Leonard Cohen was the poet of brokenness.
The knowledge haunted the first song that drew attention to him, "Suzanne":
Jesus was a sailor when he walked upon the water
And he spent a long time watching from his lonely wooden tower . . .
But he himself was broken, long before the sky would open
Forsaken, almost human, he sank beneath your wisdom like a stone.
That brokenness was always there.
It proved central to his music and to his body of poetry and literature (nobody else ever mastered all three disciplines as well as Cohen), and it marked "Hallelujah," his most famous vision of transcendence:
It's not a cry that you hear at night
It's not somebody who's seen the light
It's a cold and it's a broken hallelujah.
It followed Cohen into a Zen monastery, where years of contemplation and prayer were sometimes as agonizing as the horror that had driven him there.
It even appeared among the final lines of the final song on his final record, released weeks before he died:
It's over now, the water and the wine
We were broken then, but now we're borderline.
But Cohen – who died on November 7th, 2016 at age 82 – never submitted to the darkness.
In a 1992 song, "Anthem," he sang, "There is a crack in everything/That's how the light gets in." 'Depression has often been the general background of my daily life," Cohen told me. "My feeling is that whatever I did was in spite of that, not because of it. It wasn't the depression that was the engine of my work. . . . That was just the sea I swam in."
Many...sang his music – particularly "Hallelujah," the song Columbia once wouldn't release.
"Hallelujah" was a liturgy of rejoicing that was also honest about God's deceits, and it had emerged at the most broken point in Leonard Cohen’s career. "I wanted to stand with those who clearly see G-d's holy broken world for what it is, and still find the courage or the heart to praise it," he once wrote. "You don’t always get what you want. You’re not always up for the challenge. But in this case – it was given to me."
The challenge, though, got much worse before the light got in.
Both [his mother's] temperament and [his father's] death – when Leonard was nine – had a great effect on Cohen. "My mother was a refugee and witnessed the destruction of her own milieu in Russia," he told me in 2001. "I think she was justifiably melancholy about something, in the sense of a Chekhovian character. It was both comic and self-aware. But I would not describe her as morbidly melancholy, as I was. . . . The death of my father was significant, and the death of my dog were the two, I would say, major events of my childhood and my adolescence."
Montreal's Catholic sensibility would inform Cohen’s works as affectingly as his Jewish background.
"The figure of Jesus always touched me, and still does," he told me in 2001. "Love your enemy. Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the Earth. These views were not foreign to the Jewish education I'd had, but I felt they were a radical refinement of certain principles."
Long before mystery junctions between spirit and flesh made their way into Cohen's songs, he had already established himself as an unorthodox and powerful poet and author.
When he was 17, Cohen entered McGill University as an English major. Aspirations to mythology and possibility – along with an appetite for women – came early and forcibly. Looking back on his early writing, Cohen believed that Montreal's lack of any recognized centrality to the world of art, literature and ideas may have turned out to be a boon for him and his Canadian compatriots. "It was completely open-ended," he said. "The atmosphere of our meetings and gatherings in Montreal cafes and private houses was that this was the most important thing that was going on in Canada – that we were the legislators of mankind, that we had a redemptive function in some way. ..."
Cohen worked on a second novel, "Beautiful Losers", while living [in Greece]. It just about cost him his mind.
"At a certain point, I went into the room and I got up on a chair and started writing around the wall in gold paint: 'I change I am the same, I change I am the same, I change I am the same, I change I am the same. . . .' That’s the only thing I ever wrote on acid, and it appears in the book."
"People talk about loneliness," Cohen told me, "but I really passed days without speaking to anybody."
"Sometimes weeks where the only contact I would have was with the woman I bought cigarettes from, and a day could be redeemed by her smile. . . . It was a difficult period, and it didn't stop being difficult for a long time. . . . I understood that a lot of other people must be in this predicament, because I have these biblical metaphors circling around in my mind. I began to develop this idea that some catastrophe was taking place. I couldn't see why I couldn't make contact."
During one post-midnight discussion, I asked him about "The Guests," which opens Recent Songs.
It reminded me of a Chekhovian tale, or James Joyce's "The Dead," which implied a sense of warmth or community, but the more the guests gathered, the more isolated they seemed from one another, and it eventually turns into a meditation on death that embraces humanity beyond the gathering.
Cohen – who drank a fine bottle of something as we talked – enlightened me:
"Its sensibility is sponsored by the poems of Rumi and Attar, who are Persian poets of the 12th and 13th centuries. I guess it’s a religious song, just about our strangerhood on the Earth and how it's resolved."
One by one, the guests arrive
Guests are coming through
The openhearted many
The brokenhearted few.
From there, Cohen launched into a line-by-line exegesis of the song. The guests, he suggested, ask, "Where is God? Where is truth? Where is life?"
Many songwriters would never bare such background thought:
It's too much commitment to their own meanings, or an admission that they might be uncertain of those meanings. Cohen knew every inch of what any of his songs signified – he explained others that night, meticulously – and if some of his phrases or images seemed ambiguous, he was not. As we kept talking, I heard the clink of a bottleneck on a glass. Cohen chuckled. "Drunk," he said. "Drunk again."
At his Carnegie Hall appearance in July 1988,...he addressed the foreboding in his new music
...scarier, more outward-directed than anything he’d done before, but also full of dark humor. He talked of an apocalyptic scenario that had befallen humanity – a plague, a bomb, the decline of our political systems – even if humanity had not yet realized it. At one point he stood up, slipped off his pants and folded them neatly over the back of another chair. It was a sensible thing to do. It was such a hot day; why wrinkle the slacks to a nice suit? Cohen kept on his jacket and tie, his socks, shoes and blue-and-white-lined boxer shorts as he sat back down.
There was a knock. "Excuse me," said Cohen. He rose and pulled his slacks back on, opened the door and signed for a cold soda he'd ordered for me. He handed me the drink, took his slacks off and folded them again. He flashed a warm smile.
I realized I had just been given an example of how one behaves with poise, even while contemplating the end of days.
Though much of what Cohen had to say that day was portentous, I failed to understand that he wasn't speaking simply from an interesting philosophical or political perspective. On his next collection, 1992's The Future (actress Rebecca De Mornay, who was his girlfriend then, has a co-producer credit), it seemed that sense of sociopolitical foreboding and apprehension might be prophetic, that his new songs were also revealing – maybe more clearly than ever before – a distress that lay deep inside his own mind, heart and history.
The songs were played at clubs and used in movies, and their combination of tones and images fit the times. They were the biggest hits of the artist's career. At age 58, Leonard Cohen seemed – improbably – on top of the world.
Then he walked away from everything in his life.
As it turned out, Cohen had in 1994 taken up residence at a Zen monastery on Mount Baldy, an hour northeast of Los Angeles. The site was previously a Boy Scout camp, 6,500 feet up the mountain, run by Cohen's longtime Zen master, Kyozan Joshu Sasaki Roshi. Cohen studied periodically with him for 40 years, and saw him as a friend, sage and kind of father. During the recording of Various Positions, Cohen took the Zen master to a session in New York. "This was a time when all the news about me was bad and depressing," he said, "razor blades and all that stuff. The next morning, I said to him, 'What did you think, Roshi?'"
"He said, 'Leonard, you should sing more sad.'"
"Everybody was telling me quite the contrary. But he saw that I hadn't gone where I could go, with my voice, with my trip. It was like the deepest, and at the same time the most pragmatic, advice. He saw that my voice could go low, that I could get deep into the material consciously – that I could explore things."
Then, just as unassumingly as he took leave of his life, Cohen also took leave of the monastery, and returned to his family and friends.
In the fall of 2001, he released an album, Ten New Songs. In contrast to the often-acerbic themes that dominated...The Future, Cohen's new LP was about the sad-eyed acceptance and full-hearted love that come after the fires of suffering and the advent of age.
It was not about a fearsome future but rather about a tolerant present.
Deep in the folds of the album there were hints about the mysteries that had surrounded Cohen in the 1990s: Why did he leave the world behind when the world finally seemed ready for him?
"There was no sense of dissatisfaction with my career," he told me one afternoon in 2001. We were sitting in his recording studio, built above the garage behind his modest house in Los Angeles’ Mid-Wilshire district. "On the contrary," he continued, "if anything, it was, well, this is what it's like to succeed. But the predicament, the daily predicament, was such that there wasn't much nourishment from that kind of retrospection.
"By the time I finished my tour in 1993, I was in some condition of anguish that deepened and deepened. Prozac didn't work. Paxil didn't work. Zoloft didn't work. Wellbutrin didn't work. In fact, the only comic element in the whole thing was when I was taking Prozac, I came to believe that I had overcome my [sexual] desires. I didn't know that it has that side effect. I thought it was a spiritual achievement."
The daily regimen of life at the Zen center was sometimes preoccupation enough.
"None of this represented the solution to a crisis of faith," Cohen told me. "I looked at it as a demonstration of solidarity with the community. I was never looking for a new religion. I was perfectly satisfied with my old religion."
Other times, the Zen life wasn't enough.
"I was sitting in the meditation hall one afternoon," said Cohen, "and I thought, 'This sucks. This whole scene sucks.' And I moved from that into cataloging the various negative feelings I had for the mother of my children. I found myself descending into a bonfire of hatred, you know – that bitch, what she'd done to me, what she left me with, how she wrecked the whole fucking scene. I was in there, I was in my robes, and the furthest thing from my mind was spiritual advancement. The furthest. I mean, I was consumed with rage."
That day, Cohen's rage gave way to a moment of unexpected grace, a kind of temporary epiphany.
"There was sunlight on the floor of the cabin, where we were waiting to go see Roshi," he said. "There were leaves outside and the shadow of these leaves was on the floor. The wind moved, something moved, and I disappeared into this movement. . . . The whole scene blew up. A dog started barking, and I was barking. And everything that arose was the content of my being. Everything that moved was me. . . . In certain blessed moments, we experience ourselves as the reality that is manifesting as everything. There's no 'I am one with the universe,' which is the cheapest mystical slogan."
Cohen paused. "There is that moment," he continued, "and it decides that life is worth living."
But dread still arose, and it could obliterate the self.
"I picked up a book by an Indian writer by the name of Balsekar." Ramesh Balsekar was a Hindu mentor who lived in Mumbai and wrote about a concept called "non-dualism," developed in Hindu and Buddhist traditions. In 1999, Cohen departed Mount Baldy and headed to Mumbai. He spent a year studying with Balsekar.
"The model I finally understood," he recalled, "suggested that there really is no fixed self. The conventional therapeutic wisdom today encourages the sufferer to get in touch with his inner feelings – as if there were an inner self, a true self, the real self that we have glimmerings of in dreams and insights. . . . There is no real inner self to command your loyalty and the tyranny of your investigation. What happened to me was not that I got any answers, but that the questions dissolved. As one of Balsekar's students said, 'I believe in cause and effect, but I don't know which is which.'"
Slowly, the depression eased.
"By imperceptible degrees, something happened, and it lifted," Cohen continued. "It lifted, and it hasn't come back for two and a half years. That's my real story. I don't feel like saying, 'I've been saved,’ throwing my crutches up in the air. But I have been. Since that depression has lifted – and I don't know whether it’s permanent or temporary – I still have the same appetite to write." Ten New Songs was perhaps the loveliest and most gracious album Cohen had made.
"The Future came out of suffering," he said. "This came out of celebration."
Cohen told me, "I like what Tennessee Williams said. He said, 'Life is a fairly well-written play except for the third act. It's a badly written third act.' I feel I’m at the beginning of the third act. By the end of the third act, which nobody can predict, it can be pretty hairy. I just know that life is worth living."
It's hard to say whether romantic love ever truly fulfilled him.
It often seemed inseparable from his quest for God or relief. "I had a strong sexual drive that overpowered every other consideration," he said in 2001. "My appetite for intimacy, and not just physical intimacy, was so intense that I was just interested in the essence of things. . . . It was unavoidably intense, the hunt, the gratification. It wasn't particularly enjoyable. It was just an appetite. . . . And consequently, misunderstandings and suffering from both parties arose. When that aspect dissolved, the friendship became clearer. I tend not to lose people in my life."
[At the end,] Cohen wrote to his lover:
"Well Marianne, it's come to this time when we are really so old and our bodies are falling apart and I think I will follow you very soon. Know that I am so close behind you that if you stretch out your hand, I think you can reach mine. And you know that I've always loved you for your beauty and your wisdom, but I don't need to say anything more about that because you know all about that. But now, I just want to wish you a very good journey. Goodbye old friend. Endless love, see you down the road."
Cohen simply got better at the end, creating a trilogy of albums about mortality, apprehension and poise.
They were full of entreaty and peril, and were driven by a sepulchral voice (owned by "just me and Johnny Cash," he’d said with a laugh) that sounded like truth beyond question. He always aspired to better angels, but he also admitted to – in fact, took a certain relief and pride in – an honest assessment of his less merciful side.
On the late albums, he wasn't simply proclaiming prayers but also saw a duty for penance, in himself and all around him, in the broken hearts and spirits of a broken world.
"This sounds like the most hackneyed 19th-century platitude," Cohen once told me, "but in the midst of my own tiny personal troubles, I turned to the thing I knew how to do and I made songs out of it, and in the making of those songs, much of the pain was dissolved. That is one of the things that art does, is that it heals."
"A man who makes those choices in his own life is often more beautiful than his works."
"Any artist who remains true to himself becomes a work of art himself, because that is one of the most difficult things to do. If someone does have that vocation, and diligently applies himself to the exigencies that arise, he will lose a great deal but he will have created his own character."
-Mikal Gilmore, excerpted and adapted from Leonard Cohen: Remembering the Life and Legacy of the Poet of Brokenness