r/technology • u/OryxConLara • Jun 18 '12
How To Get From Manhattan to London in Under Two Hours
http://bostinno.com/2012/06/14/how-to-get-from-manhattan-to-london-in-under-two-hours/70
u/sindher Jun 18 '12
Concorde.
London to New York.
3 hours and 30 minutes.
Bring her out of retirement.
22
u/scaia Jun 18 '12
We have the technology. We can make her better, faster, and stronger than before.
0
Jun 18 '12
[deleted]
20
u/scaia Jun 18 '12
Yeah, but imagine the cost of a ticket and the security inspections that come with a train ride through a trillion dollar, 3k mile vacuumtunnel.
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (1)5
385
u/shoez Jun 18 '12
All it takes is sucking the air out of a transatlantic tunnel, just like a vacuum.
Oh, that's "all"?
130
u/Assaultman67 Jun 18 '12
Yes, because putting a tube under pressure from outside and then putting it in a vacuum sounds like a good idea.
Imagine what would happen if you sprung a leak?
130
u/c_vic Jun 18 '12
Yay thats a lot of delta P
42
22
u/Tntnnbltn Jun 18 '12
Reminds me of the Byford Dolphin incident I read about the other week (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byford_Dolphin#Diving_bell_accident).
On 5 November 1983 at 4:00 a.m., while drilling in the Frigg gas field in the Norwegian sector of the North Sea, four divers were in a decompression chamber system attached by a trunk (a short passage) to a diving bell on the rig, being assisted by two dive tenders.[5] One diver was about to close the door between the chamber system and the trunk when the chamber explosively decompressed from a pressure of nine atmospheres to one atmosphere in a fraction of a second. Five of the men were killed instantly; the other was severely injured.
[...]
The first two steps had been completed, and D4 was about to carry out step 3 when, for some reason, one of the tenders opened the clamp, which resulted in explosive decompression of the chamber. A tremendous blast shot from the chamber through the trunk, pushing the bell away and hitting the two tenders. The tender who opened the clamp was killed, and the other was severely injured.
Diver D3 was shot out through the small jammed hatch door opening and was torn to pieces. Subsequent investigation by forensic pathologists determined D4, being exposed to the highest pressure gradient, violently exploded due to the rapid and massive expansion of internal gases. All of his thoracic and abdominal organs, and even his thoracic spine were ejected, as were all of his limbs. Simultaneously, his remains were expelled through the narrow trunk opening left by the jammed chamber door, less than 60 centimetres (24 in) in diameter. Fragments of his body were found scattered about the rig. One part was even found lying on the rig's derrick, 10 metres (30 ft) directly above the chambers. His death was most likely instantaneous and painless.
→ More replies (7)107
13
→ More replies (7)7
u/stash0606 Jun 18 '12
in the case of the video, they're using PSI of water to calculate the pressure. what would you use in the case of vacuum?
→ More replies (15)13
u/AnArtistsRendition Jun 18 '12
You could have multiple layers of the outer casing with water in between to identify leaks. One layer sprung a leak? No problem, we have another already in place.
→ More replies (2)35
Jun 18 '12
what about the train that carries the passangers? if this thing breaks down, you are under water, around 1500 miles away from the nearest people, in a capsule that is slowly or quickly losing air in a vacuum, oh, and did I mention the fucking ocean that is above you.
→ More replies (47)104
u/Lorpius_Prime Jun 18 '12
Yeah, you're probably about as screwed as you are if your airplane breaks down at 30,000 feet.
→ More replies (44)6
u/The_Serious_Account Jun 18 '12
The pressure difference between vacuum and normal air pressure is the same as a tunnel at 10 meters water depth. You make it sound like its an extreme extra pressure. It's really not. There are other issues, of course.
→ More replies (1)6
u/schwab002 Jun 18 '12
A transatlantic tunnel doesn't have to be under water. Either way it'd be a huge feat of engineering.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (8)4
u/ableman Jun 18 '12
It's not a big deal. A vaccuum causes about 1 atmosphere of pressure difference. 30' of water do the same thing. We have tunnels more than 100' under water.
8
u/jesseaknight Jun 18 '12
it's been tested in some sub-mile structures for testing something involving lasers. They held up for years in the test. But yes..managing a pressure failure and not killing passengers as they hit the wall of air would be quite tricky.
→ More replies (1)12
35
u/jetpackmalfunction Jun 18 '12
This type of reductive pessimism can also be used to make cars, trains, planes, boats, shinkansen, zeppelins, any form of transportation faster than a brisk walk, or basically any technology at all sound utterly insane and impossible.
Let's cling to the backs of horses as they sprint across the highlands! How perfectly reasonable, tying ourselves to the backs of mad, bucking stallions!
Let's float on top of water, and let the wind push us in whatever direction it's blowing!
And such and such.
→ More replies (1)10
Jun 18 '12
This is different though, because regardless of how you do it, its going to cost eleventy trillion dollars. Its not that the tech isnt advanced enough, because it is. It just costs a fuckton of money. Even REGULAR maglev trains arent built that often these days because of their tracks costing so much. Just think of how much the tube alone costs.
→ More replies (6)17
u/Jyana Jun 18 '12
If it's going to cost a fuckton of money, then the tech isn't advanced enough yet. Today's computers would have cost unthinkable amounts of money 30 years ago.
3
2
u/Godisman Jun 18 '12
Yeah, simple as cheating the speed of light...you just have to "do it"!
→ More replies (1)2
u/mg115ca Jun 18 '12
I know right?
If you're going to make the tunnel a vacuum, you may as well make it a gravity train and get the time down to 42 minutes (ish. depending on elevations).
All it takes it tunneling through the earth's mantle.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (51)2
u/alexthealex Jun 18 '12
How, you ask?
All it takes is the combination of technology with some magnetic levitation.
Fuck this article, already.
15
u/recockulous Jun 18 '12
Donald Fagen's prediction gets a little closer to reality.
9
5
5
u/amajorseventh Aug 04 '12
If you're not really concerned about travel time, you COULD take the long way.
Grab the Wolverine down to Annendale.
Write an album about the west coast while living on the east coast.
Write an album about the east coast while living on the west coast.
Drive west on Sunset to the sea...
→ More replies (2)3
5
103
u/dopafiend Jun 18 '12
Just the thought of traveling from New York to London brings on the jet lag. But imagine a world where the journey could take just over an hour
I'm not entirely sure the author actually understands what jet lag is.
21
u/one_random_redditor Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
But with 60s/70s British/French technology we could do it in ~2hrs.
Concorde! I know it was too costly but surely it'd be cheaper than building one of these things.
Edit: Okay so apparently it was more like 3hrs due to noise regs meaning the concorde had to go subsonic for a lot of it's journey but this was 60's tech, could it be done quieter & and faster thesedays?
→ More replies (4)3
u/talontario Jun 18 '12
Aren't they working on a replacement for the Concorde though? Believe I heard updates about it not too long ago.
68
u/CocoSavege Jun 18 '12
Just devil's advocating here...
A vacTrain makes a day trip feasible. So no jet lag!
→ More replies (4)21
16
u/rjbeads Jun 18 '12
Yea, I don't think traveling faster would solve the problem of exchanging time zones.
5
u/one_random_redditor Jun 18 '12
Britain should just inform it's colonies that they will be using GMT0 from now on.
Problem solved.
→ More replies (3)
14
u/jesseaknight Jun 18 '12
he's been repping this idea for years (>9 yrs) at engineering schools. There are always some in the room that are super excited, and some that are terribly skeptical. It's true that humans have completed other projects that seem implausible on this scale, and that it would revolutionize long-distance travel. But.. I don't think we'll be able to get ourselves organized around this any time soon.
→ More replies (12)2
u/ramsay_baggins Jun 18 '12
Something that instantly hit me as I was reading it: How in the hell would they get it through the Trans-Atlantic Rift? The huge fault line running down the middle of the Atlantic where magma comes to the surface driving sea floor expansion, and ever increasing the distance between the continents? They'd have to find a way to protect the tunnel from the extremely hot magma, and make sure the tunnel can cope with the fact it's being pushed apart at all times from the middle. It may be a small amount of expansion, but over time the stress will build up and cause terrible issues.
51
Jun 18 '12
I guess you could say that this...
sunglasses
Is a pipe dream.
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
→ More replies (2)
5
40
u/mrdeadsniper Jun 18 '12
If we are imagining things, can we just imagine a transporter from Star Trek and make the trip take 30 seconds?
14
u/EasyReader Jun 18 '12
Nuts to that. Ballistic flight from anywhere to anywhere on earth. Just shoot people in metal capsules out of a railgun into orbit, then reentry at the proper time and place to land where they want.
→ More replies (2)7
Jun 18 '12
Yes please.
Also, have the capsule land in a giant pit of tapioca pudding.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)10
u/abudhabikid Jun 18 '12
Actually kinda, with quantum tunneling and Bose-Einstein condensates, we can transport simple molecules.
See Dr. Michigan Kaku's Physics of the Impossible, and the chapter on teleportation.
10
16
u/MLP_Awareness Jun 18 '12
Oh god please, let's hold off on the ethical/psychological problems of resetting consciousness.
→ More replies (2)19
u/brycedriesenga Jun 18 '12
Say what you want about the ethical/psychological problems of resetting consciousness, but at least its an ethos man.
→ More replies (3)5
u/DanielPhermous Jun 18 '12
We can create wormholes between two points as well. That would be a far better solution, as us humans would likely prefer the idea of walking through a door than being disintegrated.
We do need to ignite Jupiter for a power source, though.
5
u/ByronicBionicMan Jun 18 '12
Hey no problem. All we have to do is get there and cover it in these nifty black boxes.
18
u/jbrandt01 Jun 18 '12
10
u/antimattern Jun 18 '12
Concorde was retired 9 years ago and I don't believe there are any civil supersonic aircraft currently running.
→ More replies (2)14
u/Laser493 Jun 18 '12
I think the point is that the concorde which is a 60 year old design can go from london to new york in about 2 hours. It would be significantly cheaper to design a build a new supersonic aircraft for transatlantic journeys than building a tunnel.
→ More replies (2)20
u/Dra9on Jun 18 '12
But a single Concorde crashed, so we shouldn't build a supersonic passenger craft ever again.
→ More replies (3)
4
4
u/CorporatePsychopath Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
Get the Chinese onto it - they'll have it up and running by the end of the year. Of course they won't make it through next year without a horrific catastrophe, but it probably won't be on your trip.
→ More replies (1)
15
u/MLP_Awareness Jun 18 '12
I kinda want it to change its mechanics into a giant moo tube, muuuuuuhhhhh moooooooggg ( you know flip the toy and it makes that sound)
→ More replies (1)18
3
u/paintin_closets Jun 18 '12
It's be cheaper to build a hypersonic atmospheric skipping craft. Probably safer too.
3
3
u/rtkwe Jun 18 '12
Relevant xkcd:
For the lazy: "10 years out == We haven't finished inventing it yet."
3
3
u/Noradrenergic Jun 18 '12
Remember seeing a documentary about this on Discovery Chanel about 7 years ago. It was "maybe in ten years" back then too.
2
u/stankbucket Jun 18 '12
I saw the same one. I seem to remember the cost estimate to be about a trillion dollars. http://dsc.discovery.com/convergence/engineering/transatlantictunnel/interactive/interactive.html
3
3
u/whenwillthisdayend Jun 18 '12
Why don't we try this new technology on land before putting it under the frickin ocean. I imagine a similar technology could be utilized from NY to LA.
→ More replies (3)
7
Jun 18 '12
This is what worries me:
Crash in a boat: will probably survive
Crash in a car: could survive
Crash in a plane: incredibly slim chance of survival
Crash in an air vacuum tunnel, miles under the Atlantic Ocean, travelling at 2500mph: NOPE!
5
u/TheDrDroppedMe Jun 18 '12
Bright side to crash in air vacuum tunnel. Unlike the other scenarios, your brain would never have time to process the crash. Death would be instant, painless, and without warning.
You'd just be traveling along, rocking out to the tunes on your iPod, or watching the in-transit movie and BAM! You're just shut off like a computer.
→ More replies (1)4
u/hawthorneluke Jun 18 '12
And then just compare the number of fatal car crashes a year to those of planes.
→ More replies (4)2
u/rtuck99 Jun 18 '12
I seem to remember somewhere the average odds of survival from plane crashes is something like 50%. So not that bad really.
→ More replies (1)
20
8
u/gamwizrd1 Jun 18 '12
Wanted to upvote, but after the 5-year joke and "a girl can dream".....
Best I can do, not downvote.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Justavian Jun 18 '12
In the episode of Extreme Engineering (i think that's what it was called) where they discussed this 10 years ago, they estimated the cost would be about a trillion dollars.
2
2
2
u/U-smilie Jun 18 '12
describing it as “space travel on Earth.”
It comes with all the dangers of regular space travel, like dying in a vacuum if there's a leak in the vehicle.
2
u/Supersnazz Jun 18 '12
There's a Discovery Channel type show, Extreme Psychotic Engineering Madness or something, about this very thing.
10 billion USD plus, and basically uninsurable. Essentially impossible within the next 200 years, without some massive and unexpected game-changing technology.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
Jun 18 '12
Despite the problems that building this at the bottom of the ocean produce, I love the idea of this being applied on land.
2
u/optionalcourse Jun 18 '12
Meh, I think sub-orbital scramjets are a more feasible futuristic technology.
2
u/mns2 Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
"All it takes is sucking the air out of a transatlantic tunnel, just like a vacuum."
Screw you. You have to build a tunnel strong enough to sustain a vacuum and you have to periodically check for leaks all over it. Have you ever seen a truck fold in on itself due to air pressure at sea level? Water is about twice as bad at 10 meters of depth. The material for the tunnel would have to be insanely strong and then there's having to maintain fucking several thousand miles of it. And then there's the insane ease with which just about anything could screw the whole thing up. Storms and ships could damage the tunnel at any time.
I do not believe it is feasibly possible to build this with the technology we have now. Even if it was, it would be so fucking economically nonviable it's not even funny.
2
u/CosmicBard Jun 18 '12
Every fucking first year engineering student tackles the problem of a train Manhattan to London so much, it's a goddamn meme in the community. It's a joke almost used in hyperbole in comparison. "About as plausible as..." comes up a lot.
The thought process is that it seems as though this is a great idea that we've had for a hundred years or so but for some reason have been unable to technically achieve until right this moment. So, queue our plucky junior engineer who cobbles one of these together in a couple nights of fevered design. Every one of his peers could probably pick one separate thing about it that would completely ruin the entire concept.
It's just not feasible.
2
u/scaia Jun 18 '12
As awesome as the idea of a transatlantic train is, it'd be too impractical. Instead, why not do the same idea, but on land? It's overdue for the U.S. to have a super fast bullet train connecting the coasts and major metros.
2
u/Industrialbonecraft Jun 18 '12
I have to ask: how well does the human body cope with speeds of 2,500- 4,000 mph?
4
u/Troez Jun 18 '12
Well the ISS travels at around 17,000mph... It's not velocity that's dangerous, it's the forces due to rapid acceleration.
3
u/Lord-Longbottom Jun 18 '12
(For us English aristocrats, I leave you this 4,000 mph -> 10752000.0 Furlongs/Fortnight) - Pip pip cheerio chaps!
2
u/niggertown Jun 18 '12
And when things go wrong everyone in the train experiences explosive decompression.
2
u/MARRYING_A_FURRY Jun 18 '12
As a person in a long-distance relationship with an American... yeeeeees.
2
u/ThatJanitor Jun 18 '12
The next puzzle for the engineers is to figure out how to stop the train going 4023 km/h.
2
2
Jun 18 '12
Frictionless Surfaces
As I stepped onto the Magtube, a thought struck me: Can there be friction where there is no substance? And can substance be tricked into hiding from itself?
-- Dr. Gayle Nambala,
Morgan Industries ResearcherSid Meier's Alpha Centauri
→ More replies (1)
2
u/antisoshal Jun 18 '12
The real sadness here is that people smart enough to understand and create this are also still naive enough to think that it could ever happen. Even the most basic public works project is almost impossible to finance under anything like a free society. Privatized, this sort of construction would be so cost prohibitive to implement and operate that it will simply never exist. The only people on this planet with enough money to finance this will demand a level of return on their investment that simply could not be attained. Figure out how to move a few million gallons of oil that fast and have it cost less than tankers, and maybe you are on to something. In the end, speed will only matter when its cheaper.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
u/AvroChris Jun 18 '12
It's a cool idea! Now they just need a 3,500 mile air-tight tunnel, and the means to remove all the air from said tunnel. For comparison, it's taking the Swiss 20 years to make a 35 mile standard railway tunnel (Gotthard Base tunnel). A modular idea (courtesy Dhex) could work for overland but Mag-Lev on its own is monumentally expensive.
Not with ten thousand men could you do this. It is folly.
2
u/enjinn Jun 18 '12
I noticed some people talking about the speed, but I want to know more about the acceleration/deceleration. Traveling AT 2500mph is the easy part, but can the human body comfortably handle (or survive, for that matter) getting from 0-2500mph and the opposite when stopping? Jet pilots and astronauts wear suits to prevent blood pooling in extremities and blacking out. The space shuttle, while accelerating to much higher speeds, takes over 8 minutes to reach escape velocity, but astronauts are also very fit and went thru extensive training. Then there's the question of whether this tunnel would be straight, because a large enough change in direction at high speeds causes whiplash.
2
Jun 18 '12
Yeah. Bullshit. It's like those retro news and articals about planets being colonized in a few decades. Won't happen
2
2
u/Frangar Jun 18 '12
The thing is, the faster you travel threw air, the denser it gets, over 200mph is like flying threw a smoothie, so even the tint particles left in the vacuum would have a big impact at them alleged speeds.
2
u/Geaux Jun 18 '12
I think the biggest adverse issue to deal with could be as small as a pea-sized hole in the tube. It would completely depressurize the entire thing and take a really long time to find and fix.
2
u/Jober86 Jun 18 '12
Don't know if anyone has written this but I remember seeing a discovery channel special about this years ago. http://dsc.discovery.com/convergence/engineering/transatlantictunnel/interactive/interactive.html
2
2
u/lomoeffect Jun 18 '12
has nobody else considered how ugly this would look? look at the photos on the bottom of the page and I think you'll find it hard to see Governments (and indeed land owners) agreeing to put that massive tunnel over their land.
2
u/fancy-chips Jun 18 '12
Hmmm suspended tube void of oxygen under the ocean with train going hundreds of miles per hour inside. I can't ever forsee how this could go bad.
2
2
u/violizard Jun 18 '12
So the airports are hard to get to but a tube station will be immediately accessible? And I am sure there will be nooooo 5 hour security checkpoints either lol
2
u/TILnotathing Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12
This idea is so old...I've seen multiple specials about it over the years on science channels.
Sad thing about this is the amount of US debt would cover the cost of this in its entirety.
2
Jun 18 '12
anyone else worried about the acceleration of these trains? we're gonna get to 2,500mph how fast? and how fast are we going to slow down?
ib4someone'sbrainshootsoutoftheirface
2
Jun 18 '12
The real engineering marvel needed is a way to tunnel under/around the mid Atlantic ridge and it's constant spreading. None the less making the train survivable in the event of a mechanical problems of flooding mid trip.
2
u/AnythingApplied Jun 18 '12
It produces a maximum of 1G of force at top speed
Every horizontal mode of transport that starts and ends at a stop will produce more than 1G at some point, so they are just referring to when maintaining top speed, which by the laws of physics you will experience only 1G in every mode of transport. I don't know how they can be listing other modes of transportation as worse by this measure unless they are really incompetent or allow their marketing team to lie through their teeth.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/xMooCowx Jun 18 '12
Oh yay, this again. I'm going to wait for all the armchair engineers to come out and argue about how this is totally feasible and how anyone who tells them it isn't "lost the ability to dream!" (this is actually something that someone told me)
4
3
5
u/JoseJimeniz Jun 18 '12
Not likely ever.
Nobody will want to pay for it. Airplanes can already fly from New York to London, and they don't require a tube built the entire 400 mi length. Much cheaper to build two 1,000 ft runways, and a plane.
59
u/sixtyt3 Jun 18 '12
I might be wrong but I estimate NY to London to be more than 400 miles, good sir.
31
u/The_Drizzle_Returns Jun 18 '12
He forgot to include his assumption that there is a wormhole that covers the other 3000ish miles.
→ More replies (1)7
→ More replies (56)5
u/abudhabikid Jun 18 '12
One of his (Oster's) interesting selling points that he kept spouting off while my design team worked with him was that, after the capsules and track are payed off, it could be so cheap that advertisers would pay travelers to travel.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/doismellbacon Jun 18 '12
would going from 2500MPH to 0MPH in 5 seconds kill you? Assuming you had seatbelt's on and uh a head restraint too.
7
u/haikuginger Jun 18 '12
The official website for the project suggests that acceleration will be in the range of 1 G (gravitational unit), or about 10m/s2 , meaning that the train will accelerate or decelerate for about 2 minutes at the beginning and end of each trip.
8
u/Reddit4Play Jun 18 '12
Gravity is about 10m/s2, and this deceleration would be reducing a velocity of ~1100 m/s in 5 seconds, or about 223 Gs. The largest amount of standing force that a human has experimentally been subjected to was a volunteer in the 1950s, who resisted between 25 (minimum constant) and 50ish (peak) Gs for about a second in a precisely similar deceleration. Though he survived he had permanent vision damage of some degree for the rest of his life (if I recall a documentary I watched a decade ago correctly it involved bursting capillaries in his eyes). I suspect that this would result in severe permanent vision damage if not other problems as a result.
Whether it would kill you has yet to be experimentally determined, though.
→ More replies (10)6
u/aphexcoil Jun 18 '12
Going from 2500mph to 0mph in 5 seconds would be like going from 250 mph to 0mph in .5 seconds (but suffering from the deacceleration for even longer). That's definitely going to kill you. There isn't even a chance of you surviving something like that.
Not to mention that all the seats would be ripping out of the floor and having pieces of metal fly around at that rate of deacceleration.
You would die and it would be painless.
→ More replies (2)2
→ More replies (1)3
u/zugi Jun 18 '12
change-in-velocity = acceleration X time.
2500 MPH = acceleration * 5 seconds.
2500 miles per hour = 3667 feet per second (Google).
acceleration = 3667 / 5 = 733 feet per second per second
"1G" (gravitational acceleration) equals 32 feet per second, so that means acceleration = 23 gees.
Performance aircraft usually limit pilots to 10 gees for any sustained period of time; at 23 gees death would likely result.
Give yourself at least 13 seconds to slow down to barely survive, more like 3-5 minutes to decelerate comfortably.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/beatonbw Jun 18 '12
allowing you to leave the United Kingdom at noon and arrive in Manhattan at 8 a.m. the same day.
dear god....
5
u/atla Jun 18 '12
Meh, not that impressive. Phil Collins was in two places at once nearly three decades ago.
2
u/verronbc Jun 18 '12
Don't tell manhatten what's going to happen between 8 and noon though...theyll want to be surprised... (semiquoted joke from Friends)
1
1
1
1
u/wiithepiiple Jun 18 '12
This makes me think of Futurama travel.
3
u/schunniky Jun 18 '12
"These are dark matter engines I invented. They allow my ship to travel between galaxies in mere hours."
"That's impossible, you can't go faster than the speed of light!"
"'course not. That's why scientists increased the speed of light."
1
u/HAL-8999 Jun 18 '12
It was not impossible to build Rapture at the bottom of the ocean. It was impossible to build it anywhere else.
1
u/SwipeyDipey Jun 18 '12
We need these fucking things across the US. From LA to Vegas in like 20 minutes? Why the fuck not? This would change the fucking world.
3
Jun 18 '12
Why not high-speed rail first? Wasn't California going to build a bullet train, but the voters said no?
1
u/kpatterson14206 Jun 18 '12
Leave London at Noon.....trip takes one hour... Manhattan at 8am.....OMG TIME TRAVEL
1
1
u/meatpod Jun 18 '12
This is retarded. It would cost jillions of dollars to build, so it would probably cost millions of dollars to ride. They would have to build thousands of them to meet the demand, otherwise why would you pay millions of dollars when you could fly for a thousand? Just takes a little longer.
1
1
Jun 18 '12
I saw another program about it recently. They said it would take 100 years to build not counting the technologies that need to be invented.
1
u/OKAH Jun 18 '12
Man this would be so awesome - I love American sports so I could buy a 50quid train ticket, watch a Ravens/Orioles game and then go back to Yorkshire!
Please finish this before i die!
If you assume its a New York to London line it would be a 2.5hour trip from Yorkshire to London, then another 2.5 to NY, then what 2hours to Baltimore? (or wait till they play a NY team away)
1
1
u/OKAH Jun 18 '12
I'm ignorant to the science of this but couldn't you just create a vacuum just in front of the train saving you having to pressurise the whole line at once?
You could seal off the pipe in sections to maintain the pressure, or am I talking out my ass?
Also, wouldnt the futurama idea be more "cost effective" a smaller pipe that carries a 2 person size capsule must be cheaper than a train sized one.
2
u/ataraxia_ Jun 18 '12
I presume you mean depressurise - and no, I don't think your suggestion is feasible. Assuming no leakage, it'd be more efficient to depressurise the line and keep it depressurised. Once it's depressurised you only have to remove the air seeping back into the tunnel. The 'no leaks' bit is a bit of a logistical nightmare. Depressurising it and repressurising it would be an insane amount of energy expenditure, which again makes it unfeasible.
Also, why seal off the pipes in sections, when the end result is that they all have to be depressurised anyway? I don't really see it.
And finally, yes, the smaller the pipe the cheaper. Probably. But you still need to make it big enough to fit the capsule that contains the people, and the motorisation to make it all go. Keep in mind that people can't be exposed to the vacuum in the tube, or they'd asphyxiate.
1
u/wjv Jun 18 '12
Harry Harrison went there back in 1972, in his alt-history novel A Transatlantic Tunnel, Hurrah! Which is still well worth reading!
1
u/mykew Jun 18 '12
Couldnt it be divided into smaller sections, with a sort off automatic shutter every so often (as it goes through one section, opens the one ahead, closing the one behind) making it easier to maintain the vacuum?
1
1
u/NachosAreYourFriend Jun 18 '12
One ticket, please! I have always wanted to visit London. I'm not sure what public transportation is like over there...Manhattan is ok if you like the hustle and bustle, but you'd have to take, like, 5 trains just to get to this one fancy train.
1
u/emceelokey Jun 18 '12
... Are they basically explaining the vacuum tubes that you used to see in banks, or the tubes in Futurama?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/jadecat Jun 18 '12
how long woul it take to comfortably accelerate and decelerate?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/pascalbrax Jun 18 '12
Nice, that's the same idea behind the old SwissMetro and many other projects.
1
u/1eejit Jun 18 '12
I presume magnetic breaking to handle deceleration? Friction being intentionally out of the question.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/jam_i_am Jun 18 '12
Didn't Brunel try something like this in the 1840s, but it kept springing leaks so it wasn't feasible?
1
1
1
1
Jun 18 '12
Why not build a bridge instead of doing this at the bottom of the ocean?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/MrTubalcain Jun 18 '12
This would be incredible but we're too busy warring and arguing about bullshit. We do these things not because they are easy but because they are hard.
1
u/JSLEnterprises Jun 18 '12
Traveling through vaccuum = no friction, no turbulance... totally plausable, and the train doesnt even need to be areodynamic... it could be a full cylinder in shape.
1
1
u/jakus55 Jun 18 '12
They were going to do this with rockets too, but I don't think it would take off.
1
1
u/bscotty919 Jun 18 '12
This story was on reddit before, but I'm glad to see it's still in our attention span. It's good stuff. I hope it happens.
1
u/vanderzac Jun 18 '12
From the photo's displayed it looks like it is built in modules which are assembled onsite. If production were to ramp up to 100,000+ modules for the deployment of a massive system, economies of scale would have a much greater effect. Also, this system seems to be mounted above ground level which may allow it to be deployed in cities without destroying existing infrastructure. Larger versions of this could probably be used for transporting goods, making this an economic investment as well. As I understand it this transportation system is the most advanced system conceived, and likely the fastest method of transit we will have thought of over the next 100 years. If this were to become the new transit standard, the cost does not seem as extreme, when compared to the cost of the existing train and highway systems, and the cost of automobiles, over the last 50 years alone, adjusted for inflation. Also, this could be a massive government works program providing jobs all over the country.
1
1
u/sirbruce Jun 18 '12
“Our airways are becoming terribly congested, and getting to, from and through airports is very time consuming.”
Airways are NOT congested. AIRPORTS are congested, because no one wants a new airport in their backyard, and we only have so many ATC, runways, and gates.
1
1
1
u/Draptor Jun 19 '12
Small question, couldn't find it anywhere in this thread. Would it take a substantial amount of time to speed up and slow down? Not just the limitations of the propulsion, but the comfort of the passengers? And would this greatly impact the quoted 2 hour time?
1
u/toodrunktofuck Jun 19 '12
I hope someone is bold enough to make this actually happen or at least say conduct research towards prototypes and inter-city connections using this technology.
Makes me sad thinking about Germany's hostile environment towards technology like this in the last decades. The Transrapid-story makes me sad and angry.
142
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
The channel tunnel doesn't require a vacuum chamber, or maglev rails, and cost almost £10 billion. It took almost 10 years to build, and it took over 20 years before the company running it made a profit.
It was only 30 miles long.