r/technology • u/[deleted] • May 21 '12
Facebook stock sinks 11 percent, below IPO price
http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/facebook-stock-down-nearly-7-percent-as-it-opens-for-2nd-day-of-trading-as-public-company/2012/05/21/gIQAT4VIfU_story.html?hpid=z269
May 21 '12
Facebook doesn't have a product. At least Zynga has paying customers who put money into their games. Facebook's revenue model is literally a pyramid scheme that only works if its user base grows. Advertisers are already showing that FB marketing isn't paying off. Once FB hits a user ceiling they need to either diversify into web services (like Google) or start charging for premium services. This is why rumors of a FB phone are so popular.
17
May 21 '12
Exactly what I think. I recently read that Zynga is responsible of 12% of Facebook revenues! And I'm not even sure that it includes the revenues of 3-party ads displayed on zynga's games pages... And in my opinion, it's mainly on those game pages that user are clicking on ads.
18
38
u/LinuxNoob May 21 '12
Facebook does have a product, it's you. They sell that product to many companies world wide. Same with Twitter.
→ More replies (2)9
u/MasZakrY May 21 '12
Twitter doesn't make any money or have a way of generating revenue.
→ More replies (1)12
u/wallychamp May 21 '12
There are ads on Twitter.
→ More replies (6)24
u/spuur May 21 '12
According to the leaked financial results Twitter does not have a working business model yet and was taking heavy losses as late as Q3 2011.
→ More replies (2)7
u/Sabotage101 May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
How is it a pyramid scheme in any way whatsoever? Why would the user base need to grow in order to generate revenue by advertising to it when it's already profitable and sustainable(though not wildly so)?
3
u/willcode4beer May 21 '12
Television networks don't have products either but, much like facebook, they make a lot of money selling advertising.
How is it's revenue like a pyramid? That statement doesn't even make sense.
→ More replies (51)2
u/M3wThr33 May 21 '12
GM is a goddamn idiot company. They're also backing out of Super Bowl ads. They're just being cheap asses.
36
u/NobblyNobody May 21 '12
It think it's standard practice at this point to get desperate to monetize it more intrusively and cheese off everyone that uses it - past the breaking point, killing the user base off as well.
Google must be dancing around like a goat on a treadmill
edit:Split Infinitive
21
u/david_n_m_bond May 21 '12
Agreed. See Digg.
→ More replies (4)52
u/Thydamine May 21 '12
Creation
Acceleration of popularity
Monetization
Further Monetization
Plastered with ads
Forgotten by the youth (no longer cool)
Mocked as "old"
Bankruptcy
Life of a website
→ More replies (1)25
May 21 '12
I need to show this my friend. His three attempts of creating websites have always gone from step one straight to step eight.
→ More replies (4)4
u/BCMM May 22 '12
There is nothing wrong with the split infinitive. Some guy in the mid-19th century took a snobbish dislike to it. Though it has a long history, it was said to be becoming more popular, and he declared that it just wasn't proper English. It's not entirely clear to me who put him in charge of the evolution of the language, but people listened to him for a hundred-odd years. The view is now considered outdated.
3
u/putin_my_ass May 22 '12
In linguistics this is known as prescriptive grammar (his) vs descriptive grammar.
There's a reason that modern linguists are largely from the descriptive school.
2
u/NobblyNobody May 22 '12
agreed, normally. In this case though the sentence ran like a donkey dropping a foot in a pothole 'til I fixed it.
133
49
u/gregp203 May 21 '12
Investing in Facebook now is like investing in the yellowpages in the early 90's.
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (24)7
May 21 '12
lose and yes it can go really fast. Look at yahoo, myspace, aol, digg, etc. It can happen in a matter of days or months. Digg seemed to die within a week.
→ More replies (1)
46
41
u/mookx May 21 '12
Gee, didn't see that coming. You mean it's not worth more then GM or GE?
18
u/willcode4beer May 21 '12
General Motors net income: $5.44B
General Electric net income: $12.97B
Facebook net income: $652M
OTOH, Facebook is the only one of them with a high quarterly earnings growth and it's profit margin blows the others out of the water. If it wasn't ridiculously over-priced it could be good for a 3-5 year investment. As it is, the price is still just too high.
→ More replies (7)1
May 22 '12
I did. I have a feeling there's a lot of people out there who are going to game this stock so hard due to so many idiots buying stock who don't know what they're doing.
9
u/iorgfeflkd May 21 '12
Good time to buy then?
I find it funny how people use facebook so ubiquitously but still want it to fail.
5
u/igonjukja May 22 '12
i think this is a symptom of people's great annoyance with how careless and arrogant FB has been on the privacy issue. which also makes it easy for me to imagine how ppl could eventually jump ship once something that they like better comes along.
1
May 22 '12
I don't want them to fail, I just want them to understand that me being there keeps their site alive. So don't give my information to "apps" or even have the option of apps "posting anytime as me".
At the same time, this is a big reason why Facebook is so successful.
Also, Zuckerberg's a dick, I've seen Social Network and that was 100% truth.
273
u/shnape May 21 '12
The stock was way overhyped. Sad but true.
239
u/wgsbnen May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Day trader here. What do you mean by "overhyped?" The media attention with Facebook was always going to be huge, it's the biggest IPO in American corporate history. It's difficult to overhype that. I don't know any of my colleagues who weren't expecting this to happen on day 2. It isn't representative of anything. I'll only grow concerned when I see a negative two week graph but I expect this to fluctuate for quite a while before we get an idea of a base price. Long story short: It's far too early to tell and the only reason why we're seeing such a drop on day 2 is because of nervousness and a lack of research from potential buyers. Facebook has a fairly solid business model and a superb team. Give it time.
Edit: Biggest by MC, I should say.
Apologies. I'm going to give it a rest replying to people. I want to clarify: I've spent my adult life making a living doing my job and it seems many of those replying to me simply don't like Facebook as a company or social media as a valuable facet of the internet. I was hoping for a good discussion about the IPO and to give people some trading advice based on my experience, but most of what I'm getting is emotive responses from ideologues. It's making it very difficult to extract any good discussion from this story.
30
u/buckygrad May 21 '12
From the WSJ: "At $34, Facebook would have a price/earnings ratio, a measure of how expensive or cheap a stock is, of about 57 times projected earnings for the next 12 months, according to FactSet research. That still is a much richer valuation than other tech companies, such as Google Inc."
This is why.65
May 21 '12
Their P/E is 108. Their IPO was set at a rough market cap of 100 billion, HALF of Google's market worth. Yet, facebook's profit last year was 1 billion (1% of their market cap). Google's profit last year was 37billion. That's 37 TIMES more profit than Facebook. Come on, the metrics are right in front of you. You had to have some expectation that Facebook was possibly overvalued, ya?
The market is correctly reducing FB's price. It was overvalued.
16
u/Florenceandtheravine May 22 '12
I agree, but your numbers are off. PROFIT at GOOG was $11.7 bn. REVENUE was $37 bn.
NINJA EDIT: That means both figures are about 10x FB's numbers, but google is a bit more efficient.→ More replies (2)77
May 21 '12
Day trader here.
Prepare yourself for a volley of platitudes from an army of armchair economic experts.
→ More replies (1)37
29
u/the_catacombs May 21 '12
As a day trader, what do you, personally, think the real intrinsic value of Facebook is? Do you think those piddly little ads are really going to justify a $104b valuation? How about the aggregate information, which I believe to be dwindling? Obviously I don't think it's worth 104 bil. But what do I know..
→ More replies (8)52
u/wgsbnen May 21 '12
I think it's the fact that it has become a real platform (to many people Facebook and Google are the internet in its entirety), from which you can possibly sell, license, or showcase anything. That's the risk and unending potential of it. I think a lot of people on Reddit find it an affront that a social network could be valued so highly. I don't place value in Facebook based on the social network itself (the liking and chatting between friends), rather what it can become. The group of people running Facebook are truly excellent. They're biding their time and have shown great restraint with their cash on hand. Many cite their profit per user as a reason not to invest, but with such great people running the company I find it very difficult to believe they're not currently planning huge expansions in other areas. When you consider how much one company, Zynga, makes for Facebook you can really see where they could go.
That being said, it is still risky and I think it will be a very shaky stock in the short term, but Facebook is very far from smoke and mirrors, as some on here have put it. You gotta remember that people invest based on potential, not solely on the current business model and profitability.
SORRY! Edit: By "great" people, I don't mean they're wonderful human beings. I'm saying that they have great experience and have shown excellent management skills and ability to produce profit in the past.
11
May 21 '12
The problem is that if if they ever monetise it in the way you're describing, people will probably leave and they'll be left with nothing. Google is a utility; it's the phone book, no one cares if it's covered in ads. FB (like Myspace before it) is just 'the cool place to be'. I just can't see how they could monetise it in the way you're suggesting and maintain that same cultural cachet. The only truly valuable thing they have going for them is the information they have on their users but if they ever use that in any significant way (launch their own ad network, for example) the press will crucify them.
I don't have any personal dislike for FB, but it simply doesn't have the intrinsic value of something like Google. It isn't much of an oversimplification to say that someone can just make another one.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (27)18
7
u/willNEVERupvoteYOU May 21 '12
Do you not consider a price to earnings ratio of over 100 to be "overhyped"?
→ More replies (2)19
May 21 '12
The problem is you fell for the promise of future profit where current returns are very low. You are also in /r/technology which tends to have more tech-savvy subscribers who actually understand the technology side behind Facebook. Most business people look at Facebook as an opportunity because the tech side of the equation is lost on them.
The fact is that mobile ads are an incredibly poor avenue for generating profit (a problem facing other tech companies). Facebook's current revenue is mostly from desktop ads, not mobile. Meanwhile, their mobile app is starting to (expected to continue to increasingly) cut into desktop usage which means their future prospects for ad revenue are slim at best unless they find new ways to innovate. A company as large as Facebook buys innovation, it rarely creates it. Therein lies the problem - Facebook will have to buy its profits. They're going to have to take on heavy debt to innovate and have any chance at creating a real profit.
To make matters worse, a large number of people have been shown to have zero interest in Facebook's ads (source). Couple that with the strong distrust in privacy from Facebook and there is a giant trust hurdle that business people don't seem to talk about. Google created a Facebook clone almost overnight -- I could see in 15 years the younger generation hopping on Google+ simply because their parents aren't there. Nothing currently ties users to Facebook -- and if people don't trust it then that only furthers to drive them away.
Perhaps most worrying of all is the distribution of power in the company. Zuckerberg's hold on shares means you are nearly entirely at his mercy with regards to the company. Between the poor financials, poor future prospects, poor user sentiment and balance of power in the company things look pretty bad. If this isn't dotcom 2.0 then I don't know what is.
Facebook isn't going away. Facebook will definitely keep making money. however, at $38/share it's waaaay overpriced. You're talking about almost a 90x multiple on earnings for a company that is likely to see its earnings start to slip. Any sane investor I know would be investing in something else with actual growth potential.
4
u/no1chachi May 21 '12
I don't disagree with you that Facebook is way, way overvalued, even taking into account its potential for future growth.
But I just want to challenge a couple of things you said:
(1) That large companies don't innovate but have to buy profits. That's just plain wrong. There are countless examples: Apple, Google, and even the dinosaurs Microsoft, Intel, continue to innovate.
(2) That nothing ties users to Facebook. Actually, a lot ties users to Facebook; it's called Network Effects. The value of Facebook is that everyone is already using it and posting content to it. If you are the first to jump over to Google Plus, you are going to be all alone with no content to enjoy. Something has to drive a mass exodus from Facebook.→ More replies (1)3
May 21 '12
I was hoping for a good discussion about the IPO and to give people some trading advice based on my experience, but most of what I'm getting is emotive responses from ideologues.
Welcome to Reddit. Good luck finding good discussion on a subreddit of this population.
102
u/floridalegend May 21 '12
Sound like someone invested poorly.
→ More replies (11)75
u/wgsbnen May 21 '12
Haha! Nope, I'm holding off for a month at least. It interests me, but only as curiosity. I never let tech stocks make up more than 3-5% of my portfolio.
→ More replies (86)7
2
u/whatupnig May 21 '12
How will FB make money when most of their users access it through mobile, with no ads? When over half your userbase is not seeing ads, and that base is increasing, how will FB make money? GM pulled out for a good reason... Btw, it's clear you have stock with them, people are less aggressive towards your opinions when you have full disclosure (I don't have shares, $38 is overpriced).
2
u/wuy3 May 22 '12
what did you expect, you are trying to explain economics to a bunch of high schoolers who don't even know enough to only buy loss-leaders at their fast food venue of choice. Just go back to r/investing, you'll have more luck there.
2
May 22 '12
Morgan Stanley dumped way too many shares on the first day, I think they just wanted to set the record rather than making a sensible IPO. And a major red flag should have been raised when 60% of issued shares came from insiders when the average tech IPO is around 30%, it looked like a bunch of people saw they chance to finally make money off Facebook and they took it. I don't see a long term plan for either the business model or the stock and I think we're seeing this with data coming out regarding advertiser sentiment regarding Facebook. 850 million in revenue just doesn't justify this IPO. Perhaps at a price closer to 15 or 20.
2
u/Florenceandtheravine May 22 '12
Whenever someone says that they're a day trader, I'm reminded of what the interviewer at GS told me "For every billion dollars of profit we make, 50% comes from failed day traders." It struck me as very arrogant, given it was 2011 and all, but congrats on making it!
→ More replies (80)6
u/Kinseyincanada May 21 '12
Don't bother to try an explain anything about the stock market on here. No one seems to know how it works, a fluctuation in stock price a day after trading is normal, but they see the stock drop and instantly think the bubble burst or anything.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Thunder_Bastard May 22 '12
It is pretty clear there is a problem when the investment banks that have money already in Facebook are buying up the stock to keep it from falling below offering price on the first day of trading.
I have this funny feeling that investors are going to be losing billions before this things settles out.
But why would anyone at Facebook care? They are all off buying exotic cars and planning out their mansions.
1
u/SpaceToaster May 21 '12
Do you mean that there was more praise than it deserved? Most opinions before the IPO I read were neutral to negative, with a few positive speculation sprinkled in.
1
u/ICouldBeTheChosenOne May 22 '12
You mean a company with no business model isn't worth a billion dollars?
→ More replies (3)1
u/olivermihoff May 22 '12
You can get 20 shares with a 12 piece bucket of chicken at KFC now... I told everyone this would happen. Soon they will trade in PESOS.
7
May 22 '12
One would think that a company valued at $104b could at least make a decent mobile app...
15
May 21 '12
Investors are de-friending Mark Zuckerberg...
1
u/slinkymaster May 22 '12
except the ones who have been hanging onto these shares long before they went public and are now multimillionaires, or even billionaires in some cases.
5
u/FetidFeet May 21 '12
While everyone is wringing their hands in glee, just remember that FB didn't leave any money on the table (underpricing the IPO). FB had a tremendous amount of leverage in choosing who they wanted to take them public. They made it clear from the start they were calling the shots, and not letting the bankers benefit their buddies (and future business) by underpricing.
If I'm Mark Zuckerberg, I'd rather raise my capital at a higher price and let the IPO sink than raise at a lower price and benefit the IPO holders (people I've never met).
5
May 21 '12
Without turning into a spam machine I don't know how they plan to make more money
1
u/expertunderachiever May 22 '12
They sell your content to others. E.g. your pictures might be useful as clipart/etc for advertisers. What you post too. For instance, I recently bought a Hyundai car. If Hyundai wanted to see what demographic/etc are talking about [and what they are saying] they could contract FB to catalogue all that for them...
FB has ads? Adblocker to the rescue.
5
u/boot20 May 21 '12
Anyone that was around for the .com crash knows this is very familiar. Facebook makes nothing, does nothing, and is a fad. Social media is here to stay, but Facebook isn't going to be a name brand forever.
8
8
u/ClubSoda May 21 '12
700 million users daily ? I want that audited independently. Are they all unique user accounts?
1
u/WadeAndBeccasLvgRmPC May 25 '12
There's no way they're unique user accounts. But with all pages, users, and different devices to access facebook from I could see maybe close to that.
4
u/Southernz May 22 '12
Frienster. Myspace. Facebook. Why would u dump money in a social network if the past proves they all flop?
4
u/eloist May 22 '12
At about $100 per user profile, it just seems completely overvalued.
That's a lot of ads to click.
7
u/Akira_kj May 21 '12
This is what happens when people remember what happened to Yahoo. From $115 a share to near penny stocks. Why would anyone want to ride that ship off into oblivion again? Don't buy wgsbnen's BS about how the stock will correct, they are a Tech IPO with some holdings in other tech companies that rely on internet advertisement for revenue. What happens when the next facebook comes along (myspace anyone?) or when Mark Z says or does something offensive and the site turns into a ghost town. To invest in Facebook on anything more than a lark you would be more than foolish in doing so.
4
u/tomdarch May 21 '12
Yahoo? What about AOL? (Insert sound of crashing WWII bomber falling out of the sky...)
→ More replies (1)
9
u/Foley1 May 21 '12
Hmmm, Facebook is on the way out, my chance to strike with a fab new social network Foleyfaceprofilespacepagebook.com
30
May 21 '12
This makes me very happy. I want them to tank.
23
→ More replies (2)10
u/spuur May 21 '12
They are probably not going to tank, and they are probably going to myspace instead.
→ More replies (2)2
6
3
u/yhelothere May 21 '12
Facebook missed the smartphone-trend completely, they would have been able to make a shitton of money with that + what else besides social networking (compared to google) does FB offer/creates? Nothing.
Besides that am I not a big fan of that company. I am using FB but only because all my friends are there and I am too lazy to missionize them for Google+
1
u/is_this_4chon May 21 '12
yep....they were pretty arrogant to put out garbage iPhone/Android apps and shitty mobile web offering....perhaps it's because they see too much value in having their user base to continue using PC's where they can easily datamine the unsuspecting of offline activity.
3
3
3
u/PaxiSnack May 21 '12
Good. This is a company that sells our 'metrics' for advertising dollars. Talk about feeding a vampire monkey on your back.
1
u/willcode4beer May 21 '12
The sad part is how terrible they are at it. Google makes something around 11X per user. Facebook should really hire some people who can build a decent ad network.
At a minimum, they should at least try keywords. Google ads are usually related to search history. About the only targeting (I notice) in Facebook ads is geographical, and it's usually wrong.
Look at how many people whine about their medical problems on facebook. That's advertising gold and they don't make use of it. Heck, Google makes around $50 a click on a mesothelioma ad. Facebook has the potential for ads that are much more targeted.
3
3
u/Halfwegian May 21 '12
"IPO=It's Probably Overpriced" --The Intelligent Investor by Benjamin Graham
Of course, it's not always overpriced (for instance VISA took off after the IPO), but unless you have an excellent understanding of the company, it's leadership, the business model, and have a good understanding of a company's competitors--both now and over the next several years--investing in an IPO is probably foolish.
What we're witnessing with FB's stock isn't necessarily a complete lack of faith by the market in the company, but moreover a price correction. Price Distortion is common in IPOs, since only a select few (relatively speaking) are involved with the setting of the price. Once the company is public, millions of people from all over the world decide on the price of the stock via the most basic of all microeconomics: supply and demand. Sure, markets are sometimes too bullish, and sometimes far too bearish, but speaking in generalities, they usually do a fairly good job of valuing companies. I think FB's probably just experiencing a price correction--but it's impossible to say for sure given the volatility levels and period of time.
2
u/willcode4beer May 21 '12
This advice goes double for tech companies.
In start-up land, one of the primary things folks discuss is the "exit strategy". Which basically means what's the plan to cash out and get out? The most common exit plans are to be purchased or have an IPO.
So, even if you have great people build the company, it's rare for them to stick around for long after the IPO.
→ More replies (1)0
3
u/irishsteve12 May 21 '12
From a technical standpoint this is very interesting, considering the performance of other internet IPOs from the past year or so. The stocks of these companies (Groupon, Zynga, and LinkedIn being some of the most prominent) all fell around 30%-60% in the first ~25 days of trading before regaining much or all of that ground in the next month or so. Someone more knowledgeable than me could determine whether there is some underlying characteristic of internet stocks that has caused this trend, or whether it is pure coincidence. Either way, I thought that Facebook might be different enough from the previous stocks (by virtue of sheer size and popularity of the IPO, if nothing else) that this trend might not occur in this scenario, but...then this happened. We will see.
3
u/MeLlamoViking May 21 '12
Bahaha, seeing this makes me joyous. And worrisome at the same time, when facebook begins to decline in price, with the mass amount of data they have on people. What will they do to turn a profit from that, if their current methods are failing?
1
u/bmberlin May 22 '12
Here is a big problem. How do they cut cost and increase revenue? They have no intrinsic value, just speculative worth.
20
7
u/Eight8Eight May 21 '12
I hope it drops like a rock personally
I use facebook but could use something else
5
u/onlyvotes May 21 '12
Facebook cooked the books and shifted as much money as possible to say "we make a billion a year".
The utter fucking insanity of this was - it was a pure psych play. The psych101 idiotic advisors (who think they are so clever, and plot to change the colors of buttons to change user behavior) thought, let's try and get the 'IPO value' ingrained in people's minds as 100 billion.
It is an utter fantasy.
The same as asking Microsoft to take a very small piece of the company for at least a sizable investment - to look legit, but to make the impression of a large valuation, that 300 odd million investment.
Fuck facebook.
3
u/tomdarch May 21 '12
I wish I could find the source, but I thought that i heard that in order to justify the US$100 billion valuation, FB would have to capture something like 10% of the entire global advertising spending within some number of years. If that's true, it's nuts.
→ More replies (1)
4
4
2
May 21 '12
It is most likely still being partially propped up by the underwriters for the IPO. Just wait until tomorrow.
2
u/enarbandy May 21 '12
I think that Facebook's stock will fall further. A key point to consider here is what is Facebook really offering that evokes confidence in a rational investor? Does an investor really think it is worth the premium? The answer to the first question harkens back to the days of the IT bubble in the late nineties, early 2K.....Eyeballs. That's it for now. The answer to the second question (if history has really taught us anything) should be a resounding no.
Now having said that if Facebook were to begin creating digital value that added to the bottom line by using (legally) the immense information they have about their users to cater innovative and valuable, digital and real world products and services that users like, they can end up creating a very successful business model. They need not search far and hard for an exemplar on how to do this. They can just Google it.
2
u/Ractrick May 21 '12
Well what did you expect? With this much media hype, it was bound to go down initially
2
2
u/EOTWAWKI May 22 '12
As someone who still doesn't see any reason to have a Facebook account. This makes me very happy.
2
u/scorcher_IV May 22 '12
I don't use facebook, is it true or a rumor that they sell your information to other corporations so they can market specifically to you, or is this just bullshit?
1
u/DanielPhermous May 22 '12
You're in the right ballpark. I believe they collect your information and build a profile of you which companies can then target. For example, they might know that you have dogs and cats at home and can directly target you with an advert for a pet food that works for both.
2
May 22 '12
I'd never buy it because it seems like the investment world version of musical chairs. Lots of people will make money for a while but one day the music will stop and if you are not careful you'll be holding a pile of shit. Facebook as just another variation on the company with webpages and advertising that is hot now - but can be a ghost-town in a short time (Geocities, MySpace, AOL) . This one is strictly for the professionals who know how to hedge risk.
2
2
May 22 '12
imo, a company based on a social media fad is just not a viable in the long term. we all know fickle people are with social circles. facebook is incredibly overvalued. if i was zuckerberg i would've cut it loose at a cool 1billion. oh wait, facebook bought instagram for 1 billion? lol. retards.
2
May 22 '12 edited May 24 '12
You mean spending $50 on a share isn't going to make me a billionaire? Thanks a lot, Obama.
3
u/j2thaP May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
There's three very solid reasons to not buy Facebook stock... yet.
Facebook Does Not Have A Great Monetized Product.
Facebook’s Financial Performance Will Be Uneven In The Near Term, and Markets Hate Uncertainty
Facebook’s Potential is Longterm
If I were hazarding a guess, I'd say 12 - 18 months will be a great time to buy. But that's reliant on a lot of product, success, and B2B PR assumptions.
A complete post on this opinion is here, if you're interested.
→ More replies (1)4
u/tomdarch May 21 '12
My 3 reasons not to invest in Facebook are: AOL, Yahoo and Myspace.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
u/foomachoo May 21 '12
Uh, why should the BUYERS at IPO day benefit?
This IPO showed a rare example where the underwriters properly priced the opening, so that the founders, & early investors (those that took the big risk) got 90%+ of the reward on opening day.
Also, it showed rare examples of rational market behavior, where there wasn't a huge speculation bubble on top of bad fundamentals.
10
u/emperoni May 21 '12
The fact that Zuckerberg got every penny possible out of the IPO and left nothing for the common investor says a lot about the guy.
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)17
u/jorgepolak May 21 '12
Quiet! Can't you he's USING BOLD CAPS? He must know what he's talking about.
2
u/WaterAndSand May 21 '12
Fuck yeah. My friends looked at me like I was crazy when I said I wouldn't buy this stock if I had the money to do so.
2
u/manberry_sauce May 21 '12
I wonder how long until the SEC has them over a barrel for over-valuing their IPO. Or the investors themselves.
I wish I was a trader. I would've shorted them on friday so hard.
→ More replies (10)
2
u/lopo12 May 21 '12
Oh dear, that bubble didn't take long to burst.
9
u/tophat_jones May 21 '12
It's not burst yet, just correcting for the absurdly overvalued IPO.
Hopefully the bursting will be more spectacular.
→ More replies (1)
2
May 22 '12
I think it's hilarious hoe people keep com,paring FB to Google in a positive way. Someone bad talks FB and then someones responds with "but look at Google.."
I'm of an age where I'm old enough to have seen all of the "greats" rise and fall, but young enough to have used all of them.
Google search may seem unkillable, but so did Altavista before Google came along. Google just did what Altavista did, better.
Google search is starting to look just like everything that we used to hate about those ols searches. There's nothing of intrinsic value about Google search; it just searches the best at the moment.
We fled hotmail to gmail almost entirely because the capacity was like 10mb for hotmail. The improved email searching etc of gmail was nice, but that's not why we left. All that a new email provider has to do is provide a new feature and people will flee.
We left IRC for ICQ because ICQ was more personalised. We left ICQ to MSN because msn was faster. I don't use chat protocols but I vaguely understand that MSN and FB chat are the standards now. FB chat offers convenience compared to MSN.
I must be too young for Friendster, but my age started on Diaryland and a few similar oldschool blogging ssystems. We moved to Myspace because it was more personal. We moved to FB because it was cleaner and a bit more functional.
With it's new "timeline" shit, FB is turning into a real mess. It can take ages of wading through shit on someone's wall page just to find their last 3 status updates.
We moved to Firefox because it was lighter and faster and more capability. We moved to chrome because Fiirefox got bloated. Now Chrome is bloated so I've switched back to firefox/opera.
MORAL OF THE STORY. All of the current platforms seem like the only way it could be (who eants to use ICQ, Myspace, IE, Hotmail) but at the end of the day it just took a siingle improvement by the NEXT platform to make us jump ship (more storage, faster messaging, faster load times, cleaner interface).
Google might seem infallable, but it isn't. Neither is FB.
It's not easy for someone to pop up overnight with a new car company with factories built, cars engineers, crash standards met, emission standards etc etc. New web platforms don't cost billions to launch like a new car does. Google search and facebook are a perfect example. Probs $20k a piece?
5
1
1
1
u/baconeverything May 21 '12
I see FB turning into Myspace in 6 months to a year. And I feel that it's going to start with advertisments. Right now facebook ad placement is pretty bad (good for us users) but I have a feeling fb is going to change and ads are going to be more annoying.
2
u/tomdarch May 21 '12
Personally, I see Facebook turning into AOL in not that long. I remember great puzzlement when TV ads would include the "AOL Keyword" for their product - this was the time when there were a bunch of people for whom AOL was "the Internet" - a sad little semi-walled garden. Facebook seems to be trying to suck people in and keep them as much as possible within Facebook and to the degree they venture out, capture the comments sections and advertising of other sites - in other words, to create a new version of AOL's semi-walled garden. Given the track record of those who have tried this before, I have low expectations for FB's performance.
(In contrast, Google wants to be a springboard to launch you out onto the real internet/web, and when they capture ad revenue, it's pretty transparent. They are happy to be along for the ride, as opposed to trying to lock you onto a kiddie bumper car track.)
1
u/Zangrefia May 21 '12
Over hyped and inflated. Expect it to dip lower. There is no backbone to it and nothing supporting it. Most people don't use facebook advertisements and just look at them without clicking.
1
1
1
1
May 21 '12
question did facebook sink 11 percent below ipo, or did it sink 11 percent making it fall below ipo thanks
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/mrbooze May 22 '12
This actually says to me the IPO was priced much closer to correctly than most are. We'll see if it continues to drop, but if it settles in at 10-20% below IPO (after all the emotional investors who bought it for no reason then turn around and sell it for no reason) and then starts climbing back up, that's a pretty reasonably successful IPO if you ask me. (Note: I have not and don't plan to buy any Facebook stock directly.)
When you see an IPO debut at $11 and shoot up to $120 by the end of the day, the company should be pissed at how badly priced the IPO was. IPOs like that are highly profitable for insiders and VIPs of the firms handling the IPO who get in at the artificially low opening price, but the company gets screwed out of what should have been a lot more capital.
1
u/MAIRyoutube May 22 '12
Am I the only one who knew this was gonna happen? It's just a fad why would you purchase stock for hit anyway?
1
May 22 '12
I can't believe anyone bought into it in the first place. They have no revenue stream except for ads, and recent research shows that Facebook advertising is pitifully ineffective. The company is way overvalued, and I hope it dies soon.
1
1
May 22 '12
The only reason that it even made its IPO price after a day's trading is because Morgan Stanley scooped up shares. What a farce. Do people even remember the dot-com bubble?
1
1
u/jwelly May 22 '12
Not sure if someone said this already but IPO's are usually overpriced by about 19%.
1
May 22 '12
I wouldn't worry, there'll be a few weeks of people attempting to buy and sell at highest and lowest price immediately.
It's no indication of what the actual worth will end up being. Problem is, facebook hasn't released anything solid that screams "Value" to consumers and investors to signify value.
Compare it to Apple. They released the ipod then the iphone, both massively successful in the real world of tangible goods. It was extremely easy for intelligent and savvy investors with the money set aside to invest in Apple before everyone else jumped onto the band wagon to do so. Sone did, some didn't, thats how risk/reward works.
Facebook has to do something other than just run a website. It can't be services based. If they rely on that for their business model they're doomed to be the next AOL.
If they were savvy, they'd release their own Android-based phone/netbook software platform with intelligent video/photo sharing. Unfortunately, they probably won't.
1
1
1
1
u/Samurai911 May 22 '12
Zuckerburg is smart... he is one tweak away from fixing FBs mobile act, another app away from starting a Reddit equivalent forum, a few more acquisitions away from offering you a complete marketplace etc... it is silly to project the future of his business based on what we see today. He is smart, and has built a great product without any help from financial analysts...
1
May 22 '12
If my local pub said that they went public and I could buy shares, I would think they were kidding me, so I really don't see how people are surprised at this kind of news.
1
u/Schreber May 22 '12
Anyone taking bets on how long it'll maintain a 30+ share price before everyone starts abandoning ship?
1
u/Solkre May 22 '12
I forgot where I heard this, but it sounds accurate to me. "The future of Facebook is the mobile platform, and they don't know how to make money there."
1
1
u/Sybertron May 22 '12
Hey guys look, it's an inflammatory titled article fortelling the doomsday for a massive tech-based company. I've never seen one of these before.
1
u/Zebba_Odirnapal May 22 '12
Keep shorting the fuck out of it and maybe the valuation will begin to approach something realistic.
Translation: bwahahahahaha hahaha hahaha hah
1
1
1
u/gameyey May 22 '12
let me get this math right... facebook is worth about 93billion, because of it's user base of almost 1 billion. So every single facebook account is actually worth almost 100$? and FB only gets money from advertisement, so f.ex if an advertiser thinks 10% of their sale price should go to advertisement (i am guessing that's a high estimate), each facebook user should on average spend 1000$ buying dumb things or services advertised on the site?
With no further knowledge whatsoever, i predict it's insanely overpriced.
1
1
u/irrelevantradiant May 22 '12
That's what happens when you artificially inflate your IPO price because of your enormous ego.
1
u/juicybananas May 22 '12
Is there not an r/stockmarket for this? I know it's technology related but I tire of stock market paranoia. No doubt OP will be posting in a few months how the stock is up....
yawn.
1
1
1
u/beaverlakenc May 21 '12
Sidebar: why is that we can be very anti-corporate, yet not be closing our facebook accounts because of the highly fucked up way the guy decided to become a non american. Seriously - America gave him safe harbor while he/they built that company while here in america. he was protected with american tax dollars if you think about it, and it just seems everyone is tolerating the big fuck you he has given all of us (americans). Partial in part not to pay us americans back some tax dollars after providing such a great place to be in a start up company
This is a major PR fuck up IMO, we as consumers allow this . . . it's all down hill from there
1
May 21 '12
Can anyone help me? I want to do stocks but don't know where to start.
2
u/BongHitta May 21 '12
You don't. Buy ETF's and don't EVER move your money around.
A great ETF to buy covers the whole S&P is SPX.
You will never win at the market. Ever. No one does.
→ More replies (7)2
u/willcode4beer May 21 '12
Start by educating yourself. Don't invest any money until you have an idea of what you are doing.
1
200
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I always thought that Facebook has a poor monetization perspective (in the current scheme). The platform is great, but it is not enough straightforward to be easily monetized. Take Google Adwords for example : people using Google are actively searching for something, and ads based on the search keywords are extremely relevant for them. And it's not even hard to propose those ads, you don't need all that social graph database that is facebook's supposed driving force. That's simple keyword matching. Simple and straightforward, like all good and profitable ideas.
At the opposite, people go on facebook passively, they are not searching for anything in particular, we basically go on facebook out of boredom. People going on facebook are not in a mindset that is receptive to advertisement. Even a perfectly targeted ad on facebook would still propose something that I'm not actually searching at the moment.
Still, there certainly are other revenue perspective for Facebook, but I still haven't heard anything concrete about it...