r/technology • • Jun 17 '12

AirPod, a car that runs on air.

http://europe.cnn.com/video/?/video/international/2010/10/27/ef.air.pod.car.bk.c.cnn
891 Upvotes

502 comments sorted by

88

u/broken_cogwheel Jun 17 '12

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Three wheels is okay, but not if the single wheel is in front. Why manufacturers keep trying to make three wheelers backwards, I'll never understand.

3

u/broken_cogwheel Jun 18 '12

Pretty much.

See Campagna T-Rex, the only stability problems it has is the rear loosening under duress. These guys are working on COMPRESSED AIR propulsion--maybe good in a very targeted area/market...but wouldn't actually good battery tech for EV's be a worldwide blockbuster?

3

u/derpderpdeherp Jun 18 '12

Is there a reason you think that? Tailwheel airplanes (which have the casterable wheel in the back are less stable on the ground and harder to control than tricycle gear ones). So much so, in fact, that the FAA requires a special tailwheel endorsement (above and beyond a regular pilot's license) from a qualified instructor before you are allowed to fly one.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/somequickresponse Jun 18 '12

That article was from 2010, apparently now it has 4 wheels, scroll down in their news: http://www.mdi.lu/english/actualite.php

2

u/biznatch11 Jun 18 '12
  1. Was that car really as popular as he says it was?

  2. Was he driving it very "extremely"? He doesn't seem to be. Maybe he's driving it a little harder than normal.

  3. If this car was very popular, and tipped over so easily with normal driving, wouldn't there be tons of people tipping over all the time?

4

u/BabyBumbleBee Jun 18 '12

If you grew up in England in the 70s you saw a fair few around. They seldom tipped because they'd give a lurch before they went and were never the vehicle of choice for boy-racers. And Clarkson knows how to make good tv.

3

u/Tylerdurdon Jun 18 '12

Holy shit! That was hilarious! Thanks much for that!

4

u/paffle Jun 18 '12 edited Aug 17 '26

Encouraging vast juggle teeny smell tangerine sulky vase pinecone

This post was anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Dragon029 Jun 18 '12

Also, the only reason 3 wheels is so unstable with the Reliant Robin is because it's centre of gravity is poorly positioned (high and too far forward).

See the Nissan DeltaWing for a "3 wheeler" (it has 4 wheels, but the front ones are quite close together and are only 10cm wide as well) done well - it can take corners tightly due to it's centre of gravity being just in front of the rear wheels. Down-force maintains the front wheels' grip.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

[deleted]

22

u/polite_alpha Jun 18 '12

In addition to that, 3 wheels have less friction than 4.

22

u/jagedlion Jun 18 '12

One of the things that makes friction so insanely cool is that it is calculated as u * Fn (coefficient of friction*normal force)

That means that increased surface area, with the same weight, actually has the same friction. Super cool, right?

Of course, you mean friction in the bearings or on the axles, not the friction between the car and the road, but it's always worth pointing out physics 100 concepts when the opportunity presents itself, right?

→ More replies (12)

10

u/TheBrokenWorld Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I don't know why you got downvoted, 3 wheels have lower rolling resistance than 4. This is one of the reasons Aptera stuck with the arrangement.

Edit: The reason for this has to do with the tires themselves, not the friction between the tire and the road.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Is aptera still in business? I haven't heard anything about them and their budget EV in ages.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/random_2 Jun 18 '12

And 3 wheels are cheaper to buy. :-)

→ More replies (20)

254

u/NuclearWookie Jun 17 '12

Deceptive title. The car runs on whatever ends up powering the compressor, which can be anything.

33

u/BradBramish Jun 18 '12

He acknowledges this in the video. The blame is now shifted from the vehicle to the grid. Allows more of an argument for clean, renewable power.

20

u/CaptainChewbacca Jun 18 '12

Getting the polution out of the cities would be a huge benefit for cleaner air.

2

u/Retsoka Jun 18 '12

And no need for polluting, heavy and expensive car batteries.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

And let's not forget that compressors are some of the least efficient machines in existence. 30% is an astoundingly high efficiency for a compressor.

Regardless of what form of energy powers the compressor, the vast majority of it will be wasted.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

That might be true (not sure about their efficiency), however consider the fact that even though LiPoly batteries have something like 99% storage efficiency, they will degrade after a while, especially in hot climates. And they are expensive to produce and recycle. They also present other problems, like exploding. Of course, this air compressed tank can also explode, but there won't be any flames or heat, so your car won't be set on fire.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/pantiloons Jun 18 '12

If we can ever come to our senses and use the energy that the sun gives us to power things, maybe then will we have a true "green" car. Or energy. Or anything. Because its everywhere.

1

u/SethBling Jun 18 '12

To be fair, the energy in fossil fuels also came from the sun. Entropy doesn't just decrease on its own, ya'know.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Yeah, and "electric" cars run on whatever generates the electricity, and combustion engines run on whatever generates petroleum, i.e. solar energy, but of course solar energy is generated by fusion, the fuel for which was generated by the Big Bang. But Airpod itself runs on compressed air, and there's nothing deceptive about that, any more than there is in saying a gasoline engine runs on gasoline. You put stored energy into the car in the form of compressed air, or you put stored energy into the car in the form of combustible fuel. It's obvious that the stored energy doesn't magically appear out of nowhere, and nothing in the title or article implied otherwise.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I don't see the point at all. Compressed air storage is cheap, but it's far less efficient than batteries. This car won't go very far and will cost a lot more to refuel.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

How will it cost more to refuel? How much does it really cost to put some air in a tank?

And if you use it strictly for commuting then it is perfectly acceptable. A lot of families have two or three cars here in the US. Why not have one like this for commuting, and the other for longer travels?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Darthallen417 Jun 18 '12

Additionaly this car has been in development for years and they still cannot solve the problem that cold air creates as it freezes the seals and the compressed tank loses its compressed air once a seal blows due to the cold. This car is a fail and is a pipe dream unfortunatly. Hydrogen is a better alternative but there is not enough platinum on the planet to mass produce untill we can start mining metals from asteroids. Our closest solution to our energy crisis is the moon and mining helium3 from the surface of the orbital rock but getting there is going to cost us a lot of petro and when we do get there the cost to return the private sector would charge for it would still make fossil fuel the best alternative. I also knwo that a lot of people are hoping for a green solution to bio fuels as well but what do we sacrifice to get there; more forrest land and wild life diversity or do we stop feeding the masses to grow the fuel that we need. This is a conundrum we are in and it may not be solved soon enough or cheap enough.

1

u/greg_barton Jun 18 '12

Sure it will. See energyfromthorium.com

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

Yup. For a moment, I thought it was John Galt's motor, til' I read "compressed air".

1

u/CanNibble Jun 18 '12

I agree. The article says that it runs on "thin air," but as far as I'm concerned, compressed air is "thick air."

1

u/NuclearWookie Jun 18 '12

Well, the troublesome bit is the word "run", which in this context means "derives energy from" and puts it in the same class of phrases as "runs on water".

1

u/markrobbo96 Jun 18 '12

Came to the comments for the catch.

Wasn't disappointed

1

u/hairaware Jun 18 '12

to be fair the car does run on air. You can have emission free methods of producing this compressed air. Hell maybe theyll even have hand powered pumps at some point so you never have to worry about running out of air :D

1

u/NuclearWookie Jun 18 '12

Hand-powered pumps would be least efficient, particularly if you eat meat.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (145)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Ignoring the wacky design, is compressed air even more energy-dense than other solutions?

14

u/alsdfkajfkfj Jun 18 '12

it is less dense, see here. However, i don't know what the "energy per weight" is, presumably that is pretty competitive.

1

u/ShadowRam Jun 18 '12

Energy per weight argument is destroyed by all the weight of the controls/distribution needed for high pressure pneumatics.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

3

u/Sryzon Jun 18 '12

I'd imagine the engine would be much lighter, though.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/paffle Jun 18 '12 edited Aug 17 '26

Subsequent sulky jar deliver absorbed ribbon growth coherent quiet

This post was anonymized with Redact

2

u/kartuli78 Jun 18 '12

No shit? Remember when Apple started suing any company that used "i" before their name? AirPod? fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck.... this company is no longer going to exist after Apple bankrupts them.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/spinningmagnets Jun 18 '12

If they are committed to using three wheels, Id put the pair up front and the single in back.

The MDI-Tata from India has enough rolling examples for real world data on air-powered.

Benefits: can recharged from a large standby tank in less than a minute. Standby tank can recharge immediately, or late at night to take advantage of lower rates and existing electric infrastructure. EV batteries wear out in a few years, must be replaced. Air car components expected longevity is many decades.

Smog from electric generation can be shifted to a central location and thus more controllable, also E-plants can be upgraded (as opposed to gasoline).

Sadly, limited applications, and short range.

10

u/errandum Jun 18 '12

The moment you can recharge it in less than a minute, I wouldn't consider it "short range". If in those 150-200km you can't find a gas station... Then maybe.

But this is a city vehicle, so the point is moot. And if compressed air is all that's needed, I wonder if it wouldn't be viable to buy your own compressed air thingie and refuel it at home (:

8

u/ineptjedibob Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I didn't see what pressures they're running, but I'd imagine the air compressor you'd need would be well out of the range of normal tool/inflation models. Given that the larger ones (such as those used for SCUBA applications) can be thousands of dollars, I'd rather fill up at a station. This is before you've even considered the costs of maintaining such a beast, and the noise pollution it creates while running.

Keeping an "emergency" bottle in your garage might not be out of the question, though.

EDIT: The Wikipedia article linked here (thanks rspam!) uses a pressure of 4500psi (30MPa) for their energy-density calculations, which leads me to believe they'd be using something similar in the AirPod. Normal compressors won't touch a tenth of that.

4

u/tmeowbs Jun 18 '12

You just need a decent paintball shop! Compressed air tanks for paintball markers can run at 3000 or 4500psi.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/errandum Jun 18 '12

Guess it isn't. Thanks for the answer (:

2

u/Dragon029 Jun 18 '12

And as a reference, at work, we have a trailer, containing about 10 cubic metres of air, compressed to 3000psi. That trailer is a back-up system, to be used to start 1 engine on a Boeing 737. During the procedure, the majority of the air is drained.

Using an old, but fairly large large (about the size of a car's engine block) electric air compressor, it takes around 6 hours to charge the bottles back up.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ZOMBIE_POTATO_SALAD Jun 18 '12

These things aren't filled to 100PSI, think more like 4500.

Go to a paintball field, you might see a giant diesel compressor or something similar, that's what they use.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I have doubts about the many various gaskets, valves, sealing surfaces and bearings lasting "decades"...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Those are cheap and are non proprietary usually (just a rubber Oring) and would be comparable or less in price than gas equivalent vehicles.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Teledildonic Jun 18 '12

But those are just standard wear parts. They are not expected to last forever, and therefore are cheap and replaceable.

No different than the belts, batteries, and filters you have to periodically replace in a gas car.

1

u/spinningmagnets Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

I have driven 18-wheelers that had over 750,000 miles on the original engine (I am 52). Air compressors and air-engines operate at much lower temperatures and pressures. It is not unreasonable to expect that the longevity of the Air-engine would be impressive. The concept has a few flaws, but I am of the opinion that the long life of the components is not a concern.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Geezheeztall Jun 18 '12

I hope this three wheeler does not become a modern day Reliant Robin.

1

u/bobjohnsonmilw Jun 18 '12

This needs to be recognized as one of the best Top Gear clips of all time.

5

u/chubowu Jun 18 '12

Ohhhh how i want one so badly :(

4

u/Ralfnader66 Jun 18 '12

Why the hell do new-age cars that run on new-age fuels have to look to fucking retarded. Come. On.

3

u/dnew Jun 18 '12

Because real cars are too heavy to run on compressed air.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

You can do light weight without changing the controls people are used to. Like as not, most people will not accept a joystick controlled vehicle where the door is in the front.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/rspam Jun 17 '12

Cars running on compressed air are reasonably common.

Seems this company's trick that makes it a tiny bit different is they have an active heater to heat the compressed air before using it.

3

u/SilentRunning Jun 18 '12

The old man in the video engineered F1 racing engines. They also use compressed air to start the motors.

MDI

1

u/pi_over_3 Jun 19 '12

Helicopters, airplanes, and even M1A1 tanks run on air ... they just have a turbine engine heating it up first.

3

u/new-socks Jun 18 '12

It runs on water, man.

3

u/DaSasquatch Jun 18 '12

Is it just me or are all these futuristic type cars always fugly?

5

u/errandum Jun 18 '12

If the dates on the website are correct, this was news back in 2010. And I have yet to see an AirPod going around.

Cool, but I guess it didn't stick...

4

u/somequickresponse Jun 18 '12

This "news" keeps being brought out every 6mo. They've been around for years and always with a promise that they're about to go into production...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/hyperspeed14 Jun 17 '12

Some people could find this a huge leap from fossil fuels, but hey didn't they say that about electric cars too? In the late, late nineteenth century electric cars were first built commercially in the United States. A hundred years later you can barely pick out a handful of electric cars out of the hundreds zooming by every minute on America's highways. A car that runs on air is a diversion to the reality that to create that compressed air, electricity must be created. The air-powered piston revolution won't make its impact until oil reserves are sucked dry and we have no fuel to burn.

2

u/Dreamtrain Jun 18 '12

Was gonna say in before Scumbag Apple sues because the name conflicts with one of their products, but then noticed this thing still has ways to go

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

This reminds me of That 70's Show. "So I saw this car... that runs... on water!" "Was it a boat?" "No, it was a car. But it ran. ON WATER!" "So it was just a boat?" "NO IT WAS A CAR THAT RUNS ON WATER!"

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Wind-up car

2

u/formation Jun 18 '12

Can someone explain something to me.

By reading peoples comments saying that electric cars leave the same footprint, how is this true? Isn't it harder to dispose of batteries rather than a canister of air?

I know it requires energy to compress the air.

The compression time is very short, making it easy and quick to fill.

On a electric it takes many hours to charge, usually over night. But you get greater range and a much cooler looking car.

Not really sure how they could integrate this into 4x4's or something thats not so small. This wouldn't go down well in my country.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

The compression time is very short, making it easy and quick to fill.

Wrong. Compressing things to high pressures actually takes a relatively long time. One issue is the heat that is generated when a gas is compressed, this can cause tanks to become too hot which leads to other issues. This is why SCUBA tanks are filled quite slowly.

Anyway, compressors are horrendously inefficient machines. Regardless of what energy source powers the compressor, most of it will be completely wasted. This isn't a "minor issue" air compressors are quite literally the least efficient machines on the face of this planet.

1

u/formation Jun 18 '12

Thanks for the more technical reply, so there's still chances for explosions?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Also you don't have to replace the canister every 3 years as you have to with batteries..

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Though, you'll still have to send them in for periodic hydrostatic testing (still a heck of a lot cheaper).

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

It's a matter of trade-offs. You'd have to pick the best solution for the application at hand.

A vehicle running off of compressed air will be less efficient than an electric vehicle. Compressing a gas (air) creates an enormous amount of heat (Boyle's law) that must be dissipated. That's wasted energy. When running, the air will cool as it expands, leaving you with less energy from the compressed air. This proposed system includes an air heater, thus using more energy. Storing a significant amount of compressed air is another challenge so, you'll have less range than an electric.

The primary benefits, the gas cylinders can be refilled in a few minutes as compared to hours of charging (as you mentioned). It would be much cheaper to produce than an electric vehicle, and should weigh significantly less. With some smart engineering, regenerative braking should be possible.

It could be good for an inter-city delivery vehicle, taxi, or short to moderate distance commuter car. But, I don't think it's a good replacement for the family car.

2

u/BaconKlan Jun 18 '12

Why is it ugly?

2

u/jazz_fashions Jun 18 '12

You know why gasoline continues to dominate?

Because all cars running on alternate energy are ugly as sin.

2

u/moonsetmagic Jun 18 '12

CNN's tag line says the car runs on thin air. If it's compressed, wouldn't that be thick air?

2

u/Danog123 Jun 18 '12

I would get so much pussy cruising around in that thing.

2

u/Mikesapien Jun 18 '12

car that runs on air.

False. The AirPod runs on compressed air. The air is compressed by electricity. Electricity comes from coal-burning and natural gas power plants which produce emissions. If everyone was driving the AirPod, electricity usage would rise as would emissions. Essentially, this car is still powered by carbon-emitting fossil fuel.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: let's go nuclear.

2

u/clonn Jun 18 '12

I can imagine all the US-Americans redditors finally using their conversion apps to understand this.

2

u/brainflakes Jun 18 '12

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

They'll adress those issues, I'm sure.

2

u/OtherSneakierAccount Jun 18 '12

Won't its front-opening door make parallel parking impossible?

2

u/ShadowRam Jun 18 '12

Compressed air will never go anywhere.

It's not energy dense enough.

It's wasteful.

It won't work well in all climates. (rapid cooling while expanding)

You can't 'recharge' it quickly. It will heat up very fast.

You can't control it easily. It's compressible, unpredictable, Hose/fittings/values all are expensive and heavy for high pressures.

Just a stupid idea.

2

u/beckettman Jun 18 '12

I was reading about Tata motor's work on compressed air vehicles a few years ago. I still don't think it is going to work. They had vehicles with a range of 7-8 km and had projections that they would be able to get ten times that range from calculations based on unicorn farts.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Compressed air will never go anywhere.

FYI, compressed air vehicles are currently being used in India and China for taxis and deliveries.

It's not energy dense enough.

Compared to a family car, absolutely true

It's wasteful.

Very much so, especially compared to the alternatives.

It won't work well in all climates. (rapid cooling while expanding)

Well, this is a case of using the right solution for an application. Not all cars work in all environments and not all of them need to.

You can't 'recharge' it quickly. It will heat up very fast.

It's faster than charging a battery. If you "charge" it from a tank that's already compressed, this is much less of an issue (heat has already been dealt with). If you are pumping directly into the vehicle's tank, then you'll need a big radiator to deal with the heat. This get's back to the wasteful part.

Hoses, fittings, etc are a solved problem.

Just a stupid idea

It depends. If you are trying to replace the general purpose soccer mom family car, then it's clearly a bad choice. If you are trying to replace fume belching 2-cycle taxis in Shanghai, the technology is clearly a better option because it's price equivalent.

1

u/ShadowRam Jun 18 '12

FYI, you still do work on the tank your filling with a cooled down high pressure source, meaning you still create a ton of heat.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wellscounty Jun 18 '12

have they not seen the Top Gear episode with the three wheel car that Jeremy crashes every turn?

1

u/ElagabalusCaesar Jun 18 '12

These people took Jeremy's Reliant Robin and made it even less reliable? Brilliant!

1

u/wellscounty Jun 18 '12

if they promised it wouldn't work, at least it would be safer!

3

u/yeoman_flirt Jun 18 '12

1

u/lexicon1909 Jun 18 '12

I came here hoping to see someone link to this video. I was not disappointed.

4

u/averad Jun 18 '12

This car blows

2

u/Dreamtrain Jun 18 '12

zing!

4

u/averad Jun 18 '12

It's more of a pfffffffft...

→ More replies (2)

2

u/roadsiderick Jun 18 '12

Impressive idea. But how safe would it be in a collision?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

As safe as walking.

13

u/Isvara Jun 18 '12

As safe as walking with a canister of compressed air.

5

u/bangupjobasusual Jun 18 '12

As safe as walking at 30 mph with a gigantic canister of air under the highest pressure they can fit inside of it.

I have safety concerns too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/errandum Jun 18 '12

Quite sure it'd be safer than a motorbike.

If you're talking about the tank, well, just watch the mytbusters episodes on compressed water. heaters to see how hard it is to get one of those to fail... And even at extremely high pressure values, unless the force is directed, I don't think it'll be that destructive - You might just get the ride of your life for a second or two though.

2

u/crusoe Jun 18 '12

If you break the valve stem off a bottle, the bottle becomes a rocket. The valve stem is the safety system, and they have been knocked off of gas cylinders before.

2

u/Fourdrinier Jun 18 '12

Someone else pointed out that the standard for vehicles is around 4500psi. Your standard air compressor is only around 200-400psi. At this kind of pressure, water heaters are equivalent to popping bubble wrap with a .30-06. With the right kind of force, this tank could become a shrapnel bomb of immense magnitude.

Of note, the Mythbuster's Episode proved that the tank would launch like a rocket when it far surpassed it's pressure threshold.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I wouldn't buy one of these specifically, but this is extremely promising.

2

u/M0b1u5 Jun 18 '12

AirPod, a car that runs on air pure, concentrated stupidity.

Fixed your inaccurate title under reddit protocol Orange 11.

Here's why.

Any vehicle with three wheels is retarded unless the single wheel is at the back.

Any vehicle with a joystick, is capable of having the controls moved from full-left-to-full right almost instantly. Unlike a steering wheel, where you must move the wheel through an easily controlled amount of distance (and time), the joystick allows instantaneous fuck-ups.

Anyone who has ever tried to use a joystick to control a racing car game knows this is a fact. Yes, you can use a joystick to control a car, but it is a remarkably stupid way to do it.

We can discount the entire vehicle because of its obvious and severe design flaws. The design means the rest of it is also conceived by idiots, and if you wanted a sure fire way to hurt yourself, or lose money, then buy one of the things, or invest in the company.

1

u/thordsvin Jun 18 '12

Any vehicle with three wheels is retarded unless the single wheel is at the back.

I disagree, Three wheels are awesome.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

The full-on left right can be managed in software. See: early 90's Saab 9000 (with joystick steering).

1

u/RandomThoughtsGuy Jun 18 '12

I remember reading up on this a while ago. You see this tech has been around for the last 20 years. There is also a problem with long distances. There is definitely potential for it to become a simple personal city/town transport system. But apart from moving people around it cannot do much with heavy loads over long distances.

At least that is what my conclusion was. But I still wouldn't mind these things getting popular within cities.

1

u/jay_the_vast Jun 18 '12

150 kilometers = 93.2056788 miles

1

u/KWAD2 Jun 18 '12

The chevy volt can do 300 miles on a single charge and is more spacious.... Ain't lookin too good.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Reuger Jun 18 '12

I accidentally broke my headphones so i Cant listen to the video, but it looks to be like hydrogen powered. Hydrogen energy is clean and the byprouduct is water, so I think this car is a great idea and could help reduce the amount of pollution we put out daily a lot. Some people dont think about it or dont like to, but hybrid cars, when charged, use coal most of the time to produce electricity, which is just as bad if not worse than gasoline. The car seems like it would be much more stable and more versatile if it had 4 wheels. A sleek design would benefit as well.

1

u/SoundOfDrums Jun 18 '12

How much does it cost to run in terms of the electricity used to compress the air?

2

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

I guess we could do the math based on the pressure and capacity of the tank, waste heat (Boyle's law), efficiency of the compressor motor, and friction loss of the compressor.

I'm too lazy at the moment. Maybe, I'll try to calculate it out when I get home...

1

u/kfriend815 Jun 18 '12

I prefer locomotives that run on us!

1

u/ObligatoryResponse Jun 18 '12

AC would be super cheap. That air is going to be cold leaving the tank, and so you just direct it into the cabin after it exits the engine. Heat would require electricity and cold climates will cut down on the efficiency.

So overall, a bad winter car, but should be great for summer.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Problem is, in the summer you need to dissipate the heat of compressing the tanks....

1

u/ObligatoryResponse Jun 19 '12

Compressing happens outside the car in the compresser, right? Or would the tank in the car heat up as you fill it from the larger tank at the station?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CostaRicanConnection Jun 18 '12

TBH, until they develop an engine that can exceed 50 mph, I don't see it being a huge success in the US.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

This is meant as an urban car. How often do you go over 50mph in NYC, for example?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cive666 Jun 18 '12

These look like the cars from Idiocracy.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I feel like a stipulation for making a car that doesn't run on gas, is that it must look stupid. They'd have a lot more consumer appeal if it wasn't ridiculously shaped. But, I don't know, it might be like that so it can operate.

Also, I'm aware they would change it later, and this is a prototype.

1

u/Llikregit Jun 18 '12

A prototype (at least I'm assuming it's not a working model) of this car has been sitting in the Miami Science Museum for a few years. Pass it all the time on my way to their wildlife center.

1

u/delitt Jun 18 '12

Ok Reddit. Tell me why this wont work.

1

u/Guysmiley777 Jun 18 '12

The volumetric energy density (the amount of energy per unit of volume) of compressed air is laughably bad compared to liquid petrochemicals. The reason this is a problem is because of how little range you'd get out of a standard sized "fuel" tank, or alternatively how impractically gigantic that tank would have to be to get the same amount of range as a gasoline fuel tank.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Well it would be great for Europe, just not north america

1

u/delitt Jun 18 '12

A question? What is the bet option/idea on the market right now?

1

u/Noggin_Floggin Jun 18 '12

Then you hit the average pothole and the front wheel disappears and you're stuck

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Just watching that thing drive around the parking lot, you would not think those suckers can hit 80 km/h

→ More replies (1)

1

u/chuckles2011 Jun 18 '12

This story is from October 2010. So, there has been enough time for these vehicles to be developed and I'm sure they are a commercial success right now.

Let's all rush down to the dealer showroom and buy one.

So much for CNN breaking news.

1

u/Vranak Jun 18 '12

It's all very well to power the car with air compressed by electricity coming from a wind turbine, but I wonder how much fossil fuel is typically used to make wind turbines to begin with. To drive out the parts to a hill and to install them. The buck has to stop somewhere.

2

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Probably 99.9% of the energy is in creating the turbines. Aluminum requires a huge amount of energy to extract from ore. This is why the majority of aluminum plants are located near hydro-electric plants.

If composites are used, as in most modern turbines, the resins are basically petroleum products. There's also the cost of producing magnets, copper winding, etc..

With that in mind, the average turbine should recoup that energy expense within the first month or two of operation. It's good that you bring up the point, we should always look at these things with an end to end perspective. Just in this case, it's not really a big deal.

1

u/maintenacemanJ Jun 18 '12

Put the AirPod system on a motorcycle or moped frame, and sell it in the United States.

1

u/football2106 Jun 18 '12

Why can't they make a car that runs off the kinetic energy made by the tires rotating? And you just need a little bit of gas/electricity to get them moving again once they've stopped.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

There is very little energy in the rotating wheels. OTOH, the momentum of the moving vehicle contains a huge amount of energy. Thus a thing called regenerative braking. It is implemented in the majority of hybrid vehicles on the market.

So, great idea but, you're 20 years behind the times ;-)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I find it ironic that there was an add for a "fuel efficient" car before the video.

1

u/TotalChuck Jun 18 '12

For fuel economy this car is amazing. They don't realize that their silly futuristic designs will be the downfall of this tech. Not to mention the seats are arranged in a way so that the driver can't communicate with the passengers comfortably. This fuel tech is also ignoring "petrol heads" or, people that enjoy top gear and love fast loud awesome cars. Unless they can find a way to push this fuel to produce more than 80k/h, they will only have a marketable vehicle for hipsters and environmentalists. I personally am not pulled to buy the car simply because its slow and silly looking, so they are losing a huge market, average male drivers ages 16-25 who love to go fast and look cool. Also, I didn't see a single safety feature and the car itself looks fragile and has nothing but a thin piece of whatever material they use to construct the car in between you and another car.

1

u/Brians13 Jun 18 '12

My auto-mechanics teacher would tell me that energy efficient cars pollute more when they are being made than a gasoline engine car would in its lifetime.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

It depends. A pneumatic engine doesn't require any more energy to make than an ICE. Since it's much simpler, it should actually require less. Though, your mechanics teacher is referring specifically to the batteries in electric powered vehicles.

OTOH, with the massive amount of waste heat created compressing air, it's possible it might use more energy in use than an ICE. I'd have to do the math. If you happened to live in an area where the majority of your power came from wind/solar/etc, then it would obviously be less.

TL;DR, it depends...

1

u/tregart Jun 18 '12

I have the best idea for an improved version of this. I think I may have just figured out how I'm getting rich....

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Oh hey, it's that Negre Guy!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Why do "Eco" cars always have to look stupid?

1

u/wolfthewhoozzy Jun 18 '12

um...it takes other energy to compress the air....

1

u/Cortexion Jun 18 '12

Needs an air-cooled, fiberglass engine that runs on water, man!

But yeah, saying this thing doesn't pollute is like saying an electric car doesn't pollute... you've just moved the polluting mechanism to some secondary producer that's not IN the car.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I love the premise - but they need to make it look cool with a fancy dash, not like a stupid geo.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

It looks unappealing.

1

u/_I_am_here Jun 18 '12

Cool. Why does it have to look like that?

1

u/qosmith Jun 18 '12

I looked at that car for one second and closed the video.

1

u/AntiSoap Jun 18 '12

Watch out for the oil company.

1

u/XcelentTom Jun 18 '12

Apple will probably sue this guy for the coincidence that there is an R present inbitween the I and P.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

If this was promising, the warehousing and factory industry would have widely adopted it already.

1

u/batrobin Jun 18 '12

Hey, it runs on the ground!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I'm sitting here in my quiet apartment at 12:15AM. I click on this link...

LOUDEST AD EVER

I damn near had a heart attack.

1

u/butterbunz Jun 18 '12

If only it didn't look incredibly stupid....

1

u/ZombieRaptorJebus Jun 18 '12

came here to say that

1

u/godofwar7018 Jun 18 '12

It's a 3 wheeled wheelchair with a roof and windows

1

u/pebble1986 Jun 18 '12

This is an example why an engineer, or developer shouldn't design.

1

u/TardMuffins Jun 18 '12

Oil Business is probably racing to kill that.

1

u/jamesbiff Jun 18 '12

Im not well read enough on this kind of tech to comment on the intricacies or practicality of said tech, but ive always seen a major problem with all green energy:

Oil. Whilst oil is so damned expensive/profitable, i find it highly unlikely that any Oil tycoon or politician for that matter will gladly give up the billions they make from oil for clean renewable energy that sometimes can be cultivated in your own back yard. Being self reliant is something they do not want. I dont know, its just the pessimist in me i think. This tech is for the good of humanity, and i just dont think the people who can properly kickstart it have the good of humanity in their list of priorities.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Worthless. Two words: crash test.

If we could replace 90% of the worlds cars with dinky little things like these (not necessarily air powered, just tiny and very fuel efficient) it would cut our emissions tremendously, but until the other giant cars are off the road, nobody will want to drive one.

1

u/explosivechiliring Jun 18 '12

sooo... what powers the compressor that refills your tank? stupidity. noone seems to think about shit like that. This applies to virtualy all forms of alternative fuels. except naturaly occuring things such as wind and solar.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Couldn't they have made it not look retarded? I'm pretty sure this is part of the reason these innovations don't get taken seriously by the public.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Too bad it wouldn't be very safe on a highway.. I would love to have something like that and be able to travel back home for a visit for only $3. With the price of gas these days, to travel 300km to visit my family it costs me $50...

1

u/ddes3 Jun 18 '12

Buy a bicycle...

2

u/MrStrings2006 Jun 18 '12

"Ya know a lot of people ride bikes!"

"Yeah, when they're fuckin' six."

1

u/trumpet Jun 18 '12

Hmm. Their news feed on their site looks real professional: http://www.mdi.lu/english/actualite.php

(Second one down: "THE PRESS REALESES PUT OUT BY Mr SAMBUC OF CATECAR AND WANTON STATEMENTS MADE BY HIM ARE PATHETICALLY FEEBLE DISTORTIONS AND LIES." Nice.)

1

u/Skeeteacus Jun 18 '12

Was I the only one who thought that this was you g to be an apple product.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Sigh. If an article does not state:

  1. Specific energy (energy stored per unit mass)

  2. Energy density (energy stored per unit volume)

then it is hype and bullshit. Without those numbers it is impossible to compare to the current state of the art (Lithium ion batteries).

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Why would we need them to provide numbers that the average high-school kid can calculate with the 'ideal gas law' ? What we just need the volume and pressure of the tank.

However, that's still useless. It only tells us the amount of energy stored. Putting that energy to work is another matter entirely. To compare to a Lithium Ion electric car, we need to know the efficiency of the pneumatic engine (modern electric motors can do better than 90% efficiency) and how well the heat-exchanger (for the cooling decompressed gas) works, and whether or not the pneumatic engine is performing double-duty for regenerative braking.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
  1. I intended the principle to apply to all "super duper energy breakthrough" articles.

  2. Because I don't feel like doing the calculations myself, it would take me a considerable amount of brushing up, and there are many who wouldn't be able to do it at all.

  3. True, you need to know the efficiency too, but if you know the specific energy is already lower than chemical electric batteries, then the efficiency is irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Dpaterso Jun 18 '12

A 3 wheeled car eh? heard those never roll over:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQh56geU0X8

1

u/avoutthere Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I want to see someone run one of these up to 80 km/h and then jam the joystick sideways. No seatbelts, no bumpers...oy.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Am I the only one who sees a new Reliant Robin when I look at it?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
  1. Compressed-air cars are gaining popularity in India already.

  2. A door on the front? Many concept cars, ZERO production cars.

  3. Three wheels, fine. But this configuration has long proven to be unstable. Should be two in the front, one in the back.

  4. Looks like a death trap to me. Although that is a problem with tiny cars in general

Still hope it takes off - we need alternative tech badly.

1

u/nomagneticmonopoles Jun 19 '12

Well you won't be going very fast in it, so it might not be as dangerous as you think.

1

u/NoblePotatoe Jun 18 '12

So, what makes this car unique is that they added an external heat source to your typical stored compressed air vehicle. Because of this the vehicle can run at pressure ratios (compression ratios) that are 33 times greater then your typical car and 10 times greater then your typical diesel engine.

The compression ratio has a large effect on the efficiency of an engine. Combine this with the fact that you can burn practically anything to provide the heat since it is an external combustion engine and there is the potential for a very efficient and environmentally friendly vehicle.

Sorry to geek out, but I have been waiting years for someone to try this.

1

u/Tebasaki Jun 18 '12

I've been watching these guys for years. MDI Ent I would love to believe it can got from LA to NY in one tank of gas (900+ mpg), but I'd have to drive it to believe it.

1

u/xenon5 Jun 19 '12

Nice idea, but that's one fugly car.

1

u/harhis84 Jun 19 '12

lol The first time I saw a car like this was when I was watching the series, Mr. Bean (Rowan Atkinson). I was even thinking such 3-wheeled car was built just for the show.

The video has proven me otherwise.

1

u/FastLikeTurtles Jun 19 '12

Insteresting.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Is this idiot still really trying to sell these things as an alternative fuel source car? Airhogs would like a word with you.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Why do people buy into this crap? Yeah, the CAR doesn't have any emissions and 'runs on air' but guess what? You still need energy to compress the air in the first place. The compressor probably runs on electricity, which you probably get from a coal fire energy plant. The carbon footprint remains the same. It's the same fallacy as electric cars.

6

u/sdavid1726 Jun 18 '12

Coal power plants are far more efficient than internal combustion engines.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/ineptjedibob Jun 18 '12

See my post a couple comments down. Efficiency is getting close to maximum, but even in '08 it was a damn sight better than internal combustion.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kill_Ian Jun 18 '12

I come to this link interested, and the moment I click on it I say "It better not look abnormal or retarded"

Guess what.... It looks abnormal and retarded.

1

u/Kilagria Jun 18 '12

Airpod : Another vehicle that will become extinct due to greedy corps.

1

u/persian_mamba Jun 18 '12

I can't wait until the oil companies buy the idea form them and it vanishes from the public

/sarcasm

1

u/ExplicitlyExplicit Jun 18 '12

Its only a matter of time before this begins to be illegal in the U.S.

1

u/available_nickname Jun 18 '12

The commentator said air-powered vehicles were never a success. She forgot to say why. It's because oil lobbies do everything so it doesnt happen.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

I'm afraid the laws of physics trump the conspiracy theories.

It's all about energy. Compressed air contains a finite amount of energy. The amount of energy is based on the pressure and volume of your storage tanks. The pressure is limited by the state of the art in materials science.

As air is used, compression released, it cools. When the temperature of a gas is reduced, the pressure drops correspondingly (ref: high-school science). Less pressure == less energy.

The combination of these things greatly limits the range.

Worse is the case of compressing the air. It creates a huge amount of waste heat (aka wasted energy).

With all those issues, there are still a number of niches where these are useful. Air powered vehicles are used in both India and China for taxis and deliveries.

1

u/gamerlen Jun 18 '12

Interesting, I wonder how long it'll be until some oil company kills the production stone dead.

1

u/MrStrings2006 Jun 18 '12

Yeah it's only a matter of time before he either retires with millions of dollars in his bank account that comes out of nowhere, or he goes mysteriously missing never to be seen again.

1

u/gamerlen Jun 18 '12

Its what happens to anyone else who makes a car that can potentially run without oil.

1

u/willcode4beer Jun 18 '12

Like the oil companies did in China and India? Oh wait, they didn't. Air powered taxis and delivery vehicles are being used in both countries. The number of them is growing daily.

0

u/dre10g Jun 18 '12

30 second commercial.. pass

1

u/warbAU Jun 18 '12

30 sec?, mine was 1m 40sec..