r/technology • • Jun 16 '12

Linus to Nvidia - "Fuck You"

http://youtu.be/MShbP3OpASA?t=49m45s
2.4k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

164

u/GrognakTheBarbarian Jun 16 '12

I'm surprised to hear this. Back a couple of years ago when I used Ubuntu, I always heard that Nvidia drivers worked much better then ATI's.

106

u/madeinchina Jun 17 '12

Not anymore. Nvidia still doesn't support Optimus in drivers for Linux, and support for slightly older drivers (300M series on last years macbook pros for example) is nonexistent. This isn't normally a problem because open source developers maintain older hardware, but Nvidia is the least helpful.

25

u/unfashionable_suburb Jun 17 '12

As an accidental user of a laptop with Optimus, I still find it hard to believe that they're not even planning to support Linux.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/rellikiox Jun 17 '12

Nvidia still doesn't support Optimus in drivers for Linux

I found out about that the hard way... at least I have Bumblebee!

33

u/Omnicrola Jun 17 '12

Bumblebee Project link for those who are unaware. Optimus in Linux.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/keithjr Jun 17 '12

This is the first I've heard of it. How is this working out for you, performance- and battery-wise?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

231

u/botle Jun 17 '12

Yes, Nvidia's binary blob was much better then ATI's, and probably still is, but Nvidia refuses to release any specs or help to develop free drivers.

193

u/MrDoomBringer Jun 17 '12

Let's get it a little more straight here.

NVidia releases, for free use with their cards, a set of Linux drivers. That they will not release open source drivers or information is their choice/folly to make. The fact remains that they at least make an effort at it, and their drivers are generally pretty useable.

Meanwhile, AMD's driver support is present but laughable at best. The FOSS drivers are similarly so. Take what you will from this but I don't have qualms with NVidia wanting to keep their proprietary technology under wraps.

101

u/flukshun Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

AMD's driver support is present but laughable at best

AMD's drivers are plug and play as far as display management goes, since it supports xrandr 1.2+ just like intel and every open source driver, which is 90% of the use-cases people care about.

But that only matters for the users who even bother to install proprietary drivers. Due to AMD releasing their specs, the open source radeon driver is pretty stable.

I do applaud Nvidia for finally adding xrandr 1.2+ in their just-released drivers, however. It's enough to make me consider them again for use with linux.

NVidia releases, for free use with their cards, a set of Linux drivers. That they will not release open source drivers or information is their choice/folly to make.

Let's get this a little more straight. Nvidia releases, for free use with their cards, such as the uber-expensive Quadro workstation and Tesla GPGPU variety, which are often used in conjunction with linux and thus mandate some level of driver support from nvidia, a set of linux drivers that lack features that a small group who reverse-engineered their specs were able to work into the open source, mostly stable noveau driver on their own free time.

It's not just a bad decision from an ideological standpoint, it's just plain bad business when so much could be leveraged with only just a little more openness regarding your hardware specs. And having the linux kernel maintainer flip you off because you fucked up your relationship with the open source community, during a time when you recently started flooding LKML with patches to add support for the Tegra platform that your company's future is riding on, is testament to that.

Not that Linus or whatever submaintainer wouldn't accept those contributions if they were deemed ready because they don't "like" Nvidia, but it could be the difference between someone taking the time to work with you and lay out a plan for you to get your stuff upstream, or simply telling you your patches suck. And that can be worth months and months of development time.

→ More replies (20)

52

u/lahwran_ Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

NVidia wanting to keep their proprietary technology under wraps.

Yeah, in the case of graphics drivers, no kidding. there's some really crazy stuff in there, such as the shader compiler and implementation of the fixed-function pipeline (both of which are software). That's the kind of shit they put serious R&D money into, and I can see why they'd want to keep it from competitors. Whether that's actually a good thing is up for debate, though.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/Dark_Shroud Jun 17 '12

ATI/AMD gave tons of documentation to the FOSS community on their hardware drivers. So the community has been slowly making things better for AMD. Nvidia hasn't done much in recent years besides talk a big game and under deliver in most areas.

43

u/yiliu Jun 17 '12

ATI's gotten much better.

NVidia's driver was generally much better--that is to say, the resulting graphics were smoother and better. The process of setting it up was a nightmare, because it's a binary blob compiled for a specific kernel.

Generally, NVidia is one of the only major hardware companies around that has done nothing to create or help to create open-source drivers.

7

u/cibyr Jun 17 '12

Actually the process of setting up ATi drivers is much more painful than for NVidia. ATi's drivers actually are distributed as a binary blob complied for a specific kernel (and you're shit out of luck if they haven't built it for your kernel). NVidia's driver is a binary blob that interfaces with an open-source stub (distributed with the driver) which you can compile for whatever kernel you want.

The whole optimus thing really sucks though, and as far as I can tell it's impossible to buy a quad-core laptop without it (or ATi's equally horrible version).

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (13)

30

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

The nvidia drivers are full of so many bugs at the moment... Ati has much better opensource drivers.

12

u/TLUL Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

It's interesting to hear about this change. On the laptops I've compared with (a few years old now), ATI cards were useless on Linux, but Nvidia cards worked flawlessly. The computer I'm using right now has an ATI card and can barely play video on Linux, but runs most games on max graphics settings without a hitch on Windows.

Edit: clarified last sentence

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Im_100percent_human Jun 17 '12

I disagree.... the ATI drivers are still a pile of crap.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

That's sad, because the ATI opensource drivers are still garbage. Trying playing a game with them. Trine 2 just looks like a bunch of jumbled shapes.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/GAndroid Jun 17 '12

Ati doesn't even work on kernel 3.2 and above.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

This 'Fuck you' wasn't about quality it was about ethics. :)

→ More replies (11)

230

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

This is why I like Linus/Linux. He's not scared to say fuck you to a big corporate entity.

224

u/madeinchina Jun 17 '12

Probably because he and his work (linux) is more important than just one big corporate entity. Nvidia should be ashamed.

149

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

nVidia should be ashamed. They're basically marrying themselves to the Windows environment and proprietary software. Call me one of those crazy OSS guys but that paradigm isn't long for this world. With the prominence of Linux growing on mobile devices that will be expected to have good graphics hardware, they're cutting themselves out of a very large market. Their loss. Fuck nVidia.

163

u/candyman420 Jun 17 '12

Yeah man, linux is really gonna catch on in the mainstream for real this year.

-1998

→ More replies (118)

22

u/always_sharts Jun 17 '12

I agree man. Anyone who uses linux past beginner stuff has had to deal with graphics drivers, its really a pain.

→ More replies (74)
→ More replies (20)

10

u/achacha Jun 17 '12

This is the perfect time for AMD to become an important player in the Linux world by shipping super stable drivers(current ones are ok, but have trouble with multimonitor setup).

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

He actually explains a few questions prior in the view how philosophy towards being blunt and honest. The whole video is really, really interesting.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

It's way easier to publicly swear in your non native language. There's no cultural background behind the words when you say them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

526

u/sirbruce Jun 17 '12

One minute later: "I wish everyone was as nice as I am."

168

u/hatperigee Jun 17 '12

That was just the icing.

→ More replies (119)

197

u/H5Mind Jun 16 '12

That came across as heartfelt and sincere. Given Android's market share, as Linus pointed out, I wonder what has been going on at nVidia HQ to prepare for the near future?

274

u/adrianmonk Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

He's not saying they aren't participating in the Android world. On the contrary, they make the Tegra chips which are used in many Android phones (such as the new HTC One X).

He's saying that despite being happy to benefit from the sales of Linux (in the form of Android), they don't cooperative with the Linux community. He's saying they're willing to take (enjoy making money selling ARM chips for Linux-based Android phones) but not willing to give (by providing hardware documentation that developers could use to make open-source drivers instead of reverse-engineering everything).

17

u/smellybottom Jun 17 '12

Well, since you put it like that... Fuck you Nvidia!

26

u/rockmongoose Jun 17 '12

Honest question here - would that make any sense for nvidia from a business standpoint ? I mean, it's nice to make the small linux community all fuzzy and warm inside by releasing the documentation you mentioned, but as a business, what would they have to gain (especially in the long run)?

34

u/adrianmonk Jun 17 '12

Well, they might gain a better reputation among Linux users and/or people in the computer industry. It's good PR to cooperate with the community.

They might also get people to do part of the work of writing and maintaining the drivers for them if they were open enough that such a project were something people could enjoy contributing to. That could allow them to sell to the Linux market with less overhead, maybe even to an occasional BSD user.

And it might have an effect on morale and recruitment in their engineering department. Computer nerds tend to like Linux, and if they felt their employer or potential employer were something of a good citizen, they might be a little more likely to stay at nVidia or a little more likely to join the company.

Of course, that has to be balanced against whatever risk they think there is to releasing the documentation. Although that's nVidia's judgement call, I can't imagine the risk is that large, particularly if they decide to, say, wait 3 to 6 months before releasing it to lessen any effects of releasing information their competitors could benefit from.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/datenwolf Jun 17 '12

would that make any sense for nvidia from a business standpoint?

Yes! NVidia makes hardware. That's their key competence, and they're very good at it. Hardware is, what NVidia sells. Everything that makes their hardware more attractive to the customer means potentially more sales.

NVidia does not make money selling their drivers – if you'd have to pay for each and every driver update, people would go up the walls. So any independently developed driver, that just broadens the potential market for a given piece of hardware, just adds to sales.

Also take note, that developers are not asking to make their drivers open source, but to just to publish documentation required to write a driver from scratch. Actually AMD/ATI is doing this in their OpenGPU initiative, and it did no harm to their sales.

→ More replies (6)

39

u/merreborn Jun 17 '12

I mean, it's nice to make the small linux community all fuzzy and warm inside

"small"? Android is linux-based. There are hundreds of millions of android devices out there.

The development community is small, yes. The number of people using linux-derived devices is not.

Linux is making a lot of people millions of dollars right now.

→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (8)

121

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Windows 8

→ More replies (447)

43

u/huhmz Jun 17 '12

Those of us who use the LG 2X with CM9 this statement is just as current as it ever has been. Nvidia refuses to release drivers to their Tegra 2 chipset and LG's software department is also a fucking joke.

2

u/wildcarde815 Jun 17 '12

Same with the Motorola atrix 4G :(

→ More replies (10)

1.2k

u/Drunkensailorxx Jun 17 '12

"I like offending people because I think people who get offended should be offended"

I'm stealing that quote

234

u/exteras Jun 17 '12

I love the line from one of the girls who asked a question, concerning Nvidia's reluctance to do anything to help Optimus support on Linux.

"We're playing in the same sandbox. Why can't we just be nice to one another?"

164

u/Hyperian Jun 17 '12

because money, that's why.

99

u/kcsj0 Jun 17 '12

It's always because money. :(

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (14)

5

u/yawaworht_suoivbo_na Jun 17 '12

Actually, it's because X is too old and inflexible to efficiently support multiple devices rendering to the same display. The current 'solutions' all involve multiple X servers (one for the NVIDIA gpu, one for the Intel integrated gpu) trying to share framebuffer data, which results in piss-poor performance.

Like ALMOST ALL graphics issues in Linux, the problem is related to X. Unless the Linux community gets around to replacing it with Wayland, they'll be stuck with second-rate graphics support.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/jumaklavita Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

1:00:30 "if you make that video available on the internet there will be thousands of people who will get really upset"

→ More replies (3)

65

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

21

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I get all my opinions from stand-up comedians too.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (4)

72

u/-kilo Jun 17 '12

I hope there was more context to that line, because it just sounds juvenile. "Haha! I offended you!" Being apologetic or indifferent to offending someone is one thing, but taking joy from it?

24

u/tidux Jun 17 '12

It was the finishing touch to a rant about how nvidia is making all these GPU cores and ARM/GPU SoCs specifically for Android, but they were still being cunts to the Linux software ecosystem.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

A "rant" which covered less than 2 minutes of a one hour and three minute long video, in case anyone didn't watch it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Indifference is worse. Psychopaths are indifferent enjoyment just makes you an ass.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

18

u/Notyourfaja Jun 17 '12

Marvelous. Now wait one day and karmawhore it to the rest of reddit.

13

u/skizmo Jun 17 '12

I'm stealing that quote

You want to become an asshole like Linus ?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I AM OFFENDED THAT YOU ARE OFFENDED

35

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

"I like offending people because I think people who get offended should be offended"

What a specious comment.

'Hey n_____ get your n_____ ass back to the ghetto'

'Hey you dumb cripple kid, your mum's a whore'

So if I throw out these insults and the recipients find them offensive I should like that? They should be offended? Seems to me it would make me an arsehole.

I think this would need a lot of context if you were to use it.

102

u/mvuijlst Jun 17 '12

Non-US person here.

Honest question: if everyone knows you're really talking about the word "nigger", why disguise it? Why say "the N-word" or even "n_____"?

You're not calling anyone a nigger, kike, wop, chink, or whatever -- you're using the word in a sentence, right?

17

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

non US person here too, so I'm not sure how much offence it causes. I just thought it would show more respect to type it like that, in case some people do find it that offensive (whether rightly or wrongly as I don't know enough about the word to understand the baggage that comes with it).

→ More replies (1)

26

u/1338h4x Jun 17 '12

Sometimes people just want nothing to do with those words, even if it may be okay in context.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

This is reddit. That quote wasn't even given a minute of critical thought before it was endorsed by that guy, and others. Your expectations are too high.

→ More replies (20)

3

u/CollisionCourse34 Jun 17 '12

You like quotes? "Drunk sailors are more common to have sexual relations with the same sex than a drunken fisherman on a 3 week fishing trip" 34 so how do you feel about offending people now?

→ More replies (21)

94

u/MadFerIt Jun 17 '12

Guys this has much more to do with Nvidia's Android position then graphics cards. They are completely unwilling to open-source most of the Tegra series SoC drivers.

8

u/AberrationsOfMan Jun 17 '12

As a guy with a tegra 2 device with very little dev support, I'll say this is quite relevant.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/muldoonx9 Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

Might this have anything to do with those awful software patents? If they don't show their source code, nobody can sue for patent infringement. I think something similar happened when they open sourced one of the Quakes recently.

Edit: It was Doom 3, not quake: http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20111117/11422216807/potential-patent-infringement-threatens-to-doom-highly-anticipated-open-source-project.shtml

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Probably because they don't want to just give away their 5 billion dollar project.......

20

u/nauzleon Jun 17 '12

Release an opensource driver will not give away your hardware engineering at all.

19

u/nomeme Jun 17 '12

And people will write drivers for you, for free.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/smellybottom Jun 17 '12

then graphic cards what?

→ More replies (3)

136

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Linus is going to be a great grumpy old man.

14

u/1338h4x Jun 17 '12

Going to be?

14

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

He's not that old if that was what you were implying.

3

u/CUNTBERT_RAPINGTON Jun 17 '12

He's 42 years old.

Kinda fascinating, how early a lot of computer pioneers tend to grey over.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (17)

915

u/Nvidia Jun 17 '12

Well fuck you too, Linus.

75

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

The hell? This is the first comment you've made in 2 years. How does that even work. Lurk to the max?

101

u/hiero_ Jun 17 '12

Spoilers, it's a novelty account of an active redditor.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

127

u/Dravorek Jun 17 '12

2 years and 3 months, nice.

20

u/always_sharts Jun 17 '12

Your time to shine has come and you are this far down on the page... sorry man

→ More replies (5)

20

u/dhvl2712 Jun 17 '12

Nvidia probably doesn't give a damn. I mean if they did, Torvalds wouldn't be angry in the first place.

5

u/wallaby1986 Jun 17 '12

Torvalds is angry because Nvidia makes good hardware and doesn't play nice with him. If the hardware wasn't there he wouldn't care. Simple as that.

→ More replies (2)

57

u/pixelpenguin Jun 17 '12

Happens around 49.40 min for those on Mobile.

57

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

those of us on iOS

Ftfy. Android supports links with timestamps

11

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Not entirely surprising given the affiliation between YouTube and Android. Noted though.

8

u/Vaughn Jun 17 '12

Timestamped links aren't exactly complex. If iOS doesn't support it, that's pretty much down to laziness.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/voneahhh Jun 17 '12

Doing God's work, son.

→ More replies (1)

93

u/Keleris Jun 17 '12

What exactly is his problem with Nvidia? I don't have an hour to waste atm.

18

u/WasterDave Jun 17 '12

Nvidia's graphics cards are honkingly big parallel processors and almost nothing else. When you boot an OS with an Nvidia card it sends it a binary that is the program responsible for knowing how to render 3d. Obviously a lot of hugely important intellectual property is embodied in this piece of software. Linus says "how about you tell me how it works so we can write an open source one", Nvidia say "yeah, how about not".

Free software fanboys the world over lose their shit and swear blind they'll never buy an Nvidia card even though theirs is the only one that works at all under Linux. People with money completely fail to give a shit. The world continues to spin.

20

u/thermite451 Jun 17 '12

I'd like to disagree with your reductionism. And raise holy hell about the finer points. But the fact of the matter is I just got 12.04 + xbmc + an E450 AMD APU up and running. Took me about 3 hours to get it to play video without tearing. It's still dodgy with high level h264.

I can build an Atom/Nvidia ION rig in about 30 minutes.

Take it as a given, I'll just stick to the Atom/ION for XBMC from now on. Because I don't give a shit, and I just want it to work.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (32)

33

u/Waterrat Jun 17 '12

I've made that gesture more than once at my Nvidia card..It ignores me.

2

u/Vexin Jun 17 '12

It's not ignoring you, it just plans to set your house on fire the next time you leave your computer unattended.

19

u/HolyLiaison Jun 17 '12

With Steam coming out for Linux soon I could see ATI and Nvidia stepping up their driver games on Linux. Valve putting some weight behind Linux I think more companies in general will start to put out viable Linux drivers.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/h221baker Jun 17 '12

This is making me doubting my decision making, since I am starting my first job at Nvidia android team next month.

5

u/da__ Jun 17 '12

Convince your new bosses to stop being assholes to everyone including themselves. I mean, fuckers developing your drivers!! FOR FREE!!!1 What more could an exec of a computer hardware company want?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/arewenotmen1983 Jun 17 '12

As a Linux user, I think a few honorable mentions are in order:

  1. For completely failing to provide a browser plugin that fucking works, fuck you, Adobe and your Flash.

  2. For your unsolicited middle finger to every linux user on the planet, fuck you, Netflix.

  3. For your unwavering maintenence of the package libraries my OS needs to function, as well as security updates, thank you Canonical.

  4. For your excellent, free and secure browser, thank you Mozilla.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I'll paypal $40 to someone taking a screenshot and posting this on the Nvidia campus ;)

3

u/Peanuts4MePlz Jun 17 '12

I'm interested in seeing the outcome of this.

But not doing it, of course.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/moleofproduction Jun 17 '12

This whole video is worth watching. The Nvidia line is a throwaway.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=MShbP3OpASA#t=3673s

He also says at the end he likes to make outrageous comments.

5

u/happyscrappy Jun 17 '12

But maybe his comment about making outrageous comments is the one designed to be outrageous and the other is normal? ;)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

MORE OPEN SOURCE GAMING!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/rdog25 Jun 17 '12

Linux newb here. Just installed Ubuntu a month ago. Suddenly my HP printer started working wirelessly like magic. Must be a coincidence!

19

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Whenever I know I'll have to plug my computer into a random new printer, I'll boot into Linux. I can't be bothered to download drivers in Windows to just to use a friend's printer.

23

u/chaogenus Jun 17 '12

Long time linux user here.

I had a flatbed scanner on a SCSI port that included some scanning software for Windows 95/98. The software refused to scan the full height of the scanner but included an offer to purchase another software application that would allow you to utilize the full height of the scan bed.

I installed Red Hat Linux 4.2, Gimp, and Xsane. All the features of the flatbed scanner I had purchased were immediately available. Since then I've been sold on linux and open source software.

Windows 8 is near release and I still don't have a copy of Windows 7. I had a Mac Pro G4 Dual CPU MDD to try out OS/X. Sold it when future OS/X updates required I hand over another $200 and never regretted it.

9

u/candyman420 Jun 17 '12

wat? OS X updates are now something like $30.. even cheaper due to download-only. I believe mountain snow will be $20

20

u/chaogenus Jun 17 '12

are now

Updating a G4 was free up to a point, then you had to buy the full OS all over again.

Back then linux upgrades were free.

Today linux upgrades are free.

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/FlopDonker Jun 17 '12

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Me too. Guess what I'm doing right now?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LordAnubis12 Jun 17 '12

Surely if/when Steam start adding more native support to Linux Nvidia will have to pay at least some attention?

3

u/tripdes Jun 17 '12

fsck the establishment!1

9

u/JohnFrum Jun 17 '12

To be fair, Nvidia is a horrible company to deal with for Windows people too. Unprofessional and unhelpful in my experience.

10

u/1338h4x Jun 17 '12

As someone with an Optimus laptop (that Lenovo thankfully forgot to label as having Optimus when I shopped around to specifically avoid this), I wholeheartedly agree. I don't know how anyone can claim they have great Linux support when there's an entire chipset that won't work at all.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/JackDostoevsky Jun 17 '12

Nvidia always tears me in so many directions. On the one hand, they are very, very closed source. On the other hand, they produce binary-blob drivers for Linux that actually work. I haven't used a Radeon in years because of this.

6

u/12_Baconed_Narwhals Jun 17 '12

I was expecting a more subtle, business-like insult or thinly veiled expression of dislike, etc... then he flipped off the camera, and I knew this guy wasn't fucking around. he's honest and doesn't give a damn about being "professional" when he's got some offending to do. and he has my respect for it. we need more people like this guy, unafraid to speak their mind.

4

u/VomitingNinjas Jun 17 '12

Now I have something to do for an hour. Thanks OP.

4

u/franklyimshocked Jun 17 '12

Respect for this man hitting an incredibly high level :)

8

u/mfukar Jun 17 '12

Someone had to say it. Good for him.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I actually like my nvidia EVGA GTX560 2GB video card. :'(

→ More replies (2)

7

u/JerkyChew Jun 17 '12

But, Nvidia's Linux support is really good, at least from a dumb end-user standpoint. All my MythTV DVRs run Nvidia chips.

2

u/Runningflame570 Jun 17 '12

People say this, but it took two years for me to actually get working 3D acceleration with my 7900gs and I built the blasted thing almost a year after it was released.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/zerro_4 Jun 17 '12

I feel like a scrub for asking, as I don't have audio and plugging my headphones in to the computer is not acceptable at work, what is the gist of the video?

8

u/always_sharts Jun 17 '12

Nvidia have been complete shits about releasing hardware specs and releasing drivers for linux. Linus let out some anger

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

This is one wordy mother fucker of a host.

2

u/gottabe22 Jun 17 '12

I watched the entire video up until the fuck you moment to ensure I wouldn't miss it

2

u/KosherNazi Jun 17 '12

Yeesh, Will Cardwell is a terrible host.

2

u/tetzy Jun 17 '12

Sweet Jesus - I thought the introduction would never stop.

2

u/narcissist523 Jun 17 '12

AMEN to this!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

Well he's not a diplomat, but it's refreshing to know what public figures actually thinks. :)

2

u/hilaryyy Jun 17 '12

I understand the bad blood, but why he hasn't dropped the F-Bomb on any number of wireless network adapter manufacturers is beyond me.

3

u/da__ Jun 17 '12

Cos nobody asked.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/atypic Jun 17 '12

I am in awe about the sheer number of people here who have no idea about what they are talking about. The girl who poses the question explicitly states that what she does not like is the optimus-tech, yet none of you people here seem to grasp what that even is and take the opportunity to either bash on or defend nVidia. It's not even an issue about open source or not, it's just that nvidia refuses to even attempt to support this in their graphic drivers, citing some rather work-aroundable limitations with Xorg.

2

u/bodyglove Jun 17 '12

At the end, that guy Juha, is he a developer@nvidia? and what did he exactly say... I couldn't hear it good enough to understand?

2

u/skztr Jun 17 '12

well, there goes that hour

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

And that is why I'm trying to improve my skills in the field of automatic program analysis: reverse engineer proprietary drivers, improve, publish, ignore lawsuits because the DMCA tells me I can to some extent.

2

u/CounterPillow Jun 17 '12

nvidia praise (in /r/linux) and hate within one day. ONLY ON REDDIT.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Thank you for saying what I've been thinking for the last five binary driver releases.

I'm still on 290.10 - everything beyond that up to and including 302.17 crashes X when using Unity / GS on 12.04 with my 260M. I know X is shit, but I refuse to believe that this is the best QA nVidia are capable of. Either make your shit work right, or release the specifications so we can do your job for you.

2

u/nk_sucks Jun 17 '12

i concur.

2

u/anechoic Jun 17 '12

the man is my hero! :)

2

u/BrailleCAPTCHAExpert Jun 17 '12

I've had problems with ATI drivers on Windows for years, messing up textures in new titles, BSODing, causing slow performance, and me having to wait for driver updates, or having to roll back to a previous release in order to play a game. ATI is no angel. The problem with both companies is the race to intro new chipsets, to convince the public that they need newer, faster video cards. That's what leaves both companies behind in drivers development- mature drivers that is, and no time so think about Linux because Linux doesn't make them any money. Meanwhile the public continues to bend over to receive new video cards and... get your mind out of the gutter, it's easier to extract wallets when the subject is in the correct position. Thank you sir, may I buy another?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

"People that get offended should be offended" - Linus Torvalds

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Interesting, I was under the impression that Nvidia drivers were more friendly towards Linux than ATI. In fact, I know for sure that at some major companies like Google they don't allow employees to get a computer with an ATI if they're going to use Linux, because of all the possible problems that come with ATI drivers and Linux.

11

u/crusoe Jun 17 '12

Its changed, ever since ATI started handing out docs to dev. The closed driver is still faster, but with ATI, they are making progress on a Nvidia driver. On my Ubuntu box, I've had no real problems with ATI.

6

u/Klowner Jun 17 '12

Aside from crap performance, my ATI has worked pretty darned well in my Linux setup, and that's using tri-head output even.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jeffdaking Jun 17 '12

I like how the Asian guy asks about gaming. :D

3

u/onionsman Jun 17 '12

I will forever be in the Linus corner. The guy is an incredible person. (I have met him at freegeek) Those of you that have issues with him, remember Linux is open source. If you have a problem, pay money for windows & complain about Microsoft support.

3

u/NikhilT90 Jun 17 '12

I'm staying at Aalto university this summer, this talk was all that people were talking about here. Glad he came through with an awesome speech.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

What's NVIDIA suposed to do? Make a driver for every specific flavor of .NIX for their smallest market? That would be a stupid business decision.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Release the driver source - or barring that, the hardware specifications and firmware so we can get nouveau up to snuff, 3d-wise. Pitifully, nouveau is already vastly outperforming the nvidia binary driver in terms of 2d-performance.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/RabidRaccoon Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

He doesn't understand that NVidia selling chips into the Android market and released a closed source Android driver doesn't mean they have to release an open source Linux driver.

As far as most people are concerned Android is the commercially important OS. It may use the Linux kernel but it does not use Linux userland. So NVidia make a closed source Linux driver and a closed source Android driver. They don't need to contribute to the open source Linux driver.

5

u/JoeGrubbsJr Jun 17 '12

Seeing that my ATI card doesn't work as well as it should under Linux (it works fine with Windows..) I'm under the impression that a lot of graphics card manufacturers get the ol' "fuck you" from Linus and the Linux development community fairly often..

13

u/idiogeckmatic Jun 17 '12

Pretty sure they give him the "Fuck you" and he merely responds appropriately.

4

u/CalcProgrammer1 Jun 17 '12

ATI was just as bad as nVidia up until AMD purchased them. AMD has done a decent job at releasing hardware documentation for their graphics products including the older cores that were acquired with the purchase of ATI. Because of this, we now have working, 3D accelerated open-source drivers for everything from the old Rage/Radeon 7000 up to the Radeon HD7000 series. It may not perform quite as well as nVidia's binary driver or Catalyst under Windows (even Catalyst under Linux, which has major issues) it is 100% open source and is reliable (crashes, lockups, glitches are very rare).

3

u/Fajner1 Jun 17 '12

Aren't there only two major manufacturers plus Intel?

4

u/whydoipoopsomuch Jun 17 '12

I remember, back in the day when I had desktop computers, I always thought that ati was crap and nvidia was great. Now that I've spent hundreds of dollars on their video cards, I've found that every single one of them died. I bought an ati all in wonder once and it worked fine. I had old, really old, ati cards that had a meg of ram onboard and I will be damned that they still worked ten plus years later. I know this topic is about android and nvidia, but I thought I'd throw my two cents in there. I started playing around with nvidia cards back in the tnt days, back when they first started putting 2d and 3d cards on the same board. Anyone remember sti? My first real video card setup was a matrox millennia (sp) and sli dual voodoo 2 3d cards. Man, unreal and forsaken ran like a hot knife through butter!

4

u/vqhm Jun 17 '12

All my nvidia cards have over heated and died at some point. I have ATI cards that have just worked for 5+ years and even when the fan died and the card would safely shut itself off so I could just R2 the fan.

That said, Older AMD CPUs used to over heat and fry while my Intel CPUs would just shut themselves down and you could R2 the fan. But I refuse to use the new Intel chips with the hardware lock out so I'm back to AMD now: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandy_Bridge#Intel_Insider_and_remote-control

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Between this and Intel being compromised at a hardware level, is it a wonder why I like AMD/ATI?

5

u/always_sharts Jun 17 '12

This is the thing no one knows about. How intel basically is the master of the compilers and have control over instruction set usage. AMD chips are seriously gimped out of the box with how rigged intel has made the low level environment for their chips.

→ More replies (14)

3

u/fusionove Jun 17 '12 edited Jun 17 '12

A very interesting talk, indeed. Thank you.

EDIT:

"People who get offended should be offended!"

Linus FTW!

3

u/Transmatrix Jun 17 '12

What's funny is, although not being open source, Nvidia has provided drivers for Linux for years where ATI did not until AMD picked them up. To this day I only buy Nvidia cards because I want them to work on Linux if I need them to...

2

u/Creativation Jun 17 '12

For those for whom the link is not working here is an alternate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MShbP3OpASA&t=2989s

2

u/mglachrome Jun 17 '12

Was about time.

2

u/yhelothere Jun 17 '12

oh wow, a windows vs. linux discussion, how uncommon...

2

u/westdonkeykong Jun 17 '12

At what point in this hour long video does he say this? Because it is awful to listen to this guy introducing Linus.

8

u/Fajner1 Jun 17 '12

The linked part.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Classy guy. It disappoints me when crass attitudes like this are applauded.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Linus is known for table flipping so it's kinda expected now.

3

u/healedmouboo Jun 17 '12

in comparison with theo, he's not too bad :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I am still enjoying my GTX470 from 2010.

1

u/fishbert Jun 17 '12

Push button to start fire?!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Oops, looked at the youtube comments

1

u/BrucieCampbell Jun 17 '12

I love the loud fart at 51:06..

1

u/jstarlee Jun 17 '12

Whoa he looks and sounds very different from how I remembered him a few years ago. Had to double check to make sure I didn't go crazy.

1

u/DeFex Jun 17 '12

Who was bothered by the wonky light switches behind the guy who asked about open courseware?

1

u/WASDx Jun 17 '12

So, what card am I supposed to buy?

1

u/yoyomanyo Jun 17 '12

monkey with a michine gun hahahahahahahahahahaha

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

What about Android? Can you really call that open-source when there is clearly a hidden cost of privacy, neatly packaged for Google to exploit? When a service is free, the product is you.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Heh. I had to get a restraining order against an Nvidia engineer recently. This is delicious schadenfreud.

1

u/Big_P Jun 17 '12

I'm confused - aren't the Nvidia drivers for linux 10x better than AMD/ATI drivers have ever been? Seems a bit harsh for what I've always heard to be the best/only graphics card you should consider for a linux box if you want to game on.

What am I missing?

14

u/CalcProgrammer1 Jun 17 '12

The nVidia drivers for Linux are quite nice, but AMD openly provides hardware documentation that helps non-AMD developers build robust open-source drivers for Radeon cards. nVidia keeps all their information, code, reference material, etc. behind closed doors, making it difficult to build proper open-source drivers for nVidia hardware. The nouveau project has finally got basic 3D working after years of hacking, reverse engineering, testing various registers and opcodes to determine functionality, etc.

There's two ways to look at this, the now vs. the future. If you look at right now, nVidia's binary blob wins over AMD's binary blob and any open drivers. However, in the future, if AMD keeps providing documentation, they have great potential to improve while nVidia is stagnated. Plus, the official drivers like to drop support after a few years, leaving it up to open source drivers to support older chipsets. The nouveau project supports older nVidia GPU's (5x and lower) and the open-source radeon project supports all Radeon's, including the pre-HD series that the proprietary blob no longer supports.

While you may be quick to yell "UPGRADE!" you may not realize that many laptops are relying on open drivers to stay up to date. You can't go upgrade your GPU in a laptop, and Linux works well on older hardware. It would be wasteful to replace a perfectly good laptop that runs Linux well just because the binary driver dropped your card.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)