So, I've been reading Saturnine (shocker, I know). For context; I've read many of the other books in the Horus Heresy, but dropped the habit before getting up to the events leading up to the Siege of Terra. I read a Reddit post here about how Abaddon went into the five stages of grief during this book, and was interested in reading the rest of it. I'm about a quarter of the way through the book, but I've found parts of it that already make me feel... Weird.
Notably;
‘The Order of Remembrancers is long dissolved, by Council edict. Its purpose is curtailed. There is no formal programme. The late Solomon Voss’ great project is abandoned. No more illumination is needed, no more iterators required to articulate the truth of-‘
‘It was necessary to control the flow of ideas,’ said the Praetorian gently. ‘Fundamentally necessary, as a measure of security. The word of the enemy can be toxic. The idea of the treason is toxic. It is infectious. You know that.’
‘I suppose I do,’ said Sindermann.
‘Censorship is abhorrent to me,’ said Dorn. ‘It runs against the principles of the society we were meant to be building. Great Terra, I’m beginning to sound as high-minded as Guilliman. My point, Kyril, my point is… we’re not building any more, and we had no idea how words could contaminate everything we hold dear. Remembrancers. Theists. Ideas that, in better times, we might at least have gently humoured. I stand opposed to all that woman Keeler represents, but I would defend her right to say it. In better times. But words and ideas have become dangerous, Sindermann. I don’t have to explain that to you, of all people.’
Bolding was mine for emphasis.
It feels jarring to read Rogal Dorn espousing the virtue of free speech. I think I can understand why he was written as doing so; I think Dan Abnett might have intended it as a poignant bit of melancholy. We know that the Imperium will ultimately win the Horus Heresy, but will progress onto the 42nd millennium as a tyrannical empire that has completely shirked such noble principles. Along with other moments throughout the book, such as Rogal Dorn's heart-to-heart with Constantine Valdor, or Kyril Sindermann expounding on the virtues of treating prisoners well, it paints a moody, tragic image of the Siege of Terra, the guttering of a light, the fading of nobility...
Hang on a minute
This is the Imperium!
Mornarchia, the Interex, the Diasporex, servitors, repression of religion, the thousands of psykers sacrificed to the Golden Throne, the poor treatment of some of the Primarchs, the countless xenos and human civilisations consigned not even to the footnotes of history under the tramping jackboots of the Great Crusade. Saturnine is asking me to believe that they care about individual liberties? It's asking me to feel sad about the Imperium that has done all that?
Maybe it's not. Maybe, I'm supposed to realise that this is all told from their perspective; that when Dorn talks about freedom of speech, he's thinking about a definition of freedom of speech that isn't the same as mine. Maybe we're supposed to think that he's either an idiot or wilfully ignorant, considering that we soon meet the same Euphrati Keeler being imprisoned for refusing to renounce her faith in the God-Emperor.
Maybe Kyril Sindermann, who later in the book expounds on the virtues of treating prisoners well, is supposed to be an example of dramatic irony, in that he becomes one of the founding members of the Inquisition.
Vaskale nodded. ‘We have set food and water rations every day for the inmates. That’s a waste, isn’t it? They’re not on our side, or they wouldn’t be in here. Why feed and house them, when we can’t feed and house our own?’
‘I think the answer to that lies somewhere in the field of ethics,’ ventured Sindermann. ‘In trying to maintain some kind of decent, human society.’
‘Really? Does it?’ Vaskale replied. He chewed that over. ‘You, you’re making reports, are you? Enquiring? My name going to be mentioned?’
‘No, sir,’ said Sindermann.
‘I’m not ashamed of my opinion,’ said Vaskale.
‘And you’re entitled to it.’
‘No. I see that look. Snooty, superior, liberal-intellectual… I’m not suggesting some... eugenic cull, I’m-‘
‘I never said you were,’ said Sindermann. ‘You’re desperate. We all are. We’re caught in the greatest siege history has ever known, and everything we have is dwindling and running out. You are obligated to keep and feed criminals and threats to our sovereignty, while good people go without. So you voice a pragmatic idea.’
‘Pragmatic,’ Vaskale nodded.
‘Brutal, but pragmatic,’ said Sindermann. ‘I fear you’re right. It may come to that. I also fear that, if it does, then we cross a line and become no better than the things trying to break these walls in.’
Maybe I'm missing critical information or a needed perspective. Maybe the rest of the three quarters of the books, or later books even, make the point that Dorn is a hypocrite and Sindermann spawns the scalpel of the 'cruellest and most bloody regime imaginable' in direct contradiction to his purported ideals. Maybe I've just become so disillusioned with grimdark stories that I'm now reviled by them when I read them.
I don't want to turn this into a lecture. No doubt most of you will not need to be told Imperium Bad, and some of you will be annoyed that I'm doing so. But Saturnine feels like a weird book to me. It's asking me to be sad that lobotomised cyborgs enslaved to tend to the gardens of the Imperial palace were repurposed to instead work at munition depots, while itself not dwelling on the condition of the servitors.
Sindermann wandered along the garden walk. The Katabat Terrace, a hanging garden, once a paradise. The beds had been left to grow wild, stone tubs and planters split by untended roots. Auto-irrigation and pesticide systems had been shut down to conserve power. The botanical servitors had long since been recoded to serve in the munition vaults. The garden staff had been conscripted to siege labour brigades or sent to the front lines. Other Palace gardens, and there were many, had been turned over to food cultivation.
But not the Katabat. The highest, the loneliest, the Emperor’s favourite, near the top of old Widdershin’s Tower. It had simply been abandoned. Perhaps He, the beloved Emperor, hoped it could be opened again one day, the gardeners brought home, the precious specimensnurtured back into bloom.
If that was so, thought Sindermann, then hope still existed.
The Katabat had not withered. Rain drummed across its paths, beds and parapets, pooled on uneven flagstones, and overspilled from empty pots. The garden had turned feral, overcome with weeds, untamed creepers and unpruned saplings. Water dripped from the bowed and buds of chemically disfigured flowers. The symbolism was breathtaking.
I can certainly believe that Imperials would feel the tragedy in that. But it feels like I'm being asked to join them in their mourning, uncritical of the Imperium's failings and evils. It's a feeling that takes me out of the book in a bad way, and wonder if the author is attempting to white-wash the Imperium.
It feels weird.
Anyway, it's 4:30am. I think that's enough screaming into the void.
Edit: One last note.
I don't want to shame anyone for liking this book, its themes or its characters. I also don't want to claim that anyone who does is a secret fascist-sympathiser or whatever. I personally enjoy those themes, it's just that when I reflect on them I find it jarring that they're ascribed to the Imperium. Especially since, in my opinion anyway for whatever that's worth, they'd fit better with the Craftworld Aeldar, or maybe the T'au, or maybe even the Necrons. I certainly think that Twice-Dead King went in a similar direction and pulled off the execution much better.