r/23andme • • Nov 12 '25

Question / Help why do a lot of black americans assume ALL white dna is from slavery?

3 Upvotes

before you get your pitchforks out i’m not denying the non-consensual events that happened. but people don’t consider how admixture works or what a dna test can tell you .

let’s say we have two people with 25% euro and the rest african. person A has different percentages spread across different european regions (7% for scotland, 7% for germany, 7% wales, 4% norway). person B has all 25% euro from germany. while both individuals have the same euro% in total, test indicates that one has a direct white grandparent.

slavery was abolished in 1865 (or 1863 in the confederate states). if the “ALL of their white dna is from rąpe” argument were to be made….then that would most likely be the case for person A more than person B (given that person Bs grandparent was born in the 1920s-1940s).

now let’s take someone that has 50% or 60% euro and the rest african. if you don’t have a “white parent” but your dna totals up to that amount of euro…

could it also be possible that their parents married generational biracials after 1863/65? or had people who descended from free blacks (who often married other free blacks who were 60% white or so)? instead of “ALL white dna is from rąpe”

does someone like angela davis (two white grandparents) or vanessa williams (quadroon dad and mixed mom) not exist?

why does someone need to be one white parent to be mixed or for the identify to be “valid” to african americans? and why get mad at someone who identifies as mixed if they have similar mixture without a “white parent”?

ps: i’m aware all the people i named identify as black. that’s not what i’m arguing against. i’m saying it doesn’t make sense to say “ALL white dna is from rąpe” when there are some descending from mixed race communities (like lumbees or creoles). this specifically applies to black americans with 30%+ nonblack dna


r/23andme • • May 10 '22

Discussion Does having African ancestry equates to being athletic? Everyone in my gym says being black helps.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Mar 27 '25

Results 99.7% purebreed european

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Not too suprised, trace DNA is Northern Indian & Pakistani.


r/23andme • • Mar 13 '24

Results American of colonizer descent

Post image
0 Upvotes

I found out the Dudley family came from Dudley, UK and in 1553 tried to put Jane Dudley (maiden Grey) on the throne, but got couped after 9 days, and then beheaded 😬 Family largely fell out of favor and emigrated to the colonies. I still have the surname!

They had a couple Spanish ancestors in the late 1300s from a noble family called the House of Ayala. Would this be the 0.5% Spanish, because I don’t know of any other Spanish ancestors of mine. Pretty cool family story though.


r/23andme • • Jan 10 '24

Family Problems/Discovery Our Family Shattered Under the Results of 23andMe

1 Upvotes

I know that everyone is curious about their genealogy and it seems a harmless (and could be useful in the case of genetic health issues) test - but it's also important to remember that DNA testing can unearth family secrets that it serves no one to unearth.

I saw this in my family when a niece did a 23andMe and found out her father was not her bio-father. The mom was shocked although she had been having an affair, she had made made a conscious decision to end it because she wanted a stable family for her child. She had no idea that she was pregnant with the other person's child. She was deeply in love with the man, but refused to break up the marriage over it.

Forty-five years later, the child found out with 23andMe. Mom was in shock at first, but told the daughter that she would tell her anything she wanted to know and encouraged her to reach out to this man. (The father who raised her (and was a great dad) had passed 20 years before.) Unfortunately, the bio-dad had become an alcoholic and died shortly after they connected.

The daughter has now cut the mother off and hasn't spoken to her in five years. The mother is heartbroken, but understands her daughter's anger and has said: "I have it coming...it's my punishment." She is 73 now and this was her only child.

Long story - but just to say - running out and getting a DNA test and then sharing the news in it indiscriminately can backfire. - badly. The story above isn't the only story I've heard of these tests shattering families. As I said, it's one thing if it's for a genetic/health reason that you need to understand a health history.

But maybe some secrets just need to be secrets. My sister will never be the same - she's old and she's now lost the people she loved the most through her own fault - as she says. But, I have to remind her that she's human and humans make mistakes. At this point, it makes little difference.

Just think carefully and wisely if you get a result back that is shocking, surprising, not what you expected. There can be more at stake here than your curiosity.


r/23andme • • Oct 10 '24

Discussion The “Ashkenazi” category doesn’t make any sense.

9 Upvotes

I understand that the category is supposed to be an all in one bundle baking in all the components us Ashkenazim are mixed with, but that’s the thing, Ashkenazi is in and of itself an inherently mixed MGM ethnicity, akin to Mestizo Latinos and Romani and the like (though not really mixed race like the latter two are aside from our minuscule Asian admixture).

Even with the bottleneck cutting down our gene pool and making us more homogenous, that gene pool itself is still incredibly ethnically diverse, as the Ashkenazi ethnicity is comprised of multiple ethnicities (Israelite, Italian, Greek, North African, French, German, Slavic, and Turkic/Central/North/East Asian) coming together to form a singular one. It’s why even with our bottlenecked gene pool you can still get full siblings in any one 100% Ashkenazi family ranging from Mediterranean/Southern European looking, to MENA looking, Nordic/Slavic looking, Western European looking, and some even outright mixed race Hapa or Quapa leaning! (Hi Joseph-Gordon Leavitt and Ezra Miller lol)

From what I know of genetics you only inherit 50% of your parents DNA, so if your parents are mixed with multiple ethnicities and are from an MGM ethnicity like Ashkenazi, it’s entirely possible for one Ashkenazi to have completely different ethnic components from another, hence the range of phenotypical diversity within our population. While the odds are low, one Ashkenazi could theoretically come out as 100% European (if they inherited each whole 50% European DNA portion from both parents) while the other 100% Israelite because they just so happened to inherit only the Israelite portion of both parents DNA, and both could very well be full siblings.

Because of this I don’t understand how you can even make and detect an inherently “Ashkenazi” category and just group everyone of this ethnicity under it, when the ethnicity to start out with will already be carrying different percentages of their components and one Ashkenazi’s ethnicity inheritance will look different from the next one’s. Singular categories like this should only really work for non mixed ethnicities such as the Irish or Han Chinese - because the entire gene pool will always be genetically identical due to only being compromised of a homogenous singular ethnicity rather than multiple, so everyone will have the same amount of that ethnicity if they’re fully Irish or Chinese or what-not as there would be nothing else to inherit from the genepool.

I guess what I’m asking is how exactly do they detect specific Ashkenazi markers to group together the whole Ashkenazi population into one singular “Ashkenazi” category when Ashkenazi itself is an inherently mixed ethnicity and no two Ashkenazi’s will have the exact same ethnic inheritance percentages? Are they just able to group us all into one category without breaking down our components because unlike other ethnicities they group us together by shared genetic relatedness rather than ethnic relatedness, and that’s what they mean when they say the Ashkenazi Bottleneck makes it easier to group us all into one big Ashkenazi category?

In other words is 23andMe and AncestryDNA simply classifying us on the fact that all Ashkenazim are essentially fifth to tenth cousins and the category is more a familial category rather than an actual ethnic one? Even then that doesn’t make much sense because you still share less than 1% DNA on average with a fifth cousin, and we’ve already established that with an already inherently mixed ethnicity like Ashkenazi it’s very likely that two fifth cousins will have an entirely different ethnic DNA composition, so how would they even be able to tell we’re all related enough to form an entire category out of it when the familial DNA linking the ethnicity is still less than 1% even with the bottleneck?

Am I missing something here? Cause the Math ain’t Mathing…


r/23andme • • Apr 13 '24

Question / Help If you’re trans will 23andme show you as your birth sex to your dna relatives?

2 Upvotes

Ex. If you have a sibling that has also taken the test and you’re a trans man (female to male) will you show up as that sibling’s sister even though 23andme allows you to customize your gender?


r/23andme • • Nov 08 '24

Results I'm just a white mutt. Nothing special.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Oct 09 '24

Question / Help arent jews and arabs lowkey the same?

10 Upvotes

especially palestinians and jews, genuine question


r/23andme • • Dec 08 '23

Discussion Single digit African ancestry ≠ “mixed”

97 Upvotes

I am so tired of seeing some people act like there wasn’t transatlantic slave trade that contributes to their .6 or 3% African ancestry. Maybe I am a hater as an African woman, but seeing some of y’all dang near call yourselves “mixed” from 2% African dna is so funny lol


r/23andme • • May 25 '25

Results How are west africans related to other human populations if they have 2 - 19% of dna from an unknown species?

0 Upvotes

There was a study which claimed africans, specifically West africans, have 2 - 19% of dna from an unknown species that predates the human Neanderthal split. But if you look at PCAs or other graphs of human populations, west africans dont seem that genetically distant from other humans, including other sub saharan africans.

How can they have this significant genetic component but its not obvious from genetic tools?


r/23andme • • Sep 13 '25

Discussion 23andme should be working to remove Native American from East Asian categories and improving their Indigenous American Samples

0 Upvotes

Contrary to what you may be led to believe, indigenous Americans are not related to modern East Asian people, and are actually about equidistant between Chinese people and Northern Europeans. Regardless they are not related to either.

Adding them together is not only misleading, it could be politically motivated.

No other DNA testing company does this and it seems like ethnic erasure. And any DNA test that cannot tell any indigenous new worlder from an East Asian sample is less than useless for these groups.

To this day indigenous Canadians score Manchurian ancestry on 23andme despite the fact that they are not related at all, their nearest genetic link is before the neolithic period.


r/23andme • • Oct 01 '26

Results Miranda Cosgrove's 23&Me results

Post image
55 Upvotes

iCarly star Miranda Cosgrove's unique 23&Me results... 😮

In the video, she claims she just discovered she's part Mexican, and a third Jewish...

How could someone discover THAT much of their ancestry in their 30s? It just doesn't make sense to me... Did her parents never discuss their ethnicity or grandparents' ethnic/cultural backgrounds with her? It doesn't make sense. How could someone be so out of touch with their own heritage?


r/23andme • • Oct 09 '24

Discussion Who has more European dna Arabs, black Americans, Asians or Indians?

0 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Jan 16 '24

Results Palestinian DNA

Thumbnail
gallery
83 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Jan 16 '26

Results Finally 20% European!!! I told everyone!!

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Feb 22 '23

Discussion West Eurasian people

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Oct 01 '24

Discussion Why Northern Africans considered “white” in the us census although black Americans have much more European admixture?

0 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Jan 22 '25

Results Can we stop policing people's perceived looks/phenotype?

0 Upvotes

Someone reached out to me and commented that I'm "Chinese looking". This was after one of those threads asking others to share our pictures and have others guess our ancestries.

While I agree with it in general, I have shared that locals in countries such as Thailand, Myanmar, Indonesia and the Philippines have mistaken me for a local. When I was in Perth, I was mistaken by an Aussie PR as someone who grew up in Australia because I could switch accents.

Yes, most of my ancestors are from southern China Guangdong/Canton Province to be exact. I've been to my ancestral village. Due to my overall package, I don't look like I belong.

I wish people who don't understand people who look different from their assigned "ethnic group(s)" would stop telling me how we should identify. It would be nice if others could stop undermining our feelings or our experiences.

Do note that I have no issues with the public comments if the Redditor decides I'm "Chinese looking" as I knew that was for fun.

Edited for clarity.


r/23andme • • Apr 29 '26

Discussion Do most Latinos think their European ancestry came from colonization?

9 Upvotes

I get that obviously colonization played a huge part in it, but also there were other European immigrants that came after the colonial era. Not to mention most of Latino countries were not majority mestizo/mixed during their colonial era. Mexico’s population for example was around 60% native, 30% Spanish, and less than 10% mestizo during the colonial era. And in Colombia, Venezuela and other South American countries the 3 main groups were natives, Spaniards and Africans. Spanish men had non consensual relationships with native women during the colonial period but that makes a small percentage of our ancestry because they didn’t out number them. It’s very different from African Americans because almost all their European ancestry came from slavery. Most Latinos European ancestry came after the colonial era. During Spanish rule native people lived in small towns outside cities where European lived, these were call republicas de Indios. After independence the government took their lands and made them live in the city with Europeans and this lead to the mixed race population to increase in Latin American countries. Plus many non Spanish and Portuguese European immigrants came to Latin America after independence like in Brazil, Argentina and Cuba.


r/23andme • • Mar 30 '24

Question / Help Are Palestinian Christians more native to the levant than the Muslim counterparts???

0 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Sep 30 '26

Discussion Is the Black Irish appearance present in English populations?

0 Upvotes

I recently learned from my Grandpa that his Dad had jet black hair. I have taken a DNA test, and 0% Irish shows up. The other I thought could be possible is Native American ancestors, but I had no Native show up on my test either.

The reason I am confused is because if I am correct, we though that my G-G-G-Grandparent was actually a second marriage, and on documents I found out that their last name was Gallagher, which I looked into and should be from West Ireland where the Black Irish commonly live.

My Grandpa has super red hair, but I heard it's somehow kinda common for Black Irish to have a ginger child. Also, on my Grandpa's Mom's side, for some reason, during somewhere around the late 1700's, throughout all the 1800's all the Women on my paper trail are gone and I can't find out who they are. They would have been around SC, AR, TN, MS, or AL, but idk where at the time. I can confirm that one during like the 1850's had a second wife, and the first wife is completely invisible.

What do you guys think?


r/23andme • • Jan 11 '26

Discussion Ethiopians are genetically closer to North Europeans than to Yoruba Nigerians

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/23andme • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion Why do so many people in the US seem to think their dumb US census based categorizations (black, white, Asian, LatinX or whatever you wanna call it), somehow connect to DNA?

2 Upvotes

Some of them seem to think being categorized as Hispanic or LatinX or black, or white or purple or green is like this form of universal truth that defines your life and your DNA.