r/technology • u/tkmon • Jun 19 '12
Funnyjunk's lawyer has been suspended from practicing law in two different states for violating his duty to maintain client funds in trust, unlawful practice of law and practicing without a license.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Carreon45
u/Nickoladze Jun 19 '12
Did you just link to Wikipedia and not the source it quotes
76
u/GrinningPariah Jun 19 '12
This isn't a college paper.
11
Jun 19 '12
Exactly. So no linking to Wikipedia!
→ More replies (4)9
u/HotRodLincoln Jun 19 '12
What if we just made a list of Wikipedia's sources at the bottom of the article and linked to each source from there? It seems like that would be super efficient; we could have all the information on one page, but still quickly and easily verify through the sources.
→ More replies (3)5
u/Nickoladze Jun 19 '12
It was just... odd. A topic like this is just internet-bandwagon enough to warrant adding random claims to Wikipedia.
4
u/FountainsOfFluids Jun 19 '12
Not really odd, imho, but you make a fair point that wikipedia might get tainted by the nerdrage.
4
u/Doctor_McKay Jun 19 '12
Wikipedia should have some kind of system where pages get auto-semi-protected when they get a whole lot of traffic.
→ More replies (1)
366
Jun 19 '12
as a retired lawyer, i know we have many assholes in our profession, but damn few wikipedia-grade assholes.
117
u/BaconCat Jun 19 '12
I propose a new classing system for assholes, with wikipedia-grade assholes being the top tier.
39
u/creepyeyes Jun 19 '12
I'm pretty sure history-textbook asshole is the top tier.
→ More replies (1)20
15
u/Ivan_of_Zeta Jun 19 '12
I don't think that grade is high enough for Jack Thompson
37
u/mnp Jun 19 '12
Correct, media lawyers are one class above that.
1 standard issue asshole 2 wikipedia grade asshole 3 RIAA/MPAA grade asshole11
u/strolls Jun 19 '12
Nope:
standard issue asshole
wikipedia grade asshole
disbarred wikipedia grade asshole
→ More replies (2)19
u/r_dageek Jun 19 '12
1 standard issue asshole 2 wikipedia grade asshole 3 disbarred wikipedia grade asshole 4 MPAA/RIAA→ More replies (3)→ More replies (6)2
u/dividezero Jun 19 '12
Only if their main reason for achieving a wikipedia article is from their asshole-ary, then I'll second that.
17
u/randomb_s_ Jun 19 '12
I'd say he's on Wikipedia because of his multi-million dollar, high-profile sex.com verdit. (And now because of his Oatmeal nonsense.)
I don't think his disciplinary actions would give him wiki status but for the other two actually-noteworthy events.
(I'm not a fan of his, just like clarity.)
20
u/Insignificant_Being Jun 19 '12
That's when you know they're the worst..
0
Jun 19 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (2)37
u/HotRodLincoln Jun 19 '12
They're the opposites of batman.
35
→ More replies (8)4
1
u/JIVEprinting Jun 19 '12
It's so outrageous that this actually happens at all, let alone among senators etc.
1
u/shawndw Jun 19 '12
As a person who popped a shampaign bottle when Jack Thompson got disbarred I concur.
1
98
Jun 19 '12
You seem like a glass half empty kinda guy. Look on the positive side. In 48 states he has a spotless record!
21
→ More replies (2)10
364
u/HoweM3835 Jun 19 '12
Before everyone hops on the "GLAD THATS OVER!" train, I'd like to point out this happened back in 2005, not recently. It has nothing to do with the Oatmeal/Funnyjunk suit.
In October 2005, Carreon was suspended by the Oregon State Bar for 60 days for the unlawful practice of law and failing to deposit or maintain client funds in trust.[11] In September 2006, Carreon was also suspended for two years by the State Bar of California, stayed, and placed on two years of probation with an actual 60-day suspension for violating his duty to maintain client funds in trust, and for practicing without a license in Canada
*It also only lasted 60 days with a 2 year probation, so it was all over after 2007 as far as I can tell, but I am not a lawyer.
45
u/malicart Jun 19 '12
Does this make you feel better about hiring this particular lawyer to represent you? I would not want to hire a lawyer who was suspended for these reasons.
19
u/HoweM3835 Jun 19 '12
Not at all! I wasn't defending him, I was just making sure people didn't mistake this for Careon getting disbarred because of the Oatmeal incident. I mean, Reddit wouldn't make a mistake like that in the first place, but I gotta play it safe right?
→ More replies (1)5
u/root88 Jun 19 '12
You are correct to do this. The way the headline is written, it looks like news, not something that someone just happened to find in Wikipedia.
→ More replies (5)83
u/nerocaesar Jun 19 '12
This is probably exactly why he chose this lawyer. Not every lawyer will pursue frivolous lawsuits, gotta scrape the scum to find a guy like this
0
Jun 19 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (2)55
Jun 19 '12
Better call Saul!
→ More replies (1)25
u/BlackStrain Jun 19 '12
I doubt Saul would be stupid enough to accept this case.
→ More replies (3)1
u/wasniahC Jun 19 '12
Indeed.. I mean, it's nice to show he's an ass and all, but pretty meaningless otherwise. Not sure why it's turned up on the front page of reddit twice as if it matters.
→ More replies (14)1
23
u/OnWingsOfWax Jun 19 '12
For those who don't know, it takes a lot to get suspended by a bar association. The fact that he's been suspended more than once, in more than one jurisdiction, is incredibly telling.
5
Jun 19 '12 edited May 02 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/OnWingsOfWax Jun 19 '12
Not only mishandling funds, which is one of the biggest no-nos, he also told the company that he was licensed to practice in Canada when he wasn't.
44
u/ropers Jun 19 '12
On June 14, the contact form on his website was turned off with the explanation: "Due to security attacks instigated by Matt Inman, this function has been temporarily disabled."
Instigated by Inman? Can he prove that? If not, then isn't that statement, you know, slander?
22
u/timetide Jun 19 '12
since its printed that makes it libel. slander is spoken while libel is printed.
→ More replies (1)11
→ More replies (6)5
u/scarecrow1 Jun 19 '12
Exactly what I wanted to post... I'm pretty sure that comes under an unfounded allegation of criminal conduct. That'll be $20,000.-, Sir.
→ More replies (1)
43
Jun 19 '12
Never thought I'd say he has gone downhill since the Sex.com case
28
u/0011002 Jun 19 '12
Apparently some people who know and respected him are even WTFing on this. The Popehat blog mentioned one such person and another blog was written by another.
→ More replies (2)9
u/teamspike Jun 19 '12
Link?
35
u/0011002 Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
Ok when digging for then info it turns out it was one person not two. The person that wrote the blog is the same person popehat mentions.
His name is Marc. Here is his blog post and here is where Popehat mentions him.
Here is the quote from Popehat:
Edited To Add: Marc Randazza, whose First Amendment credentials are extraordinary, and who has routinely stood up against thuggish threat letters, has this to say about Mr. Carreon:
I have known Charles for a few years, and know him to be one of the good guys. I did ask him "what the fuck were you thinking?" when I first saw his letter.
I think he just made a judgment error, which is different from saying that this event exposes a latent character flaw. I've never known him to do anything like this before, and I am prepared to give him a First Amendment mulligan. Let he who has never fucked up before cast the first stone. Well, ok, cast stones even if you have fucked up — since he might have asked for it and he can likely handle it, but I ask everyone to try and remember that Charles has been on the right side of the good fight far more times than he's been on the wrong side. On balance, he's one of the good guys, and I think he's engaging in some valuable self-reflection right now — which is itself a sign that he is one of the good guys
This doesn't change my evaluation of the letter in question. But Marc's word is worth a lot with me, and I recognize that anyone — perhaps especially a lawyer — can take a very wrong-headed approach to something on a bad day.
Second Edit: OK, with all respect to Marc, I take back my charitable thoughts based on his words about Charles Carreon.
Third Edit: In fairness to Marc, I gave him a shot at amending his prior statement, which he did:
Despite my earlier charitable comments, I can not find any words to defend trying to shut the fundraiser down. I can't even gin up a minor benefit of the doubt on that one. I can see an ill-considered demand as a mistake in judgment while hoping to gain an advantage for your client. But taking a shot at the fundraiser would not do that – it would just be lashing out to hurt bears and cancer patients? Holy fucking shitballs inside a burning biplane careening toward the Statue of Liberty, Captain! I hope that the reporter merely got the story wrong, because if not, that's more fucked up than a rhino raping a chinchilla while dressed up in unicorns' undergarments.
And Marc's own blog:
Carreon just made himself a meme — and not in a good way. This will not end well for him. I just want to say that I tried. I really tried to get him to come to his senses. I tried really really hard.
→ More replies (2)3
6
Jun 19 '12
This is reminding me more and more of Ocean Marketing now.
2
Jun 19 '12
It's worse than Ocean Marketing. At least they didn't sue a fucking cancer charity, they just wwebsite as on the internet.
42
u/SoInsightful Jun 19 '12
Sensationalist, misleading title for a Wikipedia article that has nothing to do with r/technology.
Front page, here we come!
→ More replies (3)
4
u/propanol Jun 19 '12
I picture this guy to be someone with the legal ineptitude of Bob Loblaw while at the same time being just as morally bankrupt as Saul Goodman.
11
u/DeFex Jun 19 '12
Too sleazy even to be a lawyer! What's after lawyer, oh yeah. Loan shark.
6
u/0011002 Jun 19 '12
Padded room maybe. What happened to Jack Thompson after he was finally disbarred and Fox stopped featuring him?
4
u/reflibman Jun 19 '12
Politician. After all, they were originally larval lawyers, who metamorphosed.
2
1
1
u/Unenjoyed Jun 19 '12
Some lawyers make a life style of fucking up, getting disbarred, rising from the ashes, and then fucking up again. It's possibly unimaginable to be too sleazy to be a lawyer.
2
u/Triviaandwordplay Jun 19 '12
I know a couple personally who are like that. They have more money coming in than they can squander.
One just rode out a suspension and went right back to being a piece of shit lawyer. Most of their clients have no idea exactly what's going on. Whatever happens, the clients think it's just part of the process.
3
u/Unenjoyed Jun 19 '12
These lawyers are key components of the under belly of modern American civic culture.
→ More replies (5)
6
Jun 19 '12
I’m eating ravioli in spaghetti sauce with a white dress shirt on.
6
u/JudgeEric Jun 19 '12
Living on the edge.
3
Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
As i was just posting some odd,
all be italbeit true, thing that was going on in my day. I never thought it would be seen or commeneted on. Thanks for the smile.3
2
8
u/ewillyp Jun 19 '12
i bet he gives a good Chewbaca defense
2
u/Darth_Meatloaf Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
Could you please elaborate?
EDIT: All of the links provided so far in response to my request for elaboration all lead back othe same page. southparkstudios.com is blocked at work. I humbly request a copypasta of the relevant information or a link to a different page.
2
u/ewillyp Jun 20 '12
there's a wikipedia page that talks about it, it's a reference to a lawyer on southpark who may or may not be based on Johnny Cocharan and or the black lawyer from seinfeld. Johhny Cochoran making the "if the glove doesn't not fit, you must acquit" quote and the seinfeld lawyer who made many non-sensical arguments. The chewbacca defense is exactly that a nonsensical argument that is presented with such seriousness and vigor that you WANT to believe it. and this is way too much of an explanation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chewbacca_defense
2
u/coeddotjpg Jun 19 '12
Sounds like the background of a lawyer in some movie. Who will do what's right, against his nature, time and again, until he's redeemed in the end.
Somehow I think this guy will eventually be sunning in a white collar prison.
2
u/yes_thats_right Jun 19 '12
Wasn't the general idea of the first legal noticed to The Oatmeal based on Inman saying (truthfully) that Funnyjunk had been profiting from their users taking his pictures?
It seems strange to me that someone could find this to be a problem but at the same time be completely fine with implying that Inman was encouraging users to hack his website.
2
Jun 19 '12
I was just saying in another topic that if kept this up he would likely be disbarred for wasting court time and filing false claims as retribution for what he saw as being wronged. Who was that other guy that got disbarred for doing similar things protesting video games?
3
2
u/KNHaw Jun 19 '12
The talk page is an amusing read as well.
Someone identifying themselves as Tara Carreon, Charles Carreon's wife has been responding to comments [in the talk page itself]. It is unknown if they are legit.
2
u/Poopfartmcgee Jun 19 '12
Careful guys, his next absurd lawsuit will be against us.
0
Jun 19 '12
[deleted]
2
u/Poopfartmcgee Jun 19 '12
In that case, I think he is a fine attorney doing a fine job in this and many other fine lawsuits and I wish him a good day.
2
Jun 19 '12
I find how detailed this page is and the page history much more fascinating than what it particularly says :D
If nothing else, he's gaining a lot of experience in his chosen field of expertise, inadvertently as it might be.
2
u/jimminyjojo Jun 19 '12
What ever happened to Jack Thompson?
2
u/Aeleas Jun 19 '12
Permanently disbarred and fined $43,675.35 in Florida mid 2008.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
u/OrangeAstronaut Jun 19 '12
Seriously guys, you want to quote an open-source article from wikipedia? Even if he is a douchebag, please be a little more skeptical before shitting all over people.
2
2
Jun 19 '12
It says that his website form was taken down citing attacks instigated by Inman. Maybe Inman has a potential libel suit against Carreon now?
2
u/indianthane95 Jun 19 '12
Anyone know if the American cancer society or the WWF has actually responded to this dickhead ?
2
u/Lardarius Jun 19 '12
Pro-tip: use his name (Charles Carreon) in future post titles so that these threads show up when someone Googles him.
2
2
Jun 19 '12
"On June 14, the contact form on his website was turned off with the explanation: "Due to security attacks instigated by Matt Inman, this function has been temporarily disabled."
Doesn't that give Matt very good grounds to file a fat libel suit against this douchebag lawyer?
Matt did no such thing and this turd of a human being is implying that Matt has sent hackers to him, which is actually implicating someone for an actual criminal offense.
2
1
1
u/venomoushealer Jun 19 '12
Is there any subreddit I can go to where a won't here this? I didn't mind hearing this the first time, but I feel like it's in every subreddit.
1
u/Paultimate79 Jun 19 '12
I wish i could see the judges face as he reads through this guys case files. Pretty lol worthy when he quotes some of what TheOatmeal says. :D
1
1
1
u/LouBrown Jun 19 '12
Everyone knew this guy growing up. He was the obnoxious kid that everyone loathed. He would always force himself upon your social group, though, oblivious to why nobody liked him.
1
u/mage_g4 Jun 19 '12
Funnyjunk is a two bit, piece of shit site, so it makes sense they would have a two bit, piece of shit lawyer, to match.
The guy is so stupid it's almost painful to watch.
1
1
u/smallpantsbluehat Jun 19 '12
Why would you ever pick a fight with someone who has totally ingratiated themselves with the internet community.
1
u/HattoriDunzo Jun 19 '12
Your title implied that these suspensions were in response to his current behavior. Kinda misleading...
1
u/ghosthendrikson Jun 19 '12
This is, once again, a perfect example of why you don't poke the Hive Mind with a stick. Granted we aren't very consistent. But when the tide rises, it can quickly become a tsunami.
1
u/askyou Jun 19 '12
You know this was in 2005 and 2006, right? Nothing to do with the current Oatmeal case and related lawsuits.
→ More replies (3)
1
1
1
1
u/WestonP Jun 19 '12
I don't like the guy either, but this is old news, not relevant to the case, and a misleading headline.
1
u/theGlassHero Jun 19 '12
I find it hilarious how every post I see on here, refers to him as 'Funny Junk's Lawyer', and not by his actual name.
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
I've never heard of funnyjunk OR oatmeal before all this news came up about it but I thoroughly support Oatmeal. I even donated several dollars to the cause.
And I will NEVER visit funnyjunk even though curiosity piques me knowing that they "slather with ads" and that I'd be giving him money for my visit.
The internet is turning into a sad place. I'd rather it be a place of no rules just ethics. If people want to go to digital warfare so be it. Such events would only push the networking technologies to advance.
1
1
1
1
u/Points_To_You Jun 19 '12
I feel like I could post anything with Funnyjunk and lawyer in the title and hit the front page.
1
Jun 19 '12
I hope this sinks FunnyJunk. Complete scumbags being represented by a complete scumbag.
1
1
1
u/snehituralu Jun 19 '12
Great catch! And even if it is true, I'd be damned careful about getting potentially libelous statements from a publicly-update source. Just sayin'.
1
u/whoitis Jun 19 '12
It looks like his wife likes to [post copyrighted material] (http://www.scribd.com/doc/69610750/American-Buddha-What-s-Next) without permission on her website too.
1
1
u/tharosbr0 Jun 19 '12
Can someone confirm the sources? Are we sure this wikipedia article hasn't been trolled?
1
u/Cecil_Hardboner Jun 19 '12
question: Does FunnyJunk actually employ this guy, or is he just filing lawsuits on their behalf?
Clarification: is he FunnyJunk's attorney? Or is he filing on his own volition? I just cant believe that the owners of FunnyJunk would be dumb enough to actually persue this action in the first place.
1
u/scarecrow1 Jun 19 '12
Originally: yes, funnyjunk employed this guy to conduct the first suit, demanding $20,000 (well according to his letter, in any case)
Then he took it upon himself to go after the theoatmeal's guy (Matt Inman) for "not being an authorised charity fundraiser" (as far as I can read out of the claims document) - in the public interest, as he claims - and for allegedly inciting someone else to impersonate him on twitter - both in his own capacity.
Then he took it upon himself to claim Matt Inman was behind a security attack on his website (that's a claim of a criminal activity, and if not provable, probably a libel).
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
In October 2005, Carreon was suspended by the Oregon State Bar for 60 days for the unlawful practice of law and failing to deposit or maintain client funds in trust. In September 2006, Carreon was also suspended for two years by the State Bar of California, stayed, and placed on two years of probation with an actual 60-day suspension for violating his duty to maintain client funds in trust, and for practicing without a license in Canada.
Oh, not recently.
1
1
u/MathBosss Jun 19 '12
Hi, my name is OP and im gonna milk this story for all the karma i can get. Even if its the smallest thing ever. OP do you want me to draw a picture of your mom loving and a bear?
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
NOW this makes sense. He's drumming up attention for himself.
Probably will write a book at some point.
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
has been suspended from practicing law ... for practicing without a license
wat ಠ_ಠ
how can he be suspended if he didn't have a license to begin with?
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
CHARLES H. CARREON [#127139], 50, of Pacifica was suspended for two years, stayed, placed on two years of probation with an actual 60-day suspension and was ordered to take the MPRE and prove his rehabilitation. The order took effect Sept. 21, 2006.
Carreon, who is licensed in both California and Oregon, was disciplined in Oregon for practicing without a license in Canada. He represented a U.S. corporation as house counsel for its business operations in Vancouver, British Columbia, but he was not licensed there.
As counsel for the company, he held in trust settlement proceeds from a litigation matter. Without consulting with his client, Carreon used $1,400 of the settlement money to pay a money judgment obtained for a residential lease he had signed in connection with his employment in Canada. He knew or should have known that the company disputed whether he was entitled to payment for the lease as a reimbursable expense.
The Oregon order found that Carreon violated his duty to maintain client funds in trust. The violation amounted to a violation of the California Rules of Professional Conduct. Practicing law in a jurisdiction where he was not entitled to do so also violated the California rules.
1
1
u/liquidmini Jun 19 '12 edited Aug 01 '26
Walnut grasshopper mellow tangerine ribbon pinecone saffron
This post was anonymized with Redact.dev
1
u/Deggor Jun 19 '12
This comment is going to be about as off-topic as posting this in r/technology.
I understand why Charles Carreon's Wikipedia page exists, as the Sex.com legal case was notable. It spanned six years and set precedences relating to domain names, their ownership, legal responsibilities surrounding them, etc. Unless Carreon can get the courts to make some radical decisions in the matter, there is nothing interesting or notable about this little scuffle that would merit a Wikipedia page.
1
u/shawndw Jun 19 '12
wait how can he be suspended if he didn't have a license to practice law in the first place.
1
u/ProximaC Jun 19 '12
Hyper-Chicken: I'd have done better but it's plum hard pleadin' a case while awaitin' trial for that there incompetence!
1
u/Schlibwak Jun 19 '12
I'd rather post here the source from wikipedia. I think this is mroe reliable than a wikipedia article that can edited, as we already have seen this happen already : http://www.osbar.org/publications/bulletin/05nov/discipline.html for the Oregon
and http://archive.calbar.ca.gov/Archive.aspx?articleId=83602&categoryId=83521&month=2&year=2007#s19 for California
1
1
1
1
u/plonk420 Jun 19 '12
it's sad that as an american to be "truely safe" when talking about this piece of work of a lawyer, we have to resort to calling him a douchebag. always reminds me of Penn & Teller's Bullshit (last paragraph).
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Jun 19 '12
Funnyjunk and their Funnylawyer: It's funny until somebody gets sued. After that it's hilarious.
1
1
1
1
u/jeffnnc Jun 19 '12
Noticed that the Wikipedia page is being considered for deletion. Wonder if Mr. Carreon has anything to do with that?
2
Jun 19 '12
No, if you look at the Talk Page lots of people want to delete it. He's not famous or notable.
→ More replies (1)2
u/feodoric Jun 19 '12
It looks like most people on the deletion discussion seem to be assuming that the article was originally put on Wikipedia by Carreon himself, or by PR people representing him.
I assume that was before he became the new president of WTF-istan.
→ More replies (1)
626
u/thattreesguy Jun 19 '12
sensationalist title - he was only suspended for 30/60 days. You are implying that he is currently suspended in two states.