I have been lurking for quite some time and figured it was about time to say hello.
I'm old, 68, have been to sea, lived for 20 yrs in a commune, harder than you might think, and have done dhit sorta like seasteading.
now, i live on a big lake in BC, and am electrifying my bike and my canoe. And raising chickens. This is a small part of what I think about seasteading. I have a LOT of notes.
I figure to avoid political difficulties you would have to go to a deep sea location. Houseboating is attractive but it isn't seasteading, that word implies integration with the sea environment, and for there to be any kind of continuity the community would of neccessity be intentional rather than ad hoc. Intentional community is a difficult enough endeavor on dry land where the forms and rules have had a long time to grow. Setting up a community of even 20 people in some kind of a floating ersatz, modern day commune in say one of BC's many inlets would be immediatly percieved by native people as a take over of their turf. Rightly so, and the government would back them to the hilt. Commercial ventures like fishfarms might , and have, got much further.
So in a deep sea space I would first very thoroughly examine the means by which other creatures manage to survive there.
Birds are the ones we easily observe at sea. The sprightly Petrels, so light they bob right on top of the breakers, then leaping up into the wind to be carried effortlessly away to another place. They carry no baggage. Nor does anyone else out there, but us emulating the petrel would be a square peg situation from the begining. Now the majority of the rest of the bird world out there are master soaring animals. The wind seldom drops to zero at sea, though I recall the sargaso as windless. There was still enough for the flying fish to get a hundred yards from a jump. So some kind of kiting might have some merrit in some situations. Kiting under full out oceanic storm conditions would certainly be an adrenaline inducing way of life though. Penguins I will return to latter.
The fish have lessons for us in the realms of adjustable buoyancy, oxygen extraction, and most certainly regarding hydrodynamics. A certain amount of finning through a new garden of life has it's appeal, but a fulltime fishlike existance, I don't think so.
I think I'm a surface creature. Like a seal or a penguin only more so, they haul out of the water for various reasons and probably enjoy it. A seal is more like me, the penguin flying through the water. Seals, upright in the water seem to have the art of tweaking neutral buoyacy down to a fine art. I have watched them in the face of 40 foot rollers near tofino. They have no problems whatsoever rising high up the wave then submerging below the crest and passing onto the backside to wait languidly for the next. No wave is too big and they don't even seem to LOOK at them, just allow them to slide up behind, and they KNOW if a little more ballast is needed for this one, they can pass 10 feet below the crest of a monster wave with perfect equanimity. It's said there are 100 foot waves out there and I believe it. I think a seal would handle them just fine. Near neutral and adjustable bouyancy I believe is a core tenet of long term survival, for us, on the high seas
The canadian coast guard has medium sized ships that are able to handle anything out there they say. Even to the extent of being able to roll right over and bob back up to the surface. I believe they are rather expensive, a refined survival trait though, eh?
Consider a number of interconnected dwelling and infrastructure spaces, each 20 feet in diameter ( for convenience) with a dome or hexagonal shaped top, for structural strength (ferrocement). The actual outside shape of the top is malleable to purpose, platform, breakwater, whatever. The bottom floor,(could scale for more than one) FLOATS. The structure is ballasted from below by easily releasable, or extendable cable (for wave damping and ultimately, safety), to atain close to neutral buoyancy, where the top of the structure is normaly a little above the surface. (to reduce wind push OR NOT) The buoyancy of the structure is managed by the addition and exhaustion of compressed air about a norm of neutral buoyancy. A submarine style sealing hatch near the top is necessitated for normal traffic (i suppose, at this stage). Expensive probably. The space can be exited if underwater by swimming down the watercolumn inside the cylinder, below the floating floor if desired. I think contemplating "seasteading" without taking being IN the sea a lot is absurd, think about it.
This dwelling and infrastructure space is to be maintained at near neutral buoyancy for safety from the waves. It could be enginered to descend to some prescribed depth in extremis, in which case it would be quite protected from wave action which seems to be the shibboleth of most of those who have studied seasteading. I haven't quite got the figures yet but I'm pretty sure 2 to 4 atmospheres is safe for humans and doesn't require decompression techniques. that's 33 feet to 130 odd feet below the waves. Far enough to be immune from wave effects. I would guess staying at the lower limits of this range for long would require decompression but you would only be doing that in extremis.
In the community circumstance, I visualise a semicircle or V of these structures upstream of a floating maricultue/aquaculture/ even some forms of agriculture projects. Solar panels if that's thought to be the best energy system. I would rely more on wind and wave action myself,(simple mechanics as opposed to hitec) tide if I had something to anchor to, though I doubt there is much tide rise far out to sea. Solar for lights. If the xcultural modules are in themselves seaworthy, structuraly designed for their environment, and battening protocols are in place there should be few losses.
It is inevitable that some land based things would just be taken for granted and tag along with us, I don't think the alfalfa sprout sandwich will disapear soon. I do think however that the less conventional land based thinking that goes into planning and designing a seastead the better. A thorough examination of the traditional ways of the junk people (name?)of the south china sea would be informative, though they were primarily traders, smugglers etc I believe, I'm sure they had many traditions that would be invaluable to know. Probably a prospective seasteader should cultivate a liking for seaweed, fish, mussels, all other forms of seafood, and likely milk fattened seagull as well.
It would be futile to attempt to grow enough land based food out there to be sustainable. Why bother if you have a 6 month backlog of dried smoked sea cucumber muscle, (beche de mere?) and home grown abalone to trade, when you are drifting right by china and japan in the north pacific gyre anyway. I'm sure something else could be aranged for the california, British columbia end of the yearly loop. Likely word would get around and visitors would show up and want some little souvenir to mark their visit. A spidery crab exoskeleton from 8000 feet down say, something not to be found at the mall.
Realisticaly, information is the cleanest thing to sell. (and fertility enhancing goods are the intelligent things to buy) The ability to survive out there, that's information and it's valuable. If you could offer accomodations, transport, communications, etc for reasonable pricing, a world of grad students and their profs would be at your doorstep. Step it up a notch and another world of seasteading "students" would appear. The flight to Hong kong and the lengthy sail to intersect you would be part of the appeal, and in reality would put the whole thing in its true perspective. A world class hoot. thanx 4 listnin