r/40kLore • • Apr 15 '24

In response to critiques female Custodes and how female fighters are portrayed in 40k

11 Upvotes

So there's a common assertion going on that female Custodes are nonsensical because men are stronger than women and as such make better warriors, so it wouldn't make sense to recruit from an inferior pool of candidates. Hard to argue with given medical science and human history, right? Here's the thing though:

Women in 40k are not physically less capable of fighting than men. Certainly not at the top levels.

It's why arguably the best unaugmented fighting forces in the Imperium are women: the Sisters of Battle and Sisters of Silence.

It's why at the start of the second Eisenhorn book the hulking bruiser and melee specialist of his retinue was Ravenor's seven foot tall amazonian girlfriend.

It's why there is a huge amount of portrayals of female members of the Officio Assassinorum.

It's why throughout every single official licensed 40k RPG there has, not once to my knowledge, been a penalty to strength for playing a female character.

People seem to think 40k is a gritty down to earth speculative fiction series like Game of Thrones, where people function the way they do IRL unless otherwise noted. It's not. It's a high fantasy with superhuman larger than life characters that don't have to conform to real-world limitations. Including their women, when authors bother to write them in.

The realism argument for 40k is and always has been silly to me. It's like complaining about the single best hand to hand fighter in Batman being Cassandra Cain, the second Batgirl, who can near-effortlessly beat the breaks out of the much physically larger and male Bruce Wayne. These arguments imo try to force 40k to be what they think it is rather than what it is.

edit: Remember, a downvote without an argument is an admission of defeat. =)


r/40kLore • • Mar 03 '23

Why does the belcher's gland exist?

0 Upvotes

I mean out of the lore context. It's such a random ability in context of all the other enhancements Space Marines have.

It reminds me of why Superman has cold breath, which is because his creators just kept slapping random powers on him. Even these days, every decade or so Superman will have a new power in him revealed.

Is it the same thing with Space Marines?

If not, why stop at acid spit? Why didn't all Space Marines also get flames shooting out of their armpits so they can incinerate someone in a headlock and sleep gas shooting out of their assholes that they're immune to?


EDIT: It's okay to just say it's there for the cool factor. You don't have to pretend there's some grand scientific or logical reason behind it. You don't have to get defensive about "cool factor" in the lore for toy soldiers in a game that children play.

EDIT2: Many of you have lost the capability to separate 40k lore with reality. The reasons that humans, living in real life, decided to add acid spit is not the same thing as the explanations these humans in real life came up afterwards for it.

Those of you claiming I'm making fun of Warhammer or Warhammer fans by asking this, it's actually only you that's insulting Warhammer and Warhammer fans. You're the only ones that are making the statement that acid spit being there for "cool factor" makes Warhammer lesser.

The hallmark of insecurity is getting angry at things that haven't been said.

EDIT3: If it upsets you to hear that Warhammer is about toy soldiers in a game that children play, you're exactly the person who needs to hear this message.

You're the one who ties ego to it and you're the one who cares about how superior your hobby makes you feel.

I'm quite happy playing with my toy soldiers and thinking about my toy soldier lore.

EDIT4: Those of you kicking and screaming and going out of your way to get offended instead of just being able to admit what's stated here: https://www.reddit.com/r/40kLore/comments/11h3m9r/why_does_the_belchers_gland_exist/jatb0jl/

Truly have issues.


r/40kLore • • Aug 26 '25

The Imperium of Man isn't a bad place to live for everyone

0 Upvotes

Every discussion of life in the Imperium focuses on the worst case scenarios because those tell interesting stories. They focus on the hive city hells where about 90% of the Imperium's population live in squalor. They focus on the vast armies where countless trillions of soldiers spend short brutal lives on battlefields that would make a WWI soldier long for the trenches of the France. They focus on the feral death worlds where every plant or animal can instantly kill you and the rate of children surviving to 18 is 30%. The Imperium is a horrible, brutal place to live for most people.

But not for everyone.

The Imperium of Man is an extremely diverse place. There are at least a million, or possibly millions, of worlds, and in the grand scheme of things most of them have complete autonomy to govern their own affairs as long as they pay their taxes and ensure everyone worships the Emperor as a God, and even the form of worship is open to local interpretation.

There are worlds out there that are idealic paradises even for the poorest citizens. There are rural worlds where everyone can live on a farm and sustain themselves from the land. There are worlds that are free democracies where the planetary governor is elected by the populace and beholden to a congress. There are paradise worlds meant to service the Imperial elites where even the servants are pampered and want for nothing.

Most people live in the hell-hives, it is true, but most worlds are probably not that bad, or even marginally better than our own, as long as nobody starts sacrificing newborns to make the crops grow faster.


r/40kLore • • Nov 11 '23

Horus statement about Ferrus only needing him to win the Heresy doesn't make sense.

3 Upvotes

Horus says that if he had Ferrus on his side that he would've certainly won the Heresy with ease. This statement alone is contradicting and the biggest example is Perturabo and the IW, without them, the traitors would've had hard time breaching Dorn's defenses. If we swap Perty with Ferrus, the combined forces of Dorn and Perty would decimate Horus and Ferrus. If the Lion and Gulliman were present, even then Horus and Ferrus would not stand a chance.

If Ferrus and the IH were really that strong as claimed by Horus, they could've defeated Fulgrim and the EC then and there on Istvaan 5. The Khan defeated a corrupted Mortarion, Sanguinius fought against Ka'Bandha, Daemon Angron, and juiced up Horus, Kurze fought 6 Primarchs simultaneously and here Ferrus couldn't defeat Fulgrim who at the time didn't even achieve Daemonhood.

Some of the Iron Hands joined Horus even though he was indirectly responsible for Ferrus murder. The Iron Hands believe only in strength and victory at all costs, Horus and Fulgrim won, therefore proving Ferrus was weak.


r/40kLore • • Dec 07 '24

Abaddon feels the Ruinous Powers trying to infiltrate his mind and he refuses it, experiencing terror for the first time [F]

0 Upvotes

The whispers grew louder.

"I will not.", Abaddon spat through gritted teeth.

The whispers grew louder.

"You have my answer. Leave me!"

The whispers grew louder, each syllable cutting like the sharpest of blades. Were these his own thoughts? No, such cowardice would never be displayed by the Lord of the Black Legion.

"Why must you hide in the shadows and mock me? I am your Champion! If you desire to make such demands of me, show yourself! I am the Despoiler of the Galaxy and my voice is heard across it. Show yourself!", Abaddon roared into the void. In the time it would take to blink, it appeared before him. It's presence was overwhelming and encapsulated the entirety of his sight. Surrounding him, engulfing him, Abaddon was unable to draw breath. Before any utterance began, before any limbs came alive, he experienced pain. His two hearts slowed, aching with every beat. From his insides he felt tumorous explosions rolling throughout his body. His organs felt like they were being rung out. The blood in his veins became icy and thick. What had been but a moment had begun to feel like hours, like time itself had been rend. What stood before him now was as much present in realspace as his mind, and he had lost all control of his reality. His mind could not process what was happening.

For the first time in his existence, Abaddon experienced terror.


r/40kLore • • Dec 15 '24

I‘m against all primarch returns, change my mind.

8 Upvotes

Reason 1: it ruins the main characteristic of a decaying imperium.

Reason 2: it weakens the role of corrupt Terran politics. To me those story arcs are way more interesting than watching Demi gods doing Demi god things.

Reason 3: their story is told. It was perfect that their values and flaws continue with their sons.

Reason 4: more from a hobby perspective, takes away a major point of 30k…

Don’t get me wrong. I love those guys but I think we won’t benefit from having them back.

Maybe you can change my mind?


r/40kLore • • Oct 24 '24

Hot take, Tau do not need to be grim dark, nor should they be

27 Upvotes

Honestly, I get it. Them not being grim dark like any other faction makes them stand out, they don't seem to fit in the whole ultra-violent setting that is WH40k. But in my opinion, that's a good thing. I don't say this just cause the solution to this so far has been "Let's just make them racist" which is horrible in my opinion, all the other factions are racists and what makes tau unique is that they are not that. But in my opinion, the tau not being grim dark can help the reader appreciate the grim darkness of the universe. From the Imperium pov, we see a space marine as a noble warrior, protector of humanity against xenon and chaos threats,fighting the enemies if the Imperium the galaxy in the name of the god-emperor. From tau pov, we see a war criminal, enhanced to be an immortal murder machine, a living super weapon with the blood of countless innocents staining ther blades. Tau provide a way for the reader to experience the grim dark nature of the other factions, without any of the zealotry or unreliable narration blocking our view. Where the Imperium sees a glorious imperial world, untainted by the ruinous powers or xenos threats and loyal to the god-emperor, the tau see an authoritarian hell hole, where the people are oppressed and live in poverty as the upper classes bloat in gluttony and greed, where innocents are slaughtered horribly for rebelling against their horrible condition. Where the Imperium sees glorious battle in the name of the emperor, the tau see savagery and needless death, where peace and diplomacy are a present and reasonable option. With stories being often told from the pov of the Imperium, it's easy to get lost in the imperial narration and forget that hey, these people aren't good guys. And sometimes it just helps to have a good guy to compare with and remind you of how fucked up the other guys really are. And that's what the tau can be. A good guy, to compare the other factions to in order to emphasise their evil and cruelty. The naive idealists, pursuing hope where there is none to begin with. Trying to make the tau grim dark by making them racist and genocidal towards humans just kind of ruins that. Usually the reader can be led to view an imperial victory as a sign of hope for humanity against chaos or whatever threat. But when seeing humans live in much better conditions under tau than they would ever dream of under the Imperium, we remember that imperial victories aren't a sign of hope, it's just humanity being stuck between a rock and a hard place. That doesn't work when you suddenly make it so that humans are discriminated and sterilised under tau rule cause tau were actually racist all along. It just doesn't have the same effect.

Edit: To clear a misunderstanding, I have no delusions that tau are a perfect peaceful egalitarian utopia. I know full well they're an imperialistic, manipulative, caste system with an expansionist agenda. Still, compared to the other factions, they're not fanatic xenophobes or theocratic totalitarians. Their shtick is an empire serving the greater good of all species, even if they suck at doing that. And it isn't for no reason that I described them as naive idealists. However, in terms of their goals and society, they are really no worse than our own real life states compared to the other factions. And it is that comparison that I'm talking about. We have an empire who seeks to propagate the greater good for all sapient species, coming in contact with a galaxy filled with genocidal ultra xenophobic empires, who have no interest in diplomacy, only war. Sometimes it is easy to forget how awful the Imperium can be, under all the heroism and glory, especially when the other factions to compare with are the likes of drukhari and orks, so having a tau pov would allow the reader to see beyond the heroism. Sometimes readers need to remember that the main faction, isn't the good guys of this story. And that reminder can come from seeing the Imperium through the eyes of a faction that isn't, you know, drukhari and orks and the likes.

Second edit: I'm also not a tau fan, I like the nids better


r/40kLore • • Jul 15 '26

Has the hypocricy of the imperium ever broken your immersion like it did mine? (spoilers for the end and the death) Spoiler

29 Upvotes

a few weeks ago i finished the End and the Death, great book, however when i got to the part where vulkan is forced to do the unspeakable sanction (doing the human sacrifices so that malcador can last longer on the golden throne) the way it's shown kinda bugs me.

Vulkan is like crying and saying "how could we do this!? human sacrifices oh my god! i can't! these innocents will die so that the whole of humanity will live! oh god oh man oh god oh man oh god oh man!"

and the chosen of malcador are also distraught, they are also afraid of the whole situation, as detected by actae who is a psyker.

so now i'm sitting here like, yes obviously someone would be morally burdened if they were forced to kill one thousand people, i get that. but this is vulkan and the chosen of malcador

vulkan, who in the great crusade probably wouldn't care when he genocided a xenos planet, and was only a bit mad when he wiped out a planet of both humans and eldar.

vulkan who i have not read a book about him truth to be told, but since the emperor didn't krump him i'd think he'd agree with the emperor on the great crusade which means he agrees on the "kill other humans when they don't like us until they do".

and the chosen of malcador i don't need to say more about them, considering malcador had an eldar kill himself everytime he told him his secrets.

i would expect this reaction from like, a grunt, a space marine maybe, someone who has not given the orders himself, and now he has to bring himself to embrace the monstrosity of his imperium, not a primarch, who was a general of a grand fleet then the regent of the entire imperium, and certainly not the secret police.

people say it's a case of "unreliable narrator all warhammer books are propaganda" but i really, really hate that theory with a passion.


r/40kLore • • Aug 12 '20

Death of Hope is cancelled, Let help him change his mind!

31 Upvotes

Here is the video Majorkill uploaded about it, DoH Cancelled

-Mark has decided to cancelled the Death of Hope series and has already unlisted the first episode and plans to uploaded the second episode as unlisted as well. We need to see if we can convince him not to do this.


r/40kLore • • Aug 16 '23

40k isn't satire, it's misery porn.

199 Upvotes

Like the whole setting was created to make the Imperium necessary and there are many sources of horrible misery that pre-date the Imperium:

Loss of AI and servitors replacing it, hive worlds, psykers unwittingly opening gateways to demons, most common type of an alien being a species of space Nazis that live only for war, loss of technology, dependence on extremely advanced technologies that were created in dark age of technology, etc. all pre-date the Imperium.

It doesn't really set out to warn about anything, it has no message behind it, only "look at these people suffer" and "look, cool power armour!"

I feel like there are lots of people in Wh40k PR side that (like the ones that generated all the social drama messages) just don't get it. They got the "wh40k is satire" meme from 1st ed community and "Imperium is the baddies" meme from Tv Tropes, but it was never really the point.

The point was creating a setting where human species can exist only at cost of massive misery and oppression of vast majority of individuals and having cool miniatures fight battles in it.

There were lots of satirical elements in 1st ed due to inspirations from 2000AD but later the setting got much more serious.


r/40kLore • • Dec 01 '23

What's the appeal of space marines?

0 Upvotes

As the title states. They all seem a bit... dull, to me? The honor and purity stuff gets old real quick. But they're also the most popular faction. What am I missing?


r/40kLore • • Apr 19 '22

I hate the Imperium

6 Upvotes
  • I hate their architecture. Their gothic-excessive-apocalyptic style manages to bother and annoy me more than any of its individual parts. It's both a catholicism more ostentatious and tacky than anything in our world, gaudy and disgusting in how overly ornate anything is, or it's so decrepit and filthy that I get something like seven different diseases just from looking at arts of an average Hive city.

  • I hate the Inquisition. I hate their role of secret police, I hate that they see blowing up an entire world as perfevtly normal. I hate that all the examples of Inquisitors we're focusing on are all reasonable people that really regret dooming worlds, but there really was no other way.

  • I hate the Ec lesiarchy. I hate their whole shitck of religious fanaticism. I hate that the lore paints them as actually right and give them faith powers that actually work better than psychic powers. I hate that, for some reason, no other specie is allowed faith powers similar. I hate their looks, I hate that Sisters of Battle are most likely issued from a nun fetish some designer had in his life.

  • I hate Space Marines. I hate their aesthetic, which seems to combine both the 'tacticool soldier' and the 'fantasy knight' archetype, but somehow fails at both, never landing in either in a way that's actually visually appealing and cool to me. I hate how powerful they are, I hate how much models they have, I hate that we have more chapters of space marines, than we have Xenos armies. I hate that Space Marines alone have more characters than anything else. I hate that they outdo everyone else at everything (think you had cool tech? Nah, the Dark Angels have better. You're a good commander/administrator? Nah the Ultramarines are better. Good guerilla fighter? Nah the Raven Guard is better.). I hate that the lore and larketing are all too happy to present them as good guys and relateable (see GW releasing the shiny Space Marine 2 trailer playing 'look at this badass spaceknight saving the innocent' with the straightforwardness of a punch to the face just months after GW tried to say 'the Imperium is evil, guys!').

  • The Imperial Guard is the only bit of the Imperium I don't hate, I just don't feel anything about them.

  • I hate Custodes, who are somehow more OP and absurd than Space Marines, who are even better at everything, smarter, faster, stronger, better, have even better gear, are totally uncorruptible and would never EVER turn against the emperor. I hate that the fanbase have fully embraced that, as seen by the screeching whenever you mention the Harlequins managing to kill some.

  • I hate that the Imperium is the only faction allowed to be important:
    I hate that we don't have any Xenos champions of Chaos.
    Where are the Xenos empires and tech?
    I hate that Eldars Psykers suck so much compared to Mephiston or Magnus or Malcador.
    I hate that the Ynnari's only narrative role was to revive Guilliman and they're now the imperium's sidekicks.
    I hate that Tau got grimdarkified so that Guilliman could be the "Reasonable protagonist".
    I hate that Cawl gave the imperium more 'new' technologies than the Tau have apparently developped since they were introduced.
    I hate that Tyranids apparently can't be smart whenever they fight the imperium.

  • I hate the emperor, I hate that most of the lore paints him as either right or right-ish.
    I hate the Sisters of Battle.
    I hate that the imperium get Faith powers when Ekdars don't.

  • I hate that the emperor actually said 'lol no' to a "this disease perma-kill Primarchs"

  • I hate that the only actual Xenos game where they didn't have to share the spotlight with imperials is now old enough to drink and was a janky mess.
    I hate that I love the other races, but I can't actually enjoy thel because they have so little content.
    I hate the memes, I hate that any discussion of 40k inevitably turns to the imperium.


r/40kLore • • Feb 19 '23

Pirating BL materials will result in an instant ban.

51 Upvotes

This includes offering or requesting any pirated content. No exceptions.


r/40kLore • • Feb 14 '23

Khorne smiting the galaxy and turning an Imperial fleet into berserkers is dumb and makes Nurgle look stupid

5 Upvotes

If the Chaos gods can just get up and fuck up entire fleets at a whim, why did Nurgle not just corrupt the whole Indomitus fleet attacking his forces in Ultramar? Is he just a chump compared to Khorne? Surely the warpy conditions were similarly favorable for Nurgle. Also, Nurgle paid a price for the Ultramar shit. Khorne just dabs on realspace without suffering any consequences. Again, making Nurgle look really pathetic.

Also... I can't imagine the level of rage that would saturate this sub if an Imperial crusade flew up to a Chaos fleet and prayed so hard that the Emperor sent out a psychic blast that turned all of the Chaos forces loyal again. Does everyone remember how mad people got when Guilliman/Emps burned up part of Nurgle's garden, having no actual consequences other than irritating Nurgle?

Dude Angron was flying around in the fucking void killing whole spaceships by himself. Guilliman had to take a special DAOT Custodes ship full of bodyguards, and fight like hell to overtake a single Death Guard ship. I can't imagine how people would have reacted if he then set off a purity bomb that made all the Death Guard love the Emperor again...


r/40kLore • • Oct 17 '24

Why won't people read the books?

0 Upvotes

Every day this sub is flooded with questions about the lore that are easily answerable by reading the numerous books. How is it satisfying to get the answer from YouTube or a sentence from a stranger on reddit? Don't get me wrong I'm glad every found their way to the hobby but I just don't understand how you can be so interested in something and completely skip over the resources with the answers everyone is wanting?


r/40kLore • • Mar 06 '24

The Horus Heresy has done worse than paint Chaos as weak; it made every Traitor a Lame Loser.

0 Upvotes

(i got thinking about that upon reading the "Abnett has some words on who 'won' the Heresy" thread).

While we can debate for a while on whowon the Heresy, if it was the Traitors, the loyalosts, the emperor, the Chaos gods, some combination of the above, or none of them...
Now that the Horus Heresy is over, I think we can look back on how it presented the traitors throughout.

And it's not great.

Usually, when writing a wargame, you want all factions to feel (roughly) equally as badass and cool, so that people are encouraged to pick and play their favourite. They will be cool for different reasons, but they need to be appealing to the readers in some form or another.

And the Horus Heresy is absolutely not that.

The Horus Heresy itself endlessly insisted that the traitors were cowards, that the Night Lords could only run away from the Dark Angels, since the DA were oh-so-cool and had oh-so-powerful weapons and Primarchs. Every page written about the World Eaters is a long spiel about how far they fell and how fucked up they are, Magnus is an indecisive idiot, Angron is a tragic failure, Fulgrim is victim of a sword, etc... Every victory the traitors get over the Loyalists is a Purrhic one, where we're told how bravely and fiercely the Loyalists fought.
Perturabo ambushed an Imperial Fists fleet, is supposed to be a genius of war and had superior numbers? He still almost lost to a Space Marine. The Word Bearers cripple the Ultramarines at Calth in a suprise attack? They still lost two-thirds of their forces and the book is such an endless Ultramarines wank that later books had to retcon a "Losing half of his forces was part of Lorgar's plan all along".

The traitors are written inconsistently, and the loyalists get to point those inconsistencies as a sign of how lame and indecisive they are.
Jagathai literally breaks canon to be able to land cool zingers that make no sense if one thinks about it for a minute.
Books are retconned to make the traitors seemed lamer (Echoes of Eternity saying Magnus's vision of an offer of redemption (which was the climax of Fury of Magnus) was something he made up to feel better about himself)

We're told and shown that Angron, who already has reasons to be angry at the Imperium, further empowered by Khorne, still has a rage that's less pure than Sanginius whom he cannot kill in melee either.
Fulgrim ends the siege looking like he could be distracted from killing you by dangling keys in front of him AND he was told he sucked by Dorn and the narration without coming up with a comeback.
Mortarion can't managed to kill Jagathai and just takes his 'sick burns' without coming up with a retort himself.

And we got so much focus on the Amazing and Cool and Stalwart loyalists that by the end of the Siege, it feels like the only reason they got so close to winning was that Chaos had an endless amount of faceless, nameless demons to throw at the Imperials rarherthan any feat of strength of their own.

And canon is broken to make the Loyalists seem even more righteous and TRAGIC in their EPIC LAST STAND (Apparently Dorn vales freedom of Expression? The Imperium thinks it should treat prisonners humanely? SINCE WHEN?!)

All to make their defeat even mpre tragic and sad, at the expense of Chaos and the traitors, to the point I'm wondering how can anyone that read Heresy books be a Chaos fan.


r/40kLore • • May 14 '22

Each of the Primarchs had some real life influence that inspired their creation. What real life figures inspired the creation of Khan?

7 Upvotes

r/40kLore • • Dec 17 '22

World Eaters are poorly written

3 Upvotes

I get that every chaos god needs their patron legion, but the world eaters just don’t make any sense from the emperors perspective.

Angron is clearly unstable from the moment the emperor meets him. The nails have a strong hold on him and it’s quickly determined that they cannot be removed without killing him. So off the bat, the guy who the emps wants to lead that legion is an unhinged maniac that will most likely never listen to or follow any plan laid out for him.

Next up is their purpose. Emps wanted them to be shock troops to storm and assault any garrison. Um hello space wolves. They serve the same purpose as them but lack the ability to be a coherent military unit. So really they are just worse furries.

Lastly, the style they choose to fight, up close and personal, just leads to massive casualties in every engagement. This is something space marines can’t really afford cuz they’re so hard to make more of them. Yes, plot armor can see them back up to full strength when it matters, but that doesn’t count here.

In all, it just makes way more logical sense for the emps to have ended that legion as soon as he saw how insane angron was. Boohoo, lost a primarch who clearly would never lead his legion properly or do whatever the emps needed. Imo, just kinda lazy writing around khornes legion. Feel like they could have done them a better service that tells their story and downfall in a more logical sense.


r/40kLore • • Apr 07 '23

I hate that people think Minotaurs are Iron Warriors

0 Upvotes

As someone who loves the Minotaurs chapter and plays them on the tabletop, I wanted to bring up something that really grinds my gears in regards to how they are seen and described by many people in the community. I often see forum posts, and even some influencers, saying that Minotaurs are made from Iron Warriors geneseed. Apparently, this whole idea comes from a single instance of Eadwin Brown speculating that Minotaurs are of Iron Warriors descent. Eadwin apparently helped Alan Bligh write the Badab War HH books. Regardless, Alan Bligh himself never confirmed this to be true.

The main reasons I disagree with this notion completely are due to the existence of the Horus Heresy novel, The Outcast Dead. There is some questionable stuff in that book, no doubt, but my personal favorite part of the entire book was the plot line revolving around Arik Taranis, one of the last remaining Thunder Warriors.

For those who haven't read it and don't want spoilers, you may want to stop here. But for those who don't care, this book hints VERY strongly at the Minotaurs being descended from Thunder Warriors.

In the novel, Taranis and his subordinate are hiding out in the Petitioner's City on Terra and are dying due from organ failure since the Emperor made the Thunder Warriors to be unstable and eventually die or be killed off. Fast forward to the end of the book and Taranis manages to fix their degradation by sourcing organs and genetic material from a couple of the Crusader Host Astartes who died earlier in the story. So now we have Thunder Warriors who at the very least have managed to prolong their own lifespans, and possibly even found a way to make more soldier like them.

We know the Minotaurs geneseed is said to be chimeric, which lines up with Taranis sourcing material from multiple legions.

We know that the Minotaurs dislike other Astartes and frequently get into confrontations with other loyalist chapters. This lines up with Thunder Warriors and how they were killed off and replaced by the Astartes. I believe their dislike and distrust of other marines is because they remember how their predecessors were killed off and replaced by Astartes and that resentment still persists.

Minotaurs are also described as being vicious and brutal to the point of seeming almost unstable. Which the Thunder Warriors were also known for.

Then there are the obvious aesthetic similarities between Thunder Warriors and Minotaurs. If you look at artwork of TWs, you will see that their armor is a very similar color to that of Minotaurs, including the splashes of red here and there.

Lastly, we have the personal heraldry of Arik Taranis himself being described in The Outcast Dead. It is described as a red bull's head. Sound familiar? It literally matches the Minotaurs own chapter heraldry. Hints at connections don't get much more blatant than that.

So with all of this being said, WHY do people still choose to believe that Minotaurs are Iron Warriors? As someone who loves the chapter's aesthetic and what little lore they have, it drives me crazy to see people water down the mystery behind them by just saying they are Iron Warriors because "they are both angry, tough, and paranoid"... They are paranoid because their predecessors were betrayed and killed off by the Imperium and Astartes in particular. We don't need another loyalist Iron Warriors chapter when we already have one in the Silver Skulls! And if it wasn't for this plot line being in the aforementioned novel, it would probably have no reason to exist at all. Sure, we have the Greek connections with how the Minotaurs have a Spartan-inspired look and Perturabo's planet of Olympia being very much inspired by Greece, but the similarities seem to end there from what I can tell. And Greco-Roman aesthetics aren't exactly unique to any one faction in particular in 40K.

So yeah... With the rant over, what do you guys think?

EDIT To be clear, I am NOT saying that Minotaurs ARE Thunder Warriors. Just that their lineage was created by and possibly influenced BY Thunder Warriors.


r/40kLore • • Feb 25 '23

Why does the imperium tolerate commorragh and the dark eldars existence

13 Upvotes

There is something particularly repulsive about the existence of the dark eldar and their dark city. It is a blight on existence itself. A place of incredible suffering. Countless human slaves have been torture raped in their dungeons; many twisted into immortal beings in order to prolong their pain indefinitely.

The imperium exists to face this kind of darkness. No where does the genocidal ethos of the empire make more sense than in the face of the drukhari and their interdimensional hell city. Whether it takes 100 or 10 thousand years; I think a worthy goal would be planning the utter annihilation of the dark city. Various crafts / robots with nuclear bombs strapped to them; forbidden old world weapons; whatever it takes. You'd need to get some agents in and map it all out; including hidden pocket dimensions; but it could be done.

Why has it not been done? By the emperor! Why is the dark city allowed to persist!


r/40kLore • • Mar 24 '24

which chaos god could be killed the most easilly?

0 Upvotes

Tzeentch is the first out- its almost a joke because Ahriman has basically been trying to get a one up on the deity for approximately 10,000

Slaanesh-- good luck- the Aeldari have been trying for-- what- 15,000 years?

Nurgle- I honestly think we are working with something here. If you managed to bring enough Sisters of battle to his realm and a couple hundred exterminatus ready ships, an absolute metric ton of Tzeenchian sorcerers, and their most powerfull artifacts- and yeah, I think it could be done.

Khorne-- How much more firmly can I say----- NO!!!!----- exactly?

If you tried, you would just make him stronger.

The last guy who tried to take him down- got bitch slapped across space time so hard- that, that particular daemon did not heal- that it has not healed until today- it is just- a mistake to even consider trying.

First you would have to manage to at least kill Nurgle and Slaanesh both at least.


r/40kLore • • Feb 04 '24

Heresy The Horus Heresy is mind-numbingly stupid

0 Upvotes

<Rant on>

Right, I’ve read the first five books so far, and having just finished Fulgrim, I just find the whole thing a bit stupid. I kept waiting for something that would justify so many Primarchs and their legions turning traitor, but it never came. It’s just episode after episode of supposedly (nearly) perfect beings, peerless military commanders with superb judgment and boundless charisma, suspending all their critical faculties and going all-in on a nakedly idiotic and seditious enterprise because someone told them to do so. “Let’s make the galaxy better by setting fire to it and starting a civil war” is cretinous by any measure. There’s even a bit where they try to blame lthe Emperor for the fact xenos are now taking advantage of the turmoil in the imperium caused by their uprising. Eh?

I’ll carry on reading as I’m sure further novels will flesh out their back stories and motivations, and some of the writers are great, but it is fundamentally impossible to justify the heresy.

Fulgrim is a good example. McNeill makes a point of highlighting the exterior influences that corrupted him - the Laer temple and then daemon in the Laer blade - and has a half-hearted attempt at illuminating his anguish as the good elements of his personality grapple with the daemon’s influence. But it’s hard to believe a Primarch could so spectacularly fail to recognise things are turning a bit squiffy and take action accordingly. You can just about get your head round the idea that they feel a bit isolated (the loneliness of command) without Daddy being there telling them exactly what to do, and making the odd bad decision, but they then seem to pick and choose whose advice they listen to. Fulgrim parks his rational judgment when pitched the idea of the heresy by Horus but is totally unwilling to accept any counter arguments from Ferrus, to whom he’s far closer. It’s also just incredibly childish to want to know exactly what the Emperor is doing back on Terra. You’ve been given a mission - conquer the galaxy - and you’ve been given the freedom to do it your way too (mission command! - most commanders would kill for that level of freedom), and yet they’re pissing and moaning because Daddy isn’t holding their hand and explaining his every movement ? Fulgrim and Horus gripe about not being honoured enough - despite hundreds of thousands of iterators, artists etc being dispatched to follow the Crusade for that exact purpose.

There’s also a really weird juxtaposition of people being corrupted very gradually by the pernicious influence of Chaos - the EC becoming vain and haughty, or the lodges within the SoH - and the almost instantaneous flip into utter debauchery (EC suddenly deciding to wear people’s skins and sew their eyes and mouths open after the Maraviglia, for e.g., or just executing brother Astartes in cold blood). A bunch of soldiers seeking perfection (which is itself a stupid concept) rapidly turning into junkies after accidentally attending a rave is beyond silly. You can just about see how they might be willing to submit to Fabius’ ministrations (a parallel is an average athlete taking performance enhancing drugs) but even that is a bit OTT. And surely the additional (soon-to-be traitor) legions arrive at whatever muster they had before Istvaan V where they were pitched the idea of the massacre, take one look at the Emperor’s Children and go “Nah we’re ok thanks.” Can you imagine a Night Lord seeing an EC bloke with his eye shadow and lipstick on and thinking “I want a piece of that action!”

For soldiers whose entire concept of self-worth is based on honour, brotherhood and loyalty to so readily turn on their own is mental though (I say this as a soldier). In reality, large numbers of blokes would just go “No boss, we’re not doing that, sorry.” People will point to the Nazis in WW2 as an example of good people drawn into doing horrific things by toxic leaders, but you’d like to think Astartes are above that. Perhaps their indoctrination makes them more susceptible, not less.

Ultimately, I just find it disappointing that the traitor Primarchs are reduced to spoilt, attention-seeking, idiot children with no moral compass, incapable of rational, critical thought, and are terrible judges of character (“This Erebus fellow seems like a swell guy and I will absolutely do everything he suggests against my better judgment and the advice of my most loyal, trusted inner circle”).

And I still think Horus is an ocean-going bell-end.

<rant off>

Edit: At no point did I say I hated the books. I genuinely really enjoyed them (it’s ultimately a great, albeit well-known story of hubris leading to ruin)I just find the motivations for the traitors’ downfall really silly. As people suggest, I’ll keep reading. I’m eager to read the SoT series too as by then the motivations are largely redundant and it’s a question of how we reach the ultimate denouement.


r/40kLore • • Jul 09 '25

Why is Horus Rising rated so highly?

0 Upvotes

I'm new to Warhammer and started with Eisenhorn/Gaunt's Ghosts Omnibus

I'm starting the Horus Heresy now and have seen lots of people saying Horus Rising is their favourite book

To me it seems pretty uneventful and more of a setup book where it's introducing characters and setting up the major future events and leaving small hints of the cracks forming in the traitor legions

Interested in hearing people's thoughts on why it's rated so highly or if there's some different opinions on the best Heresy books?


r/40kLore • • Nov 06 '23

Imperial white-washing in Saturnine Spoiler

5 Upvotes

So, I've been reading Saturnine (shocker, I know). For context; I've read many of the other books in the Horus Heresy, but dropped the habit before getting up to the events leading up to the Siege of Terra. I read a Reddit post here about how Abaddon went into the five stages of grief during this book, and was interested in reading the rest of it. I'm about a quarter of the way through the book, but I've found parts of it that already make me feel... Weird.

Notably;

‘The Order of Remembrancers is long dissolved, by Council edict. Its purpose is curtailed. There is no formal programme. The late Solomon Voss’ great project is abandoned. No more illumination is needed, no more iterators required to articulate the truth of-‘

‘It was necessary to control the flow of ideas,’ said the Praetorian gently. ‘Fundamentally necessary, as a measure of security. The word of the enemy can be toxic. The idea of the treason is toxic. It is infectious. You know that.’

‘I suppose I do,’ said Sindermann.

‘Censorship is abhorrent to me,’ said Dorn. ‘It runs against the principles of the society we were meant to be building. Great Terra, I’m beginning to sound as high-minded as Guilliman. My point, Kyril, my point is… we’re not building any more, and we had no idea how words could contaminate everything we hold dear. Remembrancers. Theists. Ideas that, in better times, we might at least have gently humoured. I stand opposed to all that woman Keeler represents, but I would defend her right to say it. In better times. But words and ideas have become dangerous, Sindermann. I don’t have to explain that to you, of all people.’

Bolding was mine for emphasis.

It feels jarring to read Rogal Dorn espousing the virtue of free speech. I think I can understand why he was written as doing so; I think Dan Abnett might have intended it as a poignant bit of melancholy. We know that the Imperium will ultimately win the Horus Heresy, but will progress onto the 42nd millennium as a tyrannical empire that has completely shirked such noble principles. Along with other moments throughout the book, such as Rogal Dorn's heart-to-heart with Constantine Valdor, or Kyril Sindermann expounding on the virtues of treating prisoners well, it paints a moody, tragic image of the Siege of Terra, the guttering of a light, the fading of nobility...

Hang on a minute

This is the Imperium!

Mornarchia, the Interex, the Diasporex, servitors, repression of religion, the thousands of psykers sacrificed to the Golden Throne, the poor treatment of some of the Primarchs, the countless xenos and human civilisations consigned not even to the footnotes of history under the tramping jackboots of the Great Crusade. Saturnine is asking me to believe that they care about individual liberties? It's asking me to feel sad about the Imperium that has done all that?

Maybe it's not. Maybe, I'm supposed to realise that this is all told from their perspective; that when Dorn talks about freedom of speech, he's thinking about a definition of freedom of speech that isn't the same as mine. Maybe we're supposed to think that he's either an idiot or wilfully ignorant, considering that we soon meet the same Euphrati Keeler being imprisoned for refusing to renounce her faith in the God-Emperor.

Maybe Kyril Sindermann, who later in the book expounds on the virtues of treating prisoners well, is supposed to be an example of dramatic irony, in that he becomes one of the founding members of the Inquisition.

Vaskale nodded. ‘We have set food and water rations every day for the inmates. That’s a waste, isn’t it? They’re not on our side, or they wouldn’t be in here. Why feed and house them, when we can’t feed and house our own?’

‘I think the answer to that lies somewhere in the field of ethics,’ ventured Sindermann. ‘In trying to maintain some kind of decent, human society.’

‘Really? Does it?’ Vaskale replied. He chewed that over. ‘You, you’re making reports, are you? Enquiring? My name going to be mentioned?’

‘No, sir,’ said Sindermann.

‘I’m not ashamed of my opinion,’ said Vaskale.

‘And you’re entitled to it.’

‘No. I see that look. Snooty, superior, liberal-intellectual… I’m not suggesting some... eugenic cull, I’m-‘

‘I never said you were,’ said Sindermann. ‘You’re desperate. We all are. We’re caught in the greatest siege history has ever known, and everything we have is dwindling and running out. You are obligated to keep and feed criminals and threats to our sovereignty, while good people go without. So you voice a pragmatic idea.’

‘Pragmatic,’ Vaskale nodded.

‘Brutal, but pragmatic,’ said Sindermann. ‘I fear you’re right. It may come to that. I also fear that, if it does, then we cross a line and become no better than the things trying to break these walls in.’

Maybe I'm missing critical information or a needed perspective. Maybe the rest of the three quarters of the books, or later books even, make the point that Dorn is a hypocrite and Sindermann spawns the scalpel of the 'cruellest and most bloody regime imaginable' in direct contradiction to his purported ideals. Maybe I've just become so disillusioned with grimdark stories that I'm now reviled by them when I read them.

I don't want to turn this into a lecture. No doubt most of you will not need to be told Imperium Bad, and some of you will be annoyed that I'm doing so. But Saturnine feels like a weird book to me. It's asking me to be sad that lobotomised cyborgs enslaved to tend to the gardens of the Imperial palace were repurposed to instead work at munition depots, while itself not dwelling on the condition of the servitors.

Sindermann wandered along the garden walk. The Katabat Terrace, a hanging garden, once a paradise. The beds had been left to grow wild, stone tubs and planters split by untended roots. Auto-irrigation and pesticide systems had been shut down to conserve power. The botanical servitors had long since been recoded to serve in the munition vaults. The garden staff had been conscripted to siege labour brigades or sent to the front lines. Other Palace gardens, and there were many, had been turned over to food cultivation.

But not the Katabat. The highest, the loneliest, the Emperor’s favourite, near the top of old Widdershin’s Tower. It had simply been abandoned. Perhaps He, the beloved Emperor, hoped it could be opened again one day, the gardeners brought home, the precious specimensnurtured back into bloom.

If that was so, thought Sindermann, then hope still existed.

The Katabat had not withered. Rain drummed across its paths, beds and parapets, pooled on uneven flagstones, and overspilled from empty pots. The garden had turned feral, overcome with weeds, untamed creepers and unpruned saplings. Water dripped from the bowed and buds of chemically disfigured flowers. The symbolism was breathtaking.

I can certainly believe that Imperials would feel the tragedy in that. But it feels like I'm being asked to join them in their mourning, uncritical of the Imperium's failings and evils. It's a feeling that takes me out of the book in a bad way, and wonder if the author is attempting to white-wash the Imperium.

It feels weird.

Anyway, it's 4:30am. I think that's enough screaming into the void.

Edit: One last note.

I don't want to shame anyone for liking this book, its themes or its characters. I also don't want to claim that anyone who does is a secret fascist-sympathiser or whatever. I personally enjoy those themes, it's just that when I reflect on them I find it jarring that they're ascribed to the Imperium. Especially since, in my opinion anyway for whatever that's worth, they'd fit better with the Craftworld Aeldar, or maybe the T'au, or maybe even the Necrons. I certainly think that Twice-Dead King went in a similar direction and pulled off the execution much better.