r/thebutton • 4s • Apr 26 '15

update on flairs from yesterday's outage

The flair that was applied during yesterday's button outage, including my own, will remain.

You may only press the button once, regardless of the circumstances.

0 Upvotes

870 comments sorted by

341

u/powerlanguage 4s Apr 26 '15

Up until yesterday's outage I had thought of myself as a non-presser. However, when faced with the dwindling timer I pressed the button: I found myself, despite my previous thoughts, wishing for this project to continue.

Once I realized my press had not reset the timer I thought to exempt myself from the rules of the button by reverting my presser status. This impulse stemmed from my own sense of importance within this community. I have a position of status here and misguidedly thought it was okay to preserve that status by exempting myself from the rules. For me, this was the test of the button. I am grateful to the community for calling me out on my error.

As the others who pressed during the outage, my flair shall remain. The rules remain and apply for all:

You may only press the button once.

534

u/beefhash 42s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

The button: Showing people everywhere how power corrupts.

And now imagine how bad things could possibly be with politicians.

86

u/remez 41s Apr 26 '15

If they would just end up the same, owning their failures, we'd be in a slightly better place.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

52

u/nyxwulf 11s Apr 26 '15

I disagree with this decision primarily because pressing the button is supposed to reset the timer. As you note in your post, your press didn't reset the timer, so it wasn't an actual press due to a technical malfunction.

This feels different than the /u/GyroDawn situation. Here a press isn't a press, it didn't function as the game is designed, so since it didn't work, you should reset the flairs and let people actually press the button and have it function as the experiment was designed.

Basically I agree, you get only one press, but a press resets the timer. That is the fundamental function of a press. If that didn't happen, it's not a press, plain and simple.

20

u/beowulf 1s Apr 26 '15

As further evidence, here is the text from the announcement:

When this post is 10 minutes old, a button and timer will become active at /r/thebutton. The timer will count down from 60 seconds. If the button is pressed the timer will reset to 60 seconds and continue counting down. Only users logged into accounts created before 2015-04-01 can press the button.

You may only press the button once.

We canโ€™t tell you what to do from here on out. The choice is yours.

Yes, the rules are simple, you can only press once, but if the button is pressed the timer resets. If the timer didn't reset, it should not be counted as a press.

Simple Rule: A Press Resets the Timer, you get only one Press.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Basically I agree, you get only one press, but a press resets the timer. That is the fundamental function of a press. If that didn't happen, it's not a press, plain and simple.

You are exactly correct and it's just common sense, so of course the admins here don't have it.

→ More replies (3)

45

u/Iamspeedy36 36s Apr 26 '15

But there have been other technical glitches where flair was changed. I think many people are wondering why this time it was not changed. I appreciate your honesty, but your decision has changed the whole button dynamic.

58

u/roastedcoyote 19s Apr 26 '15

Yes, The flair was changed due to presses during glitches. It was called cheater flair. /u/powerlanguage should get a 4s purple flair like the glitch pressers who preceded him.

73

u/something111111 40s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 27 '15

It's funny because most people with cheater flair didn't actually cheat, but /u/powerlanguage DID cheat and he doesn't have cheater flair!

Edit: It seems some people may be confused. I am solely referring to the fact that he pressed, then attempted to erase his press, then put it back. While it was noble to put it back, he did cheat, so his flair should now be purple. Not red.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

140

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

I found myself, despite my previous thoughts, wishing for this project to continue.

proceeds to ruin the project

29

u/WezVC 59s Apr 26 '15

Yep, I think a massive portion of this sub has completely stopped caring in the last 24 hours.

Oh well, it was fun while it lasted.

425

u/mncke 56s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

So, you asked us what to do with those who clicked during the outage, and we expressed our opinion very clearly.

But now you are going to ignore our opinion just because you personally were affected?

Unprecedented sub-10s flairs, you ignoring the community's opinion, you not doing any damage control for 22 hours and you spoiling the fun for everybody else by leaving /u/GyroDawn's and others' red flairs are much more detrimental to the button's integrity than a few people getting another click.

This kills the button.

Edit: I am the guy who develops the squire and one of the leaders of the largest button faction out there. There are people who say I've done the most to further our understanding of the button. And I just see my efforts flushed down the toilet. I've been interviewed for media outlets twice already, and twice I said that the button is an extremely interesting and unconventional experiment. Turns out, it is an experiment in community destruction, power abuse and extremely sloppy product management. I've been gilded twicethrice in this sub, and I am disgusted by the fact that a part of the money people paid to show appreciation of my work goes to your salary.

137

u/Sataris non presser Apr 26 '15

Yep; public opinion was hugely in favour of reverting those flairs, and he just threw it back in our faces.

→ More replies (5)

89

u/Kvothe24 non presser Apr 26 '15

I'm with you 100%. Why even ask us if you're going to just through public opinion to the wind and do what you want?

I was blown away when 1 red flair was allowed to remain (/u/GyroDawn) but it was a humerus aspect of The Button so it didn't bug me. However, what, upwards of 70 not only incorrect red flairs but some 1s red flairs? IMO, those were going to be the most exciting flairs to see first start popping up. Now there will be no way to distinguish the legitimate ones from all these faux flairs running around.

Sucks to have a ton of fun with something for 26 days, something that's main appeal revolves around a literal countdown to the end, just fail like this.

I feel like I've been waiting 26 days to take the best dump ever, but when I sat down to let fly, it was just a fart all along.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

lol

It's a button

Online

That has no effect on your life

→ More replies (2)

14

u/TotesMessenger non presser Apr 26 '15

This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.

If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)

→ More replies (1)

27

u/WezVC 59s Apr 26 '15

For me, this was the test of the button. I am grateful to the community for calling me out on my error.

This is such a pandering, lazy, and cop-out answer

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Frostiken non presser Apr 26 '15

What the fuck did you just say to me, you little bitch? I'll have you know I'm the guy who develops the squire, and one of the leaders of the largest button factions out there.

etc. etc.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/RacistHomophobicCunt non presser Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

The 22 hours part is especially what irks me. It does not take a day to come up with a valid PR reason.

The button is dead.

→ More replies (6)

54

u/my__name__is non presser Apr 26 '15

I've been gilded twice in this sub, and I am disgusted by the fact that a part of the money people paid to show appreciation of my work goes to your salary.

...

It's a button. With a timer. Created as a joke on a free website for some casual amusement.

Take a few deep breathes, take a walk outside, and let it go.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (30)

36

u/Lothraien non presser Apr 26 '15

This is not the best action to take. The flairs acquired yesterday were only 'available' because the button didn't reset itself properly. Any technical errors on the server side should annul the times given, just as technical errors on the client side produce cheater flairs.

17

u/Iamspeedy36 36s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

Apparently it's now changed to "you may only press the button once, regardless of the circumstances".

→ More replies (3)

6

u/g_3 non presser Apr 26 '15

I don't think this thing has ever really been about the flair. It's a game. Some people don't like losing anything.

6

u/AFabledHero non presser Apr 26 '15

You don't have to give another press. Just give them and yourself a special glitch flair or a cheater flair.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

But if the button can hit zero, reset and continue, why would anyone care if it runs out? You speak the axiom of "you may only press the button once" but clearly pressing the button is not the only way to reset it.

4

u/user40152 can't press Apr 26 '15

Reset the undeserved flairs and keep your finger off the button. You are not a player, you are the button commissioner.

3

u/dumbest_name 35s Apr 26 '15

Splendid! powerlanguage, what do you think of my suggestion to Put an asterisk* next to glitch flairs?

The post has received a lot of support since I put it up yesterday. As a compromise it has a lot of strong points. An asterisk and an explanation in the sidebar would solve most of our problems, without alienating anyone. Red flairs would regain their worth, but not at anyone's expense.

The community has voted this solution 92% positive. Take a look, decide what you think is best. Regards, powerlanguage!

Maybe post a sticky to officially ask the community how it feels about this solution? The weighting algorithm has started to push my post back down, it's on the second page now.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15

Why don't you have cheater flair?

3

u/Kaibakura 59s Apr 27 '15

Here's an idea: remove the flair but do not regain the ability to press the button.

Become the can't presser you deserve to be.

8

u/Princess_Batman 60s Apr 26 '15

Sooo much buttonhurt in this thread.

12

u/ARandomDickweasel non presser Apr 26 '15

That's why you have to kill it. Your instinct is to keep it going, the same as your instinct was to revert your button press, and you're changing the rules to do that.

Seriously, it was fun while it lasted, but now it's becoming Joanie Loves Chachi.

→ More replies (11)

6

u/alowe13 non presser Apr 26 '15

You think the experiment is about not pressing the button, but it is not. Pressing the button once is not about extending the experiment, otherwise you could program a personal timer and see who is going to press and who isn't. The experiment is are you willing to wait long enough to get a red flair.

This was never about seeing the button tick down to zero. Any none pressers who say that at this point is lying. This is about getting the red flair. You gave in and clicked, not because you wanted to extend the "experiment," but because you had the chance to obtain status. You sir, are the Steward of Gondor, unwilling to see the falseness of your power.

If this was not about the status or the flair, you would have no problem giving it up.

→ More replies (105)

647

u/__dirtydishes non presser Apr 26 '15

Newest phase of the project: Examine how quickly a subreddit can turn on its creator.

108

u/kingphysics 59s Apr 26 '15

All great empires fall.

28

u/nero4983 non presser Apr 27 '15

What happened?

95

u/__dirtydishes non presser Apr 27 '15

On June 9, 68 Nero was killed thus ending the Julio-Claudian dynasty.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (16)

78

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15 edited Apr 27 '15

He wasn't the creator, but something similar is going on in /r/pcmasterrace. Gabe Newell was idolized up until 2 days ago when they announced paid mods, and now he's despised by the community. I mean, his face has been on the banner for as long as I've been going to that subreddit.

45

u/__dirtydishes non presser Apr 27 '15 edited Apr 27 '15

Yeah, it has been fascinating to watch that. I hope the whole situation gets sorted out.

Edit: The Valve/Mod situation deals with an actual, real-world issue whereas the button controversy deals with the implosion of 24 days of circlejerking hype around a meaningless button. Yet in both cases people are taking it extremely seriously. People are weird.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/DiggingNoMore 9s Apr 27 '15

That's all it takes to kill a reputation - one fleeting moment.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

425

u/Shutupharu 11s Apr 26 '15

What was the point of asking the users what should be done if you were just going to disregard it anyway?

I agree with keeping the button going, but I think letting the glitch presses stand is really disappointing.

173

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

Right. See my flair? That was during a glitch which they said they would fix and didn't.....so it remains and it's a cheater flair but MOD GOD gets to keep his red. As far as I'm concerned any red is not real. It shall be called GLITCH RED from this day forward.

39

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Some of the reds have been quite honest, and wish their own flairs to be reset. This is definitely a debate, but I think that categorizing the reds as a glitch using bunch isn't fair. What about the 11s reds, ones of which we've had before with no glitch or crash.

34

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

I think the 11 true reds should be pissed and asked for their flair to show they are the first true reds.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/frakkinadama non presser Apr 26 '15

Disappointing isn't really the word I would use...

15

u/guiltypleasures 10s Apr 26 '15

Moreso, I would say that the inconsistency with this decision in contrast with the unpurple is unsettling.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

62

u/thri11co11ector 11s Apr 26 '15

As a former, vigilant member of the Redguard I am disgusted that these glitchers will be allowed to keep their ill gotten gains. What will my legitimate 11s mean if there are 1s and 0s strutting around like cock of the walk. THEY ARE COCK OF NOTHING!

At this point I am so disillusioned that I have no choice but to join the League of Shadows (the grays) and help to bring about the end of this failed experiment you call The Button... and to watch this subreddit BURN!

7

u/dengseng non presser Apr 27 '15 edited May 14 '15

one of us, one of us

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

745

u/TheJaice 23s Apr 26 '15

As a social experiment, this is actually one of the best things that could have happened. It has given a very clear example of how being in a position of power changes the outcome. We have literally just witnessed the 1% being created. There are hundreds of users whose flair was changed to purple, despite thinking that they were clicking to keep the button going. But when it happens to a mod, the rules change, for a select few. It's the type of result that we see constantly in real life.

125

u/ub3rm3nsch 59s Apr 26 '15

To be honest /u/powerlanguage has seemed like kind of a dick from the beginning, when he/she started making posts about removing "low-brow content" from a subreddit that is supposed to be an April Fool's joke.

Now he/she can't even admit that the button timer ran out, because he/she wants to keep his/her imaginary fiefdom.

51

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Actually I'm kind of glad he deleted a lot of the low-brow content. There was a flood of really dumb reaction gifs and excessive karma-whoring right before he started moderating. These still exist now but to a lesser extent

→ More replies (4)

6

u/ForceBlade 60s Apr 26 '15

social experiment

Bro don't hit me, it was a social experiment!!

5

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Yeah and the coolest catch to the story is that he won't admit it was a poor decision to announce. He should have just stayed to his original inquiry of 'What should we do?' and spend the extra two hours just removing the flairs of a select few. Crazy how a community can die so quick

→ More replies (16)

288

u/ItsNot1972 non presser Apr 26 '15

I stand by my statement yesterday. Reset all, chaos is beautiful.

53

u/98022812 non presser Apr 26 '15

Anarchy

0

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

[deleted]

5

u/enceladus47 58s Apr 26 '15

This is actually an awesome idea, everything is reset but knowledge is there, so people won't press right away and purples are much less, with much more potential pressers it will be harder for the button to reach zero, people are fed up with the button and we have to make plans to kill it.

→ More replies (10)

206

u/BoredByTheChore 42s Apr 26 '15 edited Feb 18 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

dime unite retire square sort outgoing compare steer salt license

→ More replies (25)

1.1k

u/bigbadler 1s Apr 26 '15

The button is dead

550

u/Wizmaxman 15s Apr 26 '15

all glitched flair needs to be removed.

without it - this means nothing.

42

u/bitch_im_a_lion 60s Apr 26 '15

Removed or given a different color that shows that the flair was glitched so that legit reds are still special.

23

u/waffledoctor87 60s Apr 26 '15

How about a lighter color of the actual one?

Like how can'tpressers are a light non-presser.

So powerlanguage gets pink, and one of my alts gets sky blue.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

328

u/Deto non presser Apr 26 '15

Yes, it's the glitched flairs that make this pointless... /s

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (16)

140

u/_Timboss 5s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

I watched the timer run down to 0 on the button snitch and on /r/thebutton and despite being a sworn member of the /r/Redguard and against my better instincts, I did not press the button at 1 as I could have done. Having closely followed the popularity and progress of The ExperimentTM since April 1st I realised that it had to be another network or server error and didn't want my sole use of the button to be for an 'illegitimate' click / flair!

IMO it's absolutely correct that a "server fail" was not considered to be a legitimate end to the experiment, but also absolutely correct that /u/powerlanguage has now agreed to keep his (and all the other) [filthy] pressers flair and 'pressed' status that came about from presses during the server fail. One press for all, glitch or not, and all [filthy] pressers should be branded for life.

I just wish that glitch-pressers could be differentiated from legitimate-pressers (extra flair maybe?)

40

u/TehProblemSolver 11s Apr 26 '15

April 1st I realized that it had to be another network or server error and didn't want my sole use of the button to be for an 'illegitimate' click / flair!

I posit we should consider clicks during network/server problems "wasted" clicks as opposed to illegitimate/fake/cheaters. If you does click during a server hiccup, did you extend the life of the button? No. So it's wasted. Nothing more, nothing less.

62

u/RonanHJ 3s Apr 26 '15

Well I tried to save the button and look where that got me.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (7)

48

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

15

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Well... That's the end... Absolutely NOTHING!

8

u/BladeWalker non presser Apr 26 '15

The button is dead

"Not if we have anything to say about it." - /r/RoninAtTheEdgeOfTime

9

u/Dopeaz non presser Apr 26 '15

Long live the button

3

u/Veneroso 60s Apr 26 '15

The only solution is to stop visiting the sub so that it runs out again!

3

u/BPiddy 60s Apr 26 '15

What a shame....This experiment is corrupt

3

u/Requi3m Apr 26 '15

We did it reddit!!! We downvoted hitler's stickied post to 0!!!!!! Hide yo flairs, hide yo wife.

→ More replies (18)

414

u/bigbadler 1s Apr 26 '15

This is so lame... may as well just press whenever I guess. If the 0s presses stand, then the button should be over, because it expired. The outage was either canon, or it was not. Can't have it both ways you damn dirty presser.

44

u/jonesyjonesy non presser Apr 26 '15

Evidence that every problem in the world is caused by a presser.

→ More replies (2)

127

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Yep. This game is over and done now.

121

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

This basically ruined the fun. There's no more anticipation and who gets the lowest LEGIT number anymore.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/Jimmychichi non presser Apr 26 '15

Its no longer fun checking how low people got since the lowest is already done.

34

u/robble_bobble non presser Apr 26 '15

Exactly right. It was a fun little game for a while, but the banker is obviously stealing from the bank and that ruins the game. I always wanted to press, but now it is just pointless.

Nice April Fools /u/powerlanguage. You got me for sure.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Yes yes yes. You described it perfectly. So, what can we do? Surely if we all come together they'll do something.

Anyway, now I'm definitely never going to press. Fuck a button.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

72

u/abelcc 0s Apr 26 '15

You asked the subreddit about what we wanted and the top replies were about removing the flairs.

Then you ignored them and wrote 2 sentences in response.

Why the hell are you a mod here?

6

u/thefadd 60s Apr 27 '15

because he's Hitler, duh

150

u/QuicksandGM non presser Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

Can we at least give them Glitch-Pressers a different shade of red?...I don't know about all of you but I don't think those red flairs were well deserved.

Edit: /u/dumbest_name has a great suggestion, "Add an * next to the glitch flairs". We've created hundreds of new subreddits/religions for this button. why not one more? "The Glitchers".

→ More replies (7)

124

u/wildcard451 non presser Apr 26 '15

The presses mean nothing now. Your experiment is a failure because you could not provide a reliable platform to test.

Game over kids. Was fun while it lasted.

33

u/my__name__is non presser Apr 26 '15

In this pretend world where this is an experiment and not a simple April Fool's joke, you are the subject of the experiment. You don't get to decide when its over. You don't even know the true purpose. They can collect data whenever the button crashed or not.

27

u/goodkicks 59s Apr 26 '15

Exactly. When this is all over today will simply be remembered as "Day 27: The Revolt". It's just another chapter in the fascinating narrative that has been /r/thebutton.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/sh1tbr1cks 42s Apr 26 '15

Flairs lose meaning when 0s and 1s are given out without effort. No point at all in me trying for those now. Might as well wait for another glitch.

13

u/You-Can-Quote-Me 59s Apr 27 '15

Excuse me?

People have gotten cheater flairs... when the button has gone out before people got purple flairs despite being convinced they pressed it at <10s ... But you get to keep your red flair?

Bullshit.

54

u/electric_drifter non presser Apr 26 '15

Wow this is a terrible decision. You keep saying: You may only press the button once. However, you can still remove/change their flairs without letting them press the button again.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Willbuscus 9s Apr 26 '15

I still think that the people who pressed during the outage should have their flairs reset, as the people who got the 1s flair for example, had people press the button at 4,3,2 before them, but the timer wasn't reset. This is to some degree not exactly fair, even though some believed they were playing by the "rules"

Edit: there were also people who pressed the button but retained their "non-presser" status. This also should be fixed.

95

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

For me, the experiment is over, I clicked and am now leaving.

24

u/JamieFoxxxxx 56s Apr 26 '15

Is that what happens when the timer runs out?

20

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

It is what happened yesterday

29

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Damn, spoiler alert bro :(

→ More replies (6)

35

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

That's all we get? What the fuck is this. Man fuck this shit.

6

u/moon-jellyfish non presser Apr 26 '15

Maybe they'll make a new ending?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/biehn 60s Apr 26 '15

I think this is the time to come out.

Guys...I'm a 60s purple.

11

u/juehoffmann non presser Apr 26 '15

I forgive you.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Devonmartino 58s Apr 26 '15

The flair that was applied, including my own, will remain.

including my own

Somehow, I feel like if you'd gotten a purple flair, we'd be hearing a very different tune.

75

u/racist_sunflower non presser Apr 26 '15

Fuck you, /u/powerlanguage. This is a fucking joke.

The button reached 0. I'm done with this shit

→ More replies (2)

53

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

This place isn't what it once was. I come into the current stickied post, the first post people see as they come to this subreddit and what do I see? "The button is dead" and similar sentiments from several of the top comments. And to my surprise, part of me actually agrees. The timer is still going, sure, but I now understand that isn't everything the button is.

I watched the button end. As the last few seconds slipped away I smiled, feeling happy about remaining a non-presser and anticipating the end. The timer hit zero, and the button told be that the experiment was over. Some might see it as an anticlimactic ending, even though many of us knew that was coming, but all I could think was "No it isn't." It couldn't be the end, we had more to do here.

I was right, I suppose, but things certainly changed. Because of a glitch we have people with flairs they didn't fairly obtain and subscribers with feelings ranging from annoyed to outraged. But how can all of this be when the timer is still going? The button is there and anyone who still has their press can use it as they please. I thought that's what this was all about, we watch a timer and press at a certain time or not at all. But no, people have flairs they shouldn't have and somehow that ruins the fun, it takes away the magic. We care about the flairs, we care about the posts and the bragging rights and the religions that have been put together here. Whether we meant to or not, we devoted ourselves to this thing that started as a joke. We made it matter.

I'm not mad at /u/powerlanguage or at the glitch for ruining my fun. I'm mad at myself for not seeing the value of what we had here. For spending hours reading arguments about flair color and not even realizing why I cared, that somewhere along the way this stopped being an April Fools joke and started being a community. So whether you're leaving now or waiting for an ending that's not a glitch, just remember what this experiment really showed us. That if people have the opportunity and the effort they can come together and really care about something, even if that something is as simple as a flair color.

Thank you /u/powerlanguage and the rest of the admins, I've had a great time.

8

u/saintsorfools non presser Apr 26 '15

Holy crap, this is genuinely thoughtful and well written.

3

u/Dreamtrain non presser Apr 27 '15

There was a BUTTON here.
It's gone now.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/longshot4212722 can't press Apr 27 '15

Looks like Nobody Agrees with you. I expected errors and was surprised when the first cheater flairs were given out when it was not their fault. They should have had their press removed and been able to have a fair chance. Actual cheaters should have cheater flairs. Wrong presses at the wrong time shouldn't.

As for your decision to not only go against the people, but also the standard you yourself set (cheater flair) makes you a hypocrite and a bad person. This is why people are calling you literally Hitler.

Moving forward, The button as an event is over. I love the 42 followers for flair because HGTTG is my favorite book. It is too late for you to reconcile and fix the system. So it will last as a great April fools joke, but a disappointment to those who cared. No one will read this but I had to say something.

14

u/BeardOfEarth 42s Apr 27 '15

The button will end soon enough.

But /u/powerlanguage will be remembered as a deceitful cunt for as long as he/she keeps that username.

What a douche.

56

u/shadowofahelicopter 60s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

The button is dead, you should have let it die. We saw it end. Unless you can confirm to us that it didn't die on all servers or something, there is no reason for this to continue. It would have been just as poetic as how it otherwise would have ended if it had ended in a technical failure. Now, it's just not fun since we know the button's ended and these people still have the flairs, which I imagine you're doing because you have no track record of pressers unless they comment so you can't since everyone else wanted the flairs removed if this were to continue. It's just disappointing were not letting this die.

Edit: To prove my point even further, there's no value in lower flair anymore. The value of flair has become what's your favorite color. The dynamic of the psychology and economics behind this is no longer there moving forward. If that doesn't prove my point that the button is dead, then I don't know what will.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/mncke 56s Apr 26 '15

So, you asked us what to do with those who clicked during the outage, and we expressed our opinion very clearly.

But now you are going to ignore our opinion just because you yourself was affected?

These unprecedented sub-10s flairs, you ignoring the community's opinion, you not doing any damage control for 22 hours and you spoiling the fun for everybody by leaving /u/GyroDawn's and others' red flairs are much more detrimental to the button's integrity than a few people getting another click.

This kills the button.

53

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Together with what looks like censorship since a lot of the threads calling /u/powerlanguage's bullshit out has been deleted. Remove the faulty flairs already.

8

u/remez 41s Apr 26 '15

Ztripez posts were deleted too. Seems fair.

6

u/BitFlip32 32s Apr 27 '15 edited Apr 27 '15

Imo this whole emphasis on "you only click once" regardless of anything that happens isn't really the best. Any event that happens outside of the user's control, such as the client clock being out of sync with the server clock, or perhaps a server outage, should result in the revocation of all erroneous clicks. Even if the user tried to cheat, it should just be invalid because it's hard to differentiate between a person trying to cheat and a person that honestly clicked. And if something goes wrong, the timer should just stick at 60 and disable until everything's ok. And if there is some sort of outstanding case of a low click, it should be examined on a case-by-case basis.

It's unfair if people wait for hours, watching the clock tick slowly down and try to nab a low time, then another user just waltzes right in here right when the servers go down and gets a unique flair. But I guess it's too late now...

The only lottery that should really happen here should be at the cause of other users clicking the button: not because of an arbitrary anomaly in the programming or the server's downtime.

I'm looking too far into this. I need sleep or something.

31

u/bigbadler 1s Apr 26 '15

I read this as "update on flairs from yesterday's outRAGE", which seems more fitting.

11

u/theAmazingShitlord 59s Apr 26 '15

This is bullshit. An error on the server makes all red flairs worthless now.

24

u/spidersnake 30s Apr 26 '15

Sorry /u/powerlanguage but the opinion expressed by the community was vehemently opposed to the flairs remaining as they are. You have now directly gone against the will of the users of /r/button, after many of us expressed our disappointment over how the button had been spoilt by these sub 5 second presses.

Why not meet us halfway with the asterisk'd flair idea? That seemed to solve all the problems.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/sound_forsomething non presser Apr 26 '15

Do you see what you get? Do you see what you get when you press the button?!

If everyone would have just let the clock run down, this all would never have happened. Further proof that being Grey is the one true path.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Scummy way to avoid a 60s, dude.

5

u/neon 20s Apr 27 '15

Bad decision. Way to totally ignore your communities wishes :(

5

u/Suddenly-Rampart non presser Apr 27 '15

18 seconds - Your flair is a lie you dirty, filthy presser.

Everyone previous to this has gotten purple and the very first incident (unless I'm mistaken) had their presses reset - you keep a four second red flair? When it doesn't even register as being that low?

Technical failures should not end the button. Those who pressed during a technical failure should have their flair and button press reset. Once a technical failure has been corrected, the button should be reset to 60s, or if possible the amount of seconds at which the failure occurred, and the experiment should continue.

That ^ is the very top suggestion on the thread you linked. Way to ignore what the vast majority considered to be the best solution - I hope your fake red flair makes you feel good, because you and we will always know that not only is it false, but that you're just a dirty presser.

16

u/BootlessTuna 11s Apr 26 '15

This is absolutely retarded and unfair to those of us who had REASONABLY not expected 1s flair to be possible yet. Fuck you and fuck the button, you just killed the coolest thing on reddit. You probably just decided this so your red flair would remain.

9

u/bradlees 60s Apr 26 '15

I agree that the presses should stand. However, I also agree that it should be noted that they were given red under a glitch.

It is not their fault they pressed during the failure. They only saw what was in front of them and took the opportunity to do what most of us would do in the same situation.

As far as /u/powerlanguage 's flair, well, he is a mod and the way I see it as it's not a true red nor should it actually count. All mods should actually have a different flair (but that's my opinion only).

9

u/badmother 0s Apr 26 '15

Sorry - that stinks. If pressing the button does not reset the counter, then you clicked "a button that did nothing", not "the button that keeps it alive".

I urge you to reconsider - reset the flairs granted, and undo the record of the presses. Really not that difficult.

As it stands, all red flair is meaningless, and consequently there is no longer a sense of achievement in earning it.

9

u/kibbles0515 42s Apr 26 '15

Flair acquired during glitches should be cheater flair. Part of pressing the button is that you might get 60s if the button resets. The button did not reset from presses, meaning everyone had the opportunity to press without the possibility of the timer resetting. Risk removed = cheating.

21

u/Skedoozy non presser Apr 26 '15

Way to disenfranchise an entire community.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

If the clicks and flairs count, then so does the timer reaching zero. The experiment is over, turn off the button.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

The button is dead

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

The button is dead

The timer ticks, and the Shade remains strong.

4

u/pizzaforce3 59s Apr 26 '15

I'm loving the drama.

People are demanding that their viewpoint be heard, calling each other names, demanding recounts, attempting to sabotage the results, demanding investigations, and taking sides.

The US Senate? Nope. Us.

Another phase of the social experiment kicks in - what happens to people's attitudes and behaviors when things get down to the wire?

4

u/Jimm_JimmsVapes 59s Apr 27 '15

Love it! "It was our bad, but that's not our problem...it's YOURS (redditors)" --powerlanguage

4

u/mrkrabz1991 non presser Apr 27 '15

Yeah I'm not to happy about this decision. This makes the button far less interesting and I really don't give a shit about flares anymore tbh. Fuck the button.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15

This isn't the button anymore, I'm out.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

This is bullshit. Those are cheater reds.

15

u/meancivilian 28s Apr 26 '15

So, if I (hypothetically) am good enough to hack/crash a server. I could be guaranteed a 1s push, and it would stand. Unacceptable.

Button is dead.

For all we know the said server crash could have been intentional.

10

u/Slothies 45s Apr 26 '15

welp ...this is disappointing.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/James_Keenan 42s Apr 26 '15

This whole subreddit has become far too serious.

More than ever, I seriously hope it's actually deleted when this experiment is over.

I can't over-emphasis how much I wish that were true. If nothing else, to teach people that maybe they need to realign their priorities, and not invest so much in the "ephemerality" of "internet fame", as expressed here in flairs.

10

u/Suzystar3 2s Apr 26 '15

Not just that. It's the sense of community experience and observing human nature that draws most of us here. Don't think it's all about that. Why do you think people are complaining? Not because of the lost chance at greatness so much as that it's not following the rules people expected of it.

6

u/bigbadler 1s Apr 26 '15

So what DOES matter, James?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/roguebagel 59s Apr 26 '15

So why does the button reset now? According to your reasoning you have to keep the glitch flair, well the same glitch brought the timer to zero. Game is over.

3

u/artemus_gordon 0s Apr 26 '15

When you asked if the game should continue, you should have specified that you weren't going to fix the erroneous flairs.

I would like to update my previous answer. The button shouldn't be restarted. When the button hits zero the game is over, "regardless of the circumstances." Hypocrisy.

3

u/spin987 43s Apr 26 '15

Asterisk

3

u/Ralain 3s Apr 26 '15

Wow I've never seen a stickied post downvoted as much as this one is

3

u/tkltangent non presser Apr 26 '15

I'm okay with this.

3

u/tanzmeister non presser Apr 26 '15

Let's all downvote the STICKIED SELF post! That'll show em!

3

u/Sheesha1992 59s Apr 26 '15

Seems to be working the thread is at 0 lol

3

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15

Typical. Its considered false pressing since it wasa technical issue. YET since the mod got the fancy red flair everyone gets to keep the red flair. Pfsh

3

u/tasty_serving 43s Apr 27 '15

Hey guys, what do you think I should do regarding the button? JUST KIDDING HAHHAAHA APRIL FOOLS HAHHAHA

Reminds me of those girls that ask whether they should break up with their abusive boyfriends. You emphatically tell them yes then the very next day you see her with said abusive boyfriend.

3

u/NeoHenderson 18s Apr 27 '15

It's okay /u/powerlanguage ...

We understand. You've been getting paid to watch the button all month, just like us.

Your boss cracked first though.

3

u/Chetuo can't press Apr 27 '15

You killed such an exciting game. The button was the only reason I visited and joined Reddit. I watched it a home, at work and on mobile and now it is over and your explanation just sucks!!!

9

u/dado3212 42s Apr 26 '15

No. Revert the flairs or all of this is even more useless then it was. If those button presses count them so does the timer running out. You can't have it both ways.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Do you know Dev?

5

u/goatisbusy 50s Apr 26 '15

Welp i'm done and gone. Its been fun.

5

u/Filter78 non presser Apr 26 '15

A banks server makes a mistake with a number of peoples pay and adds one zero to many. Does the bank allow the people to keep the extra money due to a server error, no, they correct the pay mistake.

4

u/Iamspeedy36 36s Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 27 '15

"Regardless of the circumstances" was never mentioned in the original April 1 button announcement post.

Edit: spelling, punctuation

4

u/Bonkeroo 53s Apr 26 '15

I ever so carefully waited... with held breath and with great precision clicked at the one second mark. My reflexes aren't perfect, but sheesh.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/QwertzHz 42s Apr 26 '15

What was wrong with /u/Ralain's suggestion?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

How do I shot web?

2

u/Graysok can't press Apr 26 '15

How could you!?!!

2

u/plokmkolp 42s Apr 26 '15

Should I choose to push the button I will use this comment as proof that I did not get my future flair through any past outages.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Spectrum117 non presser Apr 26 '15

A false red? Still looks like a normal red to me. This makes more sense.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

lol guys due to a glitch in the system that made it super easy for anyone to get something really challenging, you all totally deserve it for just being there at the time

You've ruined all mystery, surprise, and feeling to the button. Now it's just something on Reddit instead of this huge enigma that it once was.

Also, didn't you press the button more than once? Breaking your own rule? "Regardless of the circumstances" unless you made it, of course.

EDIT: as /u/bigbadler said, it hit 0. The button should be over. If the outage wasn't "canon" then the presses should be reset. If the outage was "canon" then the button should be done.

2

u/timmadara 51s Apr 26 '15

I wonder which colour i have

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JLofAmerica 57s Apr 26 '15

update on flairs from yesterday's outrage -FIFY

2

u/SmallFryHero non presser Apr 26 '15

boooo

2

u/NinTheFolf 36s Apr 26 '15

Read through this thread for delicious grey tears, was not disappointed.

2

u/sh1tbr1cks 42s Apr 26 '15

But now we know exactly how it ends. It just says "The experiment is over."

Also, there are unobtainable flairs. The 0s. And the 1s flairs that would have been rare and hard...they're out there too.

Defeats the whole purpose for me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CaptainFree 15s Apr 26 '15

where u watch flairs? i dont see any

2

u/Sadkinkythrowaway non presser Apr 26 '15

Why won't you tell us what happens when the button go down to 0?

2

u/Brohanwashere 60s Apr 26 '15

Proud to be a purple today.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

Flair doesn't even matter anymore.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

IT'S NOT IN THE LORE!!!!

2

u/MisterGrieves non presser Apr 26 '15

so other people that had previously gotten red flair during outage or issues get the cheater flair but powerlanguage gets a red during one and then decides to let them stand? who would have thought?

2

u/Kirxcy 32s Apr 26 '15

We're done here. Pressed green. It was fun while it lasted

2

u/Douglas_Everson 55s Apr 26 '15

Very disappointing :(

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

This is one of the funniest threads I've read in my 6 years here. Easily top 5.

You people need help.

2

u/j1mb0 13s Apr 26 '15

Yeah, the rule is you may only press once, not that you're entitled to the "rewards" of pressing if the press is a glitch.

2

u/Sheesha1992 59s Apr 26 '15

I still think that they all have a betting pool going on and "a glitch" wasn't a good enough reason to end the button and loose the bet...

2

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

We are doing a great job remembering that this is an online button that matters very little-keep on preserving the humanity good folks

2

u/BlueGlass47 non presser Apr 27 '15

The irritation surrounding this event comes from a lack of judgement and integrity on behalf of u/powerlanguage. Unfortunate events such as 'outages' regardless of how the occur should be met with a previously thought out plan, they should be anticipated. this has not occurred, even though this is the second time this has occurred. this lack of planning is irritating. this first point is enough to cause frustration. the second point, more jarring than anything else, is that the moderator at the top of the list, the chief moderator, has unwittingly (at best) exploited the outage that they are in charge of preventing, or at the very least, managing. coming to the internet to expect values... is a fraught proposition, whether or not you take the button seriously is external to the chief grievance here.

2

u/IceWindWolf non presser Apr 27 '15

I DONT WANT TO PRESS IT AGAIN, I JUST WANT A FLAIR!

shameless plug for /r/buttonpurgatory

2

u/ghost_moose 1s Apr 27 '15

I'm a little bitter about all this, as I was holding out for red. Seems like red would be meaningless now. I think I will aim for Orange or green since they are my two favorite colors.

2

u/krogger 21s Apr 27 '15

Introduce a new flair (and color) for anomalous presses with a hover hypertext of "?" linking to an explanation of all anomalies and a full audit trail of assigned flair color.

If possible, quantitatively define system and network conditions that are considered anomalies (SLA, p99.99, etc).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sweatymetty 59s Apr 27 '15

I don't even get it

2

u/username1338 60s Apr 27 '15

Stop being a fucking cock and letting a technical failure affect an experiment that should be a controlled setting. You are ruining it a possible scientific test just you can make it seem awe-inspiring.

2

u/Mixlop 58s Apr 27 '15

DAMN YOU POWERLANGUAAAAAAAAAAAAGE

2

u/cipheos 42s Apr 27 '15

While I clicked for 42 myself a week ago and I am glad everyone is joining us, I completely agree that these flairs should remain, they would become meaningless anyway sooner or later.

2

u/Cheerzy non presser Apr 27 '15

Man this post is popular!

2

u/lady0420 non presser Apr 27 '15

My position as Red Guard is ruined!!! NonPresser here Now. ๐Ÿ˜•

2

u/JollySmash non presser Apr 27 '15

The button was a great thing, now fro you and your FAKE red comrades selfish desires, you have sapped the religious idol of all legitimacy, meaning, and purpose. You killed the button.

2

u/DoubleYouOne non presser Apr 27 '15

You can only press the button once.

2

u/specsthedude41 60s Apr 28 '15

This was once a place of wonder and culture and it was ruined by your lack of integrity and dedication to the button. shame on you

5

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15

What bullshit, just utter bullshit

4

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15

You many only press once.*

*-Unless you are /u/powerlanguage

3

u/user20142015 can't press Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15

In my opinion Powerlanguage CAN save the day, by:

a) admitting things went wrong and because of a glitch we have seen the original ending

b) reset glitchflairs as they have been attained during false circumstances. The people don't have to be punished with cheaterflairs as their intentions where not bad.

c) Come up with a brilliant alternative ending. Just announce: We have created an alternative ending. We can't tell you what to do from here out. The choice is yours. The alternative ending must entail something that makes it either good or bad to keep the button running, without us knowing what is best. Before this glitch we didn't know either what was good or bad.

*edit formatting

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Serrated_Banana 20s Apr 26 '15

The whole premise of the button was that people press the button and it resets the button. It's a transaction. Button is pressed. Button resets. If one of these isn't fulfilled, it's not a valid transaction. The button was pressed but the button didn't reset. Non-valid transaction, thus it should all be reset.

Conclusion: This is fuckin' lame.

3

u/yumenohikari 11s Apr 26 '15

ITT: the butthurt of the masses, and the all-too-usual cries of "CORRUPTION!" when redditors don't get their way.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15

It is clear that creating the button was right in the mod's wheelhouse. Kudos to u/powerlanguage. But it is equally as clear that that same mod is entirely incapable of moderating this sub. Their handling of the sub has been so ham-fisted and excessively poor that I'd guess this is either purposeful - aka trolling - or that we're dealing with a full-blooded engineer, and all the social and common sense limitations that that normally implies.