r/technology • u/antihostile • May 28 '12
Germany Sets Solar Power Record: 50% of Nation's Electricity Demand
http://insideclimatenews.org/breaking-news/20120527/germany-sets-solar-power-record-50-electricity-demand149
May 28 '12
As a german, thats the first time i've ever heared about this! But it filles me up with pride.
257
u/MagicalRainbowfish May 28 '12
Stop it! We mustn't be proud! Bad things happen when we're proud...
121
u/Magro28 May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Yeah! I've got this warm feeling of proudness... Hey and the weather is perfect for some little world conquering right now. Let's start engineering super war robots.
125
u/fooppeast420 May 28 '12
As long as they're solar powered.
→ More replies (7)45
u/SaikoGekido May 28 '12
I believe the article mentioned biomass as an environmentally friendly option. That gives me an idea...
→ More replies (3)44
→ More replies (4)19
u/kirbyderwood May 28 '12
Yes, please. Conquer us and force us to adopt solar, fast highways, and good industrial design.
→ More replies (1)50
u/Sc0tch May 28 '12
I hear Poland is really nice this time of the year.
→ More replies (3)21
u/Magro28 May 28 '12
The europe soccer championship starts there in two weeks. We could utilize this as a sneaky Blitzkrieg.
→ More replies (4)2
→ More replies (1)2
u/poopypantsn May 28 '12
It makes me kind of sad that newer generations still hold so much guilt. I mean it's probably a good thing, and we should ALL remember that EVERY one of us is capable of doing shitty things in some circumstances.
9
u/Paultimate79 May 28 '12
Only 4% annually. http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/05/26/us-climate-germany-solar-idUSBRE84P0FI20120526
Media likes to mislead.
→ More replies (5)8
→ More replies (1)1
43
u/SpudOfDoom May 28 '12
Meanwhile in New Zealand, 77% of all electricity generation in 2011 was from renewable sources. We've actually gotten worse in the last 30 years =/
3
u/1632 May 28 '12
This is great, but you can't really compare the two economies. Germany is is second strongest exporter of goods with a massive industrial base. Hope we will be able to reach your rate of renewables within the next 30 years... well done NZ!
2
u/BracesForImpact May 28 '12
Wow. Best economy in the EU, and using clean power. I thought the GOP said this was impossible?
→ More replies (4)9
u/sutongorin May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
That's really admirable. Though a little easier to pull off with 4 instead of more than 80 million people to provide for.
3
11
u/schrodingerszombie May 28 '12
Why? It's primarily a per-capita basis to create green energy. It should get easier with more people as you can afford larger scale projects and drive the price down further.
→ More replies (7)6
u/amorpheus May 28 '12
Where those people live is the largest factor, and what per-capita resources are available. Compare a mostly landlocked country to a few islands in the ocean... it isn't accidental that NZ's energy is mostly hydroelectric.
→ More replies (1)
104
u/sankeytm May 28 '12
Only 50% on Saturday. It's still "one third" for the rest of the weekday.
22
u/impshakes May 28 '12
→ More replies (5)13
u/mrana May 28 '12
And what percentage do we get in the US? So what if it was just a peak hour on a really productive day. The point is that they are doing it and we are not.
→ More replies (16)4
1
1
0
May 28 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (30)89
u/Vik1ng May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Yep, already playing the rare earths game.
→ More replies (39)20
u/JB_UK May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Except rare earths aren't that rare, and they're not concentrated in a handful of countries with despotic regimes, they can be recycled over and over again, and they can almost inevitably be replaced with other materials. Oh, and the vast majority of photovoltaic panels are silicon, which don't use much rare earth material in the first place.
Edit: typos
→ More replies (7)
74
u/Uncle_Erik May 28 '12
Awesome. Good for Germany.
I'd love to see similar stats here in the US. We have a lot more sun and a lot more potential.
116
u/unknownsoldierx May 28 '12
We need a way to generate electricity from greed and stupidity.
34
May 28 '12
Put Paulites on a treadmill and hang a gold certificate off a string in front of it.
→ More replies (3)9
May 28 '12
Wouldn't work. They all know the promises of gold certificates are all too soon broken.
→ More replies (1)6
u/take_924 May 28 '12
Don't underestimate waste. If you are a typical American there's two meals worth of food and a days worth of heating and electricity in your garbage-bin.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)10
u/successadult May 28 '12
Greed and stupidity are a human problem, not just an American problem.
27
16
u/export40 May 28 '12
That is true, but greed and stupidity are orders of magnitude more influential in American politics due to the amount of money it requires to acquire and keep political office.
→ More replies (1)10
u/Home_sweet_dome May 28 '12
The headline is misleading. They were able to produce that much for a short period on one day. They are not able to sustain that rate.
→ More replies (5)10
4
u/anxiousalpaca May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Not so awesome if you factor in that these get subsidized heavily and we owe more than 100,000,000€ (estimation) for the PV electricity generated. And the subsidies are at least for another 20 years.
High price to be paid.16
9
→ More replies (6)2
u/Kazaril May 28 '12
We should only attempt to solve power generation problems and climate change with free solutions, because money that's not spent on making more money is a waste of money.
1
u/El_Sloth May 28 '12
In the U.S. we would more likely see a headline saying wind, hydro, and solar (maybe nuclear as well) power now fuel half the U.S. than just solar alone.
→ More replies (25)1
u/pU8O5E439Mruz47w May 28 '12
We do have a lot of sun, but average energy consumption for the nation is about 500GWh.
36
u/MunaEndel May 28 '12
This is good news for renewables but solar will still produce less then 5% of the annual electricity in Germany
EU should start investing in solar in its southern countries with weak economies.
There the peak consumption correlates better with solar availability then in Germany and other northern countries, where the max consumption is at winter (when panels are probably covered with snow)
Investments would also create jobs and lessen the massive trade deficits that those countries have by need to import less fossil fuels. So IMO it would be a win-win.
20
u/Lucasterio May 28 '12
As a Spaniard, YES!
7
u/what_the_actual_luck May 28 '12
Are you unemployed? Had to ask..
11
u/Lucasterio May 28 '12
Lol, yes, but that is perfectly normal because I graduate this June, though I'm already finished. My battle with unemployment has just begun. That is why I'm not even trying it in Spain. Thankfully, I'm fortunante enough to be able to try my luck in english speaking countries :D.
→ More replies (8)9
u/1632 May 28 '12
2
u/Kazaril May 28 '12
Renewables =/= Solar. The solar component is at about 4%. This is still a huga amount of energy though.
→ More replies (4)1
21
u/Dickybow May 28 '12
I have to ask, what do they do when a week passes with no direct sunlight or wind?
27
u/obfuscation_ May 28 '12
I would guess that you predict the weather beforehand, and therefore know your renewables are going to lull. Then you get ready to throw more coal/gas/<other fuels here> into your significantly less green power plants.
They're not saying they rely on solar for 50% of demand- they're just saying they had a good weekend, and probably saved themselves a fair amount on their national fuel bill :P.
On another note- solar panels don't all require direct sunlight, and IIRC some perform worse in it [citation needed].
16
May 28 '12
Solar panels really don't like getting hot, as their efficiency drops significantly when they heat up. So yes, there's a "too much sunlight".
People also completely underestimate how bright even a somewhat cloudy day is.
→ More replies (3)3
u/obfuscation_ May 28 '12
There is even research aimed squarely at places with less direct sunlight in fact Source
→ More replies (1)4
u/Dickybow May 28 '12
'Throw more coal'? - It takes about a day to 'fire up' a coal plant, they do not like being turned off!
Gas or oil plants are quicker but you still would need enough of these plants to supply your country with power continuously, why risk power security by turning them on and off?
→ More replies (1)5
u/obfuscation_ May 28 '12
Preface: I have no relevant background whatsoever to inform my opinion
I admit I was understating the complexity of increase/decreasing the scale of fired powerstations, but the general idea still remains- provided you can predict weather with reasonable accuracy over a couple of days, provisions can be put in place surely?
why risk power security by turning them on and off?
So long as the loss in efficiency of spinning up/down capacity is not too great, this seems self-evident... Fuel is expensive, and if you can reduce your usage without damaging your equipment, I don't see the problem.
The only problem I foresee is if the time to increase/decrease fired stations is too great when compared to the time of (reasonably) accurate weather prediction you have.
→ More replies (2)20
u/Sinaasappelschil May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
This is the big issue: you need those flexible power generation technology (STEG, etc.) in case there's no wind or sunlight. The problem this poses is that you'll get a permanent operating cost for those power plants, but they'll only make money when they're working. Therefore, the more renewable energy capacity, the less the base plants will be working, the more they'll have to charge for each kWh. (Or shut down).
You can't just eliminate those 'because the sun will always be shining somewhere'. There will always be a (small) risk that it doesn't, and the cost incurred of not providing power is thousands to millions that of the cost of the power itself.
Ergo: you need a certitude of being able to cover the maximum demand with controllable resources. Renewables don't cut it, even with the idealized smart grid.
Edit: I realize this is most likely to get buried because it's providing perspective against all the joyful comments how wonderful renewables are.
15
u/rockkybox May 28 '12
What about the thing where they pump water up a hill when they've got energy to spare, then generate from that water store in a cloudy patch.
7
u/Magro28 May 28 '12
This is the answer. There are many researchs for storing the surplus of solar and wind energy. Another thing I read about was to compress gas in an underground storage or to use the surplus to generate synthetic natural gas. (http://www.gastip.de/rubrik2/19924/Oekostrom-als-Erdgas-speichern.html)
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (9)6
u/Sinaasappelschil May 28 '12
This is being done, has about 75% return (which is pretty good), and the peak power can be close to that of a nuclear plant. You do need large bassins though, and the initial investment is huge. If you look at how policies on energy have changed the past 30 years, these investments are a huge risk. A decision now may take 10 years at least to see completion, and another 20 to earn the investor's money back.
5
u/CartmansEvilTwin May 28 '12
The costs aren't the "real" problem. In fact nuclear, coal and gas power plants just have a long reaction time, so they can't deliver as fast as needed. The common practice is to produce "too much" power with those slow power plants and only use renewables at peaks. The rest of the time they just shut them down. I live in an area where really everywhere wind mills are being built and even when there's a fair amount of wind to "harvest" many of then just stand still.
→ More replies (3)4
u/Osmodius May 28 '12
Exactly. You always need the baseline to keep everything up. Wind/Solar is not stable enough to be a baseline.
→ More replies (6)2
11
u/b-schroeder May 28 '12
Import atomic energy from France. We have had shitty weather here for a couple weeks and really nice weather over the weekend, so it was a good example of how much power can be generated under optimal conditions, but not an indication of the average power generated. Still, it's good news.
→ More replies (2)22
u/stesch May 28 '12
Funny fact: In summer the French import energy from Germany because they can't run their nuclear reactors at full because of the cooling problems.
→ More replies (2)8
u/Br3HaAa May 28 '12
It was a test for one day, I dont think you could sustain that amount in all weather conditions... I would love to know some more technical facts anyway, the article is not really that helpful...
8
3
u/stesch May 28 '12
That's why you don't rely on just one technology. You combine different solutions together. There were extended tests and simulations a few years ago. Solar, water, wind, bio gas, etc. All work perfectly together in an intelligent network.
For example: You have a lot of solar and wind energy? Use parts of it to pump a lot of water up a mountain. Wind too calm, many clouds? Water runs down this mountain and powers a turbine. (Very simple example. Reality is of course more complex.)
3
u/Dickybow May 28 '12
Your naivety is a little depressing "There were extended tests and simulations a few years ago" Really? Dinorwig Power Station is one of the few 'real world' pumped storage power systems in the world; it can generate 1,800 MW for five hours, it makes use of the local geography and would cost about a Billion pounds to build today. That's 1,800MW for 5 hours a day for £1,000,000,000! That is a lot of money for not much power!
→ More replies (12)1
May 28 '12
Not a week, a second. The power that is produced has to match the power that is used, second by second.
Once someone figures out a viable large scale way to store electrical power, solar and wind become viable power sources. Until then, they are a huge waste of money, because all of their capacity has to be duplicated with other sources.
BTW, Germans pay over twice as much for electricity as I do in the US.
→ More replies (1)
6
24
11
u/Zaffaro May 28 '12
Did however anyone know that Norway gets 99% of electricity from renewable hydropower?
(The other 1% comes from mountain trolls tamed by ski wearing vikings riding on mooses)
4
u/kayende May 28 '12
Norway actually has capacity for 106% of yearly consumption in hydropower. The official figures look different though because they sell "certificates of origin" so that power producers anywhere else can produce electricity in their coal or nuclear power plant with a certificate of origin that says the power is clean. In this way Norway produces clean power, but it isn't officially clean because the certificate of origin is used somewhere else.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/aakaakaak May 28 '12
For comparison:
Germany's consumption this weekend was about 40-44 GW. They took in about 22 GW from photovoltaic sources. Roughly 50% of their power this weekend came in via solar power. Mostly this happened because nobody was at work.
The United States standard consumption is about 3,300 GW. Wind power in the us is about 43 GW (twice that of Germany's solar power). Hydroelectric covers about 204 GW. However, the U.S. has only about 2 GW of photovoltaic power, but the number is growing. (I could be off with some of these numbers, so correct me if I'm mistaken. Wikipedia was my source.)
In the end, we use a crapload more energy than Germany does. Compare that with the size of the U.S. Vs. Germany and the number would pair down a bit, but we still consume energy like fat people eat cake.
→ More replies (3)2
u/1632 May 28 '12
Germany's power grid is fully integrated on an European level. The country has about 82 million citizens and is the world's second strongest exporter of of goods. The number of its citizens roughly equals the combined population of California, Texas, Georgia and New Jersey.
Even considering the much wider range of climate, making it necessary for the US to use plenty of ACs ... this kind of energy consumption is a disgrace.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/Kylius May 28 '12
I read something pretty interesting about a project that Germany are working on with Greece, called Helios.
The idea is that solar panels along the Greek coast gather solar power, where it's then transported - cross continent - to Germany via transmission lines.
From what I understand, Germany are really hammering the renewable energy sources after closing their nuclear power stations after Fukushima.
→ More replies (4)
12
u/jrhnemo May 28 '12
I thought I should reiterate how big a deal this is. Germany is not a small country. Around 80 million people live there. That's a ton of homes to power, so anyone who says solar power isn't viable on a large scale ought to look at Germany. (By the way, it's not a sunshine paradise, either)
7
u/agep29 May 28 '12
Sometimes I feel like Germany is one of the few countries in the world that really has their shit together in this post-recession era.
6
u/dbossnirvana May 28 '12
Currently residing in Germany here. Yes, it is that awesome.
2
u/idk112345 May 28 '12
no it isn't, that's why we are cutting back subsidies now. The billions invested into solar have caused electricity bills to skyrocket and innovation to hault as producers were able to sell either way, since people rich enough to afford those pannels got tax breaks to buy them leaving poor people like me having to pay higher electrical bills.
19
u/LepKoGreh May 28 '12
wow, how much taxes go to subsidizing them? oh and i would like to see those outputs in winter time...
69
u/x-skeww May 28 '12
Compared to war, this stuff is basically free.
→ More replies (5)8
5
u/Paladin8 May 28 '12
PV saved our asses this winter when we had some cold and clear days and solar produced a lot of the extra energy needed to heat our homes.
→ More replies (4)9
u/steezetrain May 28 '12
Don't know why you're getting downvoted, because it's a legitimate question. Solar and wind have some serious downfalls. Energy storage, lost energy in grid transfer (and lets face it... not everyone can store energy in dams either -.-), high feed-in-tariffs, a falsely created demand, and an inconsistent source of energy are a cause for problem in the Alt energy sector.
It's a great idea, but right now it is way behind.
→ More replies (1)4
u/1632 May 28 '12
Consumption of solar energy in Germany is mainly regional. The German Wikipedia article cites sources clearly indicating that solar power in Germany has lower transfer losses than any other kind of energy production.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/SherlockPwns May 28 '12
Can somebody with knowledge in the field explain why this is not happening in the US or Canada? I would think that if Germany could pull it off, other modern nations could as well. No?
13
u/JoseJimeniz May 28 '12
German government gave taxbreaks to those who buy solar panels, and enticing buy-back rates of the generated electricity.
Republicans don't believe the government should be spending money at a time like this. Not when we're dealing with record deficits, caused by democratic overspending, and the poor economy caused by Obama's policies that that have been prolonging this recession.
And besides, the government should not be in the solar power business. As we have seen over and over is that government is the problem. The government cannot to anything right. The government needs to cut taxes to help private business built a solar and wind infrastructure. Then it will be done right, without the money-wasting government being involved.
And if you agree with that then you're a conservative - and a fool.
4
u/balzacstalisman May 28 '12
I was reading this thinking, how did this Ayn Rand freak get in here?
It was sufficiently whiny, robotic & 'on message' enough to get my liberal hackles up .. then I saw the last sentence & I thought, he's not a mean Troll after all ..
Nearly got me, Sir.
3
3
May 28 '12
Republicans don't believe the government should be spending money at a time like this.
Funny how the Reeps blocks attempts to end oil subsidies, eh?
→ More replies (1)3
2
u/anxiousalpaca May 28 '12
It's incredibly expensive.
2
May 28 '12
i know i would rather save money buy spending more money in the long run
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (8)1
u/DrArcheNoah May 28 '12
Germany wants to show that it can work and hopes that other will follow later.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/CrayolaS7 May 28 '12
And this is why I don't understand why Germany wants to quit using Nuclear. If they kept developing better Nuclear as well as using solar they could have completely fossil-fuel free electricity generation already. I am including things like Thorium reactors when I say nuclear.
→ More replies (18)
2
u/jamesdaBames May 28 '12
Which kind of solar power plants do they have? Photovoltaiks or thermal solar?
3
u/ActuallyNot May 28 '12
9
u/hypogenic May 28 '12
Yeah, but this kinda poops the party just a little bit:
The German solar PV industry installed about 7.5 GW in 2011,[2] and solar PV provided 18 TWh (billion kilowatt-hours) of electricity in 2011, about 3% of total electricity.[3] Some market analysts expect this could reach 25 percent by 2050.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (1)2
u/jjswee May 28 '12
I know my company is building a lot of Photovoltaic panels in Germany. I don't know about the rest of the country, but my guess is that it would be Photovoltaics as well.
→ More replies (5)
2
u/t0rsk May 28 '12
Maybe it's time for sunnier countries to start investing in solar-energy perhaps?
→ More replies (2)
2
May 28 '12
Well... its just bec... the angle of the light in 'Merica... our cloud cover is... I... I... aye! OKAY THERE ARE FINALLY NO MORE EXCUSES FOR NOT DOING THIS IN OUR COUNTRY!
2
u/fantasyfest May 28 '12
http://wyandotte.patch.com/articles/wyandotte-unveils-state-s-largest-solar-energy-project It is happening everywhere that the energy companies can not stop it.This project is in Detroit.
2
2
u/Ironic_Creationist May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Germany has disbanded its nuclear power program in favor of importing nuclear power from the chech republic. 50 % renewable power seems a bit inflated?
Something smells fishy
2
u/torino_nera May 28 '12
I guess this disproves the whole 'solar and wind energy can't sustain a whole country' notion that conservatives have been trying to push on us in America, right?
6
u/62346346364 May 28 '12
Comments on reddit for past 12 months: Solar power is worthless. lololol! Watch Germany fail and go back to coal! hahahah. "I'm totally a scientist guys, this stuff is impossible." Coal and Nuclear are the only two sources of power possible! Germany fails! LOL! Thorium = God! Solar power is for Luddites, nuclear is the future!! (followed by mass downvotes [ and "explanations"] of anyone who disagreed).
I hope most of you burn in the nonexistent hell that awaits us at the end of our existences. You honestly deserve it for constantly attempting to hinder human progress to feel special and in your active pursuits of the spread of misinformation.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/kayende May 28 '12
This is just a gag made for publicity. At best it is telling the pretty version, at worst you could call it lying.
Solar power plants produce power when the sun is up. Unfortunately it produces the most when the sun is at its highest point around noon. This coincides with the time of day where power demand is at its lowest. This means that in order to make solar power replace fossil fuels, you need to store it. And soring means losing some because no viable storage solution is 100% efficient. Which in turn means you have to build extra capacity that you would not need with coal or nuclear power plants that can be turned on or off on demand. Additionally you need to compensate for winter and lousy weather which means even more "overcapacity".
At the moment, Germany has decided to get rid of their nuclear power plants. This is an honorable thing to do, but the problem is that they in this way will get more dependent on fossil fuels like gas and coal to make their electricity. This undermines the goals of the rest of the world of lowering CO2-emissions.
The later days have been very warm and sunny in Germany. The Germans have done a good job with solar electricity, but they still have a long way to go and they still are VERY dependent on coal power.
1
4
u/evitagen-armak May 28 '12
through the midday hours on Friday and Saturday
I think the title is a little misleading. It's not 50 % of the power of one year. It's just for a couple of hours in the middle of the day, in the summer when sunny. Still impressive though.
4
u/StarlightN May 28 '12
I love everything about renewable energy. I love the technology. I love the sustainability. I love the ideas.
With solar in particular, I think setting up huge solar farms is the wrong way to go about it. It's costly, requires a lot of land that just isn't available in Europe.
Why not focus on spreading the resources across the residential sector? If each house has a solar panel or more that all contribute to the grid, wouldn't that make more practicality sense? It takes up no extra space, and everyone is contributing continually.
Just an idea.
10
u/stesch May 28 '12
Take another look at Germany: Every small town and village has a lot of solar panels on private roofs.
On my way to work I can see solar panels on the roofs, wind turbines, and cooling towers of a nuclear plant. :-)
→ More replies (2)1
u/balorina May 28 '12
Because they are expensive and need replacing and maintenance. It is easier and less of a burden on everyone to create a "solar farm" where one organization is in charge of all that.
→ More replies (1)1
May 28 '12
The real answer is that small-scale solar is very expensive and often takes decades to break even. Since the equipment may not last that long, it may never recoup the original investment, particularly if no government subsidy is available.
3
u/Golemfrost May 28 '12
Like said, this makes me rather proud to be German. btw, Wind power plants have been popping up everywhere aswell.
3
u/jakewolf23 May 28 '12
Germany should be considered a role model country in today's world. Their work ethic and strong economic condition is comparable (if not better) to the United States.
2
2
2
u/Commisar May 28 '12
well, this is sort of useless if they can't store and efficiently transport the energy. meanwhile, France gets 80% of its power ALL THE TIME from nuclear. But still, good job Germany.
2
u/SleepyEel May 28 '12
I still think nuclear is the way to go for the next century. It really upsets me that the general public is still scared of it.
2
2
u/eelnitsud May 28 '12
Key word being "midday" to say that it supplies 50% of the nations energy demand is false.
2
May 28 '12
50% of Nation's Electricity Demand
You mean from 7 AM to 7 PM?
5
u/anxiousalpaca May 28 '12
Yes and on a national holiday when shops and industry must be shut down.
6
u/47h315m May 28 '12
To clarify, in Germany, all shops are closed on sundays and holidays.
→ More replies (8)
2
u/spock_block May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Well done Germany!
To those who thinks this proves renewables can replace other, more stable forms of energy, think again.
Because they don't like to print out graphs that aren't favourable to them, it is difficult to come by graphs plotting total demand vs total wind/solar production. But the data is there if you want to look for it.
So here is a chart over Ireland's total power demand vs total power production from all wind farms from Monday 120521 to Sunday 120527. The place isn't Germany and it isn't solar, but the principles are the same. You will notice how the demand is predictable and cyclic, but the production from wind is erratic and intermittent. Also note the huge cut-off towards the end of the week. It is either maintenance, but more probably the turbines have cut out due to too high wind speeds.
Wind/solar cannot replace fossil or nuclear because it is an intermittent source of energy. It is a great source to add to the base load however, when available. What is happening now though, in Germany specifically, is that politicians and laypeople are dictating how one of Europe's biggest energy consumers are going to produce their energy. Not scientists and facts, but fear of the word "Nuclear". And they believe that you can replace highly dense and reliable energy production, with low-density intermittent sources.
And because people have a fear of Nuclear, they instead build new coal-fired plants, that will pick up the slack when the wind dies down or the sun goes into the clouds. And because people don't know how a fossil-fueled power plant works, they do not know that you can't just flip it on like a switch. It is constantly running at low loads, constantly burning, to be ready when the inevitable dip in power comes. And then turn around and say that they must build more wind/solar. Which in turn means even more fossil.
Wind and solar is great, but it isn't a replacement, it is an addition.
→ More replies (7)
-1
u/estomagordo May 28 '12
Stopped reading at "Gigawatts per hours". Clueless people really shouldn't be trusted with keyboards. Let alone jobs.
16
7
1
u/LaughingMagpie02 May 28 '12
For a country that has the 50 parallel going through it this seems a tad ambitious. I think the gesture is fantastic but what about hydroelectric, geothermal or wind?
2
May 28 '12
Hydro is a non-issue. That's something for Norway, not Germany. The mountains would have to be built first...
Wind is actually bigger than solar.
Geothermal isn't exactly ready or well applicable. Leave that to the vikings on Iceland.
You forgot bio, which is actually up and coming in rural areas in an effort to reduce heating and electricity bills.
3
u/1632 May 28 '12
This is not true for the southern parts of Germany. Next to the alps, especially in Bavaria, there are plenty of water plants. Most of the are in the process of being seriously updated just now. New store facilities are in the final stages of planing. In the northern Ruhr-area mining companies are planning to convert old mines to subterranean water storage facilities in order to store energy on a large scale.
Just next to Munich a huge Geothermal plant has been finished 2 years ago. Several more are projected.
→ More replies (1)3
u/LaughingMagpie02 May 28 '12
There are mountains and plenty of rivers in the south of Germany unless my understanding of German geography is very poor.
I mentioned geothermal as I read an article in a paper this weekend about how the UK reckons they can get about 20% from all their geothermal "hotstops" if they were to exploit them fully.
Wind if you can get people to get over the "blight" on the landscape and so on.
I did forget bio you're right very absent minded of me. I certainly think it is well worth it, us humans produce plenty of waste we should put it to good use.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Jabberminor May 28 '12
Why can't England do this...oh wait, we don't get nearly enough sunshine often.
1
u/MaxManus May 28 '12
There is a load of other renewable energy recources which you can use. Especially "Gezeitenkraftwerke" (s.th like tide powerplants) is a way for GB 'cause you got ocean all around;)
(And get your houses insulated )
→ More replies (1)
1
u/hauboe May 28 '12
Through the midday hours, so say... six hours? So divide that output by 4 and you have the real number. On a sunny day.
1
u/hauboe May 28 '12
Not that solar power is bad, but I feel that nuclear power is so misused and has a reputation for being dangerous that is completely unfounded..... I don't even have the energy to explain each point I'm trying to make.
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/GlowingShutter May 28 '12
And on the other hand we still import a lot of electricity from atom-powered nations like france. Not so "green" on the second look. But still - there is progress.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/lobius_ May 28 '12
Florida, Arizona, New Mexico and Nevada could power the entire continent with solar.
1
u/undergarden May 28 '12
Any why aren't we doing this at such a scale in the vast southwestern US?
2
u/fantasyfest May 28 '12
Three western states derive over 10 percent of their energy from wind. Between solar and wind, they are on the right track.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/SonOfAGrayHairedMan May 28 '12
This is the 3rd or 4th repost I've seen of this same story in 2 days.
2
1
u/Mycakedayis1111 May 28 '12
"Well if Germany is doing it then let's get on board". Hold on one second there Italy.
1
u/DepletionRegion May 28 '12
That's going to suck when we block out the sun to prevent the Machines from taking over.
1
1
u/srsh May 28 '12
I'm sure all the oil lobbyists in USA are very happy about this. They've all got big pay hikes coming. They've also got a lot of new career opportunities now.
=== As for USA:
Anybody that's done a cross-country drive will tell you there is SO MUCH empty land throughout the country. So many places where solar power panels can be setup.
It would benefit everyone except BP/EXXON/etc... and their stock holders .... which is why it would never happen.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/executex May 28 '12
Hey Germany, just wait till the next Ice Age. As our fossil fuels are melting the ice caps and dumping fresh water into the atlantic, your currents will disappear, and your warm weather will go, and you will be stuck with useless solar panels :D.
We already planned your demise!
We won't stop there, we convinced you to dismantle your nuclear program, because we tricked you into thinking it's unclean. Next we'll develop our improved nuclear plants that doesn't produce nuclear waste. And you'll regret abandoning nuclear efforts.
Meanwhile our corporations are developing electric cars to sell to you. While your BMW and Audis are still requiring premium gas.
1
u/mattockk May 28 '12
If Germany can do this with fractions of the space Canada has and nearly 3 times the population. As a Canadian I don't understand why we are not pursuing renewable sources way more than just for publicity, because what we're doing now is an abomination to human advancement and nature which could be well improved, we have to space to say the least.
1
u/DrSweetscent May 28 '12
Between all the bickering in our day-to-day politics, news like this make me confident that my country is, en gross, on the right track.
1
u/Sallymander May 28 '12
Whats this? Cheap renewable energy source? Lets collect it and charge an arm and a leg for it.
1
1
1
u/fbdysurfer May 28 '12
Germany sets solar power record using outdated tech! Check out ZenithSolar.com No subsidies needed to operate. Of course you have to pay the upfront cost for the install. It also heats water up for a building. Now that is efficient.
1
u/tree_D May 28 '12
Can someone explain to me why America can't do stuff like this? Is it oil company lobbying? Does America not have enough money to make that kind of investment?
1
1
1
1
u/brandon_14 May 28 '12
i heard it was only a 1/3 rd of there demand but i'm probably wrong and should be downvoted into oblivion
1
u/Scottmkiv May 29 '12
Yeah, right. It would be impossibly expensive to do that. Germany is also horribly positioned to even try. They just don't get enough sun.
1
u/dumbguy2012 May 29 '12
Germany also has to import a lot of it's energy. It's a cool finding but I would temper some excitement.
1
1
1
1
u/stepchanger Jul 05 '12
the solar (photovoltaics) industry in Gemany was based only on subsidies, that´s why such an incredible increase has been achieved. However, in the last 2 years politics cut subsidies, now the solar industry is dead
1
May 28 '12
German solar power plants produced a world record 22 gigawatts of electricity per hour
I simply couldn't read on.
1
1
1
185
u/xxdeetsxx May 28 '12
"22 gigawatts of electricity per hour" is a unit of acceleration of energy production.
I assume he means 22 gigawatts, or 22 gigawatthours in a particular hour.