r/1200isjerky • u/LeighSabio • Jul 26 '17
Skellylogic is fatlogic
This isn't exactly a satire, but I'm posting it here because a lot of skellylogic/analogic gets mocked in this sub. Does anyone else notice how the same logical fallacies lead to fatlogic in fat people and analogic/skellylogic in thin people? Examples
Thinking things other than eating lead to absorbing calories
Fatlogic: Skinny people can eat whatever they want and stay thin, but I get fat from the smell of a cookie. Skellylogic: I should log extra calories for the food I smelled
2. Thinking eating doesn't lead to absorbing calories
Fatlogic: I had celery with my peanut butter so the negative calories in the celery balance it out Skellylogic: I eat mostly negative calorie foods because they are safe food for me.
3. Insisting they are BMI outliers
Fatlogic: I'm 5'6 and moderately active, so my 40 BMI doesn't account for my muscle. I'm still healthy Skellylogic: I'm 5'0 and sedentary, so 16.0 is a healthy BMI for me
Ridiculously low TDEE estimations without suspecting a math error
Fatlogic: I ate 800 calories a day and worked out and I was still obese Skellylogic: I'm only 5'3, so 800 is maintenance for me.
4. Condishuns
Fatlogic: I have PCOS. Weight loss is impossible Skellylogic: I ate over 2000 calories one day last year and didn't become obese. I must have malabsorption.
5. Seeing exercise as a punishment for eating
Fatlogic: I don't exercise, I engage in joyful movement. If I ever push myself, it's mentally unhealthy. Skellylogic: sure, I walk 5 miles a day and rock climb for 2 hours every other day, but I'm still sedentary because I don't exercise. The walking doesn't count because it's part of my job and the climbing doesn't count because it's a hobby.
5. Sweeping generalizations
Fatlogic: adults need 2500-3500 calories a day. 1200 is starvation (even if you're 4'11 and bedridden) Skellylogic: women need less than 2000 calories a day. Eat that much and you will gain (even if you're 6' or an Olympic athlete)