r/AcademicPsychology • • Dec 15 '24 Bravo

Discussion What to do about the high-Openness low-Conscientiousness students

1.3k Upvotes

Every year this time of year, I start to really feel for my high-O low-C students. Y'all know who I mean: they're passionate, fascinated, smart as hell... and don't have their shit together. At all.

How much should it matter that a student wrote an insightful essay that was actually interesting to read about cognitive dissonance and "Gaylor" fans... but turned it in a month late, with tons of APA errors? How do you balance the student who raises their hand and parrots the textbook every week against the student who stays after class to ask you fascinating questions about research ethics but also forgets to study? I know it's a systemic problem not an individual one, but it eats me every term.


r/AcademicPsychology • • May 13 '24

Psychology IS STEM. Don’t let anyone tell you different.

Thumbnail apa.org
1.0k Upvotes

I get really tired of people saying psychological study is for lazy stupid people. It absolutely is not. Just in case you need this for the less educated people in your life, see link. Have a great day!


r/AcademicPsychology • • Apr 15 '21

Other 3D print of my own brain (fMRI) I’m in the process of Sanding & painting

Thumbnail
gallery
815 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Nov 09 '23

Question What are the dark sides of clinical psychology/ counseling people don’t talk about?

626 Upvotes

I feel like a a lot of psychology majors have good intentions of helping people but often not knowing what the work actually entails. From the emotional burnout to better opportunities to re-educating/liscening, what else is there that isn’t talked about enough?


r/AcademicPsychology • • Apr 17 '25

Discussion We just ran the analyses for an undergrad thesis and got p = 0.055.

613 Upvotes

When talking with my student I was sympathetic, said she could say in her discussion section that the data suggest an effect might occur in a future study with more power, checked her work, praised her for not p-hacking... But from my point of view, it is kind of hilarious.

Like, that is the worst p-value it is possible to have in the entire infinite field of numbers! It has to suck so fucking much to write that up, especially given I outlawed phrases like "trending toward significance" and emphasized the importance of dichotomous outcomes in NHST. Obviously NHST has an element of luck no matter what you do, and this time the luck gods decided to hate my student. She's rolling with it, but JFC.

Anyway, anyone else have stories of when the temptation to p-hack became near maddening?


r/AcademicPsychology • • Jun 03 '20

A great read this quarantine : Who else here loves the book "Abnormal Psychology" by Ronald J. Comer? I found it well written, easy to read and absolutely engaging. It is packed with case studies, "between the lines" and accounts of people who have gone through disorders. Try if you haven't!

Post image
450 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Oct 30 '24

Resource/Study I had trouble understanding 'statistical significance' so I broke it down like this. Does it work for you?

Thumbnail
gallery
418 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Mar 28 '25

Discussion Rant: I hate it when people and society in general do not take psychology as a serious science

414 Upvotes

I work at a school that places a strong emphasis on training students in STEM careers. Naturally, subjects like biology, chemistry, mathematics, computer science, and physics are at the top of people's list when it comes to what they want to study for these future careers. However, there is an unstated, but very obvious attitude that psychology does not belong in that group.

You can see this in government too where most of the funding prioritizes these previously stated areas and ignore psychology who I think contributes just as much if not more. Counseling and therapies are vital as mental health issues are on the rise. Research on love and glee are some examples that show how psychologists are changing the world. Recently, I've been enamored by research investigating the neuroscience of self-perception and self-regulation. There's even research looking at animal personality. In my humble opinion, this is where the future is at, and I'm not just talking about the future of psychology. Who cares what's out there in the cosmos when we can be learning about things right inside and in front of us.

Finally, not sure if this is related, but I noticed most people who end up majoring in psychology are girls. Why is that? Find any research lab website and look for lab member photos. It's pretty clear that women pursue this major during both undergrad and grad schools. Where are the guys? What do you think it tell us? Statistically, guys seem to go into the more respected majors too. I would like to see equal representations here.

Anyway, I would love to live in a world where people would not look down their noses at those who do this work.


r/AcademicPsychology • • Feb 24 '19

Most desperate desire of our hearts

Post image
397 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Jan 17 '24

Supervisor said I don’t belong

391 Upvotes

I am doctoral student in clinical psychology. Clinical Supervisor said I don’t belong in the field. She also mentioned that i would never find a job. When i confronted her, she said “i never said that, but do believe you will never find a job base on how you are dress.” The program pulled me out from this relationship because my mental health was plummeting. While I am happy I don’t have to work with her, i just cannot shake off her words and how she said them. It felt very traumatic, especially because I come from low-income and underserved background while she seems to come from a white privaLage family. She doesn’t know if I could afford clothes, or how hard i had to work and the discrimination i had to endure on my journey to one of the too doctoral programs. She hasn’t been the first one who i said I don’t belong, yet I am still here. She made me feel as if there was something deeply wrong with me. My mentors have been amazinf at validating that I belong, but i cannot shake off her words. I just wanted to vent. Thank you for reading…


r/AcademicPsychology • • Jul 04 '22

Resource/Study Psychology needs to get tired of winning: Published literature... shows that nearly all study hypotheses are supported. This means that either all the theories are correct, or the literature is biased towards positive findings

Thumbnail
royalsocietypublishing.org
380 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Jul 09 '25

Question What’s a psychological concept that totally shifted how you see people?

362 Upvotes

Genuinely curious!


r/AcademicPsychology • • Oct 18 '24

Discussion Philip Zimbardo Obituary (1933 - 2024), known for his 1971 Stanford Prison Experiment, has passed away

Thumbnail legacy.com
347 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Feb 22 '19

Good 'ol Pavlovian jokes

Post image
311 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • Dec 09 '21

Discussion How is Jordan Peterson and his works perceived in the academia and among Psychologists in general?

305 Upvotes

Jordan Peterson is a controversial figure to say the least. Liberal Arts college students in USA and Canada seems to hate him with a passion while YouTubers almost worships him. I was wondering how Psychologists in general perceive him/his works. Cass Eris, a Cognitive Psychology YouTuber has been covering him polemically. Her basic point, from what I understand, is that JP uses an outdated form of Psychology, probably called 'Jungian Psychology' iirc, and sometimes uses badly conducted studies. Do you guys agree? Is he legit (like whatever he says or cites, are those legit)?


r/AcademicPsychology • • Feb 03 '24

Question Are repressed memories a myth?

304 Upvotes

I've been reading alot about the way the brain deals with trauma and got alot of anwesers leading to dissociation and repressed memories...

Arent they quite hard to even proof real? Im no professional and simply do my own research duo to personal intrest in psychology so this is something i haven't found a clear answer on


r/AcademicPsychology • • Mar 30 '25

Discussion Hot Take: The names of disorders are all wrong

289 Upvotes

TLDR: Mental Disorders are currently categorized and labeled according to observation of behavioral symptoms. They should instead be categorized and labeled according to the actual neural pathway they are affecting. This would make mental disorders both more empirical and more medically actionable.

This is just my hot take, my opinion. Feel free to disagree with me civilly.

Okay, so this idea has been stewing for a little bit. When you open the DSM-V, you might find something with a name like "Major Depressive Disorder", "Obsessive Compulsive Disorder", or "Bipolar Disorder".

Now, here's my issue. These names describe behavioral symptoms. That might make sense intuitively, but it just doesn't make sense medically.

If someone was in a cold sweat, collapsed, screaming about chest pain and shortness of breath, we wouldn't look at them and say: "Oh, they have Chest Hurting Disorder". No, we would diagnose the problem and name it for what it IS and IS AFFECTING, i.e. "They're having a HEART ATTACK."

Stay with me now. How does it make any sense at all to categorize mental illnesses by what they look like to a casual observer, rather than what they are in reality (think SKIN cancer, BACK pain, CARPAL TUNNEL syndrome).

These labels are critical in indicating what is actually going wrong and very much shapes our understanding of how they should be treated.

Take Major Depressive Disorder for example. The DSM-V Criteria for Major Depressive Order are:

1.Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day, as indicated by subjective report (e.g., feels sad, empty, hopeless) or observation made by others (e.g., appears tearful).

2. Markedly diminished interest or pleasure in all, or almost all, activities most of the day, nearly every day.

3. Significant weight loss when not dieting or weight gain (e.g., a change of more than 5% of body weight in a month), or decrease or increase in appetite nearly every day.

4. Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day.

5. Psychomotor agitation or r*tardation (apparently reddit makes you censor this word LOL) nearly every day (observable by others, not merely subjective feelings of restlessness or being slowed down).

6. Fatigue or loss of energy nearly every day.

7. Feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt (which may be delusional) nearly every day.

8. Diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness, nearly every day.

9. Recurrent thoughts of death (not just fear of dying), recurrent suicidal ideation without a specific plan, or a suicide attempt or a specific plan for committing suicide.

Notice how none of these criteria, nor the actual name of the Disorder itself, actually helps us understand what is happening at the causal level? Nor do these criteria lend to any real, practical solution, since none of them name anything within the body that we would be able to aim a cure (or preventive treatment) at! (remember? HEART attack?)

If you still don't see how this could be problematic, I'll raise you this: Schizophrenia used to be known as "Dementia Praecox", literally meaning "early dementia". People really saw these two wildly different mental disorders and thought they were the same thing because they were categorizing based on external, behavioral observations. It was only developments in neurobiology that helped us better understand what was really happening, thus getting one step closer to being able to do something about the problem.

So, my thesis is this: Disorders should be named and diagnostic criteria based on the neurobiological reality of what is happening, not based on behavioral observation. For example, OCD should be called something like "Thalamic Hyperactivation Disorder" (Take that with a grain of salt, but I hope you get my point). Not only does this bring mental health diagnosis and treatment more in line with the modern standard of medicine, it also allows us to use much less subjective metrics for diagnosis. We are currently taking what we see and trying to extrapolate backwards to name/guess a cause. It is more scientific and effective to take a brain scan, blood work, and family genetic data, then use it to create a comprehensive analysis of what is actually wrong.

Edit: Thank you everyone for raising some very good points. This has been very illuminating. For something like "back pain", some of you have pointed out that the actual pathogenesis of such conditions is sometimes less physical and more mental. This is a good point! Maybe we shouldn't call it back pain either.

I believe that no matter what ails us, mind or body, we should aim to target the most basic cause as high up on the causal chain as possible.

Some of you also pointed out that there are, more often that not, ultimate causes outside of the brain and body that eventually manifest as these things we call disorders. This is also a good point. That being said, this is exactly what my issue is; such cases should be treated as the sociological issues they are, rather than reduced to individual medical issues or even moral failings.

Western individualistic philosophy and medicine has done a lot of harm to us all, but I hope conversations like this will one day contribute towards a more holistic, empirical, and most importantly, effective mental health model.

Edit 2: Phew! Looks like this post is really striking a chord. Thank you to everyone who agreed and disagreed respectfully, as I requested. However, to those of you who are blatantly or (not so) subtly attacking me, please reflect on yourself. If you wouldn't speak a certain way to someone's face, don't do it here either.


r/AcademicPsychology • • Jan 30 '20

Research shows that humorous memes about depression/anxiety on social media help make people less depressed.

Thumbnail
nature.com
265 Upvotes

r/AcademicPsychology • • May 29 '22

Discussion [META] This sub should focus on discussions of psychology and related topics. We are not librarians.

233 Upvotes

I see so many posts that are basically, "I'm curious about [topic], can someone tell me what I want to know? Can someone link me articles?" It feels like this sub is just becoming a hub for undergrads to get answers without having to do actual lit reviews or watch a 10 minute youtube video on statistics.

I'm not saying this suggestion is perfect, but what are your thoughts on requiring posters inquiring about a specific topic to list 1. the database they used and 2. search terms / boolean phrases? Or "I watched [linked video] on these different experimental designs, this is what I make of it, but I'm confused about x,y,z." Or even, "I'm curious about answer [this question], and I tried searching [these terms], but only found [this article], does anyone have any suggestions for other search terms?"

In other words, I think there should be some impetus on the poster to demonstrate effort in trying to understand a concept or do their own learning instead of "Help! I have a project due in the morning I mean, I'm SUPER curious about this concept AND I NEED THE ANSWER ASAP!"

Thoughts?


r/AcademicPsychology • • Jan 30 '26

Discussion My paper on Ice Age extreme cold psychological adaptations was the 6th most downloaded APA paper of 2025!

228 Upvotes

I published a paper at APA's Evolutionary Behavioral Sciences journal in March 2025, about how humans psychologically adapt to extreme cold environments- and found a distinct psychological complex of heightened emotional suppression, ingroup cohesion, introversion, self consciousness, social sensitivity, and perseverance which was present in native Inuit of Arctic regions, Northeast Asian descended populations, and coincidentally as polar worker selection criteria of developed nations. It turned out to be the 6th most downloaded APA paper of 2025 out of all nearly 100 APA journals, far exceeding my early expectations of a few dozen downloads at best https://www.apa.org/monitor/2026/01-02/top-ten-journal-articles

Read it here if you like https://psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2025-88410-001.html . It also includes a new evolutionary psychology method that allows researchers to observe natural selection of psychological traits in real time, by observing data used to form personnel selection criteria for ideal candidates in a particular environment (ie- polar workers who tested to be more cautious suffered less injury than those who tested to be bolder, or those who were more introverted had higher group approval ratings than those who were more extroverted).

Comments and civil feedback welcome!


r/AcademicPsychology • • Sep 07 '20

Why are personality disorders and the DSM considered scientific when they're based almost entirely on subjective and culturally defined criteria?

228 Upvotes

I was reading through some lectures today for one of my classes and came upon a couple of personality disorders. The clinical markers/definitions for them had me contemplate this question.

For schizoid personality disorder, they noted that characteristics include "preferring to be alone" and "not valuing interpersonal relationships". This does not directly have a negative impact on this person's life (i.e. cause dysfunction) UNLESS you factor in the societal perception and reaction to said individual. For schizotypal disorder the clinical markers include having "odd ideas/beliefs" and "behaving/dressing strangely"...that has to be some of the most subjective/relative criteria I've ever heard. And again, how does this negatively impact that individual's life if you don't factor in the societal/cultural expectation component? By this same logic, someone who is defined as mentally healthy today could very easily be defined as mentally ill in another time period or region of the world simply because they do not conform to the societal norms/expectations of that era or location. Being homosexual could be defined as a disorder relative to your culture because you could argue it causes you significant distress and dysfunction in your life when mainstream society regularly treats you poorly and rejects you, thereby causing an internalization of hatred of your sexual identity.

And look, I'm not saying there aren't general patterns of different personality types that tend to have similar presenting features. I think from a broad categorization standpoint it can be useful to have a general idea of what types of traits tend to cluster together to form personality groups which gives a basis for different treatment modalities to assist those who are unhappy or struggling with specific, recurrent issues. But I find myself scratching my head at how much of our basis on these disorders is reliant upon subjective data. Even brain scans are highly limited in what they can tell us. Sure, you can measure electrical activity and see how "healthy" brains fire relative to "unhealthy" brains (which again is entirely subjective; why does a different electrical pattern in a brain imply it is inherently unhealthy?), but the true mechanisms of neurotransmitters and their proper functional levels still have no way of realistically being measured so instead scientists just broadly speculate about brain health and disorders using vague electrical brain wave pattern data.

All of this to say, I think there will be a point where psychology will have the ability to objectively measure and understand the brain and it's functions while interlinking it to the subjective data we currently use as a basis for most of our understanding and treatment of mental health. But the current guidelines that exist to assess, diagnose, and treat mental "illness" seem to overreach quite a bit given the level of actual understanding and again, rely HEAVILY on cultural/subjectively-defined criteria. It's not the inherent study of the mind and its dysfunction that is pseudoscientific, but the practice as it currently stands today definitely seems to be imo.

TL;DR: Some disorders seem genuinely based on a dysfunction of the brain whereas others seem to be based on whether or not someone's behaviors/thoughts have a negative impact on their lives as defined by their relationship to society and it's cultural norms. Either way, we currently have very little means to objectively confirm the basis of these assertions and yet we seemingly reach far beyond our current objective understanding of the brain/mind in how we assess, diagnose, and treat mental health disorders.

EDIT: I would just like to say I appreciate all of the thoughtful and detailed responses. I never imagined I'd get so much insightful discourse so I'm grateful! I've certainly got a lot to chew on from all of the perspectives contributed to this thread. Thank you!


r/AcademicPsychology • • May 22 '22

Question I was plagiarized- now what?

224 Upvotes

I did a google search for my dissertation, which I successfully defended in 2017. I found a “conference paper” with the same title written by a doctor (MD) in Turkey and published last year in “Psychiatria Danubina” in Croatia. I live in Philadelphia, PA (US).

Initially, I was excited to see someone else researching my area of interest but, as I was reading, it seemed way too familiar. I looked at my dissertation and found that it was an EXACT MATCH without mention of my name anywhere. This person even used the quotes I included from the participants in my study!

I am beyond upset. I have already emailed the publisher and am waiting for a response. I’m wondering if anyone else has ever experienced this before. I’m aware that the process may not be simple because of us all being in different countries. Any advice is welcome and appreciated. Thanks!


r/AcademicPsychology • • Jan 27 '22

Discussion Is "thinking fast and slow" worth reading and if so how should one go about it?

211 Upvotes

Recently I started listening to "thinking fast and slow" and as I was looking online I came across a video saying that the book is outdated and that so much has since been proofed incorrect (UpTo 50% of the book) that it's better not to read it.

I started looking into it and saw it posted in more places but everything I found seemed to be based on the same source: research done by Ulrich Schimmack. Wich made me uncertain because if this was true you would expect more then one source to be talking about this.

My question is

  • how is the book treated/ seen by the psychology community?

  • Is it still worth reading (or listening to) or is it to likely one comes away with some very fundamental misconceptions about psychology?

  • If one is to do so how should one go about it to make sure to avoid the incorrect information, for example are there chapters one should just skip since the research behind it is so Shakey?

Edit: so many lengthy responses, thank you all! When ever I see the bad sides of reddit I remind myself of communities like this, with so many people taking the time out of their day to help other people.