This post spoils A Clash of Kings / Season 2 of the show.
This post only covers Westeros. Piss off Essos/Wildlings.
The Problem
The army counts of the various holdings in this game are WAY off. Below you will see the population and army counts for only the holdings that (1) have a wiki created and (2) start with letter A-D. Clearly you can see a number of holdings are off on their estimates.
Holdfasts A - D
Acorn Hall – Riverlands - 1000 population, 100 army, 10% army
Antlers – Crownlands – 4200 population, 1005 army, 23% army
Ashemark – Westerlands – 199000 population, 5988 army, 3% army
Ashford – Dorne – 180,000 population, 2000 army, 1% army
Blackhaven – Stormlands - 9000 population, 6400 men (800 knights? 1/10 of the population is knights?), 71% army
Blackmont – Dorne - 14,000 population, 600 men, 4% army
Braavos – Essos – 800,000 population, 1300 ships, 2000 army, .25% army
Brightwater Keep – The Reach – 7000 population, 500 army, 7% army
Bronzegate – The Vale – 25000 population, 5500 army, 25 ships, 22% army
Casterly Rock – Westerlands – 200,000 pop, 10,000 army, 5% army
Castle Cerwyn – The North – 7,500 pop, 2,000 army, 26% army
Clegane’s Keep – Westerlands – 1,000 pop, 200 army, 20% army
Crackclaw Point – The Vale – 5,000 pop, 1,000 army, 20% army
Darkdell – The Reach – 4500 pop, 850 army, 18% army
Deepwood Motte – The North – 100,000 pop, 2500 army, 2.5% army
Dragonstone – Crownlands – 100,000 pop (on one island?), 4000 army, 230 warships (Battle of Blackwater had pirates and it only numbered 200 ships), 4% army
Duskendale – Crownlands – 14,000 pop, 3,500 army, 25% army
The Battle of the Whispering Wood had only about 2,000 men on the Lannister side and 6,000 on the Stark side. The battle of Blackwater Bay had ~21,000 on Stannis' side and 8,100 on Joffrey's side (before the reinforcements showed up).
I believe that the lords are forgetting that these troop totals are combined totals of every lord under Robb's, Tyrion's, and Stannis's command, including their own levies. These aren't their personal armies, but all of their lords combined. Most holdings should only have armies in the hundreds. Look specifically at this: http://towerofthehand.com/books/101/054/index.html
A solution?
Now that I’ve shown why this is an issue, let’s start looking at a solution. I am proposing that we place all Great Houses at relatively equal military strength (because we aren’t tracking economy, only military matters). How could we do this? We first determine a good population number to have for each region and then we use that population to set Army Percentages.
Populations
I agree with (most of) the estimates of population on this post on Westeros.org: http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/topic/60775-how-many-people-live-in-westeros-in-each-kingdom/?p=2931712
I made some modifications (I lowered the North, Dorne, and the Iron Islands). That puts us at the following:
• The North: 1 million (down from 3)
• The Riverlands:1.2 million
• The Vale: 2.2 million
• The Crownlands: 1.5 million
• The Westerlands: 2.5 million
• The Stormlands: 2 million
• The Reach: 5 million
• Dorne: 1 million (down from 2)
• The Iron Islands: 500,000 (down from 1, still probably too high, but we can give them a larger military percentage)
From here I got this quote “It is sparsely populated in the vast regions of the North and the deserts of Dorne…” and I use to justifying lowering their numbers. And there's no way in hell the Iron Islands hold a million. They don't even plant crops.
Armies
From here we set up Army Percentages. Each region is given a certain percentage of the population that can be used for an army without lowering their morale. If a territory levies more troops than allowed they’d get a penalty to their morale. We do the math and get fairly close Army Strengths. Each lord would then calculate their number of troops based on that Army Percentage and their allotted population.
I propose the following values:
Region Population Percentage Army Strength
North 1,000,000 3% 30,000
Riverlands 1,200,000 3% 36,000
Vale 2,200,000 2% 44,000
Crownlands 1,500,000 3% 45,000
Westerlands 2,500,000 2% 50,000
Stormlands 2,000,000 2% 40,000
Reach 5,000,000 1% 50,000
Dorne 1,000,000 2% 20,000
Iron Islands 500,000 5% 25,000
Allotting Population to Holdings
Now where do we go next? We divide this population amongst the various holdings that we have for each region. These are the number of current holdings in-game per (pre-split) regions. Independent is Essos and beyond the Wall.
*Region* *Number of Holdings*
Independent 14
Westerlands 11
Vale 9
Stormlands 5
Riverlands 11
Reach 14
North 15
Iron Islands 5
Dorne 17
Crownlands 9
Average 12.22222222
You can find my list of the holdings here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B--3kZwJSiC8bzNfNzFTbEhJQ1E/edit?usp=sharing
We then give a set amount of population for each major city and port. I like this list of major cities: http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Seven_Kingdoms#Population
King’s Landing has .5million, so let’s set every other major city at a cool .25 million. We subtract these values from the overall region totals and then divide among the other houses.
I’m not going to do the math for every region, but let’s do The North. We start with 1 million population, subtract 250,000 for White Harbor’s population. That leaves 750,000 to distribute among the remaining 14 holdings, putting each at about 53,500 population. Therefore, a normal territory in the North would have about 1500 men in their army. Obviously some of the territories would have more and some would have less. I’d probably divide the remainder by more than the number of holdings and give the extra allotments to certain territories. If this idea gets approved we can figure that out later.
Even More Gods Damned Rules
From here we can do cool stuff like casualties. If you fight in a battle you should lose some men from them combat. Perhaps we setup a system wherein you recover a certain Army Percentage per year (maybe .5%)? Now populous regions that have a lower percentage for balance regions (i.e. The Reach) can have more constant battles. On the same idea, one disastrous defeat for the North could set them back for up to 6 years.
Maybe boats are counted towards the army total as 1 boat = 50 men. Then powers that are known for being naval (RedWynes, Iron Islands, etc.) would get a discount for "buying" boats.