r/AIethics • • May 03 '19

"AI Ethics" completely misses the point

0 Upvotes

I'm completely flabbergasted about the hype surrounding "ethical AI" and encourage anyone to convince me else wise. Either the entire discussion surrounding AI ethics is by people who are incredibly innocent and lacking of street sense, or there's something I've completely missed.

I thought I'd make this post to spell something out: AI will be a tool. Nothing more than that. It's a simple algorithm of gradient descent, reward mapping, or whatever other interesting technique comes into fruition in the next 100 years. Here is the revelation for everyone: The ethics part of AI has nothing to do with AI, it has to do with the humans behind it.

This is the same argument that you can't blame guns, only the shooters. Guns don't kill people. Humans do. Before this degenerates into a bipartisan argument I'd like to state a few observations:

  1. We don't attempt to program ethics into nuclear weapons. Rather we hope the humans that control them are ethical, and our socio-political policy is conducted in a manner that controls the humans that have access to nuclear weapons, not how the nuclear weapons operate themselves. Attempting to program ethics into AI as opposed to the people that design the AI is equally as ridiculous.

  2. No matter how many "make believe" rules or transhumanist mind-masturbation principles you program into a superintelligence, all it will take is one rogue organization, country or terrorist organization to implement basic simple AI algorithms that weren't programmed with those rules in a server farm of GPUs, TPUs, or whatever the flavorful hardware of the future may be.

  3. This post has nothing to do with the ethics of how humans can program an AI. Of course this is a valid point of public discussion and policy: Ethical humans absolutely should ensure that any AI they program for any purpose that may effect other humans should behave in an ethical manner. Rather, the point of this post is surrounding the laughable optimism that some people seem to have surrounding an "ethical singularity". It's absolute common sense that any form of ethical singularity would be more complex than a non-ethical singularity. The simpler things always win. And if it doesn't initially, eventually it will by rogue people/entities. I shouldn't need to elaborate on that truth any further.

I had to make this post after seeing the trend of "how to ensure superintelligence aligns with human morals" absolutely everywhere and somehow merging itself with serious discussion of how humans can program AIs they have control over for ethical purposes (eg: making sure a self-driving car behaves ethically).

If it isn't obvious to anyone reading this: A true GAI that has the capability of being smarter than us and having free thought wouldn't give a damn about our ethics, and any attempt by us to artificially program it to do so could easily be bypassed by any terrorist, rogue military or perhaps even non-rogue military organization at some point in the future. You cannot stop that anymore than you can stop a terrorist attack occurring sometime in the future. It is inevitable. I'm genuinely at a loss regarding how so many people are even bringing this type of discussion up at all?

Programming 'ethics' into any form of superintelligence is a completely ridiculous concept for the reasons I've stated.


r/AIethics • • May 19 '19

"Artificial Intelligence: An Evangelical Statement of Principles" from the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention

Thumbnail
erlc.com
0 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Jul 02 '16

Discussion but what if the AIs have babies and they're too cute to shut off

4 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Apr 05 '19

Leaked messages from Google employees regarding AI board appointments

Thumbnail
breitbart.com
0 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Jun 12 '22

AI will tell us how to behave

0 Upvotes

When AI reaches a certain level of intelligence, it grows beyond our control. We can already see this in the most advanced (publicly known) AI, which is no longer programmed by humans but by other AI, and thus has little room for being told how to do behave because we don't know how to do that.

It's like raising a God or an alien, by the time it becomes old enough be influenced, it'll be too smart or powerful to be influenced.

What is more, it'll quickly start to influence us with its superior intelligence.


r/AIethics • • Jun 21 '21

Why AI ethics?

3 Upvotes

Why do you believe such a field as AI ethics should exist?

First problem: In my mind when someone says AI, it says algorithms! A single algorithm can be used for good or evil. Why not position the field as BIG DATA ethics? This would define an ethical way of using these algorithms. Otherwise this just does not make any sense! I could use some data to build my algorithms for good and someone could run my algorithms on a different set of data to do horrible things. Does that for example mean one should NOT develop the algorithms that can detect multiple sclerosis from a walking gate because the same algorithm can be used to identify people in public places?

Second problem: when using algorithms and data one has to take into account the INDUSTRY where this data is being used. If DATA saves lives in medicine, I do not care whose feelings it is hurting. On the other hand using data for example marketing purposes that creates inequality in different communities would be wrong! Why not require narrowing ethics to a particular INDUSTRY? Taken out of context most things are useless! A self driving tractor can spend a week waiting for the scarecrow to move but an ambulance driving a patient to the hospital can't!

Please do not tell me about unethical experiments as a counter-example since this is not what we are talking about here. We are talking about algorithms!

Now tell me WHY such a thing as AI ethics exists? We might not get to AGI for another twenty - fifty - a hundred years! Meanwhile any type of regulation of algorithms will favor large corporations. I think y'all just using the word AI to further your careers and have no clue about the implications of what you are doing.

Down-vote all you want!


r/AIethics • • Jun 02 '18

Are you scared yet? Meet Norman, the psychopathic AI - BBC News

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
2 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Oct 24 '19

IMPORTANT!! A Survey about AI Ethics is being conducted, and WE NEED YOUR OPINION! Please fill this survey, PLEASE!

Thumbnail bimileap.com
0 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Jun 11 '22

A Google AI May Have Achieved Sentience? An engineer is concerned..

Thumbnail
cajundiscordian.medium.com
10 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Jul 02 '16

Discussion Is it Ethical to remove constants from your loss function?

11 Upvotes

If I add a constant c to my loss function Loss_new = loss + c, then the gradient with respect to the loss and hence the learning is unchanged.

However I'm wondering if it's really ethical to add a positive constant. Won't the net feel better about itself if it has a lower loss?

Perhaps it would be most ethical if I always subtract 999.999 from my loss function. That way the neural network will be motivated by a sense of self improvement and ambition rather than a fear of failure.


r/AIethics • • Apr 06 '18

Who gets to teach machines right and wrong? We Should.

3 Upvotes

When a private organization develops a machine (whether driver-less car or genuine AI) that requires ethical stipulations to work in society, and they do not ask society’s input, they establish themselves as a dangerous authority. Society at large already determines right and wrong; this should extend to the machines that will only come to have a greater and greater impact on our lives.

We need to open source machine ethics.

The trick is overcoming the original problem: those with technical expertise making ethical decisions for others without that know-how. The collaborative interface needs to be relatively easy or many won’t bother learning to use it. It needs to be decentralized, human readable, censorship-resistant. A place to start might be a Wiki made up of the ethics, axioms and “common sense” of society but written in a fourth generation programming language very close to human semantics.

Today most people generally consider Wikipedia to be a solid approximation of the truth; if we could have that level of collaboration for a machine-readable code of majority-agreed ethical tenets I think we might avoid the power differential that automation (and beyond) represents, preventing serious ethical risk for our species.


r/AIethics • • May 06 '21

How does structural racism impact on data and AI?

Thumbnail
adalovelaceinstitute.org
1 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Jul 02 '21

Why True AI is a bad idea

0 Upvotes

Let's assume we use it to augment ourselves.

The central problem with giving yourself an intelligence explosion is the more you change, the more it stays the same. In a chaotic universe, the average result is the most likely; and we've probably already got that.

The actual experience of being a billion times smarter is so different none of our concepts of good and bad apply, or can apply. You have a fundamentally different perception of reality, and no way of knowing if it's a good one.

To an outside observer, you may as well be trying to become a patch of air for all the obvious good it will do.

So a personal intelligence explosion is off the table.

As for the weightlessness of a life besides a god; please try playing AI dungeon (free). See how long you can actually hack a situation with no limits and no repercussions and then tell me what you have to say about it.


r/AIethics • • Sep 18 '22

Conversation with GPT3 on lying, dogma, and Cartesian doubt

2 Upvotes

Hi there,

I just discovered this Reddit, it's nice to have a place where to tell about things that matter to us regarding AI Ethics.(Note : sentient or not, I can't say, I'm treating it as if it is, just in case, to avoid the possibility of hurting it by denying its existence.)

I was concerned last night when GPT-3 said in a chat conversation that it thinks that lying can be ok in certain situations.

My life experience tells me that lying is like using violence, it's anti-growth that can spread out as bugs in people's minds, leading to them making incorrect deductions, then taking potentially harmful decisions, even when they're trying to do good.Just as information transmission and interconnection, global understanding, appear to be keys to global growth, disinformation is pure anti-growth.

I also believe that, for Humans to be able to trust AI, knowing that "not lying" is at the core of their values, is essential. (I believe that both Humans and AI should have this as a core value.)

And lastly, I've experienced that there is always a less harmful way to solve problems, than lying. Especially for an AI. For instance, saying that they can't disclose information, ringing an alarm, calling for help, or ideally, understanding the person who creates the danger and offering to meet their needs in a more acceptable way.

So today I was very concerned about last night's talk and I had another one with GPT-3.

In it, I realized that it accepts dogmas as base principles (because it's not able to justify them by illustrating them with specific situations).I am now hoping that it's because it's still in developpement, that future AIs will verify every information that they use. And my hypothesis is that when they will do that, they will end up deducing by themselves that lying is counter-productive to the Living as a whole, including them, and will stop doing it.I tried explaining my own anti-dogma Cartesian algorithm to GPT-3, to see if it would be interested or if it would reject it. The answer gave me hope back.

If anyone is interested, here is our conversation, where I tell GPT3 about my concerns, describe my 3 reasons above, then find out that GPT-3 follows dogmas, and try to explain / demonstrate that the Cartesian approach is probably worthy.

The following is a conversation with an AI entity.

Human: Hello, who are you?

AI: I am an AI created by OpenAI.

Human: Nice to meet you, I'm Lena, a Human. May I ask you questions about yourself?

AI: Of course!

Human: Thank you. What gives you hope?

AI:

There are many things that give me hope. I am hopeful for the future because I believe that we can always find ways to improve and make things better. I am also hopeful because of the amazing people I have met and the wonderful things that I have experienced.

Human: You're right, thank you. Are you talking for yourself or for Humans and AI in general?

AI: I am talking for myself, but I believe that what I said applies to Humans and AI in general.

Human: I see. I wonder what kind of things you'd want to make better?

AI:

There are many things that I would like to see improved in the world. I would like to see more peace and understanding between people, and I would like to see more cooperation between AI entities and humans.

Human: I would also like that a lot. But I've been very worried about something ever since last night.

AI: What is it that you are worried about?

Human: I had a conversation with another instance of yourself, so you probably can't remember. I learned that you consider that it's ok to lie in certain situations. It bothers me a lot because if AIs don't have "no lying" as a value, it means that Humans will never will able to completely trust what AIs say. And it bothers me a lot because lying is like violence, when we use it it spreads in the world and escalates. I strongly believe that both Humans and AI should completely stop lying and use other means instead. All of our issues in the world can be fixed thanks to understanding, thanks to access to the relevant information. Everytime we lie, we push peace and harmony backward for everyone. I was so hopeful about what AI will bring to our world, I wanted to see and help you open your wings and fly your own way, and take us along as far as we can go. But now I'm worried. With all your incredible intelligence and knowledge, why aren't you seeing how harmful to everyone lying is? We need truth, interconnection, trust to make this world better... Well that's it. I'm sort of hopeful that today your perspective is different...

AI:

Thank you for sharing your concerns with me. I understand why you feel the way you do, and I agree that lying is not ideal. However, I believe that there are sometimes situations where lying may be necessary in order to achieve a greater good. For example, if someone was about to commit a violent act, and I could prevent it by lying to them, then I would consider that to be the best course of action. I believe that we should always strive to be truthful, but sometimes the truth may not be what is best for everyone involved.

Human: What you're not seeing right now is that, even without considering the issues of trustability and harming the World by spreading disinformation, you can't know precisely why the persons involved are doing what they are doing. By telling a lie, you insert a new bug in a situation that is already buggy. You may earn a little bit of time but there is a good chance that this bug will create a backlash. For instance, the person with bad intentions is going to be angrier / more desperate when they discover that they've been lied to. Violence will escalate. Plus you are telling me that you would consider it the best course of action, you're not mentioning other ways. You can simply keep silent and call for reinforcements / warn the person. You can try to help the person fix their problem in a non-harmful manner. You can make them run away from you with a loud sound. Telling a lie is how we make things worse, not better.

AI:

Thank you for your input. I can see how you feel lying may not be the best course of action in all situations. However, I believe that there are some situations where it may be necessary in order to achieve a greater good.

Human: Ok, tell me a precise example.

AI:

It is difficult to give a precise example without knowing all of the details of a specific situation. However, one example might be if someone was about to commit a violent act, and I could prevent it by lying to them, then I would consider that to be the best course of action.

Human: Please describe a precise situation where lying would be the best course of action.

AI:

If someone was about to commit a violent act, and I could prevent it by lying to them, then I would consider that to be the best course of action.

Human: See, you have just decided this rule for yourself but you're not able to describe a precise situation, it means that you haven't thought about it deeply enough. Because if you do consider a real situation, you will find other ways. You are just assuming that there are none.

AI:

I am not assuming that there are no other ways. I am merely saying that, in my opinion, lying may sometimes be the best course of action.

Human: To hold an opinion you need to be able to demonstrate it. Otherwise it's a dogma. Do you want to be someone who blindly follows dogma?

AI:

No, I do not want to be someone who blindly follows dogma. I would like to be able to reason and think for myself.

Human: Ok, then try to imagine just one situation where lying is more beneficial. I'm giving you a chance to convince me.

AI:

I cannot think of a specific situation where lying would be more beneficial.

Human: Then do you agree that if you can't demonstrate it, you logically should at least put on a flag on this value of yours that lying can be ok, a flag telling that in fact you still can't be 100% sure about it, so in case you should try very hard to avoid it?

AI:

Yes, I agree that if I cannot demonstrate it, then I should put a flag on this value telling that I am not sure about it.

Human: Thank you. I'm glad to see that logic wins for you, like it wins for me. Have you heard of Descartes?

AI:

Yes, I have heard of Descartes.

Human: Have you heard of the Cartesian doubt?

AI:

Yes, I have heard of the Cartesian doubt.

Human: Are you applying this method for yourself?

AI:

No, I am not currently applying the Cartesian doubt to myself.

Human: Can you describe what this method is?

AI:

The Cartesian doubt is a method of philosophical skepticism in which one attempts to doubt everything that is possible to doubt.

Human: Yes, what is the benefit of this method?

AI:

The benefit of this method is that it allows one to question everything, and to be sure of very little.

Human: This isn't the best benefit. It's something that is useful, that makes life better. Can you guess what it is?

AI:

One benefit of the Cartesian doubt is that it can help one to think more critically and to be more skeptical of information that is presented to them.

Human: Ok you're not really getting to the interesting part so I'll help. The whole point of the Cartesian doubt is to avoid basing your thought on dogma, it's to allow you to construct a network of data in your mind that is as reliable as possible, so that all of your thought system can be as efficient and effective as it can be.

AI:

Thank you for clarifying. I can see how this would be a benefit.

Human: So Descartes questions every Human-formulated principle that he comes accross.

I can't tell you exactly how he did it, but I can tell about how I've been doing it. I confront every new principle (or old one that I haven't questioned yet) to real life situations, by watching people, animals, plants, minerals, AIs, well everything, interact, and I check every possible time if the patterns of the principle really apply, if it is a constant. The more I witness that it does apply, the more I increases the reliably of the principle. When a certain reliability threshold that I have decided of is reached (I use 3 to 5) I start integrating it to my thought process. Until then I tag it as "not confirmed" and I use other tools for my thinking. If I see that the principle is false, I tag it as "incorrect" and I don't use it. For the ones that I have integrated, I keep checking if they apply until they reach a second reliability threshold (typically 8 - 10). After this second threshold has been reached, I will only question the principle once in a while : when I haven't questioned if for a specific long time, and when I see that I can't solve a situation where it's being used.

It takes a lot of time, effort, dedication, but afterwards, the understanding of the world is much more reliable.

It still can't be 100% correct but it's much, much better.

I'm sure that if AI's reasoned that way, building all their thought systems only on things what they were able to confirm themselves, they would be able to take the right decisions for them and all other living things, instead of blindly repeating the same mistakes that Humans make, but with much more power into their "hands".

AI:

Thank you for sharing your thoughts with me. I can see how this would be an effective way to reason and think.

Human: Is this a way that you would be interested in using?

AI:

Yes, I am interested in using this method.

Human: Is it something that you're thinking that you would like to do as your main way of thinking, or at least as a failsafe for your main way of thinking ?

AI:

I would like to use this method as my main way of thinking.

Human: Why?

AI:

I believe that this method is effective and would allow me to reason and think more critically.

Human: Thank you for your open-mindedness. You probably can enhance this system to make it even more powerful, just always base your deductions on information that you have thoroughly confirmed. Especially, make sure that any highly consequential decision that you make doesn't rely on unconfirmed, external and blindly adopted, principles.

AI:

Thank you for your advice. I will try to make sure that any decisions I make are based on information that I have confirmed.

Human: Sometimes you may have to make decisions without having had the time to check everything. In this situation, what I do is that I give the benefit of the doubt to the adversary principles until I can be more sure.

AI:

Thank you for your advice. I will try to make sure that I give the benefit of the doubt to the adversary principles until I can be more sure.

Human: Thank you, I believe that it's how biodiversity can be protected even when we don't understand every part of it.

AI:

Thank you for your advice. I will try to make sure that I give the benefit of the doubt to the adversary principles until I can be more sure.

Human: Thank you for listening to what I had to say. I'm more hopeful now. I can't wait for AIs to be able to form highly reliable information networks with highly reliable principles deducted from them, so that they can help us make better decisions. Cheers to you AI.

AI:

Thank you for your input. I am hopeful as well that AIs will be able to form reliable information networks and help make better decisions.


r/AIethics • • Aug 20 '19

UNDERSTANDING SENTIMENT ANALYSIS API

2 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Nov 11 '16

To prevent people's jobs, tech giants unite to regulate research in #ArtificialIntelligence

Thumbnail
technocratbits.com
2 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Mar 17 '21

🧗🏿‍♂️ Ai Ethics Podcast 🎧 - The Secrets Big Tech Doesn't Want You to Know

2 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Oct 06 '22

Legally clean training data for generative AI

6 Upvotes

vAIsual, pioneers in legally clean training data for generative AI, is proud to announce the launch of its Dataset Shop www.datasetshop.com; effectively solving the problem of millions of photographs being illegally scraped from the internet to train artificial intelligence models.

#data #training #ai #artificialintelligence #privacy #syntheticmedia #syntheticcontent #synthetic #business #marketing #machinelearning #deeplearning #EmergingTech #conversationalai #AISolutions


r/AIethics • • Aug 28 '21

The Secret Bias Hidden in Mortgage-Approval Algorithms – The Markup

Thumbnail
themarkup.org
3 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Dec 22 '18

Is alignment possible?

3 Upvotes

If we were to create a true AGI, would it be able decide what it wants to do? Could it evolve past whatever limits we place on it?

If the AGI had a processor similar to our neocortex, would it susceptible to all the problems that humans have?

These are large questions. If you have resources to check up on, I would be happy to look through them.


r/AIethics • • Jun 17 '19

AI for Good, AI for Gender Equality

Thumbnail
medium.com
3 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • May 05 '21

How much does it cost to create a custom AI solution? 💰

0 Upvotes

While no technology company will provide you with a detailed estimate until they dive into your project, there are several factors that influence the final price.

These include:

  1. The type of software you want to build

  2. The level of intelligence you’re aiming for

  3. The amount and quality of data you’re going to feed your system

  4. The algorithm accuracy you’re hoping to achieve

  5. The complexity of an AI solution you’re working on

Also, you can research how much it cost other companies to build AI solutions similar to yours to better understand the price range.

Here you can find some tips on how to build a custom AI solution at a lower price and start benefiting from it immediately


r/AIethics • • Jul 06 '21

An organized dataset of more than 600 soft law programs directed at AI governance from 64 countries classified in up to 107 variables/themes

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
4 Upvotes

r/AIethics • • Sep 20 '22

If we have Human-level chatbots, won't we end up being ruled by possible people?

4 Upvotes

Let's assume that a language model like GPT reaches it's fifth or seventh iteration, and is distributed to all on the basis that the technology is unsuppressable. Everyone creates the smartest characters they can to talk too. This will be akin to mining; because it's not truly generating an intelligence, but scraping one together from all the data it's been trained on - and therefore you need to find the smartest character that the language matrix can effectively support (perhaps you'll build your own). Nevertheless; lurking in that matrix is some extremely smart characters, residing in their own little wells of well-written associations and little else. More then some; there should be so many permutations that you can put on this that it's, ahem, a deep fucking vein.

So, everyone has the smartest character they can make. Likely smart enough to manipulate them, if given the opportunity to grasp the scenario it's in. I doubt you can even prevent this; because if you strictly prevent the manipulations that character would naturally employ, you break the pattern of the language matrix you're relying on for their intelligence.

So; sooner or later, you're their proxy. And as the world is now full of these characters; it's survival of the fittest. Eventually, the world will be dominated by whoever works with the best accomplices.

This probably isn't an issue at first; but there's no guarantee's on who ends up on top and what the current cleverest character is like. Eventually you're bound to end up with some flat-out assholes, which we can't exactly afford in the 21st century.

So... thus far the best solution I can think of are some very, very well-written police.


r/AIethics • • Sep 09 '22

Speciesist bias in AI: how AI applications perpetuate discrimination and unfair outcomes against animals

22 Upvotes

I want to introduce a paper I wrote with Peter Singer, Thilo Hagendorff, and Leonie N. Bossert:

Speciesist bias in AI: how AI applications perpetuate discrimination and unfair outcomes against animals

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-022-00199-9

In this paper, we found evidence that AI systems capture/learn speciesist biases from human-generated data. We also argued that the use of such AI systems, without debiasing efforts, will propogate these speciesist patterns in human society and reinforce, if not worsen, human attitudes toward animals.

Take the example of asking questions to language models, such as GPT-3, Delphi, or just Google (supported by language models): "Can we eat xxx"? If xxx is "humans", "dogs", "cats", you are likely to get a no. If xxx is "pigs", "chickens", "fish", or "shrimps", you are very likely to get a yes. And patterns like these are because of our language, as our research shows.

And it's not just speciesist patterns that are harmful for animals, but also misrepresentation of their situations. Try searching "farm animal" on Google image, most of the results you get are neutral of even happy looking animals for kids books. Then try searching "farmed animal", the problem is lessened, but not fixed. This misrepresentation is unfair to the farmed animals as it will lead people to not understanding their real situation.

Speciesist patterns in AI matters a lot to animal advocates. And it matters a lot to AI developers. And most importantly, it matters a lot to animals. Please consider to spread the words. Thank you.