r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Mar 01 '26
r/1632 • u/DavidThi303 • Dec 31 '25
The CoC are similar to the Nazi Brownshirts Spoiler
The way the CoC operates, especially in Operation Crystalnight, they are similar to the Nazi Brownshirts and the many other examples in history of political militias. In the case of the CoC most of us like what they are accomplishing from sanitation, to freedom of speech & religion, to eliminating conservative vigilantes.
Maybe that’s what it would take at that point in time. But it’s also a dangerous approach because it makes enforcing what one wants via one’s own militia an acceptable approach.
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Nov 26 '25
Any chance on downtimers finding out archeological discoveries of Troy, Mycenaes, Tyrint, Babylon, Hittite civilization, Hurrian kingdom of Mittani, etc.? ESPECIALLY many people, BEFORE 19th & 20th centuries, considered the Hittites and Hurrians merely GLORIFIED fanfiction that's part of Bible!!!
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Mar 20 '26
Is there any Flint’s or other writer’s RoF!novel or Grantville Gazette that has 1630s!Vietnam and conflicts between Nguyen lords and Trinh lords, (especially The Trịnh-Nguyễn War (1627–1673)) and the Kingdom of Champa as main base of plot and Indochinese neighboring states (Cambodia for start)?? Spoiler
r/1632 • u/Ok-Tumbleweed-3147 • Jan 03 '22
Biggest problem in this series
I will say that I love the first few books and the first few anthologies and the gazette. One thing that happens over and over again is how women tend to all be headstrong, stubborn, always right, and fiercely independant. All the men for the most part are stupid, always make dumb decisions, inferior to women and all but a couple are just femine men. That's weird saying about a city that is supposed to take place in west Virginia before ethe ring of fire too.
It just happens over and over and over again. Probably the biggest problem is just lack of failure and the whole state never feels threatened other than the raid in book 1632. David Weber is one of my favorite authors so I love the collab of 1633.
r/1632 • u/marxist-teddybear • Mar 27 '22
why does 1634: the baltic war spend so much time " justifying" a relationship between a 15 year old and a 20 year old? Spoiler
I'm reading 1634: the baltic war and it's pretty good other than the super weird and definitely unnecessary relationship between the daughter of the king of Denmark and an American. I just don't understand why the author goes through such torturous lengths to justify a 20-year-old pursuing a sexual relationship with a 15-year-old. It's extremely uncomfortable and comes across as the author using this as an opportunity to sexualize children. There is absolutely no reason why this relationship needed to be in the book and I am very disturbed by the time dedicated to it. Does anyone know anything about this? How did this get past editors?
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Nov 27 '25
Will New Nippon (Pacific Northwest of America) meet Grantville!uptimers/delegation of USE? What will be downtime!Japanese reactions to Japan Army’s war crimes in WW2; and USA interment of its Japanese-Americans and atomic bombings of Hiroshima & Nagasaki? Reactions to Date Masamune himself?? Spoiler
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Feb 04 '26
Does any Grantville Gazette mention Magdeburg Zoo, with its animal habitants??
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Jan 02 '26
Considering that uptimers and their allies made effort to save 🦤 from extinction in “Second Chance Bird” by Garrett W. Vance, will be there any such attempts for Carolina Parakeet, Kauaʻi ʻōʻō, Thylacine, Steller's sea cow, Californian & Mexican Grizzly Bear, The Elephant Bird, Pyrenean Ibex, etc.?
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Dec 27 '25
Will there be any mention of former Yugoslavia from OTL and its history, ESPECIALLY Sarajevo assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Habsburg (28/6/1914), colapse of Austria -Hungary in 1918, WW2!genocide in Independent State of Croatia (1941-1945), and 1990s!wars??
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Jan 10 '26
Any chance on Habsburgs, especially Spanish branch, realizing dangers of inbreeding by finding out the ultimate fate of King Philip IV’s son Charles II of Spain, THE LAST Habsburg ruler of Spain and its Empire in OTL?
r/1632 • u/[deleted] • Aug 01 '21
Is it inevitable (assuming humanity doesn't wipe itself out) than humanity would become majority left-leaning and Irreligious? That this process would accelerate in 1632 and Alexander Inheritance?
There is this author in the Nonreligious section of Patheos that talks about the long road humanity walked to get to this point (Paraphrasing)
That to get to where we are, Progressives/Left-leaning people had to fight countless battles (not always militarily) to elevate human civilization to our modern sense of peace, prosperity, equality and justice (relative to the past)
In the 1632-series, over THREE HUNDRED years worth of science and progress has been dumped on this Alternate Earth
Slavery and Serfdom are ending centuries earlier. Commoners getting more rights much earlier. Science accelerated
In the Alexander Inheritance, over TWO MILLENIA'S worth of science/truth and humanistic knowledge has been sent back
Going from Iron-Age societies to an 1800s mixed civilizations in just a few years
r/1632 • u/wagner56 • Jan 24 '26
The Nördlinger Ries Impact Crater - mentioned in a documentary - Ancient impact with a German town built in a 16 mile across crater (remains)
Was a 'Perhaps' speculation type show
"NOVA: Asteroids: Spark of Life?" where this was mentioned
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Jan 16 '26
Any chance on downtimers finding out sugar beet as alternative to sugarcane and its use in OTL? If so, will it have effect on stopping transatlantic slave trade, considering that sugar beet can grow in non-tropical climate?
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Jan 01 '26
Will there be any mention of ABBA, Ofra Haza, Modern Talking, Rammstein, Rod Stewart, Tom Jones, The Beatles, Rolling Stones, Queen (ESPECIALLY Freddie Mercury!), Louis Satchmo Armstrong, Elvis Preasley, Sting, etc. and their music ??
r/1632 • u/Major_Pressure3176 • Jan 11 '24
Liking Ram Rebellion, minor quibble
I am liking the short stories and collaboration. I think the other authors help spice up the story. I especially like the stories of Farmer Birdie, Flo, and the ballet company.
There was one line in Oh Ye Saints, however, that rubbed me the wrong way: "...the events of the Book of Mormon are unlikely to happen that way in this timeline...". From the perspective of a believer, the events in the Book of Mormon happened from ~600BC-400AD. They are over and done, and the record already placed.
What annoys me more is that with a simple change, it works: "... The events of the Restoration are unlikely to happen...".
r/1632 • u/[deleted] • Aug 10 '21
I do have to suggest Walt Socha's Crossover Series as novels 1632 fans would enjoy very much
The two books, Conflict and Contact, have a similar premise to 1632 but have a different written style. I bet that many here would enjoy reading those books
-Five Nonreligious Time-travelers from 2016 go back in time to 1054 to help the Native Americans (Can save more people and prevent more suffering than 1632)
-The stories feel more personal and less formulaic. Rather than focused on the grand scheme of things we see the plights of the main characters
-The writing style avoids some of the pitfalls of Flint's novels. Info dump, bland scenery, uninteresting and overload of dialogue, etc.
(Honestly, the premise is pretty much the major reason why any of us read 1632)
-The second novel shows just how religion hurts people and why people that don't believe in dogmatic fairy tales are able to choose the right decision even when it is difficult
(Shows how religion does warp the minds of people)
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Mar 28 '26
Any Grantville Gazette or RoF!novel that has extinction of Aurochs in 1627 as its main plot? Spoiler
r/1632 • u/[deleted] • Jan 28 '22
Spotlight is going to happen very early in both 1632-verse and Alexander Inheritance-verse. Causing a similar trend to today's decline of religion and mistrust of religious authorities
1632-verse journalists and soldiers will find the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant churches raping kids. They would punish the pedophiles and spread news around.
Same with Synagouges and Mosques eroding Islam and Judaism's moral, cultural and legal authority and giving reason to adopt Secularism and Irreligion
The Evangelicals and Mormons in Alexander Inheritance are going to have their own pedophile incidents, its inevitable. They'll try to cover it only to be found out and punished.
New America is going to be very Secular and Irreligious
EDIT: Patheos/OnlySky released an article about how the Catholic Church alone molested FIVE-HUNDRED-THOUSAND KIDS IN FRANCE IN JUST SEVENTY YEARS!!!
Who knows how many kids the various religions have molested THROUGHOUT HISTORY!
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Nov 29 '25
Is there any mention of Romani people/Gypsies in "1632" novels or "Grantville Gazettes" books??
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Nov 25 '25
Any chance of Russians reaching northern borders of China and Manchuria through Siberia in the New Timeline?
r/1632 • u/be_rational_please • Aug 18 '22
We're the female characters in 1632 a bit over the top?
It seemed like the women in the story were almost overpowered. Every time something happened there was another strong female to fix things. I also found it very hard to believe that Rebecca would have been able to do and act like she is portrayed.
Was this because it was in 2000? Was there some need?
r/1632 • u/Agreeable_Acadia9246 • Nov 25 '25



