r/technology • u/DrJulianBashir • Jun 11 '12
DOJ tries to block return of data to MegaUpload user
http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57450153-93/doj-tries-to-block-return-of-data-to-megaupload-user/106
u/Exallium Jun 11 '12
The Motion Picture Association of America, the trade group for the six film studios, is concerned that pirated movies and TV shows aren't once again circulated but said last week that it has no objection to "legitimate" content being returned.
Why the fuck would the MPAA have any say over what is done with legit content?
61
u/crackbabydaddy Jun 11 '12
hi, this is planet earth, it runs on money
46
2
u/Duthos Jun 11 '12
Human society anyway, and only because we let it.
Sooner or later we will have to realize there are more important things than an artificial denomination of an equally artificial concept. Like human rights. Those are important.
2
u/creepig Jun 11 '12
No, because then someone will tell someone else that they can be better than everybody else, and the whole thing will collapse. It's basic human fucking nature.
2
u/Duthos Jun 11 '12
Prioritizing human rights would preclude that.
Our nature is to adapt, the problem is that we have been adapting to a shitty system of our own creation, rather than adapting that system to us.
→ More replies (4)8
6
u/CactusA Jun 11 '12
It shouldn't even be talking about all other illegitimate content that is not owned by the MPAA. It acts like it is the only producer of content that ever existed.
2
u/Exallium Jun 11 '12
I completely agree, it was just that basic claim that the MPAA had the right to withhold legit content that made me rage a little.
6
Jun 11 '12
Don't you know? The MPAA owns all video and the RIAA own all music produced for all time.
2
u/Hypersapien Jun 11 '12
Why would ASCAP get to charge bars and restaurants a fee for hiring musicians that play music that they wrote themselves?
1
2
u/cnostrand Jun 11 '12
Why would they have any say at all? This is a criminal investigation by the DOJ.
On top of that, it's not like if any copyrighted material that got released to users would add more to the number of copies out there. It's not like they're releasing physical bootleg copies "back on the streets". There's not a finite number of copies of Captain America (or whatever) on the internet... stopping anything on MU from being released doesn't make ANY difference.
72
Jun 11 '12
I swear it's almost like there's a bondvillan-esque character who's laughing maniacally as they orchestrate all this douchebaggery
54
u/johnnynutman Jun 11 '12
except that bond villains are actually clever.
16
u/djnathanv Jun 11 '12
Except in how they all fail at killing Bond even when he's subdued and in their possession...
11
u/madjo Jun 11 '12
Don't ever start orating about your brilliant plan when you have Mr. Bond in your possession. Don't use elaborate traps to get rid of him either or use goons to kill him, just shoot him yourself.
→ More replies (1)20
u/aakaakaak Jun 11 '12
I just want to see one Bond film where the bad guy entraps Bond, tells him his elaborate plan, only for the whole plan to be a load of crap that cons Bond into setting things up for the criminal.
"Remember when I told you I planned on blowing up the moon? I lied. Thanks for destroying your own space program. I couldn't have done it without you."
0
9
u/DeedTheInky Jun 11 '12
It's like if Bond got to the villain's HQ and discovered that instead of a supergenius, there was just a drooling imbecile with an IQ of 40 and a sledgehammer. And then he got bludgeoned to death because nothing in his training had prepared him for something so random or stupid.
1
2
u/Morbo_Mad Jun 11 '12
And they supply their cronies with metal teeth. Now THATS healthcare I can get behind.
2
u/roterghost Jun 11 '12
These guys seem clever enough. They're going to get away with it, after all.
Hell, who needs some doomsday laser when you've got an army of corrupt police officials, and a population that mostly either has no interest in what you're doing or actually supports what you're doing?
1
1
u/Airazz Jun 11 '12
Except when the villains do a little excursion for Bond where they explain their whole plan and how everything works, which allows Bond to see what he can do to ruin the whole thing and escape safely.
5
u/SubGeniusX Jun 11 '12
If what he were doing was actually villainous. Kim Dotcom would make an AWESOME Bond villian. With his huge estate, cars, choppers, armaments, women, look and attitude, he would be a perfect fit.
1
513
u/RandomMandarin Jun 11 '12
Returning videos to Kyle Goodwin, a former MegaUpload user, would set a bad precedent, the U.S. said in documents, copies of which were obtained by CNET.
Ohhh. The government doesn't want to set any bad precedents! Hear that, everybody? I guess we'll be ending detention without trial, warrantless wiretapping, ex-President war criminals walking free, bailouts for crooked banks, unlimited campaign money, etc. etc. etc.
243
Jun 11 '12
Can you imagine the precedent this might set? It'd be like admitting that there are things the Government can't do! Or, god forbid, some of you filthy fucking peasants actually start to think you have some sort of rights!
115
u/robertcrowther Jun 11 '12
Maybe you should just rejoin the British Empire? Seems like that whole revolution thing might have set a bad precedent...
38
u/cogitoergosam Jun 11 '12
I'm not sure having to submit to a cavity search and background check before buying silverware is an improvement.
37
u/ulber Jun 11 '12
After reading just:
I'm not sure having to submit to a cavity search and background check ...
I was sure you were talking about the USA.
→ More replies (1)14
Jun 11 '12
... unless you're attempting to bring silverware on a plane. Then we demand it! Because... terruririsms!
→ More replies (50)9
u/wikireaks2 Jun 11 '12
Well, as bad as the US is, you can be put in jail for talking in the Uk. Literally.
6
→ More replies (16)4
u/tatch Jun 11 '12
The freedom is not absolute; the Supreme Court of the United States has recognized several categories of speech that are excluded from the freedom of speech, and it has recognized that governments may enact reasonable time, place, or manner restrictions on speech.
The US too, apparently.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)6
u/Craigellachie Jun 11 '12
Don't put faith in revolutions. They always come round again. That's why they're called revolutions.
10
u/keepthepace Jun 11 '12
You know what ? This is a toxic meme that is false. Revolutions do change things. They are not reliable, they often fail, they kill way too many people, but changes do occur.
17
u/RumpleForeSkin72 Jun 11 '12
Don't put faith in revolutions. They always come round again. That's why they're called revolutions, people die, and nothing changes. --Terry Pratchett
You should give credit to the originator of that phrase
→ More replies (5)4
5
u/sangjmoon Jun 11 '12
We have rights all right if we bothered to vote these guys out of power instead of keeping the 2 party system in place.
10
u/arkofjoy Jun 11 '12
During the 2008 election my sister was living in a very pro republican area of new York state. Out of curiosity on evening while we were discussing the outcome Of the election I decided to look up the voting stats. It turned out that the votes cast for onomatopoeia ( spell check did that and I decided to leave it ) was about equal to the vote for the other guy and the weird chick. But more eligible voters just didn't show up than voted for either. If everyone who didn't vote in the last election had voted for kermite the frog, we would now have a green president with only one guys hand up his ass instead of many.
6
u/sangjmoon Jun 11 '12
Frankly, it probably be better to have a nonexistent official who did nothing and just got out of the way of the people than to have these idiots in both the Republican and Democrat parties "help" us with increasing government control.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
u/white_discussion Jun 11 '12
Sorry, no. That is the biggest lie of all. They want you to believe it is true - in fact they count on you continuing to believe in that that falsehood. A continued belief that there is a chance to change things at the federal level via the voting booth is the main way the kleptocracy keeps the citizenry pacified. The persistent (though incorrect) faith and belief that we actually live in a functioning "democracy" (representative republic) at this point. We don't. And it is that faith and belief that helps to keep them in power. It actually works against us. We do ourselves in.
The U.S. is an inverted totalitarian kleptocracy wherein "democracy" is managed to ensure outcomes for the established powers that be. Read about inverted totalitarianism and managed democracy. There is no way for us to vote ourselves out of this. Here this will get you started:
23
Jun 11 '12
No, but they said he had another option....
"Mr. Goodwin," the government's lawyers wrote, "can sue MegaUpload or Carpathia [Hosting, the company that hosted MegaUpload's servers] to recover his losses."
When Kim Dotcom can't even get access to his servers let alone return anything. Yep, that makes perfect sense.
This is becoming ridiculous to watch. The people in charge have absolutely no idea what they are doing, and it shows.
23
u/lilzaphod Jun 11 '12
The people in charge have absolutely no idea what they are doing, and it shows
Bullshit. They know exactly what they are doing. It's called Stonewalling.
2
24
Jun 11 '12
So the government seizes this guy's videos, which are 100% legal, denies him access to them, and tells him to sue the guy they took the stuff from who they have yet to legally prove did anything wrong aside from having a stupid name. This is impressive troll logic even by the high standards the government sets.
3
3
Jun 11 '12
My favorite part is:
You take MPAA's videos? You are a criminal.
Government takes your videos? Nothing wrong here!
→ More replies (8)2
u/Random_Fandom Jun 12 '12
The people in charge have absolutely no idea what they are doing, and it shows.
Unfortunately, in the specific case of denying Goodwin his videos, they do. The government is paving a precedent for their future confiscations of innocent people's possessions. This has another, nice benefit for the government: it also sends the clear message that they can trample our rights to possess our own shit, whenever it suits them.
I don't know what ticked me off more: their bullshit line,
"Mr. Goodwin's proposed solution is to have the government bear the financial cost of restoring his data, even if that means releasing assets of the defendants which are subject to mandatory forfeiture,"
or the smugness in suggesting that Goodwin "sue MegaUpload." First of all, they're using the Supreme Court's ruling to deliberately avoid a far more simple solution: get a 3rd party to retrieve Goodwin's data. No funds will have been released to the "criminal defendant," Goodwin is happy, the government will have restored a smidgen of faith in its citizens for having done the Right Thing.
As for Goodwin "suing" MU: Really?? How's that supposed to pan out, exactly? MU's assets are in seizure, and when it's over, nothing will be left. And even if Goodwin did sue MU, it still won't get him back his freaking videos!
11
u/ShadowFluffy Jun 11 '12
I still have no idea how any amount of money could ever fill the amount of sorrow for what's become of your government. I can't wait for it to become a shining example built with an honest and fair structure, as it was intended to be, so it can show the world how great life really is.
8
u/incredibleridiculous Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Come on, if you are going to be the top comment, at least read the article and not just the summary.
The bad precedent referenced: "The United States also reminded the court that the necessary circumstances don't exist for the court to exercise its "equity jurisdiction." Finally, the government said if the court grants Goodwin's request, it would open the door for any third party to petition the courts any time a search warrant affects them adversely."
This is a valid point. If you loaned something to a friend, and when he committed a crime it was seized as a part of the warrant, the government would not want to be responsible for figuring out the details. Sure, laws have to be changed when the items being taken are files, but that is why the government is arguing here.
Edited: 'summery' should have been 'summary'
1
u/NoNeedForAName Jun 11 '12
Not only that, but the data isn't in the government's possession. They haven't seized the servers, where the data is located, and there's no protective order or anything like that preventing Goodwin from accessing his files. Carpathia has 100% control over the servers right now, and this guy is trying to make the US give him something that the US doesn't have.
→ More replies (2)3
u/Condawg Jun 11 '12
"If we return his videos, everybody who uploaded things legally would want them back!"
3
Jun 11 '12
If 'BAD PRECEDENTS' doesn't work they have their tried and true, 'NATIONAL SECURITY' card to play.
1
1
u/apullin Jun 11 '12
Imagine an architecture of government where we had checks and balances ... that'd be crazy !
1
u/8e8 Jun 11 '12
First the FBI ends the battle on piracy by telling us the unauthorized copying of data is only illegal if it's not physical, and now this. I'm really starting to like these guys.
1
u/gigitrix Jun 11 '12
Not to mention drone strikes and infecting computers worldwide so you can destroy centrifuges and spy on your enemies...
1
u/daveime Jun 11 '12
I'm with you on detention without trial, warrantless wiretapping, ex-President war criminals walking free ...
But "bailouts for crooked banks" ? What exactly did they do that was illegal ?
Answer : NOTHING !!!
Had the banks NOT been bailed out, millions of people would have had their homes repossessed as the holders of toxic assets seeked to cash-in on their investments ... as it is, the government lent them money, and they've repaid over half of it in 2 years WITH interest !!!
So what is it ? America, the home of the house loan, car loan, 27 credit cards, and unlimited credit even if you put yourself in hock up to the eyeballs for the next 70 years ? UNLESS YOU ARE A BANK, in which case, different rules apply ?
Stop with this bullshit already ... the reason the banks were "too big to fail" is because too many ordinary hardworking Americans would suddenly of found themselves homeless.
1
u/RandomMandarin Jun 11 '12
I read something a while back about the US economy becoming like a poker game.
Used to be, you got paid well enough that, if you busted your hump a bit, you could probably save up for things you really wanted and avoid going into debt much. But, with real wages stagnating for most workers, people more and more found themselves forced to borrow just to stay in the game. Just like when one poker player has so much money he can force you to keep raising or fold, and soon you must borrow to stay in the game.
Big difference: if you can't afford to stay in the economy, the only way to quit the game is to die!
So, anyway, those banks never should have been allowed to be too big to fail; never should have been allowed to do predatory lending that would have got them thrown in jail 30 years before; etc.
Some of what they did was no longer illegal; some of it, like the massive amounts of forgery that lies behind many foreclosures, is very illegal... if only the gummint would prosecute it!
1
1
→ More replies (1)0
36
u/frankster Jun 11 '12
Its amazing that they believe Megaupload should be liable to users for anything the US government chooses to do.
TBH confiscating the servers of an internet business is equivalent to knocking down an office block. At the very least barring the shutters and locking the doors. without giving anyone a chance to leave.
9
u/Neebat Jun 11 '12
MegaUpload is actually absolved of responsibility by the terms of the user agreement. MegaUpload makes no warranty of continued access to user data.
The government does not have that protection. They get a whole different set of protections. :-(
21
u/keiyakins Jun 11 '12
It would set a very good precedent - that the government is not allowed to seize our documents for no reason.
That that HAS to be set is the problem.
76
u/-jackschitt- Jun 11 '12
Not one bit of that makes the least bit of sense.
"Mr. Goodwin's proposed solution is to have the government bear the financial cost of restoring his data," the U.S. Attorney's office wrote in its filing, "even if that means releasing assets of the defendants which are subject to mandatory forfeiture. Twenty-three years ago, the Supreme Court made clear that a criminal defendant does not have a right to use someone else's money to finance his defense."
Um......what?
Finally, the government said if the court grants Goodwin's request, it would open the door for any third party to petition the courts any time a search warrant affects them adversely.
Again.....what? If I'm negatively affected by a search warrant that has nothing else to do with me, I'm supposed to just suck it up and take it?
I believe DotCom is nothing but a sleazeball who was knowingly profiting off of piracy. But that doesn't mean I agree with the way that the US government has handled this case at all. The guy might be a sleazeball, and I believe he's 100% guilty. But he's still got the right to a fair trial.
66
Jun 11 '12
The article is fairly poorly written, but here's what appears to have happened:
The government carried out a warrant to seize some of the data off of Megaupload's servers and froze Megaupload's accounts due to the criminal charges it brought against Megaupload
The remaining data stayed on Carpathia's (Megaupload's data hoster) servers, and soon after the initial seizure the government said it didn't need anything else and Carpathia was free to do what it wanted with the data
Carpathia started saying it wanted to delete the data since Megaupload to could no longer pay its bills
So there's two possible cases for the individual suing:
his data was amongst the data seized by the government, in which case he's suing the right people and has every right to reclaim his property (although typically not until after the trial, as it's being used as evidence, although since this is digital they could probably just make a copy (hah, ironic)).
his data is not amongst the data seized, in which case it is still residing on Carpathia's servers, and he is suing the wrong people, which is why the DOJ is making the statements that it is. If the government never took the data, and the plaintiff wins, then he would effectively be getting the government to pay for Megaupload's data hosting (Carpathia would likely demand payment to retrieve the data). The reason they're saying it's a bad precedent is that it would be setting a bad precedent, by making the government financially responsible for any debts or property loss indirectly brought about due to the arrest of criminals (whether or not Megaupload is or is not guilty is immaterial to this specific issue).
To use the often referred to real life storage locker analogy, this is like the government arresting the owner of a physical storage locker but saying they could care less about the storage property or its contents, and then getting sued and forced to pay to allow all of the man's customers to get their stuff back.
33
u/rum_rum Jun 11 '12
All well and good, except for a couple of things. If the government didn't actually have the data, they wouldn't be contesting this action on these grounds. And their version of civil asset forfeiture is aggregious even by this administration's standards.
Frankly, they should be on the hook for this badly bungled smash-and-grab operation. The only lesson anyone has to take away from this so far is never to host your data in America.
19
Jun 11 '12
So if the government shuts down your cloud service (by bankrupting the owner), basically you have no recourse. I think the cloud just got a lot less attractive for me.
→ More replies (1)5
u/DeFex Jun 11 '12
I don't know why anyone would have only one copy of important stuff stored online. Maybe as a last ditch backup in case you lost your drive and your offsite (or at least hidden in a different room) backup drive at the same time.
→ More replies (2)9
Jun 11 '12
Like I said, it's a poorly written article, but they'd be contesting this action on exactly these grounds if it is the second case I'd illustrated above. They're not stepping in to stop a user from dealing with Carpathia, they're defending themselves in a lawsuit brought against them.
17
u/rum_rum Jun 11 '12
I see what you're getting at, but this bothers me as well:
it would be setting a bad precedent, by making the government financially responsible for any debts or property loss indirectly brought about due to the arrest of criminals
First of all, no one is yet a criminal, that is alleged. Second of all, why shouldn't they be?
You would never approve if a SWAT team burned down an apartment building to nab one guy dealing weed, and then told all the now-homeless people to screw off, and their possessions are being impounded as evidence. But you're OK with this?
5
Jun 11 '12
You are correct about alleged, which is why the assets are frozen, not seized.
You would never approve if a SWAT team burned down an apartment building to nab one guy dealing weed, and then told all the now-homeless people to screw off, and their possessions are being impounded as evidence. But you're OK with this?
The SWAT example isn't quite right (for a lot of reasons, since in that case the government would be going after an individual user, not the company itself), because the government did not destroy Megaupload's data. Yes, the consequences are effectively the same, but the actions are not, and it makes a difference.
The US is alleging that Megaupload profited and built a business around the illegal activities of some of its members (and allegedly some of its employees). It's impossible to separate out the "bad, illegally gained" money from the "good" money in terms of Megaupload's assets, so the government has to freeze everything. By allowing them to continue to spend that money, it's allowing them to use money gained through illegal activities (alleged). If Megaupload is found guilty, the government is not allowed to go and get the money they released back from whatever Megaupload spent it on - that wouldn't be particularly fair to the recipients of that money. That's the problem, which is why money is frozen in criminal cases.
→ More replies (2)5
Jun 11 '12
Actually... I work in storage. We had such a case not so long ago.
The man committed a crime, and a lot of the evidence was in his storage locker. The feds came in, removed all the evidence they wanted... then we had to just hold onto the locker indefinitely. No payment, no anything. It just sat there gathering dust for years since the guy who owned it was in a coma.
If someone else's stuff had been in the locker and successfully got a court order for us to return their stuff then we would have had to give them their stuff, without a payment. I don't know how it works with data storage, but for physical storage you rent a space for your items, and you are the only one responsible for it. But they would have to have a court order because otherwise we can't even go in there to get the stuff.
In this case they are talking about releasing some portion of Dotcoms own money to free up the servers long enough to allow retrieval of peoples own property. This would also allow him to get his own files for defense which they seem adamant about keeping from him.
Plus, in all likely hood, the DOJ has a copy of the entire system, not just bits and pieces. How could they have sorted through such a large server so quickly? No, they did a quick copy and left more then likely. So they probably have a copy and just don't want to start releasing it to this one person, because if they do then others will follow.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Deathfrom Jun 11 '12
This would also allow him to get his own files for defense which they seem adamant about keeping from him.
Are you saying the DOJ is actively preventing Kim Dotcom from material that would help in his defense, isn't that anti-justice? Sorry, if I'm being naive.
→ More replies (5)2
Jun 11 '12
Yes. There have been several articles in the last few months were Dotcom asked for access to his files so he could prepare his defense. They not only refused, they also sent the files to the USA after saying they would remain there until the court said they could be removed. Then they said they didn't break the court order because the files are not physical items, therefore don't count under the laws.
5
u/novagenesis Jun 11 '12
I don't know the details...but:
Carpathia does not have access to any data for Megaupload customers. We support the EFF and their efforts to help those users that stored legitimate, non-infringing files with Megaupload retrieve their data.
~ Brian WinterCMO of Carpathia Hosting
and...
"While Carpathia has never had access to the data on Megaupload servers and has had no mechanism for returning that data to Megaupload users, we have been attempting over many weeks to resolve this matter to the satisfaction of all parties involved, in a manner that would allow for Megaupload users to be in a position to ultimately recover their data. Despite our best efforts, the parties have been unable to work out a voluntary solution that meets the concerns of all the various parties who have claimed an interest in Megaupload’s data. As a result, Carpathia has filed a motion in federal court seeking the court’s guidance on how to proceed in resolving this matter."
~Brian WinterChief Marketing Officer, Carpathia Hosting
As some of you may or may not know, Carpathia and the EFF have partnered in creating this site for the purpose of helping and educating former Megaupload users of what's really going on.
2
Jun 11 '12
I am aware, I've linked to that site in other posts, which is why I'd lean towards the encrypted side. If the data is not the case, then Carpathia could absolutely get at Megaupload's data (although they'd have no way to know what data belonged to who) - it's just unencrypted data sitting on hard drives, it can be recovered through various (and sometimes expensive) means. It's likely contractual issues that stop them from accessing the data, physically it's quite likely they could do it (again, assuming it's not encrypted).
→ More replies (1)2
Jun 11 '12
making the government financially responsible for any debts or property loss indirectly brought about due to the arrest of criminals
Isn't this already a pretty common precedent? Or at least, a normal cause for action?
→ More replies (4)2
u/thenuge26 Jun 11 '12
Yeah, the new shiny police tanks that we have to pay for accidentally blow up your house, along with the meth lab next to yours. And the government just says "tough shit?" I don't believe that.
1
Jun 11 '12
f the government never took the data, and the plaintiff wins, then he would effectively be getting the government to pay for Megaupload's data hosting (Carpathia would likely demand payment to retrieve the data).
However, wouldn't he hypothetically have a case against the government for causing the situation that led Carpathia to delete the data in the first place?
7
Jun 11 '12
No, he would not. He would only have such a case if he could prove the government was not acting in good faith when they froze Megaupload's accounts.
4
Jun 11 '12
Wow, seriously?
So let's say the government prosecutes company X, thinking company X has done something bad.
Company X successfully defends itself and proves its innocence (granted, this hasn't happened with MU, I'm just trying to understand US law for such a scenario, appreciate any info). Just making sure I grok this 100%, apologies if I'm being obtuse:
Say, I rely on company X for my business / income / whatever (let's say they make widgets that I require for my patented Hogenklangers).
could Company X sue the US govt. for (a) legal costs and/or (b) loss of income resulting from the in-retrospect-wrong prosecution?
could I sue the US govt. for loss of my income?
If I understand it correctly, the government can basically do whatever it wants without financial consequences if they cause damage (loss of income, destruction of property / data, etc.) Is this related to the concept of sovereign immunity?
Thanks for any clarification.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Neebat Jun 11 '12
So long as the "government" acts through court systems following due process, yes, that's pretty much how it works. Judges have a lot of power and take their jobs very seriously.
1
Jun 11 '12
Imagine if all the people with legal data on those servers wanted their stuff back and they all sued for it at once. Good times ahead for the gov ;)
1
u/NoNeedForAName Jun 11 '12
It's the latter. The data is on servers still in Carpathia's possession, was never copied or seized by the US, and is not subject to any kind of protective order. All the guy has to do is get on the phone with Carpathia and see what they'll do to give his data back.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)1
u/Inuma Jun 11 '12
There's a few issues with the warrant:
The government carried out a warrant to seize some of the data off of Megaupload's servers and froze Megaupload's accounts due to the criminal charges it brought against Megaupload
Essentially, the USG made this case about criminal copyright infringement with little proof of actual infringement. They also don't have anything relating to charges before a seizure was committed. The charges of money laundering and wire fraud all circle around the infringement charge.
The remaining data stayed on Carpathia's (Megaupload's data hoster) servers, and soon after the initial seizure the government said it didn't need anything else and Carpathia was free to do what it wanted with the data
Yes, they wanted to eliminate evidence by having it deleted, which has caused the problematic position that the USG is currently in.
Out of your scenarios, I'm doubting that this sets a bad precedent though. In this regard, this is akin to a seizure on a book store and closing it down before a judicial hearing. What they've essentially done is take away the people's ability to buy a book or use a service because of their actions. I believe the government is culpable for the actions that provide a tangible loss of revenue or value to a service through their actions.
→ More replies (1)12
u/TheIceCreamPirate Jun 11 '12
I hate how everyone will throw in some dotcom or mega upload bashing in order to sound more reasonable. He was convicted of a single crime many years ago. That is not some lengthy rap sheet that makes him a scumbag.
Have you seen his interviews? As he rightfully points out, the internal YouTube emails from the Viacom suit make mega upload look like saints.
Wish everyone would stop saying they think he is a scumbag and mega upload is likely guilty, but they just want the law to be followed. On the contrary, mega upload does not look like they are guilty of any crime, and if that is the case, why is dotcom such a scumbag again?
21
u/mightymonarch Jun 11 '12
Twenty-three years ago, the Supreme Court made clear that a criminal defendant does not have a right to use someone else's money to finance his defense.
I don't understand this. How is using a court-appointed attorney (using other people's tax dollars to fund their defense) not this exact thing?
7
Jun 11 '12
Because of the right to a fair trial (Constitution) which has been interpreted to mean you have the right to proper representation in order to ensure you have a fair trial
2
2
u/novagenesis Jun 11 '12
What they meant, Translated to English, is that they have the right to freeze your assets to make sure you cannot afford a defense of any quality, to virtually guarantee you are found guilty. Once you're found guilty, your frozen assets are forfeit to the US government.
This can happen at any time a person's source of income is accused to be illegal. It does happen in drug-dealing cases, but it seems rarely otherwise outside of theft.... except when alternative currency or online services are involved.
1
u/spanktheduck Jun 11 '12
You don't have a right to steal money/obtina money by breaking the law and use the stolen money to hire an attorney
8
u/frankster Jun 11 '12
Although I'm sure he is aware that there has been copyrighted material on the servers, the DMCA specifically states that service providers' obligation is to have notice/takedown procedure which I understand that he has done.
Regardless of Kim Dotcom's possible sleaziness, its a basic fact that any effective method of transferring data will be useful to pirates. Bittorrent is a significant advance in computer science...it pushed the boundaries in bandwidth-efficient data transfer (or at least preventing a source server being overloaded).
Because it was so efficient at transferring files obviously pirates picked up on it as did various linux distributions, computer game manufacturers (blizzard) etc.
Similarly megaupload has managed to fund servers for people upload and download files. Yes people will use it for copyrighted stuff, but also lots of people use it for other purposes such as sending files that are too large for email etc etc.
Any effective data transfer system will be attractive to pirates, I don't see any way around it. But shutting down useful services causes a huge amount of collateral damage and I'm certain its the wrong course of action.
→ More replies (3)6
u/andbruno Jun 11 '12
Again.....what? If I'm negatively affected by a search warrant that has nothing else to do with me, I'm supposed to just suck it up and take it?
You are not to question The Government, citizen. The Government has our best interest at heart. How dare you. Thinking you have rights, how pathetic.
3
u/SigmaStigma Jun 11 '12
Feds seize hip-hop site for a year, waiting for proof
So the government can illegally ruin someone's business and can't be held liable. Overturning that precedent, would be a bad precedent to set.
1
15
Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
This is absolutely ludicrous. Have any of you noticed at no point of this Anti-piracy movement has anyone brought up the rights or needs of the consumer. I started pirating music because the CD's that I bought and loved...eventually were damaged. I couldn't go to the store and exchange my now ruined copy for a new one. I either had to buy a new copy or download a pirated one. I wasn't trying to steal, I just wanted to keep my music.
These record companies never made any attempts to resolve this issue for consumers. They thought they had ultimate control of the distribution of music and they acted with a attitude of, "tough, if you want it pay for it". So piracy got bigger. Eventually people got so use to downloading, that when a new CD came out, we just downloaded it. For the majority consumer, we did it because it meant we could do anything with it, it would last, and it was easy. It met the consumers needs and wants better than CD's. Still, these companies sat idle by doing nothing.
Now, these same companies are in a frenzy because they aren't making any money. Well I say tough, if you couldn't see and respect the needs of your consumers, and were so blind to where the technology was going then tough. The moment downloading music was on the radar you should have invested in it, not ignored it. Show me one instance where a better technology didn't grow to evolve the market. People like Kim Dotcom and Shawn Fanning saw a need in consumers and provided a incredible solution. It wasn't until Itunes was released in 2001 that you could easily and legally download music which was, conservatively put, 6 years too late. Consumers were already told and use to the idea of getting it for free. They waited to long, and the consumer has already learned what he can get.
Have these companies learned nothing from this. DON'T FIGHT THE CONSUMER, PROVIDE FOR THE CONSUMER. If people aren't willing to pay for the CD or go to the movie theater. Instead of implementing fascist legislation, start researching and analyzing what has changed in the wants and needs of consumers. What happened in the last 10 years to make the idea of going to a movie theater/buying a CD unappealing? Why do consumers look at the cost of these things as over-inflated or unreasonable? What effect has super-distributors such as Walmart had on the psychology of the consumer? Do anything that shows you understand economics or business, or just stop and let's create a system where bands and directors can directly distribute their work.
I know I focused mainly on the music industry, when it's the movie studios really fighting it, but it started with music and all piracy is for the same reasons.
5
Jun 11 '12
Buy a CD, and something like $1 goes to the actual artist. The rest goes to the greedy fat cats lining their pockets with other people's time and talent. I refuse to buy CDs. If you wanna support an artist go to a show, buy a t-shirt or donate directly to them. FUCK THE MPAA/RIAA! LONG LIVE ROCK AND ROLL!
→ More replies (1)2
Jun 11 '12
Very true point, in all honestly it's probably considerably less. A few friends of mine who got their bands signed got like 6% of all CD sales, so its not even based on the sale price of the CD. It's total crap. Let me extend the olive branch if I made it sound like I don't go to the shows, there is nothing better than a heavy metal mosh pit. So far I'd say the best show I've seen would be between Lamb of God, CKY (There's always an underdog), or Children of Bodom. Slayer had the craziest mosh pit (which is like saying a Ferrari goes fast). I'd continue but I can't help but feel I'm losing focus of the original point.
1
u/diamondjim Jun 12 '12
I started pirating music because the CD's that I bought and loved...eventually were damaged. I couldn't go to the store and exchange my now ruined copy for a new one.
I'm divided on this.
You don't expect a television to last forever, and when it eventually breaks after many years of use, you don't expect the manufacturer or store to provide you with a new one. You just get rid of the old piece and buy a new one.
However, in the case of music, the recording company is not selling you the physical CD, but a license to play the music on it. Your license is not bound to the physical condition of the disc. For fairness sake, you should be allowed to get the music from elsewhere and continue to listen to it as you have paid fair price for that privilege.
46
u/0011002 Jun 11 '12
Government is trolling hard
"Mr. Goodwin," the government's lawyers wrote, "can sue MegaUpload or Carpathia [Hosting, the company that hosted MegaUpload's servers] to recover his losses."
→ More replies (9)18
Jun 11 '12
a criminal defendant does not have a right to use someone else's money to finance his defense
"you need to pay for things you've done yourself"
and
"We took all of your data but we're not giving it back so get your compensation from these guys"
22
u/00Dan Jun 11 '12
Corporate censorship at it's finest.....
Sure, the web is great. Use the cloud, buy our services, only $9.99 a month.
But make sure you only use MPAA approved services, otherwise we'll delete your files. Why were you dealing with that scummy company anyways? Apple offers a competing service and they're government censorship approved!
16
Jun 11 '12
I move for a vote of no confidence in our current justice system
10
u/crawlingpony Jun 11 '12
You can
Support the us criminal justice reform act of 2011, by senator James Webb of Virginia. 39 senators have already signed on. Our effort can knock this over the tipping point.
3
Jun 11 '12
Don't you see the irony of having the obviously corrupt legislative system try to "reform" the judicial system? Our justice system is bad, but not nearly as fucked as the other branches. Be wary of Senators that want "reform". What they really mean is even more control and less oversight.
1
8
7
u/csmark Jun 11 '12
If ever there was a picture that had a 1,000 potential memes it's Kim DotCom's picture in this article.
5
u/whodiopolis Jun 11 '12
Funny you don't hear any politicians complaining about "big government" interfering with businesses regarding this case.
5
u/bigtoine Jun 11 '12
Finally, the government said if the court grants Goodwin's request, it would open the door for any third party to petition the courts any time a search warrant affects them adversely.
So that's not already the case?
17
Jun 11 '12
And this, ladies and gentlemen, is why I have a backup hard drive in case shit like this goes down.
3
3
u/jmdugan Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
The new Goodwin's law:
"The government really is screwing you."
3
Jun 11 '12
Returning videos to Kyle Goodwin, a former MegaUpload user, would set a bad precedent, the U.S. said in documents
Yeah, they wouldn't want to break their perfect track record of being complete assholes or anything.
3
7
2
u/Cross88 Jun 11 '12
Wow. It's amazing how differently the law applies depending on what side the corprorations are.
2
2
Jun 11 '12
I totally read this wrong and thought it said DJO blocks the return of Data... Was watching, expecting Day Job Orchestra.
2
u/firefeng Jun 11 '12
Just out of curiosity, why has there not yet been a class action lawsuit by "legitimate users" against the U.S. government for unlawful seizure of private data in this case?
I mean, aside from the fact that the U.S. government has to agree to be sued.
2
u/rima044 Jun 11 '12
I may be wrong, but in a more physical case, let's say a storage place gets raided because SOME units had drugs, wouldn't the other units be returned to their rightful owner? And the owner of the place would never get in trouble only the unit owners... Someone wanna correct me or am I on the right path?
2
u/chuperamigo Jun 11 '12
This fucking corporate owned U.S.G. is not going to stop until they are able to monitor and regulate every bit of information over the internet.
2
u/Tommyt125 Jun 11 '12
Utter WTFuckery, This whole article is maddening. Typical American "Nuke first, Fuck the questions forever" approach. I feel bad for all those legit users who lost data, I'm glad I never jumped on that bandwagon.
1
u/flynth99 Jun 11 '12
The saddest is that all this crap the US government does is making the world hate Americans as people. That cannot end well in the long run. It is only a matter of time before we will have an all out shooting(possibly nuclear) war of USA vs. the rest of the world.
1
u/Tommyt125 Jun 12 '12
I, fortunately, have many friends that are international students/grad students/ etc. I love being able to talk with them about the current state of affairs. It does suck because basically the whole world hates us, for good reasons.
2
u/tunapepper Jun 11 '12
Finally, the government said if the court grants Goodwin's request, it would open the door for any third party to petition the courts any time a search warrant affects them adversely.
And, what is wrong with that?
2
u/powercow Jun 11 '12
Goodwin's request, it would open the door for any third party to petition the courts any time a search warrant affects them adversely.
yes and this is a good thing. Innocent people should be able to petition the courts when they get caught up in the "pursuit of justice"
2
u/itsnotlupus Jun 11 '12
I wish journalists would have a little more balls.
Instead of uncritically repeating quotes from various players, they could write things like "actor X claimed Y, in spite of fact Z."
Instead, this article is repeatedly doing the opposite, presenting a claim from a party as an implicit fact, without the use of quotes.
As written, according to Greg Sandoval, necessary circumstances don't exist for the court to exercise its "equity jurisdiction."
Also according to Greg Sandoval, pirated movies and TV shows aren't currently circulated.
Are you sure, Greg?
2
u/mrpointer Jun 11 '12
Does anyone else notice the hypocrisy? Mr. Goodwin isn't allowed to use the "government's money" to get his own property back, but the government offers up the proposal Mr. Goodwin use his money to further the government's cause in persecuting MegaUpload by suing them. Essentially the government told a taxpayer he isn't entitled to use taxpayer funds to recover his rightful property, but that he should use personal funds to attack the target of the U.S. government. What a fucking joke.
Also the government owns no money. The government is trusted carefully to use the citizen's money to fund things the citizens don't want to overlook individually. Government's aren't entitled entities, they are representative entities.
2
2
u/tedrick111 Jun 11 '12
The funny thing about this is that we're actually funding the DOJ right now as we speak (at least the US job-holders in Reddit)
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/elliuotatar Jun 11 '12
"Mr. Goodwin's proposed solution is to have the government bear the financial cost of restoring his data," the U.S. Attorney's office wrote in its filing, "even if that means releasing assets of the defendants which are subject to mandatory forfeiture. Twenty-three years ago, the Supreme Court made clear that a criminal defendant does not have a right to use someone else's money to finance his defense."
What the hell does the second thing have to do with the first?
Also, who gets to decide that a criminal defendant's money is someone else's money, when said defendant is supposedly presumed innocent until proven guilty?
1
u/solwiggin Jun 11 '12
MegaUpload's managers allegedly enriched themselves by encouraging users from around the world to make illegal copies of movies, music, and ?software and then store that material on the company's servers.
Really? I wasn't aware Megaupload encouraged pirating... ALLEGEDLY...
1
1
Jun 11 '12
The DOJ cares more about appeasing RIAA, MPAA, and etc. more than ensuring that the individual citizens of the USA or world get a shake.
1
1
Jun 11 '12
Legitimate data should be returned. The government should be required to show cause for not returning data to the owner. Seems to me that the government needs an individual warrant for each person who has/had data on megaupload.
The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
1
Jun 11 '12
The good part of all this how it's all dragging out....something the MPAA didn't want. It's turned into a giant ball of confusion and they are stuck in mire. They won't be trying this trick too soon again.
1
u/Doctor_McKay Jun 11 '12
This is hillariously funny. The governement took down Megaupload because of "copyright infringement", and now they're denying this guy access to his copyrighted videos. The governement didn't even commit piracy here, they committed outright theft, which is worse than the piracy that they're trying to prevent. With piracy, the original still remains in control of its owner. With theft, the legitimate owner no longer has access to his work. The government removed these videos from the guy's possession, and are refusing him access to them.
1
1
Jun 11 '12
This is when reddit should probably pour the verbal anger of the internet onto the DoJ.
Anyone want to take the lead and find the email of the judge?
1
1
u/The-Internets Jun 11 '12
I bet some asshole was trying to use MegaUpload as their own personal wikileaks and caused all this bullshit.
1
u/MrCheeze Jun 11 '12
I was going to make a comment supporting their decision, but the circlejerk already has enough momentum that doing so would be impossible.
1
u/MrFrimplesYummyDog Jun 11 '12
Maybe I'm misinterpreting the details. A guy has his own legitimate content and he put it up on Megaupload's servers. Megaupload was closed. The man is upset that he can't get his content back. I do agree that sucks. But are people really uploading their own content and then deleting it, so that the ONLY copy is up on an internet storage site? Would the issue be moot if he had accessible copies, i.e. bought a few terabytes and backed up his data on that, and burned them to DVD or BluRay as a more permanent solution? I understand putting them on a net service for sharing - but it would seem the only reason to make such a fuss is if you have NO copies but this. I hope that's not the case and I am sincerely just misunderstanding this.
2
u/dutch_gecko Jun 11 '12
The details in this specific case is that he used Megaupload as a back up service. His hard drive crashed, and so he turned to his backups - which had been taken offline.
1
u/MrFrimplesYummyDog Jun 11 '12
Thanks! I'm not sure I really trust an internet based service for backups. Net connections are flaky, who knows when a company disappears - even for legit reasons (goes out of business, etc.) I'd like to believe that when a company closes it's doors that people will have a chance to get their stuff, but even just the other day I read about a brick and mortar store going out of business (wedding dresses) - they knew for a while they were having issues. One day, brides show up - doors locked. I think I still feel safer at this point committing backups to some media that I have control over.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/DMercenary Jun 11 '12
|Twenty-three years ago, the Supreme Court made clear that a |criminal defendant does not have a right to use someone else's |money to finance his defense."
But... Goodwin isnt the criminal defendant? What the fuck DoJ?
1
1
u/CreeDorofl Jun 11 '12
Nobody needs to have data "returned".
I dunno if reddit is sincerely confused about the difference between uploaded copies vs. local originals, or if we're all just pretending so we can make it sound like the government is unjust towards random innocent football fan.
1
u/evrlast985 Jun 11 '12
Seems like I should be liable to get my lawfully obtained copyrighted material back if I did nothing wrong. Not understanding the main problem here.
1
1
Jun 11 '12
The purpose of DOJ is to restrict freedom of criminals. Ideally.
So they (a) restrict freedom (b) of criminals
What is easier to implenent (a) or (b) - figuring out who is criminal or who is not?
1
1
u/shaolinpunks Jun 11 '12
I think this comment sums it up "Each user had their own storage shed. Just because some other users might use their storage shed for illegal purposes doesn't mean the government should be able to not just seize, but burn down, the entire complex." Didn't Megaupload abide by copyright takedown notices? If so I see no difference between it and YouTube. When there is a flagged copyrighted video on YouTube it gets taken down the site isn't seized by the government.
1
u/contrarian Jun 11 '12
This has nothing to do with technology. It's U.S. civil & criminal procedure, evidence, and property law.
1
u/Grimlokh Jun 11 '12
According to George W. Bush's executive order in 2006, "The order limits this use by stating that it may not be used "for the purpose of advancing the economic interest of private parties to be given ownership or use of the property taken."
thus he can sue the US government, DOJ, or anyone with their name on this for Subverting Eminent Domain laws found in the US constitution as well as a presidential Executive order by Bush.
1
1
u/KosherNazi Jun 11 '12
Reddit upvotes the shit out of this, yet will still vote for Obama in the fall and laugh at the "extremists" supporting Ron Paul.
2
3
u/Synergythepariah Jun 11 '12
Yes because supporting a candidate that wants to deregulate everything and let the businesses do whatever they wish dependant on the state laws.
You know, the fifty different states.
2
u/KosherNazi Jun 11 '12
Because a gargantuan, unresponsive, belligerant central authority that gives rise to abuses like the OP is better.
2
u/Synergythepariah Jun 11 '12
This is why you vote people that will respond into congress. That way they will be responsive as well as a president that will listen.
I don't particularly like the idea of having to memorize a new set of laws just to visit family in a different state.
Giving ALL of the rights to the states would result in fifty loosely governed countries under one weak, insignificant government.
→ More replies (6)
1
169
u/TruthinessHurts Jun 11 '12
Actually Mr. Godwin hasn't committed a crime, so claiming he's using someone elses money in his defense is bullshit.