r/technology • • Jun 15 '12

FBI ordered to started copying 150TB of Kim Dotcom's data and return it to him for his defence.

http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10813260
2.2k Upvotes

644 comments sorted by

248

u/mr_z06 Jun 15 '12

Just 150TB? that sounds low

77

u/kezzaNZ Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Yeah its just his data, off the computers found in his residence, not the megaupload servers.

Also my bad with the title. Start not started.

2

u/herrokan Jun 15 '12

wtf... who has 150TB data at his home? DAYUM

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (49)

36

u/Maxfunky Jun 15 '12

And apparently it's taking the more than 10 days to do it? They must be burning it on to CD's just to be assholes.

14

u/jared555 Jun 15 '12

If they are copying one drive at a time.... 150,000,000 MB / 50MBps / 60 / 60 / 24 = 34 days 17 hours 20 minutes.

6

u/smacbeats Jun 15 '12

That's if the drives are even copying that fast. I have a 7200rpm drive in both my laptop and external drive, and it usually transfers around 25-40 MB/s.

20

u/OCedHrt Jun 15 '12

That's because USB is actually not that fast when you have a bunch of small files.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (19)

10

u/yelirekim Jun 15 '12

If it was 1 hard drive, sure, but there is no way they can't find a way to parallelize this...

30

u/GeorgeForemanGrillz Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

Let me tell you that any computer forensic lab worthy of that name would have the equipment to quickly replicate drives. It's standard procedure for any forensic exercise to make a 1 to 1 copy of the data using a low level copy tool (such as dd) and to never do any kind of investigative work on the original drive. So unless the drive is physically damaged and the only way to retrieve data is to use a clean room the evidence is never worked on directly.

The reason for this is that there is no way to guarantee that your are not altering the contents of the drive. The very act of mounting certain file systems even in read-only mode can alter the data. For example: mounting an ext3 file system even in read-only mode will trigger journal replay so even though it's mounted read-only in user space the kernel is making changes to the bits on the disk. Ext3 journal information is useful for recovering recently deleted files.

So because it is common practice for investigators to make copies of the disks they are investigating they will always have a means of copying storage devices using the quickest way possible such as having the source and target on the same SCSI adapter. Even the earliest version of SCSI supported up to 7 drives.

The FBI person that was quoted was totally full of shit or misquoted by the reporter. It's likely that he pulled that 10 days duration out of his butt as an excuse to sway the judge into reversing his/her decision. It's courtroom/legal fuckery that we've come to expect from federal agents, prosecutors, and federal agents.

EDIT

It's standard procedure for any forensic exercise to make a 1 to 1 copy of the data using a low level copy tool

Should be:

It's standard procedure for any forensic exercise to make a 1 to 1 copy of the entire contents of the storage device using a low level copy tool

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

25

u/IDontHaveUsername Jun 15 '12

Burn a CD? isn't that fire hazard? I'm going to get my floppies.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

If they really wanted to mess with him they'd copy it to tape.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

That's only about 31 kilometers of standard tape or 1.5 kilometers of the IBM super tape.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

For example, I work for a company who is required by law to copy about 30TB of data to tape every two weeks. We use LTO-5 uncompressed tapes, which means they only store 1.5TB per tape. It would take us about two and a half months of constant backing up to do this, and we have one of the best systems I have seen thus far in my career.

10

u/TemporaryBoyfriend Jun 15 '12

Uh, the only thing stopping you from copying that much datain a day is money. I build massive storage systems serving companies in the banking/insurance/healthcare space, and we can (and do) copy more than 30TB to tape on a nightly basis, and send it offsite the next morning in a steel box.

There are half a dozen vendors who would be happy to sell you a tape library that can do this, and much more.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/GeorgeForemanGrillz Jun 15 '12

Most big companies that deal with terabytes of data usually do their backups by copying from one SAN/attached storage device. Is it a legal requirement that the data has to be copied to tape?

we have one of the best systems I have seen thus far in my career.

Your company is limited by their own stupidity and you're stupid to think that backing up to tape drives one at a time is the way to go. Companies who have to deal with that kind of data volume that has to use a tape device will usually have multiple tape libraries so that the task can be handled in parallel.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

we have one of the best systems I have seen thus far in my career.

I'm going to be blunt here: you haven't seen any good tape backup systems in your career. You posted the model of tape library you're using in another post. That library writes a single tape at a time and stores only 4-6 total. There exist much larger tape libraries that can write half a dozen tapes at once and store tens of tapes total. In fact, they manufacture systems capable of storing thousands of tapes and writing hundreds at a time (generally these are used in very specific applications, but you get the point).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (137)

880

u/sovereignwaters Jun 15 '12

The FBI is making copies of terabytes of copyrighted data? Someone better alert the RIAA/MPAA!!

384

u/Level_32_Mage Jun 15 '12

So they can call the FBI!

421

u/Harvin Jun 15 '12

Federal Bureau of Inception

→ More replies (20)

86

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Mr Postin said copying all of the data could take two and a half months. He said some of it could not be copied because it has been encrypted.

So they can't copy data because it's encrypted? DAE think that sounds corrupt as hell?

48

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Not corrupt, shady... incompetent. Would be the words I'd use. Encrypted data can be copied just fine. You just copy it over encrypted. Basic example, lets say our encryption flipped every bit, thena 010100001 become 101011110. Both of those can be copied just as easily.

42

u/Yazzeh Jun 15 '12

The idea is that they don't want to give him anything that they don't control.

27

u/rum_rum Jun 15 '12

There's no incompetence going on here. They're just letting it look that way.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

66

u/singlehopper Jun 15 '12

It takes 2.5 months to image 150TB of data? What are they using? Zip disks?

That's 38 4TB drives. It should take a few days.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

You know they'll probably give it back to him on CD or something.

21

u/mctx Jun 15 '12

he said it had taken 10 days to copy 29 terabytes.

That's 33.56 MB/s, which isn't too bad.

At that rate, 150 terabytes would take 51.72 days.

41

u/chocolatemeowcats Jun 15 '12

so the FBI hasn't discovered that you can image more than one drive at once?

50

u/flukshun Jun 15 '12

No, theyve discovered its cheaper to have 1 lab monkey copying disks 1 by 1.

There's no incentive for them to optimize the procedure, so theyre gonna do just enough

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

That's a terrible transfer rate for such large amounts of data, where many drives should be used at once.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/ozmotion Jun 15 '12

Did it not occur to them to copy things in parallel? It's not like there is one gigantic 150TB drive. Probably more like 150 1TB drives. So setup 150 connections, and copy them together. Takes a few hours.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kraftik Jun 15 '12

few days? give me a few computers and some guys who know there way around a sata cable and we can get that done by the after noon.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/_Powdered_Toast_Man Jun 15 '12

The RIAA is completely impotent after a decade of throwing their cash into dumb lawsuits. If we stop talking about them they'll go away. Like Michelle Bachman or candleja

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (27)

30

u/happyscrappy Jun 15 '12

Inaccurate headline. From the article

'But whether or not the information will then be passed to Dotcom's lawyers as they prepare a defence against his extradition to the US will be the subject of a future legal argument.'

6

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I can't believe a title like that would make it to front page in the first place. Knights of new, what's up?

"FBI ordered to started copying"

1

u/GNG Jun 15 '12

I found it rather amusing that the reddit submission headline directly contradicts the article, myself.

122

u/brerrabbitt Jun 15 '12

He should have made the request in the form of 3.5 inch floppies

61

u/Zhang5 Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

That'd really suck worse on his end when he wanted to actually access any of it.

Edit: Time for some fun. Assuming the 150 TB is straight up 150,000 GB, that'd be 110,492,730 (rounding up) 3.5" floppies worth of info (according to this converter).

Edit 2: More fun. After a quick Google search I see some reasonable numbers for the weight of a floppy. About 17 grams to 20 grams. That gives us between 4,141,111.13 and 4,871,895.44 pounds (or 1,878,376.41 and 2,209,854.6 kilograms) of floppies.

25

u/climbeer Jun 15 '12

From now on I'm using the FD equivalent as a method of quantifying amounts of data. Like In this case we are talking about ~2MtFD.

5

u/itskieran Jun 15 '12

He should take them all into court and throw them into the air like some jumbo confetti, or have a trap in the ceiling where when a code word is said, they all drop into the courtroom

20

u/Zhang5 Jun 15 '12

And then everyone is literally crushed to death.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Not to mention the failure rate of floppies and their crappy data integrity. Also, probably darn near most of the files would be segmented.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Hk37 Jun 15 '12

He'd have to make a custom drive that accepts 10 floppies at once just to view a single HD photo.

16

u/IDontHaveUsername Jun 15 '12

Just zip it in multiple .rar files, then copy them and extract.

7

u/CharlesAnderson Jun 15 '12

That procedure would require "only" about 1.042*108 (104200000) floppies.

11

u/Johnsu Jun 15 '12

Reminds me of that ncis episode. The FBI hated ncis, so instead if giving the team access to the electronic documents, they brought them the paper copies. A whole van of boxes would've pissed me off too.

3

u/CosmicBard Jun 15 '12

Cassette tape.

Sort of funny, you could store nearly 1000KB per side by the end of it, so technically it would be fewer. But I think the access time to do it in is the funny part.

28

u/Oddblivious Jun 15 '12

Even better... the cassette is just someone reading off....

"one, zero, zero, zero, one, one, zero, one..."

10

u/swazy Jun 15 '12

and slip a Two in some where.

11

u/SickZX6R Jun 15 '12

So the ECC would just be some dude listening to the tape and every time he hears a 2 he yells, "ERROR!"?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/redditisworthless121 Jun 15 '12

Nothing a little pkzip to multiple disks couldn't handle... oh yeah, they could probably get that down under 4 million floppies with the compression.

→ More replies (3)

164

u/Doctor_McKay Jun 15 '12

NOT GOOD ENOUGH.

They said that under US law, disclosure is only granted once the accused appears in a US court.

They're trying to get Kim to show up in a US court so they can start calling it a US case, not a New Zealand Case.

He said some of it could not be copied because it has been encrypted.

Excuse me? I'm no expert, but how hard is it to insert hard drive, insert disk imaging tool, transfer data?

TL;DR This article and the US Government is full of bullshit.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

It's an extradition case, obviously they want Kim Dotcom to show up in a US court.

45

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

The US gov don't know the difference between copying and reading data.

84

u/Paralda Jun 15 '12

No, they are well aware. They just don't want to do it.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

What if Dotcom used self-encrypting drives? Better ones require authentication at boot time, not even starting up without the correct password. To extract the encrypted data on such a drive the FBI may have to send them to a data recovery service reading from the platters directly, which is costly and time consuming. Access to the data may also require a key securely stored in the original drive hardware, to prevent an attacker from bypassing authentication and disabling encryption simply by replacing the electronics.

10

u/dwerg85 Jun 15 '12

You can still copy it using a disk imaging tool afaik. You don't need to read the data to read the bits on the disk.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SpaceSteak Jun 15 '12

Wouldn't the FBI have some of the best data forensics experts in America?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

101

u/TalkingBackAgain Jun 15 '12

The time will soon be upon us where demands for extradition or seizure by US courts will be met with indifference and annoyance.

Why does anyone feel a need to abide by US law? The US certainly doesn't abide by anyone else's law, they don't even abide by their own laws.

41

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Fucking this. America (which I am in) needs to get the fuck off the pedistal

18

u/ckufay Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

I can answer this,

Tl;Dr: The united states is currently the world power (since we live in a uni-polar world) so it can bully others without much objection.

America is the super power in a unipolar world. In the past there were other countries that could contest on equal political ground (Military and/or economy wise) which made the world Multipolar, or multiple super powered controlled world. (Example: The Cold War.)

If other states started to deny the United States when the US trespassed on other states sovereignty, then the US could either use hard power (force it's way) or soft power (passive aggressive if you may).

An example of this is Iraq. Even though the UN had told the US not to forsake Iraq's Sovereignty, they had and received no consequences. If a other country had done this without the US' consent then the US has the option of exercising it's power.

This isn't to say that the US is a single minded power as we have multiple politicians with different POV's.

If you want to learn more then try looking into current International Relations theories.

Edit: Added something to Tl;Dr

15

u/TalkingBackAgain Jun 15 '12

You are -not- a super power if you can't pay your bills.

Let's see how much super power the US is if foreign countries abruptly stop buying their debt.

If there was limited and declining public debt, if there was a surplus on the budget and the country was engaged in aggressively building its infrastructure and its knowledge economy in all layers of society, then yes, very much so.

Now the US is squandering the nation's fortune, for which the coming generations are going to have to pay, for 0 gain.

That is not a super power.

If you're fighting a war for 10 years against an enemy that has a limited range of small caliber weapons, some bombs in the ground and you can't defeat them when you have two of everything, 10 years time and spend 4 [FOUR!] times the entire GDP of the country you're fighting in one year alone, then you are not a super power. A super power would have decisively dominated the theater.

You are not a super power if you engage in another guerilla war after having lost the first one and then not learned enough from it to do better in the next one. That is an extremely unimpressive track record. That does not spell 'super power' to me.

10

u/ckufay Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

I understand what you are saying and please try to understand that I am not trying to promote the US' unipolar status. This is just the understanding I have of International Politics and most theories define the US as a super power as it has the current dominating military power. New Age International Theories define political power as a Economic power rather Militaristic.

Joseph Nye did a ted talk on the transition of power. It's not directly related but it may help in understanding from a international relations POV.

Also Shashi Tharoor defined Super powers rather well in his ted talk (2009). He talks about the Hype in India with the growing idea of becoming a super power and leads this to the topic of Soft Power.

From my understanding, being a super power isn't necessarily related to having money rather having the potential power to exert/defend your sovereignty and trespass on others in order to extend your own.

Edit: fixed a sentence that was grammatically wrong. Edit2: Forgot to upvote you for relevance :)

→ More replies (3)

14

u/immunofort Jun 15 '12

Let's see how much super power the US is if foreign countries abruptly stop buying their debt.

You're only looking at it from one POV though. I could argue that electricity companies are worthless if it were not for their customers, which is true, however their customers are extremely reliant on them as well. Ask yourself why so many investors and countries by US debt. It's because it's probably the safest investment out available.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/DarkSideofOZ Jun 15 '12

If they did, Bush and Cheney as well as many other U.S. Politicians and crooked corporate CEOs would go the way of Osama Bin Laden or Saddam Hussein, or at least be held accountable in international court for warcrimes, and other crimes against humanity.

2

u/TalkingBackAgain Jun 15 '12

It's a blot on our character that they haven't been likewise prosecuted.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

10 bucks says they can't give him exactly 150TB. Or they just "lose" it.

10

u/myztry Jun 15 '12

I don't have a lot of faith in the chain of evidence.

I would be more worried of extra things like the source code for Stuxnet being added and then used as evidence for terrorism as only a terrorist organisation would have such things.

2

u/venikk Jun 15 '12

Or they find nothing and decide to put something there.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Kattpiss Jun 15 '12

"Meanwhile the the US Attorney's office has rubbished Kim Dotcom's plea to have criminal charges dropped, saying the request is a waste of court time and resources."

Due process: A waste of time

2

u/Winga Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 16 '12

I couldn't understand the section related to this:

lawyers for the American government also argued that Dotcom's request to dismiss the charges was "premature" because none of the defendants have refused to appear before the court.

I read this as saying that the defendants have to refuse to appear before the charges can be dismissed, but that can't be right. Does it actually mean that the request is premature because they have all refused to appear?

11

u/jesusthatsgreat Jun 15 '12

if only there was a site where they could host that 150TB of info, then share it with whoever wanted access... it would save the copying of data and allow people to only access the bits they want...

21

u/parasiticfiend Jun 15 '12

So how much data will be "lost/corrupted?"

20

u/fuzzb0y Jun 15 '12

Any amount of data that will help his defense.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/PartyTaco Jun 15 '12

Fuckers' might as well download a car.

34

u/itskieran Jun 15 '12

You wouldn't kill a policemen

Then steal his helmet

Then go to the toilet in his helmet

Then give it to his grieving widow

Then steal it again.

22

u/jbot Jun 15 '12

Don't tell me what I wouldn't do.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jameoh Jun 15 '12

I remember this, but what is it from?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

You wouldn't do that though, would you?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jlamothe Jun 15 '12

Mr Postin said copying all of the data could take two and a half months. He said some of it could not be copied because it has been encrypted.

Wait, what?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/dr_do_nothing Jun 15 '12

Actually, the most interesting part is at the end where the government has 66.6 files belonging to MU users. It seems to me that if you put your property on deposit in a storage facility and the govt seizes it dues to a criminal investigation of the facility's owners then you can request your stuff be returned. So it would follow that I should be able to request a copy of my files which are my legal property that was stored on MU. Obviously I would not suggest requesting a copy of the illegal shit you might have had stored on MU... but what about legitimate files.

19

u/Johnsu Jun 15 '12

I think my 2k ePub files might trigger some red flags especially since I named the folder " books I didn't pay for"

8

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Good on you for not paying. Authors are kings of the fat cats.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/evilblob Jun 15 '12

If they have 66.6 files, I want to know how you can have .6 of a file...?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

porn.avi

porn.avi.part

10

u/amorpheus Jun 15 '12

The same way the average family can have 2.3 kids.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/smacbeats Jun 15 '12

probably 66.6m files. Perhaps billion, but that seems kind of extreme.

2

u/RockinZeBoat Jun 15 '12

Its 66.6 million files. Most of them are probably big rar/zip files since MU didnt have size limits.

4

u/ibisum Jun 15 '12

What needs to be understood is that the government thinks it is justified in holding onto all of this data, because, until proven in court with real case, the incriminating data belonged, actually, to the holders of the hardware: Dotcom. It didn't belong to any other users out there, legally, or at least this has not been determined (yet) and is not the priority: since, the government also belives that there is much evidence of further crime in the archives, and may wish to reserve it for future investigations and criminal prosecutions -i.e. there is more in the MU archives than just plain legal content.

I'm not advocating a position for the government in this case; I think the true enemy in this situation is the general publics trust in those who offer safety and comfort and ease of use, on both sides of the aisle, in exchange for what is in fact, limited freedom.

The argument has to be understood that MU is not just the MU executive's private use of the MU service to serve illegal data, nor is it about Dotcom alone, but it is in fact about the entire archive .. which once was a living, breathing, functioning eco-system of exchange and economy, now completely dead.

The government, and the MPAA, killed it. Apparently, such is their right to do so, because they believe the archive itself is full of crime, which they alone have defined under their terms, not that of the terms of the general population of users and public.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

From the claims that they cant copy encrypted data, to the claims that it will take months to copy 150TB of data is ludicrous.

150TB is nothing. It would take no more than a couple days tops to copy that - and that would involve the time driving to bestbuy to pick up some external storage.

The FBI is either criminally incompetent, or criminal by practice.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/flogic Jun 15 '12

But how are they going to get Game of Thrones now ?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/scswift Jun 15 '12

Didn't the FBI aready copy the data once when they removed it from New Zealand via FedEx without the permission of the NZ government? If so, how did they manage to copy it so quickly then, and why are they suddenly unable to do so?

1

u/Doctor_McKay Jun 15 '12

Oh wow, I forgot about this. What's going on????

3

u/scswift Jun 15 '12

Come to think of it, if the FBI only copied the data, shouldn't the NZ government still have it? Were there some drives they allowed them to take?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/OCedHrt Jun 15 '12

10 days to copy 29 TB? WTF are they using? Floppy disks?

2

u/Drumedor Jun 15 '12

Had to use dropbox to transfer the files to another location first.

3

u/always_sharts Jun 15 '12

Then routed through Hamachi via a dialup connection

→ More replies (1)

6

u/WoollyMittens Jun 15 '12

I bet the FBI wishes they could just have arrested him to death when they played GI Joe at his mansion.

9

u/vontysk Jun 15 '12

That was the NZ police. And our police absolutely do not get away with using their guns. Ever. If cop here uses a gun here it is serious, serious business. He will be in a whole world of shit from the second he pulls the trigger, regardless of whether he should have or not.

11

u/bfreddyberg Jun 15 '12

DEFENSE! THUMP! THUMP! DEFENSE! BANG! BANG! DEFENSE!

3

u/fuck__karma Jun 15 '12

Get that title out of here.

5

u/sinfuljosh Jun 15 '12

But whether or not the information will then be passed to Dotcom's lawyers as they prepare a defence against his extradition to the US will be the subject of a future legal argument.

sounds like it doesnt say to return.. just copy.

5

u/SoetSout Jun 15 '12

150 for himself, not bad. expected more cinsidering his financial status and interests. im at 13 TB now.... so low...

→ More replies (8)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

They better have USB 3.0....

1

u/PsychoNitro Jun 15 '12

How bout Thunderbolt? Asus now has a motherboard with TB.

2

u/Zeliss Jun 15 '12

While I agree that thunderbolt is fucking awesome, that won't help much if it's stored on traditional hard drives with a read speed of 100/150 MB/s.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/reden Jun 15 '12

I'd ask them to upload it to my Google Drive.

2

u/Thameus Jun 15 '12

I guess I wasn't paying attention. I thought what they brought back from NZ was copies to begin with.

2

u/squone Jun 15 '12 edited Jun 15 '12

"They said that under US law, disclosure is only granted once the accused appears in a US court."

Someone correct me if I'm wrong but should this not apply until they are extradited since they're in New Zealand and thus New Zealand law would apply? Thus they have full access (or whatever New Zealand law is) until such time?

Edit; I live in New Zealand.

3

u/KeyBoardNinjaNZ Jun 15 '12

nah mate New Zealand bends over for the U.S quite often, our government does as its told, its shit but such a small country needs to keep the ol yanks in a good mood apparently.

2

u/GeorgeForemanGrillz Jun 15 '12

To give an idea of how much work was involved, he said it had taken 10 days to copy 29 terabytes.

BULLSHIT, Michael Postin! Everything else you say should be seen with skepticism. If I were in that courtroom I would totally call you out. FBI faggots are so full of shit.

2

u/l4qu3 Jun 15 '12

"Uh, sir. We got to 96% and Windows needed to restart the computer. I'll come in early tomorrow sir."

2

u/ElagabalusCaesar Jun 15 '12

But it's going to be on an inappropriate medium, like magnetic core memory or vinyl EP's.

2

u/defconoi Jun 15 '12

the fbi shouldnt even be involved here

2

u/Harry_Seaward Jun 15 '12

Here are 400 million floppy discs Mr. Dotcom.

2

u/Kdnce Jun 15 '12

"ordered to started" - ? My head hurts ...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I bet they are going to do that old trick of faxing everything then scanning it into PDF's at a slight skew and poor quality so you can't search or use it or OCR it since it's a messed up picture.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Excuse my ignorance, but can someone put 150TB in perspective for my computer-tech-lacking mind. About how many GGW movies is that?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Temptress75519 Jun 15 '12

The US jacked the info from dotcom and refused to give it back.

A guy from another country operating in another country and the us thinks they have jurisdiction?

Wtf?

2

u/rtft Jun 15 '12

He said some of it could not be copied because it has been encrypted.

What a bunch of BS.

2

u/BloodshotHippy Jun 15 '12

Give me 24 hours and all that shit would be copied. Im sick of my piece of shit government. I'm down for a revolution.

2

u/xesttub Jun 16 '12

That's one .. megaupload! or I wonder how they're send it to him, probably put it up on rapidshare

2

u/BallsackTBaghard Jun 15 '12

How much of that is porn?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/zSnakez Jun 15 '12

If I were these men, I would not come to the US. I would just flip them the bird and run with my millions. Some old ass judge is not entitled to that kind of information, nor should the US government be able to persecute these websites. It's funny how they take action against websites like this, but obvious scams that directly steal your identity and credit card numbers are yet left un challenged. It's good to see who's side they are on. Fuck you USA, I am ashamed to live in this country. Nobody in the courts today have a fraction of a right to pass any laws. For they are corrupted, and the people who put them in power are equally corrupted. I say you should be thrown in prison, for convicting and harming humanity, and keeping us from our true potential.

2

u/cbf88 Jun 15 '12

They don't have millions since their assets have been frozen.

1

u/myztry Jun 15 '12

The last thing he wants to do is disappear from the public spotlight.

This would make other means of acquisition more feasible.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/spanktheduck Jun 15 '12

It's funny how they take action against websites like this, but obvious scams that directly steal your identity and credit card numbers are yet left un challenged.

You don't think it has something to do with the fact that megaupload was a massive website whereas those "scams" are usually one-shot deals and hard to track down

2

u/iheartbakon Jun 15 '12

That's a lot of porn.

1

u/matike Jun 15 '12

If this goes to trial it's going to be the longest. trial. ever.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

FBI ordered to start copying 150TB of Kim Dotcom's data and return it to him for his defence. I think that is correct not ordered started , sorry if I am wrong

1

u/shoseki Jun 15 '12

Man, DotCom has lost weight!

1

u/eydryan Jun 15 '12

Link is broken on mobile :(

1

u/dzr724 Jun 15 '12

Well, hope the FBI has heard of Robocopy!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/judgej2 Jun 15 '12

That should take until Christmas, if done to USB2 external drives.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

the title is funny... "copied it"....but you have to "return it".

1

u/TwistEnding Jun 15 '12

I guess now we will find out if the information really will help his defense or if it was just a stall tactic.

1

u/fool_of_a_took Jun 15 '12

Any pity I might have for this guy evaporates when I remember that he changed his surname to "Dotcom".

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Put it all on floppy disks.

1

u/Endurlay Jun 15 '12

Hoo boy! Hope they're using USB3.0 or that's gonna take a LONG time!

1

u/marty_m Jun 15 '12

Plot twist: The data is on floppy disks and the copy will take 37.5 years. -M. Night Shymalon

1

u/Hellscreamgold Jun 15 '12

What, so he can try and say he didn't pay people to upload pirated content? lol

1

u/KrangMurphy Jun 15 '12

RIP Claw Machine, you've tricked us long enough.

1

u/ANeilan Jun 15 '12

holy crap, that's gonna take quite a while

1

u/Kardlonoc Jun 15 '12

I just realized how much Kim Dotcom looks like, and name sounds like, a super mogul from a hundred years from now...featured in some sort of game or movie about super moguls written in the 80's-90's.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ellipses1 Jun 15 '12

It would be hilarious if they copied it onto a warehouse full of 3.5" floppies

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

30-some mbps is what i get when using usb 2.0 to copy stuff onto an external hdd. im not really tech savy but wouldnt it be faster to set up a network?

1

u/jwr_ Jun 15 '12

2 centuries remaining.

1

u/alcoholierthanthou Jun 15 '12

Hot damn, that's a lot of movies and music!!

1

u/hockyboofer Jun 15 '12

this proves how fucked the law actually is... people need to stop taking credit for shit and deal with copy and paste of computers. we are computers. lets make copy and paste illegal from within ourselves too! or we can alt-f4 out of life like a dumbass.

1

u/chonglibloodsport Jun 15 '12

It's clear to me that the government has found a loophole that allows them to destroy somebody's business without any due process at all. It no longer even matters now whether or not they win the case; the damage has been done.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Fbi will never have to watch reruns again. I bet they're all like "sweet, a dark Knight 2 bootleg"

1

u/VLDT Jun 15 '12

They're going to fuck this up somehow.

1

u/trezor2 Jun 15 '12

What should be clear here, is that no actual law or procedure has been followed when they created this case, yet they expect law and procedure to be applied to dismiss it.

And somehow the judges don't have a problem with that. WTH.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Reason why it's taking so long is because they are outsourcing it to Ontrack. which always takes a few weeks to get any data back.

1

u/mineofgod Jun 15 '12

Not trying to be rude here, but why does everyone care about this so much? I'm not saying that to be snide, I'd actually like an answer to the question. To me, this is just as much drama as anything to do with the Kardashians, except more expensive and ridiculous. Why should we care? Will this affect us in personal ways that I don't know about?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RemoteBoner Jun 15 '12

This whole debacle is the biggest waste of time and money in the history of the whole goddamn earth.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/captainmcr Jun 15 '12

I bet the FBI copies only the most useless in a court of law, unless everyone is horny and wants to rub one off.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

My money is on that the evidences get "mysteriously" damaged/stole/abducted by aliens.

1

u/Electroverted Jun 15 '12

If I'm reading this right, a NZ judge ordered a US justice department (which is probably in the pocket of the RIAA/MPAA) to do something. I don't think this will end the way the judge thinks it will.

1

u/FuriousMouse Jun 15 '12

"Mr Postin said copying all of the data could take two and a half months. He said some of it could not be copied because it has been encrypted."

That is utter bullshit, the FBI just has to copy the encrypted data and give it to dotcom.

Forensic Evidence Formats like EWT, which the FBI is using anyway will allow dotcom to access his encrypted data.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

I think it's bullshit they took everything and now are asking for more time to prove he's guilty.. He shouldn't have to give em anything as they took unlawfully. Doesn't this kinda break the 5th amendment?

1

u/SigmaStigma Jun 15 '12

So much past tense.

1

u/bossrabbit Jun 15 '12

"Can't copy encrypted data"?? They need to stop whining. I'm sure they've already made block-by-block copies of those encrypted drives for their own purposes.

And I lol'd at all the comments about copying things with PATA / one at a time / with USB drives / with floppies.

1

u/mushpuppy Jun 15 '12

Taking bets now on how much of that data is determined to be irrecoverable.

1

u/fullfire55 Jun 15 '12

Lets just hope they aren't using USB 2.0

1

u/too_toked Jun 15 '12

they'll deliver it on 3.5" floppies, or better yet as ass backwards as they are 5.25"s

1

u/JimmyNic Jun 15 '12

I can't say I support Kim Dotcom, but it is entertaining as hell watching the FBI embarrass themselves.

1

u/SirElkarOwhey Jun 15 '12

They said that under US law, disclosure is only granted once the accused appears in a US court.

So, he can only have the evidence he needs to fight extradition after he is extradited. And somebody somewhere thinks that's justice.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

wow i really hate how stupid this country has become. everyone is a fuckin bleater

1

u/why_ask_why Jun 15 '12

Last time, our company was in court to defend a copyright case. We had to print the all the emails, one for the court, one for our attorney, and one for the defense attorney. Poor trees.

Kim could've and legal can ask FBI to bring a physical copy of the harddisks in paper to the court room, send one to the defense attorney.

1

u/qtipjoe Jun 15 '12

I was expecting there to be more data than that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Fuck the FBI.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Bad day to be an FBI intern.

1

u/Csoltis Jun 15 '12

canihasdata?

1

u/Rulebook_Lawyer Jun 15 '12

I feel sorry for the FBI IT Team assigned to this case...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

These threads make me want to beat people to death, and not for the reasons most would find acceptable.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

AKA Downloading the interwebs.

Damn, I'd like to have a copy too. Do you think I can ask it?

1

u/manaworkin Jun 15 '12

This guy is about to have so much porn.

1

u/garychencool Jun 15 '12

I'd laugh if everything was corrupted.

1

u/duck_tales Jun 15 '12

Return it for his what?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '12

There should be alot more than 150tb.

1

u/CocodaMonkey Jun 15 '12

I really don't see how it's a problem for the FBI to copy 150GiB in 30 days. It's just copy, not sort through and analize. It could easily be done in a single day. Just grab 50 3TiB drives and away you go. Even if you did it one drive at a time it would only take a couple days and if you weren't retarded you'd use multiple computers to copy the drives and could easily finish in a single day with just one guy doing it.

This is also assuming just basic tech people have at home. If you have an actual setup to do this and you buy faster HD's you could do it in a matter of hours.

2

u/smacbeats Jun 15 '12

Depends on the drives they use. The FBI might just be using some Seagate 7200rpm drives.

1

u/brkdncr Jun 15 '12

at this level, they're going to be using legitimate storage technology and sending it via freight. The legal costs are so high at this point that the cost of an all-in-one NAS or SAN solution isn't much.

-1

u/beltorak Jun 15 '12

how much you wanna bet there's going to be an "oops, i accidentally a folder" moment? "sorry bro. u mad?"

36

u/Terrible_Gamer Jun 15 '12

I would be willing to bet that if they "lose" anything after being ordered to copy it and make it available for his defense that any case they thought they might have had will go straight down the shitter.

This guy knew that people were sharing files that they didn't own. There is no doubt in my mind that he knew his site was hosting "illegal" files. He also took down files when he was notified of a copyright claim. He was also getting a metric fuck ton of false claims from the RIAA/MPAA. They were going through and taking down files that had nothing to do with piracy at all. I had some files from an rFactor mod I had worked on hosted there for easy downloading. They got taken down every other week. I had to reupload them and then go fix links at several websites. The RIAA/MPAA was crying wolf with at least 50% of all the files they claimed to be pirated. The same thing happens on youtube all the time. Videos are removed everyday that were all 100% legal content. This is why he was not removing them as quickly as the RIAA/MPAA and other sources wanted them removed.

The problem is that there is no way to really police what was being hosted legally and what was not. You could have a text file stopping uploads with the names of movies, songs, artists or whatever you wanted. They could have had a list of hashes that matched pirated files and kept them from being uploaded. Both of those are very easy to bypass. You just change the name of the file, or delete 5 seconds of the credits or add a few seconds to the end of a song and the hash will not match whats in the database to block the uploads.

The only surefire way to keep filesharing sites 100% legal is to hire a few hundred people to verify that every upload is legitimate. That is not feasible even for an operation as big as megaupload was.

What this boils down to is he wasn't taking the RIAA/MPAA notices and removing the content fast enough. He pissed them off and they have some politicians in their pocket that have friend in high places in the FBI. They don't care if the FBI ends up losing the case. They have ruined the guys business and I doubt that he would be able to sue the FBI and get anything from them. This is a case of a corporation using their money to harass and ruin someone just because they can.

Honestly I am of the opinion that electing officials just doesn't work anymore. They break every promise as soon as they are in office and money from a dozen different lobbies starts pouring in. We need to outlaw lobbying and make it illegal for anyone except the individual people who elected an official to call or write in to tell them what they want their government to do. It should be a mandatory 25 to life if an elected official takes money or gifts or goes to work for a corporation that they helped while in office.

The U.S. has no damn reason to be fucking with someone in New Zealand in the first place. If our government keeps going the way it has the last 30 years it's going to be time to remind our elected officials why the 2nd amendment is in the constitution in the first place. It's not there so we can shoot kids in hoodies carrying a bag of skittles. The 2nd amendment is there for us to be able to fight against and remove a government that has stopped representing its people and started making laws to protect corporations and give them more rights that the citizens have.

8

u/beltorak Jun 15 '12

I agree with you on so many points; but I think that they (the feds) realize they are not going to have the slam dunk in the courts that hollywood promised them, so winning the case may not be a primary goal. actually the primary goal has already been met - megaupload is gone. so if they know they are already lost in the courts (which I think is starting to dawn on them since NZ is giving them flak about proper procedures just to start with), how much do you want to bet that his stuff (or a significant portion thereof) will "accidentally" get deleted? Maybe out of spite, maybe to try to stop him from relaunching, maybe as an object lesson to others ("" doesn't matter if you will win in the courts, we still have your stuff, so STFU "").

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

It's encrypted so they can't actually do that.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Jesus christ, finally...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Think of all the money that could have been saved if this investigation never happened.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '12

Bet they send it to him on CD-ROM's just to be dicks. How many CD's would that be anyways? haha.

1

u/ANeilan Jun 15 '12

a little over 150,000