvotes

Count


r/AccursedKings • • Jan 07 '25

(Spoilers All) Marie & Guccio... Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I've just finished Book 6, don't plan to read 7 for a bit. Loved the series, but one thing I need to talk about right away (yes, I know this sub is dead....)

I don't have the books with me, but in Book 3 or 4, we have our final scene with Guccio and Marie, just after she tells him she's pregnant. It hits like a brick because Druon comes out of nowhere to outright say "Yeah from here on out, their lives SUCK."

The author mentions that the two see each other one more time, 10 years later. I was eagerly looking forward to that...but it never came? They never see each other when Guccio takes his son, and that's not 10 years later.

So, did I miss something? Or did Druon decide to change how the scene was written, making the earlier passage slightly inaccurate?


r/AccursedKings • • Dec 28 '24

Any relevant Maurice Druon interviews or essays?

11 Upvotes

I'm just about finished up with the series, absolutely loved it. I'd like to read more about the series, not so much from a historical perspective but specifically Druon talking about writing/researching the books. As an English speaker in 2024, I'm not coming up with much!

For example, the English language copies from the 1960s refer to Books 5-6 (and I assume 7) as the "second volume" of the series; they are much longer than the first four books and I know book 7 is quite different, not to mention written two decades later. These are subjects I'd love to hear Druon discuss; did he always plan on 6-7 books, with a jump in the middle? Why'd he choose to skip Philip's reign? etc.

Any help would be appreciated!


r/AccursedKings • • Jul 13 '17

Tor.com: Grimdark Historical Fiction? The Iron King by Maurice (book review)

Thumbnail
tor.com
2 Upvotes

r/AccursedKings • • Jul 19 '17

(Spoilers All) Infographic for readers of TAK and A Song of Ice and Fire

Thumbnail
theoriginalgot.com
6 Upvotes

r/AccursedKings • • Jul 16 '17

[Weekly Reading] The She-Wolf of France, Part III, by Sunday, July 23

4 Upvotes

Discussion of Part III (of IV)(!) will happen on this thread starting Sunday, July 23.

Meanwhile, don't forget to weigh in on Part I here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AccursedKings/comments/6lvgrx/weekly_reading_the_shewolf_of_france_part_i_by/

And Part II here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AccursedKings/comments/6m8off/weekly_reading_the_shewolf_of_france_part_ii_by/


r/AccursedKings • • Jul 09 '17

[Weekly Reading] The She-Wolf of France, Part II, by Sunday, July 16

3 Upvotes

Discussion of Part II will happen on this thread starting Sunday, July 16.

Meanwhile, don't forget to weigh in on Part I here: https://www.reddit.com/r/AccursedKings/comments/6lvgrx/weekly_reading_the_shewolf_of_france_part_i_by/


r/AccursedKings • • Jul 31 '22

Why does She-Wolf and Lily and the Lion veer so far off course from the original 4?

7 Upvotes

In my opinion The Royal Succession was the crown jewel of this novel series. It saw the climax of Mahaut's wickedness, the tragedy of Marie and Guccio, and most of all, the competent Philippe of Poitiers could finally become his father's worthy successor. With all this build up, why did Maurice Druon decide to skip over Philip V's reign?


r/AccursedKings • • Aug 30 '22

My video review of the book series. I really love these books and am amazed they're not more popular. Hope you enjoy!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/AccursedKings • • Mar 25 '17

[Lecture de la semaine] Discutons Les Rois Maudits -- Le Roi de Fer, deuxième partie (Chapitres 10-12)

5 Upvotes
Résumé:
  • Les deux frères d'Aunay sont exécutés sur-le-champ en place publique à Pontoise : roués de coups, écorchés vif, leurs sexes tranchés et jetés aux chiens, ils sont finalement décapités, leurs corps traînés puis pendus par les aisselles au gibet.

  • Marguerite de Bourgogne et Blanche sont condamnées à être tondues et conduites dans un chariot couvert de draps noirs à Château-Gaillard. Quant à la troisième, Jeanne de Bourgogne, femme du futur Philippe V, elle est enfermée à Dourdan pour avoir gardé ce secret et été complice passive.

  • La deuxième partie se finit sur l'annonce faite à la cour que le 20 avril 1314, le pape Clément V, qui avait « couvert » l'arrestation des Templiers, est subitement décédé.


Le fil précédent:
Qu'est-ce que vous pensez?

META (En anglais) Enquête: Voulez-vous lire les livres plus rapidement? https://goo.gl/forms/lsUi34eyFOPrUgYG3


r/AccursedKings • • Mar 16 '17

[Lecture de la semaine] Discutons Les Rois Maudits -- Le Roi de Fer, deuxième partie (Chapitres 7-9)

4 Upvotes
Résumé:
  • Isabelle révèle à son père les agissements des trois jeunes femmes - Jeanne, la sœur de Blanche, n'étant accusée que d'être complice muette des adultères des autres.

  • Les deux frères d'Aunay, découverts porteurs des deux aumonières données par Isabelle à ses belles-sœurs, sont jugés par Philippe le Bel qui les condamne pour crime de lèse-majesté. Ils sont exécutés sur-le-champ en place publique à Pontoise.

(cr. wikipedia)


Le fil précédent:
Qu'est-ce que vous pensez?

r/AccursedKings • • Aug 15 '17

[Weekly Reading] The Lily and the Lion, Part II, by Sunday, August 20

4 Upvotes

Discussion of Part II will happen on this thread starting Sunday, August 20.

Catch up with Part I here.


r/AccursedKings • • Aug 07 '17

[Weekly Reading] The Lily and the Lion, Part I, by Sunday, August 13

3 Upvotes

Discussion of Part I will happen on this thread starting Sunday, August 13.

Catch up on Book 5, The She-Wolf of France, in these threads:


r/AccursedKings • • Mar 10 '17

Amazon Discount on books 3-5

7 Upvotes

I hope this is okay to post, but I was looking up the future books on Amazon and the paperbacks of books 3-5 are only $6 right now. If you're committed to the series, it seems like a no brainer deal.


r/AccursedKings • • Aug 07 '17

[Spoilers History] The Troublesome Reign of Edward the Second

2 Upvotes

English Renaissance dramatist Christopher Marlowe wrote a play about the events of The She-Wolf of France. This play has been highly influential in the popular understanding of Edward II's reign and his sexuality.

It is widely available for free:

Here is Isabella's speech in the play upon landing in England.

Q. Isab. Now, lords, our loving friends and countrymen,
Welcome to England all, with prosperous winds!
Our kindest friends in Belgia have we left,
To cope with friends at home; a heavy case
When force to force is knit, and sword and glaive
In civil broils make kin and countrymen
Slaughter themselves in others, and their sides
With their own weapons gor'd! But what's the help?
Misgovern'd kings are cause of all this wreck;
And, Edward, thou art one among them all,
Whose looseness hath betray'd thy land to spoil,
Who made the channel overflow with blood
Of thine own people: patron shouldst thou be;
But thou—
Young Mortimer. Nay, madam, if you be a warrior,
You must not grow so passionate in speeches.—
Lords, sith that we are, by sufferance of heaven,
Arriv'd and armed in this prince's right,
Here for our country's cause swear we to him
All homage, fealty, and forwardness;
And for the open wrongs and injuries
Edward hath done to us, his queen, and land,
We come in arms to wreck it with the sword;
That England's queen in peace may repossess
Her dignities and honours; and withal
We may remove these flatterers from the king
That havock England's wealth and treasury.

See also the murder of Edward in the play; it was obviously a source for Druon's version of the scene.

Light. I know what I must do. Get you away:
Yet be not far off; I shall need your help:
See that in the next room I have a fire,
And get me a spit, and let it be red-hot.
Mat. Very well.
Gur. Need you anything besides?
Light. What else? a table and a feather-bed.
Gur. That's all?
Light. Ay, ay: so, when I call you, bring it in.


The play and its portrayal of Edward II's sexuality has been the subject of academic study. I thought it would be helpful to take a look at these studies, especially for an alternate perspective to Druon's attitudes about gender and sexuality.

Excerpts:

Marlowe’s Edward II presents the case of sodomy as the transgression of the laws governing the interpretation of the relations between the king’s two bodies. In the eyes of such contemporaries of Marlowe as Edward Coke, as Bray quotes, such a transgression was so dreaded and abhorred as to be considered “crimen laesae majestatis, a sin horrible, committed against the King; and this is either against the King Celestial or Terrestial...”

.... What exactly are the two bodies of the king and how did late medieval lawyers differentiate the two and determine their relations? Simply put, late medieval English political thought held that a king possessed a dual persona: he was human by nature and divine by grace. As a human being, he was subject to time, error, decay and death; as divine, he was timeless, incorruptible and infallible. Legally speaking, from his human aspect, he was always subject to positive law (servus legis); however, from his divine aspect, he was always above it (dominus legis) as what pleased him became law.

From the 14th century - especially with the reign of Edward I (the father of Edward II and the one whom the earls invoke to legitimize their hatred for Gaveston) - the relations between the king’s human and divine bodies began to be cast in the form of a reciprocal relationship between the king and the Crown. As Kantorowicz notes, while contemporary lawyers saw the king and Crown as distinct, they firmly held them to be inseparable, underlining that the Crown was always and already incarnate in a king. With the king’s demise, the Crown immediately attached itself to the natural body of the next legitimate king/heir to the throne and so forth, promoting the legal tenet that the Crown could and should never ever be separated from the natural body of a king.

Excerpts:

However, such focus on sexuality in Edward II has caused critics to overlook another major issue that the drama presents: that of a foreigner’s immigration to England and his quick and deleterious rise to power. I contend that this play constructs a way of seeing and staging the political effects that nationality, class, and biological sex demonstrate in the court, especially when they intertwine. Edward II portrays the early modern English fears of alien intrusion by focusing on Gaveston’s foreignness and his being from birth a non-aristocratic male. I argue, moreover, that Marlowe’s staging of this sort of anti-French xenophobia takes the specific form of an intimate friendship because this type of alliance shows that immigration carries with it certain dangers that transcend those posed by military battles, which are fought externally and at greater distance from the court itself. Edward II and Gaveston’s “forbidden intimacy” (Bray 42) is problematic not because it suggests a same-sex sexual relationship, for which there is no concrete textual evidence, but rather an issue of power transposition between men of different ranks and nationalities.

... The intense focus on the king’s and Gaveston’s punishments suggests that Marlowe is admonishing sodomy. Edward II’s possible engagement in same-sex sex, moreover, signifies a loss of virility and “self-cohesion” (Stymeist 221). Because Edward II’s alliance with Gaveston directly begat his enervation insofar as he continuously positions himself as subservient to a foreign, non-aristocratic Frenchman, he suffered alongside his court and the English as a whole. To that end, Mortimer Jr.’s empowerment throughout the play marks him as the king’s foil—a strong medieval warrior with clear political interests and indeed also a heterosexual alliance with the queen. But while Marlovian critics, such as McAdam and Stymeist, discuss the important issues of sex itself, the implications of Edward’s subordination to Gaveston are as much political as they are sexual since a focus on the homosocial relationship does not take into consideration Gaveston’s being foreign and non-aristocratic. I argue that his national origin and status make his presence and alliance with the king even more objectionable.

As surprising as Druon's frank portrayal of the King's sexuality is in a series written in the mid 20th century, it's even more surprising (to me) to find it imagined in detail in the 16th century.

What do you think?


r/AccursedKings • • Mar 07 '17

[Lecture de la semaine] Discutons Les Rois Maudits -- Le Roi de Fer, deuxième partie (Chapitres 4-6)

4 Upvotes

Résumé:

  • Guccio Baglioni rencontre Marie de Cressay, parce que son père, Jean de Cressay, est mort avant 1314 en laissant des dettes auprès de la compagnie lombarde de Spinello Tolomei.

  • Les deux frères d'Aunay sont découverts portant des deux aumonières données par Isabelle à ses belles-sœurs.

Le fil précédent:

Qu'est-ce que vous pensez?


r/AccursedKings • • Oct 09 '17

[Weekly Reading] The King Without a Kingdom, Part IV, by Sunday, October 15

2 Upvotes

Discussion of Part IV will happen on this thread starting Sunday, October 15.

Catch up on the rest of the book in these threads: