r/technology • u/1nf • Jun 10 '12
Anti Piracy Patent Prevents Students From Sharing Books
http://torrentfreak.com/anti-piracy-patent-prevents-students-from-sharing-books-120610/954
Jun 10 '12
I love how this basically implies that libraries are criminal.
289
Jun 10 '12
Damn you crazy liberal, Benjamin Franklin! How dare you create something that obviously goes against the Constitution you helped write!
149
Jun 10 '12
Socialist. The Socialist Benjamin Franklin. Don't forget the socialists involved in the Great Library of Alexandria and all similar derivatives - libraries that we, with all our so-called grandeur as a society, have yet to replace in truth. Learning institutions for the public good? Not when there's no money involved. Not without politics. Not without indoctrination. Ideas are dangerous - best label them criminal.
→ More replies (9)106
Jun 10 '12
The textbook industry is the most blatant example of knowledge exploitation I can think of. Seriously, WTF has changed in the last 20+ years in basic undergrad biology, genetics, mathematics, physics, chemistry, etc.... that requires a new textbook every couple years?
→ More replies (43)24
u/why_ask_why Jun 10 '12
The Library of Congress will be biggest one. They get a copy of everything.
19
u/greenbowl Jun 10 '12
Actually a lot of university libraries (despite being EXTREMELY well reserved with books from every single subject), will not carry any textbooks for the sole purpose of making students pay for the books.
I know my university does that to popular courses.
→ More replies (4)12
u/Ethrinil Jun 11 '12
My university had a separate section of the library solely for the purpose of allowing students access to text books. There were no photocopiers in this area and you were not allowed to leave the area with the text book. I didn't buy text books outside of my core classes because of this and borrowing books from friends that were in the class or had taken it in the past.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)38
Jun 10 '12
No, it doesn't imply libraries are criminal. You can use the library as much as you want, but if you don't pay "protection," you don't pass the course no matter how well you know the material. This is simply a corruption matter.
27
u/therearesomewhocallm Jun 11 '12
The article does say:
Others facilitate piracy by placing texts in the library reserve.
→ More replies (3)
226
u/formesse Jun 10 '12
This sounds like pay to succeed. And that is wrong.
Edit: Referencing persons who have limited income to access the usually overpriced text books. Not to mention this effectively stops people from selling back textbooks completely.
31
u/TheGirlInTheCorner Jun 11 '12
I had a math book last semester that only had practice problems online. The book came with a code to allow us access to the online material, but it was only good for one semester and the class used the book for two semesters (math151 & math152) The publisher actually had the audacity to not allow students to use the book they purchased for their own class. Thats fucked up.
→ More replies (1)24
u/wanking_furiously Jun 11 '12
This kind of thing is illegal for Australian universities.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)20
Jun 10 '12
Yeah its a way of imposing via a complex and ugly route of Darwinism.
It's a return to the days when only the rich can afford education
→ More replies (6)64
368
u/driveling Jun 10 '12
When I went to school the University had ethics rules concerning professors who required their students to purchase books that they wrote.
209
u/tacojohn48 Jun 10 '12
I had a finance class with the professor who wrote the book. He had a new edition come out the semester I took the class. He opted not to adopt his own new version so that there would be used editions available for his students.
→ More replies (48)61
u/orthogonality Jun 10 '12
I had a professor who photocopied portions of his own book, so we wouldn't have to buy it.
50
u/midnitte Jun 10 '12
my professor writes up his own notes for us to use instead of using the $120 book. good guy, professors
→ More replies (5)19
u/Timmmmbob Jun 10 '12
Every single professor did this in my (well known UK) University. Most were fill-in-the-gaps, which sounds silly but actually works pretty well.
I never bought a single textbook in four years.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)28
u/WhipIash Jun 10 '12
Today he'd probably been sent to jail for copyright infringement...
→ More replies (6)62
u/ficshunfalse Jun 10 '12
On rare (VERY rare) occasions, you'll have a professor require their own books simply because they are the only person who has written on the topic, or at least they are one of the most well respected opinions on the topic.
But again, that's exceedingly rare.
20
Jun 10 '12
I have a professor like that, except it's a nice course specific incredibly useful and clear course pack for electrical engineering, and only $30. If you're gonna make it that useful and that cheap, I'm grateful. Otherwise I'd be paying $200 for some textbook that I have to sift through to look for the relevant parts.
→ More replies (5)29
u/bfish510 Jun 10 '12
The school I'm at has a lot of people like that. Most of them heavily reduce the cost of the book and some offer free pdf versions.
20
u/umlong23 Jun 10 '12
I've had to buy two text books written by profs that taught the class at my univeristy.
The first was a calculus textbook. It's a great, very well written textbook. It was the required text for the 5 calculus courses I had to take. It only covered the first half of the fifth course, so instead of making us buy another text book, the prof wrote an addendum to the textbook, had it printed in loose page format at the university copy centre, and sold it to the students for ~$10. Totally worth it.
The second was a communications textbook, and it was a steaming pile of shit. It hadn't been updated in over ten years and was completely useless. Thankfully there were two profs for this course, and I got the one who didn't write the book. She implored us not to buy the textbook, so I didn't. The prof who wrote it required every single student to buy it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (23)14
u/Decyde Jun 10 '12
Ego maniac retarded professors do this. It's worse if they wrote one damn paragraph, trust me as I am speaking from experience, because they fucking make you buy the outdated book from the bookstore and revolve 10 weeks around such paragraph.
→ More replies (3)
406
u/MrChaoticfist Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Go fuck yourself you old greedy man. Textbooks are marked up beyond fucking belief. The same books i buy in Canada should not cost 50% less in Europe. It should not be cheaper for me to ship books to Canada then to order the same book here.
Kindly go fuck yourself.
126
u/frankFerg1616 Jun 10 '12
Check this out: My Macroeconomics book costs $197 New, $150 Used (paperback) at my college's bookstore.
Using Bigwords.com, I found a copy of the book, new, for $49 with shipping included. The catch is that it's the "Global/International" edition. On the back cover, it claims that the book has different material form the US edition, and is therefore inappropriate for use in the US. I have yet to go through page by page, but by comparing the table of contents with the US edition (available online), it has the same exact content, just in different order and with different page numbers (I'll update when I can actually compare page by page)
This isn't the first time I've used International copies. Usually they're all the same exact content as the US edition, with nuances here and there (my calc book had one or two different practice problems every chapter from the US edition).
What I don't get is, how the hell can they sell books for much cheaper outside of the US in a way that would make 3rd parties be able to re-sell back to the US for real cheap compared to our local bookstore prices??? The ""economics"" baffles me. My MacroEcon class just started, and its my first econ/business type of class (I'm a bio/chem major). So I don'r really understand this stuff very much (thus my taking MacroEcon, so I can better understand it). If there's any econ savy people out there, if you could explain this shit to me, I'd be most grateful!
67
u/firstsnowfall Jun 10 '12
International versions are exactly the same as the US versions, only much cheaper.
I remember purchasing an international version of a psych textbook on Amazon once. One of the negative reviews was a woman who complained that it says on the cover that this edition cannot be used in the US. She accused the seller of breaking the law. I couldn't help but laugh at the stupidity of this woman.
→ More replies (4)19
u/DierdraVaal Jun 10 '12
These are 3 comp sci books I own. I've always wondered why they weren't allowed to be sold in the states.
They're already quite pricey here - if this (50-80 euros a book) is considered cheap in the US then I feel your pain.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (29)15
u/cyber_pacifist Jun 11 '12
My math teacher would distribute a bijective mapping showing how math problems in textbooks have been reordered between editions so that students can use either edition. Fucking publishers trying to make perfectly usable editions obsolete.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (9)9
u/WhipIash Jun 10 '12
And he dears to say we threaten their multimillion dollar industry? I can't even be sure I can afford food every day, I sure as hell don't got hundreds of extra dollars lying around for you.
→ More replies (1)
88
u/woppo Jun 10 '12
So students sharing textbooks is "a threat to the publishing industry."
Sharing is the foundation of society.
It would seem that the publishing industry, like Hollywood and the music industry, is threatening the basis of society.
I wonder how history will view them.
→ More replies (3)20
u/Aerithia1 Jun 11 '12
Just look at Star Trek. They'll view this exploitation of people who simply want to learn to better humanity as barbarism.
→ More replies (4)
165
u/frostycakes Jun 10 '12
How is this new? Just this past semester, I had to pay $90 or so for that WileyPlus bullshit in order to even be able to do my assignments in one of my classes, since I didn't want to pay the $280 for the textbook that had the access code included...and I actually did torrent the book later for that class anyways. Fucking scumbags.
50
u/kemikiao Jun 10 '12
Had to buy a brand new book so we could do the online assignments with the fancy code. We had ONE FUCKING online assignment that needed that fucking code. A 10 point assignment was not worth $150...
→ More replies (7)16
u/bettse Jun 10 '12
maybe this is tin foil hat territory, but I wonder if the professor got a kick back?
→ More replies (1)14
Jun 10 '12
The professor sets the assignments and their point value. Unless it was the most clueless/idiotic/hateful professor out there he got kickback on it.
Which still makes him a douche.
I can not see any scenario it is okay actually. Either he should not do his job because of incompetence or he should not do his job due to greediness.
→ More replies (3)24
Jun 10 '12
I did the same thing last semester, I don't get why they make us pay to do work in a class we already paid for to work in, It's crazy.
→ More replies (1)18
u/ja50n Jun 10 '12
I had to deal with the Wiley bs one quarter too and the greatest thing was that the school I went to already has a system in place for online homework.
→ More replies (3)13
u/frostycakes Jun 10 '12
My school's the same way, AND the instructor for the class had a D2L page for our section, where he could have made the assignments just as easily.
→ More replies (3)12
u/djdanlib Jun 10 '12
We students were doing that 10 years ago. It sucked then, and our naive attitudes about it and failure to change that system contributed to this. Sorry to have contributed :(
Learn from our mistakes... write letters to the schools, the publishers, the authors, your government. Protest this!
→ More replies (12)6
u/Osmodius Jun 11 '12
Fucking worthless cunt of a system anyway. I don't know how something as important as assignments can be left to something as absolute as a YES/NO computer system. Doesn't mark on working out. Doesn't mark on partial answers. If you get the first part of a question wrong, there's no way to finish the next part, even if you know how to.
It's a fucking horrible system.
→ More replies (2)
79
u/Ripudio Jun 10 '12
Fuck this guy. When publishers charge a reasonable price for books I'm all for buying them, but $250 for a book that barely even gets used that can't be sold back (for MAYBE 10-20% of the original purchase price, and only if a new edition hasn't come out already) is obscene.
"Professors won't have a chance to publish" wah-wah, maybe if you published something actually WORTH reading, I would want to read it. Requiring your students to supplement your salary with publishing royalties is just plain unethical.
→ More replies (6)
57
u/I_mengles Jun 10 '12
As a university professor, I find this proposal outrageous. I refuse to punish students for being on a budget. I further refuse to hold a student's grade hostage until they have paid ransom, which is what this is really about. Deplorable.
11
53
Jun 10 '12
"Students who don’t pay can’t participate in the course and therefore get a lower grade"
Because your grade should be based on your money, not on if you've mastered the material. Here's an idea: instead of supporting publishers in this manner, let's support open source textbooks, and projects like that.
3
u/el_guapo_taco Jun 11 '12
Whoa, is this accurate..? Pitch fork and torch are ready to go.. Just need to make sure I'm pointing at the right guy.
Edit: Answered my own question. It is!
100
u/DavidWilliams81 Jun 10 '12
I guess Richard Stallman isn't so crazy after all: The Right to Read
27
u/shadowman42 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Man I hate it whan he's right. He can be such a pessimist.
12
→ More replies (9)11
Jun 11 '12
I don't think he's ever been wrong. All his predictions are either validated, or pending.
→ More replies (2)
37
u/tankgirl85 Jun 10 '12
the profs at my university(the one's I have so far) have went out of their way to make sure we got cheap or even free books. Either by posting them on-line for us(they would photocopy and upload or post an e version) or making course plans that didn't rely on those stupid on-line added features most books come with (as my psych professor said " when they can send me data that proves these on-line courses improve test scores, I will make them mandatory, until then...") my profs even send out emails during the summer to let us know what texts we will use, and where on-line they have found them for a lower price. I really hope this never changes, it makes me feel like my profs give a shit, and that they understand and care that I am not a person with a bottomless wallet. I understand that paying for books keep publishing alive, but it's bullshit that they constantly revise the books every year so that you have to buy a new one.. I would pay a small fee to access a site that contains the revisions, instead of having to get a whole new book because they added a picture or changed one paragraph....maybe they do more than that, but really, how much can text book info change in one year.
→ More replies (10)10
u/Aulritta Jun 10 '12
My Microbiology professor, as part of his introductory e-mail, stated that he assigned us a textbook and readings to complete prior to each class period. In the next sentence he said, "Consider this textbook supplementary material only, as all tests are constructed from material covered in lecture."
In the class itself, he admitted that most everybody who passed didn't need the text, but he had to assign it or else his dean would wonder why...
→ More replies (2)5
u/poischiche Jun 11 '12
This is a good point-- there is often a lot of pressure coming from upstairs about these textbooks. I've taken my share of flak from admin/colleagues about not making textbooks obligatory for my students, because the books are expensive/unnecessary and we can cover the necessary material in class.
26
u/h-v-smacker Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
So basically, the guy offers to sell access to higher marks. E.g. if the participation is 10% of the final mark and the textbook is $200, it means that by buying the code (with or without the book) you essentially pay $200 for unlocking a bonus to your mark, like some extra weapon from DLC in videogames. Why then all this complicated bullshit? Why not just set a fee for increasing the mark or sell some coupons/vouchers, and go along with it? E.g. $100 per half-letter. So if one is expected to get a B-, $300 will turn it into a solid A. It also saves trees and stuff.
8
u/TheBenno Jun 10 '12
this is exactly what i was thinking, why not just purchase the remaining 85% of your grade too
6
u/h-v-smacker Jun 10 '12
Also, there can be mass discounts. E.g. buy "mark coupons" in bulk in the beginning of the year and get each for $30 less! And then there can be a lottery, you know, like the green card ones: among those who donate to the University, a bunch of diplomas get awarded with probability based on amount of donations. There are so many other ways to make education fun and completely worthless!
→ More replies (2)5
u/mikemaca Jun 11 '12
That's a really good point. That part of the grade is not based on doing work, it's based on paying the professor money. It comes down to that and only that.
Let's say what it is: This is a patent on a system where you pay money to the professor to get a higher grade.
23
u/edubyah Jun 10 '12
This pisses me off a lot. Publishers will slap a new cover on a textbook and sell it as a "new" edition even though the content is exactly the same to make more money. The people who worked the buyback at my school were such dicks that if you didn't take $3 for a book that cost me $100 they would make snide remarks like, "Enjoy your paperweight." No thanks assholes I rather give it away to some poor college student or burn it than let you make a ridiculous profit.
10
Jun 11 '12
At my university, they sent an email out that said you need a permit to sell a book to another student or there would be repercussions. Fuck them, I'm not putting an extension on my house I'm selling a fucking book.
6
u/edubyah Jun 11 '12
wow seriously? that's so stupid, sell dat book!
p.s. If you are still in college and don't know about half.com, get on it. I bought all my books from there for super cheap. You can sell yours there easily too.
6
u/thecheese_cake Jun 11 '12
I question the legal validity of what was said in that email.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Luxray Jun 11 '12
My school offered me something like 12 bucks for a book I paid $90 for. I sold it online for about 45.
→ More replies (1)
22
Jun 10 '12
It's a shame the educated are selling out our long-term future for some short-term profit. As a people, we should be offering education to everybody who wants it. Who knows where the next Edison, Tesla, or Einstein will come from? Could be a poor kid in Ethiopia who just happens to be brilliant beyond any previously recorded measure. The richest might have dragon blood or whatever myth they perpetuate, but if they're shoving the smart aside in favor of the randomly fortunate, they're damning the future. Worse, they probably know it and don't care.
→ More replies (6)13
Jun 10 '12
No, they just don't care. Money is the only thing that matters these days, society can go fuck itself as far as the colleges are concerned.
21
u/HK-4orty7even Jun 10 '12
May Khan Academy crush this! (and no, it has nothing to do with Klingons)
→ More replies (5)
20
37
u/elustran Jun 10 '12
Boycott his classes. Shun him from all polite society. Try to get him fired. Sue him for whatever is possible.
Fuck this sociopathic bullshit.
76
u/harmsc12 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Students already pay obscene amounts just to have a seat in the room. This idea just smacks of the same damn greed that's strangling this economy already. NO MORE DEBT!!!!!
edit: A clearer head remembers a short story by Richard Stallman predicting this very path for academic literature.
→ More replies (8)
46
u/geon Jun 10 '12
This is retarded on so many levels.
Why the convoluted process? Just make buying the book directly from the publisher a requirement to take the class at all.
Call me a naïve idealist, but I think knowledge should be freely accessible. How can someone devote their life to teaching, and then not make their teaching as accessible as possible? Do they do it for money only?
And don't tell me it's not feasible to make textbooks free and open. The software industry is doing fine with open source.
→ More replies (8)21
Jun 10 '12
Well, he taught economics. He is of the opinion that "There's no such thing as a free lunch," which is a totally true statement. His books, or any other books for that matter, are the result of many, many hours of hard labor by the authors. I understand why he would think this.
Nevertheless, I totally agree with you. Knowledge is free, and I imagine that every professor who is worth his weight in gold would agree. This guy is a prof that I would never never never never take.
→ More replies (3)49
u/philbee Jun 10 '12
See, in Germany, professors aren't allowed to require a text book. They can recommend it for further reading, but they can't tell you that you need a book. Result: almost every class has a course pack with the professor's own notes that you can use to study. This is, of course, ideal, because it means you get a book with the exact material that is covered in the class and no other garbage. You know exactly what to study for the exam, and it's covered in the same order that you covered it in class. Also, you can get it by pdf and print it only if you want to. So basically, it's part of the professor's job to develop these notes--US professors outsource this task to book publishers.
→ More replies (10)
16
Jun 10 '12
What fucking pisses me off is how a college book store will charge $100+ for a book and then try to give you $5 to sell it back to them if you are lucky enough that they will buy it back from you at all.
→ More replies (1)3
u/mikemaca Jun 11 '12
LifeHack: When I was in school I'd take the textbooks to the first class during the next semester and offer to sell to the students leaving the class the book for $10 less than the bookstore charges used. Example: $120 textbook, used price $100, I sell for $90. There was always several people rushing to pull out their wallets and I ended up much better than accepting the $1-$15 or so they paid for buybacks.
16
u/Random Jun 10 '12
I'm a prof, and this is fucking disgusting.
Yet another way to screw students. As if a new edition a year and $180 for a textbook that should cost $40 at the most isn't enough.
Yet another reason for open source, fuck the publishing companies, textbooks.
Any university that punishes students who don't buy the textbook should be mocked.
Wow. Just wow.
→ More replies (1)
15
u/CaptainChewbacca Jun 10 '12
How much you want to bet this professor is the kind of asshole who revises his own textbook every year to keep sales up?
→ More replies (1)
14
u/timobedlam Jun 10 '12
Professor of Economics Joseph Henry Vogel is a huge dick.
→ More replies (2)
13
u/mosesmanomg Jun 10 '12
It is just one more way that Universities are separating the haves and have-nots. Making College just out of reach of the have-nots.
11
10
u/Niel_deTrees_Tyson Jun 10 '12
This guy is a hack. If he's an Economics professor at UPR-Rio Piedras (A mid to low tier school that excels in hard science more than anything else), it's not photocopying that's preventing him from being published and competing with the N. Greg Mankiws of the world.
9
u/Wurmcoil_Engine Jun 10 '12
Oh, so we don't have to pay an arm and a leg for school and textbooks already? This guy reminds me of this teacher I had who wrote the textbook for his class and "updated" it every year so students had to buy the new version.
→ More replies (2)
9
8
u/drphilthy Jun 10 '12
they have been doing this. not only does it suck but it makes the book worthless when you try to sell it back. Its no good without the code. If you try and buy just the code its super overpriced. And online textbooks expire after 6 months. I think we need to fuck over the publishing companies as much as we can. fucking scam.
8
Jun 10 '12
Wait, are they trying to assert that buying used books is illegal?
→ More replies (1)3
u/Dont_deport_me_bro Jun 11 '12
And libraries are underground black market terrorist organizations that support al-qaeda.
→ More replies (1)
8
8
8
u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 10 '12
How the fuck is requiring an access code to login to a forum patentable?
7
Jun 10 '12
The same crank econ professor wrote this book. Sounds like Ronald Coase on crack. Well, more crack.
12
6
u/_fp_ Jun 10 '12
“Professors are increasingly turning a blind eye when students appear in class with photocopied pages. Others facilitate piracy by placing texts in the library reserve where they can be photocopied,” Vogel writes.
Yes, the FSM forbid that you put textbooks in the library for people who can't afford them can read them. Oh silly me, apparently the only reason for putting a book on reserve on the library is to pirate it. Clearly, the solution is to ban libraries altogether, with their quaint notions of lending books and all that...
19
Jun 10 '12
Nearly every day I read something that makes me happy that I went to college in the pre-internet era.
47
Jun 10 '12
Not me. There was a sweet spot for the wild west unrestricted internet which I loved.
My professor proudly announced that a course would bedistributedsold in PDF form, and not to even bother trying to break the super secret unbreakable DRM.
I had that .rar packaged up and on an FTP site before dinner.12
14
u/nihilisma Jun 10 '12
Me too.
And as I am soon going to be a professor myself, I will be ACTIVELY looking for ways to provide the poorer students in my class with FREE books. Clandestinely, of course; I do not want to get sued to oblivion by some billion dollar company.
→ More replies (2)
17
u/philko42 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Let's ignore corporate greed here for a moment...
As it gets easier and easier for students to avoid purchasing textbooks, it gets harder for textbook writers to get compensated for the time it took them to write the book.
If we want textbooks to continue to be written then we have to find a way to make it worth the author's time to do so. Some options:
Dickhead moves like the one described in this article.
Disadvantage: Forces every student to pay, even those who can't afford to.
Advantage: Every teacher has the ability to ignore the online component, turning the situation into the existing one.
Simply raising the price of textbooks.
Disadvantage: Encourages more sharing/copying/pirating, which will then require further raising of prices.
Advantage: Nothing about the current system needs to change (except for the possible addition of a digit to the price stickers)
Coming up with an entirely new way to compensate authors.
One possibility: If a teacher decides to use a textbook for a given class, the school would pay the publisher and the actual books would be free to all enrolled students. Teachers would be provided with a set budget per class and would have to choose texts within that limit.
Advantages: EVERYONE would get a book; schools could use existing financial aid systems to spread the cost burden based on ability to pay; teachers would be discouraged from "requiring" books and never using them in the friggin class
Disadvantage: I can't really think of any.
Edit: Another possibility occurs to me: Embedded advertising / product placement. It makes me cringe, but it could definitely help subsidize content creation.
Advantage: Keeps the current publishing model in place, but brings textbook prices down.
Disadvantages: Oh, where to begin?
13
Jun 10 '12
I can think of a disadvantage: publishers and authors would be constantly harassing and marketing to teachers to pick their books. This is currently happening to doctors. Pharma companies are constantly sending trinkets, sales people, etc to clinics to convince doctors to use their brand of drugs. It's gotten corrupted in some circles, to the point of free dinners, holidays and other kickbacks.
The downside of this is that sometimes the marketing works, and doctors will pick a particular drug to prescribe to patients, even though it may not be the best choice.
Same could happen with teachers. They could end up picking really shitty textbooks because they got bigger benefits. Even if they didn't succumb to constant marketing (which I'm sure happens now, but your system would cause it to become more aggressive), it would at least be wasting teachers' time.
I agree with everything else you said, but that system you proposed is too ripe for corruption.
→ More replies (1)7
u/philko42 Jun 10 '12
How would it be different than it is now? Teachers are currently marketed to, with the goal of having them list a book as required for their course.
→ More replies (10)4
u/CaptainChewbacca Jun 10 '12
Or they could come up with an inexpensive way to sell/distribute the textbook.
→ More replies (7)
5
u/ChasenTheBears Jun 10 '12
Of the many things wrong with this idea, I find this to be the most frustrating.
"Vogel’s idea leaves the option open for students to use second-hand textbooks, but they still have to buy an access code at a reduced price. This means publishers can charge multiple times for a book that was sold only once."
5
5
u/WhipIash Jun 10 '12
The industry is fucking huge already, they make literally millions of dollars, and on top of that they often come out with the same book only slightly changed every year so we can't buy the old ones. And nowthey want to make it illegal for us to help each other out so we won't have to give them an extra $100 when I can't even afford food every day? Yeah, their industry is in the shitter, I'll tell ya.
→ More replies (1)
49
u/Inukii Jun 10 '12
They can fuck off...
I went to University. I studied music technology and production. I had to get a lot of books out from the Library.
And you know what? I never got a fucking job or learnt anything god damn relevant to my studies. I'm currently unsuccessfully freelancing. I also had to invest all of my grant money into buying hardware and software so I could ACTUALLY learn what I went to uni for in the first place.
So this student-book-pirate relationship thing can entirely go to hell until Universities start deciding they want to teach me and not "Test" me.
7
u/skooma714 Jun 11 '12
Most of my professors are just glorified powerpoint narrators. Seems like the only value-added thing they offer is tests
→ More replies (14)10
u/UnexpectedSchism Jun 11 '12
How does your rant about your shitty choice of major apply to shitty textbook publishers?
8
4
u/NZDarkFalcon Jun 10 '12
I only ever bought books in my first year of university and I never read them, in my third year now and I don't buy any. The lecturers have suggested course books but always link to every thing you need to know on their websites anyway. Example of one of my papers webpages: http://www.cs.waikato.ac.nz/~tcs/COMP317/index.html
4
4
u/greiton Jun 10 '12
you can follow a link to his website which has his email address i say let him know how we all feel about being forced to pay extra for used copies.
4
u/defecto Jun 10 '12
Lets make it harder for people to learn... as if we don't have an education problem already. Only way forward is for people to learn and smarten up, I hate all these barriers to education, not to mention high tuition.
4
Jun 10 '12
I was told in one of my classes that had these things called I-clickers (a way for the prof to get large scale responses, which luckily was optional in that class) that sharing one, even if it is for different courses, would count as academic dishonesty and could get you expelled.
→ More replies (4)
4
Jun 10 '12
I might be somewhat ok with this if the professors, who require students to purchase only their 10 piece of paper pamphlet for the class, DON'T charge $300 for it. I worked at a university book store for a short while and saw students who would tell me they only have 3 classes that semester and were spending $3000 on the 4 books alone. Make the cost of the books something everyone can reasonably afford then we'll talk. Til then he can go fuck himself.
4
u/scienceisneat Jun 10 '12
Books are expensive to begin with and this asshole is basically saying that unless you can afford a new book, you don't get to learn. And no, the publishing industry does NOT have a place in my classroom.
Needless to say, publishers are excited about gaining more control in the classroom.
This line in particular bothers me. If anything, students need more control in the classroom. Education in the US is not based on an open-knowledge society, it's a multi-million dollar capitalist market. For me, that's not okay. The second you start making money off of people trying to learn, you compromise their academic journey.
4
u/winteriscoming2 Jun 10 '12
Others facilitate piracy by placing texts in the library reserve where they can be photocopied
Or do their studying in the library for free. What about students like me who buy used books from Amazon? Do I get a code? What if it is an old edition?
My guess is that this is really intended to shut down the perfectly legal second-hand market.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Oiman Jun 10 '12
Wikipedia and khanacademy are both free and have helped me pass more subjects than any text book ever has. This idea is against anything education stands for.
There should be a "textbookpedia", where everyone can contribute to a certain subject. Almost like Wikipedia, but organised per course as they would be taught in college/university. Complete with excercises/solutions and a tablet friendly layout. Anyone can write an explanation or expand a subject, but people would vote, very Reddit-wise, on the best possible explanation, culminating into "standard" textbooks used by all universities.
Also, it should be called WikiPearson, just to fuck with those guys.
→ More replies (2)
4
4
7
8
u/alphadogkp Jun 10 '12
From the article: "He believes that piracy, lending and reselling of books is a threat to the publishing industry."
Who cares? If the publishing industry can't figure out a way to move forward with technological advances they should fall/die as an industry. As an economics professor, the guy who made this patent should know this. And once again, students aka some of the most poor people on the planet are forced to spend more money...
3
u/CpnCornDogg Jun 10 '12
yeah because being a proffesor is about the money and not about teaching the future generations. Also it seems like this guy is trying to make a way to pay for grades......sad sad shit
3
u/Kah-Neth Jun 10 '12
Wow, so I looked at his webpage, then I looked that the abstracts and previews for his books. This guy is a fucking nutcase.
3
3
u/LolRaquel Jun 10 '12
Seriously fuck this guy. I get grants for school that cover my tuition fees but I still have to pay for my books, and there have STILL been times in the past where I had to drop a class because all the texts and materials were just too expensive. I once dropped a history class because for the same amount of money it would take me to buy my books and materials for that one class, I could have bought everything for all my other classes combined and still had money left over.
Also I worked at my campus bookstore earlier this year and I always felt so bad for the students when they came in and found out that their required text for a class was the brand new, latest edition written by their professor specifically for that class and there was absolutely no other option than paying the full price. I always tried to help students find the lowest possible price for a book but sometimes it was inevitable. =/
3
u/aschla Jun 10 '12
"He believes that piracy, lending and reselling of books is a threat to the publishing industry."
The implementation of this patent is a threat to the spread of knowledge on a much greater scale than the sharing is a threat to the publishing industry.
On a separate note, so public libraries...
3
Jun 10 '12
Im sorry buy copyright laws are bull shit! If I want to borrow a damn book, watch me do it! Then they cut off financial aid so how tge hell are poor college kids supposed to afford all this?
3
u/billmcneal Jun 10 '12
Great. Let's keep the poor uneducated and further convolt higher education with more and more debt. Every layer aside from actually good professors is making it harder to get an education.
Slightly off topic, my Alma Mater is currently building a very expensive football stadium, after completeing a new Student Union building a few years ago, and cutting many department budgets for, you know, learning. It could be my indifference towards athletics, but I actively hate those who feel that collegiate level sports are part of the "college experience" and deserve funding over actual education. I couldn't care less about someone else's "experience" when it actively impairs my educational endeavors. I went to college to get an education, not to cheer on a bunch of sweaty people hitting each other for two hours.
3
u/hiphopchef Jun 10 '12
I want to round up a few good men and burn this Vogel character at the stake! Who's with me?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/vaeiou_gaming Jun 11 '12
I like to think that education is about the sharing of intellectual discourse and ideas. Realistically, I know that, like many things in life, education is a way to segregate groups of people. Educated / Uneducated, Rich / Poor, etc. This patent does not bode well for those who really need textbooks. Hint: lack of education => being poor => can't afford textbooks.
It breaks my heart to see education increasingly become more of a paid service, like going to McDonalds and ordering a Big Mac - except you're ordering a Bachelors of Happy Meal that comes with a toy called a diploma. Now, in order to buy the Happy Meal this professor is making you buy an extra side of french fries and telling you not to share it.
Why do we need DRM for education?
→ More replies (1)
3
5
u/Michichael Jun 10 '12
Everything you need to learn to succeed is available for free on the Internet. Until people realize that education is overrated and you can learn what you want, when you want, from the Internet - instead of just using it for pictures of cats and reddit.
3
u/schizoidvoid Jun 10 '12
Everything you need except the little fucking piece of paper that makes you magically employable. Not that it gives you an advantage! No, it just saves your resume from the shredder.
→ More replies (6)
5
u/alphadogkp Jun 10 '12
Charging money for knowledge and information. Holding back the human race since...a really long time.
2
u/ProcceedToFuckShitUp Jun 10 '12
Furthering the divide between how much alcohol the rich and poor can afford to drink a semester.
2
2
2
u/latebaroque Jun 10 '12
This makes me wonder why textbooks aren't included in the fee for third level education. If it was then people would stop pirating them because they would have already paid for them.
Well, whether the additional fee for the inclusion of text books would be reasonable or not would be another thing altogether.
2
u/DrMasterBlaster Jun 10 '12
I can see faculty revolting over something like this. A vast majority of them are sympathetic to the price of textbooks, and in graduate school they even go so far as to create a "book" of freely available research articles to avoid textbooks in the first place.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Breakingblueforyou Jun 10 '12
All it takes is professor boycott of the system and it all goes to hell.
2
u/Red_Spork Jun 10 '12
This isn't really new at all. With many Physics and Calculus courses at my university you have to buy the book to get the WebAssign access code or purchase it on the side so you can do the homework and it isn't cheap.
2
2
u/Rohaq Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I can understand them having problems with students photocopying books and pirating them, but this is not the way to fix it.
What happens to students who buy their books second hand? Or go to the library? I bought most of my books second hand during university. In my first year alone, I managed to get all of my recommended reading books for the year for about £80 used. If I'd bought them new, it would have been around £300-400. I did not have rich parents, and would have had a thoroughly difficult year if I'd had to pay full price for all of my reading material. I made good use of the library and legal online book services throughout university too.
I've got to say, I'm very interested to see what the response will be if universities start allowing for marks to be reduced for not buying reading materials from what would have to be authorised sellers.
For a start, you're reducing marks despite students having potentially the same quality of work, simply because one decided to say, lend a book from a library, rather than purchase it.
Secondly, you're setting up a monopoly if you can only purchase books from a particular reseller or the publisher directly in order to avoid losing those marks.
I'm sure that the book industry has suffered with the increase in the availability of sources through the internet, and the more widespread acceptance of online sources by universities, but this is a terrible way of responding to it.
Is there anybody here with a legal background that has an idea of what kind of position this places students in if they find their marks reduced for not making a 'required' purchase?
2
u/bbth Jun 10 '12
AS a college professor, I find this downright evil. I would never recommend a textbook that was encumbered like that.
2
u/benj23673 Jun 10 '12
This idea just kind of hit me, a textbook library for example you set up a library just off a college campus charge students $300 a semster they can borrow books anytime for the semester if the library does not have your book they order it? I dont know I am just a dumb college kid might work one day?
2
u/Technosnake Jun 10 '12
I love how these patents are now stooping as low as to stop the flow of education
2
Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I had a professor who made us buy his book. It turns out his book is actually just a summary of 5 other books, which he also forced us to buy.
The whole course was basically one long session in how you too can pass on other peoples' ideas as your own as long as you are so blatant about it nobody thinks to question you.
It was really bad. Our reading assignments consisted of a chapter of his book that mostly contained massive quotes and paraphrasing, and the exact works that he just copy/pasted from. With full citations of course, he did not plagiarize I want to make that clear. I think he just found the perfect books for his course. Why he had to write his own book which was just the best parts of the other 4-5 I don't know.
I don't think he added any of his own thoughts on it (the material), it was just a "Here is the information. I will test you by asking you to write it back to me in paper format." I ended up dropping a whole letter grade because I stopped going to the class. It was just two hours of re-reading what we were assigned to the class. And listening to other people read aloud is something I can't abide for two hours, especially if it's information I've read myself and is therefore old fucking news. And I try to abide most things.
I don't doubt the guy's passion for his work, and the material was very interesting and something I may not have learned otherwise.
Edit-I need to proofread better.
2
u/Amonette Jun 10 '12
This would only be an acceptable idea if the book and course code were only distributed electronically and the price was made significantly lower and more affordable. By that logic they would be making everyone buy the text (more actual sales) but at a more affordable price. If they're just going to be greedy and charge the regular price, they're being assholes.
If you want to deal with the fact that piracy threatens the future quality of textbooks, you need to do so by realising that the old model doesn't work any more. Textbooks are bloody expensive, and by making students limit their choice of texts by making each one full price instead of borrowed or second hand, their own ability to learn and read around the subject is impaired, it's like limiting people to three vitamins a day and them wondering why they all have rickets.
Another way to do it would be to have some kind of subscription service where you could download the text you needed for a fixed monthly fee that was means tested by the college.
2
Jun 10 '12
If this does get passed. I hope there are some pissed off students who pay for the access, then screencap every page of all the books they had to buy. Share with friends / upload to torrent sites.
Anyone who has been to college knows much the publishers and bookstores themselves rip students off. Fuck them
2
2
2
u/tblackwood Jun 10 '12
I'm graduating college in a week- the most bullshit part of this is the incestuous relationship between the textbooks/ required books and the professors. This guy complains that it reduces his chances of getting published, but that's because most (but not all) professors are shitty authors who write shitty textbooks that would rightfully warrant shitty sales, UNLESS THEY CAN FORCE A CAPTIVE AUDIENCE TO BUY THEM. The worst part, is that this captive audience is not only forced to buy the shitty book, but they have to do so at a shitty inflated price. Altogether, a shitty experience. For some students, especially the ones who have to take out shitty college loans, the unsuspected and rising shitty cost of shitty textbooks can bankrupt them, which is a shitty economic state to be in. This patent also seeks to add a shitty component to class grades (some shitty online forum where shitty, forced discussion may or may not take place). Altogether, I find this professor to be a shithead.
2
2
Jun 10 '12
Does anyone know where I can find an email or a school inbox to send a letter to this professor? This is a disgusting idea whose only purpose is to exploit students.
This guy is a scumbag trying to continue to turn academia into a business, rather than the pursuit of truth and knowledge.
2
2
Jun 10 '12
I had a history prof who bought all the texts of marx and lenin from the chinese government bureau of propaganda. He they sold them to the class at cost. It was a about $6 for all the books. They had manilla paper covers and glue spines. But they were fine for students. Coolest thing I ever saw a prof do.
2
u/Razorfiend Jun 10 '12
As if college wasn't already expensive enough. It's assclowns like this that reduce my faith in humanity to almost nil. The only way I could possibly see such a policy working is if the price of textbooks also dropped considerably.
2
u/TissueReligion Jun 10 '12
Guys! This is actually a great thing for book piracy! Think about it! If the publishers are happy that they're getting their fair share from students buying their products, then they won't go off and shut down things like gigapedia.
...maybe.
2
Jun 10 '12
Hey those damn students have wayyyy too much money to waste on everything. Let's milk'em some more, it'll show 'em not to starve or try bein' educated !
2
2
u/forgotmyfuckingname Jun 10 '12
Fuck. This. Fucking. Fuck-tarded. Fuck. Of. A. Fucking. Professor. Fuck. Fuck. Fuckity. Fuck. Fuck. Fuckerson.
2
u/rcbarnes Jun 10 '12
Oh, give the guy a break. He's just trying to earn a living in the far beyond his kin world of academia. I mean, how else could he earn his salary?
He's too lazy to just tweak some of the questions/examples each semester and publish new editions to eliminate resale and limit the duration of photocopies' value.
He's too stupid to recognize the gaping holes in his reasoning are at odds with premises of his entire field.
He's too ignorant to discover the ample prior art that essentially nullifies his patent claims.
*He's to socially inept to anticipate the massive backlash publicizing his absurd opinion on scope "intellectual property" rights will raise (especially in a career that values sharing knowledge more than nearly any other imaginable).He's too oblivious to see the appalling implications of his inane solution that exacerbate economic injustices good people have been striving for years to mitigate.
He's too irrational and egocentric in his reasoning to possibly be able to teach students anything nontrivial.
Clearly that just leaves him the one option of "try to pioneer new ways to limit the flow of knowledge that allow him to outsource the actual development and maintenance of the mechanisms that enforces said public hindrance, then extort as much money as possible from those who lack the freedom to select their own information resources."
That felt good enough that it's wholly worth the deluge of downvotes my tone and style are sure to attract.
2
u/jacob6875 Jun 10 '12
Just an example of how stupid this industry is: I took an entry level criminal justice class just for an elective and I bought the book (published in 2010) for around $50. Once the class ended I went to sell it back and they told me it wasn't work anything. So I went and looked at the new 2011 textbook and the only that that had changed was the cover. They literally changed the color of the cover from yellow to red and replaced the year 2010 with the year 2011. The rest of the book was identical.
2
u/3dogs3catsandahedgeh Jun 10 '12
I just went through this. I am taking an online class in medical terminology, and without a special code, I could not take the quizzes online that were necessary for my grade. The price for the online code? 52.00, in addition to the 115.00 for the PAPERBACK text. I was furious. The interesting thing is that I found out the code would work for 6 months, so if students planned it well, theoretically two students could use the same code, in Spring/Summer term. I really detest the cost of texts, the monopoly that is the textbook industry, and just how awful most of the texts are to read and use. And don't get me started on the business model for colleges. The whole attitude is that students should be grateful for being permitted to study at a particular college, not that they are the customer and should be courted, solicited, and satisfied as a customer should be. Bad professors are rampant, and cannot teach or communicate the subject they are assigned. Education is less about learning than it is about jumping through the necessary hoops. I learn more from Khan Academy than from a 400.00 class. But I get no credit for Khan Academy. I look forward to the day when college is a competitive business focused on providing for the needs of its students.
2
u/Zer_ Jun 11 '12
What next, DLC for Academic books?
"Uh Professor? My book doesn't have Chapter IV."
"Oh yeah, that's DLC, you gotta buy that chapter separately."
2
u/a_tad_rapey Jun 11 '12
Fuck this guy.
It's sad that a professor can be this stupid.
Yeah guy, let's find a way to make income affect education even more.
2
2
Jun 11 '12
I don't understand why people from the educated, 1st world, haven't come to the understanding that if people want to pirate something.... they will.
In this case, students will either group together and buy access and then screen capture it, or copy and paste it, ...something....will work. I've never seen a product that was copy protected that stayed that way, because if it was created by a human mind, it can be defeated by a human mind. What's that saying... if you have a million monkey's typing a million pages a day eventually one of them will type out War and Peace.. All inventions will be broken...
Props to this guy though, because I'm sure publishing companies will license his technology and the scam that is college will become even more obfuscated, more expensive and less of a good idea to those who really "get it".
tldr; don't try to lock people out of information... all copy protection is breakable somehow...fuck this guy...
2
u/Haljegh Jun 11 '12
This is fucking stupid. Greedy fucks need to embrace the ability to share information freely instead of trying to make a profit on it.
2
u/Beefaice Jun 11 '12
Talk about restriction of knowledge. Does this guy want to make libraries illegal now?
2
u/PatternWolf Jun 11 '12
I'm usually sympathetic to copyright holders to some extent but college books prices can go fuck themselves.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/BlueTengu Jun 11 '12
The day I hear that someone kicked Prof. Vogel so hard that his kids shit blood, is the day I bake a nice lasagna and offer it as a sacrifice of thanks to the Great Spaghetti Monster.
2
u/burntheblobs Jun 11 '12
I always like to pop in threads like these and share my textbook deal finding website. It doesn't usually get a lot of love, but I do it anyway! http://textspyder.com
→ More replies (1)
2
u/macgabhain Jun 11 '12
As a professor I'd just like to say that this asshole can rot in hell. If hell doesn't exist, someone should create it so he can rot in it.
Over the last 10 years the major textbook companies -- there are only three major cross-disciplinary ones left -- have been getting more and more clever in ways to prevent a legitimate used market. They don't need people who are supposed to advocate for students helping them out.
2
Jun 11 '12
The reason I hate all this piracy stuff is because I think it is total bullshit that people think they own knowledge and have the power to keep that knowledge.
I was once discussing to my professor the boundaries of putting citations on my paper. He claims that "any information I read anywhere that I use on the paper has to be cited or it's plagiarism."
I said, "what if I already have the knowledge and I don't hold the source in easily recoverable memory." He claimed that in that case you didn't need to cite.
Now, I'm all about giving credit where it is due to researchers and such, but when I read a book and learn things the knowledge I gain is mine now. I should be able to use that knowledge. The information had to have been discovered sometime who's to say that I'm not smart enough to come to my own conclusions and come to this knowledge by myself.
TL;DR I think "intellectual property" is fucking bullshit. knowledge in general should be free and shared.
2
u/historianLA Jun 11 '12
As a professor at a public university, I think this is despicable. I would never adopt a book whose authors and publisher were so intent gouging students' pocketbooks.
2
Jun 11 '12
Knowledge should not be an object subject to scarcity. This might just be the worst fucking guy in the world. I wish him nothing but the most despicable karma. He is not a teacher. A teacher is someone who shares knowledge with the world. He is making the world worse off and is trying to prevent people from learning.
2
u/CJ_Guns Jun 11 '12
All of my textbooks have had these codes? It's not like professors or colleges have to mandate an online portion.
2
2
u/moviedude26 Jun 11 '12
This patent epitomizes capitalist ideals of unrestrained growth and willful ignorance of the limits to which we can exploit natural resources.
2
2
u/TH3ManChild Jun 11 '12
go ahead and allow this piracy act, just cut down the book cost to about $10 each...
2
u/holyghosttown Jun 11 '12
Hey, how about instead we concentrate on the fact that we're charged $200 for a fucking book, only to see it get reprinted the next year with approximately 5 changes total (if that), then buying those books back at $5 a pop.
Fuck. That. Bull. Shit.
2
2
u/Thuraash Jun 11 '12
I am so glad that a sizable proportion of the professors at my law school are aggressively promoting open-access textbooks and actively minimizing the amount of money students spend on books. THAT is how you improve education opportunities. Professor Vogel can keep his damned Ivory Tower.
2
u/hostergaard Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
The older generation; destroying intellectual freedom for the sake of profit since one could share knowledge indirectly.
Hope you guys die soon so the younger, more visionary and more well versed in the possibilities of the interned, can take over and use it for the betterment of mankind rather than fattening your purse.
I thin we should sue the publishers for having what is effectively a intellectual monopoly and laud pirates as heroes for breaking that monopoly. That is why they hate us; we take away the monopoly and thus the disproportionate profits.
2
2
u/all_of_my_cringe Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Guys,
Professor Joseph Henry Vogel is a professor, a scholar. I say we all send him well-thought out emails we as to why we disagree with his patent.
punishes poor students
restricts knowledge
if it is put into practice, most likely more people will pirate or not purchase out of protest. Which would mean less opportunity for being published.
anything else?
http://josephhenryvogel.com/home.html I'm sure his contact details could be found on there.
2
u/socrates28 Jun 11 '12
This. This here is the problem with academia. Many professors are forced into weird positions due to the publishing (academic paper publishing not publishing a textbook) but this is ridiculous. He claims he wants more publishing opportunities, and I just fail to see how a textbook, that most of which isn't bleeding edge research, will enable him to have more opportunities publishing what I assume he wants to - academic papers in proper journals. Yeah, maybe more textbooks, the more seriously they take him, but this doesn't even deal with that, it deals purely with the profit aspects.
His views on knowledge transmission (via the path which limits the most students and makes the most profit for himself) is grounds for being shunned from any serious academia. This to me, says straight away, "Realistically, knowledge, research, and any other aspect that is important in acquiring more knowledge is completely unimportant if there is no really big paycheck for me at the end."
I wish to become a part of academia eventually, but I just wish that this career path wasn't stained with the likes of Vogel.
Hmm, maybe if we redefine students as "Stakeholders" in a University for their financial and research contributions to the institution as a source of prestige. The university then adopts that their responsibility is to the stakeholders (students, donors, and government bursaries) thus giving the students the capability to demolish administrations that screw them over constantly. If there is one thing I would love to do is telling the entire school administration where I am, that they are all fired. Services are crap, education is crap, treatment of professors is crap, and there is not much we can do other than just shut up and pay, most can't even vote with their money.
2
u/TruthinessHurts Jun 11 '12
Joseph Henry Vogel: asshole making it even hard for students to afford school.
Fuck you, Vogel. You are helping the pieces of shit win.
2
Jun 11 '12
It's a special surtax the professors can charge regardless of the quality of their book.
The schools should view it as a 2nd tuition because really that's what it is.
2
u/PixelBlock Jun 11 '12
Y'know, students would share the books around a lot less if they were actually reasonably affordable. Not to mention that you'd be able to save publishing costs by printing new textbooks once every other year. Or by moving completely digital, thus reducing the need for printing presses entirely, meaning that operating costs would drop and more money made available in the company coffers (which apparently is the reasoning behind these current shenanigans).
Dealing with the causes of Piracy would be much simpler than dealing with Piracy itself, but hey ? What do I know ?
2
u/insultingidiot Jun 11 '12
What do we have here, a teacher who would rather make money than teach kids what they need to know. Unless he's teaching a course in money management!
If there isn't one already, there needs to be a website where students can look up which courses, or teachers, use which books, and what they'll cost. It should also tell you if the book can be sold to another student or not, because the practice questions remain the same, or the other student will need to pay full price for the book because the author and publisher changed the practice questions so the book can never be re-used
This book scam is right up there with the printer ink scams.
885
u/KazakiLion Jun 10 '12
This is a brilliant way to punish poor students.