r/westerospowers • • May 27 '14

[EVENT] [EVENT] King-Elect of Crownlands! All Crownlanders to swear fealty

21 Upvotes

The election is done, there is no reason to wait for the last vote... the vote belonging to the man, who won the election. After long discussions, disturbed by foreign lords, the lords of Crownlands choose their King. All Hail King - Elect Targaryen of the Crownlands!

According to the law created by the Crownlanders, he will have to make an oath to protect his vassals and respect the sacred laws they've created and made him a King. In return, all of the Lord - Electors will swear fealty to him. Those will not obey this order, will be called traitors and shall meet the punishment from the True King of Crownlands.

King Targaryen will rule for 4 years [Meta]Until 27-06-2014[/meta] and then next election will be held. Shall he die or resign during his term, a new King will be chosen.

[meta] please upvote for visibility


r/westerospowers • • May 31 '14

[META] Official Army Sizes!

20 Upvotes

The mods have been hard at work at balancing the lore of GRRM and creating a fun game. With that in mind, some lords are going to be more powerful than others.

Army Sizes

Below you will find a link to the army sizes. Please correct your own holdings' wiki page to match these values. To be fair, everyone with a current holding on that list will be set to those values (whether its higher or lower right now). If you are in the field, use proportional numbers; don't attempt to add the extra men into your fight. For example, if you have 70% of your men in the field, make sure 70% of the new values are in the field. Civilian population will not have an affect on any game mechanics.

/r/WesterosPowers Official Army Sizes

Holdfasts and Armies

Ruling these holdfasts is the only way to receive additional troops. Any other towns, villages, areas, etc. on the map can be fought over for storyline reasons. However, you will not receive additional troops for capturing the small town of Rushing Falls on the God's Eye. Think of the holdfasts in this list like territories in Risk.

What do these troop numbers mean?

Think of it as a combat score. Sure your Wildlings might have some giants but they won't give you any additional benefit in battle. Same goes for your army heavy in armored cavalry. The numbers are the only thing that matter, not troop type composition. An army of 1,000 infantry will be as powerful as an army of 1,000 cavalry as far as game mechanics go. We hope to rectify this later, but not yet.

How do we come up with these?

  1. We looked at existing references from the books, tower of the hand, westeros.org etc.

  2. We determined how many troops we wanted each grographical region to have.

  3. We gave the largest houses troops based on their in-canon strength in the region.

  4. The remaining troops in the region we distributed equally to the remaining houses.

  5. To make future calculations easy, we tended to round to the nearest 1/10 or 1/4 of a thousand.

What if I'm not on the list?

Send a [message to all of the mods] (http://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=%2Fr%2FWesterosMods) (please no PMs). We will have to add your house to the list for your region and remove troops from the other houses.

When will these numbers take effect?

These army numbers will begin RIGHT NOW. Remember that all battles/rallies/etc. are going to use proportional values. Don't add all of your new men into the fight; keep the same proportions.

Why do houses have such high numbers?

Each realm probably has hundreds of individual lords. In this game we're only going to have about 15 houses in one region. Assume that these smaller houses gain their extra levies from nearby lords who are under their command.

What if I disagree with an army count?

Reply to this message stating (with sources cited) of why you believe a house should have a different army amount. Most likely we'll leave the house the way it is, but if you can find good arguments we might change our minds. Note that any additional forces will be taken from the other lords in your region. Region balance is key.

What about boats, travel time, money, etc.

  • We have ideas for a system to restrict a territories' navy by port size. Also boats will take away from a houses' army size on land.

  • We plan to address travel time, mustering time, etc. One thing at a time.

  • We intend to do this but I don't think an Iron Bank will be the solution.


r/westerospowers • • May 28 '14

[meta] A call for realism in... Pretty much everywhere.

20 Upvotes

I've been wanting to post this for a while. This is supposed to be a semi-realistic game. Semi means we are not drowning in rules. It does not mean we may do whatever we want to. Here are a few examples of what I mean.

  • I think Valyria shouldn't have been unveiled. Knowing what happened there is one of the major plots of the series. The men who have tried to sail there, never came back. (Come on, does anyone actually believe Euron? ) Well, why wouldn't I send men to the lands of the always winter and get the Others to bend the knee before me?

  • Valyrian steel weapons are supposed to be the rarest thing in Westeros. In the series, there are less than ten of those left in the realm (although I didn't count them, so there might be 11). House Lannister, the richest house in the realm, has struggled for centuries to obtain a Valyrian sword. Now every farmer owns his valyrian steel fork. I'm exaggerating of course, but you get my point. Seriously guys, calm down on these.

  • When a small realm builds castles, ships, longbows (not the cheapest ones) and hire two or three -or more, for all I know- mercenary companies, you may wonder how deep their chests are.

Those are the few examples in my mind, but they're certainly not the only ones. And I have nothing against those players, no need to defend yourselves. Those are only the ones I had in mind. But they're not especially the ones that made me write this post. It's a general statement, and concerns us all. At this point, I wouldn't be surprised if Greyjoy tamed a combat kraken, if Stark raised an army of giants or if the Reach equipped all its ships with plasma-propulsion reactors.

Come on guys, just try to be realistic. This is a game, but it looses its whole sense if we simply create whatever we need without any problems.


r/westerospowers • • May 28 '14

[META] Map update... + ESSOS!

19 Upvotes

Hi guys! I am extremely happy to announce, that I was able to create Essos Map! It's crappy and looks horrible, but hey, I felt morally obliged to do that, after last time I was given Reddit Gold(en Crown) from ruler of Dothraki! Of course there might be and will be mistakes, so I am as usual waiting for all your hints and spotted errors. I also announce, that I will no longer update the map on the fly, reading all the posts regarding claims and expansions, so it's up to you to comment every time I post a map, to give me some details.
If you spot a mistake or something missing, please link the post with the proof that you're right as well.

Here are the maps:
Westeros
Essos (The territory down of Qarth is actually Great Moraq, not Yi Ti, it will be changed)

Essos map is somehow lore - unfriendly, but I had to go Practical > Lore Friendly, because I couldn't find a better map for my use than this. It's from the TV show and a lot of people were actually saying, that it's wrong in some places, especcially regarding the eastern reaches of Essos, which are usually only hinted in one - two places in books, but well, I think it's better than nothing!


r/westerospowers • • Jun 18 '14

[CONFLICT-RALLY] An Open Letter to the Dornish

17 Upvotes

My Lords of Dorne,

The past few months have been troubling. The crisis from Volantis is barely over and already we are marching from our borders to fight the Northerners and the Valemen. Why? Our Prince claims we are marching to relieve our allies of the River but are they our allies? Are they Dorne's allies or are they the allies of our Prince? I remember the last time we marched out of Dorne. Once again we were marching to assist a personal ally of our Prince, the Dragon.How did we benefit from helping the Dragon? We did not, and we shall not now.

Why should we march again and again to help Doran play the game of thrones while our people die? I shall tell you why we are marching, and it pains me to do so as our Prince is a personal friend to me and I bring dishonour to myself in what I am about to do but I do it in the hope that Dorne is strong, rather than Doran.

The Direwolf is correct. The Spear, Stag, Tower and Fish planned to crown Rhaenys Targaryen Queen of Southern Westeros. I received a raven telling me this . He did not ask for his hand's counsel until it was decided, he has not told the lords of Dorne let alone the smallfolk who will have their families broken yet again by Doran's ill-advised obsession with Dragons.

I beseech you, my lords and friends: it is time that Doran gives up the mantle of Lord of the Dornish. I wish no ill to him but I feel his rule must end. When he has been active we have been on the brink of war for almost all of the past 4 years. I do not look to sit the Sun Throne however, I do not pretend to have a claim to it. Instead I put forward Lord Yronwood. The Yronwoods ruled us once, before the Rhoynar and he has remained the Bloodroyal ever since. Lord Yronwood has spent time in Kings Landing and the Vale, discussing peace and friendship with our former enemies while Doran plotted to bring back the dragons, aplot that surely would have antagonised and threatened all those North of his new Westeros.

I call upon all who call themselves Dornish to remember that we never bowed to the Dragons. We forced the dragons to bow to us and yet Doran wishes to place the Dragon's yoke back around our necks.

I shall return to Skyreach with my 5,500 emento see who stands with me. It is my hope that blood is not needed to be shed over this. If Prince Doran will stand aside for Yronwood to rule Dorne can return to the peace we once knew

Lord Albright Fowler, Warden of Princes


r/westerospowers • • Jun 02 '14

[META] Valyrian Steel Contest - VOTE HERE

17 Upvotes

This will be the thread to vote, not the one where I explained the contest.

  • You may post the whole story or just a link to it. The post with the link will count as an entry like any other.

  • The number of upvotes will be considered. Downvotes will not matter at all.

  • The 10 posts with the most upvotes will get the weapon mentioned in the story.

  • In case there are any ties in the 10th place, a tie-breaker post will be made after the contest is over.

  • Voting will end tomorrow at 17:15 GMT.


r/westerospowers • • May 28 '14

[META] Changes to the Conflict Process

17 Upvotes

We're going to change up the way Conflicts are run. This is in response to some lords not having enough time to commit their troops into battle.

There will be 3 steps to any battle:

  1. [Conflict - Rally] This step will be used for a lord to call his allies to rally on him for a coming battle. Any lords that wish to participate in a coming battle must respond to this post in order to be counted in the battle. Any forces that were loaned to a lord by an [Event] post can be rallied by the loanee. The opposing side in the conflict should create their own rally post. You can still choose to stand down from a rally.

  2. [Conflict - Commit] This post will be used to commit a sides forces into battle. At least 24 hours IRL must have passed since the first [Conflict - Rally] post, otherwise, the mod will not perform the next step until then. Any forces that were rallied at the time of the commit are eligible to fight in the battle.

  3. [Conflict - Result] The mod performs the combat process and determines a winner. If the loser is not soundly defeated, another battle may occur.

[Conflict - Release] This post means that the troops rallied return to their original positions. This should be used when tensions have lessened and a lord wishes to release their troops back to their original lords. After a battle completes due to a surrender, all troops are automatically released and this post is not necessary.

If you wish to betray those who think you allies, Rally as normal for your supposed allies. Then send a message to the moderators with a [Conflict - Betrayal] tag. The mod will take your forces into account on the correct side.


r/westerospowers • • May 28 '14

[EVENT] The Great Westeros Council.

17 Upvotes

[META] OK, here goes guys. I ask that if you are not on the list of Lords who said they were attending you dont comment. I obviously cant enforce this in any way, but from a lore perspective the only ones who could converse in the council would be the ones who are there.

As all the Lords finish filing into Harrenhal, Iron King Tychus Greyjoy takes the time to establish exactly what this council aims to achieve.

My fellow Lords, Ladies, Queens and Kings of Westeros. I thank you for taking your time to come to this council. Your devotion to being present at this meeting shows that the security of Westeros, despite issues you may or may not have with each other, is of some import to you. The Eastern powers are strong. Should they ever ally against us it could break the Realm and bring it to heel. I feel that they could never achieve this without help from within Westeros. I fear, however, that whoever sided with them to achieve such a malicious goal would only be their next target, why else would they risk so many ships, men and resources to attack Westeros?

I have gathered us here today to discuss a pact, two pacts actually, unlike any other in the history of Westeros. These pacts would establish a defensive response force should any military fleet of significant size cross the Narrow Sea, no matter their intended goal. The first pact I propose, The Great Westeros Naval Pact, would require those with strong Navies to ally, in order to meet the foreign fleets before they hit the mainland. The second pact, The Great Westeros Land Pact, would ally several houses with not much Naval strength, but heavier strength on the ground. Should the naval force fail in protecting Westeros, this secondary group of allies would respond to any remaining force that may attempt to land.

The Pacts would NOT require you to set down your own plans, personal goals and grudges against other Westerosi. Should one House of a Pact be conquered by another Lord, then the new Lord would take up their place in upholding the Pact.

Now that you know what I propose, I would now hear your words. I have also invited dignitaries from the East, who wish to remind us that not all of the Eastern powers hold us ill will. I would have their voices heard in fairness and reason, as I would remind everyone that this is not a call to arms against the East but rather a call to the defense of our home should the East ever decide they want to shit in our back yard. What say you now my fellow Lords and Ladies?

Attending Lords:


r/westerospowers • • May 21 '14

[META] Not to put an onion in the ointment, or anything, but am I the only person that thinks the Others should be a Mod Event?

17 Upvotes

r/westerospowers • • Jun 04 '14

[DUEL] God-Emperor R'hllor of Volantis x Lord Master Tyson of New Ghis

16 Upvotes

The High Priest, with his red robes and flaming sword, walked slowly out of the gates of Volantis, eyes fixed on the Ghiscari champion, Master Tyson, his long Naginata, Shadowspike, held lightly in his hands. They drew closer, both men trying to glean whatever information they can from the other. The High Priest’s sword burned hot with a brilliant white light, more than some mummer’s trick, it seemed. However, Tyson did not seemed phased. Both men wielded the Dragonsteel of Old Valyria, the Ghiscari naginata light and fast, the Volantine’s longsword sharp and deadly, dark black contrasted by the blinding flame. they met in no mans land, Volantis’ high walls peering over the battle on one side, and on the other, a wall of pikes, spears, swords and lances watched, as two great men crossed their blades.

The first blow was dealt by Tyson. While the High Priest’s eyes continued to study him, they showed no sign of his apparent madness. The Spear of the East struck hard with an overhand blow that was poorly defended, doing 12 damage.
God-Emperor (30) 0 x 6-4 Tyson (20)

Shadowspike now gleamed red with the self proclaimed God Emperor’s blood, and quickly struck again, but the High Priest was able to predict the move, side stepped and delivered a crushing blow to Tyson’s back plate, doing 8 damage.
God-Emperor (18) 11 x 3-1 Tyson (20)

Again the God Emperor fell back, studying the injured legionnaire. While he watched, Tyson lunged out with a quick one handed thrust, delivering three damage.
God-Emperor (18) 0 x 3-2 Tyson (12)

Startled by the speed of the man he was facing, the High Priest tried to quickly return a blow, but his sloppy lunged was countered with a quick swipe of Shadowspike, to which Tyson again drove towards Benerro’s chest, causing 3 damage.
God-Emperor (15) 3 x 5-2 Tyson (12)

Reeling, the High Priest only got a glimpse of the next strike. Tyson was growing confident, and spun with his spear in one hand, building momentum with what he felt would be the final strike. the High Priest raised his flaming blade, which caught the brunt of the strike. Any other weapon would have been clove in two, but the Valyrian steel held strong. This strike made both weapons sing, a high pitched ring that could be heard for miles. the amount of force was enough to knock the High Priest on the ground, knocking the wind out of him.
God-Emperor (13) 0 x 4-3 Tyson (12)

Tyson, seeing his opportunity to finish his opponent once and for all, attempted a grand leap, aiming the naginata at his fallen opponents exposed chest. But before he could connect, as if he saw it coming, the High Priest rolled sideways and into a crouched position, swinging the burning Valyrian steel into the soft leather boot of his foe, severing his tendon. Tyson fell to his knees howling in pain, swinging Shadowspike feebly in the High Priest’s direction. The High Priest muttered a quiet prayer in High Valyrian, and told Tyson, “The night is dark, and full of terrors” as he swung his longsword high in the air, bringing it down on the crown of the Ghiscari’s head, splitting his skull, and burying the blade deep into the man’s chest, burning flesh as he went.
God-Emperor (5) 19 x 2-2 Tyson (12)

RESULT: The God-Emperor wins the challenge and kills Lord Master Tyson.

[META] Story by: Lord Tyrell - /u/therobinhood


r/westerospowers • • Jun 01 '14

[META] Valyrian Steel Contest - 10 weapons available

16 Upvotes

First, I'd like to say that recently acquired valyrian steel blades are revoked. No more "oh, I just came back from Valyria" or "the Sealord was king enough to give me a couple of valyrian steel swords". Valyrian steel should be unique and hard to come by, and allowing everyone to create events where they get one takes away all the fun. They also make a difference in duels, so there's another reason they should be rare. GRRM says there are 200 in Westeros alone, but very few have been mentioned in the books. We're giving 10 now but other contributions to the lore and the game will be rewarded with blades as well. Other events like this could happen again, if people like this one.

Every house that does not have an ancestral valyrian steel weapon may take part in the contest. Players have to write a story about a member of their house in which a special weapon is used. It can be something heroic as killing a firewyrm or kraken, or simply a duel with someone who had one.
I will give a 24 hour period for everyone to write their stories. Starting now. They will be submitted and voted in another thread tomorrow (you won't have to copy the whole text here, just a link to your wiki page will be fine and can be upvoted).

Rules:

  • Houses Tarly, Stark, Corbray, Hightower, Harlaw, Celtigar, Mormont, Roxton and Drumm may not participate. Sorry, guys.

  • House Lannister, however, can. Their blade was lost in Valyria, so they don't have it anymore. If Lade Lannister wants to write a story about how she found it again, it should be just as valid as another story.

  • Any kind of weapon mentioned in the series may be used. Here's a list of weapons mentioned in the books.

  • The weapons's name is up to the player as well, and should be mentioned in the story.

Existing stories can be posted here for feedback or whatever, but votes will not be counted before the appropriate thread tomorrow.


r/westerospowers • • May 30 '14

[META] THERE WILL BE NO RESET!

16 Upvotes

Final. Done. The End. We can stop talking about this now.

While I'm not ruling this out for the entirety of existence, we are not planning a reset right now.


r/westerospowers • • May 29 '14

[Meta] Cessation of conflict

15 Upvotes

Hey everyone. Maybe we should put a hold on all battle etc. (at least in Westeros) until we can establish a fair system for working out region size/army size.

It's for the greater good.

edit: used cessation wrong I think. need more sleep

edit: I know we are not following canon etc. and that 'george is bad with numbers' but some armies in the wiki exceed estimations from the ASOIAF series

http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/Military_forces_of_the_Seven_Kingdoms

C'mon guys. I'm not going to name names because you know who you are but lets make things reasonable.

edit: don't be a dick and downvote. If you have legitimate counter-arguments then express them because I would be genuinely interested in hearing them. I am enjoying this subreddit and think it has real potential. Don't downvote just because you think your mega-army will be damaged. We will all benefit in the long-term from this as it will ensure the longevity of 'the game'


r/westerospowers • • May 29 '14

[Meta] Realism concerns, army sizes, shipbuilding, etc

15 Upvotes

/u/BisonST and I agree about the recent complaints regarding realism in warfare. We're currently using several sources from the ASOIAF universe, real history and (hopefully) common sense to come up with better numbers for everyone.

The solution we've found is to give fixed numbers for each house to use right now, instead of the current wiki information. Time doesn't stop, though, so it's clear we also have to come up with a growth rate for each year, including the effect war and winter will have on the smallfolk.
We're not going to make numbers out of thin air. An explanation for every region in Westeros, sellsword company or city in Essos will be provided, and your feedback in the threads can change those numbers if necessary.

Another important factor is the ability to build ships. Several things have to be taken in consideration. Port size, wood resources, gold for the people building the ship, supplies for the crew, and so on. We're going to give categories to coastal cities and clarify ship types. Some cities will be able to build war galleys, others only longships, and most can only build small trading vessels that are not fit for war.

As for gold, that's the hardest thing to fix right now. It is a priority and we're working on a system that will make it a lot better, but I think common sense (which has been used so far) will be enough while we're doing this.

Sorry if this thread seems kind of pointless, I just want to make sure people know we're working on it and that any suggestion is welcome. If necessary, Conflict-Commits may be put on hold for a few hours in order to be fair with everyone.


r/westerospowers • • Jun 11 '14

[META] Discussion On Goochmoist's Role as A Moderator of /r/westerospowers

14 Upvotes

Many of us have been talking and we almost unanimously feel that /u/thegoochmoist has done nothing to add to the enjoyment of westerospowers and has even abused his powers as a mod. One such example is his claiming of THREE castles as soon as he started the game. He also made up the foolish story of having "joint ownership" of Tumbleton with Tyrell which would clearly not happen no matter what. I believe there are many other such abuses and I want people to talk about them here. I invite everyone to come and discuss why he should or should not be allowed to be a mod on this sub.


r/westerospowers • • Jun 05 '14

[Claim/EVENT] Winterfell

14 Upvotes

Timothy Rivers took a deep breath before he put the quill to the page. He knew that what he was about to do would change his life forever. His Uncle had arrived several days ago, and the revelation he had dropped had shocked him. He did not want to do this but he felt honorbound, nay duty bound to write this down.

The last few days had been a whirlwind of emotion and meetings. He had gone before the Leadership of the Night's Watch with an unheralded request. One that he could easily die for making. And they had listened. These men were his friends, and his brothers. And they knew that what he said was true. The Realm was in danger. If there was not a strong leader, then the Watch would get no support when the Others finally moved on the Wall. They needed someone to sit at Winterfell. Someone who would support the Watch full heartedly, and someone who knew their plight. The vote had been close. There were 21 people in the Night's Watch leadership who voted on him. 10 voted to have him killed. 11 voted to release him from his Vows. And so, the Lord Commander was no longer the Lord Commander. Just a regular old man.

The Night's Watch would not be getting involved in this conflict, as was their job. However, they would allow him to leave. And allow his Wildling allies to come through with him if need be. They would honor his plans. Qhorin Halfhand was the new temporary Lord Commander, and he knew all of Rivers plans. Timothy Rivers... he mulled the name over in his hand. He was no longer the Lord Commander. And in fact.. he Wasn't even Timothy Rivers anymore. He was no bastard...

He was a Stark.

He turned back to the Letter and began to write.

"My Lords of the North,

My Father was a Stark. The Stark blood runs through my veins. I have been released from my Vows as Lord Commander. I hereby pronounce my Claim for Winterfell. A Stark must always be in Winterfell. I ask that you all support me in this Claim. We must restore the Wolfs Peace. This pointless bloodshed between Northsmen must stop. I ask that all Northern Lords begin marching on Winterfell, and there we will meet and talk peace. And we will begin a new Era of Wolfspeace with a Stark in Winterfell.

-Timothy Stark, Lord of Winterfell.

[META] I ask that all Lords of the North, please join the IRC over there >>>. Also join the room #JustNorthThings We have a lot of things to discuss.

We all know that the World needs an active Stark.


r/westerospowers • • May 22 '14

[META] I've created a map...

14 Upvotes

So our Mod is pretty swamped and I've decided to help a bit, since I had an evening off. Here's map of current situation in Westeros:

http://i.imgur.com/0Uo8QOH.jpg

  1. I've marked all the expansions that weren't challenged by anyone (for example The Reach challenged Iron Island expansion on Shield Island)

  2. If someone claimed a holdfast, without specific region, I gave him some land.

  3. If there was an official vassalage, I marked it - The Senior gets the star and the vassal a circle in the same colour.

There might be and probably are a lot of errors, but I hope it will be helpful for some of us. There is only one mod, we should help him, guys! Also, if you spotted an error, feel free to tell here - this format of the map is easy to correct... for now. I guess the Blank Westeros map already divided in regions would be awesome to make a map, that we could change anytime.


r/westerospowers • • Jun 13 '14

[CHALLENGE-DUEL] Iron King Tychus Greyjoy vs. the God Emperor

13 Upvotes

Tychus sat brooding in the Seastone chair. There were many things that were troubling him as of late. All of the petty lords and their imaginary fleets they kept threatening to send against the Isles, all of the backstabbers and boy fondlers on the mainland and once again news of another victory for this self-proclaimed "fire god" in the East. Another foolish champion of Westeros and the false seven had challenged this "fire god" and fallen bleeding in the dirt.

Tychus knew why. The seven were as false and unreal as this man who thought himself a god. There was only one God. The Drowned God. And his command of the watery depths outweighed that of any fire that foolish men claimed to wield.

It was time to take action. The Iron Isles would no longer make idle threats. They were to be feared once again. It was time to return to the old ways.

"Bring me my armor and Soulreaper," he commanded to the shadows nearby, "and ready Death. We make a voyage to the far East."

"At once my king."

Tychus rose and stood, as still and hard as the cold stone from which the Seastone chair itself was carved, as his servants armored him once again. First, a coat of black ring mail followed by black enamel steel plates trimmed intricately in gold. Finally, a pair of pauldrons adorned with ornate golden krakens and a cloak as dark as the night itself. He drew up the hood of his cloak, casting his face in deep shadow. He then took Soulreaper in his grasp, a great two-handed war scythe, and proceeded to make his way to his flagship 'Death.' It was a massive war dromund of over 200 oars. It would easily cut through any recent winter ice and it had survived a thousand storms.

It was time to show the world that even a god emporer could bleed.


r/westerospowers • • Jun 11 '14

[META] My Absence

13 Upvotes

Hey guys.

I'm /u/valyrianmycelium, and I created this sub. You may know me as the Grand Maester. I want to say that I am supremely proud of what has been accomplished here, a vibrant sub with consistent players and which continues to surprise me every time I visit. Thank you to everyone who has contributed, the amazing mod team (/u/Fairfax1, /u/n0rsk, /u/Joshmofo1, and once /u/BisonST),and /u/Robak, the unofficial cartographer for a long time. Here's to you, who turned a stupid whim into a community. You've been doing an amazing job.

However, it seems the Citadel has been rather quiet recently, and I haven't been as active as I'd like to be recently. My work has been exhaustingly busy, and I have a huge assignment due Friday. This unfortunately takes priority at the moment, but after that I will be able to devote much more of my time here.

We've had a bit of a bumpy start, most of us had never done this sort of thing before, but we have come light years in a short amount to time. It's down to us to keep the sub in good order.

May the Crone give you wisdom,

/u/valyrianmycelium, Grand Maester of the Citadel.

Edit: I'd also like to thank /u/Mag_da_Mighty for her mapwork of late.


r/westerospowers • • Jun 11 '14

[Event] New Map Penned & Partially Inked.

13 Upvotes

http://imgur.com/WKLfEPG
Lords & Ladies, Kings and Queens of Westeros,
One of my husband, Artos' first acts after coming to his seat was to instruct Septa Senelle and Maester Yoren to begin putting together a comprehensive map of Westeros. I am pleased to announce that after nearly two years of laborious research and tedious drawing, that the map has finally been completed. They will do their utmost to keep the maps updated annually from now onwards.
I hope that this will be of help to new lords and old alike, in planning your schemes and machinations.
Regards,
Alyssane Dayne


r/westerospowers • • May 30 '14

[META] TIME OUT!

13 Upvotes

There shall be no, 0, offensive moves until the army numbers have been straightened out. That includes Piper trying to save his lands, the Vale attempting to rescue Darry, or any other offensive moves.

It's Friday night, I want to get drunk. I don't want to be baby sitting you guys.

NO OFFENSIVE MOVES UNTIL THE ARMIES ARE READY!


r/westerospowers • • May 29 '14

[META] While we're dealing with army numbers

13 Upvotes

I think I have the perfect occupation while we're at it: a big ass fucking tourney with the whole continent.
If you're in favor of holding hostilities for now, I say we do a tourney like the Tourney at Harrenhal with every damn lord playing this game.

The Tourney at Harrenhal and the Tourney at Braavos for our friends in Essos. What do you say? I've seen people using some very nice mechanics for tourneys here, you could all take care of it.
The only rule should be that Lord Raabe is not allowed near horses before the joust.


r/westerospowers • • May 28 '14

META: Let me throw some numbers at you

13 Upvotes

This post spoils A Clash of Kings / Season 2 of the show.

This post only covers Westeros. Piss off Essos/Wildlings.

The Problem

The army counts of the various holdings in this game are WAY off. Below you will see the population and army counts for only the holdings that (1) have a wiki created and (2) start with letter A-D. Clearly you can see a number of holdings are off on their estimates.

Holdfasts A - D

Acorn Hall – Riverlands - 1000 population, 100 army, 10% army

Antlers – Crownlands – 4200 population, 1005 army, 23% army

Ashemark – Westerlands – 199000 population, 5988 army, 3% army

Ashford – Dorne – 180,000 population, 2000 army, 1% army

Blackhaven – Stormlands - 9000 population, 6400 men (800 knights? 1/10 of the population is knights?), 71% army

Blackmont – Dorne - 14,000 population, 600 men, 4% army

Braavos – Essos – 800,000 population, 1300 ships, 2000 army, .25% army

Brightwater Keep – The Reach – 7000 population, 500 army, 7% army

Bronzegate – The Vale – 25000 population, 5500 army, 25 ships, 22% army

Casterly Rock – Westerlands – 200,000 pop, 10,000 army, 5% army

Castle Cerwyn – The North – 7,500 pop, 2,000 army, 26% army

Clegane’s Keep – Westerlands – 1,000 pop, 200 army, 20% army

Crackclaw Point – The Vale – 5,000 pop, 1,000 army, 20% army

Darkdell – The Reach – 4500 pop, 850 army, 18% army

Deepwood Motte – The North – 100,000 pop, 2500 army, 2.5% army

Dragonstone – Crownlands – 100,000 pop (on one island?), 4000 army, 230 warships (Battle of Blackwater had pirates and it only numbered 200 ships), 4% army

Duskendale – Crownlands – 14,000 pop, 3,500 army, 25% army

The Battle of the Whispering Wood had only about 2,000 men on the Lannister side and 6,000 on the Stark side. The battle of Blackwater Bay had ~21,000 on Stannis' side and 8,100 on Joffrey's side (before the reinforcements showed up).

I believe that the lords are forgetting that these troop totals are combined totals of every lord under Robb's, Tyrion's, and Stannis's command, including their own levies. These aren't their personal armies, but all of their lords combined. Most holdings should only have armies in the hundreds. Look specifically at this: http://towerofthehand.com/books/101/054/index.html

A solution?

Now that I’ve shown why this is an issue, let’s start looking at a solution. I am proposing that we place all Great Houses at relatively equal military strength (because we aren’t tracking economy, only military matters). How could we do this? We first determine a good population number to have for each region and then we use that population to set Army Percentages.

Populations

I agree with (most of) the estimates of population on this post on Westeros.org: http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/60775-how-many-people-live-in-westeros-in-each-kingdom/?p=2931712

I made some modifications (I lowered the North, Dorne, and the Iron Islands). That puts us at the following:

• The North: 1 million (down from 3)

• The Riverlands:1.2 million

• The Vale: 2.2 million

• The Crownlands: 1.5 million

• The Westerlands: 2.5 million

• The Stormlands: 2 million

• The Reach: 5 million

• Dorne: 1 million (down from 2)

• The Iron Islands: 500,000 (down from 1, still probably too high, but we can give them a larger military percentage)

From here I got this quote “It is sparsely populated in the vast regions of the North and the deserts of Dorne…” and I use to justifying lowering their numbers. And there's no way in hell the Iron Islands hold a million. They don't even plant crops.

Armies

From here we set up Army Percentages. Each region is given a certain percentage of the population that can be used for an army without lowering their morale. If a territory levies more troops than allowed they’d get a penalty to their morale. We do the math and get fairly close Army Strengths. Each lord would then calculate their number of troops based on that Army Percentage and their allotted population.

I propose the following values:

Region	Population	Percentage	Army Strength

North	               1,000,000	3%	30,000

Riverlands	       1,200,000	3%	36,000

Vale	                2,200,000	2%	44,000

Crownlands	        1,500,000	3%	45,000

Westerlands	        2,500,000	2%	50,000

Stormlands	        2,000,000	 2%	40,000

Reach	                5,000,000	1%	50,000

Dorne	                1,000,000	2%	20,000

Iron Islands	           500,000	5%	25,000

Allotting Population to Holdings

Now where do we go next? We divide this population amongst the various holdings that we have for each region. These are the number of current holdings in-game per (pre-split) regions. Independent is Essos and beyond the Wall.

*Region*     *Number of Holdings*
Independent   14
Westerlands   11
Vale              9
Stormlands     5
Riverlands      11
Reach           14
North            15
Iron Islands    5
Dorne           17
Crownlands    9
Average	12.22222222

You can find my list of the holdings here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B--3kZwJSiC8bzNfNzFTbEhJQ1E/edit?usp=sharing

We then give a set amount of population for each major city and port. I like this list of major cities: http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Seven_Kingdoms#Population

King’s Landing has .5million, so let’s set every other major city at a cool .25 million. We subtract these values from the overall region totals and then divide among the other houses.

I’m not going to do the math for every region, but let’s do The North. We start with 1 million population, subtract 250,000 for White Harbor’s population. That leaves 750,000 to distribute among the remaining 14 holdings, putting each at about 53,500 population. Therefore, a normal territory in the North would have about 1500 men in their army. Obviously some of the territories would have more and some would have less. I’d probably divide the remainder by more than the number of holdings and give the extra allotments to certain territories. If this idea gets approved we can figure that out later.

Even More Gods Damned Rules

From here we can do cool stuff like casualties. If you fight in a battle you should lose some men from them combat. Perhaps we setup a system wherein you recover a certain Army Percentage per year (maybe .5%)? Now populous regions that have a lower percentage for balance regions (i.e. The Reach) can have more constant battles. On the same idea, one disastrous defeat for the North could set them back for up to 6 years.

Maybe boats are counted towards the army total as 1 boat = 50 men. Then powers that are known for being naval (RedWynes, Iron Islands, etc.) would get a discount for "buying" boats.


r/westerospowers • • May 27 '14

An invasion from the East looms! Westeros Unite!

13 Upvotes

My Lords and Ladies,

too long have the plotters been allowed to remain in the dark. I warn you, all inhabitants of Westeros of a plot to destroy our lands as we know it. Several Free cities have allied with the Lord (self-proclaimed King) of the Vale to bring Westeros to it's knees.

Dothraki, Qartheen, Qohori and Slavers have all banded together with this traitor King.

Long have I declared that a Westeros weakened by internal strife and not united under a single monarch would be ripe for the taking. My fears are now warranted as I have two confirmed sources for the existence of this plot. I plead to all you Lords and Ladies to cease hostilities and to enter into negotiations to restore a single Monarch who will allow greater rights for the Lords but who retains the ability to call the realm together for outside threats.

I, the Prince of Dorne, have no desire to see Dothraki and Slavers in my realm and wish to protect my smallfolk.

In Dorne all preparations are made for winter and war, harvests are taken in our cysterns are filled with water and our levies are trained. I hope that we do not stand alone against this foreign threat. Whether you like the idea of a single King or not is not even important, the questions is would you rather have barbarians rule over our glorious lands, rape our sheep and eat our smallfolk?!


r/westerospowers • • Jun 16 '14

[RELEASED] [Meta] The so-called 'Grand Maester'.

12 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm /u/valyrianmycelium. I was the original creator of this sub, and the only mod for about a fortnight. I put a great deal of time into building this into the place it is today, and when /u/SirFairfax offered to help I was happy that I could share the burden.

But it was here that I messed up. I took advantage of the situation and began shifting my responsibilities to the small team of mods here, none more so than /u/SirFairfax. Soon I did nothing else but watch as they turned my small sub of no more than 15 people into a vibrant community of over 250, which continues to surprise and entertain me to this day.

I'm sorry for that. I'm sorry I went away. I tried to get back in, lurked a bit and made my excuses, but the damage had already been done. I was already in the black cells, I just didn't know it yet.

Yet still I dallied, and did nothing but cause trouble for the community which I founded. In fact, I only succeeded in driving off one of the oldest and most respected members of the sub.

As Jaime Lannister put it: "That boy had wanted to be Ser Arthur Dayne, but someplace along the way he had become the Smiling Knight instead."

I realize that this falling-out has threatened to divide the sub in two, so I am ending it here. It's clear that you don't want me for a mod. It's probably better for everyone if I just leave, and let you play the game in peace. If this makes Fairfax come back, then great, but it really is better for the sub if I get out of your way.

It was a great ride, but we all have to get off at some point.

Good luck and gods bless.

Your absentee Grand Maester, /u/valyrianmycelium