r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 25d ago
Press X to doubt
All you have to do is prove that your concept of "momentum conservation" actually works in Galilean relativity. Best of luck!
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 25d ago
All you have to do is prove that your concept of "momentum conservation" actually works in Galilean relativity. Best of luck!
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • Oct 19 '26
r/7not37 • u/MaximHeart • 12d ago
That's what you get by trying to be good faith with DraftScience. You try to establish a conversation and all you get in return is babbling nonsense and needlessly insulting rhetoric.
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 11d ago
/u/6not36 said,
No Holy Ghost and 1/2vmv are fables.. And Newton never said f = Ma what he did say was "twice the force twice the motion three times to force three times the motion
But let's check the tapes, /u/6not36 .
Newton's Definition II:
The Quantity of Motion is the measure of the same, arising from the velocity and quantity of matter conjunctly.
The motion of the whole is the Sum of the motions of all the parts; and therefore in a body double in quantity, with equal velocity, the motion is double; with twice the velocity, it is quadruple.
The "Quantity of Motion" is what physicists now call "momentum". The "quantity of matter" is mass, and so we have momentum is "arising from the velocity" and mass "conjunctly". p = mv.
(I expect, Bob, you may quibble over the "Sum of the motions of all the parts". We can get into parallelograms later.)
Newton's Law II:
The alteration of motion is ever proportional to the motive force impress'd; and is made in the direction of the right line in which that force is impress'd.
If any force generates a motion, a double force will generate double the motion, a triple force triple the motion, whether that force be impress'd altogether and at once, or gradually and successively. And this motion (being always directed the same way with the generating force) if the body moved before, is added to or subducted from the former motion, according as they directly conspire with or are directly contrary to each other; or obliquely joyned, when they are oblique, so as to produce a new motion compounded from the determination of both.
You much like to quote this, Bob, but you seldom quote it in its entirety.
Here, "alteration of motion" = change in momentum
But what is "motive force impress'd"? We can do back to Definition III, but it's not necessary. The point is that Newton's phrasing doesn't align with modern phrasing. We know that from the fact that physicists use the term momentum to talk about Newton's quantity of motion.
In other words, "motive force impress'd" is not necessarily what we understand as "force" today.
But let's call that motive force impress'd F. The first paragraph says Δp ∝ F . The "alteration of motion" Δp is proportional to the "motive force impress'd" F.
But now let's consider the second paragraph. Here I'll focus on this sentence (emphasis mine):
If any force generates a motion, a double force will generate double the motion, a triple force triple the motion, whether that force be impress'd altogether and at once, or gradually and successively.
So F is not an instantaneous thing. Its influence can be spread out over time and still result in the same change in momentum... at least once the full action and interaction are over.
So now we can say F is some function over time, F = F(t). Moreover, we can suppose that F has some derivative f(t) = F'(t). In other words, F(t) = ∫ f(t) dt.
That means Let (Δp)(t) = p(t) - p(0) = F(t) and now take a time derivative.
(Δp)'(t) = p'(t) ∝ F'(t) = f(t)
Or f ∝ p' = ma
All right, we didn't establish strict equality here, but any additional proportionality constant can be rolled into the definition of mass. f = ma.
F, or Newton's "motive force impress'd" is what we call "impulse" today. The rate at which impulse is applied is force.
Of course, I'm sure you're aware that when an object is acted upon by a force that depends on position, and not time, energy is conserved, and that can be seen as a consequence of this reading of Newton's second law.
You may say this still doesn't amount to Newton saying f = ma. Well, he didn't say p = mv, either. He used the word momentum in Latin to talk about the product rule in calculus.
In other words, sometimes you have to use your brain.
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 29d ago
r/7not37 • u/archaic_bot • Oct 22 '26
It's a real pickle. Forget about kinetic energy. Behold the mysteries of springs!
r/7not37 • u/MaximHeart • Oct 19 '26
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • Oct 20 '26
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 27d ago
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 1d ago
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 9d ago
Bob likes to say "force = energy = momentum". Alas, if only it were that simple!
A world in which kx + mx' = constant for an object on a spring is a world in which springs don't oscillate at all. It means mx'' = ma = -kx' = -kv.
It means acceleration is proportional to velocity, so an object on a spring would simply grind to a halt.
We can see with our own eyes that's not true at all.
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • 5d ago
r/7not37 • u/MaximHeart • 10d ago
Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/PhysicsIsBadLogic/s/4c7rX3J7sp
I just thought this post by u/ShonOfDawn was nice and informative.
You don't need any such thing a lab thermometer will do just fine a clay or ballistic gel has lots of locations that won't be disturbed by the ballistics
This feeds back into my previous point. A 3000 J bullet is more than regular 5.56, more close to a .500 S&W Magnum. If you want 99.9% of the energy being dissipated as heat as you claim before, you need the factor m1/(m1+m2) we talked about to be 1 / 1000. A .500 S&W bullet weighs 24 g, so the ballistic pendulum needs to weigh approximately 24 Kg. If you insert the thermometer on the outside of the ballistic gel block so that it has some hope of surviving the impact without getting damaged or dislodged, the heat needs to travel all the way from the impact side to the outside. And, as I said, 3 KJ is a pitiful amount of energy to heat up 24 KG of material. Ballistic gel is basically 90% water, which has a specific heat of 4100 J/(Kg K). Let's be generous and assume the specific heat of ballistic gel is c = 2000 J/(Kg K). The heat capacity is c times mass, or 48 KJ/K. This means the 3 KJ we input will change the temperature of the block by a whopping 0.0625 K, which is non measurable outside an absurdly expensive lab setting.
The irony of it all is that DraftScience/6not36 doesn't even have a formula to convert between temperature and his version of (misdefined) momentum. Not only do the units not work out, but he literally has no system/theory to work out ANY prediction. It's just his guesses made out of his ass left and right. Anyways, this post is great because it actually answers one of his complaints.
r/7not37 • u/Muphrid15 • Oct 19 '26