r/worldnews • u/eagleowl123 • May 09 '12
Russian plane disappears over Indonesia
http://news.blogs.cnn.com/2012/05/09/russian-airliner-disappears-over-indonesia/9
u/ineedmoresleep May 09 '12
Updates: http://sergeydolya.livejournal.com/465960.html?thread=78228520#t78228520 (today's picture of take-off)
trajectory (around the mountain and then went down around where the black arrows are): http://twitpic.com/9j3zy1 http://twitpic.com/9j3oup
1
u/vigorous May 10 '12
"Because this was a demonstration flight, sometimes the pilots or the crews deliberately take the aircraft right to their limits. And they do that sometimes when the aircraft is quite close to the ground. That's what a demonstration flight is often like. Sometimes they push the limits just too far and that might have happened."
RT News interview with Flightglobal's safety editor, David Learmount
4
u/clickity-click May 09 '12
note to self: never, ever hitch a ride on a 'demonstration' flight.
1
u/marty_m May 10 '12
Not in a wheel well, not in the main cabin, and not in the bathroom. Forget it.
6
u/keindeutschsprechen May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
It's not just "a Russian plane", it's the very lastest airliner, the Superjet 100. It's not in the same category as the cold war planes, it's a brand new plane that relies a lot on western technology and is supposed to compete with Bombardier and Embraer.
5
3
3
u/timedevourer May 10 '12
http://www.vz.ru/news/2010/7/28/421435.html :: About 70 people who worked on the plant that made the Superjet used fake education diplomas to get paid more.
Not surprised in the slightest.
2
2
10
8
u/Fandorin May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Here's the Fandorin scale of air travel safety from safest to 'you're gonna die', based on nothig more than where I'm most or least likely to feel safe:
Boeing aircraft in the US
non-Boeing aircraft in the US
Boeing aircraft in Western Europe or between US and W.Europe
Airbus in Western Europe or between US and W.Europe
Boeing in APAC and Far East
Non-Boeing in APAC and Far East
Any plane in South America
Western-made plane in Russia or former USSR countries
Tupolev or any other Russian made plane in Russia former USSR countries
Tupolev or any other Russian made plane in Central, South and West Asia and the Middle East.
Western-made plane in Africa
Tupolev or any other Russian made plane in Africa
1
u/keindeutschsprechen May 10 '12
Boeing doesn't have a better track record than Airbus, nor does the US compared to Europe (actually, the fleets are generally more modern in Europe).
Really, that list is based on nothing but a clueless impression you got from reading the web. Great.
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
1
u/Fandorin May 09 '12
I think the US is higher, but that's not the reasoning. Mostly due to the Air France 447 crash, the reasons behind it, but also because the EU is not uniform at all. I've been to airports in EU countries that are pretty sketchy.
1
u/famousonmars May 09 '12
US has had an endless supply of pilots with 1000's upon 1000's of hours of flight experience from its war machine.
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
21
2
u/vdek May 10 '12
Boeing helped them design the plane in the first place, they are a Consultant on the project. ಠ_ಠ
They have their own financial stake in the program that is long term. But yes, go on and believe your conspiracy theories.
3
May 10 '12
I find it funny that people are commenting on the quality of Russian made hardware. Considering they have matched just about everything the US has and have the largest nuclear submarine on Earth. And lastly Sputnik
2
u/vigorous May 10 '12
There's a lot of schadenfreude in the postings.
It's disrespectful of the dead.
Don't worry about your reddit point count. You're absolutely right here.
0
u/YourMomSaidHi May 09 '12
Shit isn't magic. The thing crashed. You can call it "disappeared" if it makes you excited, but the thing crashed. I know that doesn't make as cool of a title for your news article, though. Sorry.
34
u/Ampatent May 09 '12
Typically, a good journalist doesn't jump to conclusions. A plane could enter a region where communication is cut-off and that would still qualify as "disappearing". Claiming that it crashed would then be more sensationalist than simply stating the current knowledge.
Why does it matter anyway? It's not like it would make any meaningful difference if the title was changed from disappeared to crashed.
-11
u/YourMomSaidHi May 09 '12
"Plane disappears" feels more sensational than "plan loses radio contact during descent" to me. I suppose disappearing is one way to describe what happened, but I like the actual facts rather than a description of magical events. The plane did not disappear. It just malfunctioned and cannot still be in the air. If it landed, that would be lovely, but considering all the evidence... I doubt that is what happened and so does everyone else.
12
u/Ampatent May 09 '12
Considering the circumstances, yes it probably did crash. But when it comes to headlines it's more factually accurate to state that the plane disappeared rather than to assume it crashed. Also, when it comes to submitting stories, one shouldn't editorialize the headline, regardless of the quality of the headline.
1
May 09 '12
"Plane disappears" feels more sensational than "plan loses radio contact during descent" to me.
That's because you're dumb.
4
u/Nefandi May 09 '12
You can say it crashed if you can see its pieces on the ground, and/or an investigative committee concluded that it crashed. If you can't find the remains of the plane, then even though we believe it probably crashed, we can't be 100% sure. So the technical term for that is 'disappeared'. Something 'disappears' if we don't know where it is and/or what happened to it.
10
May 09 '12
It could also have flown to space, though highly unlikely.
-7
u/YourMomSaidHi May 09 '12
It barely had the fuel to get to its destination and I don't think the path to outer space is in a descent from 10,000 to 6200. I respect your guess though. It was as likely as magic
3
u/MyDadApedohunter May 09 '12
Completely missing the point. i think he's pointing out simply that like ampatent already told you that just because our logic and common sense quickly came into a conclusion that the plane crashed, it haven't been proved yet as of now so you may as well state that the plane went into outer space or something and the statement would be as valid as when you said it crashed
For now, it's simply 'disappeared'
4
1
-9
May 09 '12
I agree, it crashed into the Pacific ocean between Indonesia's islands, no big mystery there.
7
u/foresthill May 09 '12
The article says it went missing in the mountainous region of Bogor, West Java. Bogor is inland. Also, that part of Indonesia is in the Indian Ocean.
1
u/vigorous May 09 '12
Russian embassy in Indonesia working to clarify situation with Russian SSJ-100 jet (Part 2)
1
u/vigorous May 10 '12
Helicopters find missing Superjet 100 http://www.itar-tass.com/en/c32/413663.html
1
1
u/Nefandi May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
This plane appears to have a side-stick design (00:17 & 00:35) that's been implicated in a recent crash of an Airbus plane with a similar design.
I'm not saying that SSJ100 crashed because of the side-sticks. I'm just noticing a coincidence here. Please don't jump to conclusions ahead of time.
-6
u/asimovfan1 May 09 '12
Well, I know I'm never going to fly on a Russian airliner.
4
u/Bunsky May 09 '12
Because a Russian plane crashed this one time? You might want to think twice about flying altogther. It's fairly rare, but shit happens.
14
7
u/asimovfan1 May 09 '12
Nah, I travel a lot for work and since I don't really like wandering around and meeting random people I'll only know for a few minutes I watch a lot of hotel TV, which usually includes HBO documentaries. One recent one was about how abysmal the safety records for several different Russian airline agencies is. They were talking about entire hockey teams being lost, etc... It's not just this one.
Also, I fly several times a week on average and I'm sticking with my rule that the day they book me a flight on a Russian airline is the same day I take the bus.
2
3
May 09 '12
Last flight I took on Aeroflot was on an Airbus A320. I'd also like to point out that this was a demonstration flight by the manufacturer Sukohi, not a Russian airline. I fly around Russia and the former Soviet states all the time, and keep track of the tail numbers of the planes I fly and the only two that have crashed have been a 737 belonging to Turkish operating as TK 1951 in Amsterdam, and an Airbus A330 fin number C-GITS, crashed in the Azores. Neither were operated by a Russian or Eastern airline. One French built plane, one American. I don't think you have anything to worry about.
1
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
3
May 09 '12
That's the air france crash. I still don't understand what happened there. Apparently the pilots messed up when converting height from imperial to metric?
2
u/keindeutschsprechen May 09 '12
From what I read, the main reason is that, for the purpose of the demonstration, the pilots put the plane in a very "unnatural" position.
They did a low pass with full idle and the stick way back. Any plane would have stalled, but an Airbus has this system that prevents it and the computer just keep flying it. That was actually the point of the demonstration.
But they made a pilot error and tried to do the resource too late. Apparently one of the causes was that the computer took a few seconds more to react than in normal mode (because it basically had to "trust" the commands again).
I haven't read about this unit error, but I find it very unlikely since at this altitude you don't rely on the altimeter, it's not precise enough.
3
1
-1
u/the_oggmonster May 09 '12
I just bought a ticket for a flight on a Russian airline literally less than an hour ago... thanks for the confidence!
3
u/Fandorin May 09 '12
Where to and from? And what plane, if you know? I occasionally have the joy to fly within Russia and the former republics, so I might be able to give you a small confidence boost, or not depending on your flight.
3
u/the_oggmonster May 09 '12
I'm only joking, not really worried at all. It's a Rossiya flight from London to St. Petersburg on an Airbus.
4
u/Fandorin May 09 '12
You're fine then. I was afraid you were flying on a Tu-134 from Moscow to Vladivostok or something like that.
1
-2
0
-2
-8
-1
-10
0
May 10 '12
I can't believe no one has pointed out that the aircraft due to the angle looks like part of it's wing has disappeared.
0
-4
-5
-6
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Sweet! more episodes of air crash investigations!
edit: the fuck guys, downvotes? Have you ever seen the show
-7
-2
-2
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
9
May 09 '12
Airliners.net has one too:
http://www.airliners.net/aviation-forums/general_aviation/read.main/5460828/
9
u/vigorous May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Now that's what responsible commenting on a disaster, the cause(s) of which are not known, should look like.
I don't care if I'm down-voted for this like I was for as earlier comment but I really DO NOT CARE for people who think it is fun to joke about Russian aircraft, especially where Soyuz is the only aircraft keeping the ISS alive at the moment and Russian aircraft are heavily relied upon in Afghanistan and for humanitarian relief missions all around the world.
3
May 10 '12
I agree. Many of the folks at Airliners.net work directly or indirectly in/for the aviation industry, so they tend to have a more professional mindset when it comes to things like this.
Also, Russian airplanes are generally pretty robust. Their operators have horrible safety records though, which tends to mar the reputation of the region-specific hardware they use.
3
u/ineedmoresleep May 10 '12
if russian pilots didn't fly planes while drunk, or didn't try to save $$$(fuel) by going straight over huge storm clouds instead of diverting, or didn't let their children at the controls, or didn't try to take off while on parking break... then we wouldn't have to hear/read all those jokes.
but you are absolutely right, it's not the aircraft, it's human error/judgement that is a problem in russia :(
2
u/vigorous May 10 '12
Yaroslavyl lost its hockey team because the co-pilot left the e-brake on for takeoff?
There is definitely something wrong with that picture.
1
u/ineedmoresleep May 10 '12
the plane was just found BTW: https://twitter.com/#!/dolyasergey/status/200426430704779264
0
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
18
u/clickity-click May 09 '12
I think you left out a few acronyms...
16
u/jheregfan May 09 '12
CFIT = Controlled Flight Into Terrain
ELB = Emergency Locater Beacon
SAR = Search and Rescue
5
u/strl May 09 '12
Because this is totally illegible to layman like me here's some help for the lazy:
ELB means electronic logbook. SAR is search and rescue.
Sounds like they crashed into a mountain but the lack of a signal confirming this is strange. Suppose search and rescue teams didn't get a lot of time to search before weather kicked them back.
2
u/vigorous May 09 '12
Flight path: http://www.flightglobal.com/blogs/flightblogger/2012/05/breaking-superjet-100-missing.html
Acronyms: Google is your friend.
2
4
u/vigorous May 09 '12
I'm glad you got the 7 points (so far).
You deserve them.
I just went through the posts and down-voted many for inanity, immaturity and ignorance.
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
5
u/vigorous May 09 '12
The commenters at AV Herald have a better overall outlook on aviation matters. They know enough to go directly to this site when there's trouble.
With reddit, it's Forrest Gump's box of chocolates.
0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
3
u/vigorous May 09 '12
You're right about that, AVHerald now has its share of off-base posts, although when I looked at it earlier today, the tone was largely grave, factual, and sane.
1
u/vigorous May 09 '12
I see there are some idiots posting at AV Herald.... but relatively fewer ...and they have been dealt with.
12
u/ineedmoresleep May 09 '12
pictures: http://gallery.me.com/sdolya#102194