r/1200isjerky • • Jul 26 '17

Skellylogic is fatlogic

2 Upvotes

This isn't exactly a satire, but I'm posting it here because a lot of skellylogic/analogic gets mocked in this sub. Does anyone else notice how the same logical fallacies lead to fatlogic in fat people and analogic/skellylogic in thin people? Examples

  1. Thinking things other than eating lead to absorbing calories

Fatlogic: Skinny people can eat whatever they want and stay thin, but I get fat from the smell of a cookie. Skellylogic: I should log extra calories for the food I smelled

2. Thinking eating doesn't lead to absorbing calories

Fatlogic: I had celery with my peanut butter so the negative calories in the celery balance it out Skellylogic: I eat mostly negative calorie foods because they are safe food for me.

3. Insisting they are BMI outliers

Fatlogic: I'm 5'6 and moderately active, so my 40 BMI doesn't account for my muscle. I'm still healthy Skellylogic: I'm 5'0 and sedentary, so 16.0 is a healthy BMI for me

Ridiculously low TDEE estimations without suspecting a math error

Fatlogic: I ate 800 calories a day and worked out and I was still obese Skellylogic: I'm only 5'3, so 800 is maintenance for me.

4. Condishuns

Fatlogic: I have PCOS. Weight loss is impossible Skellylogic: I ate over 2000 calories one day last year and didn't become obese. I must have malabsorption.

5. Seeing exercise as a punishment for eating

Fatlogic: I don't exercise, I engage in joyful movement. If I ever push myself, it's mentally unhealthy. Skellylogic: sure, I walk 5 miles a day and rock climb for 2 hours every other day, but I'm still sedentary because I don't exercise. The walking doesn't count because it's part of my job and the climbing doesn't count because it's a hobby.

5. Sweeping generalizations

Fatlogic: adults need 2500-3500 calories a day. 1200 is starvation (even if you're 4'11 and bedridden) Skellylogic: women need less than 2000 calories a day. Eat that much and you will gain (even if you're 6' or an Olympic athlete)


r/1200isjerky • • Apr 01 '26

So FILLING!!! Life hack: eat your partners puke to save calories!!

0 Upvotes

If you don’t have a partner like me, just ask a local homeless person. They’ll do anything for a few bucks!

You might wonder why someone would ever do this. If you are, you’re not a skinny queen like the rest of us and you need to leave the sub. But I’ll humor you anyway; puke is predigested. This means there’s less calories but the liquid and solid contents mushing around in your stomach keep you fuller longer!!!


r/1200isjerky • • Mar 15 '26

is this like edtwt or something?

0 Upvotes

only difference is weird satire replies do we have eds or what is this a joke genuinely


r/1200isjerky • • Aug 02 '24

Eating Disorder I can't lose weight to matter what and I'm tired of people saying that I'm not logging correctly.

0 Upvotes

I have been so damn stressed. Literally nothing I do I don't lose weight. I ate 1400 calories yesterday (should be eating 2400 for my diet) and Literally nothing. I didn't even lose water weight. I Literally stayed the same weight. And if I posted this to the main sub, guess what would happen? This has happened before mind you. "Are you tracking your calories right?" "Are you sure you aren't lying? Calories in, calories out" "you can't just break thermodynamics, you're lying" "have you tried lowering your calories?". Holy. Shit. I'm gonna like lose it (hahah lose it, loseit, hahah funny pun). I know this place is like a lighthearted, making fun of people place, but like theres no where else for me to put this without the answers I get. I promise you all, I've been logging correctly, maybe even over logging. I just don't eat, i have no appetite. I have to force myself to just eat everyday. I'm so hungry but like the thought of food makes me want to puke just because it doesn't sound good. I just don't get it. Do I Literally need to eat air? I feel like im going insane, it feels like I need to eat only 500 calories a day in order to even lose a pound a week. For some reason though I don't gain at my current amount either, like it doesn't matter if I eat 1500 calories or 2400 calories, I don't lose either way. BTW my doctor won't be of help either, he doesn't listen to me, he doesn't do any tests. He'll probably just tell me again to "walk more". And stupid calming methods don't work either. Take 5 minutes to deeply breathe? Yeah, sure, but that doesn't help me!! I'm literally so damn stressed right now that it would probably take me 5 years in order to get my stress levels fully down and then maybe I can lose weight. But I don't have 5 years! I have to get top surgery done in 2 years, and I've been dieting since I was 12, I highly doubt I'll be able to lose the weight in time! Most doctors have a bmi limit of 30 because technically it's a cosmetic surgery when it's a life saving surgery for me. What the hell am I going to do if I have to wait a decade for surgery? I can't wait to live my life for a goddamn decade. So yeah, I either have to fucking starve or wait for God knows how long to lose weight. Mods feel free to take this down, I know technically this sub isn't for venting at all, I'm just not sure where else to put this without people blaming me for my lack of weight loss. God it feels like I can hear my eating disorder calling to me lol


r/1200isjerky • • Sep 23 '24

Balanced Meals Does an IV break my fast?

Post image
94 Upvotes

r/1200isjerky • • Apr 05 '23

1200 calories is for a child ?????

12 Upvotes

I LOVE this sub but obviously I’m in the respective cousin sun as well. It’s a great read.

Question: please someone I mean SOMEONE tell me how none of their posts have comments saying this isn’t healthy????

How does ANYONE survive of 1200?!!?!? I’m an athlete and I’d starve. Literally.

That group just promotes disordered eating and I needed to come here and state my opinion.

TYA for listening :)

Edit: wow thank you all for your added opinions. Felt like I was the only one who was confused … appreciate the comments!


r/1200isjerky • • Apr 16 '18

My before and after progress pics!!!

3 Upvotes

Oh also I was going to the gym 5 times a week religiously with a personal trainer, but I swear it was the CICO.


r/1200isjerky • • Apr 02 '23

Question

0 Upvotes

I've been scrolling on this thread for some time now and most of the posts are diagreeing about the concept of a calorie deficit but my question is : as an overweight-obese person, what should I do to lose some weight ? And if you're going to tell me "eat healthy" Yes. eating healthy is good but, what is the definition of "healthy" to the people on this thread ? Thank you in advance.


r/1200isjerky • • Apr 22 '21

What should have my mother named me?

6 Upvotes

I eat foods with so much calories my mama should have named me "Calorie"


r/1200isjerky • • Aug 05 '26

STOP

0 Upvotes

Hey guys just let me eat


r/1200isjerky • • Jul 05 '17

1200isplenty posters getting in the spirit of July 4

Thumbnail
imgur.com
3 Upvotes

r/1200isjerky • • Jul 28 '19

is this a jerk about a specific diet trend or something?

0 Upvotes

serious answers only pls


r/1200isjerky • • Oct 17 '26

Fatty Bombatty Zone STOP RN

0 Upvotes

I told you once before and I'm telling you again rn JUST LET ME EAT


r/1200isjerky • • Apr 13 '26

may i ask what tf this sub is

0 Upvotes

maybe im mistaken but this is very eating disorder-esque... the vibes are weird in here! are you guys disordered? fasting? dieting? what the hell is going on


r/1200isjerky • • Jul 22 '25

Cassie from skins core

Post image
19 Upvotes

I’m


r/1200isjerky • • Aug 18 '22

Food choices!?! ack!

4 Upvotes

Hello lovelies,

I am struggling with food choices. I'm trying to make a meal plan, and I want everything yet nothing all at. I have so many eating disorder rules and "shoulds" circling my brain that I don't know what I truly want. I end up just eating comfort childhood foods to satisfy my mood. What do y'all do?

Thanks for the supportive community. Stay well xoxo.


r/1200isjerky • • Feb 09 '22

Miss you for days

5 Upvotes

Friend,

I’ve reached the halo top, toothpick and abs carved out for days. Wish you could be here , I miss you for days

Sincey,

Your Friend


r/1200isjerky • • May 20 '26

I don’t know how I joined this sub and I don’t understand

0 Upvotes

Is this page making jokes about ED? Or are yall all really that demented 😵
Idk how I joined this sub but I always be confused 😆😆


r/1200isjerky • • Sep 02 '24

Eating Disorder You can’t convince me the original sub isn’t disordered

392 Upvotes

Serous post here but I saw someone complaining how little their tdee is because they weigh 94 pounds . I’m sorry what ? Tell me that isn’t an Ed and you’re lying.


r/1200isjerky • • Jul 17 '26 Heartwarming

confused as heckkk

28 Upvotes

is this sub like… genuinely for very very disordered people or is it for healthy people to like make jokes about anorexic people? lost lol…


r/1200isjerky • • Jul 16 '25

I don't really know where to go from here.

0 Upvotes

Okay so uhm I guess I should start with my stats?? I'm currently 13f, 4'11 and 128. Overweight. Wanting everything to go away. The last couple months I've been putting a lot of energy into losing weight after I realized I was the shortest and fattest of all my friends. At first I did a calorie deficit, a light one, after finally figuring out how to portion control. I did a disgusting amount of research in the last two months on weight loss and how the body uses glucose and how weight loss works. My sister (16f) recently struggled with disordered eating and anorexia recovery. She managed to drop 30lbs in 6 months, and my close friend V dropped 15 in one month because of the same eating habits. Suffice to say, after going down a weight loss rabbit hole I have succumbed to the restriction diet. I am also not claiming to be anorexic btw because I don't want to falsely label myself and I truly don't believe I have anorexia. Also I'm not skin and bones. As seen earlier I still have a decent amount of chub on me. Okay, now I can finally get to my point. It's a new month, and that means that after even more research it's time to continue with my diet. I eat around 700-800 cals a day flat, and then exercise enough via walking for long periods to have my calorie intake be around 300-400 a day because of burned energy. I track everything obsessively, checking how many calories I consumed and then stressing when I would get over 800 and immediately panic and try to burn it off by the evening. It's gotten to a point where my calculator screentime has skyrocketed and my entire search history is "how many cals in..." I don't view these habits as unhealthy btw, because once I just became aware and mindful of what I ate my calories dropped quickly. I sometimes panic at certain foods, like salami and bread for example are foods that terrify me if I have to consume because of such a high calorie count. Thank goodness my parents use whole wheat bread so one slice is 70cals I can eat toast in moderation. The calories in a banana scare me yet I can eat my weight in sugar. Ironic, isn't it? Anyways, I've lost 6lbs already and am wanting to lose even more. I've become more active lately and convinced my mother to get a gym membership and we go 3-4 times a week. Using a calorie deficit calculator I should be consuming 1k cals a day to keep steady wl because of my more active lifestyle + it's summer. The problem is that my restriction mentality is so that I only eat 500-600 cals a day with exercise and high restriction. I'm aware my habits aren't the best, but I want the weight to keep shedding off. And honestly, I like how restriction feels. But I worry that because of restriction my body will go into starvation mode and my progress will stop. My newest question is: should I back off and go to a 800 calorie deficit to prevent a plateau or will the change mess with my body?? I've heard that a moderate calorie deficit will ensure weight loss but I feel like it's gonna take too long, and yes I understand wl always takes time but people can drop weight rapidly in 1-2 months with enough commitment. I feel like I've dug myself into a hole that is terrifying to even attempt to climb out of. I'm worried I'm gonna stop losing weight and things are gonna go back up again and I feel like with enough restrictions my body will adjust and I'll keep losing weight. I'm also worried about the starvation mode thing again tho. It's like midnight rn so I gotta sleep lol xx


r/1200isjerky • • Nov 27 '20

Pure devastation

Thumbnail
imgur.com
14 Upvotes

r/1200isjerky • • Dec 21 '25

Uj/ Interested in members in weightloss journey

0 Upvotes

Just curious at which point are you at your weightloss journey. Survey conducted on 22nd December 2025 till 25th December 2025.

91 votes, Dec 24 '25
12 Achieved goal weight and maintaining
47 Still in weightloss journey
5 Planning to start the weightloss journey
12 Regained lost weight
6 Paused weightloss for a reason
9 Never planned lossing weight

r/1200isjerky • • Feb 12 '20

Me, banking cardio calories.

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
1 Upvotes