r/supergirlTV • u/MajorParadox DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Dec 09 '19
Discussion Supergirl [5x09] "Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part One" Post Episode Discussion Spoiler
Crisis on Infinite Earths: Part One
Live Episode Discussion | Promo | Scene | Crisis Cast & Characters
The Monitor sends Harbinger to gather the worlds' greatest heroes - Supergirl, The Flash, Green Arrow, Batwoman, White Canary, The Atom and Superman - in preparation for the impending Crisis. With their worlds in imminent danger, the superheroes suit up for battle while J'onn and Alex recruit Lena to help them find a way to save the people of Earth-38. (Dec 8, 2019)
Don't forget there's a Crisis Aftermath I special hosted by Kevin Smith right now!
Crisis on Infinite Earths Schedule
| Part | Subreddit | Air Date and Time | Discussions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part 1: Supergirl | r/SupergirlTV | Sunday, December 8 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 2: Batwoman | r/BatwomanTV | Monday, December 9 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 3: The Flash | r/FlashTV | Tuesday, December 10 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 4: Arrow | r/arrow | Tuesday, January 14 at 8pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
| Part 5: Legends of Tomorrow | r/LegendsOfTomorrow | Tuesday, January 14 at 9pm ET | [Live] [Post] |
More Information about Crisis in this Subreddit
Please keep all discussion civil and about the episode. Mark comic and future spoilers. Report any rule breaking and enjoy!
Brought you to by the mods of r/arrow, r/FlashTV, r/BatwomanTV, r/LegendsofTomorrow, r/SupergirlTV, r/SupermanandLois, r/StargirlTV, r/BlackLightning, r/ArrowAndTheCanaries, and r/DCTV!
396
u/finally_not_lurking Dec 09 '19
Killing the Arrow off on a different show is a bold move. Let’s see if it lasts.
2
271
u/mrguy231231 Dec 09 '19
I don’t believe for a second that he’s dead. It’s likely that he will die for good later on, in part 5, but that death scene was WAY too quick and only a few heroes were there. I think that when he does die, it’ll be in battle surrounded by everyone, similar to Iron Man
→ More replies (21)24
21
u/AnnaK22 PIZZA 🍕 AND POTSTICKERS 🥟 Dec 09 '19
I'm guessing the future arrow will have something to do with the rest of the crossover so Stephen will still be active in the crossovers. And I hope he does somehow come back, do he'll get a proper role on his Earth.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (30)29
12
u/BornAshes Dec 09 '19
They nailed it for the first episode. They just fucking nailed it. That whole thing was beautiful and I loved every moment of it.
5
u/MajorParadox DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Dec 09 '19
And you can tell we haven't seen anything yet! So hyped!
→ More replies (1)
363
Dec 09 '19
The stakes are pretty wild.
Kara's Earth is gone. Oliver is dead.
And we have 4 hours left. Wow.
178
27
u/rawchess Just a regular human, nothing to see here Dec 09 '19
Kara lost her Earth, her homeworld (or what remained of it), and her mom in the span of hours.
Stop hurting our girl please, she's lost so much already :(
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (16)75
u/2th Dec 09 '19
They are coming out of the corner swinging with this crossover. I'm all aboard for the Chaos.
→ More replies (1)
326
u/ThaUnderboss Dec 09 '19
Well...Time to gather the Dragonballs.
105
→ More replies (4)13
u/BornAshes Dec 09 '19
Or Plane Shift to the Feywild for a bit until it all blows over
→ More replies (6)
185
u/CasualKing21 Dec 09 '19
I really expected Oliver to die in like episode 3, right before the break to let us breathe and cry.
115
u/lord_flamebottom Dec 09 '19
Hell, that's when I expected Barry to die, leaving Oliver for the end (and bringing Barry back).
→ More replies (9)22
u/MY-SECRET-REDDIT Dec 09 '19
So we are getting three episodes this month? Damn I was waiting for another episode afterward this one.
→ More replies (8)
162
u/Skullripper675 Dec 09 '19
I really liked how they seemed to humanize the monitor during olivers death. He always seemed so apathetic doing most things, but not when he was talking about the 1 billion or so lives he saved
→ More replies (1)97
u/MutekiGamer Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
He seemed to be genuinely surprised that a human could single-handedly save that many people
→ More replies (5)
141
Dec 09 '19
Oliver queen died in part 1 of this 5 part crossover.
I totally believe it.
→ More replies (6)19
u/max1001 Dec 09 '19
Funny part is the arrow subreddit is freaking out. Like they gonna kill hi. Off in the Supergirl episode.
→ More replies (1)
274
u/cmath89 Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
I refuse to believe that’s how they take Ollie out.
Edit: The Titans show being referenced at the beginning was cool.
211
u/tonystankisajerk Superman Dec 09 '19
The Titans show being referenced at the beginning was cool.
And hearing the brief Batman themes for E-89 and E-66 along with seeing Burt Ward and his classic "Holy..." line
→ More replies (12)→ More replies (7)66
u/FosterSlays Dec 09 '19
He saved a billion people staying there longer.... It's the only way oliver wanted to go
→ More replies (4)
125
u/electric_ocelots Dec 09 '19
I hope they release Crisis as its own movie on Netflix or something. Just have all the episodes edited together without the cuts to commercials.
→ More replies (20)73
238
u/neoblackdragon Dec 09 '19
So let's start with the bad.
Part 2 is not on right now.
The Good
Part 1 exists
→ More replies (2)53
225
u/samtherat6 Dec 09 '19
Like how Barry just assumed that the Wells that showed up was Nash. Like it could’ve been Thawne for all he knew.
246
u/Nejaru Dec 09 '19
Barry is like Brock from Pokémon. He’s able to tell every single one of the Wells apart even if we can’t.
→ More replies (5)89
u/TrippySakuta Dec 09 '19
I mean, Nash popped up right next to Monitor, and he was going on about Monitor earlier.
He wouldn't think it's Thawne because Thawne told him they'll fight in the Crisis. Besides, Thawne's not really the type to serve his penance.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (14)20
u/ArkhamIsComing2020 Dec 09 '19
Thawne has deep black hair in season 5. Pariah looked the same as Nash. It's not that hard to tell.
→ More replies (1)
108
u/motleo95 Supergirl Dec 09 '19
On the bright side Kara, now you’ve got Leviathan out of your hair
→ More replies (6)57
u/Adas_Legend Dec 09 '19
Don't jinx it; who's to say they weren't amongst the 3 billion who made it to Earth 1?
→ More replies (5)
211
u/sarroush22 Dec 09 '19
Killing Oliver off in the first episode...Eh, not sure how I feel about that.
That aside though, Lena holy shit.
Her smile was 100% genuine, and then she's like "Oh shit, I forgot to activate bitch mode, give me 1 sec".
Stop this pleaaase ;__;
62
u/Ygomaster07 Dreamer Dec 09 '19
I know, i really can't wait for everyone to forgive each other. I want Lena and Kara working as friends, not as enemies(or frenemies).
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)30
Dec 09 '19
Yeah this Lena shit is pissing me off. Like you could tell she was feeling comfortable with Alex and then realized oh wait I'm supposed to be angry.
It wasn't Alex's secret to tell no matter what so why is Lena mad at her anyway. This pettiness should stay between her and Kara if she's mad at anyone.
→ More replies (7)
95
u/AnnaK22 PIZZA 🍕 AND POTSTICKERS 🥟 Dec 09 '19
I legit screamed when I saw Titans. How exciting that Arrowverse managed to get them, even if it's just for a short scene. Also, there were unbelievable number of cameos. Incredible!!!
→ More replies (11)63
u/MutekiGamer Dec 09 '19
When Hawk showed up my mind hadn’t fully realised what was going on until Jasón Todd showed up and I immediately freaked out
→ More replies (5)
93
u/Spainguy82 Dec 09 '19
So what happened to Earth 38’s Mars? J’onn literally just sent his brother to M’gann. Also what about Mon-El and Winn?
37
u/KrayleyAML Dec 09 '19
Since Winn comes back on the show, I figure he's alright.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (9)24
u/chrisjozo Dec 09 '19
Ironically evacuating Mars would be easier since they have a lot more space ships. Plus with our Mars being uninhabited they could have repopulated it.
→ More replies (4)
169
u/TheDarkpekka Dec 09 '19
Months after crisis after the refugees got settled in, Instagram got flooded with doppelgänger selfies
→ More replies (17)49
u/Dr_Brule_FYH Dec 09 '19
Earth 1 Argus just shooting down these alien ships trying to invade.
→ More replies (3)
223
u/electric_ocelots Dec 09 '19
"You're a good man, Oliver. On every Earth."
Goddamn.
254
u/Marc_Quill Dec 09 '19
Well, except the Nazi-controlled Earth, but we don’t talk about that.
→ More replies (22)→ More replies (2)57
u/BornAshes Dec 09 '19
You could see him just getting ready to cry as she said that. His whole world has been such a mess and then someone he loved someone he lost comes back from the dead from another world entirely and says...."You're a good man...everywhere...always". Gosh I'm probably going to cry a little when I go back and rewatch that moment because fuck was it powerful. His world was so dark and sure enough the White Canary just ignites this spark of hope within Robo Old Man Oliver before vanishing.
→ More replies (4)
76
u/KabutoRyder Dec 09 '19
Amell to showrunner/writers - Guys I have totally mastered crying on command. I think Ollie should cry as much as possible in the final season.
Showrunner/Writers - Right Stephen I am sure we can make it into a few scenes and --
Amell - ALL OF THE SCENES!
Showrunner/Writers - Maybe like once an episode.
Amell - I Accept.
→ More replies (1)
74
138
u/Liar_tuck Dec 09 '19
Three billion people, including aliens are now refuges on Earth-1. This is a problem for Earth -1.
88
→ More replies (6)18
170
u/flintlock0 Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
What if they hadn’t yet renewed Titans, and they went ahead and destroyed their world in the intro sequence just to convey that it was being cancelled?
Would have been hilarious.
“Your show is cancelled. Your show is cancelled.”
38
u/mithikx Dec 09 '19
The
anti-mattercancellation wave destroys Earth-9, and so... Titans is no more.→ More replies (1)24
u/bluestarcyclone Dec 09 '19
Shit, if somehow marvel was tied in we could do it for all the shows theyve axed over the last couple years as they killed off everything on netflix\hulu\freeform
→ More replies (3)
169
u/MattTheSmithers Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
Its weird that we are getting different versions of Superman and Flash, played by different actors. But apparently all the mutliverse Ollies will be Stephen Amell. At least have fun and use Robbie in a passing cameo as an "alternate" Ollie, haha
121
u/FosterSlays Dec 09 '19
Actually one earth had Adrian ad the Green Arrow, I assume this one just happened to have oliver as the green arrow too
→ More replies (11)29
→ More replies (4)13
u/tonystankisajerk Superman Dec 09 '19
Assuming the more likely case that he won't be in the crossover, really would have liked to see Justin Hartley's GA
115
Dec 09 '19 edited Mar 23 '21
So only 3 out of 7.53 billion made it off Earth 38 (1 billion more thanks to Oliver, GOAT!).
Damn! What a way to set the stakes 😔
→ More replies (8)41
u/klutzysunshine Dec 09 '19
I missed how many total people were on that Earth - holy shit. At least they saved a lot of people!
→ More replies (13)
112
u/Davidleilam Martian Manhunter Dec 09 '19
Fucking hell, they actually killed Oliver in the first episode of the crossover
51
54
u/AnnaK22 PIZZA 🍕 AND POTSTICKERS 🥟 Dec 09 '19
Can we give a special shout out to Blake Neely for music. Its great how good music can really set the tone.
→ More replies (2)26
u/Gateskp Brainy Dec 09 '19
Yes!! The music was AMAZING this episode. I loved how he slipped in the different themes and created such an intense mood with his score.
75
u/_Elder_ Earth-X Reverse Flash (Unmasked) Dec 09 '19
I literally can’t believe how hyped I am for another FOUR PARTS.
51
u/MetalsDeadAndSoAmI Dec 09 '19
4.5, seems black lightning is having his own related yet unrelated crisis on his earth.
→ More replies (15)
37
u/Dioniseum Dec 09 '19
There was a very specific scene in an earlier promo that leads me to believe that it's not his time yet at all.
→ More replies (5)
134
u/LordHawkman Superman Dec 09 '19
Oliver dead scene was so DRY
52
Dec 09 '19
I loved his final stand, that was chill inducing. The death I kinda agree though
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (17)93
u/Mighty_thor_confused Jon Cryer/Lex Luthor Dec 09 '19
I'm honestly with you. I felt nothing. Except for maybe confusing and slight anger.
→ More replies (10)
36
u/Good-times-roll Supes Dec 09 '19
They’re definitely gonna bring him back before arrow ends. That particular Oliver. No way they don’t.
99
u/aa22hhhh I can end your life before you birth your next thought Dec 09 '19
Oliver Queen and Tony Stark are the GOATs this year. No denying any of that. Fuck, man, this crossover has me fucked up so far.
→ More replies (1)51
u/electric_ocelots Dec 09 '19
They both started their respective universes, and they both sacrificed their lives to save them.
→ More replies (11)
34
u/ninjasaid13 Dec 09 '19
First Episode: 3,500,000,000 deaths... and one.
11
→ More replies (5)11
u/Worthyness Dec 09 '19
You forgot the other universes that got obliterated in the first like 30 seconds
→ More replies (2)
34
u/shady8x Dec 09 '19
"You are a good man, on every Earth"
Ahh, no. He is literally Hitler on at least one of them...
14
u/imdahman Dec 09 '19
Yeah but that dude ded now... of the Earth's LEFT - He is a good man on all of them... =D
→ More replies (1)
33
Dec 09 '19
Bold move at the end and a solid episode all around. I’m willing to bet The Monitor is using Oliver’s “death” to inspire the rest of the heroes to band together (like Coulson’s death in Avengers), and we’ll get a tease that he’s alive in Part 3.
31
Dec 09 '19
The Oliver and Sara scene was one of the best moments in this universe in a long time.
→ More replies (3)11
u/electric_ocelots Dec 09 '19
It's a shame Sara never came back to Arrow after a few seasons on Legends, but like she told Old Man Oliver, she's loving it with them.
87
u/h4rent Dec 09 '19
Monitor can resurrect Lex but not Oliver?? What?
→ More replies (2)64
u/FosterSlays Dec 09 '19
Oliver made a deal to die to save Barry and Kara. for what I understand, Oliver needed to die to keep the world in balance
→ More replies (10)
59
u/ConnorMarsh Dec 09 '19
It feels weird that Barry is the only participant from Team Flash so far.
34
u/ConnectedLoner Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
Team Flash would’ve had a 2nd rep if Cisco were still Vibe. Dibny and Frost just can’t help as much yet
→ More replies (13)→ More replies (4)47
Dec 09 '19
It's technically a Supergirl episode. The core supporting cast will be on every episode, but not all the little side characters.
→ More replies (3)
28
u/motleo95 Supergirl Dec 09 '19
Kinda shook that only ~3 billion were saved from Kara’s earth. Like I’m not at all surprised considering the stake, but that is still massive loss. By the time I realized I was watching Oliver die, he was closing his eyes. Totally shaken by this episode but I fucking LOVE it so far, this is gonna be the kinda crossover event I can watch over and over and over again. I cannot wait until tomorrow night when we’re all here again watching together.
The Crisis Is Here!!
78
u/Megaman99M Dec 09 '19
I just realized that Oliver doing this changes every future Barry and the Monitor saw. Oliver knew he wasn't supposed to die there but knew that Barry and Kara are destined to die alongside him so he sacrificed himself beforehand in order to change fate in a way that will hopefully allow Barry and Kara to live! He really is 10 steps ahead and we don't even know what game he's playing!
→ More replies (4)18
u/phoenix_ash Dec 09 '19
Once this is over someone is going to have to recalculate the steps.
→ More replies (1)
27
u/ThumbCentral-Rebirth Dec 09 '19
The promo thing where Stephen says “you can’t really get much bigger than COIE” he’s wearing 2046 Ollie’s suit on a set from one of the next few parts. We haven’t seen the last of him.
27
26
u/BreakTheWallsDown95 Dec 09 '19
I have to admit.
I think Olibur dying is a more effective "Anything can happen" plot device than Black Widow's death in Endgame.
23
u/OliviaElevenDunham Brainy Dec 09 '19
Holy crap! The Crisis crossover has been worth the 5 year wait.
21
21
Dec 09 '19
Part 1 lived up to the hype, easily. Even if they killed off like every other DC live action adaptation lol.
21
u/KabutoRyder Dec 09 '19
Im thinking no way 2046 Ollie comes in, gets that much screen time with Sara for him not to be involved later.
→ More replies (5)
20
20
u/Gateskp Brainy Dec 09 '19
If this is how I feel after just 1 hour, what's it going to be like in January when there are 2 hours back-to-back? 😳
→ More replies (2)
38
u/jadedfan55 Dec 09 '19
Ok, didn't see it coming that Oliver would die right off the bat.
If Burt Ward's only contribution is his one line at the start, that to me is just fan-service.
Kevin Smith is right. This is bonkers.
→ More replies (3)41
u/deyvtown Dec 09 '19
If Burt Ward's only contribution is his one line at the start, that to me is just fan-service.
A lot of the cameos will be just that. They don't have the time to dedicate whole scenes to everyone.
→ More replies (3)
18
u/OliviaElevenDunham Brainy Dec 09 '19
I wonder what happened to James Olsen & if he survived.
→ More replies (6)15
u/MrBubbles9039 Dec 09 '19
Oh shoot I forgot about that. Also M'gann and Malefic and the Legion of Superheroes
→ More replies (3)
18
u/katniss_everjeans Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
Barry seemed to exude a constant sense of panic throughout the entire episode. Even his reaction to Oliver’s death seemed more like shock that this is all real.
I think he’s still looking for a way to live. He really wanted to know what Oliver’s deal with the Monitor was. 🙃
17
u/ChandlerForrestal Dec 09 '19
I wonder if Lena, Kelly and Nia got off Earth-38 before it was destroyed. Also, I hope they don’t pull some kind of Dragonball Super and restore all the Earths that were destroyed.
18
u/Nightsong Supergirl Dec 09 '19
They kind of have to bring back parts of the Earth 38 universe... namely Leviathan and Clark's son since those two tie into Supergirl and the upcoming Superman & Lois show. So I don't think we are going to see a full on reversal and saving of Earth 38 but we will see what is relevant to the shows live on in a single merged Earth by the end of the whole Crisis event.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (6)11
u/mechengr17 Dec 09 '19
Yeah, that would be kind of lame
Also, I hate to say this, but I hope Argo City stays gone from a narrative perspective.
Its just too convenient, and it makes no sense.
→ More replies (2)
33
u/Robosmores This Sub is Bitchin' Dec 09 '19
F in chat for Oliver
→ More replies (6)27
u/Shoto-Star Dec 09 '19
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFMassive F in the chat for Ollie :(
→ More replies (2)
16
u/sapphir8 Dec 09 '19
Excellent start to the crossover. Loved seeing the Titans and Burt Ward. I am pretty sure had West still been alive, he would be a cameo. TBH, when I first saw those shadow things, I was like they must have consulted Kojima and used his BTs.
45
u/reece1495 Dec 09 '19
2 things i thought were dumb
the anti monitors ultimate prison was just a room in a sewer under a city. not very grand and cosmic
barry sees a wells appear out of thin air wearing a whacky alien cosmic looking outfit and assumes its nash just because thats the last wells he saw even though he knows there is a multiverse of them out there. way to reach barry ( even though he was right )
41
u/linkman0596 Dec 09 '19
He did also know Nash had some kinda knowledge of the monitor, so for him to show up right after the monitor would point to this wells being nash
36
Dec 09 '19
The anti-monitor's prison wasn't a room in a sewer. Nash said that it was an interdimensional door on the other side. So only the entrance was in a sewer (why? who knows).
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (5)19
u/The_Koala_Knight Dec 09 '19
It was probably because of Well's haircut. Each Well's has a different hair cut..
45
u/thecursedham Dec 09 '19
My biggest complaint about previous crossovers was that they always shit on Ollie so that scene where Sara says "The Oliver Queen of every earth is a hero" (ignoring Earth X) was extremely cathartic.
Also a lot of people saying Ollie's death isn't real but I think it is in a sense. I think we'll see Ollie becoming the Spectre from here on out and his big reveal will be in the final episode of the 3 parter. I think 2046 Arrow will also return to be a more traditional Green Arrow who gets the end The Monitor foresaw.
→ More replies (6)
15
15
29
u/Pksoze Dec 09 '19
Who would have thought when Arrow started that Ollie would die fighting shadow demons.
Anyway Alex didn't need to apologize to Lena...this was about saving the human race from annihilation...if Lena needed to be coddled for that she really is as bad as we think.
→ More replies (1)20
14
u/Davidleilam Martian Manhunter Dec 09 '19
So is Titans universe gone?
→ More replies (10)27
u/neoblackdragon Dec 09 '19
No I think a few universes are getting red skies which is an initial warning. E1 has red skies but wasn't next on the chopping block.
→ More replies (2)
14
u/NatAwsom1138 Dec 09 '19
Wow. That's a lot to unpack. Let's see what I remember off the top of my head:
Seeing Burt Ward was awesome, and Batman '66 is officially retroactive Arrowverse canon (even if it's gone).
Lois and Clark having to send their son away when they're about to die was so heartbreaking, but it was really cool seeing him in the same position as his parents. The scene where Argo exploded suddenly made me forget about Superman's involvement in the crossover, and I thought they were dead and would be brought back later.
Seeing all these heroes team up after so much build up is really satisfying.
Oliver's death - I'm going to be honest, it feels a little underwhelming, at least right now. On the one hand, Oliver saved nearly a billion people with no arrows, and his death happening in part one was a big surprise.But as I said, the way it's done just feels somewhat underwhelming, and I think it should have been saved for later. Maybe it will be undone somehow and he'll get a proper send off later, but we'll see.
Overall, though, this was a really exciting start to the crossover. Everything meshed together nicely, and I'm really excited to see what comes next. I'm also interested to see the Arrowverse reddit and other sites be updated to include other shows that have been made canon.
14
u/EldradMustLive214 Lena Luthor Dec 09 '19
Damn, I love that they only brought over 3 billion from Earth 38. I hope they address the population inflation and influx of likely doppelgängers. Makes me wonder what they’re going to do about the worlds from Black Lightning and Smallville.
→ More replies (2)
13
u/bcanada92 Dec 09 '19
OK, last time I saw Nash was on The Flash, where he finally opened the door in the sewer, which was obviously The Anti-Monitor's prison. Next time I see him is at the end of Supergirl, where he appears in costume, saying he's responsible for releasing The Anti-Monitor, and he's now Pariah.
Note that none of the other heroes says, "Wait, the Anti-Who?" It's like they know exactly who he's talking about.
So did I miss an episode of another show or a teaser or something where they actually showed Nash interacting with The Anti-Monitor?
→ More replies (3)26
13
u/sirnacreations Dec 09 '19
Non spoiler thoughts (I posted on my Facebook so didn't want to be a dick. Haha)
Wow just wow. This was beauty. It was such a dense episode and I would have loved for it to be a full hour
They've managed to capture the story of the original story so far from a 12 issue series to a 3.50 hour movie. Watching the episode I got flashbacks to panels from the story and how it matches up pretty well.
Being a Supergirl show it managed to move a few character points along so if you watched Supergirl then you will pick up on it.
There's such a treasure trove of references to the Arrowverse shows that you will geek out when you hear them. A few of them tie into the narrative story and it is amazing to see them come back in the ways they do.
The music was grand. Blame Neely really nailed it with the full orchestral.
So many great character moment. Kara and Clark. Kate and someone, Sara and Oliver, it's so good to see these people interact and the actors have such a great chemistry.
I swear one of the MVPs is LaMonica Garrett. I fell in love with his acting in Elseworlds and he truly carries the character so well. He has such a love of the lore that really makes me appreciate his performances.
The cameso. Just watch. That's all I 'll say.You will love them. Same thing with Oliver's development and story arc.
Going to be honest, this is shaping up to be more epic than Infinity War and Endgame. It is definitely more ambitious.
→ More replies (6)
12
11
11
u/thefalcon85 Dec 09 '19
So I take it that Kara and her people are now part of Earth-1.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/ConnorMarsh Dec 09 '19
Episode 4 of Crisis appears to be a Monitor/Anti-Monitor origin story
→ More replies (1)
11
u/TheCVR123YT Superman Dec 09 '19
Don’t Know if anyone here watches Blindwave but I literally cannot wait to see them screaming tomorrow lol
→ More replies (3)
11
u/spursgalea Dec 09 '19
I don't believe for one minute that we seen the last of Oliver. To have diggle not there doesn't make sense to me
→ More replies (2)
11
u/Ethosa3 Lena Luthor Dec 09 '19
Alura really just put another child in a pod, huh?
I'm still mad that E-38 got zero preparation for Crisis, especially with everything Kara just lost in one fell swoop. I feel like she's just... breakdown imminent.
Loved seeing Lena just comin thru and saving billions of lives. Excited to what Lex has planned out for her.
And definitely did not expect Oliver to die so early on. It was a little anti-climatic, I feel like this death won't last.
→ More replies (2)
31
Dec 09 '19
Didn't get a chance to watch live. Two questions, and I don't mind spoilers:
Was there a crisis?
If so, was this crisis on infinite Earths?
18
16
u/jezusbagels Dec 09 '19
Yes
Right now, I'd describe it as a crisis on some earths, perhaps a crisis on several earths. Hard to see it as more than a crisis on a plethora of earths at worst.
→ More replies (3)25
10
10
u/ShaunTheShrimp Dec 09 '19
He's not dead yet.
His final scene is in a different place.
→ More replies (5)
10
u/AnnaK22 PIZZA 🍕 AND POTSTICKERS 🥟 Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
I should have seen it coming. They had sympathetic one on one scenes between Oliver and his loved ones. I should have known he was going to die when Sara called the future ollie a good man on every earth.
I am appalled that the Arrowverse actually had Oliver dying. I can't wait to see how Barry and Kara react to his sacrifice for them.
Did it feel like the Monitor had a whole different respect for Oliver. He didnt listen to anyone else and just snapped them to Earth 1. With oliver, he actually listened to him, didn't want to defy him.
→ More replies (5)
10
u/Adas_Legend Dec 09 '19
There is ample proof that this is not THE death of Ollie we've been anticipating:
The Arrow promo showed a shot of Oliver looking up with Barry looking over him. This is likely going to be Oliver's permanent death
Preview pics for the Flash ep show Oliver and Diggle. I refuse to believe they would do something cheap like this being yet another different Oliver doppelgänger. The pics seem to be on Lian Yu, and David Ramsey posted BTS of himself, Stephen, Kat McNamara, and Matt Ryan on what looks like Lian Yu. Also, it appears that Tom Ellis was seen doing a scene with David Ramsey, Kat, and Matt, and even though he denied being in the crossover, he could very easily be pulling a Arrow season 5 Manu Bennett and lying about it. So maybe he plays a part in getting Diggle, Mia, and Constantine to some kind of afterlife to bring Oliver back
Stephen Amell said he nearly fell asleep during his last scene with Grant and posted a video clip of what appeared to the Waverider's med bay. So it would make sense that he breathes his last there in episode 4 or episode 5.
Plus, the way this "death" happened is VERY suspicious.
We didn't get true and proper goodbyes with Sara and Barry. We can't count E16 Ollie's scene with Sara
The scene was very rushed. As someone else mentioned here, this will likely be a very melodramatic moment.
We barely SAW anything. Last we saw, he was hale and hearty and recklessly charging unarmed at the shadow demons. Next thing we know, he's bloodied up. When he finally dies, it has to be an epic moment.
Who here agrees?
9
u/shadow_spinner0 Dec 09 '19
So like other crossovers it seems each episode will focus on the cast of that specific episode. This part we had development with Lena, Kelly is I guess Guardian now and Nia makes her brief appearance (come on writers do something with her). Will anyone from Batwoman make an appearance? I'm sure people from Flash, Arrow and Legends will.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Ozzdo Dec 09 '19
So what is Earth 1 going to do with the 3 billion extra people from Earth 38? Some of whom, I would assume, already have a version of themselves on Earth 1? That is one hell of a refugee crisis.
→ More replies (4)11
u/Nightsong Supergirl Dec 09 '19
If this goes the route of the comics, it ends with one merged Earth and only the heroes present at the final battle remembering the various alternate earths. So I don't think we've seen the end of Argo or Earth 38 yet, I have a feeling elements of that universe will live on in the single, merged universe at the end.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/ContinuumGuy The Flash Dec 09 '19
Wow. Just... wow. They really got straight to it. From the opening narration to the first commercial break, there's hardly any room to breath. And, man, even knowing that obviously in the end the day will be saved and these shows (save for Arrow) will go on, they really give you the feeling of just how fucked they are.
Tuning forks! Shadow demons! Two things that I never thought I'd see in live-action.
It's weird seeing the contrast between the bits where they were able to spend a lot of money (gratuitous cameos, the CGI for the tuning fork which was surprisingly well-done TBH) and the bits where they didn't have the budget (the tuning fork is defended... in a office lobby and the top of a building).
Pour one out for Earth-66 Dick Grayson. If only he had had some Bat-Anti-Monitor Repellent. Also pour one out for Alexander Knox and how those old Arl$$ checks have dried up for Robert Wuhl.
If Kara goes to Smallville-verse and sees Lois there could be quite the scene.
Nice how they brought back old man Arrow.
I am shocked they killed Ollie in hour one. I'm sure we'll see Stephen more during the crossover (flashbacks, other alternate Earths, time travel fuckery, etc.), but I honestly thought he'd last at least to the Arrow hour. I thought the death scene was well done, by the way, although I'm disappointed Diggle, Laurel, Dinah, and the rest weren't around. Really hope they don't skip over all of that.
9
u/balgruufgat Dec 09 '19
"You're a hero on every Earth."
Yeah, probably best to not mention that Earth where he was the führer. Might ruin the point.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/edd6pi Dec 09 '19
If Oliver could save one billion lives by himself, imagine how many could have been saved If The Monitor hadn’t forcibly removed everyone else.
→ More replies (4)
16
u/Ygomaster07 Dreamer Dec 09 '19
Alright, time for a post episode breakdown on part one of Crisis On Infinite Earths!!!!!!
So we actually now have confirmed that the Titans universe is a part of the multiverse, with them taking place on Earth 89, right next to Earth 90 and the 90's Flash.
Okay, i love the "Holy crimson skies of death" line. Nice to see a cameo from the og live action Robin.
We also get a nice cameo from The Ray on Earth X, which goes nicely with the tie in comic that was announced a little while back.
Superman vs the dirty diaper. I'd watch that.
Argo is destroyed and Kara's mother is dead. They are already setting the stakes high.
Legends, changing histroy for the better, except for when it comes to hetting free drinks. Also, i like that throwback to the season 4 premiere, i had completely forgotten about that. I like it.
Batwoman sucker punching Lyla was fucking hilarious.
"This one talks to rabbits." Brainy is an absolute gift.
Oliver, still loves his bro Barry. Sweet.
I also want to say, i love the voice over intro from the Monitor. Pretty good.
So there are quantum towers on various earths as safeguards. That's pretty cool.
The Anti Monitor's army looks like Time Wraiths, or the things from the Harry Potter movies(I've never seen them so i don't know their names).
Woah, they referenced Star City 2046?!?! Way back from season one of LoT!!! And that apparently is on a different earth, which is kind of weird. Conveniently, it is on Earth 16, which is the year Legends started in and when the episode aired. Nice easter egg there.
So on the subject of Sara returning to Star City 2046, the Oliver there is much younger than he was on the LoT episode. In LoT, he had grey hair. This Oliver doesn't seem to have it.
I really like that Sara and Earth 16 Oliver had that talk. It's like they are addressing a part they haven't talked about before, just clearing the air on that particular topic.
Small appearance from Nia. It is always nice seeing her on screen and in costume.
We see Lena, and i like that it was Alex who went to her, since Alex is the last person who wants to trust Lena. I also like how Alex saved Lena from getting hit with debris, and suggested some kind of thing in order to get the portal device to work properly.
Brainy's space ship is huge. Hiding that on Earth must be a pain in the ass.
Kelly using James' shield to protect someone from getting hit with debris. Pretty nice.
So they are evacuating Earth 38. Damn.
The Monitor teleports everyone of the heroes before the earth is fully evacuated. Ollie shoots him with an arrow to prevent him from getting teleported. So Oliver stays behind and fights this army by himself as the anti matter army by himself as Earth 38 gets consumed.
Oliver is transported to Star City on Earth 1 with the others. He tells Barry and Kara how they were the best of them, and that his sacrifice was so that they could live. Oliver tells Mia that he wants her to tell Felicity and William that he loves them all. Oliver then passes away, while Barry, Kara, and Mia stand there shedding tears. The Monitor appears with Nash Wells, who noe goes by Pariah and reveals he released the Anti Monitor. The Monitor says that Oliver's death was different from what he foresaw, with Pariah stating that means everything is happening differently than from what they predicted would happen. We also learn that since Oliver stayed behind on Earth 38 to fight the army, he helped save an extra 1 billion lives. We then close out on the ending credits.
Some other neat things. We get a cameo from Wil Wheaton. Pretty cool. Also, when Sara leaves Earth 16 Oliver, she says every version of him is good. She must have forgotten about Earth X Oliver, who was a literal nazi. Also, Batwoman threatening Ray with breaking his hand, and then charging up one of her Batarangs with energy was really fucking cool!
So that is it. Earth 38, along with Argo and the rest of the universe, is gone, destroyed. 4.5 billion of 7.5 billion people on Earth 38 got out before Earth 38 was completely destroyed. Oliver is dead. The first part is over. Their final stand now has to be done on Earth 1. It looks like the cast of Supergirl will take place on Earth 1 if they don't get Earth 38 and the rest of the universe back. Nash basically started the Crisis. Oliver died within the first part of Crisis, which feels weird, but i feel like seeing Earth 16 Oliver wasn't a coincidence. I feel that he will sacrifice hisself in order to bring back Earth 1 Oliver. It feels like Oliver's death wasn't proper, he didn't get to say his goodbyes to everyone he cares about.
Alright, the first part of the 5 part Crisis event crossover is done! I really enjoyed this, we got a lot of great interactions, and they set the stakes really high. My only gripe is that Oliver died, his death felt premature. Lot's of cool throwbacks and callbacks to other shows, and to past events in the Arrowverse. 10 out of 10 for this episode. I say that a lot, but this truly deserves that high of a rating(so do other episodes, but i mean this is Crisis, so it gets an immediate 10 out of 10 from me). Here's to next episode tomorrow!!!!!!! I hope everyone is enjoying the Crisis crossover as much as i am!!!!!!!
→ More replies (7)
8
8
u/Gateskp Brainy Dec 09 '19
WHOA did LaMonica just say he's the Anti-Monitor too?
→ More replies (6)11
8
u/enygma9753 Dec 09 '19
Barry and Kara now know that their lives post-Elseworlds were bought and paid for by Oliver's sacrifice. SG's Earth-38 is now gone, as is Argo City and other alternate earths. Earth-1 should still be around, but it's likely next in line for Crisis.
I liked that scene with Sara and Earth-16 Oliver too. He expressed remorse for taking her aboard the Gambit long ago, not knowing how much that decision changed their lives for the better, and she let him know that he was still a good man.
(I agree with others that this ep. isn't Oliver/GA's final rodeo in Crisis. Too abrupt to be his last scene ever -- it's The CW, they're going to milk the melodramatic living daylights out of Oliver's eventual last moment.)
There is still a multiverse around (for now) ... but he'll eventually punch his ticket out by the end. Wouldn't put it past Barry or Sara if they were to meddle with timelines to try to fix or reset things, even though I'd like to think they know better by now.
But with Oliver (for now) being RIP and likely the only one who could have reasoned with them not to risk it, it is Crisis and all options would be on the table.
→ More replies (6)
8
u/theSaltySolo Dec 09 '19
Did Oliver stun the fucking Monitor with a arrow?
This guy shouldn’t be losing to anyone at this point.
→ More replies (1)
15
15
Dec 09 '19
HEY IT'S GUGGIE
25
u/nomadic_stalwart Dec 09 '19
Putting his hatred for Kevin Smith aside for this is the actual most impressive team up.
→ More replies (8)
15
7
u/stu_25 Dec 09 '19
Considering there's still an episode of Arrow left I wonder... If not what a way to go for Oliver.
Of course this is just the 1st part but the action was good and hopefully gets more with the story.
Earth 38 was dead, they made that clear in the promos but the evacuation scene was well done.
Monitor talking to Oliver rather than making him disappear... oops... though it shows respect Novu has.
Oliver taking out Novu though? How did he do that? The thing he had Curtis make?
And why is 2046 Oliver not the same from Legends?
Argh questions!
→ More replies (8)
7
u/Munro_McLaren Lena Luthor Dec 09 '19
Lena and Kelly better have made it off Earth 38!
→ More replies (2)
19
u/GKMLTT Dec 09 '19
Shadow demons are kind of pathetic. "Let's fly aimlessly, then attack one at a time."
Plus, they're basically Naruto shadow-clones and poof after one hit. >_>
I expected the cameos would be brief too, but damn. At least Titans did make the cut, for what it was.
And it appears Lena's schtick is going to be declaring, "This don't change nothin', Hoss!" at every opportunity for the rest of the season.
Wasn't super hot on the episode (felt really choppy), but it had a few good moments and now that the setup is out of the way, hopefully things do pick up.
→ More replies (5)
13
6
u/nl_alexxx Übergirl Dec 09 '19
All the posts about the Titans cameos are being deleted from their subreddit lol
→ More replies (5)
6
u/klutzysunshine Dec 09 '19
So how exactly are all these people from Earth-38 supposed to settle on Earth 1? They need like everything.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/AnnaK22 PIZZA 🍕 AND POTSTICKERS 🥟 Dec 09 '19
If they only managed to save a couple billion people from Earth 38, what does that mean for TEAM super? Alex, Nia, Kelly, J'onn, Lena must have been snapped away somewhere else by The Monitor cause I can't imagine them jumping into the portal until everyone on their earth is safe. Unless they really are gone along with E38, but will be brought back at the end.
→ More replies (6)
6
u/glitterydick Dec 09 '19
Just found out the last two episodes of Crisis take place on my birthday. Nice. All I want as a gift is John Stewart Diggle, Green Lantern. I hope that's not too much to ask, but it probably is.
→ More replies (2)
6
u/CaptainFlash18 Dec 09 '19
Ok I know there are more important things to talk about but when Kate threatened Ray I saw Alex look impressed and I loved it
→ More replies (1)
6
6
Dec 09 '19
Okay so they said the Titans cameo wasn't going to happen and then it did.
I am now 1000% convinced the Lucifer Morningstar cameo is happening.
→ More replies (9)
5
5
5
5
5
u/mcarba Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
We still have Barry and his complex relationship with timeline.
But it would be amazing if Oliver stays dead. It gonna be "fuck the destiny,Monitor, I choose how I die,who is wise all-seeing God now?". But I doubt that would happen.
Also seeing batwoman fighting demons was so comic book silly. I love it. I love how CW nails the comics style in their shows.
5
5
5
5
5
u/lunaluciferr Dec 09 '19
Theres no way arrow dies off show and in part 1.
That cut away was too stupid of a thing to do even for the CW if it was his actual death, so I'm guessing Barry goes back in time and collects Oliver right before he's about to die to the dementors.
They do some COIE shenanigans then Oliver makes a bigger, more emotional sacrifice.
Then, to make sure the timeline isn't changed, Barry returns an Oliver who is about to die to the same place we saw in part 1 moments later (to keep the loop of them thinking he just died so Barry goes back in time to get him)
5
Dec 09 '19
"Fastest man alive turns up late to the crisis we've been expecting for years" holy damnnn
5
u/Barry_McKackiner Superman Dec 09 '19 edited Dec 09 '19
Lena: Attempts to telepathically lobotomize the entire planet to how she thinks people should behave.
Also Lena: "how dare you think i'm a villain!"
→ More replies (1)
4
u/mhurton Dec 09 '19
This makes me believe flash is definitely gonna die in his own episode to make us sad over the break
4
u/MrBubbles9039 Dec 09 '19
In the aftershow Kat said that we see and Oliver and Mia training scene sooooo
→ More replies (1)
4
4
u/MoRiellyMoProblems Dec 09 '19
I don't know how I'll be able to contain myself when they show KC Superman and Smallville Superman.
4
4
u/Zegir Dec 09 '19
So, Earth-38 is destroyed. All of the baddies from over there are on Earth-1 now. Batwoman is up next and her Earth is Earth-1(?). They can't destroy Earth-1 unless they keep portal hoping people from Earth to Earth, which isn't feasible.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/OLKv3 Dec 09 '19
There's no way Oliver is truly dead. Also strange and messed up how they just left Oliver-16 lol. Especially when they need as many heroes as possible
4
Dec 09 '19
Structurally, it makes sense for the more important guest stars to not appear in Episode 1, escalating plot and all that, but it’s funny that all 3 guest stars who would fit in most on Supergirl (returning Lex and both Supermen) didn’t appear at all.
4
Dec 09 '19
Honestly, it was everything I wanted it to be until Oliver died.
Don’t get me wrong, I absolutely loved the episode. The surprise Titans cameo, the Sara/Oliver moments, the Oliver/Mia moments, hell every character interaction was on point, Star 2046 being Earth-16 for some reason (wish Connor was there tbh), Jon Kent being introduced, all the new lore drops with the first mention of the Anti-Monitor and the towers, Lena and Brainy having a decent sized part in the story (Nia making her first crossover appearance as well), it was well worth the wait.
But I wasn’t prepared to actually sit here and watch Oliver die at the end of the first of five parts of this crossover. Even if he gets brought back somehow, I just didn’t think I’d have to see that so soon. I can’t even process that he just straight up (possibly) died right there. And now I have no idea where we’re going with this because Oliver dying this early literally wasn’t supposed to happen according to the all knowing space god.
→ More replies (4)
4
Dec 09 '19
The Oliver dying scene was so fucking cheesy. The only decent acting was his daughter lol.
4
u/TrippySakuta Dec 09 '19
Our Oliver's obviously going to come back in some form. Since the producers made clear the death was intentional, and each show's cast will deal with the loss in their own way.
So, non-bullshit options of resurrecting him. Way too late for the Lazarus Pit (development-wise) and probably too late for Speed Force time travel (total cop-out).
Legends:
The Waverider's med bay: Gideon brought back Sara shortly after she was killed once. Didn't work for Stein, because that was supernatural. Oliver presumably died of mortal wounds; so unless the writers use Parademons or his light magic it works.
Constantine: Lifeforce transference, or light magic. Likely light magic; Oliver is his friend, and this would officially close the case on his light magic tattoo, signaling his real death.
Team Flash:
Barry's speed healing: Requires the Waverider's med bay to momentarily revive him. Might set up Red Death if he gets a transfusion that includes Bloodwork's remaining cells.
Bloodwork: His blood can reanimate people. It can self-replicate, can it heal people? (I can't remember, so correct me on that. Ralph is set to take part in the Crisis, so they could pay a visit to ARGUS and just bring Allegra along to cure him. Also, Ramsey's blood can only make himself mutate so far.
Arrow:
Lian Yu herbs: Unlikely, but...
Mar Novu:
Cosmic Resurrection/Rebirth: Brought back Lex Luthor from death, could do the same. It's hard to tell if he'd pull the rebirth stunt on Oliver though, considering he actually likes him (as opposed to Lyla, who as far as we know he probably sees as a tool and nothing more).
Supergirl, Batwoman and Black Lightning don't have resurrection methods or tech, if I recall correctly.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Eternal_Density Dec 09 '19
Lena Luthor: *builds an Ori supergate*
meanwhile at S.T.A.R. Labs, Earth 1...
Gideon: "Hallowed are the Ori!"
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Cyber-Logic Dec 09 '19
I KNEW Blake Neely would have something sneaky up his sleeve!
I was filled with joy when I heard the Batman themes in the intro. <3
7
7
•
u/MajorParadox DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Dec 09 '19
Watching the Crisis Aftermath special hosted by Kevin Smith? Come discuss it here!