r/todayilearned • u/KrzysztofKietzman • May 08 '12
TIL that one cannot name a star after oneself in exchange for cash and that all such commercial companies which offer to name stars after people are in fact scams.
http://www.iau.org/public/buying_star_names/289
u/Medivacs_are_OP May 08 '12
I have a minor planet (asteroid) named after me as part of winning a 2nd prize in my category at the Intel International Science and Engineering Fair. I have a certificate from the official naming committee for such things... I paid nothing for it. It's even on wikipedia!
109
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
Could you link to it?
148
u/Medivacs_are_OP May 08 '12
I'd rather not specify the exact number that has been named after me, because it is literally my first and last name. But here is the link to the long list of minor planets that includes mine. Hope that suffices.
15
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
Perhaps planets are named differently? Anyways, wow, it's nice to be a minor planet :-).
→ More replies (7)24
u/pro_astronomer May 08 '12
Planets are named in the same way, which is that the discoverer is allowed to suggest a name and the IAU then decided on the true name, perhaps taking into account this suggestion. Asteroids, being much more common, have significantly less scrutiny put on them when it comes to naming. Stars do not, typically, have names; we usually rely on one of several catalogue numbers or a number based on the constellation that the star resides in. In fact, planets outside our solar system are generally named after this star number, with a letter suffix. The most famous extra-solar planets are probably: 51 Pegasi b and HD 209458 b.
→ More replies (8)228
→ More replies (20)34
May 08 '12
26537 Shyamalbuch
I hope that one is yours.
Actually... a lot of these names are hilarious. People should really start thinking about fusing their first and last names.
Navrazhnykh
Wat :D
→ More replies (6)14
u/ChalkUp May 08 '12
I really hope you're female, your kids friends would have the best 'Yo mama' joke ever...
25
May 08 '12
A girl in my class got to name an asteroid aswell. She named it the Swedish translation of "The Philosophers Stone"
→ More replies (7)7
u/iorgfeflkd May 08 '12
There is an asteroid named after an astronomer with the same surname as me. I'll take it.
→ More replies (19)2
u/wolfanotaku May 08 '12
The FAQ on the page actually explains that things like planets can be named because there are not as many.
192
May 08 '12
You CAN name stars after people, it's just that it's not official. We won't be colonizing any planets in the solar system Bort.
166
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
That's the deal... You CAN in the sense that you pay some company and receive a certificate in return... But that certificate isn't recognized by anyone. I could just as well issue such certificates to all my friends and they would carry the same amount of weight. Or rather, no weight at all.
147
May 08 '12
So we're in agreement. Excellent! I propose we name a star in celebration.
157
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
I'll issue the certificate, so it's legit.
2
→ More replies (3)106
May 08 '12
Can we name it Arizona? If you think about it, that's actually a pretty cool word. Ari. That sounds like, air. Kind of. And then Zona? There's a Z in there, and it's not often you get to use a word with a z in it.
→ More replies (22)8
u/lilzaphod May 08 '12
Why do you give all this authority to the IAU? Seems like a jackbooted organization to me.
30
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
"The IAU is the internationally recognized authority for naming celestial bodies and surface features on them. And names are not sold, but assigned according to internationally accepted rules."
Perhaps because it's just convenient to have such an organization? For the sake of keeping it simple?
31
May 08 '12
internationally accepted rules
Well I didn't vote for them!
→ More replies (5)18
→ More replies (1)19
u/nitefang May 08 '12
lilzaphod's point was along the lines of "Who put them in charge?" Which I would be interested in knowing as well. Who recognizes their authority, how are its officials selected. Why do they get to say that "Huge Doomey Gas Ball" isn't an official name.
→ More replies (7)26
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
It seems that the International Astronomical Union is a member of the International Council for Science, which itself is financed by UNESCO and the United Nations. Seems legit enough for me...
→ More replies (15)→ More replies (1)16
u/squidfood May 08 '12
Why do you give all this authority to the IAU? Seems like a jackbooted organization to me.
Yeah this friend of mine, you know, Pluto? Tried to go against em. They put him on ice.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (11)11
10
u/skintigh May 08 '12
You can "name" a star just like I can "name" you Irma. Nobody will recognize that name, but in my mind I can believe I have named you Irma and pay $500 for a piece of paper. And then that company, or another company, can "name" that star another name, and charge another $500, because it's all BS.
I.e. scam.
→ More replies (10)4
27
6
u/kurfu May 08 '12
But, but, but... It's "registered in book-form with the U.S. Copyright Office..."
It must be official!
→ More replies (4)8
u/dirtpirate May 08 '12
Well, you CAN name a star, in the same sense that I can name you ignorentmonkey. But what is the point, I'm the only one who accepts that that's your name, and anyone is free to rename you something else. And in the end, you'll still be named wildmonky by reddit, and whatever your name is by whatever government you belong under.
→ More replies (2)2
→ More replies (19)2
57
u/Flemtality 3 May 08 '12
http://penny-arcade.com/2012/05/07
Someone has been reading Penny Arcade recently.
24
9
5
2
u/tedrick111 May 08 '12
You didn't infer this the first time you heard the commercial? I think I might be on the wrong website.
→ More replies (3)
395
u/pro_astronomer May 08 '12
This can be very upsetting and unsettling. I've been volunteering at an astronomy centre for a star talk before now and had members of the public show up with the certificate of naming of a star for their dead child. I'm sure they found solace in this, which is a good thing, but they wanted us to find the star so they could see it in a telescope. A search of the simbad catalogue failed to show up any hits for the SAO catalogue number. The star must have been so faint that it doesn't even register in the broadest star catalogue we use. We couldn't find it at the given co-ordinates and had to pretend to the family that it wasn't up at that time of year. Star naming companies are a scam, and a sick scam at that.
102
May 08 '12
Plus, there is a change that stars can be multiply-named. The various companies don't cross-reference their catalogues, so if any two companies allocate them, say, in RA order (which would make sense), then those stars at the top of the list are going to get sold multiple times.
It's such a terrible scam because people want to believe it so much.
66
u/ZeCoolerKing May 08 '12
This is why I'm naming the Moon after someone. Less chance of a mixup.
→ More replies (7)36
→ More replies (1)10
u/LongUsername May 08 '12
Sounds like a business model to me..... Sell certificates to the same 2000 stars.
→ More replies (1)5
8
u/aigooben May 08 '12
One of the problems i have with someone naming a star so far away is that what we see is lights from billions of years ago for most of them. that star could have disappeared in relation to our own present time for all we know. So basically you are leasing the stream of light source of that star. And what if two stars collide? who gets too keep the name? or is the contact void by then? /uselessrant
17
u/cycloethane87 May 08 '12
People who pay for these scams likely lack the critical thinking to worry about this.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)4
u/jswhitten May 09 '12
All of the stars in our galaxy are thousands of light years away at most, not billions. We can be fairly certain that any given star in the sky is still there, and hasn't exploded or collided with any other stars.
16
u/you_need_this May 08 '12
people can do a simple google search. hell i didn't even know this, and I am a well educated person. i searched "name a star", and one was yahoo answers, saying it was all a scam. then if you actually go to the websites, it says it is not really official. those people that actually paid without looking more than 5 minutes are retarded. I just never took the 5 minutes up until today
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)2
u/meatblock May 09 '12
If the universe is as big as we imagine, is it possible that going in that direction long enough would bring you to a star?
81
u/luxoflax May 08 '12
Someone ought to warn The Magic School Bus kids or Dorthy Ann's birthday is gonna suck ass.
36
→ More replies (2)2
44
u/helpingfriendlybook May 08 '12
It's just an update to the old story of the man standing next to the sign "Seagulls for sale" on the beach. You walk up and give him five quid and he points up to the sky and says "that one's yours."
→ More replies (6)
38
u/starmandan May 08 '12
It really is sad that folks fall for this. As an amateur astronomer our club frequently gets requests from folks to show them their "star". Even with the coordinates and the map that they get, it is often almost impossible to positively identify the star much less see it visually as the star is quite faint, requiring long exposure photography to see it. More often than not, we just punch in the coordinates, take a picture and point out the brightest star in the image and say that's their "star".
→ More replies (1)23
u/RireBaton May 08 '12
That's the bad thing. We don't want confrontation, but we allow this to perpetuate.
Perhaps we should create a T-Shirt. Similar to the "No I will not fix your computer." shirts for computer people to wear to Thanksgiving so all their family members don't harangue them to fix their computers when they have a minute. It could say something like "You did not name a star." and you could wear it to events.
17
May 08 '12
I was seeing a girl whose previous boytoy had given her such a certificate. She framed it and hung it on her wall. I was apparently the first person to notice it had the word "Astronomy" misspelled. They just created some bullshit form on pagemaker or something, and sold it for $39.99.
I wish I had less scruples. People are so easy to screw.
24
u/RosieRose23 May 08 '12
ATTENTION SAP's
If your grandma or mother or girlfriend or ANYONE gets you this as a gift the correct response is "Thank you, that is very thoughtful" NOT "Actually this means nothing..."
5
10
u/tequilasauer May 08 '12
Well, I was happy with my purchase because my g/f was happy when I gave her the certificate in a frame with the little star compass for finding it.
And now I'm happy with my purchase because she's not my girlfriend anymore and her name will never be immortalized in the stars as she once thought.
It's win-win from where I'm sitting.
2
u/spiralkeystroke May 09 '12
You stole my post. I got a star named for my ex and that's right he is my EX! I thought it was a great gift at the time. Which it would be if it were legit, but then again we all fail at life from time to time. I am such a sucker. Anyway, score no fucking douchebag star for him! This post and yours made my day! Up votes for all!
8
u/skealoha86 May 08 '12
Do North Koreans have the same names for stars as us western imperialists?
47
u/blank_generation May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
All the stars are named Kim Jong-Il, since he personally discovered all of them himself with a special pair of high powered binoculars he built when he was 5 years old.
23
u/anthonypetre May 08 '12
You mean he discovered himself, then built the binoculars so others could see the stars he was pointing out.
17
u/Advocate7x70 May 08 '12
There should be a /r/explainitlikeimnorthkorean I would read that.
→ More replies (2)13
7
u/tjmjnj May 08 '12
I can name a star whatever I want - other people can choose to recognize my name for it or they can call it whatever they want as well.
0
6
6
May 08 '12
The star name will be filed in a Registry Vault and recorded in a book, which will be registered in the copyright office of the United States of America. source
So it is filed in a Registry Vault, recorded in a book, and it is copyrighted. No more official that that!
→ More replies (1)
5
u/camall May 08 '12
so my girlfriend made me watch 'a walk to remember" and it was all a lie? at least i got to stare at mandy moores boobs.
5
u/VeggiePetsitter May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
They're probably just selling stars in the getto galaxies where things aren't regulated as well.
5
u/Jux_ 16 May 08 '12
Many years ago, I thought it would be a cutesy gift to name a star after my girlfriend. So I did a little research and found this same page, and thought "well then." I figured if I was just paying for a certificate for a star I couldn't see that carried no weight, may as well have some fun with it.
So I picked out a star in Orion, named it after her instead, and made my own fancy certificate. Figured it was just as official. Our anniversary came, and I gave it to her, and to my surprise she had done the same thing to a different star in Orion after doing research on her own.
Should've kept her.
2
26
u/Warlizard ಠ_ಠ May 08 '12
You guys have completely missed the point.
You name a star after a girl, then give her the certificate.
"OMG, you named a STAR AFTER ME!?!?!?!?!?"
Didn't care, had sex.
27
u/Code_For_Food May 08 '12
MS Word, a certificate template, and a printer would probably get you star sex cheaper and just as easily.
35
u/frikk May 08 '12
/r/frugal would recommend open office, make it even sweeter of a deal.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Warlizard ಠ_ಠ May 08 '12
True, but I make it a habit not to lie to get sex. It's pathetic.
Girls like romantic gestures and intent. Printing up your own certificate is lame.
24
u/Code_For_Food May 08 '12
I'm not 100% clear on how your printing up a fake certificate is worse than paying someone else to print up a fake certificate...
→ More replies (8)0
33
u/pacman404 May 08 '12
They arent scams at all. They are novelties. They tell you what is going on as soon as you look into it.
13
u/yourdadsbff May 08 '12
Yeah, I "received" one of these certificates (with an accompanying star map) as a birthday present one year. I figured it was probably bullshit--since how do you even go about "claiming" a star to name after yourself in the first place?--but it was still a fun gift anyway. I just hope my parents didn't spend that much money on it, and no, I didn't ask for a star for my birthday.
→ More replies (1)21
u/pacman404 May 08 '12
I have one too, and got my daughter one for her birthday years ago. Every year on her birthday we go outside and find it. Thats the whole point, its just a fun and original gift. Lots of people in this thread calling them "thieves", "scam artists", and "master trolls". Thats just simply not the case. It says clearly that you dont actually get the name of the star changed when you sign up or it
→ More replies (3)41
u/gpouliot May 08 '12
That's all well and good, but why did you feel that you had to pay someone for the privilege? Why not just go outside and pick a star for yourself? Why was it important to pay someone for a piece of paper that you could have made up yourself?
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (2)4
u/geareddev May 08 '12
Seriously. Even if the US government made it "official" there are still 5.7 billion people in the other countries who wouldn't recognize it. I'm pretty sure North Korea doesn't recognize the name the OP gave their kid(s), but who gives a crap?
→ More replies (2)
4
4
u/IPreferOddNumbers May 08 '12
You can, however, pay to have a species officially named after you. Granted, your choices are mostly bugs and bacteria.
2
u/Sielle May 08 '12
Do you have a link to where I can get a bacteria named after my sister? :D
→ More replies (1)
4
May 08 '12
NASA should offer a legitimate version of this, because then they could get money for their space programs.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/imahugesluthi May 08 '12
Q: But if I want to, can I buy the name of a star anyway?
A: Sure, there are people who will be more than happy to take your money....
Sass.
7
1
1
May 08 '12
So I just lost 7.5 stars?
2
u/KrzysztofKietzman May 08 '12
You named 7.5 stars...? 0.5...?
1
May 09 '12
One of them is slowly dying, i had no idea i would be wasting 200 dollars on a dying star!
1
1
u/doubleyew424 May 08 '12
I have a friend that actually started a business doing just this. He was actually doing pretty well until a bigger company that sold stars sued him for copyright infringement.
1
1
8
3
3
3
5
6
May 08 '12
But you can become a minister:
And a 'Laird' (or Lord)
http://www.highlandtitles.com/
There is a wealth of information online about how the Laird titles are false. You do not become a 'peer' or have any special entitlements... but you are still a Laird. You do not sit in the house of lords but you do own some land. I think this is fuss is caused by the actual real Lords feeling copied. Which is an excellent reason for everyone to sign up! Plus it helps protect Britains wildlife.
3
u/Airazz May 09 '12
You can actually become Lord too, not just some stupid laird.
→ More replies (4)
7
May 08 '12
Companies who sell stars usually just sell the same start to 100s of people. Largest scam ever. It's not like you will ever meet a person who bought the same star as you and if you did it is a really random thing to bring up. Even if both of you do bring it up I doubt either of you know which star you own.
The person who came up with the idea of selling stars which he doesn't own is a fucking genius.
9
u/hazards May 08 '12
I honestly don't care. When I was a kid, my first pet (a dog) died. When my great aunt got me a certificate saying that a star had been named after her, it was one of the most awesome moments of my life. As I grew older, I realized that there was really no star named after her, but at this point in my life it didn't bother me. Even though she got "scammed" the gift served a purpose and finally made a child happy again. The money she spent on this worthless piece of paper did more than any toy or gift could have.
→ More replies (2)3
u/chris-martin May 08 '12
It's okay to scam adults as long as they're doing it to trick children?
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Xaethon 2 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Just like the buying the title Lord (should be Laird) or whatever from some square foot of land in Scotland is also a complete scam.
2
u/HookDragger May 08 '12
Didn't you hear... they publish it "in book form"!
Hahaha, I always laugh my ass off when they say that in the commercials.
2
u/virak_john May 08 '12
Sure you can. Who's to say?
I call bullshit on any human who says they own outer space.
2
u/virak_john May 08 '12
In other words, it's all a scam, even the "official" names.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/ChalesHStone May 08 '12
This has revealed a huge plot hole in the classic episode of 'Hey Dude' where Ted buys a star for everybody.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Dunabu May 08 '12
Who says you can't? No one owns the sky, so funny enough there's nothing really stopping you from claiming a star and making it your namesake.
Just don't expect anyone to adhere to your claim.
2
u/LostChocobo May 08 '12
I got a friend one of these a few years back. He named it Orion's Bellybutton.
2
2
u/keith_weaver May 08 '12
TIL there really are A LOT of incredibly stupid people out there. Actually I've known that for quite awhile. Although, I did purchase 3000 square acres of land on the moon. Now that was a good investment!
2
u/djstangl May 08 '12
Whatever we call other stars and planets, galaxies, etc, doesn't matter. Aliens (beings from other planets - not getting into the whole they don't exist thing, of course they do, um just look at the sky you're an idiot to say that there's no other life anywhere else. It's just like looking at the ocean or lake and seeing no fish, they exist but just because you don't see them where you are looking at that moment doesn't mean they don't exist.) could call us the shit heads of course we might not be able understand what they are saying but it could possibly translate into that.
2
u/DrMandible May 08 '12
Since nobody owns those stars, you can name them whatever the heck you want.
In fact, you can name things that people own whatever the heck you want. There's no law against it . . . yet.
2
2
2
u/Travelerdude May 08 '12
I have a pretty decent plot of terraformed land on Barsoom overlooking the Helium lakes that I can offer at a downright steal if someone's interested.
2
May 08 '12
Heh, I guess I'm lucky that "Cygnus" is already a constellation.
...and a star, if I recall correctly.
2
u/kaasmi May 08 '12
Pfffft, it's always going to be called, "Snake Griffin" to me. Best. Star. Ever.
2
May 08 '12
I read a book published by the guy who runs The Edge. It contained essays from people of all fields of STEM and other fields. In one essay, the author argued to human being have a sick tendency to name things that they don't understand completely. But by naming things, human beings get a sense of possession and a sense of absolute understanding. The truth is far from that. We might have named them Higgs Boson, and we might call them quarks, and we might call it quasars, and we might call it the Great Attractor. And we might feel as though we own it, but we don't really own it nor do we understand it completely.
Edit: Essay: The Name Game Author: Stuart Firestein Book: This Will Make You Smarter: 150 New Scientific Concepts to Improve Your Thinking ISBN: 0062109391
2
u/SoFunAnon May 08 '12
I considered registering "international-grain-of-sand-registry.com" and doing the same thing.
But with grains of sand instead of stars.
See, you would have this sand. And then you would name a grain of it, and get a certificate and the name of your grain would go into the copyright office. And if you really wanted, you could touch your grain of sand. Much more personal than any star registry deal.
2
u/Dev1lsAdv0kate May 08 '12
OP is lying guys, if you just send me $49.95 I'll register you with a star right now! :D
2
May 08 '12
Freshman year of college, my class jokingly offered to buy the professor a star in her name for Christmas, knowing exactly how she would react. She stopped the class then and there and spent fifteen minutes explaining why exactly these 'star naming' schemes are scams.
2
u/F1A May 08 '12 edited Dec 11 '25
aspiring practice enjoy sort ask reach unique subtract smart history
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
2
2
May 08 '12
I gave a wry laugh at the Layman's Guide where it says "...it would generate a system of mounting confusion for no factual reason. And this is the opposite of what taxpayers pay scientists to do." The author has clearly never had to work on fruit fly genetics.
→ More replies (1)
2
May 08 '12
What would make it not a scam? Would they have to write your name on the star?
→ More replies (3)
2
May 08 '12
TIL that people in the US thought they could purchase the right to rename a star
lol
I guess the Nigerian scam is still around because there are people who buy into it.
3
3
2
u/Batrok May 08 '12
You can name stars, planets or any other objects in space after anyone you want. Paying to do so is borderline retarded.
Either way, your 'name' for the given planetary body has no real meaning or significance to anyone other than you.
1
1
u/ovulator May 08 '12
What!? You mean I paid 10 grand to name that bright star out during the day Ovulator, and everyone is still just calling it "Sun"?!
1
u/ishallsaythisonce May 08 '12
I thought this would make a great birthday present for my mom some years back... Then I googled... :-(
1
u/arslet May 08 '12
If there was a super-mega-multi "you don't say" meme, it would be relevant right now.
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 08 '12
It takes light from a star an incredibly long time to reach us, so even though we see the light from it, the star could possibly have died a long time ago. This is why buying a name for a star is ridiculous.
1
1
u/lud1120 May 08 '12
This has obviously always been symbolic... Buying a piece of the Moon would obviously not be legal, also way, way more expensive if it was infact real.
Buying stars? Now that's where we go into fool people.
1
u/Spekingur May 08 '12
Has any nation put up a flag on Mars yet? If not then I'll make that my life's work.
1
u/noaster May 08 '12
They name the star after you in their registry. So it is named after you somewhere, just not somewhere people would actually look.
Unfortunately, you won't be a star
1
u/Fuqwon May 08 '12
I actually purchased the naming rights to the universe from this homeless guy for $1, so I'm really just waiting on some recognition for the Fuqwoniverse.
After that, I'll hook everyone up with a free star.
1
1
u/darcy_mulder May 08 '12
I always thought that whoever is in charge of astronomical standards (I'm assuming some international scientific body) could sell names and use the money for astronomy scholarships or telescopes or something. The names would of course have to be approved, and scientists would undoubtedly just keep using current names that are easier to organize.
1
1
1
1
1
u/DaveMagee83 May 08 '12
Dammit...So you are telling me that all I got my reddit secret santa was a piece of paper?!?
1
1
u/myztry May 08 '12
Settle down. There is an estimated 9 sextillion stars so everyone can have one named after them. Supply greatly outstrips demand.
1
1
May 08 '12
You had to learn this? I knew I didn't like the idea when I'd heard about it in middle school. My question was, how the hell do you expect me to find it and point it out to someone? Let alone, keep track of it and know that no one else has named it?
1
1
u/WhoKnowsWho2 May 08 '12
That's very sad. My friend did this for me in high school for a birthday and I thought it was the greatest.
1
u/Otaku-sama May 08 '12
That means that the theoretical business I made for a high school project was a scam. Cool.
1
1
1
1
u/ObamaisYoGabbaGabba May 08 '12
If anyone is interested I am holding an Auction for naming rights of Saturn. The Official Council of Naming Planets has gotten together and decided we do not like 'Saturn" so, we are auctioning off the rights to rename the planet.
Full authenticated certificates of Genuineness for the winner.
Contact me for details.
1
u/DirtPile May 08 '12
The only exception was John Hogdman naming 700 stars after the 700 Hobos. My favorite is Not Only But Also Pete.
1
u/brnitschke May 08 '12
Even old New York was once New Amsterdam
Why they changed it I can't say
People just liked it better that way
Istanbul was Constantinople
Now it's Istanbul, not Constantinople
Been a long time gone, Constantinople
Why did Constantinople get the works?
That's nobody's business but the Turks
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
1
1
u/Zes0 May 08 '12
Sometimes the thought that a star is named after a loved one is all that is needed.
1
u/linds360 May 08 '12
Well I guess that's why that relationship didn't last.
The star was a lie the whole time...
1
691
u/johnriven May 08 '12
But...but, you get a certificate? I'm so confused. Next thing you're going to tell me is I can't buy 500 acres on the moon.