r/technology • u/coffeetablesex • May 21 '12
Apple iPhone charger teardown shows you almost get what you pay for.
http://www.arcfn.com/2012/05/apple-iphone-charger-teardown-quality.html44
u/doctorsound May 21 '12
Regardless of the debate over profit margins, titles and stuff, this was a pretty cool article. I'd like to see more things like this.
→ More replies (3)17
u/newtothelyte May 21 '12
Its debates like this that still make Reddit great! I mean we got electrical engineers, economists, technologists, and consumers of Apple products in intellectual discussions without memes, shitty jokes, and worn down phrases. This comment thread is a breath of fresh air on a site that has slowly been degrading into a high school hangout. And even though the title is misleading, you must give credit to OP for post a thought-provoking and well written article.
→ More replies (2)
173
u/chimpfunkz May 21 '12
I can't tell if you are being sarcastic..... or just can't really read. But just to be safe,
I was surprised to realize how enormous Apple's profit margins must be on these chargers. These chargers sell for about $30 (if not counterfeit), but that must be almost all profit. Samsung sells a very similar cube charger for about $6-$10, which I also disassembled (and will write up details later). The Apple charger is higher quality and I estimate has about a dollar's worth of additional components inside.
So no, you don't almost get what you paid for, unless that was supposed to be a sarcastic title, in which case you do almost get what you paid for.
54
u/keytud May 21 '12
I feel like a successful marketing campaign wouldn't even have to really fool reddit. There are so, so, so many people who don't learn a single damn thing about a post other than reading the title, if it's not an imgur or youtube link.
Think about it. Sure, we the people in the comments, have fully recognized that the title is a load of shit, but 90% of redditors don't even have an account registered, let alone are clicking through to the comments. There are probably thousands of people right now that read the title, thought "hey Apple products aren't actually overpriced, because reddit says so," and then went on with their lives. That's a marketing success right there. They will go on to tell people that and base their own buying decisions off of the false belief that a very "techy" part of a relatively "techy" website decided that it was true.
2
u/cysun May 21 '12
This a problem that has always affected sites like reddit. I think moderators should be able to mark an article with "Misleading title" visible from the main pages or maybe commenters should be able to vote accordingly a title to misleading.
1
May 21 '12
Everyone downvote and bury this man so that the Apple marketing department doesn't read this....
1
1
May 21 '12
Exactly, I know a lot of people who browse Reddit, but less than half actually has an account and even less check the comments. Out of all of them, I'm the only person who comments and submits regularly.
There is definitely a severe disconnect between people who votes on submissions and those who comment, and that isn't good for Reddit. Thankfully, smaller subreddits generally don't follow this pattern.
6
u/yagmot May 21 '12
something that the article fails to point out is that in fact you are only spending $10 on the charger from apple. where you're getting fucked is the cable, which by itself is $19. $29 charger package comes with one.
8
u/mindsnare May 21 '12
Because the engineers who design these products work for free.
I'm not saying the title isn't misleading or that Apple don't hike the prices like crazy. But trying to guess the cost of something by only looking at the core components doesn't work.
3
May 21 '12
It's like a pharmaceutical company pricing their new medications. Included in that price is the amount of research and design spent on the item as well.
3
u/exteras May 21 '12
I think what the title meant is that, while Apple chargers are higher quality, they are not proportionally higher quality than competing chargers with price taken in to account. So while you get an extra dollar worth of components, you are paying twenty dollars more.
2
1
u/ggggbabybabybaby May 21 '12
I'm not that surprised considering Apple charges somewhere in the same ballpark for the USB dock connector cable too.
1
u/wogturt May 21 '12
It also says
Apple's iPhone charger crams a lot of technology into a small space. Apple went to extra effort to provide higher quality and safety than other name-brand chargers, but this quality comes at a high cost.
And More specifically
this quality comes at a high cost.
Sounds like what he's saying in the paragraph you quoted is that it would seem like since the actual parts of the circuit are rather cheap that the $30 price tag seems steep. But that was all before he mentioned the actual construction of the charger too. Let us not forget all the money that goes into designing it. The price reflects that a little as well.
→ More replies (6)-16
u/wormyrocks May 21 '12
Considering the fact that Apple likely spent 1000x the amount that Samsung did when it certainly could have just built your garden-variety block charger, no, you don't get what you pay for in materials, but you know you are getting a superior product.
No, the sheet metal in a Maserati doesn't cost 50 times as much as the sheet metal in a Pinto, but that's not what you pay for.
Not that I would ever buy one of these chargers. But that's why they are so expensive.
3
May 21 '12
Protip: You need to make your sarcasm more clear. Right now we just think you're retarded :)
4
u/nonhiphipster May 21 '12
A superior product? Who gives a shit, all I need it to do is charge my phone...there's not a whole lot of varying degrees of success that comes with that. Certainly not for upwards of 3X the price, at least.
3
u/tahpot May 21 '12
Varying degrees of success? Yes there is.... efficiency / heat loss -- as mentioned in the article
→ More replies (1)4
May 21 '12
Yeah, besides you can just walk into any Samsung Store and they will swap the charger for free without bothering you with ID or call wait times.
→ More replies (2)2
u/yagmot May 21 '12
would you make the same argument for a car?
Who gives a shit, all you need it to do is get you from A to B...
1
1
u/polarbeargarden May 21 '12
Not really, the circuit design is actually pretty standard across all chargers. There are only a few options here, and while Apple went with the higher-end one, the only thing they designed new was the shape and the ridiculously robust prongs.
→ More replies (8)-1
u/oskarw85 May 21 '12
This is charger for fuck sake... Not exactly rocket science y'know? Saying about superior quality in that context is just ridiculous.
15
u/mrbooze May 21 '12
Somewhere an electrical engineer is crying a single tear that someone on the internet thinks his life's work is ridiculous. It's like you don't even care about the double R-C snubbers filtering the diode bridge to prevent 60Hz hum infiltrating the audio signal.
3
2
u/yagmot May 21 '12
but wouldn't you be really pissed if you're trying to listen to audio while it's charging, but you keep getting interference?
→ More replies (2)
136
u/VolkenGLG May 21 '12
News flash: apple makes high quality but expensive products
→ More replies (106)18
4
u/DeFex May 21 '12
I have a lot of wall warts and stuff, but the iPad charger makes me the most paranoid of all. I won't leave it charging when I go out or to sleep ecause it gets quite hot.
2
May 21 '12
iPad charger operates at much higher specifications than the iPhone charger. If you own both, it might pay to marker them with a pen.
3
2
u/borch_is_god May 21 '12
Actually, that's a smart move. A lot of Apple products are prone to overheating.
4
u/jac50 May 21 '12
Surprising they could cram that into such a tight space without serious noise issues really. Impressive.
Seems like the blog writer has seen this, so got a few questions:
Did you run the charger open board? How did you find out it ran at 70kHz switching frequency? Interested to see the transformer temperature as well, see if it's undersized.
Do you have a teardown blog for the other chargers? Interested to see any difference between them.
And one technical point to note: the controller IC will vary the duty cycle to keep voltage steady, rather than switching frequency. Switching frequency is usually kept constant, and is chosen to weigh up MOSFET switching losses.
Interesting article though.
50
May 21 '12
Like everything else Apple, it is a premium product. You will get a better product but it is well past diminishing returns. To most consumers, 200% price for 10% better charger is unlikely to be the logical choice. Most of us probably just have the one that came with the product.
9
u/joonix May 21 '12
The only way I could justify spending that much on a charger is if it preserves the life of the battery.
→ More replies (3)2
u/keytud May 21 '12
A lot of people don't know this, but you can actually download software that does just that by using beneficial charging patterns instead of simply charging until it's full whenever you plug it in. My think pad has the option to do it under the charging settings, but I bet I could get the same thing for my dell, if I gave a shit about that old thing.
Also, for lithium ion batteries, one of the most important things you can do to prolong battery life is keep them in temperature stable conditions. The whole "let it die before you charge it" was for NiCad batteries, Li ion should be charged daily, and kept in normal, stable temps to keep them good the longest. (don't leave them in your hot car!)
3
u/captain150 May 21 '12
A lot of people don't understand that deep discharge/charge cycles on lithium ion batteries will kill them quickly. The batteries are usually good for a few hundred full cycles. If you're doing a full cycle every day, that adds up to a little more than a year. Then you have people saying "wtf, HP/Dell/Lenovo/Toshiba/Apple makes shitty batteries...fucking thing barely lasted a year".
→ More replies (18)2
u/cryo May 21 '12
There are no deep discharge cycles. The battery controller takes care of all that, and will never let Li Ion discharge completely.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
May 21 '12
would this be something that could run on a laptop? If so, can you hook a guy up with a link to where?
23
u/JohnQDaviesEsquire May 21 '12
The wonderful thing about doing PR and Advertising, is that a premium product gets its reputation from its price, not its quality.
→ More replies (5)1
May 21 '12
Clothes are the prime example of this. Clothes are made in the same sweatshops at the discount price place as they are in the "brand name" shop.
-4
u/nonhiphipster May 21 '12
Most apple customers are paying the premium price to have a battery charger with a little apple logo on it, in its glistening white color.
In other words, to be a part of the elite club.
9
May 21 '12
I love how Apple critics are all sociologists, psychologists, and mind readers.
2
u/snapcase May 21 '12
This tends to be true for people on both sides of the argument.
→ More replies (1)3
u/thiskillstheredditor May 21 '12
I don't think people are trying to make a statement with their charger. They're buying the OEM replacement charger for their cell phone.
5
u/GAndroid May 21 '12
The Asus eee-pad charger looks exactly the same, without the apple logo.
→ More replies (1)5
5
May 21 '12
It's also physically smaller (easier to carry with you) and looks nicer than a lot of the alternatives, something people sometimes like to pay a little extra for.
→ More replies (9)2
u/rkwhitney May 21 '12
I'm not sure if you mean charger, phone, or laptop. The charger size is nearly identical, iPhones are actually bigger, and bulkier, then my Motorola Defy, which is superior build quality (waterproof, scratch resistant), and my HP laptop is maybe 10-15% larger then a MacBook, but since I carry it in a neoprene case, you're not really losing any "carrying size" at all.
→ More replies (1)1
May 21 '12
Someone needs to do a study on reverse apple fanboys. There's a ton of people so passionate about the consumption behavaiours of other people.
→ More replies (2)
117
u/michaelscerealshop May 21 '12
148
u/superninjaa May 21 '12
What is this? An image for ants!?
→ More replies (1)52
u/motdidr May 21 '12
I can't decide which pixel to look at.
48
u/R7-D1 May 21 '12
If I had a dollar for every pixel in this image. I'd have one nickel.
21
4
26
u/alach11 May 21 '12
What has /r/technology come to that this is 2nd most upvoted comment?
→ More replies (1)4
u/BetaFoxtrot May 21 '12
Seriously, articles like these should be the norm for /r/technology. Not everything should be appealing to the lowest common denominator...
→ More replies (1)3
18
3
u/gordo65 May 21 '12
I don't understand why apple included a mustard seed and a grain of rice in their charger.
8
u/JeremyB4 May 21 '12
When I see schematics like these, it makes me respect the shit out of electrical engineers.
39
u/shaosam May 21 '12
Electrical engineer here. The circuit in that schematic would constitute a sophomore level lab experiment at best.
10
u/JeremyB4 May 21 '12
Really? I'm a ME so anything beyond a wheatstone bridge/simple op amp is like hieroglyphics to me.
→ More replies (3)7
May 21 '12
Where can I learn this without going to school? I must learn how to read all the charts!!!
4
u/VoidByte May 21 '12
Sparkfun has a bunch of tutorials on the basics. Most of it is geared towards building stuff with an Arduino which seems to be the recommended path to go for tinkers.
disclaimer: not a electrical engineer.
→ More replies (8)3
u/GAndroid May 21 '12
Horowitz and Hill: The Art of Electronics, Lab Manual and the book. (2nd Ed)
→ More replies (2)7
u/SenatorPenguin May 21 '12
EE here. A sophomore would have found a way to light that circuit, and the paper schematic on fire without constant supervision. And when it didn't work, the TA would have to troubleshoot it for them.
→ More replies (1)11
u/FRUITKOMMANDO May 21 '12
Im a chemical engineer and forget that, electricity works by magic plain and simple
7
u/geft May 21 '12
I'm a third year EEE and I don't think I've handled transfomers or FETs in lab experiments before.
→ More replies (1)1
May 21 '12
EE here. I suspect the writer is at that level. Strange wording choices and also mentions several time about how that transformer is converting DC. :/
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
10
u/VEC7OR May 21 '12
Another EE here - and this is exactly what is going on in the article - ooooh, look at these quality components and shit, also look at these safety ensuring thingies. Oh come on, its a normal design, nothing to rave about. Oh and that article about apple revolutionizing switchmode supplies - aw, give me a break, it was Linear, Unitrode and whatnot.
11
u/Nicend May 21 '12
It reminds me of the arguments I've heard where people talk about how much better Apple is at Screens because of how good the iPad's screen is, despite the fact that the screen is manufactured and designed by Samsung.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)2
5
u/dagbrown May 21 '12
The last part of the diagram I understood was the bit with the four diodes. I could tell what that did. After that I turned into a dog.
2
u/Deep-Thought May 21 '12
what is the thing on the top right corner of the first page? is it two inductors close together in order to induce a current T1+ and T1-?
4
u/kenshirriff May 21 '12
That's the flyback transformer TR1. The pulsed DC goes into the primary winding (switched on and off by transistor Q2 which grounds the winding through R14/R3), and the output (T1+/T1-) comes out the secondary winding. The auxiliary winding at the bottom of the transformer symbol powers the IC. Flyback transformers work a bit backwards from normal transformers. When power flows into the transformer, no power flows out (because diode D18 blocks it) and a magnetic field builds up in the transformer. When the power is switched off by the transistor, then the magnetic field collapses causing power to flow out of the transformer.
2
u/ARHANGEL123 May 21 '12
As a third year with the digital electronics concentration this power supply is definitely something I can build from schematics but not design just yet. I wish I could, but my uni has this class scheduled for the senior year...
3
u/iamveryharsh May 21 '12
Agree, I didn't see that shit until my senior year. Most of my first two years was studying math and physics, and all the EE I was introduced to was basically Electromagnetics, Signals, and Intro/Analog Circuits, and some logic design. Everything was studied at an extremely theoretical level involving more math than lab work. This carried out well into my third year as well when I first started taking lab classes.
→ More replies (4)5
u/kenshirriff May 21 '12
I'll walk you through the schematic. It's a mixture of straightforward circuits and almost-incomprehensible circuits. Starting at the plug, the diode bridge and filter is a basic circuit. The circuitry around the L6565 won't make sense unless you look at the datasheet. The Q1/C3/C13 clamp circuit is extremely obscure unless you take a look at the patent. The secondary output diode and filter is straightforward. The secondary feedback circuits are common if you've studied switchmode power supplies. (Except for the Q3/Q4 latch, which still doesn't quite make sense to me.) The resistors attached to the USB D+/D- lines are an Apple proprietary way of indicating the type of charger. (To those who find the circuit obvious, I honestly would like a good explanation of the clamp and latch circuits.)
1
u/iCEEMAN May 21 '12
well thats just a switch mode transformer, thy are not that complex.
1
u/gemini86 May 21 '12
The transformer is only one part of that circuit. The entire circuit is a flyback converter.
1
u/Ziczak May 21 '12
Well yes, transformers are common, primary, secondary windings and such but the ancillary components smooth out and protect.
2
u/smacksaw May 21 '12
I have a question for any redditors who are more knowledgeable about electronics than I:
The USB output also has specific resistances connected to the data pins to indicate to the iPhone how much current the charger can supply, through a proprietary Apple protocol.[10] An iPhone displays the message "Charging is not supported with this accessory" if the charger has the wrong resistances here.
I was wondering if it was current or resistances...I have an XM Skydock for my car that often gives me that error. But the car is a Dodge, so it's a complete POS and we've had problems with other things acting wonky from the power port, so I was suspicious that the real problem that gives the error was a lack of juice.
Perhaps it's not.
Anyone have any ideas? My theory now is that the XM Skydock is just not made up to Apple spec and this particular one is defective, but my car is fine.
4
u/dnew May 21 '12
The funny thing is that the USB spec already has a standard way of telling connected devices how much current the charger/hub can supply. Apple just didn't want you using standard chargers.
2
May 21 '12
Your car is probably fine. Apple switched up the way the pins were aligned, something to do with firewire I think, I forget the details. My car would charge my 80gb ipod fine. That got stolen so I bought a newer ipod nano, would not charge because of the switch up. I got some kind of adapter that made it work.
1
2
u/Redbeard May 21 '12
In any case, the best iPhone charger is ... An iPad charger, which while looks the same, actually produces 10 watts of power and recharges an iPhone 4 in approximately half the time.
1
u/Stingray88 May 21 '12
1
u/Redbeard May 22 '12
Sorry wasn't aware of it, as they do look the same here in Australia.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/dmurph10 May 21 '12
Misleading title. Quote from article:
I was surprised to realize how enormous Apple's profit margins must be on these chargers. These chargers sell for about $30 (if not counterfeit), but that must be almost all profit. Samsung sells a very similar cube charger for about $6-$10, which I also disassembled (and will write up details later). The Apple charger is higher quality and I estimate has about a dollar's worth of additional components inside.[14] But it sells for $20 more.
1
3
u/ophello May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Apple makes a profit?? EVIL CORPORATION!!!! Also, just because the components inside the housing cost $5 doesn't mean anything. It costs Apple money to create the plastic housing, package and ship the thing. The cost is probably closer to $10. A 1:3 profit margin is hardly unique to Apple.
→ More replies (4)
4
May 21 '12
...so should I not be using my old Samsung charger to charge my iPhone when I'm too lazy to get the one it came with?
12
u/Walter_Bishop_PhD May 21 '12
I mix and match wall chargers all the time. Right now I'm charging my Galaxy Nexus with the wall charger and ridiculously long USB cord that came with my Kindle
15
u/ave0000 May 21 '12
I use my kindle charger for EVERYTHING.
3
u/Walter_Bishop_PhD May 21 '12
It was my introduction to the world of "small usb wall chargers" and I love that little thing
1
u/pharmacyfires May 21 '12
Probably the only thing I really like about my Kindle.
2
u/Walter_Bishop_PhD May 21 '12
What about your kindle are you not fond of? I like reading on it, and its unlimited 3G came in handy for me when I was travelling. Granted its UI leaves a lot to be desired sometimes, but otherwise I think it's a nice device
→ More replies (5)4
u/Ziczak May 21 '12
Youre absolutely fine. The newer iPads really need their 10w power chargers to charge at a reasonable time.
Remember USB is a standardized port. The point of the article was to point out the quality. There's filters and proprietary circuits not in other chargers. You run into danger buying a cheap $2 charger from who knows where, they WILL cut corners.
It's become more common to see USB power out integrated in an AC wall outlet too.
1
u/captain150 May 21 '12
No, it should be fine. One of the main reasons for moving to standard USB plugs on phones and chargers is you can mix them, and when you buy a new phone/whatever you can continue to use the old charger with other things.
1
May 21 '12
Native charger will charge faster, the samsung charger does not have the right resistors across (+) and D1 and D2 and (-) so iDevice will only draw 500 mA
0
u/ave0000 May 21 '12
The nice thing about Apple products is that they're all built to a reasonably high tolerance of external abuse. What I mean is that, both the phone AND the charger are built to be used outside of spec.
1
u/ovr_9k May 21 '12
I dropped my iphone on a carpeted floor and the screen shattered.
→ More replies (3)0
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
3
May 21 '12
Except that's not how amperage works. It's capable of outputting 1A, but if the device won't pull more than 500mA, then that's all it pulls. Having too much amperage won't fry your hardware like having too much voltage will.
2
May 21 '12
The iPhone 4S uses 1A. At least the charger that came with mine outputs 1A.
The older iPhones, however were 500mA.
4
u/x1an May 21 '12
So heres my question: Is my phone better off charging from the Apple charger? Obviously from a safety aspect its a superior product, but should I take the time and effort to only charge my phone off of the brick rather than, say, a car charger?
3
u/captain150 May 21 '12
As far as the phone is concerned, all it wants and needs is a steady source of 5v power with a minimum of interference. As long as your car charger or other chargers are legitimate products (by that I mean UL/CSA/FCC approved), then they will work fine. The phone, not the charger, is what controls the charge rate.
1
May 21 '12
The chargers amperage also has to do with it. I'd you are overclocking your phone, tethering, GPS, hdmi out, decoding 1080 video or other resource intensive activities you can get to the point where your phone is using more than the charger will supply. Used to have a Motorola rapid charger (750 mAH) and I would regularly drain the battery wilhile using navigation while streaming Pandora over Bluetooth. Switched to a 1 amp Palm and that baby charges no matter what. Phone can control intake but for the most part it can ttake more than the charger provides.
→ More replies (3)1
u/ivosaurus May 21 '12
Apple's charger might be able to charge an Apple device faster, because they can communicate eachother's operating values and work at the peak current allowed.
Others will just use the standard 1/0.5W.
8
u/Santas_Dick May 21 '12
In a world where bad taste is ubiquitous, Apple provides a well designed product which is not only intuitive in function but aesthetically efficient and pleasing. Why so much apple hate round these parts?
2
u/sirbruce May 21 '12
Actually I think the Amazon Kindle charger is more aesthetically efficient and pleasing. It's longer and wider but not as tall, and it fits more naturally between your thumb and forefinger when you plug or unplug it. The Apple one is neat because it's a "cube" but ergonomically speaking it's harder to grip. Also, the surface of the Apple charger is slick, whereas Amazon's is textured for easier gripping.
→ More replies (3)4
May 21 '12
Its all about price versus content without reference to style.
The Apple hater becomes upset with the idea that luddites will buy Apple products at a considerable premium to other similarly specced products without the knowledge that they have similar components to much cheaper products. In the mind of the Apple hater these people need to be informed that they are paying for style.
15
u/p_rex May 21 '12
It's about more than "style". A product is more than a set of specifications. Apple-haters fail to understand why a Mac with hardware specifications identical to those of a PC costing 40 percent less could still be better than the PC (for reasons of ergonomics, user-friendliness, weight, battery life, and so forth), because to these people, the only criterion of value for measuring a computer's worth is whether it will run their games adequately. They completely fail to understand the excellence of Apple products because they are unable to appreciate such products as a gestalt. To them, all the machine is is a list of specifications. This is the mentality of an engineer, and is also why engineers should be supervised by designers who can understand value beyond specifications.
3
u/twowheels May 21 '12
In software design (at places where it's actually done) we talk of functional and non functional requirements. (there are also other terms). Non functional requirements are almost always overlooked and the hardest to specify, yet give it that important "something about it" quality.
→ More replies (3)4
u/clinically_cynical May 21 '12
Bottom line is that if you have trouble working computers, apples are good because they are more user friendly. I think the people that do have more computer knowledge though have a right to expect performance fitting of the price of the product they are buying.
6
u/p_rex May 21 '12
I used to build my own gaming desktops. It just stopped being fun at some point, and turned into more of a pain in the ass. Losing interest in PC gaming didn't help either. Looking back in retrospect, switching to OS X is the best computing-related decision I ever made. What I'm driving at is that even if you know how to build, operate, and repair a PC, there are perfectly good reasons not to bother and buy a machine that's easy to live with.
→ More replies (7)6
May 21 '12
More like "Apples are [seen as] good because the entire experience of owning, operating, repairing, disposing, and replacing of the product" is more user friendly. It is not enough to create a computer - it must be marketed, trialled, priced, packaged, sold (and returnable), repairable, understandable, recyclable, hand-me-down-able, compatible with a user's behavior and home, inoffensive to the user's tastes, reliable, disposable, and given of a plausible replacement/upgrade path.
Apple has a superior answer for all of these factors, hence the big money flows to them. They're not dummy-mode machines for dummies.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)2
u/Maristic May 21 '12
The thing I find funny about the “my PC gets the job done and is cheaper” crowd is that I suspect many of them wouldn't apply the same logic to their cars (or at least the cars they wish they could have).
Somehow it's okay to want a car that is fun to drive, that's comfortable, that's well built, that's reliable, and that you're happy to spend time in — to value something more than whether it is physically capable of getting you from A to B — but not okay to apply a similar broad perspective to the computer you spend huge amounts of your time using.
(And if not cars, then perhaps food, home ownership, entertainment, etc.)
→ More replies (1)1
u/GAndroid May 21 '12
Its all about price versus content without reference to style.
Its about how much money i will have left in my wallet. (at least for me). That counts more than an iphone.
2
u/unheimlich May 21 '12
Then an iPhone is clearly the choice for you. Resale value on an iPhone is much better than any Android.
→ More replies (1)1
May 21 '12
Sometimes, it's like http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fox_and_the_Grapes. Many of the loud foxes you hear don't even know what the grapes taste like.
2
May 21 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/DanielPhermous May 21 '12
Because they like to charge more than other companies for a similar product.
Used to. Apple's competitors are finding it really hard undercutting the Airs and the iPad (assuming similar specs, of course). They even complained to Intel about the Air problem, begging for cheaper chips.
And for a hundred bucks, I assume the Apple TV is also pretty cheap (but have seen no actual data on it).
3
u/Stingray88 May 21 '12
And for a hundred bucks, I assume the Apple TV is also pretty cheap (but have seen no actual data on it).
I'll take that one... For a pure hardware/size/price comparison... the Apple TV is one of the best media boxes you can buy.
The issue is the software... In my opinion, pre-jailbreak it's a worse device than it's competitors... but after jailbreaking it's a better device than it's competitors. A lot of people really don't want to jailbreak though.
1
u/unheimlich May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
On average, Macs are priced the same as similarly specced competitors, the problem is Apple does not reduce the price of their products over their life. This results in haters creating comparison after comparison showing Macs that are priced higher than competitors with superior hardware. Of course, you never see these comparisons made with a newly released Mac.
0
3
u/ienjoyopium May 21 '12
Quality in an tiny expensive package.
Cringe
17
u/kenshirriff May 21 '12
Cringe2 since I'm the author. Thanks for pointing that out. Mental note: proofread the title next time.
4
1
u/sirbruce May 21 '12
Great work nonetheless. Could you do a teardown of Amazon's Kindle charger as a comparison?
3
u/neonshadow May 21 '12
The thing it doesn't mention is you get one of these free with every apple device that uses one, so why you would buy one is beyond me.
2
May 21 '12
I have several because I like having it available without having to move my one charger about. One in my bedroom, one in my office, and one in my laptop bag for travel. It's just a convenience.
1
May 21 '12
I thought that Y capacitors were implemented in pairs, so I'm thinking that the "large blue component" is actually a varistor.
4
u/kenshirriff May 21 '12
I thought it was a varistor too for the longest time, but if you read the writing on it (fourth picture in my article), it's clearly a Y capacitor. Usually Y capacitors connect both AC inputs to ground, so they appear in pairs. This is a slightly different application, connecting primary to secondary to drain off EMI.
1
u/wishabay May 21 '12
It might not be part of this but general circuit board question - What is the black powder that is either on a circular container with a very tough tissue covering or in a solid cylinder that if broke open is mixed in liquid?
1
1
u/zbjump May 21 '12
This was a good read, however I was irritated that they didn't show a real picture of the charger before it was disassembled. I guess they assume that everyone has seen one. Well google image search here I come.
1
u/the_good_time_mouse May 21 '12
When a switching transformer fails, it will deliver the full 120 volts of AC current to the device it's plugged into.
This can be quite spectacular, but isn't nearly as cool when it's your device.
1
u/Hurricane_Hugo May 21 '12
I have 5- 10 of these chargers around. Anyone know why they stop working after a certain amount of time.
1
u/sirbruce May 21 '12
Good work nonetheless. Could you do a teardown of Amazon's Kindle charger for comparison?
1
u/TheSkyNet May 21 '12
Removed please try and avoid editorializing the titles or they may be removed.
1
1
-2
May 21 '12
Sorry Apple but your high-quality charger does not offset your shitty, overpriced products
1
May 21 '12
And yet it's still a disappointment for only having one USB socket after all these years...
1
u/nsxla May 21 '12
On a phone, a consumer can't replace the battery, YOU BETTER PROVIDE A DECENT CHARGER.
-6
u/columbine May 21 '12
Amazing. Only the geniuses at Apple could invent such a thing. There's what, like 8 compontents all masterfully wired on a single little printed circuit board? I doubt the clowns at Microsoft could even fit 2 components on there. And they'd NEVER think of using a MOSFET, that's for sure!
5
u/ignignokt_err May 21 '12
Boy, you sure are clever! I wish I could be as smart as you! The fact of the matter is, it's a quality piece of engineering, who cares who makes it? I haven't bought a new Mac in a while because the price/performance ratio is too high for me, but that doesn't mean everyone else should stop too... That also doesn't stop me from triple booting my PC because I like OS X's user interface, but not its lack of games...
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)1
u/GAndroid May 21 '12
Dont know if this is a joke, but thats the first circuit you build in the undergrad sophomore electronics lab.
0
u/ramjetros May 21 '12
1
-1
u/initials_games May 21 '12
tl;dr You get what you pay for.
2
u/Wrenky May 21 '12
Then you didn't actually read the article.
about $30 (if not counterfeit), but that must be almost all profit. Samsung sells a very similar cube charger for about $6-$10, which I also disassembled (and will write up details later). The Apple charger is higher quality and I estimate has about a dollar's worth of additional components inside.
Its ridiculously overpriced is what the article says.
-1
u/jablome May 21 '12
Steve Jobs' policy was that he wouldn't allow the company to make a product that wouldn't generate 40% or higher profit.
2
u/DanielPhermous May 21 '12
Weird. During most of the last ten years, Apple's average margin was between twenty and thirty percent.
→ More replies (1)
594
u/Atlos May 21 '12
The title is misleading <sigh>. The article seems to agree that Apple is vastly overcharging for this charger and even shows the parts list and respective prices. It then says that the Apple charger is higher quality, but not that you get what you pay for...