r/1Password • u/AganArya007 • Aug 13 '21
[RANT] Whatever people say here, I'd stay with 1Password until the day they gets hacked or greedy.
As the title says, even after a week full of outrage here on this subreddit, I'd stay, at least until the day they become so greedy they charge you 100 dollars per year, or finally gets hacked. This is purely because I've tried almost all password managers listed on the first page of alternative.to (even the dreaded LastPass) and none of them come close to how smoothly 1Password operates, from editing to syncing to autofilling.
And no, I'm not even concerned about the Electron on the version 8. Why? Because after trying it out, on my hackintosh Core i3 Haswell dual core, which is really slow by today's standard, I feel no difference at all in terms of performance. So all the outrage about increased ram by just mere 100 mbs or even less, or just like 4 percent cpu on idle... I don't know man... Are you guys insane? Are many redditors are this insane? Are the geeks are just so snob like that?
Of course, the early access is not without issues. But guys, this is early access! And the issues I've encountered are quite minor, but I do hope it will be fixed: 1. No advanced search a-la native Mac or on Windows with tag: or other strings 2. favicon loading a bit slow when first opening the app 3.no custom favicon editing 4. Maybe needs more polishing but well, so far so good.
But in terms of usability and performance, guys, there's nothing wrong about it, and I even prefer the new Watchtower than the old one on 1Password 7. And call me an idiot, but, even though it's Electron, IT LOOKS MORE NATIVE WITH TRANSPARENT SIDEBAR AND COMBINED SIDEBAR AND TOP BAR LIKE BIG SUR!!! (AT LAST!) So just fix those three issues, and really guys, this feels just like the native one.
And here's the funny thing.... NO ONE GETS THIS MAD ABOUT EARLY ACCESS ON WINDOWS. If going Electron means Windows WON'T BE THE SECOND CLASS CITIZEN AGAIN, then I'm in! I also have a Windows device besides mac, so you guys Mac snobs, please, be more rational. YOU'RE NOT THE ONLY ONE IN THIS WORLD, AND I HAVE THREE GODDAMN APPLE DEVICES ANYWAY. Gosh...
There's also the outrage about subscription only thingy. Well, to be honest, I'd rather 1Password have all the money they need and some more but still focus on our security, than being cheap and ended up offering subpar security. And it's really cheap anyway. 500,000 rupiah in my country in Indonesia, and that's like 10 times drinking fancy Starbucks! And I drink 100 cups of Starbucks every year, I can drink 10 cups less for this software!
And about the security, with local vault being deprecated and no more syncing to other cloud services. Local? Yeah, you're more in control. But you can only do so much by managing it locally. You lose your device? That's it. Your house burnt down? That's it. And then what? Yes, you can choose your own cloud service, but then you just end up putting it on the internet anyway, and then it still can get hacked, maybe even more prone to get hacked because they're... well.. cloud storage, not a place only focused on storing password like 1Password's own server. And they even now have announced the support for hosting your own server in the future. So, I don't know guys. I'm a man who's paranoid about my Macbook being scratched even just a tiny bit, but I've never been this irrational. And more importantly, none of my accounts have ever got hacked.
So, yeah, I'd stay, and I hope you guys will be more supportive by providing useful feedbacks instead of simply just being mad without any GOOD REASONS. And yes, once again, no one gets mad about the Windows one, and the Mac one, while still lacking in some features and needs more polishing, isn't that much different than the native one.
Yeah. That's all. Sorry for my rant. Thank you.
TLDR; I'd stay with 1Password, no matter what people say about 1Password 8.