r/23andme • u/hueyslaw • Nov 12 '25
Question / Help why do a lot of black americans assume ALL white dna is from slavery?
before you get your pitchforks out i’m not denying the non-consensual events that happened. but people don’t consider how admixture works or what a dna test can tell you .
let’s say we have two people with 25% euro and the rest african. person A has different percentages spread across different european regions (7% for scotland, 7% for germany, 7% wales, 4% norway). person B has all 25% euro from germany. while both individuals have the same euro% in total, test indicates that one has a direct white grandparent.
slavery was abolished in 1865 (or 1863 in the confederate states). if the “ALL of their white dna is from rąpe” argument were to be made….then that would most likely be the case for person A more than person B (given that person Bs grandparent was born in the 1920s-1940s).
now let’s take someone that has 50% or 60% euro and the rest african. if you don’t have a “white parent” but your dna totals up to that amount of euro…
could it also be possible that their parents married generational biracials after 1863/65? or had people who descended from free blacks (who often married other free blacks who were 60% white or so)? instead of “ALL white dna is from rąpe”
does someone like angela davis (two white grandparents) or vanessa williams (quadroon dad and mixed mom) not exist?
why does someone need to be one white parent to be mixed or for the identify to be “valid” to african americans? and why get mad at someone who identifies as mixed if they have similar mixture without a “white parent”?
ps: i’m aware all the people i named identify as black. that’s not what i’m arguing against. i’m saying it doesn’t make sense to say “ALL white dna is from rąpe” when there are some descending from mixed race communities (like lumbees or creoles). this specifically applies to black americans with 30%+ nonblack dna