I have a growing feeling that I've been misled into supporting the new edition of 7th Sea as it seems the vision I have for the game and what it should be is completely different from the one JWP is implementing. When I scout the web in search of other opinions as my own to share views and confront arguments what strikes me is the deafening silence around the game. Despite the fact that it got more backers than any other crowdfunded RPG project, almost nobody is discussing the game, and the few comments you can read here and there are either very polarized, someone popping out to throw a very negative comment about the game as a whole, or either one of the adepts of Mr Wick write entire panegyric reviews singing praises of the creator without much insight about the actual content delivered.
So how figuring out what's going on in this scattered community? Well, dropping from more than 11 400 backers to 2 500+ is self-explicit. To all those who justified this drop by the fact that eastern flavored backgrounds are less appealing to the western crowds I say bollocks, even double bollocks. Stamping a setting with "asian flavor inside" is pretty much a 100% guarantee for success in the West. Legend of the Wulin, Ogre Gate, Wu Xing, all these quite confidential games are quite successful at their respective scale, not to mention the giant L5R or even Qin the warring states, which is originally a French RPG, I happen to be lucky enough to know one of the author and to have played with him, and probably the most successful French RPG ever and mainly thanks to its setting. So no, Khitai did not suffer from its setting.
So what happened? Well I won't spend to much time on that since I don't know myself and considering my personal bias I can only offer guesses, but higgledy-piggledy I'd say a poor communication before and during the campaign, over stretched thresholds, odd and ultimately debatable choice of content for the rewards, weird choices of development (going from 4 of the main nations into one book to one nation per book), and of course the consequences of the ongoing deliveries for the 7th Sea 2nd Edition campaign, namely a very polarizing game system that is way less popular than the devs think it is, disappointing content, inconsistent lore, etc. These are not all my ideas, several come from posts I've seen here and there written by more or less disappointed backers.
So in the end, this leaves me with a question, have I, and many others out there, misunderstood what JWP's project was and backed something that wasn't for us? In which case then we'd have to deal with it and let it go. Or, are the devs from JWP completely off the mark and have no idea what their community expected? In other words, who misunderstood what 7th Sea is supposed to be?
In normal times I wouldn't ask the question, a developing team proposes a game, it's available on the shelves or your favorite RPG book store to browse, people check it up, like it buy it, do not like it move to the next product, simple as that. But here, it's a crowdfunded project. We all, at different levels, participated to its inception. Shouldn't we, as a community, have a say in the content of the products? I already picture some comments saying that I'm alone on this line and thus the devs don't have to listen to my single voice, sure, you're right, except that we went from 11 400 down to 2 500. We lost nearly 9 000 people! Surely I'm not the only one irritated by the content they delivered so far. I mean, someone posted that the games showcased by John Wick seem to indicate that the game was designed to be a series of one-shots, and indeed the mechanics hint that way, but all I see around is people talking about entire campaigns, and clearly the lore hints that way, so the rules and the lore both aim at two different types of games, thus my question, did JWP truly figure out what their game is supposed to be and how it is meant to be played?
The last draw for me was the Vaticine city preview we got. I asked two of my friends who are both RPG players what is the first thing they expect from a city book in a given setting. They didn't even know what game we were talking about. Both replied simultaneously "a map!". Yet here, we have a company rewarded for the quality of its maps who uses almost an entire page to tell its players and GMs in a very patronizing way that they don't need the map because the game doesn't need maps to be played, and before referring to the core book to remind them what is a dramatic sequence. One page out of 70. To tutor people in the most pedantic way possible.
So, three things. I don't think it's the place of a company to tell its players what they do or do not need, it's disrespectful and shows very little understanding of the very diverse type of plays that can exist among the RPG community. Secondly, if maps are that irrelevant, why do you spend so much time drawing them for the rest of your world? Just tell us where stuff are situated approximately and we'll roll with that... Finally, if you still need to patronize your players and GMs about how your game should or should not be played when reaching nearly 24 months of development and your tenth supplement (counting a release after Secret Societies, if it comes after Land of Gold it should be the eighth supplement) then clearly you did something very wrong.
It shows through the way the timeline issue was handled. Remember how the devs first reacted here when we brought the topic and ultimately complained about the mess that were the dates over all the books. Here is Micheal's first response to a comment where I raised the concern:
"Personally, I don't consider a specific, explicit, and highly accurate ancient timeline to be important. I don't think it matters that X King converted to the Vaticine faith 200 years ago, or 150 years ago -- the idea is that he converted to the Vaticine faith a long-ass time ago, several generations ago, and _____ is how that influences the current status of the nation and its various religions. While I certainly agree that some elements of the 7th Sea timeline are confusing or a bit jumbled, I confess that I don't understand why it's an issue in the majority of cases. It is, however, something that we are actively working on cleaning up, but I'm not directly involved in that process (I'm a rules monkey, not a setting monkey) so I can't give you any specific details or an ETA."
He simply couldn't see the issue. And it took a couple of months after this exchange for them to finally address the issue and recruit (or choose I don't know) a loremaster within the dev team. I mean, common sense suggests such a job should have been one of the first and foremost jobs filled before they even started to write any line of lore, yet they waited for the fifth supplement to be released to realize that this was not working. Half the game line has been released with unchecked and inconsistent lore and won't be fixed simply because they didn't understand lore and time were an issue for a sizeable majority of the players, and whereas this is a crowdfunded project.
So I suppose by now you have guessed what my answer to my own question would be, obviously I believe they failed to grasp the expectations of the community regarding the content of their game and instead of mending their ways they kept going against the stream no matter the consequences, aka two failed projects and one successful, albeit barely compared to the former, KS campaign. However I'm very interested in your opinions on the matter.
I'm following the development of another game right now, one that didn't use crowdfunding for its development. The supplements are more or less the same size those JWP provide us with, so while the settings have nothing in common, the content can be compared, and both team are roughly the same size (JWP would be bigger by one or two persons but not granted). When the main designer starts drawing or writing for a future release, he starts sending messages on our French community Facebook page, chatting with us like we're some kind of old buddies, sending us some teases to drive us mad with theories :), and when a product is released, he comes to us asking how we liked it, how it unfold and what should be changed in the upcoming works. And all the other devs speaking a bit of French or English do the same. None of them shows any sign of arrogance regarding their products no matter how outstanding they can be.
This is the kind of attitude I expected from the 7th Sea's dev team.
TL;DR Did JWP truly figure out what their game is supposed to be and how it is meant to be played? And are we, as players and GMs who backed the game, entitled to ask for changes in the development's direction?