r/60sMusic • u/Aggravating-Pin7555 • Jul 04 '26
Listening To Every Billboard #1 Hit: 1968
All good things must come to an end. For the refreshingly great period of music that started in 1964, this year seems to mark the end. 1968 has the least songs yet (ignoring 1958, which didn’t start counting songs until like august) and the music is also just boring. So boring, in fact, that I’ll be returning to my older format of talking about my Top 3 rather than my Top 5, since I don’t really have much to say about song 4 or 5. They were just the least mediocre. The most symbolic part of this year was Harper Valley PTA by Jeannie C Riley. This song ended up at number 5 on my list for this year, which is shocking because it’s a song that puts more emphasis on storytelling than music, which have historically been used to fill up the bottom half of my lists. Honestly, in any of the list 5 years, Harper Valley PTA couldn’t have possibly made my Top 5, but 1968 was so incredibly boring and the story was engaging enough to not end up like a Ringo or Big Bad John. Somehow, despite this year being incredibly boring, The Supremes were still barely snubbed of a top 5 spot.
Bottom 3 - 1968
3. Hello, I Love You - The Doors
Despite being disappointed by Light My Fire in 1967, I was willing to give The Doors another chance. After sitting through the boring slog that was the first half of the year, I saw The Doors and got a little excited. “Oh, The Doors!” I thought “That’s a band people like. The Doors are here to save me and help me fill out the top 3.” Nope. The thing is, I know The Doors are supposed to be really good, but I genuinely just don’t get it. Is this like a reverse Maroon 5 where they’re going to get good and right now they’re just ass? Please, somebody tell me so I stop feeling crazy.
2. Honey - Bobby Goldsboro
This song is just boring. It’s very repetitive. It’s not catchy. I really wish I had more to say about it, but I don’t. There’s not even anything about this song I can really shit on, it just does absolutely nothing to captivate my attention. I guess like it kind of feels like it ends mid-thought? I don’t know, I just didn’t like this one.
Judy In Disguise (With Glasses) - John Fred and His Playboy Band
This song puzzled me. On the first listen, I couldn’t tell what percent of this song was supposed to be a joke. I figured maybe this was a Alley Oop situation where it’s a reference to something I’m not aware of, so for the time being I just kind of chucked it into the list and continued. By the end of the year, I realized that Judy In Disguise had been rotting at the bottom of the list the whole time, and I think that’s honestly deserved. This song is kind of catchy, but unlike a fun catchy song where you happily invite it in, and then maybe after a few days it overstays its welcome, Judy In Disguise forces its way in with that stupid ‘with glasses’ line. Anyways, I dug into the song more before writing this, and found that it’s supposed to be some kind of parody of Lucy In The Sky by The Beatles, which makes it kind of funny that this song went number one and that song didn’t. Honestly, I don’t care about the background. This song is just kind of lousy.
Top 3 - 1968
3. Mrs Robinson - Simon & Garfunkel
Simon & Garfunkel back again with yet another fairly simple duet. Their voices just work so well together on every second of this song. Mrs Robinson is a good song.
2. (Sittin’ On) The Dock of The Bay - Otis Redding
This song is really good. I really liked this song in middle school, and ended up with every word permanently hammered my brain, although it’s very welcome. The way this song can push and pull its energy in such an incredible way is truly what puts it above the rest.
Hey Jude - The Beatles
I feel like every time a Beatles song lands high on the list I say this, but this song feels like THE Beatles song. Hey Jude is relentlessly catchy and the type of song that would be hard to find somebody who didn’t know it word for hard. This song may also be one of the reasons this year was shorter, because it spent around 2 whole months at number one, blocking plenty of songs that might have made the list.