r/technology • u/youni89 • Jun 10 '12
Singapore builds man-made 'super trees"
http://edition.cnn.com/2012/06/08/world/asia/singapore-supertrees-gardens-bay/index.html?hpt=hp_c3165
u/squatdeadpress Jun 10 '12
They look awesome to me. Really strikes me as structures from the future. Definitely a lot nicer than a Blade-Runner style future lol.
18
Jun 10 '12
Thats what I was thinking, it looks like something you'd see in a film set in the not-so distant future. It's beautiful...
5
u/drek13 Jun 10 '12
I was there last year and saw them under construction. They really do look like super-futuristic space trees.
6
u/MetaCreative Jun 10 '12
I would definitely prefer these super trees in place of goofy looking "art" statues, like that giant wave or that mutilated dick with gonorrhoea.
3
3
u/JabbrWockey Jun 10 '12
Filming a blade runner remake was the first thing I thought when I was out in Shanghai at night. It's a dirty, smelly, crowded, beautiful city. APAC knows how to build some damn awesome cities.
2
Jun 10 '12
I agree they are beautiful and yet still very functional. Nice to see there are people in the world who still incorporate functionality with a little aesthetics. These should spread around the world.
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
22
u/squatdeadpress Jun 10 '12
Definitely going to Signapore just based on google images of Marina Bay Sands.
7
u/IamTh3Walrus Jun 10 '12
I live in Singapore dude trust me it's nice if your serious, you won't regret it. Except be warned it's really hot and Humid.
→ More replies (5)6
→ More replies (15)5
u/YouKiddin Jun 10 '12
Here are my photos from the Marina Bay Sands Skypark where you get an elevated view of everything around you. These were from September last year, so I could see the Gardens being constructed. Also, lots of ships. LOTS.
→ More replies (1)5
u/monochr Jun 10 '12
I've been in both Dubai before the bubble burst and Singapore afterwards. If you wanted to see the future you should have been in Dubai in 2006. That is if you were one of the two privileged classes: rich expats and locals. Everyone else was fucked.
From what I remember Marina Bay Sands was just one of the rejected buildings from that epic blunder that ended up elsewhere.
5
u/inefekt Jun 10 '12
The future is always here. Today is the future of every other day that has come before it.
→ More replies (1)
28
u/derpymarc Jun 10 '12
Holy shit, I've been living in Singapore all my life, and always wondered what they were building there while passing them by on the highway. This is amazing.
11
→ More replies (2)10
u/kr0n0 Jun 10 '12
heey fellow Sg redditor!
17
u/aktsukikeeper Jun 10 '12
TIL that there's more Singaporean redditors than what I see on /r/Singapore.
7
4
u/aiux Jun 10 '12
Singaporeans unite! I can't wait to get back to Singapore after my overseas attachment :D
6
u/aktsukikeeper Jun 10 '12
Hey there! Laksa/Char Kway Teow/Chilli Crab/Nasi Lemak awaits your arrival! At least those are the dishes I missed when I went overseas. Gonna love chilli.
→ More replies (4)
46
u/IRLpuddles Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I've actually got pictures of these back when they were under construction, but I had no clue what they were until now EDIT: PROOF
31
u/imisscollege Jun 10 '12
Wow there are so many ships in the background.
5
u/ellipsisoverload Jun 10 '12
I believe around 30% of the world's shipping passes through the Straits of Malacca...
2
0
Jun 10 '12
[deleted]
2
u/cludeo656565 Jun 10 '12
I think they were number 1 for trading until Hong Kong or some mainland Chine region took over.
→ More replies (1)2
u/ThrowCarp Jun 10 '12
Where do you think all of Singapore's money comes from
IIRC:
Oil Refining, which is heavily reliant on Brunei Oil-Fields.
Banking.
Ports for Shipping.
2
u/jmh1877 Jun 10 '12
I was there in February and had no clue what they were either. My pictures from the top of the MBS look identical to yours actually. My guess was "Disneyland: Singapore" because I'm not crazy enough to guess "solar powered super trees", but leave it to Singaporeans to come up with something like this:P
1
1
u/Arx0s Jun 10 '12
Hey you got a pic of that sea of balloons I've always seen when around there. Any idea what they're for?
→ More replies (3)
24
u/void_provocateur Jun 10 '12
This looks so amazing. Who says futuristic has to be ugly. I could definitely use more of this sort of goodness in my city. I also vaguely remember a concept video for parks on top of lotus shaped towers.
→ More replies (6)
8
u/RandomProductSKU1029 Jun 10 '12
Well this is swell cos they just gave me a job (yep, right there, at the Gardens). HELLO SINGAPORE REDDITORS!
28
u/daweis1 Jun 10 '12
Amazingly, sometimes things like this can happen with a smart, tightly controlled government.
→ More replies (5)14
u/rubygeek Jun 10 '12
Who would be surprised about that?
There's plenty of examples of totalitarian governments resulting in amazing architecture or public works - they tend to like to show off, and when they want to they can cut through bureaucracy much more brutally than any private corporation gets to in a proper democracy and/or they can cut through the red tape for private corporations when it suits them.
The problem is not their ability to get shit done, it's that a lot of the time the shit they want done is directly at odds with your freedom and other interests.
Giving examples like this is hardly much of an argument for this type of government.
6
u/crdoconnor Jun 10 '12
True, but you should see their public housing and public transport too. It isn't all shiny projects.
2
u/Arx0s Jun 10 '12
True, Singapore probably has the best public housing in the world. Considering everyone is guaranteed public housing for cheap in HDBs.
→ More replies (1)4
u/whatchamabiscut Jun 10 '12
I totally agree.
I hate it when there's a certain standard of housing available for almost any level of income, an amazing public transportation system, and heavily subsidized healthcare. The housing infringes on my right and interest to live in a shitty, overpriced dwelling far from my employment; the transportation interferes with my right to not be able to go places, and my interest in being practically forced to spend more money on a less efficient form of transport; the healthcare infringes on my right to be made impoverished by being sick, and my interest of being sick.
tl;dr: SARCASM
Also democracy can be overrated.
2
u/rubygeek Jun 10 '12
You entirely miss the point, which is that using this project as some sort of example to justify this government is a logical fallacy, as it's trivially easy to point to governments that very obviously very hugely negative to their populations and that still produced fantastic public works. Up to and including governments that left the bones of people they worked to death in the walls of some of the buildings they put up.
If you want to justify an undemocratic government, public works and architecture isn't exactly a convincing argument.
20
12
u/Pfuschendennarr Jun 10 '12
My uncle is head of the project for the new gardens, heading it was his alternative to retirement. Because of him my parents got in on growing crotons (shrubs) for the garden, and some of what we've grown here is now proudly strewn around the garden and flower dome.
I forget how many trees there are, but when my parents were there they took pictures of everything, and you can see 13 of them, the amazing hotel with the famous edgeless pool and giant Ferris Wheel in the background.
I can't wait to get to go see it myself. Beyond the plants, the architecture and design of this new garden is crazy awesome. My uncle has good, weird, and expensive tastes in art. He was so happy traveling the world and shopping everywhere.
Everyone, go see it!!
6
3
u/han5henman Jun 10 '12
I know and have met your uncle! my dad also worked on the gardens. what a small world
3
Jun 10 '12
Because of him my parents got in on growing crotons (shrubs) for the garden
Insider gardening?
→ More replies (1)
6
u/DizzyMau5 Jun 10 '12
This is brilliant. However, I cannot help but think of the episode of Doctor Who where the Weeping Angels are running about and the Doctor runs through the environment of artificial trees.
Let us just hope that the angels remain a part of that science fiction world. As for these marvelous trees, bravo for further advancement in our world.
3
35
u/uTerrus Jun 10 '12
I had to check that we weren't on /r/trees.
6
3
u/ent_higherly_awesome Jun 10 '12
Got excited, clicked link, lost my entrection, went to post this same sentiment.
2
10
8
4
30
u/FutureJustin Jun 10 '12
Proud to be Singaporean!
29
1
-1
u/thefuckamireading Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
I've only been there once, and I definitely agree it's a nice place. Very modern, livable, and close to the rest of the world. I do plan to go there again.
I have been wanting to ask a local for a while though... where can a tourist get good food? I was really disappointed with everything I ate there. (PS people have told me food stalls at the markets. I still never found anything good there either though)
TL;DR Nice place, shit food. Where in Singapore is good food?
11
u/arts1 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Stay away from the shopping malls, or almost any areas that are blanketed in air-conditioning as a rule of thumb.
Markets do house the best food, but sometimes also the worst. We have this inside joke that sometimes we get into long queues without knowing where they lead, because we blindly assume everyone's queueing for a good reason so we should join in anyway. It is a odd bit of wisdom you can trust in a hawker centre though. If you find yourself without any guidance in an unfamiliar food haunt, just look around and see what everyone's having as you would a menu. Ask the locals, who probably frequent the place and would know what's good. Good places to go are the Old Airport Food Centre and Maxwell Market, though tourism is causing the latter to push it's prices a fair bit higher.
Other places you can explore are Dempsey Road for the slightly more posh eating joints, and Purvis Street for a variety of restaurants at different price points.
EDIT: Also, in a hawker centre, look out for stalls with newspaper articles featuring themselves plastered all over the store front, this usually means they're good. If the store front and sign board looks clean and modern in its design, I'd rather avoid it. Enjoy!
hungrygowhere.com is your friend.
→ More replies (4)18
Jun 10 '12
Shit food in Singapore? Safe to assume you're a total culinary philistine - the city has one of the most amazing food cultures on the face of the planet. Anthony Bourdain rated it the best place in the world for sea food and street food.
7
u/thefuckamireading Jun 10 '12
Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying there isn't good food in Singapore; I just didn't come across any of it when I was there - which is why I asked for advice. I probably just went to the wrong places... or at least I hope that's the case.
3
3
u/melancholyarugula Jun 10 '12
interesting, i'm singaporean and the food over in malaysia is loads better to me.
→ More replies (1)2
u/aiux Jun 10 '12
The street food you get to eat in Singapore are the safest you can ever find in the world, due to strict health regulations and enforcements!
5
Jun 10 '12
Travel to Malaysia! :-p It's dirtier, smellier, but for some reason the same dishes that are bland and greasy in Singapore are just heaven there. Then again I may be biased, I'm Malaysian. Did live in Singapore for 7 years though.
2
→ More replies (2)4
u/key2 Jun 10 '12
Stingray, chili/pepper crab, and laksa. Can't go wrong with those. Also chicken rice. Check out old airport road and maxwell market and east coast lagoon
10
Jun 10 '12
Nice, heading for Singapore in 6 hours one more thing to add to my list of must see.
→ More replies (5)
6
u/DevinLuppy Jun 10 '12
I feel like Singapore is the city where they test out cool shit so it's a city of the future.
→ More replies (10)5
u/fuzzybunn Jun 10 '12
We recycle our waste water for drinking, too! Welcome to the future!
2
u/nvendr Jun 10 '12
Dammit I actually spit out my water while reading that lol (I'm a Singaporean)
2
2
3
u/key2 Jun 10 '12
I drive by those things all the time and had no idea what they were until now. Thanks.
3
3
u/awesomeSG Jun 10 '12
Singapore's a really awesome place, chilli crab, chicken rice, tons of awesome food and places where you can see the magic, oh and did i mention our crazy lazer shows at sentosa and marina bay sands? yeah we do have a universal studios singapore too! now tell me, what's so bad about our political landscape? i think it's fine and should pretty much stay the same as it's been doing great stuff for the country.
21
u/canonymous Jun 10 '12
They do everything a real tree does except fix carbon, generate oxygen, and self-replicate and repair.
8
u/anttirt Jun 10 '12
except fix carbon, generate oxygen
Did you even read the article?
The man-made mechanical forest consists of 18 supertrees that act as vertical gardens, generating solar power, acting as air venting ducts for nearby conservatories, and collecting rainwater. To generate electricity, 11 of the supertrees are fitted with solar photovoltaic systems that convert sunlight into energy, which provides lighting and aids water technology within the conservatories below.
Varying in height between 25 and 50 meters, each supertree features tropical flowers and various ferns climbing across its steel framework. The large canopies also operate as temperature moderators, absorbing and dispersing heat, as well as providing shelter from the hot temperatures of Singapore's climate to visitors walking beneath.
→ More replies (5)3
u/orangepotion Jun 10 '12
To say nothing about the huge ecological footprint of a 150 ft steel structure.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Nicospec Jun 10 '12
I've seen those trees a few times when I had to do a project a at the Marina Barrage and if I'm not wrong, there is a 5-star restaurant on the top of one of them.
2
u/apollodynamo Jun 10 '12
Man, and just recently I was thinking it would be awesome to have giant trees with leaves that worked like solar panels for sustainable energy.
I'm glad the idea wasn't just a fantasy!
2
Jun 10 '12
There have been so many different designs for stuff like this lately, but I've never seen plans for one of them actually being made. Awesome.
2
2
u/ElagabalusCaesar Jun 10 '12
Cool, but the environmental impact of real giant trees will always be smaller
2
u/hostergaard Jun 10 '12
You know, I have been thinking it would be cool to make bioluminescent trees that release light during the night and use them as alternative road lamps that does not need electricity to function.
2
2
2
u/SlayFace Jun 10 '12
Oh the want to be in Singapore is overwhelming now. I never knew how beautiful it was.
2
u/dtriley4 Jun 10 '12
Came back from vacation in Singapore a few days ago. I can vouch, they look pretty awesome. So does everything around the Marina Bay area.
2
2
u/physicscat Jun 10 '12
If I ever leave 'Merica for good....this is where I want to go.
1
u/melancholyarugula Jun 10 '12
interesting, i'm heading to the states at the first opportunity, sick of living here.
2
2
Jun 10 '12
When you see movies of the 'future' you see things like this. Singapore is readily acknowledging the future needs and wants of its country, and implementing awesome attractions.
We (in the US) are arguing over Mitt Romney's religion. Viva la revolution.
2
2
2
u/riley900 Jun 10 '12
I can just see all the Ents showing up to this post..
"Super trees..? Where maaan?"
2
u/Ness4114 Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Here are the trees under construction. Bottom right. I might have a better pic somewhere...
Edit: It's not much, but a slightly better pic
2
u/genericdave Jun 10 '12
Am I missing something? As far as I can tell, these things are essentially just sculptures used to hide cooling ducts (like when they make cell phone towers into flag poles) with some lights that are powered by a few solar cells tacked on. Their purpose is to look pretty. What is "super" about them exactly?
3
u/smacksaw Jun 10 '12
Singapore will be the first to Alpha Centauri.
4
u/fuzzybunn Jun 10 '12
... We can't even buy half a satellite without our neighbours screaming bloody murder.
2
u/missbossy Jun 10 '12
I think we'd be satisfied with hacking ourselves off from the Malaysian peninsula and floating down to Australia. But Alpha Centauri works too.
4
u/nicholas_77 Jun 10 '12
Feeling super proud as i read all the comments as this this is my homecountry!! :)
2
u/firstpageguy Jun 10 '12
Don't you mean homecitycountry? :)
3
u/kr0n0 Jun 10 '12
homecitystatecountry
7
u/pandaren88 Jun 10 '12
Country: Singapore State: Singapore Province: Singapore City: Singapore Singapore: Singapore
→ More replies (2)
3
u/Atypical_Redditor Jun 10 '12
Selling technology as "green" and "good for the planet" has got to be one of the most insidious and ridiculous marketing jobs this civilization has ever come up with.
Solar panels, artificial trees, vertical gardens, massive cities where man and nature never meet - what do these things have in common?
A - they all consume non-renewable resources and further separate human from nature, to the detriment of all.
7
u/MyMotivation Jun 10 '12
Vertical gardens and solar panels consume non-renewable resources???
→ More replies (2)
2
u/Boshdy Jun 10 '12
Why not just plant real trees?
→ More replies (4)5
2
u/Arx0s Jun 10 '12
I lived in Singapore for 4 years throughout high school ('06 - '10). It was definitely the best place I've ever lived. Yeah the climate is unbearably shitty, especially for a big dude like me (80-80 year-round with 100% humidity). It's only decent out when it rains.
Singapore is incredibly diverse, clean, vibrant, and incredibly advanced, especially considering it's been independent for only about 60 years. Clubbing at Clark Quay, walking around downtown Orchard and going lanning or just aimlessly exploring. Sentosa, which has Universal Studios and awesome beaches, and is one big resort-like place. Cable wakeboarding over at East Coast was fucking awesome. And not to mention the best/cheapest food you'll ever have: Hawker fare.
Sometimes I really miss that place. Definitely gonna try to move back there after college.
1
1
1
u/vp2008 Jun 10 '12
Cool, i saw this when i was going to the city via the highway the other day! didn't know what they were! As a Singaporean, i feel so much fail not knowing about this.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/tuxedodiplomat Jun 10 '12
This is a Dubai-style vanity project. It contains glasshouses artificially chilled to house temperate climate plants. For the more than one billion dollars it cost to build this, the government could have flown every Singapore citizen to a temperate country to see the real forest for themselves.
1
1
u/HatesTheAwwlocaust Jun 10 '12
Incredibly beautiful. This is a work of art and the antithesis of combining technology and nature.
1
1
1
u/killerdrgn Jun 10 '12
Wow this is pretty cool, I was there when they first started the marina redevelopment project over 5 years ago.
Can any Singaporeans here tell me if they ever built the casino and/or raceway?
2
u/melancholyarugula Jun 10 '12
both casinos up. Are you referring to the Changi Motosports Hub? That thing is on hold, some huge debacle is going on about the consortium that successfully bid for it. If you're referring to the F1 around Marina Bay, yes its up and has been for a few years, though the track is dismantled after every race.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/viktorb Jun 10 '12
I read that as "Singapore builds man made of super trees". I was disappointed..
1
1
1
1
u/reddittrees2 Jun 10 '12
"It's an oxygen factory." ... "It's a forest.." "Yeah...it's an oxygen factory."
1
1
1
1
u/hughk Jun 10 '12
Still sucks when your flight is delayed after midnight and most things are closed.
1
1
1
u/MysterVaper Jun 10 '12
This looks like they plan to make it a dome. Those trees 'tops' are too level and placed like dome supports. Hell, they already basically make a dome. (by 'dome' I mean something more substantial than the canopy this already creates.)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/IamTh3Walrus Jun 10 '12
I live in Singapore and all I can say is that the Marina Bay Sands has an absolutely awesome set of Eco-Domes right next to these tree's. Also the grounds that the Marina Bay Sands has is absolutely amazing. Also they have a huge infinity pool on the Sky Park which lets you look down all those stories.
2
u/AndroidIsSoGood Jun 10 '12
Is it true that in Singapore you get tossed into jail for chewing gum and the electric chair for smoking weed?
3
u/xybjj Jun 10 '12
You can bring gum into Singapore and consume it. Just that the sale of gum is prohibited. I personally don't mind this because I don't like gum all over my elevator buttons or stuck on the escalator or where ever else you can stuff gum.
For narcotics, past a certain amount that you bring in, you automatically get the death sentence (hanging). In 1994, a Dutch national was arrested while on transit to another country for trafficking heroin and subsequently hung.
Here's a Nigerian national who was hung in 2007 for trafficking heroin.
→ More replies (3)2
u/thinkingpanda Jun 10 '12
Chewing gum is not illegal but bringing gum into the country is. Even then I don't think that would be a jailable offence.
As for smoking weed you don't get the death penalty but probably jail and rehabilitation afterwards. Smuggling drugs into the country will grant you the hangman's noose though.
3
u/iceberserker Jun 10 '12
Bringing gum into the country is legal contrary to popular belief, you just can't sell gum here.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/cdigioia Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
18 supertrees that act as vertical gardens, generating solar power, acting as air venting ducts for nearby conservatories, and collecting rainwater.
So...they are giant air ducts (aka - just tubes), that act as funnels for rainwater (aka tubes with a funnel opening on top), and have some plants on them? And some - as said further in the article - some have solar panels.
I may be missing a lot, but I don't see this being anything other than really really excellent marketing by calling/making them look like "Trees". It sounds so futuristic...but they sound just like giant funnels with plants stuck to the side, and for some - some solar panels. It's hard to imagine Singapore doing much that is not genuinely useful, so -
Am I missing something? Or maybe - it's just really aesthetically pleasing simple-utility structures, that foreign media is getting a bit over-excited about?
1
u/Scratchicus Jun 10 '12
Singaporean here. Reading all this stuff on reddit makes me question our citizen's readiness for greater freedom of speech and politics. Why I say this is because the arguments made on reddit are very balanced and non-toxic. In Singapore, our blogosphere is incredibly vile, both in support and opposition of the ruling party. This vileness in speech makes me question our readiness for such freedoms.
4
Jun 10 '12
The reason outsiders are able to talk this way about Singapore is precisely because we are outsiders. We have distance. Trust me, you'll probably find us equally toxic and polarized when talking about our own domestic politics.
1
Jun 10 '12
But how efficient are these things? It seems to me like these things don't really serve a practical purpose, like they're only for show. They call them super trees but I bet they're actually less efficient at producing energy than the real thing. People go all apeshit over this because it seems like some kind of ground-breaking green technology, but in reality they're just giant steel sculptures with solar cells glued on.
-3
u/Wakata Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 11 '12
Ah Singapore, the land of contradictions, where technological marvels flower to life alongside draconian punishments like this (warning: a tad bit graphic, no death so don't worry, but shocking if you were unaware of its existence), the death penalty for drug possession, and hours of community service for spitting out a piece of chewing gum in the street.
Singapore is like the good parts of South Korea mixed with the bad parts of North Korea (so, North Korea).
Whenever something like this comes up I always have to remind myself of the context which many people are unaware of.
Downvoters, click the link and do some research.
Edit: Oy, who removed my link? Mods, I don't appreciate censorship. Reddit can handle a little blood. I've put it back in, fuck the police.
14
u/baikabaik Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Honestly, while I'm for freedom and everything like that, their system works, and I have to agree with their policy on trash and drugs. I visited Singapore for the first time last month, and i found it amazing how clean and safe the area was. Although some of the punishments can be considered harsh, with a region surrounded by conflict, drug trade, and other illegal activities, the laws of singapore are a necessity to maintain a good quality of life and a stable environment for technological and monetary progress.
4
3
4
u/sixtyt3 Jun 10 '12
Going by the language (is it malay?) in that Video, I could argue that this could either be Malaysia or Brunei. But I agree - Singapore caning is one of the retarded laws this nation has.
I think Singapore can learn some lessons from Hongkong in that sense.
3
u/crdoconnor Jun 10 '12
Caning is only usually meted out for pretty serious crimes. The kind of thing where in America you get sentenced to getting raped in prison. In that context, it doesn't actually seem so bad.
2
u/sub_o Jun 10 '12
Yeah, some draconian laws there.
Is that only around Marina Bay ? I would have appreciated it more, say that if they build one around Bedok or Ang Mo Kio.
But again, from technological standpoint, it's an interesting idea.
→ More replies (5)3
u/aktsukikeeper Jun 10 '12
Sigh, if there's ever one thread that doesn't have one of these. I am sympathetic about death penalty but fuck those who stick their chewing gums in public spaces. The populace is not oppressed, dissent is not entirely squashed but prominent dissidents do get special attention.
→ More replies (2)
-6
u/niggertown Jun 10 '12 edited Jun 10 '12
Too bad most of Singapore is ugly architecture. Based on the pictures, it's hard to believe that was the place I spent 3 months in. The humidity there makes you feel sticky the whole day through and manages to bring out the disgusting smell of everything. The transit system is so crammed you're always balls to ass with some old asian lady.
On the up side, it's safe, prosperous, and the people have a collective IQ much higher than your average American city. It's probably better suited for asians than for whites.
2
3
u/sixtyt3 Jun 10 '12
It's probably better suited for asians than for whites.
Going by your account name, well...
241
u/sixtyt3 Jun 10 '12
If you find this awesome, their airport has a fucking butterfly garden, a theatre, bunch of swimming pools and a whole gaming arena inside the main terminal building. Yes, Changi Airport is that awesome.