r/technology • • May 20 '12

Mark Zuckerberg's Instant Message conversations around the time he started Facebook - says his behavior is unethical, but legal.

http://www.businessinsider.com/exclusive-mark-zuckerbergs-secret-ims-from-college-2012-5#before-launching-thefacebookcom-zuckerberg-had-to-decide-whether-to-work-on-it-or-a-similar-project-he-was-already-working-with-his-harvard-schoolmates-the-winklevoss-twins-this-is-the-conversation-where-he-works-out-that-hed-like-to-do-his-own-thing-1
1.3k Upvotes

722 comments sorted by

215

u/Rub3X May 21 '12

I like the part where he's amazed at how people just submitted their information to Facebook.

38

u/cpplinuxdude May 21 '12

I like the bit where he calls his users "dumb fucks"

58

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I am too... every damn day.

Just want to yell "You people are idiots."

22

u/Heaney555 May 21 '12

I don't really give a fuck if a database knows I like pizza so puts a pizza ad on the right of the newsfeed in facebook...

→ More replies (2)

4

u/okkookko May 21 '12

He honestly put it best with "dumb fucks"

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Its a name and email... not really idiotic behavior but if you wanna feel super smart and intelligent than go right ahead.

→ More replies (6)

-1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Having a facebook account has not had one single ill effect on my life, not one. People keep going on about the data being sold to advertisers and how awful that is.

So fucking what

Just because adverts are going to get more relevant to my interests doesn't mean that I'm going to rush out and blow all my money on shit I don't need.

Whenever I go to make any purchase I research what I want to do with it to see if it is the right "tool for the job". I make an informed decision and spend my money on something that is going to either enhance my life in some way or make it more enjoyable in some way.

If you are dumb enough to just run out and blow all your money on something that you (1) do not need (2) only want because it is the latest version even though the one you have is basically the exact same as the newer one, then it is YOUR fault for falling prey to someones trick.

I also hate to burst the moral bubble but we NEED people consumers like this to keep things like the economy going. We need people constantly spending money to keep other people in business

who keep other people in business

who keep other people in business

who keep other people in business

who keep other people in business

If we just waved a magic wand and got rid of advertising's evil practices, people would stop spending as much money very fucking quickly, which is probably a good thing right?....WRONG! we would be fucked because if people keep hoarding their money, every single business would feel the pinch. People would be losing their jobs left right and center because there companies are not getting any money in the door because no one is spending any money.

Now, that said, I'm not trying to say that the system we use is perfect, hell, I'm not even saying it's morally right! But it is the system that we're using, and that's how it works.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (133)
→ More replies (4)

570

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Zuckerberg is an asshole, no surprise there.

327

u/idkwat May 21 '12

Zuckerberg is proof that you can be one of the richest men in the world and still regarded as a dorky loser by society.

8

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Didn't Bill Gates prove that decades ago?

25

u/idkwat May 21 '12

I wouldn't call Gates a loser, he's a huge philanthropist that has donated a fuck ton of money to charity. His charity work makes him a cool guy in my book.

25

u/shiftybr May 21 '12

Not only charity, but he donated billions of dollars for scientific research as well.

26

u/nikomo May 21 '12

All I wanted him to donate was some code, but no...

18

u/KRSFINAL May 21 '12

A company does not make the Fortune 500 list by giving away their intellectual property.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/TalkingBackAgain May 21 '12

There is this common theme among the very richest that they are all ruthless bastards on the way to the ultra big money. When they finally get there, they understand that there's not an earthly purpose for having that much money so they start doing philantropy. It makes them look like awesome people and history tends to forget who they all shoved under the bus to get to where they were.

7

u/papajohn56 May 21 '12

Andrew Carnegie was a master at this.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Yep, and its not like they are going to feel the economic loss from donating to charity.. They will receive huge tax breaks and fool people into thinking that they are so generous.

I respect someone more who gives everything they have when they have so little, than someone who gives away a lot and still has a lot even after.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

That's not really true. What happens is that they realize that they will be remembered as psychopathic shitheads so they channel some of their wealth into charitable trusts that are really just wealth preservation vehicles with tax advantages which also serve to retool their image as a humanitarian. The robber barons all did this and it has always worked.

3

u/xampl9 May 21 '12

He wasn't always that way. Look up how he & Balmer conspired to get Paul Allen's shares back in the eventuality that Allen didn't survive his illness.

→ More replies (24)

1

u/bouchard May 21 '12

You obviously haven't seen Bill's pinup photos.

1

u/Nakken May 21 '12

Since when has a winning personality and money had anything to do with eachother?

1

u/snotrokit May 21 '12

I guess money can't buy you cool either.

1

u/jsullivan1331 May 21 '12

There's still hope for redditors, then!

1

u/res0nat0r May 22 '12

Zuckerberg can buy new friends and still not a single fuck what you or society think. +5 to dodge for him.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

276

u/yeaup May 21 '12

Well Bill Gates is the lovable dork. He's the kid in the movies you stand up for. Zuckerberg is the angry nerdy kid that is an asshole to everyone who tries to friend him.

248

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Bill Gates' behavior was a lot less loveable when he was in charge of Microsoft.

134

u/horse-pheathers May 21 '12

Very much this; in the nineties, he was closer to the stereotypical James Bond supervillain - you almost expected him to have a volcano lair outside of Seattle and to be accompanied on all his public appearances by a snow-white cat in his lap....

72

u/aspartame_junky May 21 '12

then he got laid, and it was all good.

Melinda, the world owes you big-time.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/wumumo May 21 '12

Not a fan of Microsoft, but what was wrong with them in the nineties? I think it's a common misconception that people think Gates and Microsoft are the bad and Jobs and Apple are the good ones.

37

u/planetmatt May 21 '12

Gates was just as ruthless as Jobs in the 90s. Hell bent on buying or destroying any competition to Windows or Office.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (22)

5

u/redditacct May 21 '12

They also schemed to cheat a guy with cancer out of money in the early MS/DOS days.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/ThomasTurbate May 21 '12

Do you think ethical and lovable behaviours will get your company money?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

30

u/mrgraham May 21 '12

tries to friend him

I was about to make a joke about this, but upon doing some research, I've found that this usage very much predates social networks. In fact, "unfriend" does too:

1659 FULLER App. Inj. Innoc. III. xxxjb, I hope, Sir, that we are not mutually Unfriended by this Difference which hath happened betwixt us. (from the OED)

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

You slept through the 90s, right?

13

u/StuartGibson May 21 '12

There are people entering the workforce who were only born in the mid-90s. People who were maybe 13 or 14 when Gates had his last day at Microsoft.

7

u/yeaup May 21 '12

Born in 92. I was watching Hey Arnold! and Angry Beavers when all that was going down.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MelsEpicWheelTime May 21 '12 edited Feb 18 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

wine pet late melodic sand price sugar unwritten rock squeeze

2

u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 21 '12

i loved how at the beginning of the social network the erica albright character basically called out all nerdy guys that yell about being 'friend zoned' when she's like "you're going to go through life thinking girls don't like you because you're a nerd (*can't remember actual word she used), but i want to tell you that that won't be true. they won't like you because you're an ASSHOLE"

5

u/taw May 21 '12

He only became "lovable" after he stopped being in charge of Microsoft and went for fighting malaria with money he made out of illegal monopoly.

2

u/ninety6days May 21 '12

friend him

You understand he's the reason you used "friend" as a verb, right?

2

u/yeaup May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

ಠ_ಠ

that wasn't an accident.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (10)

44

u/theshamespearofhurt May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

Dickish and highly unethical yes, but the winklevoss twins should have made him sign an NDA and a non compete before discussing it with him. It's just common sense especially when dealing with software. We always make our engineers sign them.

84

u/peteyboy100 May 21 '12

Good point... I'm sure most twenty year old college students think to make their friends sign NDAs while talking about making projects together.

65

u/theshamespearofhurt May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

The Winklevosses were A. Students at Harvard. B. Came from a wealthy family. C. Barely knew Zuckerberg. The legal stuff should have been a no-brainier for them. If they overlooked that then what else would they have overlooked after the website was started? They certainly wouldn't have built a 100 billion dollar company with rookie mistakes like that. Zuckerberg may be a sociopathic asshole but at least he has common sense.

12

u/a_can_of_solo May 21 '12

they were stupid old wasps.

2

u/TrebeksUpperLIp May 21 '12

Really creepy looking ones at that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Yes, Harvard students who want to start a successful website should overlook a crucial part of starting a website. Want to be a badass innovator? Close legal loopholes that let people do things you don't want them to do.

2

u/FataOne May 21 '12

Most college students aren't going to Harvard and thinking about starting up a website/company that could turn out to be wildly successful. You would think they would have been smart enough to research any legal precautions they should take.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

No but their acquaintances in the law field could have told them.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/TalkingBackAgain May 21 '12

I'm not saying you're not right, it's just that these guys are all in college. Then you get this idea and all of a sudden you have to go all contracty on the guy you're chewing through lunch with.

You're in Harvard, you're working hard to do all the things the students there are supposed to do and, oh yeah, I've got this great idea for a website. Interested?

In an established business you're certainly right. As a young student at Harvard [or any other school of advanced learning]? They were thinking about the web site, they didn't think some guy was going to screw them over.

6

u/[deleted] May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

Ugh, if your engineers could execute better on the same code than your company, you have more serious problems than NDAs.

1

u/Solomaxwell6 May 21 '12

Nah. The Winklevoss twins didn't even have working code. When he was hired, he was the sole engineer. He took the idea and spun it off into facebook, while constantly stalling for more time. Suddenly, facebook came out, and the Winklevosses were still left with an incomplete prototype. They did end up finishing up and launching it, but by that point facebook had already started expansion.

2

u/bangupjobasusual May 21 '12

True on that nda. I think these im threads only illustrate a totally normal early 20s very savvy geek. I don't think what he did was out-of-the-ordinary dickish at all.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Aren't non-compete contracts completely unenforceable?

2

u/cabotmoose May 21 '12

Only in CA, but generally companies voluntarily don't enforce them due to the financial liabilities associated with enforcing the contract.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Bad ones? No.
Good ones? Maybe

Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer.
Part of the issue is that all non-competes must have a geographical limitation. For a CEO of a massive company like Steve Jobs, the geographic restriction might be "the entire world". However, for a low-level engineer working for a big company a geographic restriction of "the entire world" would get thrown straight out of court; anything over 50 miles is not likely enforceable.

There are other restrictions of course, but the geographic limitation is very commonly used to get the agreements nullified.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/papajohn56 May 21 '12

Err, no. It depends on the NCA terms, timeframe, etc etc.

1

u/eat-your-corn-syrup May 21 '12

in some states, enforceable. unethical, but legal.

1

u/bangupjobasusual May 21 '12

In this case it would have been very enforceable. Heres the thing, let's say you work as a civil engineer in the solar industry for 10 years before you get laid off, but you signed a non compete that said you would leave the industry for two years after leaving the company. That non compete would never hold water, the agreement is preventing you from using your only real expertise, it wouldn't hold up in court at all. But if you hire me to make a website for you, I sign a non compete, then make a website that directly competes with yours and sabotage your project? Well, I have some real liability there.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

6

u/Tunafishsam May 21 '12

ding ding we have a winner. Generally speaking though, non-competes are only enforceable if they are reasonable in scope and time. Meaning they only restrict a party in the same area that the other party actually operates in (or have concrete plans to expand into). Reasonable in time means a few years generally. Exact interpretations will vary by jurisdiction.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

On the otherhand, no engineer would ever sign an NDA if they don't have to. Facebook wasn't an original idea as it was written down on paper for a job description, in the same way the mouse wasn't an original idea when Apple rolled them out. It's all about implementation. That distinguishes innovation from invention. Oh & fuck Zuckerberg.

3

u/jmdugan May 21 '12

Actually, lots of people are assholes. There's much more to this.

Zuckerberg's now one of the richest people in the world. He's more than just your run-of-the mill asshole, he's decidedly incompetent at understanding or caring about the feelings of others. Coupled with his wealth and his controlling interest (56%) in the one company with more data about people than any other - he's dangerous.

And that company now has access to the public markets.

This story is not done, and I don't see it ending well for society with this man controlling as much of it as he does.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I agree, MZ is an asshole.

→ More replies (29)

80

u/Chirp08 May 21 '12

The movie makes him look like a great friend in comparison to this.

40

u/RandomMandarin May 21 '12

The movie was a lot like some low-calorie Gatorade I bought. It goes down pretty good, then after a couple of minutes your stomach doesn't feel right.

Fincher did a fine job of directing and making it not-boring... but the more we learn about the real Zuckerberg, the more The Social Network feels like a whitewash.

28

u/colej_uk May 21 '12

I really loved it. The Social Network was a dramatization, not a documentary.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I agree. It was good, believable drama. I fully understand that it wasn't all true.

5

u/sneezen May 21 '12

in the movie he seemed very arrogant and egoistic in my opinion.

5

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

disguised puff piece

4

u/Rad_Spencer May 21 '12

My gripe was the fact that in the movie they make Marks weakness being that he can't get this girl he likes and is driven to get revenge on her. Using the tired "computer geeks can't get laid" clique. When in reality he's had the same steady girlfriend since the start of facebook.

Basically the movie ignores Mark's real character flaws and instead make one up.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Meh. Throw a different business name and change all the characters names and it's still a fantastic movie regardless.

After reading this I just feel even worse for Eduardo.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

The film wasn't meant to 100% accurately represent Zuckerberg, nor accurately depict the founding of Facebook.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Was a good story and that's all I really planned on taking from it.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

No, man. G2 is the shit.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

6

u/hatestosmell May 21 '12

I think that's where the movie might have been inaccurate. The film said they were best friends; these make it seem like he was an a friend with financial connections.

26

u/PandamoniumSC May 21 '12

How can one tell whether or not they're fake?

18

u/[deleted] May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

They were used in the lawsuits against him and iirc were confirmed by him. These are by no means "exclusive" as business insider would have you believe. They've been around for years. I remember watching the Social Network and doing research to see how much of it was biased, stumbled across most of these. The only ones i hadn't seen were number 12 and 13.

1

u/djdementia May 21 '12

The text of the conversations is real and was released as part of a lawsuit. The images are faked (and mentioned at the beginning of the article) and meant to provide a better illustration than just copy/paste text.

9

u/JustHere4TheDownVote May 21 '12

Apparently I'm the only one who is more surprised at the fact insider trading is legal in Brazil.

4

u/ristretto May 21 '12

Is it really legal? Or just saying that it's easily "overlooked"?

43

u/rosjone May 21 '12

Why do I have a Facebook, again?

54

u/yur_mom May 21 '12

because everyone else you know does...and repeat.

4

u/rosjone May 21 '12

Actually, not everyone I know has an account. Surprisingly.

11

u/Leaningthemoon May 21 '12

Most people I know don't have one.

23

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

that's just because you're on the moon

18

u/Leaningthemoon May 21 '12

Did you see what I did today?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/cakedicks May 21 '12

Because it's easier than actually asking girls to show you pictures of themselves in bikinis.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/JustHere4TheDownVote May 21 '12

I only started using it since people stopped using AIM. Plus it's way easier to find people, rather than ask for their AIM s/n. I didn't have Facebook until around 2009 or probably much later.

I'm sure more people know how it really started to take off, but I'm sure Facebook just got lucky like most websites. I don't really recall many websites being TRULY originally and the first of it's kind. Zuckerberg just had connections and funding. But this is true for non virtual businesses too. The only difference is it's a lot easier to make a website than open a business.

Also, lol. Zuckerberg spell checks into Rubbernecker on Firefox. My first spelling was Zuckerburg, which spell checked into Cheeseburger.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

EVERYONE I knew used to have a MSN messenger account so you could talk to them. Now most people have abandoned them because they use Facebook.

I only have a Facebook account now for chat and with that I use Pidgin as a chat client.

I have noticed that actual use of Facebook has dropped, people are getting bored of it now. I think Facebook will do a Myspace within 5 years.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

You can tell this as someone who never goes on it? How?

→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

2

u/hatestosmell May 21 '12

You mean brilliant and world-changing? I agree wholeheartedly

→ More replies (3)

2

u/__circle May 21 '12

I have one so I can easily contact friends, even ones I haven't had contact with in years.

2

u/akpak May 21 '12

No goddamn reason at all. You can get rid of it. The people who you actually are friends with will contact you in other ways.

1

u/rosjone May 21 '12

Very true. Time to delete!

1

u/akpak May 21 '12

I feel like I've done my good deed for today.

1

u/EmperorSofa May 21 '12

I have a fake one that I log onto when I need to get information on people.

Protip: The first place private investigators and police/government folks will do is go to facebook. Why would they go through the trouble of finding out all your personal info and escapades if you already consolidate it all in one place.

It wouldn't be so bad if they got a warrant. Facebook generally just lets them have the info.

1

u/rosjone May 21 '12

Does setting it to Friend's Only help at all? In the case of the police going to accounts. I'm sure FB would hand over my info, but I don't have a lot of personal info on there anyway.

1

u/EmperorSofa May 21 '12

It would hinder a private investigator unless you are in the habit of accepting random friend requests.

→ More replies (3)

105

u/AaFen May 21 '12

Meh. So he's a dick. He gave the world a product that it clearly wants. His personal attitude in uni makes no difference.

45

u/TheNoDice May 21 '12

Don't really understand why you're getting downvoted for calling it how it is. Steve Jobs was a dick too, but apple is doing pretty well for itself.

36

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Jobs was more of a dick, Zuckerberg is more of a douche. Jobs had some style and came out with some great ideas, but mainly treated employees really harshly. Zuckerberg is just a douche and made a social network that was good when MySpace was a steaming pile of shit. Now Facebook is just a smouldering pile of shit.

10

u/AaFen May 21 '12

The world of business is full of dicks, mostly because dicks finish first. It's in their nature. Personally, finishing first doesn't matter that much to me, so I won't be a dick. That doesn't mean I dislike their products. If Hitler himself offered me a great deal on some Austrian alpine property, I'd probably take him up on it.

EDIT: in b4 Godwin callout

3

u/Epistaxis May 21 '12

Now Facebook is just a smouldering pile of shit.

Maybe your Facebook friends are a smoldering pile of shit, but Facebook is a website that millions of people find useful and fun, and it makes a shit-ton of money.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/gt36 May 21 '12

Maybe what it wants, but in many ways probably not what it needs. Just because a product sells doesn't mean it's a good thing. And you should be more concerned that he's a dick and seeing as Facebook is as big as it is, his personal attitude makes a lot of difference. If people like you didn't brush it off like it's what's supposed to happen/expected, there might actually be less dickish things (and people) around.

1

u/chefanubis May 21 '12

Don't hate the player, hate the game.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Wasn't he like 18 when these were written? People really change a ton between 18 and late 20s.

2

u/turdoftomorrow May 21 '12

My thoughts, exactly. He was a baby. And who knows how much of this stuff was tongue-in-cheek vs. how much of it was how he actually thought / spoke? At least 80% of my thoughts between the ages of 18 and 21 could be considered "inappropriate" by someone else's standards...fortunately I wasn't a computer genius on the cusp of starting one of the biggest companies in the history of the world...uh, I guess.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/flippzz May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

The "friend" he's talking to is Adam D'Angelo.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

3

u/morph89 May 21 '12

flippzz referred to who Zuckerberg was talking to, not about.

33

u/ran4rock May 21 '12

I'm I the only one that thinks this isn't a big deal. Its a fucking college guy talking about saving people's data and calling people "dumb fucks". If I went into my one of my universities frats and took one of their cell phones I bet I could find shit just like this. "Yo bro Just broke the law, no one will catch me....dumb fucks". Just a cocky college kid, nothing else. Besides if your so scared that he is doing stuff with your information STOP USING FACEBOOK.

10

u/fuzzy335 May 21 '12

While I agree with you about how most of what he is saying shouldn't be a judge of character... like calling people "dumb fucks", But the way he just doesn't give a fuck that he's fucking everyone over around him is something that is horrible...

From DAY 1 of his company, he fucked other people over by not only reworking an idea he was given, but also sabotaged their business too...He then proceeded to fuck over his original startup partner.

Sure, in the end everyone won, but that doesn't justify ANYTHING. There's a big difference between being an aggressive businessman and a lying, conniving, thief...

To me this shit is exactly like Chris Brown... "It's okay because he can sing and dance." "It's okay cuz he made people billions"

And to those that say "stop using Facebook"... For the most part you're being unrealistic.. It's become an integral part in society as well as business... Would I support an alternative and ditch Facebook when that alternative picked up? Yes I supported google+ and still do, but it's just not happening.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

You've got the right idea, but Google is every bit as bad as Facebook when it comes to selling your personal information.

1

u/fuzzy335 Jun 11 '12

My concern isn't so much about data privacy. It's our choice to provide such detailed information to Facebook, Google or anybody else.

My reason is more because of what Mark Zuckerberg did to get to where he is... Most if not all companies screw or take advantage of others in order to get to the top, but someone willing to screw over people who are close to him doesn't say much about him... Who knows what he'd do to the rest of us who aren't even close to him...

Google may do many wrongs, but they were established on much better terms. Also, they've been pretty solid in being a trustworthy company for over a decade..

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

1

u/fuzzy335 May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

I run a Brand Development / Marketing Company.. We do brand development for medium to large businesses which includes Design, Development & Marketing services... A growing service that we offer is Social Media marketing.

So, it's a direct part of my professional life. We get paid to design, manage, and promote businesses on Social Media platforms.

It's also one the primary methods of communication between me and the people in my circle.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I use Facebook as a tool for group chats and meetings. Businesses also have pages you can like, which gather advertising and population data, no?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

1

u/fuzzy335 May 21 '12

It's a major part of my professional life (Branding company that does Social Media management)

It's also a primary method of communication between me and the people around me.. Including Friends, Co-Workers, new potential clients, etc...

It's not that I can't quit, but i'd be shooting myself in the foot... I barely use facebook in a personal manner.

2

u/spinlock May 21 '12

I'm pretty sure the first email I got in college (didn't have email until then) reference surfing the web looking for Star Treck conventions and kiddy porn. Might not look great if it came up now.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

My so scared what?

1

u/Edg-R May 21 '12

I feel the same way. He was 19. I've said worse shit than this in casual conversation.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

He admits to breaking into a computer system using email addresses and passwords of some of his users. Forget unethical- that is criminal.

0

u/ryashpool May 21 '12

No your not the only one. If I gauged people on their online comments from their time at college, well then, errrp well you get the point.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I agree with the point where you said if you don't want your information compromised stop using Facebook.

I think for a lot of people this is the first time learning about the nature of Zuckerberg and his disregard of privacy. Many people are appalled that they even shared so much information in the first place.

3

u/projectedhate May 21 '12

I am. Also, my girlfriend dragged me to the social network. It just made me sick to watch it. However, it seems all people that attain status are corrupted at some point. I mean, just going to harvard alone is going to be good for you in life. So he's already a douche anyway. In the film the character pretty much has no arc. He learns nothing. Looking at Zuckerberg, he's learned nothing either. Just how to lie better.

2

u/BlenderGuru May 21 '12

Looking at Zuckerberg, he's learned nothing either.

I'm curious how well you know him since you're judging his character?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I saw the movie a while back and have just read the messages in OP's post. I think the messages are much worse than how he is conveyed in the movie. In the movie it implies he cares about Eduardo for an extent. In those messages he literally says Fuck him.

I mean yeah it's no big surprise rich people are assholes, they had to knock a few people down to obtain their status but come on. Some of Zuckerberg's messages are lines verbatim from Anakin in Revenge of the Sith.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/TankMan3217 May 21 '12

I have my doubts that this is true, but the real story here is that some people in this thread still think Zuckerberg etc., at some point, gave a rat's ass about privacy.

Facebook users were never the customers. Customers would be the ones spending money on a product. Advertisers and marketing departments are giving them money for your information, therefore they are the customers, and your information is the product. Facebook worries about your privacy inasmuch as a farmer worries that his pigs might get eaten. None of this should surprise anyone.

7

u/__circle May 21 '12

Zuckerberg doesn't deny it's true. Why do you have your doubts?

1

u/TankMan3217 May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

This is an illustration of a supposed conversation, with no references whatsoever. That certainly merits some skepticism.

If he's admitted it, that's one thing. If he only "hasn't denied it" that's meaningless. Maybe he just doesn't talk about it. Glenn Beck hasn't denied that he raped and murdered a little girl in 1990. At face value, the article is just some words on the internet (edit) *that may or may not be true.

6

u/paper_hat May 21 '12

Funny how he gets a ton of greif for privacy issues with facebook but no one seems to care when it comes to reading his private and stolen messages.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

that is pretty funny

5

u/craeyon May 21 '12

Using Facebook makes me feel like I have blood on my hands.

1

u/yourafagyourafag May 21 '12

Yeah, all those poor african kids that died making the facebook... just sad, bro.

1

u/roboduck May 21 '12

As I fill up my SUV with oil imported from Iraq, I give a smile to my lovely fiance sitting in the passenger seat wearing that conflict diamond engagement ring I got her, when my iPhone, assembled by crippled underage Chinese kids, vibrates in my pocket. I turn it on and see that it's a new facebook notification. Oh, god, facebook? I FEEL SO UNCLEAN.

3

u/Mi5anthr0pe May 21 '12

An overtly treacherous Jew? YOU DON'T SAY.

3

u/hrdxxcorey May 21 '12

this is eye-opening

3

u/JoseJimeniz May 21 '12

Should be mentioned that his unethical, yet legal, behavior is saving images from his browser (without permission) and using them to seed facesmash.

5

u/Stopher May 21 '12

I would think his breaking into and messing around with the connect u accounts was probably illegal as well.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I think the implied legal but unethical behavior is him telling the Winklevoss twins that he was helping them with their project and doing everything to help up until the last day and then just saying:

"Hey look, I'm working on something similar, go screw yourself."

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

What obligation did he have to divulge his other project that was different? They weren't friends, they hired him to build a crappy website.

1

u/JoseJimeniz May 21 '12

The context was, "But what are the grounds for kicking you out of school?" Zuckerburg noted, "Unethcical behaviour" - "unethical and still be legal."

Those who could kick him out of school, the Administrative Board, were dealing with Mark's use of pictures from intranet web-sites without permission. They were not used for ConnectU, or Facebook, but Facemash.

3

u/King_Of_Pants May 21 '12

any proof that this is real?

2

u/whitesocks May 21 '12

I verify it.

2

u/jpeters1221 May 21 '12

This news is years old. It's just BI bringing them back up so they can get his.

In his defense. He was a kid in high school who had no idea what he was doing. And at the time, he probably didn't have an idea or actual vision of what FB could be.

Against him...they're ridiculous statement, and kind of ring true to a lot fo the privacy issues that have plagued FB. It does show a specific history of how he works, how he thinks, and how he acts. The issue here isn't that FB or Google or someone else has data on you, but how the people in charge intend to use it and how they perceive the data.

Now, I'm sure he most likely doesn't feel the same way today, and he's smart enough no to realized not to say things that like.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

They "trust" me. Dumb fucks.

And people still use facebook after reading that? You are giving away all your info and more than you even know to a guy who thinks you are dumb fucks for doing it and has no consideration for ethics and probably even breaks the law if he can get away with it.

2

u/Rivwork May 21 '12

To be fair, this was said when he was in college. His attitude could have (and probably has) changed since going from a no-name, broke college student to a multi-billionaire CEO of the biggest website in the world.

I'm no Facebook apologist... I really don't like it at all to be honest... but are we to hold everyone to the conversations and thoughts they had when they were 20 years old forever?

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I'm not a dumb fuck but everyone else on facebook is. I'm the exception. Fucking morons.

2

u/ironclownfish May 21 '12

I'd like some proof that this is real.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/res0nat0r May 22 '12

I like the part where these mysterious IM's just come to light as screenshots 8 years after the founding of Facebook the week of their IPO. Non-billionaires related to Facebook butthurt much?

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

How do we know this is real? Until I know that there's no point in believing it.

1

u/hambeesly May 21 '12

haha oh wow these IM's are so blatant I had to triple check I wasn't reading the Onion or similar..

-1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Today I deleted my facebook and vowed to get everyone I know to do the same.

12

u/sirbruce May 21 '12

Don't forget to lawyer up and hit the gym, too.

-2

u/reden May 21 '12

Good luck with that. Facebook's reached a point where it'd be as hard to get rid of as cellphones.

6

u/AppleDane May 21 '12

I go on quite happily without neither. Ok, not "happily", per se, as I am deaf and can't USE a phone. But I can exist without it.

1

u/kbz2007 May 21 '12

This guy is actually somewhat correct. There's a key difference, though. The real problem with facebook (if you want to use the cell phone comparison) is that it's as if there was only one cell phone company. As if every one of those critical devices in our pockets was run by Sprint or some other piece of shit company that doesn't provide good service and doesn't care about its customers.

I don't think the purpose that Facebook serves is as critical as cell phones. I don't even think that these messages above scratch the surface of how shitty facebook is. We all know that Zuckerberg is an asshole. The real issues are more about the data mining or the inability to terminate your account to name just a couple.

However, until someone creates a competing website that can serve the same purpose of facebook, we're all going to keep using it. It's become pretty central and serves a lot of key functions in my life. I've seen a few sites spring up, but they never complete. I've just never been able to wrap my mind around this. I'm not a programmer so I don't know how to do it. But, I feel like any competing website would just obliterate facebook. People simply HATE facebook, they just don't really have a means of getting off of it and staying off of it if they use it in their day to day.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/yagmot May 21 '12

WARNING: article is from Business Insider.

1

u/Foley1 May 21 '12

Anyone who has billions but doesn't give me any is a dick in my book.

1

u/bangupjobasusual May 21 '12

How is there so much outrage? What world do you people live in? I think what he did is entirely defensible. How can any of you get on a moral high horse? If you were in his position you would have done the same or the product would have failed. Did anyone see connectu? It sucked! It's true, the winklevoss twins had no vision. The had only a vague idea of what they kind of wanted, which it turns out, was a direct ripoff of Friendster btw.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/doubledeckerpancake May 21 '12

EVERY successful business man is unethical. If you think otherwise, look behind you because there is probably one back there fucking you right now.

1

u/CrabbyMonday May 21 '12

this shit as old as dinosaurs

1

u/Haroldholt May 21 '12 edited May 22 '12

I'm just amazed his IM records have lasted this long.

1

u/okron1k May 21 '12

i read it all in Jesse Eisenberg's voice.

1

u/whozurdaddy May 21 '12

99%, meet the 1%.

1

u/JuzPwn May 21 '12

Isn't that a little conflicting? It's legal but unethical? Aren't laws supposed to define what is ethical?

-2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Turns out instant messaging in 2003 looked remarkably like iPhone messaging in 2012...

16

u/Femaref May 21 '12

iPhone messages look like iChat messages, which was around in 2002 onwards. Also, the page says it's an illustration.

5

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

i stand corrected

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

So the guy who ended up creating one of the largest companies in our nation was/is a dick? The late Steve Jobs on line one.

0

u/Cruizelol May 21 '12

That's Mark Fuckerberg for you.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Really interesting stuff here.

0

u/StinkYourTrollop May 21 '12

I hate him as much as anyone else but there is nothing really bad here. Who gives a shit, anyway?

0

u/think_free May 21 '12

Makes me even more happy I refuse to support this cock bag by not having a Facebook account.

0

u/snoozieboi May 21 '12

btw, insider trade is legal in the US when you're in congress.. It's unethical, but legal too.

edit: haha (not "lol")

2

u/Mason11987 May 21 '12

I think that's actually been changed by recent legislation (shocking I know!)

1

u/snoozieboi May 21 '12

Great, since it made the incentives completely wrong.

0

u/Pemoniz May 21 '12

"I can pull a 2k in 2 minutes and 36 seconds"

Now that's hilarious!

0

u/lzcrc May 21 '12

In Russia, people were always complaining about the guy who did VK being a douchebag to "steal" Facebook concept back in 2006 but little did they know :)

0

u/thatsCaptainplanet2u May 21 '12

To me this just seems like a very convenient thing to release, I mean what is the actual point of making this public. It is a perfect conversation with an unknown person conveniently stating that the winklevoss idea was for a dating site and Facebook was 100% different and he never did any work on the Winklevoss website. I mean Someone maybe having a legal stake in facebook could have affected the floating price of the company,very suspicious;)

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

2

u/bpd115 May 21 '12

Nope. Chuck Testa. They're from iChat.

0

u/DannyInternets May 21 '12

unethical, but legal.

And that's basically how one become a successful capitalist in a nutshell.

-4

u/lamp37 May 21 '12

he's actually kind of more funny than he comes across as in interviews. In interviews and stuff he just seems to lack personality.

-1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I always think Zuckerberg has a sociopathic edge when it comes to running Facebook. He really doesn't give a shit who he fucks over as long as he attains his goals.

0

u/we_got_this May 21 '12

Life's hard up there on top.

0

u/Lolworth May 21 '12

I was up for defending him until the "dumb fucks" line, but many things still get said in Jest. Mark Z in "talks and thinks like a normal person" shocker.

0

u/arkain123 May 21 '12

Wow, someone get on the phone with Hollywood and tell them to make a movie about how much of a dick he is, the world must know!

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Mark Zuckerberg is a lot more cunning than he appears to be

0

u/mintpepper May 21 '12

Capitalism.

0

u/tea_bird May 21 '12

What I gather from this is The Zuck talks too much and his friend really doesn't know what he's talking about and replies with "haha."