(Screenshot is mine) This is kind of a mix of things and mostly an excuse to yap about how these games emotionally destroyed me. Be warned, there will likely be light and major spoilers in my post for Innocence & Requiem (I will censor them). Anyway.
I purchased Innocence in 2020. I’d heard the hype about it, it was almost impossible not to. So I decided to give it a try. On my very first playthrough when escaping the de Rune estate with Beatrice and Hugo, Beatrice basically left me behind. I assumed it wasn’t intended to happen this way, but she hauled ass somewhere and I didn’t see where she went and every time I tried to figure it out, I would just die. So after playing for about 20 minutes and dying maybe eight times in the intro, I dropped the game for six years. I recently decided to give it another shot, and man. I would have never expected this.
Playing Innocence and experiencing everything it had to offer is one of my favourite gaming memories. I cried (a lot), laughed, and regularly found myself angry and sad on behalf of all the kids involved. At first I couldn’t even remember Lucas’s name, died stupidly so many times that I became medieval John Wick, and developed a different perspective of the word aqueduct. I just wanted Hugo and Amicia to be happy. And that brings me to Requiem.
I started Requiem immediately after finishing Innocence. The opening shot of Lucas with flowers in his hair is probably my favourite image. Seeing the insane upgrade in graphics was unreal. Hugo’s little face, his smile, and Amicia’s lightheartedness was so nice and very much needed after Innocence. For a moment it felt like the three of them could just be kids, and I knew it wouldn’t last but I was holding onto that feeling for as long as I could. Which as it turns out, wasn’t very long at all. I had so many mixed emotions and feelings as I progressed through the story. Spoilers: seeing Hugo be treated like an animal instead of a little boy was heartbreaking. Amicia’s mental state was equally terrible to witness. When he could, Lucas tried so hard to help Amicia keep herself together. Then I met Arnaud.
Arnaud was another character I couldn’t remember the name of at first. He was just another disposable npc I figured I would have to kill. Spoilers: he wasn’t. Throughout Innocence and Requiem, a vast majority of the adults we meet prove themselves to be less than worthwhile, and at first I thought Arnaud was the same. I was immediately wary of him especially after what he did to Amicia, but I tried to be unbiased. Seeing him interact with Hugo made my heart ache. Seeing Amicia grumble like a teenager because there was an adult in her life made me smile. And as I continued making progress, I found myself hoping against hope that Arnaud would be different. He gave the two siblings something they likely never had, or at least not for a while: stability. For a moment they could both put the weight they were carrying on someone else’s shoulders. They had someone they could depend on. Hearing Hugo’s little giggles whenever Arnaud made him laugh had me in near tears.
Spoilers cont: So when I found out the truth of why he accompanied them to La Cuna, I can’t say I was shocked. Just disappointed. Because once again Hugo was being treated as an asset instead of a child. But I didn’t immediately see Arnaud as an enemy. His questionable actions didn’t overwrite the kindness he’d shown to Amicia and Hugo. I was both sad and happy with how things ended with him. Because Arnaud got the opportunity to mend things, even partially, with Amicia. And an opportunity in itself is a luxury most characters in A Plague Tale’s universe are never afforded.
When I finished Requiem, it felt like I had a hole in my chest. I cried so much. I almost feel like crying now just thinking of everything. The last time a game had such an impact on me this way was The Last of Us in 2013. Requiem and Innocence changed the way I look at things. Carnations are my favourite flower now. I never had one before. Feathers carry a different meaning. I wish someone told Hugo that it was okay to be little. I hope Amicia knew that she didn’t fail.
I guess if I had to summarize it all, it’d be this: A Plague Tale’s world hurts. And it keeps hurting. And it makes you want to hurt it back. But somewhere in that world is a flower waiting to be discovered, perhaps surviving in impossible conditions. Just like the people around it.