r/GameDealsMeta • u/gamedealsmod • Jun 14 '19
Lootbox bundles are now banned in /r/GameDeals
Starting today, we'll be removing lootbox bundles in /r/GameDeals. That is, bundles which give a randomized and individual game key to buyers.
Lootbox bundles are being specifically addressed because they represent an unknown value, and because they encourage repeated purchases. Rather than getting a dud bundle once, buyers are encouraged to try many times to get what they're actually interested in.
As of today, Fanatical and GMG's mystery key bundles will no longer be allowed to be posted. The Humble Bundle Monthly and Groupees' bundles will not be affected because they are not lootbox-style (everybody receives the same content).
Before we jump into the comments, I think it's important to explain why it took so long to reach this decision.
Large policy decisions like this require a strong consensus. For obvious reasons, we shouldn't introduce major rule changes without ample consideration. As our moderator team is spread across the globe however, getting everybody together to work out all the issues and edge cases can take a long time. It took multiple attempts and rescheduling to finally get this one right.
Additionally, this is a surprisingly complicated issue. The initial complaint being raised wasn't just of lootbox bundles, but blind bundles of any sort. Many users had concerns about encouraging gambling, and in theory this would apply to any bundle with unknown elements. That's Humble Monthly, Groupees pre-purchases, and of course Fanatical's mystery bundles. There was a lot to unpack.
We decided that the gambling concern is at its worst when bundles are designed to encourage not just one purchase, but many, as lootbox-style bundles are. And while there is still uncertainty to more traditional blind bundles such as the Humble Monthly, the information available often lets you make a more educated decision ahead of time.
When all is said and done, this is a compromise. There is no perfect solution because everyone has different reasons for liking or disliking blind bundles. For some it's the uncertainty aspect. For others it's frustration that they're not receiving the same games as others. We did our best to identify the major pain points and reach a decision that suits the majority.
We know that there was value in seeing which games other users were getting. While we won't be hosting a place for that anymore, we can recommend SteamGifts as a forum which covers this same information. I know it's frustrating not having that deal information all on one site, but having a topic for sharing results is really no different than just linking the deals in the first place.
We thank you for your time and understanding. This has been a - shall we say - contentious topic. For that reason we'll be strictly enforcing rule #1: be kind in this thread. We welcome your thoughts on the matter though, and ask that you recognize that there was no perfect solution in this case.
Thank you.
28
u/mattlantis Jun 14 '19
I think this is the correct choice. Humblebundle has its own subreddit so people who enjoy these Fanatical bundles could create a subreddit to discuss their pulls (and other more general Fanatical bundles/deals). I had less of an issue with GMG because at least they disclosed the odds but ultimately I think this decision is for the better.
14
u/thmanwithnoname Jun 14 '19
Awesome. This is exactly what I was hoping for. Thanks for the effort and thoughtfulness, mods.
12
u/capnwinky Jun 14 '19
I purchased a blind bundle once (actually think it was Groupees) and was so disappointed by what I received that it was also the last time I bought one. I had a feeling it was going to be a gamble, and it was.
14
u/FSMFan_2pt0 Jun 14 '19
This exactly highlights why these deals exist. It's a way to get you to open your wallet to receive games you would not have ordinarily bought, and certainly not if you knew what you were buying.
"Mystery" = you don't know what you're getting because if you did, you wouldn't buy it. It's that simple. If the items were enticing, they wouldn't need to be hidden. And like casinos, you can rest assured that the math benefits them and not you.
2
u/fishboy3339 Jun 15 '19
Yeah, if your not ok with being disappointed don’t buy mystery bundles. The cost is so low on those it’s fine. I’m not expecting 5 AAA titles for $13. If I get one game I like it’s worth it. Plus you get to discover games you might not play otherwise.
4
u/sammagee33 Jun 15 '19
Exact same scenario for me. I could easily see how people can be suckered into buying multiple loot bundles at a time. Thankfully, I only did it once.
1
u/Saneless Jun 17 '19
And that's the point of it. Instead of spending $0 to get nothing, you spent $3 or whatever to get nothing. Free $3 for them.
1
u/Ferromagneticfluid Jun 15 '19
Well you probably learned from the experience.
Much like I learned what value to expect out of random stuff like this when I bought Booster packs of MTG when I was much younger.
0
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
I've had it both ways. I always do them knowing it's a grab bag and just do it once. Could win. Could not win. There's a ton of stuff like that in life.
2
Jun 14 '19
But on a subreddit for buying cheap games it doesn't really belong.
3
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
But the games are actually cheap by comparison to what they would normally sell for... like every time. It doesn't mean you're going to get a 60usd game in a 8 dollar pack though. But you're generally likely to get games that are 15-20 and even if discounted would total more than what you paid. The issue isn't that it's a subreddit for buying cheap games the issue is you simply don't know what you're gonna get, you can't accurately assess the cost and savings and you can't assess the perceived value because you can't even tell if you'll be interested in what you get. They're by definition generally a pretty good deal numbers wise, it's the unknown random nature of it coupled with personal interest that complicates it.
I didn't even say they have a place here or not so it's kind of pointless to respond in that nature. I just was sharing my experience like the other person as well as how I approach them.
10
u/Ciahcfari Jun 14 '19
Smart move.
Leave advertising gambling to the triple A leeches, we consumers have to be better.
9
u/CantWashABaby Jun 15 '19
I read in the Fanatical thread yesterday that someone posted the contents of the FOUR boxes they bought, and how it was all shit. They spent 28 dollars that could easily purchase a great single game (or two months of Monthly) on a bunch of dime store keys. I know it’s their money to spend, but Jesus Christ that was depressing.
15
7
7
u/myripyro Jun 14 '19
Great decision, and well-explained. Despite some minor trolling in this thread, I expect there won't be too many people disappointed by this decision, based on how quickly lootbox threads get downvoted to 0 (and based on how many comments in those threads boil down to 'you probably shouldn't buy this!').
7
12
u/fondleear Jun 14 '19
They were basically using this method to get extra cash for the same keys that would have in all likelihood been sold cheaper in the past .
When Fanatical started doing it too ,unsurprisingly , warning bells started ringing and here we are.
I did assume Fanatical would be above such things but they seem to be happily continuing down this path.
Glad to see someone is finally speaking up about this.
2
u/throwawastedyouth Jun 15 '19
I was very late to the game, only building a pc and buying games just before the change to Fanatical, but in the short time I was familiar with Bundlestars, I felt they were above such things.
3
u/CyraxPT Jun 15 '19
I did assume Fanatical would be above such things but they seem to be happily continuing down this path.
I find it funny how a few days back they were teasing something about a machine and how "they heard us". I honestly didn't know what was all this about and thought it was related to some survey they made a while back and now they were implementing.
In no way i ever thought that this was going to be another lootbox bundle.
Like, i don't care if they do or not this type of scams, i think that people should know better by now, but the whole "we heard you and we're doing this for you" message with the reveal being another shitty lootbox bundle just rub in the wrong way.
6
6
u/Lextron Jun 15 '19 edited Jun 15 '19
thank you! I do not come here to gamble. 96% upvoted, not a terribly controversial call!
10
u/kyaputen_hs Jun 14 '19
The upvotes on this decision and the massive downvotes for past gambling threads speak for themselves. Thank you mods.
5
5
u/RoMaAg Jun 15 '19
I want to express my happiness with this decision, it is indeed very good! Keep up the good work, thanks for tackling the issue!
4
4
u/AllSaintOx Jun 15 '19
I like to do a little mystery game gambling from time to time, and I've gotten some good games from it, but they're not really what I'd call a "deal", so I can definitely understand why they don't belong here.
4
u/Watcher13 Jun 15 '19
Honestly, I didn't even know that game key 'loot boxes' were a thing, but I'm already glad they're banned. That's some anti - consumer shit, and I don't want anything to do with it. So, thanks mods, I support this choice.
4
Jun 15 '19
Nice, I totally agree that it promotes gambling, just wasted $6 on that Fanatical 6 random keys. Was debating on asking for a refund since I didn't redeem them yet, but now I guess I'll do a giveaway.
4
4
4
u/valriia Jun 16 '19
I hope this kind of practice becomes legally restricted in time, the same as loot boxes in games have been considered gambling in some places.
4
u/JaFakeItTillYouJaMak Jun 17 '19
I consider this perfectly reasonable. I mean it's one thing if we all buy an unknown bundle and I end up with Cyberpunk 2077 and someone else ends up with The Last Door. That's just wild unfair nonsense. Blind bundles like Monthly at least promise that we all get the same game. It makes your decision simply whether or not to buy rather than how many to buy. I think this is an obvious decision but regardless of how much effort was required I'm glad it was made. Carry on one of the few mod teams to not have a single red tag.
10
u/draakierules Jun 14 '19
This seems like a fair and balanced decision. Thanks for taking such good care of us!
7
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
I think this is fair. One and done random bundles are fine to me but not the grab bag multiple purchase style.
3
u/-------------------7 Jun 14 '19
Can you elaborate further on some Groupee bundles that include a grab bag styled component, either as part of the original bundle or as a bonus or option. I figure its such an insignificant part of the bundle it, would be a shame to ban it on that tiny component itself.
Eg. Groupees 6er bundle had 5 games and 1 grab bag.
7
u/SquareWheel Jun 14 '19
Good question. While it's not specified in the wording of the rule, we can judge if it's the main focus of the bundle or not. Groupees seems to just fill one item in with a "grab bag" but otherwise it's a standard bundle. That would be acceptable unless there's a much larger emphasis placed on the random loot aspect.
3
3
u/binary__dragon Jun 15 '19
Sounds good to me. I really appreciate the mods of this forum working so hard to keep it up to standards that allow me to have trust in the content I find here.
I'm curious, suppose there was a hypothetical bundle which offered one or more predefined games, but with that bundle there was also an individually randomized key. Would that be allowed under this rule? I feel it should still fit, since the value is clearly on the predefined keys and the random ones are "icing" which wouldn't encourage multiple purchases, but I'm not completely sure.
3
3
3
Jun 15 '19
Good call. "Mystery Bundles" are just dumping grounds with a very rare chance of something decent. Treat them the same as in-game lootboxes. Preying on an addiction with no age gate.
I agree that HB Monthly is different as it gives you a known game or two beforehand. The unknown games should only ever be considered as a bonus and not inherent to overall value which does, thankfully, seem to be the consensus.
3
u/EyesLikeBuscemi Jun 16 '19
Fine if these aren't posted but I do agree with the folks who disagree with the fact that Humble Bundle Monthly stays. That should go too. It, too, is gambling. Just with one or two items revealed to entice people to gamble too.
2
u/Foxhack Jun 16 '19
Everyone's getting the same games so it's not the same situation. (Except when there's region shenanigans.)
1
5
5
6
u/Relative_Result Jun 14 '19
I agree 100% to remove them from here.
It won`t stop these jerks from scamming people but at least they won`t get the exposure from here.
Well done
4
4
u/xcoleyz Jun 15 '19
As with gambling I doubt these blind bundles are fully random....
2
u/swordtut Jun 15 '19
the house always wins
1
u/Kabal2020 Jun 18 '19
And I don't think there is anything in this case to check they are as fair as actual gambling. I assume these fall outside of gambling legislation in most areas.
7
5
u/Doctursea Jun 14 '19
Thank you. Random Keys for cheaper isn't a game deal, that's just how lottery buying works.
I could literally only see it if it was a small poor of 60$ games for less than 10 dollars, and even then that's dubious.
2
u/NikStalwart Jun 16 '19
I support this decision. Bravo mods!
I set up a keyword filter in gmail to autospam the mystery stuff they send me.
2
2
u/Cuddly_Kitty Jun 16 '19
I don't have a problem with this. I prefer to know what I'm buying before I buy it. :3
2
u/Saneless Jun 17 '19
Thank you.
The power was always with the sellers in this one and I'm all for not propagating the imbalance.
2
u/Armani_8 Jun 18 '19
Man, Rest in Peace Fanatical. This was basically their entire business model.
This is fantastic news, and I'm glad that GMG and Fanatical will be peddling their mystery box garbage somewhere else.
4
u/KING_of_Trainers69 Jun 14 '19
Fair enough. They're never a good deal, and they're just a type of gambling where the house has explicit control over the odds. I'm not going to miss seeing that sort of content here.
4
u/MustLoveAllCats Jun 14 '19
They're never a good deal,
They're a good deal when you get what you were hoping for on the first or second try. They are however designed to lure people in with the thought of getting something really cheap, but on average, paying way more for it than they would otherwise, and generally play out this way. If everyone would just stop purchasing them, we'd see an end to these sorts of predatory business practices, but people are stupid, people enjoy gambling, and the two are often not mutually exclusive.
2
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
Numbers wise they can easily be a good deal. 5 dollars for what is 50 worth of games is a "good deal" but that doesn't mean you're interested in them. 90% off a barbie game is a good deal but it means nothing to me as I'm not interested. That's kind of an important distinction to make. You can't really make any assessment without knowing anything other than its gonna total out higher than you spent and its just a risk.
3
u/imafeckinturtle Jun 14 '19
I'm glad this decision was made, I bought 2 mystery bundles before and got games I already owned or games I didn't care about and I wouldn't have known they existed if I didn't see them getting posted here, the 2nd time purchasing was me thinking "well I got bad games last time, maybe this time it will be better!" I never visit Fanatical unless I see a bundle on here so the fact I can't see the mystery bundles weirdly makes me feel safe scrolling through this subreddit knowing I shouldn't be seeing them, thanks for the lootbox bundle ban!
3
u/Alexspeed75 Jun 15 '19
Finally. Thanks.
I save myself from typing anything else, to stay within rule #1.
3
5
u/imkrut Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
"And while there is still uncertainty to more traditional blind bundles such as the Humble Monthly, the information available often lets you make a more educated decision ahead of time."
Yeah, I don´t agree with this. Groupees (and humble with monthly) do the same with the "prepurchase" BS.
At the very least Groupees pre-purchase (completely blind) post shouldn´t be allowed ( I guess you could argue that monthly at least puts up at least one or two games that you know you are buying) until they reveal their lineup.
I do agree that a big difference with "loot" bundles, is that the later encourages multiple buys, while Groupes or Bundle are just one blind purchase (unless you are some sort of masochist or something). But then again, regardless of that fact, I would argue that they both have gambling mechanics built into them.
You could then again make the point that bottom line it´s the buyer´s choice, and the subreddit should merely facilitate access to the information, but that argument falls pretty fast once you take in account that the subreddit already polices certain dealers (rightfully so) due to them being shady/having shady practices and to protect consumers (which is a good thing).
1
Jun 14 '19
This.you are still gambling by giving them money and then hoping that you get something good that month. Then they tease you with revealing one game to lure you into the offer. That BS has no place to exist like any pre order on digital stuff.
3
u/BeeGravy Jun 15 '19
Isnt that part explained by saying if you don't think the revealed game alone is worth the price, then you don't have to buy, and if you do then every other game is a bonus.
They say it's the idea of having to buy many packs to get what you want, that's bot really how those bundles work its always the same for everyone.
2
u/Iintendtooffend Jun 15 '19
At least humble always offers up the highest value items up front, anything you get is in my experience a bonus. If you don't like the humble bundle monthly offerings up front, the bonus content probably won't make up the value for you.
4
u/1j12 Jun 14 '19
Were they ever good, or have they always been bad?
10
u/caninehere Jun 14 '19
We try not to decide what constitutes a "good" or "bad" deal. There are plenty of deals people might consider "bad" on the sub, simply because it might not be a historical low, or because it features a game(s) they are not interested in - but that doesn't mean it's true for everybody, and it doesn't mean those deals don't deserve a place on the sub.
Part of the issue with these bundles is that while many may be completely uninterested in them, there are people who buy them. In the end, if there is interest, you could consider something a 'deal'. Part (but not all) of the issue is that these 'lootbox bundles' are completely blind, there is no way to know their value - which changes from buyer to buyer - and we can't legitimately say if they are a deal or not as a result.
7
u/Hold_my_Dirk Jun 14 '19
For as long as I can remember, they were almost exclusively the shovelware type of games that they had a ton of extra keys that they couldn't sell (with a very, very small number of bigger named games to entice people into actually buying them). They've just gotten more popular as more of these third party sites have become more popular.
3
u/chithanh Jun 14 '19
What are the limits of this rule? Does it apply to:
Free giveaways of random steam keys
Bundles which have both random and non-random games
Deals where you get a certain game, and a "free gift" random game on top
Game keys that generate individual random trading cards or similar items
7
u/treblah3 Jun 15 '19
What are the limits of this rule? Does it apply to:
Free giveaways of random steam keys
I don't recall a random game giveaway but that would probably be a case-by-case situation, as most giveaways are. Must be available to a significant number of users and not be a beta/trial/etc., as per rule 2. Hard to complain about a free game.
Bundles which have both random and non-random games
The only instance of this so far is Groupees, where you buy 5 games (the exact 5 games are known up front) with 1 random game thrown in - that's ok for now, as long as the ratio of known to unknown doesn't slide drastically in the other direction.
Deals where you get a certain game, and a "free gift" random game on top
I think that's covered by combining 1 and 2, but that seems fine within these rules.
Game keys that generate individual random trading cards or similar items
Also fine, we don't really police the content within the game - it's the "blind purchase of random keys" that is the issue here today.
1
Jun 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/treblah3 Jun 15 '19 edited Jun 15 '19
We have nothing to do with that sub you linked so I'm not sure what relevance it has here. We allow giveaways when a store has a free game for many people to claim, not individual giveaways or the like.
The site you linked to is an unauthorized key reseller, so they would not be allowed in GameDeals (and thus your comment linking to them has been removed).
I'm not even getting into trading cards, they are a superfluous function of Steam and not a vital component to the game.
These sound like edge cases to me; rules may not cover every single possibility, but moderators will make a judgment call on those if they pop up and go against the rules.
1
u/chithanh Jun 15 '19
We have nothing to do with that sub you linked so I'm not sure what relevance it has here.
Fair enough. My point was only that such random key giveaways happen, and I linked to a recent one just for reference, and asked whether such a thing (if coming from an approved key seller) would be permitted in r/GameDeals under the new rule.
Anyway, if I understand correctly, individual lootbox content is ok as long as:
It doesn't cost anything, or
the ratio of known to unknown content is acceptable, or
the random content is entirely in-game, or
the random content is superfluous from a gaming perspective
Did I get this right?
3
u/hellknight101 Jun 14 '19
Eh, the ban is kind of unnecessary because these posts got downvoted to oblivion, so I never saw them unless I directly searched. On the other hand, hopefully it discourages this type of business model.
I also don't approve of Humble's approach but at least they give the names of the most stand-out titles before the reveal. Had Fanatical just revealed the names of all the possible games, I don't think as many users would have had a problem with these "mystery boxes".
2
2
u/Life_Elevatored Jun 14 '19
Irony? The embedded Ad to the right on this page is for the Oregon Lottery Scratch-its.
0
Jun 15 '19
[deleted]
1
u/litewo Jun 18 '19
Who is still using ad block plus in 2019? They sold out to advertisers years ago.
2
1
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19
I'm sad that this subreddit has become less useful by no longer allowing people to speak about these offerings and share information about them, whether they are worthwhile, and what others have received.
In my opinion, having less information and less dialog about these offerings from various stores makes us worse off as consumers.
11
u/Keeza_Friday Jun 14 '19
Supporting scummy actions with RNG shouldn't be allowed. If this was a loot box from a game we'd be angry so why can't that apply to game bundles that won't reveal anything?
3
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19
It's not about supporting or not supporting, it's about discussion.
Now these stores can offer these deals to hapless people knowing there is that much less information and dialog exposing when they are a bad deal.
Banning this discussion supports scummy deals.
10
u/FSMFan_2pt0 Jun 14 '19
Banning this discussion supports scummy deals.
I disagree. IMO, it sends a loud message of reprimand to the resellers promoting these 'deals'. I think it ends up hurting their brand. In my mind, Bundle Stars was a great site. Fanatical started off that way, but I think less of them now for promoting these blind offers. Just my 2¢
7
u/ICanTrollToo Jun 14 '19
While I want to agree with the person you are disagreeing with, the fact is retailers know all about/r/gamedeals and similar places online. I believe/r/gamedeals is probably the biggest these days (maybe CAG?) so banning these bundles here will likely dramatically reduces their reach and viability. I think it's important to remember this aspect as well, and ultimately it is why I find myself agreeing with you.
0
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19
It's not just about backlash to get them to change, it's about allowing consumers to share information here and now about what's on offer and whether it's a good deal.
Now these stores can market these to consumers with less information out there to help people make informed decisions.
The solution to "this is a bad offer" should never be "let's censor consumers."
3
u/Rownarck Jun 15 '19
You're not mentioning the fact that having these random bundles posted on /r/GameDeals gives them a pretty big boost in advertising. I'm almost sure there'll be less money being made by these bundles just off that fact.
→ More replies (4)5
u/ADorante Jun 14 '19
I'm for discussion. I'm against scummy deals. Maybe a constant thread in /r/GameDealsMeta could suffice. This new solution for /r/GameDeals is a compromise and we should give it some time to see how it's working in the meantime.
1
Jun 15 '19
You can make the same argument for grey market resellers, though.
1
u/Jahandar Jun 15 '19
There are several large differences, among them the fact that no one is arguing that there is anything illegal about these sales are illegal, whereas grey market resellers are frequently over the line, and are not actual retailers, and could result in your game key being revoked, etc. On the other hand, regardless of what we may think of their value, no one disputes that these are legit sales from actual retailers. Barring technical issues, you can trust that the store is giving you a legit game key.
7
u/MustLoveAllCats Jun 14 '19
Not talking about them will lead to a reduction in people seeing them listed, and ending up purchasing them, which will in turn make us better off as consumers.
3
u/Geddyn Jun 14 '19
You mean like the constant reminders posted all over every gaming subreddit that prepurchasing is bad?
Because that is working out so well.
2
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19
Not talking about them allows the stores to advertise scummy deals with less consequences, less pushback, and fewer people exposing them.
Silencing consumers makes us worse off.
6
u/himynameiswillf Jun 14 '19
As opposed to them receiving unanimous backlash for almost a year and still posting new ones? There's no evidence to suggest what you're saying is true, in fact if them continuing to post these bundles means anything it supports what /u/MustLoveAllCats is saying and conflicts with what you're saying.
Regardless, a years worth of backlash did nothing. Doubling down on that approach would be foolish when we could at least try the other method of ignoring them.
1
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
It's not just about backlash to get them to change, it's about allowing consumers to share information here and now about what's on offer and whether it's a good deal or worthwhile.
The threads on these sales in the past did a lot of good in helping people to make informed decisions. Now people will be less informed.
The solution to "this is a bad offer" should never be "let's censor consumers."
4
u/himynameiswillf Jun 14 '19
I can link you every post made about these bundles and in every post you'll find the vast, vast majority of people that bought into these bundles came out worse off, which isn't surprising given how these are just gambling and by that fact the vast majority are always going to be worse off.
But lets not play naive, these bundles exist to get rid of the stock these storefronts had that they couldn't push. Beholder, Hue, Tropico, Dark, Layers of Fear. Irregardless of these games' quality, they're all games that have been bundled into oblivion, sold for pennies or just given away because they've lost their market value. In essense, you're better off buying these games through other means to reduce the risk of both getting a game you don't want and overpaying for them.
If the mods wanted to be thorough, they could take the data comments [like these] (https://old.reddit.com/r/GameDeals/comments/bzue38/fanatical_the_magnificent_mystery_machine_steam/eqxr7b3/) compiled and very clearly show the games people were getting were below the value they paid.
I understand where you're coming from in theory but it's a very broad and airy position to take that doesn't take into consideration the logic behind gambling nor the logistics of these businesses. The solution isn't censorship of consumers, it's the complete opposite. It's censorship of exploitative businesses. People still have a forum in SteamGifts if they're interested, but the bottom line is not a single one of these bundles can or will ever be considered a "deal" by the very definition of that word.
0
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
Yes, that's exactly right, and every example you could share of a customer sharing a bad experience proves my point that these posts were useful for allowing consumers to share information and inform others. The most important time to allow conversation on a sale is when it's a bad deal that consumers should be warned about.
In each of those instances, for every one poster, there were many many other readers who learned from that experience and were better off for it.
Now, there will be no one sharing their negative experiences, and everyone is worse off.
More information is better than less information.
5
Jun 15 '19
these posts were useful for allowing consumers to share information and inform others.
Sure, for the people who bothered to read the comments. Many people don't. r/gamedeals has established itself as a trustworthy source that lists only reputable stores. The majority of games I've bought in the last few months have been through this subreddit, because I have a fair expectation that when I see a deal here, it's from a legit, reputable retailer that isn't going to screw me over.
Considering the sub has always been dedicated to not letting their users get exploited, how can you expect them to allow the advertisement of something which they feel exploits and harms their users?
→ More replies (10)6
u/himynameiswillf Jun 14 '19
That's not what "proves" means. You don't have any proof these comments deterred a single person from buying the bundle and is, like I said before, ignoring the psychology behind gambling.
This is like saying if talking about the lottery was banned, less people would know the lottery is an absolute scam and would therefore buy into the lottery more because they don't have the negative reactions to deter them from it.
These bundles are no different. In a world where people know both the lottery and mystery bundles are a scam, people still by into them, regardless of whether people tell them it's bad or not, that's just not how gambling works in the minds of many people.
People have more information and they still make bad decisions.
3
u/Jahandar Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
The threads themselves provide the evidence. There are many posts in those threads from people commenting that they've decided to forgo a bundle after seeing other people's experiences, the lists of games, etc. I myself have been deterred by them, so yes, I have indisputable first-hand proof that these comments can be a deterrent.
The solution to "this is bad" is not "we should stop people from being able to tell others it's bad."
2
u/motherchuggingpugs Jun 15 '19
I would also like to add that I too have been curious about these bundles before, only to find myself deterred by seeing people's results in the comments, and have found the information available in these threads incredibly useful. Banning open forums for discussing these deals is not the right way to deal with the situation as now consumers have to make a less informed decision which will probably lead to more people biting the bullet and purchasing out of curiosity.
0
2
u/johnkx Jun 17 '19
I don't think "lootboxes" are "deals"
Just because 1 guy got a good box doesn't mean the other guy will get the same; thus, destroying the whole point of this subreddit called "GAMEDEALS"
0
u/Jahandar Jun 18 '19
Some people decided they were, some decided they weren't, depending on the odds, the game pool, the price, and the buyer's situation/preferences, and it could change for every offer. That was the reason for the discussion, to share information allowing customers to make informed decisions.
0
u/derpepper Jun 14 '19
I feel like it's silly to decide for other adults what is and isn't worth their money. Plus taking away the place where they discuss and make informed decisions is a little backwards.
13
u/gjallerhorn Jun 14 '19
It's tough to claim something is a deal when you don't know what you'll get for the money you spend. This is a sub for game deals, you can take your gambling elsewhere
12
u/caninehere Jun 14 '19
While this isn't the reason for the ban, it was a reason for me personally. If you have no possibility of knowing the value of a purchase until after you buy it, there is no way to know if it is a 'deal' or not.
→ More replies (3)1
u/derpepper Jun 14 '19
Yeah I get the idea, but i'm sure some people think getting some random game for below MSRP is a deal. But just like most of the stuff in the sub, I ignore it because it's not a "deal" to me. Either way the ruling went wouldn't have affected me (or most of the sub) at all but I'm wondering about the people it will affect.
0
Jun 14 '19
[deleted]
3
u/yappored45 Jun 14 '19
I dont think you know the definition of certain. Nothing about these bundles are certain.
2
u/motherchuggingpugs Jun 15 '19
The certainty is that you get a guaranteed number of games for below MSRP.
4
u/voneahhh Jun 14 '19
I feel like it’s silly to decide for other adults
The sub isn't limited to adults, besides which that wasn't the only reason.
-2
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
Children don't exactly have a lot of purchasing power or access to credit cards and stuff really.
4
u/voneahhh Jun 14 '19
Counterpoint: Fortnite
-2
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
Ok? How does that give kids the money? Does fortnite print money for kids?
You make a really bad counterpoint if you can even call it that.
4
u/voneahhh Jun 14 '19
For some reason you're making it seem like the issue is kids making money. It's not. It's the spending that's the issue.
Which they're doing with Fortnite by the billions.
So yeah, kids do have spending power.
-1
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
So... You're suggesting that a popular game is popular because kids are somehow spending money that they don't make and trying to equate that to them having our chasing power because a game is free? A parent buying their kid something does not give kids purchasing power. Neither does unbridled access to payment options. The parents are the ones with the power not the kids. This is about as bad as trying to argue happy meal toys targets kids and parents can't stop kids from getting fat off McDonald's.
You've literally just said fortnite is making money so clearly it's kids spending money. Because that's what you want to believe? Cool narrative.
3
u/voneahhh Jun 14 '19
I'm suggesting that kids can buy things completely of their own volition, and the multi-billion dollar success of a game primarily played by the under 18 crowd is a testament to that.
Beautiful strawman though.
1
u/LickMyThralls Jun 14 '19
You're the one that thinks that kids playing a game gives them spending power. I'm also pretty sure that you have no actual data to back up your claims either. The link that you gave? Nothing about kids spending money, nothing about them having purchasing power. You've spun a hugely popular game making hugely big money into kids having spending power because kids also play it. Maybe you're the one that needs to produce some actual data before you call others strawmanning when you tried to introduce Fortnite as a counterpoint to refute kids not having spending power and that it belongs to adults like almost exclusively. Go ahead and cry strawman when you're the one that gave a little write up that simply said it's making a lot of money to somehow substantiate your claim of kids having spending power.
2
u/Iintendtooffend Jun 15 '19
Kids playing games doesn't give them spending power, but the mobile games market and others like fortnite show exactly how lucrative a demographic it is.
Kids are at the perfect age with parents that are still largely clueless about video games, but also credit cards are so prolific that often kids will have some level of access, or receive some form of online spending capacity for birthdays or the like. Either through pre-paid cards or the parents just putting their CC info in.
Children in this day have pretty tremendous spending power, little Timmy asks for Fortnite bucks for his Bday instead of a toy or something else. It's basically how cartoons back in the day were basically action figure commericals, if that weren't a profitable venture, TNMT or transformers wouldn't exist for example. Similar concept, different distribution.
→ More replies (0)0
Jun 14 '19
[deleted]
5
u/voneahhh Jun 14 '19
Prepaid cards are a thing, and have been for a very long time. Also children under 18 can open a bank account and get a debit card.
1
u/gryllus Jun 15 '19
Do you remember Indie Piñata? Posts about it wouldn't be allowed with the new post rules.
1
u/53R9 Jun 15 '19
Is it the one that keeps on saying "with FREE gift for redditors!". I have an app called IFTPP which automatically sends me a notification when there is a free item, and this one keeps pissing me off.
4
u/treblah3 Jun 15 '19
No, you're thinking of IndieBox - with that, you know what you are purchasing and everyone gets the same game. Throwing in a random free gift is icing on the cake as opposed to a 100% blind purchase.
1
1
0
u/Mr7FootCock Jun 14 '19
As long as it wasn't too common, I say they should've kept them on, who cares if it's 'gambling' or not
1
u/mark2uk Jun 15 '19
I'm not a fan of the random loot boxes but I'd of preferred the rules to have been changed so that any deals could only be posted by the store reps and must contain all available content and the full odds of receiving each of the items.
The simple reason for this is when being aware of the actual odds & fully available content, most people will reasonably decline to purchase.
The outright ban you have is certainly easier but people will find out about it on other reddits or email shots and will not know the odds of winning something they actually want so will be more inclined to spend money on them.
Your solution is definitely the easiest but my alternative would have been better for the greater good as it would have allowed informed decisions & increased transparency.
1
u/genericgamer Jun 15 '19
Does this include online card games such as mtg arena/hearthstone? These games inherently have this as a core attribute.
Edit: I see that my comments may not be about the the topic at hand but I'll leave this up.
1
0
u/Lagkiller Jun 14 '19
If this is the rule, are we going to also forbid games that have lootboxes in them as well? Are deals for say Hearthstone, or Mtg online banned as well? If those are, what about games like CoD or Overwatch? At what point does this rule kick in regarding lootboxes?
It would seem quite hypocritical to allow deals for games that are just lootboxes or heavily rely on them, but ban bundles which are just lootboxes.
5
u/himynameiswillf Jun 14 '19
There is no game that is "just lootboxes". Even Hearthstone which heavily pushes mtx is still completely playable without investing money. You have the option to try the game without rolling the dice. That option isn't there with mystery bundles.
1
u/Lagkiller Jun 14 '19
A difference without a distinction. If we are calling lootboxes bad, then they are either bad or not bad. Trying to say that a trial mode which doesn't allow you to participate in the majority of the game with other players doesn't somehow make it better.
5
u/Nerney9 Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
The key is to 'not take a sledgehammer to the problem', as the mods stated. Fanatical and GMG aren't banned from the sub for hosting these lottery bundles, the sub simply won't advertise those bundles.
Similarly, sales on lootboxes themselves may not be allowed, but there is no reason to forbid any mention/sale of every game that has a lootbox component.
2
u/himynameiswillf Jun 14 '19
Well I mean it just does... You're consuming content for free, content that may very well be enjoyable and give value and at which point you're free to walk away without paying a penny knowing you got something out of it. It's a risk free investment. There's no two ways about it. If you enjoyed what you played it was better, if you didn't then you lost nothing.
The difference in inherently the distinction and how that was lost on you I don't know. No one is arguing lootboxes aren't bad, the distinction is when they are forced on you. In a video game is it virtually never, with a mystery bundle it's from the get go.
1
u/treblah3 Jun 15 '19
Sorry for the late response.
While there is a lot of dislike for games that rely heavily on microtransactions and lootboxes, this rule is not about policing the content within games, it is about the blind purchase where customers receive random, unique results. So no, those types of games will not be affected.
1
u/Lagkiller Jun 15 '19
My comment is more in regards to, if we are holding lootboxes for games as a bad thing, should we not be extending that same rule to other lootbox items. Banning one but not the other is not only inconsistent but invalidates the message that you are trying to send.
-9
u/Black3ird Jun 14 '19
OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG...
That actually happened? OMG Thank you for all involved; to Mods making it happen and to the Redditor I was skeptical about the other day since this had been brought up twice before with no solution.
Like they say, Third Time is the Charm. Wish could have seen Fanatical rep's face when told. We literally begged him to stop those nonsense and they never did.
Good job.
6
u/MustLoveAllCats Jun 14 '19
Wish could have seen Fanatical rep's face when told. We literally begged him to stop those nonsense and they never did.
I can't imagine they'll be that upset, already tons of exposure, and now there's a big stickied post indirectly advertising Fanatical lootboxes.
-15
Jun 14 '19
Lol. Why can’t adults take their own risks? It’s their money. Their choice. This world is becoming so soft.
Go ahead. Downvote away. That’s what reddit does.
13
17
u/magicwhistle Jun 14 '19
How are the /r/gamedeals mods stopping you from taking your own risks? This decision doesn't mean they're going to reach through your monitor and smack your hand if you try to buy a lootbox bundle. You can still do whatever you want with your money.
-11
Jun 14 '19
There is absolutely no reason to remove them from this page. None. It’s a way for people to gather information. It doesn’t hurt to post them here. This isn’t the mods bandwidth. It’s Reddit’s.
4
0
u/chrispy145 Jun 15 '19
Except this subreddit is for the best deals when it comes to video games.80% of those who buy these random keys will have buyer's regret. Not a deal. Shouldn't be on this subreddit.
1
u/ohmanger Jun 17 '19
It is a fair question. The problem with these lootbox bundles is that the site doesn't make it clear what the risks are, which makes it impossible for a customer to make an informed decision. Fanatical went a step further recently and added the chance for a "mega" bundle without even stating its availability (it might not even still be possible to get a mega bundle - just think about that).
-1
Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
You know that being downvoted means that what you're saying or your opinion is generally impopular?
Just a FYI.
6
u/chithanh Jun 14 '19
Downvoting a post simply because you disagree with it would be a violation of Reddiquette:
Please don't
Downvote an otherwise acceptable post because you don't personally like it.
2
u/xaliber_skyrim Jun 15 '19
Some people take it with pride though, they feel like they're crusading their values against infidels.
2
u/SlamUnited Jun 15 '19 edited Dec 16 '24
dependent deranged roof uppity insurance glorious familiar domineering encouraging hospital
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/pm_me_coffee_mugs Jun 15 '19
I wish this could be prioritised, reinforced. If a comment that I disagree with makes a good point about something, I'd like to be able to upvote it. The way it works now (and as far back as I remember), upvotes are the same as agreeing... Or voting for the right opinion. I want it to mean "voting for good comments" instead of "right" comment. Of course I don't want to upvote something if people take that little increase in the sum of up- and downvotes as a redditor taking a side.
/rantHey, that's my first rant.
0
Jun 14 '19
[deleted]
2
Jun 14 '19
Yeah I've changed that comment because I can't read lol.
1
u/treblah3 Jun 14 '19
Appreciated. As I said higher up, folks were bound to be upset on either side of the issue - I just want to make sure people on both sides of the decision get to express their feelings.
1
Jun 14 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/treblah3 Jun 14 '19
Ok, this is venturing into rule 1 territory so I'm going to ask you to take a step back please.
-3
Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
🤦♂️🤦♂️
Did you see his first comment to me? Clearly not. If this is offensive we really need a reality check in this world.
5
Jun 14 '19
He did! He replied to me saying that it was rude and I changed it back to something less rude.
1
Jun 14 '19
I wasn’t offended by it. I just found it uneducated.
People can’t have a discussion about something and just downvote people. They then start attacking people. That’s a large chunk of reddit I’m discovering. They don’t know what opinions are. They are immediately on the attack if someone else voices their own opinion.
2
3
u/treblah3 Jun 14 '19 edited Jun 14 '19
Uh, yeah I did. I am the moderator that removed it and asked them to remember rule 1, in defense of your freedom to express your displeasure.
So again, I'm going to ask you to take some time to cool off.
1
-2
Jun 15 '19
You should ban Humble Monthly then. I'm guessing they are probably an advertiser so that won't happen.
2
u/Avokkrii Jun 15 '19
can you read tho?
The Humble Bundle Monthly and Groupees' bundles will not be affected because they are not lootbox-style (everybody receives the same content).
in monthly everyone receives the same games, it isn't a lootbox.
-2
u/MagicMert Jun 15 '19
The Humble Bundle Monthly and Groupees' bundles will not be affected because they are not lootbox-style
Wait... What? You are banning loot box style bundles but not loot box style bundles? That seems inconsistant.
So all a company has to do is give everyone the same games to be able to post their lootbox bundle?
8
u/Alenonimo Jun 15 '19
Uh... yeah! What they're trying to do is to cut on the gambling aspect of certain lootboxes. If you read the text, some of these lootboxes encourage you to buy them again to attempt to get a better game. That's gambling. If the content is always the same, why would you buy more if not to have more copies of the same games? :/
3
u/swordtut Jun 15 '19
groupies do blind (well semi blind) preorders so even if banned once the bundle went live it could be posted.
-10
u/promonk Jun 14 '19
This is the stupidest, laziest mod team bullshit I've seen in a while.
Got any other bright plans to save people from themselves? Or at least something else that you can argue saves people from themselves without actually having to do anything?
-4
91
u/Hold_my_Dirk Jun 14 '19
I agree with this decision. Another difference between these types of bundles and the humble monthlies is that there is an early unlock. I feel like most people on the sub recommend only to buy that month's bundle if you think the early unlock alone is worth the price of admission and to consider the later reveals to be bonus (not that it isn't okay to be disappointed in the unrevealed games). I understand the use of the Meta sub and frequent it for announcements like these but have you considered putting a temporary sticky cross post to this thread on the main sub? I doubt everyone knows about the meta thread and it might be good for everyone to see this post so they know (and also so there isn't a bunch of dumb comments about the mods from people that don't see this post).