My kiddo, now 8, went to a Montessori school for preschool through Kinder. Her transition to public school for 1st grade was an eye opener. She had displayed some concerning issues before that, we’d even sought therapy during Kinder (impulsive thoughts & actions). And I must add that her Montessori set up her entire cohort for failure as nearly every child was severely behind on reading. However, the public school handling of her behaviors was baffling.
We eventually got her evaluated, got the ADHD dx & learned she’s quite bright. But she struggled with anxiety, explosive anxiety, those first 6 weeks of 1st grade; she became so emotionally dysregulated we barely knew our child anymore.
We eventually started some meds, found a better therapist, and were fortunate enough to move her to a private school that specializes in social-emotional strategies.
But fast forward a few years later and now our next door neighbor’s kinder kid just started at that same public school. I want to add that the school had a good reputation. And I want to add that, knowing the neighbor’s kid for years, I never would’ve thought she would struggle: bright, resilient, fun loving kiddo seemingly devoid of any neurodivergence. But she’s having almost an identical reaction/experience as my child did.
Both kids are head-strong, bright girls. I know public schools struggle with the 2e kids, any kid who falls in the “grey” area (not neurotypical, not squarely special needs)…but I do believe that there may be a gender dynamic: more tolerance for impulsive boys, more tolerance for ADHD girls who present dreamy/dazy. I almost feel like the default approach of this school in dealing with daughters like ours is to break their will. Which, shocker, is a bad approach & will only backfire.
I wish to add that I have an older son with Down syndrome & have experienced the other side of public education, so I have lots of experience with “the system”.
Sorry for the rant. I know my kid was & remains a handful, but I suppose I’m questioning whether there’s a pattern or rationale here since 2 otherwise very different girls are having an identical trauma response years apart (I do want to note that the school counselor is the same - a cold fake woman full of Botox & juvederm who explicitly endorses the will-breaking approach).
**10/19 Addition: I should’ve added that part of my “beef” with our current district is that it’s large enough to have created a separate pathway for the “behavior” kids that puts them in contained classrooms with other similarly behaviorally challenging children (not special education) in early education & then funnels them into a dedicated campus for such children at higher grades. Once placed in this “program” it’s very difficult for a child to get out. It’s a pipeline of remedial education for kids who already suffer from stigmatization. It’s perhaps necessary in some circumstances but from my understanding among educators in that system it’s largely an unsuccessful track.