r/12keys • • May 02 '20

St Augustine ideas. This particular match up seems to be more than a coincidence. What do you think?

205 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Jan 12 '26

San Francisco Unsuccessful dig in SF

Post image
156 Upvotes

Hey all! Figured I would update anyone interested in what happened on our dig date in SF at Portsmouth Square. Considering I'd have posted images the instant we recovered the casque, we were obviously unsuccessful in our attempt.

I really wanted this win for the community, and it took a lot of courage to make the leap from being an armchair seeker to actual BOTG.

The trip itself was an amazing and exciting adventure, and got us off our asses and checking out a new city - just how Byron wanted it to be. And for that, I'm grateful. San Francisco is lovely, and we'll return there again one day (but maybe fly instead of drive lol).

We put about 100 (if not more) prod holes in the place where I thought it would be, and were unsuccessful. Since we only were allowed one dig hole, we chose the best spot (where I initially thought it was based on image clues) and ended up stopping at roots about 6-8 inches down, and had to stop because of the rules (no digging through large roots).

But I tell ya....being there, at that park, and experiencing Chinatown ourselves, I really do feel confident in my solve. I already let the city planner know who I've been in contact with the past several months that we were unsuccessful, and she is going to reach out to the construction company in charge of the park's demo, as they just finalized the bidding process.

I will definitely keep everyone apprised if I hear anything back (we may still luck out?), but I genuinely believe that the SF casque has been lost to history - or under about 15 years of growth from a nearby pine tree - if I'm correct in my solve.

If I'm wrong (and it never was in Portsmouth), then I hope someone else has luck with Golden Gate Park or wherever any seekers think it may be. If its in GGP, it MUST be linked to Chinese, though, and I'm sorry but I still sincerely doubt its there based off information that was leaked.

As for me? I'm still going to continue with solving other cities for The Secret (namely Milwaukee, NO, and NYC), but I don't wish to interact much more with Reddit insofar as direct posts, and I certainly won't use it as a point of reference at all.

There's too much noise and toxicity on here. While meant to serve as a powerful tool to connect others against a singular cause, it's instead been detrimental to solving these.

It also feeds false information to web searches. AI modes such as Google, ChatGPT, etc should be taken with a grain of salt (I never trusted that garbage). Trust but verify. Verify everything without overthinking or trying to squish a square peg into a round hole.

And that's all I can say about it. If anyone dares to gloat that I was wrong, maybe question why you want to turn a community into a "scene".


r/12keys • • May 25 '20

Visited Cleveland earlier this year and had to make a stop to pay my respects. ❤️

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Mar 20 '19

YouTuber Atrocity Guide Raising Awareness to the Cause

Thumbnail
youtube.com
132 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Aug 27 '19

My Boston Solution - Unfortunately it may be too late

106 Upvotes

My solution for Boston finds the casque buried on Andrew Puopolo Park (baseball/softball fields) in Boston's North End. Unfortunately, the city began major renovation of the park in July, and most of Puopolo Park is to be covered in turf. I actually asked for permission to dig from the construction manager on site and was denied. Remarkably, he stated that he had heard about The Secret and was under orders to ship the casque to a location if it were found!

So for what it's worth:

If Thucydides is
North of Xenophon
Take five steps
In the area of his direction:

Yes, Xenophon and Thucydides are found chiseled into the library, which is confirmation that Boston is the right city. The thing that stuck out in these lines to me, however, is the phrasing "in the area of his direction." If BP wanted us to take five step north (or east, south, or west), he would have said "take five steps in his direction," leaving out "area." Therefore, I think that "area of his direction" is the North Area, or North End neighborhood.

A green tower of lights
In the middle section:

We know from Cleveland and Chicago that BP's clues were often quite literal. I believe that the green tower of lights is in fact...a green tower of lights. Puopolo Field along with neighboring Langone Park are comprised of three baseball/softball diamonds. The "middle section" is simply the middle field. There are several tall green towers of lights to light the playing fields, surrounding the park. For reasons below, I think the tower of interest is the one that was by the 3rd base dugout in the middle field.

Near those
Who pass the coliseum
With metal walls

I've seen many great explanations for these lines, most referencing Fenway or the old Garden. However, I wouldn't categorize either as having metal walls. I have two explanations: 1) the coliseum is simply the baseball fields and the metal walls are the 30(?) feet high chain link fence that surrounds the fields on three sides. Definitely metal walls + coliseum. 2) My more imaginative side thinks the metal walls = iron sides = USS Constitution, which is also visible across the Charles River from the park.

Face the water
Your back to the stairs

There actually aren't too many places in Boston where you can see water with your back to stairs. I think the word "stairs" is important. If it were two or three steps (like on the Esplanade), I think BP would have said "Your back to the steps." "Stairs" signifies a more significant elevation gain. Standing on the field (exactly where I'll describe next) and facing the water puts the stairs of Copp's Hill Terrace directly at your back.

Feel at home

This was a tough one, but the image provides a clue. Home as in home plate. Notice that the woman's right and left cuffs on her dress/cloak are significantly different. Her right cuff is very simple, with a an outline of the distinctive shape of home plate on it. Note, also, that many of the outlines on the neck of her dress seem to look a lot like baseball diamonds (basepaths with mound in the middle).

All the letters
Are here to see

This may be a clue that died with time. Across the river, Flagship Wharf condos were built on the Navy Yard since the book was published. Additionally, the Coast Guard building to the east of the fields may have been painted with letters or advertisements (as many brick buildings were at the time) that could have been described as "letters." A final possible explanation is that the USS Constitution often flies nautical flags, similar to the ones found on the woman's sash.

Eighteenth day
Twelfth hour
Lit by lamplight

Seems to be an obvious reference to Revere's April 18th midnight ride. More interesting is that Revere crossed the Charles from the North End to Charlestown, leaving roughly from the area of the park (there are no markers on the North End side, but it's down only slightly from where he is believed to have landed in Charlestown.

In truth, be free.

Still a mystery clue. Many figure that there is some tie to Harvard (Veritas). If so, note that the park's namesake, Andrew Puopolo, was a Harvard student and football player that was killed chasing the thieves of his buddy's wallet. The trial of his alleged murderers resulted in increased racial tensions and was very big news at the time of publishing.

Putting it all together, I think that you stand on home plate, face the water, back to the stairs, and take five steps towards the water, which puts you directly even with the light tower down the 3rd base line of the middle field. Dig away! It would have been an easy place to dig in 1982 (the park is sheltered from the street, field maintenance is regular, and digging in dirt vs. grass is easy to conceal).

Other hints:

  1. . The North End is known for its Italian heritage, which lines up with the Peridot gem. Copp's Hill also has a significant immigration theme.

  2. The star in the image could represent the North Star (North End).

  3. . The woman's face is similar to that of Columbus in the North End's Columbus Park. (Many have pointed this out.)

  4. . The globes in the image look more like Bocce balls; there are two Bocce courts next to the field.

  5. . There was a storage shed with a similar profile to box beneath the falcon, next to the field.

I haven't been past the fields in a couple of weeks. In early August, there was a bulldozer at work, so it may already be too late. I don't think that the construction manager knew exactly what he was looking for, and the bulldozer would plow right through the casque without the operator knowing it, so there's a good chance it's lost for good.

Comments welcome!!


r/12keys • • Apr 11 '22

That is The Secret… Happy Birthday, Byron!

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Dec 31 '20

My quest to visit secret locations brought me to Lafayette Square in New Orleans, hopefully this one gets found some day!

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Oct 27 '20

After seeing last post on Lafayette Square being a possible place for painting 7, I looked on google maps, and seen some things that caught my eye, the boy statue rebalance in the park, and looks like he is reaching for flowers from the painting, don't know if this has been brought up before

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Mar 28 '20

A tribute treasure hunt you can solve from home

81 Upvotes

Bored while sitting at home? Me too!

Back in december I spent a few sick days going down the rabbit hole of The Secret. Particularly the New York casque...

Now we cannot leave our home and dig for casques.

So my idea was to create an armchair treasure hunt in the style of the secret that you can solve on the internet.

The rules

Your goal is to identify a location in the real world where an imaginary treasure is hidden.

You can discover this location by studying the image and using the internet.

The first person to submit a correct and complete solution will win a 50$ prize (amazon gift card, steam gift card, etc.).

Don’t send me any private messages. A way to submit the solution will reveal itself when you solve the puzzle.

There is no treasure buried in the real world. Don’t go digging, but #StayAtHome!

The winner chosen at my sole discretion. Any recourse to courts of law is excluded.

No hints will be given via private message, e-mail etc. , but feel free to share your findings.

A full resolution picture is available at https://imgur.com/fcmnROs

P.S.: I’m a programmer, so excuse my pixelart.

Update 2020/04/09

As of now, there has been no solution submitted yet.

There was a slight technical issue requiring a clarification of the submission instructions (sorry!). If you know what I'm talking about please check again to make sure you're up-to-date. If you don't know what I'm talking about you're fine - the puzzle itself has not changed.

Update 2020/06/09

There still hasn't been a solution submitted yet.

For those that don't follow the comments, here is one I gave a few days ago that might be of interest to you:

I'm starting to understand why these things haven't been found for so many years...

I think there's one part of the riddle that pulls many people in the wrong direction.

And there's too little attention on the painting.

To solve this, you must collaborate. I have a feeling there's someone out there further along but they don't want to share what they know.

Update 2020/06/15

If you don't mind getting spoiled, or if you have an idea about something hidden in the image and don't want to do the busywork to test it, sportager has an excellent find for you in the comments below.

Update 2020/06/20

Just letting you know that there still hasn't been a solution submitted.

As you all are putting some serious work into solving this, I try my best to hold my tongue. So even if I might not answer, I'm enjoying all your comments and theories - it's getting exciting!

I'll write down my thoughts separately and will publish them if/when a solution is found.

Update 2020/07/12

Just like The Secret, my riddle was made at a point in time. But as time passes, things tend to change.

Unlike Byron Preiss I can keep you up-to-date.

A certain search engine provider has updated their pictures of the treasure's area since the riddle's inception, but fret not, you can still see the older pictures (by clicking on the clock in the top left corner).

To even the odds here's some helpful apocrypha:

Times are changing on your screen

You're lucky it's a time machine

So you can see what's now unseen.

Back then you could fly with me,

Now there's nothing left to see

And another ho is now the home of E.

Sleepyhead, you failed the test,

You parked in front of the one at rest,

The one where you go north not west.

Update 2020/07/19

Riddlesmith, you are the worst!

You miswrote a crucial verse.

You misjudged an Eye for a Tea.

Now wrong things the searchers See.

Update 2020/07/22

A correct solution has been submitted and the treasure has been found! More information shortly.

For now let me say only this: You've all been a wonderful audience!

Update 2020/07/23

Learn all about the solution here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/12keys/comments/hwhjhh/tribute_treasure_hunt_solved_and_thoughts_about/


r/12keys • • Nov 21 '19

Here are all my ideas about the SF casque! I just learned about “The Secret” last weekend and spent the last two nights laying this all out. I’d love to hear some feedback! What do y’all think?

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Dec 31 '21

The Secret Iceburg

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/12keys • • May 05 '20

New Orleans possible match?

Post image
74 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Jun 01 '20

Montreal - Bottom of collar found at McGill Arts Building

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Jul 28 '25

New York The Secret / New York

Thumbnail
gallery
67 Upvotes

Possible New York Casque Location: Francis Lewis Park (Image 12 / Verse 10)

Hey everyone! I’ve been working on a theory for the New York casque from The Secret using Image 12 and Verse 10. After analyzing the verse line by line and comparing it to real world locations, I think I may have found a strong candidate in Francis Lewis Park in Queens.

I’ve put together photos showing how each clue connects. From the “shadow of the grey giant” (Whitestone Bridge). To the compass rose, the “arm” in the walkway sign, a V-shaped tree, and a shrub under a middle branch casting a shadow. All aligning with the poem.

I’m not in NYC myself, so I’d love a second opinion on whether this looks credible to others. Happy to hear your thoughts or feedback!


r/12keys • • Oct 10 '22

Chicago Site Visit Post-Marathon. Was as excited to see the spot as I was to finish. This is the only post in the area with the picture matching window arch if it was there in the 80s.

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Jun 08 '20

So uh, I’m new to this hunt, but it has come to my attention that a geocache I found in June of 2017 was right by the site of the most recent dig. That’s fun.

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Aug 10 '20

I visited the Chicago dig spot today! Seeing the landmarks around the area and the place itself was very cool, and also pretty informative when it came to putting together my own secret solution. On the phone is image 5, it’s just hard to see

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Oct 15 '19

Boston dig site

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Oct 18 '21

Welcome Treasure Hunters, to The Secret!

62 Upvotes

The Secret is a nearly 40 year old ongoing treasure hunt, seeking to unearth hidden Casques across North America. This forum is a place for photographs, ideas, and news surrounding the search for the 12 hidden casques.

To get started, here is an excellent introduction to get you (mostly) up to speed on the treasure hunt, including the two intact recovered casques and how they were found.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfGk0dFAhjo

https://12treasures.com is a good place to view high res scans of the images

There is a discord: https://discord.gg/qPkxjngHmy

And facebook group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/thesecrettreasures


r/12keys • • Dec 08 '19

Cleveland Casque Discovery Video 2004

Thumbnail
youtu.be
62 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Oct 01 '25

New York My full theory for the New York casque

Post image
59 Upvotes

Hi everybody!

Longtime lurker, first time poster (or maybe not first, I can't quite remember.) I'm a huge fan of reading other people's theories for The Secret locations and I figured it was time to share mine and let people tear it apart as they wish! My friends and family told me that my theory was most entertaining in the format of the journal I kept during my research, so I made two journal entries detailing my theory.

The first entry details why I think Preiss buried the casque at Grace Playground in the Ocean Hill area of Brooklyn: https://www.kitrosewater.com/post/would-you-pick-up-a-shovel-to-dig-for-treasure-part-2

The second entry details which tree I think it was buried under and why: https://www.kitrosewater.com/post/would-you-pick-up-a-shovel-to-dig-for-treasure-part-3

Yes I definitely did go visit this park and walk around it to confirm all the Google Maps images and finds. I also was able to get an appointment at the Brooklyn City Center and look through boxes of archives to see what the park and surrounding neighborhoods looked like in the 1950s-1980s.

This is totally just a theory and again, I'm only sharing it because I have enjoyed reading about other's thoughts so much. I do read people's theories online, so no need to chase me down with your particular theory. If you have posted it, I'm sure I've read it and found it interesting! :)

I wrote my master's thesis on Kit Williams's Masquerade and the canon of armchair treasure hunt books, so I've been into this kind of stuff for forever. I'm publishing a fictional treasure hunt book that is my love letter to The Secret and its treasure hunting community, and that book comes out from Penguin Random House next July. The Pigpen ciphers at the end of each of these journal entries have to do with a real treasure hunt I'm putting on for the book's publication, which will be revealed later this month and then even further next spring. If anyone's interested in hearing more about that, just DM me. I figured I'd rather put my usual author traveling budget into a grand prize for a treasure hunt instead this time around!

Cheers, everyone.

Kit


r/12keys • • Apr 07 '21

RIP JM

59 Upvotes

Very sad to learn of the passing of JM, original podcaster and a top guy in our community, you will live on through this hunt. 😢


r/12keys • • Dec 27 '23

Milwaukee The juggler's hairline is very similar to Lake Park, Milwaukee.

Post image
58 Upvotes

Especially near the City of Milwaukee Water Works’ Linnwood Water Treatment Plant. I'm not sure if this has been spotted before...


r/12keys • • Oct 25 '19

NOLA Solve - updated

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/12keys • • Apr 28 '24

San Francisco I think I solved San Francisco.

56 Upvotes

Hi, all.

I'm not sure how to go about it, but I'm pretty sure I know the solution to the riddle. Although I'm new to this subreddit, I geeked out on the hunt during COVID and went back to yesterday (after being near Golden Gate Park for lunch) to see where things were at, and think I've got it figured out.

I just came back from where I think the casque is buried this morning, and the soil there is nice and soft, which is consistent with the casques that have been found. I've submitted a request to dig in Golden Gate Park with SF Recreation & Parks and am waiting to hear back.

Here's the solution up to good ol' Twain:

  • The starting point for me ("At stone wall's door") is not the Shakespeare bust (which is not stone as far as I can tell), but the Portals of the Past in Golden Gate Park, which is largely made of marble (I think).

  • The Conservatory of Flowers and the Rose Garden are nearby, and just a few feet from the Portal itself are lavender flowers, so the "air smells sweet" there.

  • I believe "high posts are three" refer to Sutro Tower and "Education" is UCSF Parnassus, which are both visible from high points in the area.

  • I think "and Justice for all" is supposed to be read separately from "Education," and refers to JFK Drive, which had its name back then.

  • I agree with others that "Sounds from the sky Near ace is high" refers to being near where JFK Drive passes beneath Highway 1. "[A]ce is high" is Highway 1, and "Sounds from the sky" means the Highway 1 traffic (from beneath it).

  • "Running north, but first across" has two meanings: (1) Highway 1 runs north bisecting the park but just before Fulton Street it cuts east before continuing north to the Presidio, so Highway 1 is "running north, but first across," and (2) when standing on JFK Drive just east of the overpass, the Prayerbook Cross is north up the hill (i.e., "but first across" = "but, first, a cross").

My solutions for the "object of Twain's attention," "Giant pole" and "Giant step" will not be disclosed until after the dig, but they're so dastardly simple you'll freak (if they're correct, that is). I'll be sure to post my entire solution asap after the dig regardless.

Other than the starting point (which AFAIK has not been proposed online before), none of the solution is original to me. (I've seen mentions of them on various discussion threads.) My solutions to the last three clues, however, do seem to be novel and would give the location away in a heartbeat, so I'd like to have the chance to dig first before disclosing them.

Wish me luck!

Edit:

Hi, all. I didn't realize that it'd take so long for me to get a permit to dig, so in the spirit of collaboration, I'm including my solves for "Giant pole" and "Giant step." And it's possible of course that Verse 7 is not SF at all, so maybe it'll help solve another city altogether. I just ask that if someone finds one, that they give old u/burritocaca a shout out. :)

"Pole" and "Step" are units of measure:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rod_(unit)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Step_(unit)

Final edit: In the spirit of collaboration, I'm posting where I think this one is buried. Quite frankly, I don't care if I am the one doing the digging. I just want these puzzles solved. I won't dig without permission and it looks like I have to wait until next year to dig with the Parks Dept.'s blessing, and honestly I don't think I'll spend more than a year on any one theory so here goes.

Adding to all of the above, my guess is that the dig spot is a pole (~5 meters) and a step (.75 meters), for a total of 5.75 meters, west-southwest of the Prayerbook Cross. The base of the cross is at a slight angle so that the west-southwest side of the base is perpendicular with a line that would go to the center of the west boundary of the park, right where the pearl is in Image 1 ("in jewel's direction"). The soil is very soft in the prospective dig spot, perfect for burying casques. For this possible solution, the object of Twain's attention would be the angling pool on the west side of the park (low-to-mid confidence on that).

The interpretation of Verse 7 for this read is that the bearing is given by "In jewel's direction" and the directional location is the cross ('but, first, a cross'), but after reading through the Japan hints and the solved verses I'm no longer as confident that the directional location is not whatever the object of Twain's attention is.

Cheers.