r/1Password • • Aug 13 '21

[RANT] Whatever people say here, I'd stay with 1Password until the day they gets hacked or greedy.

1 Upvotes

As the title says, even after a week full of outrage here on this subreddit, I'd stay, at least until the day they become so greedy they charge you 100 dollars per year, or finally gets hacked. This is purely because I've tried almost all password managers listed on the first page of alternative.to (even the dreaded LastPass) and none of them come close to how smoothly 1Password operates, from editing to syncing to autofilling.

And no, I'm not even concerned about the Electron on the version 8. Why? Because after trying it out, on my hackintosh Core i3 Haswell dual core, which is really slow by today's standard, I feel no difference at all in terms of performance. So all the outrage about increased ram by just mere 100 mbs or even less, or just like 4 percent cpu on idle... I don't know man... Are you guys insane? Are many redditors are this insane? Are the geeks are just so snob like that?

Of course, the early access is not without issues. But guys, this is early access! And the issues I've encountered are quite minor, but I do hope it will be fixed: 1. No advanced search a-la native Mac or on Windows with tag: or other strings 2. favicon loading a bit slow when first opening the app 3.no custom favicon editing 4. Maybe needs more polishing but well, so far so good.

But in terms of usability and performance, guys, there's nothing wrong about it, and I even prefer the new Watchtower than the old one on 1Password 7. And call me an idiot, but, even though it's Electron, IT LOOKS MORE NATIVE WITH TRANSPARENT SIDEBAR AND COMBINED SIDEBAR AND TOP BAR LIKE BIG SUR!!! (AT LAST!) So just fix those three issues, and really guys, this feels just like the native one.

And here's the funny thing.... NO ONE GETS THIS MAD ABOUT EARLY ACCESS ON WINDOWS. If going Electron means Windows WON'T BE THE SECOND CLASS CITIZEN AGAIN, then I'm in! I also have a Windows device besides mac, so you guys Mac snobs, please, be more rational. YOU'RE NOT THE ONLY ONE IN THIS WORLD, AND I HAVE THREE GODDAMN APPLE DEVICES ANYWAY. Gosh...

There's also the outrage about subscription only thingy. Well, to be honest, I'd rather 1Password have all the money they need and some more but still focus on our security, than being cheap and ended up offering subpar security. And it's really cheap anyway. 500,000 rupiah in my country in Indonesia, and that's like 10 times drinking fancy Starbucks! And I drink 100 cups of Starbucks every year, I can drink 10 cups less for this software!

And about the security, with local vault being deprecated and no more syncing to other cloud services. Local? Yeah, you're more in control. But you can only do so much by managing it locally. You lose your device? That's it. Your house burnt down? That's it. And then what? Yes, you can choose your own cloud service, but then you just end up putting it on the internet anyway, and then it still can get hacked, maybe even more prone to get hacked because they're... well.. cloud storage, not a place only focused on storing password like 1Password's own server. And they even now have announced the support for hosting your own server in the future. So, I don't know guys. I'm a man who's paranoid about my Macbook being scratched even just a tiny bit, but I've never been this irrational. And more importantly, none of my accounts have ever got hacked.

So, yeah, I'd stay, and I hope you guys will be more supportive by providing useful feedbacks instead of simply just being mad without any GOOD REASONS. And yes, once again, no one gets mad about the Windows one, and the Mac one, while still lacking in some features and needs more polishing, isn't that much different than the native one.

Yeah. That's all. Sorry for my rant. Thank you.

TLDR; I'd stay with 1Password, no matter what people say about 1Password 8.


r/1Password • • Oct 02 '26

Browser Extension 1Password 7.10.4 removes support for the 1Password Classic extension

Post image
0 Upvotes

“Removes support for the 1Password Classic extension.”
→ No thank you.

I understand that software evolves and that old components eventually have to be deprecated. But I don’t really understand the decision to actively remove support for something that is still working.

If I have a perfectly functional installation of 1Password, why should a software update make part of that setup stop working?

It feels particularly frustrating when an update doesn’t fix a security issue or a technical limitation, but instead removes functionality from an otherwise working system.

I would much rather see the Classic extension remain available for existing installations, even if it is no longer actively developed or officially supported.

Please let working software keep working.

There is something fundamentally uncomfortable about installing an update and discovering afterwards that something which worked perfectly before has been deliberately disabled.

Release notes:
https://app-updates.agilebits.com/product_history/OPM7


r/1Password • • Oct 07 '21

Since AgileBit clearly doesn't care about Mac users, what are some good alternatives?

0 Upvotes

Looks like they're sticking with the Proton crap so I won't be renewing my account next year. I may just stick with iCloud's password management now that it has 2FA. I was using 1Password over iCloud because of the great user experience, but clearly they don't give a damn about that anymore. What are the other alternatives?


r/1Password • • Jan 08 '26

Discussion Do you lose any sleep that your device and correspondingly your 1P account will be compromised?

1 Upvotes

I admit this isn't some amazing thread but every so often, usually at 2 am ;), I do think about it.

Obviously the repercussions of having a 'bad actor' being able to access directly ones 1P account (most likely via malware?), would be ruinous to myself; to any individual who relies completely on 1P.

I know one often reads something to the effect "don't click on any sketchy links" or "don't open that attachment" etc. etc. but of course any of such an event can happen to anyone, unknowingly.

(I have "enhanced protection" selected for all chrome devices and Bitdefender Total Security installed but still I worry sometimes.)

EDIT: I have 2 yubikeys (+ an authenticator) for 2FA for the account but as I understand it "all bets are off" if there is malware on one's device?


r/1Password • • Mar 25 '24

Discussion Just make it work like v7 again

7 Upvotes

Perhaps this is overly broad, but I continue to find that v8 simply doesn't work as well as version 7. I'm not talking about the subscription/account side of things — another conversation — but rather for simple everyday workflows. I don't have full screencasts, but here are a few of the most common workflows I face everyday that still feel worse in v8.

  • Auto-filling a password on a website via keyboard shortcut

  • Quickly generating a strong password

  • Saving a first-time login from a new website

  • Viewing or copying the password for a saved entry (the Option key to quickly reveal)

  • Creating a new password for an existing entry

  • Installing or updating the browser extension

And before you share "you're doing it wrong" or "it's more secure now" just take a moment to think about how these features have changed and how many clicks it takes to do the basics.

Now that I'm a lifetime subscriber, I look forward to the new versions feeling more like the old versions.


r/1Password • • Mar 27 '19

1Password advocate since 2010... time to switch?

2 Upvotes

Hello fellow redditors. I purchased my first license of 1Password in April of 2010 and have been an advocate ever since. I have advised family, friends, and coworkers to use 1password as the go to PW manager. It saved me on numerous occasions first of which comes to mind was after i had to change 100+ passwords due to the 'LeakedIn' compromise. yep, i was using the same password on all my 'not quite junk but not a bank' sites. 1password's credential generator + formfill make updating them a breeze. I'm am also an early adopter of new authentication technologies so was excited to hear when 1Password as going to release support for FIDO tokens a couple years back but this was also the beginning of the end for me... The new subscription model... dun dun duuuun. Yep, i have an allergic reaction to subscription models. I get why SW companies need this reoccurring revenue but at this point, i was at least $100 invested into the SW and the math for paying for the next 10 years was rather ugly. luckily, Agilebits did support the legacy 4.6 version without re-occurring payments which allowed me to keep the existing product but without the new fancy features. All this considered, in recent reviews of PW management products I've conducted, 1password has fallen from grace and I no longer recommend it. I do still use it myself, or at least until today. Today I will be seeking out a new PW manager. I've gone the last few weeks without chrome browser extension support on multiple computers and find my self typing 20 digit symbol/alphanumeric characters from my phone into the browser and i've apparently hit my 'screw this' level. I'm sure the problem is that chrome has updated their browser and consequently broken the 1password extension and i'm sure it's on Agilebits backlog to fix it but I realize my previously amazing PW manager is on life support and its time for me to pull the plug. Truly a sad day for me. I say all this so Agilebits might understand the consumer's side of the story and how they lose the faith of reliable fans. Thanks again Agilebits for creating what was once such a beloved product.

Cheers,

Manbearbull

Edit: thanks everyone for the debate and info. I’ve been informed I can upgrade under the old ‘pay once for the new features’ model all managed locally. I’m happy to see Agilebits enable this method and hope they consider keeping for future updates. Thanks again.


r/1Password • • Feb 08 '24

Discussion I have used this version of 1Password. I bough it many 11 years ago since this app is one time purchase. Is there any reason I need to move to the new Subscription version and pay monthly?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/1Password • • Mar 14 '24

Discussion 1Password 8 experience

0 Upvotes

I’m still on 1Password 7 for iOS and the browser extension on Windows PC. I held off on switching to 8 because it had really bad reviews and users reporting issues.

Checking in again to determine if I should switch now. I looked at most recent iOS reviews and it doesn’t paint a pretty picture, but I know reviews can be biased towards negativity.

Anyone have thoughts on 7 vs 8 and if 8 has been going smoothly for them? I’m fine with holding off longer if the app needs to bake longer, but would prefer being on the latest version of tech that is supported.


r/1Password • • Aug 22 '24

Discussion 1Password <---> Apple Password App. AUDIT FEATURE

0 Upvotes

For those of us that have been with 1PW since the beginning of time and have no plans to rely solely on the integrated Apple Password app/keychain it's just never going to be the case that using both of them (which is difficult NOT to do as it is now) we need a failsafe way of keeping the two password repositories in sync. Export/Import is not enough.

I'm afraid the effort to get the two authentication tracking methods to coexist peacefully will be up to the 1Password developers because Apple most certainly won't be falling all over itself to do it.

As it is now I spend lots of really wasteful time making sure the 2 databases are in sync. That's not sustainable and it needs to be. Trying to have the two methods sync up during a change is awkward, stressful, and full of peril.


r/1Password • • Dec 30 '21

Nag screen pushing subscription

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/1Password • • Feb 10 '22

Why I'm leaving 1Password and returning to Bitwarden

11 Upvotes

The website form wouldn't let me submit this on the "delete your account" page, so I thought I would send it here.

I was all in for 1password, but there are so many issues that made me start to hate the service.

  • Why can family members delete accounts of the other people in the family, without them getting ANY warning/chance to recover the data?

  • Why is there no good method of allowing emergency access to a vault?

  • Why is my account password stored in my vault by default, which is a HUGE security flaw?

  • Why can I not "autofill and save" like Bitwarden?

  • Why can I not edit accounts in the web extension?

  • Why is your site matching so legitimately terrible

  • Why are 3rd party apps not supported in 1p8?

Your UI is great, your macOS devs are great, get your act together on shitty security features and on the backend. I would love to stick with 1password, but I just can't find myself dealing with all of these glaring issues that make dealing with your product so miserable. I'll be happily returning to Bitwarden, and I hope I can reconsider in the future.


r/1Password • • Jun 22 '22

why doesn't this damn app auto update or send us to the page to get the update?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/1Password • • Oct 06 '25

Feature Request Shared vaults between paying 1Password users

0 Upvotes

I am pretty much at this point demanding that you enable unlimited vault sharing from a paying 1Password user to others allowing the sharing of details with external parties. It encourages others to register with 1Password to access the information and eases them hopefully into paying customers.

However, crippling you paying customers is a terrible practice and quite frankly very frustrating as I need to jump through hoops to manage sharing different pieces of confidential information with various external parties as 'guests'.


r/1Password • • May 25 '22

Is it just me or does it seem that 1Password gets worse with every update?

1 Upvotes

I'm a long timer user of 1Password, at least 5 years, I think. It seems like it use to just work without any problems. Now it never works and gets worse every time they update. 1Password 8 doesn't really work at all for me. It's really frustrating.


r/1Password • • Oct 28 '25

Discussion No Black Friday love for existing users?

2 Upvotes

I've got a family plan and thought I would go see if there were any Black Friday deals going on just to find that only new accounts are feeling the love.

It doesn't even need to be half off but something for your existing users that says "Hey guys, we see you and thanks!" would be nice.


r/1Password • • Jan 15 '25

Discussion No easy way to contact support? Why should I keep paying for 1password

5 Upvotes

The 1Password website has taken down contact info for support. Instead it suggests you use the "chatbot" which just redirects you to the support page that suggests using the chatbot. Please remind me why I pay for 1Password instead of migrating to Apple's updated Passwords app?

Edit: Their mobile website is broken and does not in fact have the ability to be contacted to create a ticket. I saw from the desktop website that the possibility does exist to contact them.


r/1Password • • Feb 12 '25

Mac Am I the only one finding 1password becoming unusable?

7 Upvotes

Is anyone else starting to have issues with 1Passwords constantly getting in the way?

I've been using it for 12 years, but it's recently seemed to increasingly play badly with Safari and Arc, the two browsers I work in. I am more often than not having to waste time getting it out of the way, with dumb pop-ups all over the place asking me to do things I just don't want it to do, and then over and over and over again the same bloody pop-ups. A few years back there was seamless integration that just seemed to .. work!

Is this just my setup that's getting janky, or is the good old enshitiffication in action here too now?

For the record, I hate the main app UI redesign brought in a few years ago .. but thats probably just me.


r/1Password • • Apr 23 '25

Discussion Still paying for 1PW to have standalone 7 - where do we go from here?

0 Upvotes

I know many people who are unwilling to move to the 1Password 8 cloud system and it has seemed that after multiple interactions with 1pw support over the years there's no hope in sight to be able to continue on the standalone path. Has anyone else found any reason to hope or are we just moving away to various other options?

It's painful to experience this after having been with 1pw since its early beta days and interacting with Dave directly.


r/1Password • • Nov 21 '18

No Black Friday discount.. :(

0 Upvotes

I was waiting for a black Friday promo code or discount but they're giving away a year to giveaway to families.. What if we don't have a family? Can't we get a discount instead?


r/1Password • • Jul 05 '26

Discussion Moving from Windows and MacOS to Linux

0 Upvotes

Hello, I still have the old free version of 1Password installed on my Windows PC and Mac. In case I move to Linux as my main OS and don’t want to pay for the subscription, what options do I have?


r/1Password • • Apr 22 '25

Announcement 🚀 Big day at 1Password. Three big announcements. One bold vision.

0 Upvotes

Today marks a major milestone in our mission to close the Access-Trust Gap. We're introducing powerful new capabilities to 1Password Extended Access Management, purpose-built Agentic AI security, and a strategic partnership with Drata—all designed to help modern businesses stay secure, compliant, and productive in a world of SaaS sprawl, unmanaged devices, and AI-driven automation.

🔐 1Password Extended Access Management new capabilities

IT and security teams will gain full visibility and control over shadow IT, enforce device health checks for managed and unmanaged devices, and the ability to manage all users, apps, and devices from a unified admin hub. Employees get one-click access to all business apps. It's access the way work really happens.

👉 https://1password.com/press/2025/april/new-extended-access-management-platform-capabilities?utm_medium=social&utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=xam-platform-release&utm_content=launch

🤖 Agentic AI Security is here.

AI agents are the newest members of your workforce. Our Agentic AI capabilities give organizations the foundation to securely develop, adopt, and scale AI agent-driven automation with strong identity, credential, and access controls.

👉 https://1password.com/press/2025/april/agentic-ai?utm_medium=social&utm_source=reddit&utm_content=launch

🤝 1Password + Drata: A unified approach to security and compliance.

We’re partnering with Drata to give companies real-time visibility, device posture enforcement, and automated audit readiness—bringing trust and compliance under one roof.

👉 https://1password.com/press/2025/april/drata-partnership?utm_medium=social&utm_source=threads&utm_campaign=drata-announcement&utm_content=launch

This is a step toward a more secure, productive future—where every identity, app, and device is protected, without getting in the way of getting work done. 🔒🌟


r/1Password • • Jun 21 '25

Discussion bad initial 1password experience

0 Upvotes

I decided to use 1password due to good review in reddit.

I installed the chrome extension on my Brave browser on Windows yesterday.

Things are far from smooth:

  1. first site a tried to register - the password wasn't initially saved. After retrying, it's saved.

  2. I desperately searched for the support email in their support site - couldn't find it.

  3. their support chatbot wasn't showing to me because of Brave's OOTB ad blocker. Took me a long while to figure that out. Also it's not very smart and "forgets" what I say in the same chat.

  4. last but not least: I can't login into the PC app with the secret key and password which are both correct and they worked on my Android app.

am I doing something wrong or is the product flaky?


r/1Password • • Apr 06 '23

Discussion Poor support

1 Upvotes

Is it just me or has support gotten really bad in the last few years? Every time I put in a ticket it is like they didn’t even read it and come back with some tier .5 script and even if you play along, they eventually say they don’t know but will send it up the chain.


r/1Password • • Aug 18 '21

Should I keep 1Password, or switch to Lastpass?

1 Upvotes

I have been using, well kinda using 1Password for about 3 years. The thing is, I never really got it working with all my passwords. The auto-generate feature was not great, it couldn't fulfill the maximum password length requirements that some sites I use had. For example, USAA< my bank. Maybe some others. Once that happened, I kind of quit changing passwords for a while. The other thing I didn't like is that you have to lookup your security key and type in 30 characters to get in the website. It was difficult to change your password and then be able to log in to your AppleTV apps. I have a lot of apps on my tv. For a while now I have just been remembering passwords but it is time I changed some of them. Well last year they added sync with keychain, and I thought that would help but keychain still doesn't exactly work on the Apple TV very well. I don't really use a mac computer, so the new electron app isn't an issue for me, so I'm wondering if I should keep it, or ditch it. Is there a way to keep all my passwords synced between edge, chrome, iPhone, Windows, and Apple TV now? Or should I cancel.

Also, does lastpass need a long security key every time you login?