r/trees • u/LOLumad1013 • May 21 '12
My mom had jury duty today for a 22 year old caught with a lot of weed. Something surprising happened...
Disclaimer- I'm not a good writer so if there are typos and such I apologize in advance.
My mom- 50 year old Blond haired blue eyed conservative christian American.
She was one of two people who did not want to convict this kid for getting caught with what was described as "enough pot to sell 200 joints to the public"
My mom described the bag as a plastic large ziplock bag(most likely 1 or 2 oz.)
The other person who did not want to convict? a 78 year old conservative war veteran from the south.
What he said made me kind of excited as to how the older generation thinks about the prohibition of pot.
"I lived through prohibition of alchohol and i think it is just wrong to charge this young man and send him to prison because this pot stuff is going to be legalized soon anyway just like alchohol was"
Long story short my mom and this man deadlocked the jury which resulted in a non conviction for this young guy.
Edit: You guys are right. He was not around during prohibition if he was 78. I got the age wrong. After calling my mom and asking her she confirmed he was 87..NOT 78. Forgive me for my stoner moment)
563
May 22 '12
Right on, hopefully the prosecutor decides not to retry the guy and rethinks his stance on marijuana cases.
I don't know if your mom is aware of jury nullification, but if she explained it to the jurors I could probably see her winning a few more people over. It isn't like the judge informs jurors that they can choose to disregard a law they feel is unjust.
185
May 22 '12
Can you do that? My understanding is, at the faintest hint of mentioning jury nullification (during the jury selection) the judge just sends you out the door.
276
May 22 '12
So don't say anything about it until you've been selected.
115
May 22 '12
I don't think you understand.
But I'm kind of too high to explain.
146
May 22 '12
If graduate students can study for final exams/write thesis while high, I'm sure you can type out a few sentences.
112
u/Deltafine May 22 '12
But he didn't just say he was high, he said he was too high
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (13)167
u/SocotraBrewingCo May 22 '12
I am in graduate school for theoretical chemistry, and I support this message.
→ More replies (50)→ More replies (5)24
u/feureau May 22 '12
It's okay. Please go on and explain. We're all too high here..
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (48)3
40
u/blixt141 May 22 '12
As an attorney who has picked juries and tried cases (but doesn't practice criminal law at all), it is really for a juror to say they will follow the law and then simply refuse to convict. You just have to keep your convictions (so to speak) close to your vest.
→ More replies (9)12
7
u/msh6465 May 22 '12
when I had jury duty last month the prosecution explicitly brought up jury nullification to us.
→ More replies (1)6
u/OldHippie May 22 '12
That's mind-boggling. In my understanding, nobody wants to even mention it in court. It's like the elephant in the room.
→ More replies (1)8
May 22 '12
Well obviously you keep your mouth shut during the selection process. I don't believe the judge is directly involved in the jury selection process, but rather the DA and the defendant's attorney, with the judge acting as an intermediary. I will admit I've never actually been called for jury duty, most of my knowledge comes from the appropriately titled Pauly Shore movie. Anyone here actually been called to serve AND made it through the selection process?
→ More replies (1)11
May 22 '12
Each side gets to 'canvas' the jury, which can be done either through questionaires or interviews, depending on the judge. Each side is allowed a set number of peremptory challenges that can be used for any reason besides race. You can also challenge 'for cause' which would be that the juror demonstrates an inability to follow the law, or is otherwise unfit. This is usually what happens in death penalty cases when jurors say that they are unable to sentence a defendant to death. So if 99% of the population became opposed to the DP, the 'jury of your peers' that you're entitled to is that 1% of assholes who still think it's ok to execute somebody.
→ More replies (3)16
u/wcc445 May 22 '12
People just need to learn to shut the fuck up in these interviews. As bad as it sounds, if we're forced to play within a corrupt system, we have to really play a bit. The problem is that so many of those on the right side of big issues are too true to themselves to lie during the selection process.
3
u/The_MAZZTer May 22 '12
I don't know if it's different for CIVIL cases, but when I was on the jury for one I was informed that I HAD to accept the judge's intepretation of the law as it was given to me (I was given the option to voice my objection if I couldn't do this, probably so I could be excused and replaced).
→ More replies (2)11
u/OldHippie May 22 '12
Sure you do.
You can also simply vote "not guilty", and you don't have to explain your vote to anyone.
→ More replies (20)2
u/lacheur42 May 22 '12
That's why you only mention it after you're selected. It's legal, but they really don't like it.
6
u/shadowblade May 22 '12
Moreover, they usually flat out say you can't "Only consider the case at hand, not the law". Its a de facto right of the jury.
3
u/0851314 May 22 '12
The whole reason why we have a jury to start with is because of Jury Nullification. What's the point of having a jury if the jury is only going to make the same ruling a judge would make?
2
u/SoLongSidekick May 22 '12
You can't be retried for same crime if he was found not guilty like the OP says, but it sound like it was a mistrial not an inoccent verdict.
13
u/ItzHayden May 22 '12
You cant be tried for the same crime twice, It's called Double Jeopardy. 'Merica!
17
May 22 '12
A hung jury results in mistrial. The case may still be retried. Double jeopardy is only applicable following a legitimate acquittal or conviction.
→ More replies (1)15
2
u/brerrabbitt May 22 '12
Does not apply in the case of a hung jury. The prosecution can retry the case if it wishes too.
2
→ More replies (11)2
1
u/brownestrabbit May 22 '12
That's like asking him to re-think his job and its associated paycheck. I doubt anyone will be changing their mind in law enforcement until we stop funneling our money into the paychecks of law-enforcement.
(Of course I am perhaps over simplifying and generalizing about law enforcement's position, but I stand by it as a legitimate concern/idea.)
1
→ More replies (30)1
54
u/nsloth May 22 '12
i wish i had "enough pot to sell 200 joints to the public" except instead i'd smoke 'em
14
u/Zenithen May 22 '12
I was thinking about this, if it was only an ounce or two... and each joint had a gram in it... that's only like 56 joints.... these cops are fucking high I tell ya...
13
u/MrPartridge May 22 '12
Duuuuude. I wanna roast with you if you put an entire gram into one joint.
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (2)2
May 22 '12
Because police don't know anything about the culture of consumption. I had a friend who was arrested, and the officer asked him "how much does a ten-sack go for these days?"
100
u/ShazmasterVGS May 22 '12
Fuck yeah. Thats awesome, give your mom a high five.
181
u/lazyzebra May 22 '12
35
u/ryannayr140 May 22 '12
I do not remember seeing this picture, yet it is purple. Must've been high.
→ More replies (1)4
2
139
u/leSconnie May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
Excellent, more people need to be educated on Jury Nullification. When you're the jury, you are the law. You may constitutionally not convict someone, even if you think they're "guilty" beyond a reasonable doubt.
From Wikipedia: "If a pattern of acquittals develops, however, in response to repeated attempts to prosecute a statutory offence, this can have the de facto effect of invalidating the statute. A pattern of jury nullification may indicate public opposition to an unwanted legislative enactment."
Edit: Didn't see mudmaster already mentioned this, but yeah, spread the word!
41
u/thequux May 22 '12
Jury nullification isn't something that's granted by the constitution; rather it's inherited from the English common law system. (actually, most of the US's legal system is inherited from the Brits, because the founders simply considered it the default.)
20
u/leSconnie May 22 '12
I'm aware it isn't explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, but it is a constitutionally allowable act. I'm also very aware of common law (aspiring crim defense lawyer here).
18
u/Hemmerly May 22 '12
They screen pretty heavily for this during selection. Generally bad to have someone who knows about this on a jury.
46
u/OldHippie May 22 '12
No, bad to have someone stupid enough to mention it during voir dire.
→ More replies (1)24
u/amarine88 May 22 '12
unless you really don't want to do jury duty.
39
u/OldHippie May 22 '12
Yeah...I'm not usually sarcastic around here, but how can you fail to be impressed by people who want weed to be legalized but refuse to take on the most basic citizenship responsibilities: voting and serving on juries?
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (25)2
11
47
20
9
36
u/dcmjim May 22 '12
umm how could a 78 year old have lived through Prohibition?
18
u/fuckyoudigg May 22 '12
prohibition ended in '33, this man would of been born in '33-'34, so he wouldn't of lived through it, but his parents and family would of, so he probably knew what went on during prohibition. Also if it is Mississippi, prohibition went on till '66.
→ More replies (1)12
u/thepupilindenial May 22 '12
I'm sorry to be that asshole, but you did it three times and I have to.
"Would've" is the contraction form of "would have." "Of" is a preposition.
8
u/fuckyoudigg May 22 '12
I can't believe I did that. Well at least I was consistently wrong. I know better.
2
u/aplgirl May 22 '12
If born the year after it officially ended, then there were probably people who'd been jailed and in trouble with the law that he knew. His parents might have gotten into trouble/shaped his views on the matter.
1
May 22 '12
The second section bans the importation of alcohol in violation of state or territorial law. This has been interpreted to give states essentially absolute control over alcoholic beverages, and many U.S. states still remained "dry" (with state prohibition of alcohol) long after its ratification. Mississippi was the last, remaining dry until 1966;[6] Kansas continued to prohibit public bars until 1987.[7] Many states now delegate the authority over alcohol granted to them by this Amendment to their municipalities or counties (or both), which has led to many lawsuits over First Amendment rights when local governments have tried to revoke liquor licenses.
→ More replies (10)1
6
u/cptbass May 22 '12
I just gave everyone uptokes in honor of your bad ass mother. Keep on fighting the good fight.
6
u/TroutM4n May 22 '12
JURY NULLIFICATION!
This is a little known aspect of our system of checks and balances in the United States. Juries have the right to find a defendant technically guilty, but refuse to sentence if they disagree with the law!!!
If you are registered to vote, you have the chance to be selected for jury duty. If you get selected, there's a pretty good chance that you will find yourself in one of the millions of marijuana cases clogging our court system. In that case, you can exercise your right to not convict someone for something you don't think should be a crime!
TLDR - Register to Vote - Get Jury Duty - Refuse to convict in marijuana cases
2
May 22 '12
'S'truth!
It's a duty, folks. You want a better country, serve on a jury and be that change.
2
May 22 '12
Registering to vote it no longer the only way to get selected for jury duty, because people were just not registering to vote on order to avoid jury duty. In most states if you have a driver's license, file taxes, receive benefits and/or register to vote, you are on the list.
5
5
u/trolol420 May 22 '12
This also gives me hope. Living In Australia the light at the end of the tunnel seems distant. The stupid part is that in several states it's decriminalized anyone can even grow plants with only a small fine if caught. Yet in most states its still illegal and the public's view is still very much in the closet...
→ More replies (1)
5
May 22 '12
So they determined that the kid had enough to roll 200 joints? I see they just pulled that number out of their ass. I'm pretty sure an ounce will not yield 200 joints.
4
4
4
u/handsome_manson May 22 '12
that bit about the "enough pot to sell 200 joints to the public" reminds me of some Neil deGrasse Tyson lecture, where the judge was telling the jury how the defendant was caught with 2000mg of Cocaine or some other drug, and was just using that terminology making it appear like a huge amount when in reality it is only 2grams.
4
u/djspawn00 May 22 '12
Jury Nullification. Every ent should know about it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification
8
u/Chugmuffin May 22 '12
Alcohol was illegal from 1919 to 1933 right? But if this guy is 78 then he was born in 1934. So how did he live through the prohibition of alcohol?
→ More replies (3)2
3
u/red321red321 May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12
that's awesome. all about jury nullification too. know the law ents.
3
u/blixt141 May 22 '12
That's how it has to happen. When people refuse to enforce laws that make no sense!
3
u/brerrabbitt May 22 '12
Hell, I'm a middle aged vet that will never vote to convict on a victimless crime
→ More replies (1)1
May 22 '12
Soups you commitment to vote a crime, victimless with or without having been aware or unawares?
3
May 22 '12
Yeah prohibition still went on in the states way after federal prohibition ended. So either way. My grandma always says she lived through prohibition when we talk about weed too.
Anywhays cool story man. Thank you for sharing.
3
3
u/Triviaandwordplay May 22 '12
My 78 year old tea party republican father is pro legalization, and he drives a Prius.
3
3
u/Arnox May 22 '12
This post has everything! Edits, war vets, Christians, spelling disclaimers and legal decisions based on opinion rather than judicial procedures.
3
u/captmorgan50 May 22 '12
Jury Nullification. They judged the law instead of him. I am happy to hear it.
3
u/CARVERitUP May 22 '12
You do know that everything that is done/said/decided in that room as a jury is bound by law to be confidential? I mean, this isn't such a serious case, but in a murder, if the guy got convicted, ANY information about who said yes and no would be extremely harmful to end up in his hands. Just remember that before posting something like this to Reddit next time :\
3
u/Gogmagog May 22 '12
The worst thing is that they obviously wanted to contrive a trafficking charge instead of possession. It seems like every cop and jury in North America wants nothing more than to hand out jail time for an ounce of weed.
3
May 22 '12
Believe it or not, jury nullification is a right.
It's your right, as a member of a jury to outright refuse to convict someone if you feel the crime in question carries no blame.
1
u/QuayX May 22 '12
Spend less time with pot and more time learning and you may not find yourself apologising about spelling in advance of writing.
2
u/LOLumad1013 May 22 '12
I am a nursing student at a decently good university with a 3.89 gpa. I think i focus a decent amount of time on learning. When i get super baked and make a post about my mom on a website that doesnt count for shit in real life is when i dont care about spelling/writing.
That horse is pretty tall. You should consider stepping off of it sometime.
→ More replies (1)3
u/ikek9 May 22 '12
That's pretty awesome that you misspelled a word in your admonishment... about spending time learning so as not to... misspell words. Kudos. I will let you figure out which word it is on your own and I APOLOGIZE if you can't find it :)
4
5
2
2
u/THEJinx May 22 '12
Awesome! Good job, mom!
So is this jury nullification? Did they say that they didn't think the kid was guilty of the crime, or that the law itself was not the right one for the case? Deadlocking a jury isn't the same as nullification.
I wish they HAD used jury nullification in Florida where the woman fired a warning shot to prevent her husband from kicking her ass. She got TWENTY YEARS because of their draconian gun use law. I woulda put that law on trial so fast....
1
u/daKINE792 May 22 '12
yep that case is bullshit. She would have got less time had she shot him dead.
2
u/uradonkey003 May 22 '12
This is the type of advice that all "50" % of Americans who think weed should be legalized can use to stop the war on drugs, specifically MJ. [7]
2
2
2
2
u/watchout5 May 22 '12
Jury nullification means that you admit the person broke the law but there should be no punishment because the law in unjust. It was used before segregation to get racist white people who committed hate crimes out of all punishment, however the revolt that followed enshrined equality among races in our constitution. It's something more people use on marijuana or drug charges, one way prosecutors have got around this is mandatory minimums, I'm not a lawyer but sometimes I read the news.
2
u/GATTACABear May 22 '12
The only people who count weed in "possible joints" are people who don't smoke weed.
2
2
u/P2D_ItsME May 22 '12
I thought the jury had a question of fact, while the judge has the question of law. The jury can say whatever they want but they can't rule him innocent and say "It's going to be legal soon anyways." The judge would still overturn that because if he was caught with the weed, he's going to be punished... The current law is what sticks, and it's the judge's duty to enforce it. I'm no lawyer, but I don't understand how the jury can get the kid off just saying "it's going to be legal soon anyway"...
3
May 22 '12
This is why there is a right to trial by jury of your peers. They most certainly can refuse to convict, for just these reasons. It is de facto jury nullification. Having said that, the judge can indeed set aside a verdict, but doing so opens him up to reversal by a higher court, and isn't done lightly.
2
2
2
u/monika1927 May 22 '12
They made a guy that's 87 do jury duty? That's heartless.
→ More replies (1)2
u/blackmamba888 May 22 '12
you have the option to decline if you're over 65. my grandpa used to watch court cases when he was in his 80's. maybe this guy was just like hey i'll sign up if they summon me again
2
2
2
2
u/agnosticnixie May 22 '12
The bit about prohibition - it's a lot how prohibition ended too, juries just started to nullify trials related to alcohol. By the last year or two it was nearly impossible to convict anywhere for an alcohol related offense.
2
2
2
u/teragold81 May 22 '12
I was once on a panel for a "drug trafficking" trial. The prosecution put on quite the circus show and to top it off one of the prosecutors even looked like Jeff Greene, making it even more hilarious at a solid [0.] I wasn't selected, they told me when and where to show up but not how much rest to get. As a taxpayer I would find such a non-violent defendant not guilty and actually hope to do so one day.
2
u/daKINE792 May 22 '12
It is called JURY NULLIFICATION and it one of our sacred rights. As a Juror you are not bound to up hold any illegal law.
2
u/CollisionCourse34 May 22 '12
WOW. great post! Congrats to your Mom. She prevented a young man from going to prison, his life was not ruined because of this substance that would have caused 200 citizens a case of the MUNCHIES! Can I ask if the young man was white, hispanic, black. . .?
2
2
2
2
2
u/dangeraardvark May 22 '12
That's awesome. But what about the 10 nimrods who wanted to ruin the guy's life so they could get home in time for Two and a Half Men?
2
May 22 '12
My mother was born in 1920 and never, not even once, did I hear her say anything against pot. She had Willie Nelson to her home for dinner (she fixed dinner for him while he was touring) and told him he could smoke in her house and didn't need to go outside to do so. This was in the 1980's.
However, her position on weed had nothing to do with Prohibition; having been born in Oklahoma, she saw the stuff growing wild on the banks of the Red River. She also knew that Native people used it for healing, but if it were burned it might make you dizzy.
2
2
u/Tygray May 22 '12
Just wanna say prohibition was almost 100 years ago. So that guy couldn't have been 78... Sorry to ruin your story.
2
u/TinHao May 22 '12
If he was a 78-year-old, he didn't live through the prohibition of alcohol.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
May 22 '12
"enough pot to sell 200 joints to the public" what horse shitty way to scare a jury of suburb moms.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
May 22 '12
My gramps is a ridiculously huge conservative but he fuckin lovessssss willie nelson. The other day i visit him and he's like, "damn border patrol arrested willie! All he does is smoke a little pot, he doesn't hurt anyone..."lol the bastard won't defend it in any other context, but he knows what's up :)
2
2
2
u/AbCynthia956 May 22 '12
Having lived through the 60s and 70s, I find it truly absurd that marijuana is still illegal. Social devolution.
2
2
u/Iwant2binspired May 22 '12
y, we need more people like this gentleman and your mom :-) Uptokes for you and your mom!
2
2
u/ACE_C0ND0R May 22 '12
I promise that if I'm ever on jury duty and it happens to be a case involving weed possession (and nothing else violent), I will try to get you acquitted.
3
u/nevertotwice May 22 '12
hopefully the guy is smart enough to realize that if he gets caught again he probably won't get so lucky
→ More replies (1)
3
u/nholba May 22 '12
I thought you were entitled to a jury of your peers?
How is a 50 year old mom and an 87 year old war vet a 22 year old's peers?
→ More replies (1)
3
3
5
u/QuitReadingMyName May 22 '12
I wish there was more stuff like this in /r/trees.
Instead of stupid bullshit of pictures of food, weed and dumb ass "lol im a [10] or lol hey im an ent" (Only reason why you guys brag about this stupid shit, is because weed is illegal and you think its cool to brag about it. It's fucking childish)
→ More replies (4)3
2
u/cswalker May 22 '12
Uhm, hate to harsh your buzz, but Prohibition ended in 1933. I'll let you do the math.
2
u/asldkfououhe May 22 '12
haha did people really fact check the old dude thing? even if this story were complete fiction, it's so innocuous that it doesn't fucking matter
once again, reddit houses the most uptight stoners on the planet. grats to your mom or not, whatever
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Focused-Third-Eye May 22 '12
Awesome! I would have liked to have this happen to me... But hey, some of us have to do the time and pay the fines until the illogical laws regarding this "crime" cease to exist.
Decriminalize it. Legalize it.
1
u/jslaytrain May 22 '12
Upvote for spreading the word about those on jury duty doing the right thing!
I'd give a 2nd upvote for beeing trees related, but...yeah. take my one upvote
1
u/NoCowLevel May 22 '12
Jury nullification is the strongest tool against unjust laws and creeping authoritarian governments. More people should understand these things, they're important.
1
1
1
1
u/hornplayerchris May 22 '12
Good story. Someone who is 78 did not live through prohibition. The 21st amendment was passed in 1933, this man would have been born in 1934.
1
1
u/Danascot May 22 '12
It's called jury nullification. Spread the word so when weed friently folks get put on a jury hearing a pot case they'll know what they can do. http://the420times.com/2011/12/marijuana-legalizations-secret-weapon-jury-nullification/
1
1
1
u/mechanical_Fred May 22 '12
This is known as jury nulificiation (of a law). Even if the jury accepts the facts of a case that indicate that a law was broken, they can still refuse to convict if they don't think that what the defendant did should be illegal. This is how fugitive slave laws were defeated.
1
u/Gentleman_Bird May 22 '12
I am glad the older generation is on board with it, shockingly enough i have found that most people older than 65 are actually okay with it. my grandma and a bunch of her friends were telling stories about how the use to smoke refer and go to malt shops.
→ More replies (4)
1
1
u/VeteranKamikaze May 22 '12
Fuck yes. Moments like this, a juror refusing to find guilty a person who broke an unjust law, make me proud to be an American. These are the very ideals we were founded on.
1
May 22 '12
Nullify the ignorance, nullify a war, we can and we should. Use your power as a citizen, you'll feel great and will truly be saving lives.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Mrcheez211 May 22 '12
That's weird because today my brother went to court and got 30 some hours of community service for getting caught with a pipe and a tiny amount of weed.
1
u/harbinger44 May 22 '12
just a side note:
a hung-jury results in a mistrial, not a "non conviction". this means that if the ADA wants, he can retry the kid in front of a new jury.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/mrspaznout May 22 '12
i feel like jury nullification is one of the few things that could benefit from a few rounds of slactivism. since it really is such and unknown thing and people knowing about it would actually help.
you know how to do it. so spam youtube, facebook, twitter, and one of the 20 people on google+ make sure the others know.
1
May 22 '12
You have a pretty cool mom.
As a side note, I think it's hilarious that people still talk about "selling joints." Is that a thing? I've never seen it. Tell me it isn't a thing. The closest thing I've seen was someone selling weed and then rolling them a joint.
And how many joints do you actually get from an ounce. Obviously it depends on the size of the joint and the density of the ounce, but I'm still curious.
→ More replies (6)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/KingSmoke May 22 '12
Old people know the consequences of mixing church morals and state. It is a lesson our generation's idiots will have to learn the hard way as well.
1
1
1
u/PowerChordPsycho May 22 '12
Lol that's awesome. Uptoke for your mom and awesome old man. And about your stoner moment, it's ok. My life is a stoner moment lol
1
1
1
u/le_catchy May 22 '12
fuck yeah!
sorry, i have nothing valuable to add i just think this is awesome!
202
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Many old people realize that while they might not like something, they sure as hell don't want the government telling them what they are allowed to like.