Just got my first RA essay back and got a 3/6. I thought I did ok, definitely not so bad, but I’m interested to see what others think. If you agree or disagree, I’d like to hear why. Also any and all tips are appreciated. Thanks!
Here’s the essay (apologies for the amount of typos):
In her final speech as first lady, Michelle Obama speaks to the students and adolescents of the US to convinmce them to pursue an education so they can reach their dreams and make this country a better place. She begins by naming different parts of poeple's identities and validating their existence ad expeirience in order to advocate to them that they should pursue their goals with regard and celebration to who they are, then emphasizes the importantce iof working hard to reach one's goals to make the young poeple realize that they can pursue their dreams, and finally closes her speech by naming students and counselors that have already done so to show the adolescents that it already has been achieved by others of their generation. In order to persuade her audience to work to gain education, she must connect with her audience who may initially find her thoughts outdated or not understand their place with their identity due to preconceptions aboput class and society. To do this, she uses repetition to engage different groups, then juxtaposes that by contrasting the ability to do soemthing with the work necessary to get it done, and finally gives and example of an already successful project.
Obama begins her speech by naming different groups and repeatedly telling ea ch gorup tthat they are included in her speech to validate the young people's experiences and help the realize that their preconceptions about their palce in society may not be true. When Obama brings up immigrants, calling them "part of a proud American tradition," and tells people of all faiths they are "a great American tradition, too," the repetition invites the audience to celebrate their identity , which supports the claim that they shouldn't let their identity inhibit their place in society, rahter let it uplift and support their goals. Furthermore, Obama, in order to convince her audience that they should get an education to support their future path, asserts that all people "have a place in our American story," which matters because she repeats the idea of the American story, which carries the idea of everyone being a part oif the history. Because Obama fought heavily for the bettering of the school system, she understand that many fgroups amy struggle with their identities, trargetting this to them. This should encourage the adolescents to get an education by convincing them that if they do, they cna change ad create history.
In the next part of her speech, Obama juxtasposes this very werlcoming position to emphasize the necessity of working hard and getting an education to reach one's goals, and she gices an example of a student who has already achieved great things through application of the priorly discussed ideas to demonstrte to the aodlescents that it's not only possible but it has been achieved before, so not only should they use the aquisition of an education to do great things, but they can ffeasibly do so. In her next idea, Obama develops the idea that education and hard work is necessary by juxtaposing the welcoming energy of her first part with the words "this right isn’t just handed to you," which is important because her audience after the first part would liekly think she is goiung to be welcoming and go-lucky the whole speech, but she surprises them by naming a condition. This demonstrates to her receivers that they should pursue their goals, and, importantly, they msut work hard for it. Morevover, she discusses the timelessness of working hard by citing her own example of her and her hsuband believeing "something better is always possible if you’re willing to work for it." This tells the young poeple pf her audience that although she may not completely understand the complexity fo their sitiuation int he same way they do, the idea of working ahrd to acheive one's goals is timeless and as important then as it is now. This connects back to her first point of inclusion by demonstrating that not only is everyone included, everyone is also capabel of working hard. She builds on the idea that the adolescents must work hard to achieve their goal by closing her speech with an example of a student whob have both not let their identity inhibit them and worked hard, to exemplify to her reader that not only is getting an education and changing the US for the better an idea, but also something feasible. When she names "students like Kyra" she demonstrates the reality and ability for students to achieve great things through their work and composure. Whereas in the opening she disccsued the hypotheitcal idea of change through education, she closes by talking about real world application, showing that Obama's goal is not jsut for the sutdents to believe in their ability but also to apply it.
Score:
1/1 for Thesis
2/4 for evidence/commentary
0/1 for complexity
Here’s the feedback:
Your intro successfully creates a defensible claim that includes rhetorical strategies. Straighten out your audience by asking WHO is being centered in the speech. Who is the PRIMARY audience versus the SECONDARY audience?
BP 1 begins with a solid line of reasoning connecting repetition to her argument, but it becomes unclear how repetition is relevant to her citing the American Dream.
BP 2 successfully identifies Obama’s use of juxtaposition, but should also be SPECIFIC about what this contrast in her tone does for her argument. Your last argument around the use of examples follows a clear line of reasoning