r/technology • u/maxwellhill • May 20 '12
US “Six Strikes” Anti-Piracy Scheme Delayed: "After 6 warnings ISPs may take some repressive measures, including slowing down offenders’ connections and temporary disconnections."
https://torrentfreak.com/us-six-strikes-anti-piracy-scheme-delayed-120518/321
u/chonglibloodsport May 20 '12
This may curb piracy but it won't save their dead business models. Sorry, but people aren't going back to buying CDs and DVDs in mass quantities ever again.
48
u/keindeutschsprechen May 20 '12
It won't do anything.
In France we have a "3 strikes" law. Every time they catch you you get a warning, and the third time they cut your internet connection for a year.
Statistics showed a brief piracy slowdown, which then got back to a normal level. What happened is that less people use P2P (which is monitored), and more use direct download and streaming (or VPNs).
1
u/superwinner May 21 '12
the third time they cut your internet connection for a year
That would work on me, how can you say it wouldn’t do anything?
→ More replies (2)18
u/ramp_tram May 20 '12
Curb piracy? Hardly. It'll just revive a system where the 'techie friend' who owns a Seedbox charges his friends a couple of bucks to download shit for them.
7
u/danielravennest May 20 '12
If you are a Comcast customer, their business class is not much more than regular broadband, and has no bandwidth cap. So that plus VPN+seedbox gets secure downloads, and you can cover expenses by getting stuff for friends. A business customer has good reason to use encrypted data transfer, so likely they would not even ask you why you are doing it.
→ More replies (1)4
u/tetrisattack May 21 '12
FYI for any Comcast customers:
As of May 17th, Comcast is temporarily suspending their bandwith cap for residential plans. They'll probably come back with something even worse, but I'm downloading like crazy while I can:
http://customer.comcast.com/help-and-support/internet/common-questions-excessive-use
→ More replies (3)112
u/cloudx0 May 20 '12
This. I would rather just boycott the whole model all together and start putting my money into alternative forms of entertainment instead. The movies are cashflow trite, cable is 20 sports channels, 5 shopping channels, movies from 1990's that are hardly relevant, and at least 4 channels running reruns of law and order, and prime time tv is just sickening. I'm not paying an inflated amount of money to "stream" this crap for a price. I see netflix making a lot of money very quickly if this really pops off.
173
u/pigfish May 20 '12
27
May 20 '12
Exactly this! Also, go to kickstarter and help fund projects that you think will be hits.
Making movies might be a little expensive, but it doesn't cost millions if you cut out all the fluff of the MPAA. Help make it a reality from the ground up so we can really see them shivering in their boots!
→ More replies (2)5
u/Rasalom May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
What's great is that we are on the verge of awesome movies being fully funded by the fans and creators. Look at Cinemassacre.com's AVGN movie: funded almost totally by fan donations, actually made into a bigger project by fans donating hundreds of thousands of dollars.
5
May 21 '12
Whats awesome about this is we, the fans, get movies we want to see instead of the crap producers and studios think we'll pay for.
3
u/Daesleepr0 May 20 '12
These look awesome. Do you use either, can you give a quick review?
2
u/silaelin May 20 '12
I have plenty of music I've downloaded from Jamendo over the past few years. There is quite a bit of music I don't like, even within the genres I search for, but I've also found some that is just wonderful. Protip: Browse the list of top artists.
→ More replies (2)2
11
u/Neato May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12
Indeed. There's enough free music on bandcamp and Sound
houndcloud to keep me occupied forever.Edit: cloud not hound
→ More replies (2)2
6
u/Rasalom May 20 '12
They'll kill Netflix by limiting our bandwidth more and more, letting their in-house streaming services megabytes go unrecorded so you're forced to choose their programming.
→ More replies (2)5
May 20 '12
That's what really pisses me off about cable/satellite TV- I don't want to pay $30/month to watch the 10ish channels that I do. If I could pick and pay for channels a la carte, the only ones I'd want would be Comedy Central, the ESPN suite of channels, the Discovery suite of channels, and maybe a few others. That's it.
3
u/ovr_9k May 20 '12
I was thinking of a buisness model that let's you pick which channels you get that way you can have more of what you want and because you made a choice about which channels to choose advertising can be more focused. Of course if any of the major providers picked up on it I'm sure you would get less channels for more money.
2
u/gruntznclickz May 21 '12
I'm pretty sure selling channels ala carte is illegal. Yeah... I know..
→ More replies (5)3
u/wadsworthsucks May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12
no shit, my mom was paying $120 a month to watch the same episode of Mob Wives 5 night a week. I don't see the point.
edit: spelling, and for remembering a title
1
May 20 '12
I always thought that a great idea for entertainment companies to do is to allow you to choose the channels you want and pay for the x amount of channels rather than entire packages of channels that is extremely expensive and may or may not have what you need... WILL have plenty of channels that you wouldn't ever watch!
0
5
May 20 '12
I recently bought some DVDs- at Dollar Tree. Ironman 2 was marked down to $5- heaven forbid they COULD just drop prices and go for more mass sales.
1
u/ovr_9k May 20 '12
I love Big Lots in big towns/cities. They have awesome movies usually for less than $10
2
2
u/jordanlund May 20 '12
But the reason isn't what you think it is... People stopped buying DVDs because they bought everything they wanted and the new stuff coming out is more or less crap. Other than buying the one or two really outstanding movies a year that are new releases, I'm pretty happy with my DVD collection now.
2
u/ropers May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I've noticed that even though I'm not much of a pirate (and it would take a pretty brazen disregard for facts to even call my limited fair use "piracy"), I have gone from being a CD rental customer, a weekly DVD rental customer, and an at least fortnightly movie-goer to being a person who hardly consumes any MPAA movies and any RIAA music at all. It's not that I pirate instead. It's basically that the music and film industry associations of America (MAFIAA) –who've even gone so far as to describe fair use of legal, paid, licensed CD and DVD rentals as "piracy"– have pissed me off so much that I pretty much have a strong mental barrier these days to giving these feckers any money. (I still do at times, but it takes a lot of justifying.) My first thought is: Well, is there something else I'd rather be doing? And there's absolutely no scarcity of content and of alternative diversions these days. If I never bought a single MAFIAA product again, I'd still never stand a chance of running out of things to watch and listen to. The battle for customers of creative content is a battle for empathy these days. If you can't make me care, or if you can't make me like you, then I won't buy. And the MAFIAA are doing the one thing that's diametrically opposed to making people like them: They're pissing on everybody's civil rights and are pissing off everyone who has half a bit of sense in them by aggressively fighting their customer base. They may think they're still on to a winner because they've been outrageously successful in their rent-seeking endeavours in getting their paid-for politicians to criminalise their customers' hitherto legal rights. But that's only just an indication of the brokenness of the US political system rather than anything else.
On the other hand, I hear there are absolute masses of asses who watched Avengers. I cannot understand how these people can justify that to themselves. That's the scary thing: The MAFIAA have the power to keep up their protection racket and expand their rent-seeking because their claims (of being existentially threatened) are false.
11
May 20 '12
I pretty much have a strong mental barrier these days to giving these feckers any money. (I still have at times, but it takes a lot of justifying.)
.
I hear there are absolute masses of asses who watched Avengers. I cannot understand how these people can justify that to themselves.
I wanted to see the movie. What more justification do you think is necessary?
6
u/ropers May 20 '12
Evidently you wanted to see the movie more than you wanted to keep your civil rights.
→ More replies (5)5
u/Mrmojoman0 May 20 '12
"is it worth fuelling a corrupt, artist raping, consumer hating business model?"
→ More replies (1)13
2
u/ovr_9k May 20 '12
The Avengers might be the one(I generally see about 3 movies in theaters in a year) movie a year I spend money to watch.
→ More replies (2)1
u/calthepheno May 20 '12
MAFIAA
I see what you did there.jpg
2
u/ropers May 20 '12
I didn't come up with that, I –whoa– copied the idea from somewhere else on the Internet. But I think the description of the music and film industry associations of America as the MAFIAA is pretty apt and accurate (damn, now I'm reminded of those @%#! spam emails again).
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (72)1
u/silverpaw1786 May 20 '12
Not sure if this is humorous or interesting or noneoftheabove: I am a less than tech savvy pirater. I stream tv shows, because I don't own a tv nor do I want to plan my nights around watching the shows I want. If I were unable to pirate, I would not go back to purchasing DVDs or even watching live tv with limited exceptions. But I would re-enroll for Netflix. If there are others like me, the MPAA/Comcast/etc. will still make a lot of money off this.
48
u/Tyrien May 20 '12
This ignores the issue that the offending party may not even be the subscriber.
19
u/martinvii May 20 '12
Correct, but I'm sure that if this were actually the case, their argument would then turn to either, "Well, secure your network so that it only known users are allowed" or "too bad".
21
3
3
u/hackiavelli May 20 '12
It's a pretty lame excuse these days, anyway. I haven't seen a wireless router that wasn't secured by default in ages. The models some ISPs provide are going to all be secured too.
→ More replies (3)7
u/Kaose42 May 20 '12
So I should give up my right to run an open hotspot because someone might use it for piracy? The piracy justification for taking away rights is almost as odious as the child porn excuse for censorship.
2
u/hackiavelli May 21 '12
So I should give up my right to run an open hotspot because someone might use it for piracy?
You'd have to check if that's even allowed under the ToS of your ISP. Many will explicitly disallow it for residential customers.
Even if it were allowed I'm not sure you'd be protected. I'm not a lawyer but I believe common carrier protections are reserved for ISPs. As an end-user you'd be fully responsible for how your property is used.
→ More replies (7)2
8
u/martinvii May 20 '12
Also, what's gonna happen to businesses that offer free wifi. And what are they going to do about this? I can't imagine there being any good publicity if, say Starbucks for example, started blocking access to certain websites.
→ More replies (2)1
u/wild_bill70 May 21 '12
Most of the places I see offering free wifi keep the connection thottled down pretty low, for a number of reasons.
You can't do too much illicit stuff if there isn't enough bandwidth
They have a lot of customers to push it to.
They just don't want to pay for anything fast.
Provide enough service for email etc., and the customers you want, the ones that come buy your product and leave can check email or the menu. The ones you don't want, that camp out and don't buy shit will leave.
1
u/vertigo1083 May 21 '12
I'd say damn efficient, though. All I can think is:
Damn, these fuckers are really pushing, and fast. Each week it gets harder to pirate, even on a medium impact. Between shutting down/censoring sites, the relentless political bills, and the ISPs, this whole damn thing has gone from 0-war in the span of a year.
→ More replies (1)1
May 20 '12
I think that's what the six warnings are for. If somebody told me 6 times that illegal downloads were going on with my connection without my knowledge I would investigate the situation.
23
u/daveime May 20 '12
Comcast will just love that one ... yet another reason to cap your bandwidth and still charge you the same fee every month locked in for 24 months.
61
u/Hyperion1144 May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
My VPN is already up and running, I am on it right now! No noticeable slowdowns, just have to hop servers once in a while, since some of my provider's servers are down at the moment. CNET bandwidth meter pegs me from 3000-5500 kbps on weekdays, 2500-4500 kbps on weekends.
The proof that it works is that I can still make this post.
Also, use VPN watcher, to kill apps in case you loose your connection.
Learn more:
Which VPN Providers Really Take Anonymity Seriously?
What’s The Best VPN / Proxy for BitTorrent?
Learn about the different VPN protocols. Google a query that contains: 'OpenVPN PPTP L2TP'. These are the 3 major VPN protocols, or types. I went with a provider that used OpenVPN, seems to be the most secure and hardest to crack. According to my readings, PPTP is the oldest VPN protocol out there, which means the most holes in its security.
Important pro-tip: Stop using the Domain Name Servers (DNSs) provided to you by your ISP. There are free and open DNS sources out there, most noteable are the OpenDNS offerings and those from Google, change your DNS servers for both IPv4 and IPv6 queries. Your DNS servers are in your network properties. You just need to enter enter in the IPs for Google or OpenDNS servers.
After changing your DNS servers, check it here: http://www.dnsleaktest.com.
Remember to change the DNS servers for both internet connections, your ISP direct connection and your new VPN connection, just to be safe. Never "obtain DNS server automatically."
Open DNS servers for IPv4 are: 208.67.222.222 (resolver1.opendns.com) and 208.67.220.220 (resolver2.opendns.com). Here is PROOF.
For IPv6, I use Google's servers at: 2001:4860:4860::8888 and 2001:4860:4860::8844. Here is PROOF these are real.
How To Make VPNs Even More Secure. Learn about VPN monitors and alternative DNS servers here. Be aware that both VPN monitors recommended here did not work for me. Not saying they won't work for you, just saying I use VPN Watcher instead.
Once you are on your VPN, here are a few places to check the IP you show the outside world:
http://www.ipaddresslocation.org/
http://www.ip-address.org/lookup/ip-locator.php
http://www.geobytes.com/IpLocator.htm
That last one, from geobytes, is the most interesting. The others just show the registered home city for the owner of the server you are currently on. The Geobytes tool seems to get much closer to your actual geographic location, but still shows me that I am using a provider other than my actual ISP.
Use a paid VPN, free means YOU are the product being sold.
Start your move now. There is no reason to wait.
4
u/Kaose42 May 20 '12
Upvote for all the awesome information, thank you! May the Shrike never impale you on the Tree of Thorns.
2
1
1
→ More replies (3)1
59
u/squash111 May 20 '12
Doesn't this violate the FCC's net neutrality regulations?
36
May 20 '12
The FCC has net neutrality regulations? I'm pretty sure my ISP slows down my line all the time... and now we have data caps to boot.
15
May 20 '12
Net neutrality doesn't mean an ISP can't have data caps, it just means that they can't discriminate against certain types of traffic (like slowing down or blocking YouTube, or video sites in general, or torrent traffic).
And dunno about the FCC's regulation power, didn't a court say they have no authority in the matter?
2
→ More replies (3)1
May 20 '12
Yeah I didn't mean data caps had anything to do with neutrality, just like to throw that in when I'm bitching about my ISP... I don't really have a choice where I live.
And I don't believe the FCC currently has any regulations regarding neutrality which was the point of my original comment, but I could be wrong on that.
8
May 20 '12
There actually aren't any "regulations" that stop them from doing it. The FCC can tell them to stop it, but the ISP really doesn't have to.
Since 2006 the FCC has only had "ancillary authority" under Title I of the Federal Communications Act of 1934. However, after a federal appellate judge ruled against the FCC in the case FCC versus Comcast Corporation, the FCC lost its ability to regulate the industry. The court decided that the specific laws that the FCC were relying on were statements of policy and not legal mandates. This meant that the Commission did not have ancillary jurisdiction to impose network management mandates on Communications Act Title I information services such as broadband services.
→ More replies (1)10
u/QuitReadingMyName May 20 '12
What net neutrality regulations?
People actually listen to the FCC? Oh, you mean the FCC where all the Media Corporations have their ex-Executives on the FCC board?
4
May 20 '12
Exactly, this is why "net neutrality" would never work even if it were adopted - the fox is guarding the hen house.
15
May 20 '12
Somewhat relevant, I have been torrenting for years (and I mean, almost every single day by letting big torrents run in the background) and I have never once received a DMCA complaint (Verizon DSL). Am I just really lucky, or does Verizon not give a shit?
4
u/orphanitis May 20 '12
I don't torrent THAT much. But I torrent quite a bit. Since I got Time Warner in 2003 I haven't received anything. I don't know anyone who has either, even my friends on AT&T. I don't download movies though, just older music and programs/games. They probably go after new movies and music a lot more. Also, I never got any slowdown from them always my nice 1.2MB/s. So I dunno, we're probably just lucky.
1
u/ovr_9k May 20 '12
Yeah i tend to download movies that are somewhat older(lately I have been on an 80-90's kick) and British television shows that might not make it to the states. So far nothing yet
4
u/smacktaix May 20 '12
Verizon wouldn't issue the complaint, they would receive it from the copyright holder. The stuff you torrent probably simply isn't popular enough for MPAA/RIAA to command their anti-torrent people to monitor.
0
May 20 '12
[deleted]
5
May 20 '12
Where do you live? I live in DC and got an email like, a week after setting up my new internet with them saying 'hey knock it off, buddy.'
15
u/megamoze May 20 '12
Avengers - $457 million in 17 days. Studios, stop blaming piracy. If you make movies people want to see, they will pay to see them.
→ More replies (2)
13
u/s0cket May 20 '12
VPN... VPN... VPN... VPN........ seriously who's really worried about this nonsense?
9
May 20 '12
How does I VPN?
→ More replies (14)3
u/Oen386 May 20 '12
I would read this site for a list of providers. The providers should give you directions on how to use their services.
3
u/Kaose42 May 20 '12
I predict that VPN's will be the next big fight over piracy. But until then, it's the way to go.
2
u/s0cket May 20 '12
Once it becomes popular enough and well known enough it's inevitable. I can see it now H.R. 1199 Protecting Kids from VPN using Pedophiles and VPN Anti-Terrorism Initiative.
4
45
May 20 '12
Slowing down someone's connection speed is certainly more appropriate than 250k$ fines.
→ More replies (14)
8
May 20 '12
I think all this will do in the end is just force internet users to become smarter about their pirating. Better boats, longer swords, more peg legs, etc...
3
31
u/mishugashu May 20 '12
Oh, you want to slowdown and disconnect me? You lost my business. GG.
Not even sure why I live in a country that spends so much money trying to fuck with internet users when other countries are improving internet connections. I read somewhere (probably off here, I have a horrible memory), that the same cost for regular 25mbs internet ONLY here in the good ol' USA, you can get 100mbs fiberoptics internet AND television in France. We really want those damn Frenchies to be better than us? 'Cause imposing laws and putting money into choking connections instead of progressing into the future is putting us behind the curve.
It's 2012 you silly ISPs; let's move into the future.
6
u/snapcase May 20 '12
Wish I had the ability to say "Fuck you, I'll go do business with someone else" to my ISP (AT&T), but I can't because there's no other choice around here. I've called every ISP in the area and none of them will provide service here. My city used to block other cable companies from coming in town, because they offer their own municipal cable tv service, they even eventually offered cable internet, but the infrastructure they have is horribly dated and can't keep up with the load of the number of subscribers they have. So it's not an option for anyone who wants to do more than check their email. In recent years, it was made so other cable companies would be allowed to lay cable in the city limits... but none are willing to do so.
AT&T is the only phone company in the city. I even called up Verizon and asked if they could service my address, and they said "Oh no sorry AT&T covers your area". So much for deregulation creating competition. So I get to have shitty AT&T ADSL. I have a 6mb down/768kb up connection. The only way I could get any better of a connection is to upgrade to AT&T's still-shitty-but-slightly-faster U-Verse... and get one choice of router (a brand that has caused issues for me in the past too - 2wire).
So yeah, I have no choice besides horrible municipal cable with massive daily slowdowns from already slow speeds, or AT&T ADSL. That's it. And then I hear people complain about their FiOS.....
5
u/happyscrappy May 20 '12
In parts of France you can. In parts of the US you can get 100mbs for less than the price I can get 25mbps for, includes phone, but not cable.
15
u/Ad_Hominid May 20 '12
And in some parts of the US (like where I live)...the best option for internet is a 3Mbit down/256Kbit up line for $50/mo ($65 if I don't buy their other services also) that is functional 80% of each day if I'm lucky. County-granted monopoly in perpetuity since 1990 = no reason to upgrade anything, ever.
→ More replies (6)6
→ More replies (10)1
6
May 20 '12
This just isn't going to help. All i see happening is a sudden spike in VPN revenues. In my experience the people who pirate do so because A) Things are grossly overpriced and way out of their grasp. $60 for one game? That's like a week's worth of groceries. or B) What they are selling isn't WORTH what they are charging. I've gone to see so many horrible movies, bought so many terrible games that i just can't justify spending money on what essentially comes down to a gamble. Sure there are rare things that come along that are worth it, and do you know what i do? I BUY IT because they did a good job and deserve my money. I'm not paying these morons to make more craptastic movies and half-assed games. Yes i'm trying to justify doing something "illegal" but i'd like these companies to justify why they make us pay so much for literal piles of crap.
5
u/the_catacombs May 20 '12
What are people doing to get these warnings? In 7.. 8 years, I have not seen a single warning. Strange.
0
5
u/samout May 20 '12
"Customers may take measures not to be a customer anymore for being limited over a service they paid for"...
Seriously, there are other ways to govern copyright. If I paid for an internet connection with a certain speed and certain features, you better not even temporarily slow and limit me down, no matter what. I'M PAYING YOU, you're there to provide a service for me because I paid you to do exactly that, you're not necessary for my livelyhood and you're NOT my mother. If I allowed you to do that, where do we draw the line? Copyright infridgement isn't that simple. People break it every day without even knowing it. Even posting a funny comic on Reddit is breaking copyright. So when is it considered bad enough for an ISP to step in? When I download a Rihanna song, or when I download a "random indie band x" -song? Or when I post a NerfNow -comic here. That's why CISPA/SOPA etc. are so vilified; if you're fighting against copyright, it's hypocritical to just mean the big popular names/artists - the ones that actually do make a living out of their stuff and don't actually need protection.
4
u/gnimsh May 20 '12
Verizon describes the program as voluntary. Does that mean you just opt out?
0
May 21 '12
[deleted]
1
u/gnimsh May 21 '12
Oh :( Makes me wonder if that chose that wording to cause confusion.
I currently have RCN and will them I am keeping their service because they are not part of this group of ISPs.
4
May 20 '12
Sucks for college housing that have central routers installed. One person could ruin everybody's connections.
8
u/Sandurz May 20 '12
Governments and ISPs around the world need to realize this really doesn't have anything to do with them. This is a matter between the consumers of content and the creators of content.
For example, with TV, I'm almost satisfied with their online offerings through iTunes and whatnot, but I shouldn't be able to get an illegal torrent downloaded before the official online copy is available to us paying customers. Patience is one thing, but why should I waste my time waiting around for something that doesn't need to be delayed at all?
5
3
3
May 20 '12
Want something pirated? Just create a closed group with people from the EU and US, have them torrent it and then distritute the files through free file services like rapidshare. Renaming the files, rarring, encrypting and passwording might also help. Also VPN's.
This isn't going to stop the people who really want to pirate or put the stuff out there, this is just going to be another "war on ***" to justify whatever they feel like justifying.
3
3
u/BingoBangoMotherFker May 20 '12
“Verizon has always said that copyright infringement is wrong and through this voluntary consumer friendly system, we believe we can educate our consumers and offer them access to legal alternatives,” the company told TorrentFreak. - From the article
Just like we have legal alternatives to non price gouging, monopolistic, telecom companies, right? Please, I've yet to see any around here; and those that do try and start up are immediately shutdown by lawsuits.
I'll start playing by the rules when you and the other telecom companies start playing by the rules. You have absolutely no right to act all high and mighty here, when your own business practices are just as despicable.
3
May 20 '12
US "Six Flags" Anti-Piracy Scheme Delayed: "After 6 warnings park workers in pirate outfits may take some reproductive measures, including offending park guests by connecting temporarily on park benches."
ftfy
3
u/Jack_The_Rippar May 20 '12
If this does meet the deadline and these major ISP's start policing what you download it seems like the perfect environment for new regional ISP's to launch who won't work with MPAA/RIAA and won't adhere to the Agreement. This could a major selling point in years to come.
5
u/argv_minus_one May 20 '12
They don't have the wires between them and your house.
They can't lay said wires because of regulations.
Said regulations exist specifically to protect the monopolies of the current ISPs. (Notice how there's usually only one ISP in any given area.)
Even if such a "rebel ISP" were to take care of the last-mile problem, none of the big boys would peer with them.
Let's face it: the Internet is in the control of a handful of Mafia-style bosses. Free-market economics only work when there aren't colluding oligopolies and corrupt government officials rigging the game.
3
u/Dunabu May 20 '12
What if someone's life depends on the fact that they have internet or not? What if someone has to google how to help an unconscious person, or how to do CPR?
There's too many "What ifs" to factor in for this to be a good idea in any sense.
5
u/bdizzle1 May 20 '12
Anyone who agrees with this is honestly stupid. How are these people getting paid for this reviewing process? Is supporting dead end jobs that don't MAKE money a good way to be spending money? Is this coming out of taxes, or will they be upping the cost of the service, because I'm sure that they wouldn't voluntarily cut their own pay to monitor and monitor the monitors. As a man who cares about his money, not even as a pirate, this is just a complete and utter failure and waste of money.
12
u/silentbobsc May 20 '12
This is already in effect, when we receive DMCA notices at work we are compelled by law to suspend the account's service until they call in and discuss the matter with an abuse hotline. After the 6th case, they lose their service for 2 weeks (I beleive) and have to pay a $100 fee to have it reconnected.
Simple advice - be smart about how you download, either don't use torrents (there are older, and more effective options imo) or leech because it seems that the way they find the offenders is by tracking folks who are actively sharing /seeding. At the very least, move the files you've fully downloaded out of your torrent folder so they aren't seeded continuously.
22
May 20 '12
The problem with the DMCA is that everybody who "thinks" they own a copyright uses it. So you get a lot of this back and forth crap going on. There used to be huge fines if you used the DMCA to make false claims. I think they got a little lax on that now it seems.
I think the RIAA/MPAA need to change their business models. They are trying to make profits as if there was no recession or fads. I remember reading a story awhile back in 2008 about how they were bitching because sales weren't on par to that of 2007. No shit Sherlock we went into a recession, you are not going to make the same profits as you did before. Shit changes. Their attitudes don't. That's the problem. Look at the Avenger's movie and tell me that pirating hurts their sales.
4
3
u/silentbobsc May 20 '12
It may be true, but I work for a smaller provider (~10,000 subs) and I see about 1 per week on average and about 3-4per week when our local university is having classes. The customer can discuss it with the abuse hotline, but after 6 strikes they have to jump through some hoops to get it back on. For those, I've only seen one in the past year.
2
May 20 '12
The fact that more people don't do this anyway actually shocks me. I appreciate the people who seed continuously, but I for one rarely will seed for more than a few hours/days after I've torrented something. If I'm at home on a personal network, I usually remove it even faster.
1
u/elsif1 May 20 '12
ISPs are not required to do that when they receive a DMCA notice; that sounds like internal policy. Your advice is sound though.
1
u/silentbobsc May 20 '12
I'll have to see if I can (legally, aka not get fired) get a copy-paste of the notices we receive. I will say that most our monitoring and data management is handled by a 3rd party which handles most of the abuse tickets. It very likely could be an internal issue as the management does usually err on the side of extreme caution.
0
6
2
May 20 '12
i would have no way of knowing if my isp were doing this to me or not. the only isp i can get in my area is brighthouse. at&t, centurylink, verizon, etc all claim that they don't service my area yet i see at&t and centurylink trucks in the area all the time.
2
u/BaLLiNx May 20 '12
I recently received my "third" warning from Cablevision, yet they never sent anything prior to the third warning letter, which is kind of bs. The letter said they will shut down my internet if I continue downloading, but I wasn't downloading anything other than a few songs here and there, and even then most of the songs were free from mixtapes. I even noticed my internet connection getting progressively slower peaking at like 5 mbps prior to the letter. As soon as I got the letter I did as it suggested and password protected my wireless network. Its been a couple months since I password protected the network and now my connection is back to an average of 18 mbps. So I was getting screwed over by some dick downloading shit off my network and I could have even lost my internet connection.
3
May 20 '12
Why did you have it open in the first place?
3
u/BaLLiNx May 20 '12
The software that came with my router set up my network with this really long and complicated password that I couldn't figure out how to change, so I just left it open making it easy for friends and family to connect when they're over. In hindsight it was a very stupid decision on my part.
2
u/JowyBlight May 20 '12
How are these companies even able to tell what traffic is pirated content and what is completely legal? Will things that would be considered pirated material such as a movie have a stretch of code that would be picked up by the ISP, and then that says they are watching everything we view and do over the internet. How different is blizzards P2P launchers that get used to download and update their games.
If this warning system went into action, I only see lots of wrongful warnings and actions taken against innocent people while the people that really do want to pirate will find some way around it in a matter of hours of them starting it.
1
u/Apollyna May 20 '12
And we will see, once again, that anti-piracy measures serve only to hurt the legitimate user.
1
2
2
2
2
May 20 '12
I'm a little confused as to what will happen when this happens. Will it just be a new warning method similar to the three strike rule? Or will it be something that kills torrenting? I don't pirate things often but when I do it's only to test to see if I like something before I buy it.
2
May 20 '12
So I keep reading comments about VPN. Unfortunately, I'm a total scumbag and I don't feel like paying for anything. Is there a free alternative to VPN?
2
u/mrbrattlebary May 20 '12
Anyone have an opinion on the free vpn providers? I'm poor, and cheap, so I don't want to pay money for that stuff(I need my cash for beer and more vinyl records.)
2
u/squeak6666yw May 20 '12
i wonder if an employee downloads movies at his work computer will the whole business get this warning or will they try to punish the employee?
1
u/Mtrask May 21 '12
Company IT will just look at the logs, if the torrent can even start past the firewall. You seriously don't want to be doing anything other than work-related stuff at work, unless either you don't care about your job and were just about to leave or you're related to the owner and can not get fired.
1
u/squeak6666yw May 21 '12
I understand your point but i was wondering about who would get the warning in the situation that you did it on your company internet. If someone downloads movies on your internet you get sued not them.
2
u/aim2free May 21 '12
Oh Nooo, was Sarkozy hired by the US maffia after his ravaging presidency.
Sarkozy is the guy who made me convinced that the world is not real, it is a simulation, a weird game, when he declared:
copyright is more important than human rights online
Here I made a photo series tranCedenZ ellaborating on this.
2
u/nellynette May 21 '12
If I bought something and want to share it over the Internet that's nobody's business!!!
5
u/DustbinK May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Everyone: Quit downloading RIAA music and MPAA movies.
If you think these industries are going to shit and not putting out anything worthwhile why do you keep seeing their movies and listening to their music?
When you feel the need to check out something from the RIAA or MPAA then do so on a private tracker, with encryption, and try and use a magnet link. Not fool proof, but it will help. Just not as much as avoiding RIAA and MPAA altogether. Stay away from Demonoid, The Pirate Bay, etc. Large trackers= largely tracked.
3
May 20 '12
Would you mind dropping a few alternatives to TPB and Demonoid, for those of us (myself included) not in the know? I've scouted around the net for a few myself, but most of them seem to either a) require a paid subscription, or b) have no decent torrents to speak of, the few that are up at <10 seeders.
I'm already in the practice of stopping seeding as soon as content is done downloading.
4
u/DustbinK May 20 '12
The ones I personally use are invite only sites. I don't know if there's some sort of middleground where something is private but perhaps a little bit easier to get into.
For music I use: What.CD (easily the best music torrenting site on the web) and Waffles.FM
For movies I use: PassThePopcorn. I belonged to a few other sites but didn't find them necessary.
For the off chance I download a TV show I use: broadcastthe.net. Another case of where I just felt like that tracker own out compared to others.
Stay away from paid subscription sites. What.CD, which IMO, is the shining example of what trackers are capable of, didn't get where it is because people paid to get in.
4
u/thebluewonderland May 20 '12
There is an entire subreddit dedicated to discussing private trackers. /r/trackers .
1
u/smacktaix May 20 '12
FYI the thing called "encryption" in torrent clients is not real encryption, it is protocol obfuscation meant to circumvent ISP meddling with torrent traffic. Your IP is still visible. The packets you're downloading are still transmitted in plaintext. You can get a C&D just as easily with "encryption" enabled, it will not help you AT ALL. It is designed to circumvent traffic shaping, not keep your content/identity anonymous.
→ More replies (5)1
u/willfe42 May 20 '12
Agreed. I don't download anything the MPAA or RIAA produces (because it's all absolute shit), and I don't pirate anything either. However, I do still use The Pirate Bay, because, amusingly, it doesn't just carry "pirated" stuff.
3
u/Demojen May 20 '12
ISP have signed the death warrant for Wifi.
4
u/argv_minus_one May 20 '12
Which is exactly what they want.
3
u/Demojen May 21 '12
Oh, it's not going to die in the respect that it won't be available. It just won't be available commercially.
This process is going to drive networks off of the grid through hacks that piggy back other networks, ghosting, then vanish.
It's going to populate a whole new generation of script kiddies with tools even more powerful than the ones routinely calling themselves "Anonymous" today.
What government and ISP seem to forget is, the more authority brought against the tech generation, the faster technology develops to combat it.
This is cyber warfare. Any historian will tell you that during war time technological development speeds up.
→ More replies (3)
3
2
May 20 '12
Since I have Insight, now Time Warner, they won't have to do this since my connection already cuts off 2 or 3 times a day. I miss my Cinci Bell FiOps.
1
u/orphanitis May 20 '12
I've had Time Warner (roadrunner) for a long time and never had problems. That sucks :(
2
May 20 '12
This is so wrong it makes me sick. You cannot censor an internet connection based on piracy accusations.
→ More replies (6)
1
May 20 '12
6 warnings isn't as bad as 3. I've only received 2 warnings in my life, both back in 2001 and within a week of each other. I used to pirate a lot of shit back then off of kazaa morpheus or limewire. forget what I was using.
1
1
u/CharlieTango May 20 '12
Got a warning from comcast about a year ago, youre telling me i get 5 more before they do anything?
1
May 20 '12
I got banned from Mediacom after 3. :( I'd really like those other 2 safety strikes so I can switch from AT&T's shitty 15 kbps.
1
May 20 '12
Okay, so in the past 2 years I (may) have downloaded some music and tv shows. I have never received a letter from ISPs. Wouldn't this "6 strike" thing not affect anybody at all? This way, you cannot be randomly sued and if you get warned 5 times before any legal action. If you get caught that many times, you shouldn't be downloading anyways. Don't use pirate bay and use private trackers and you will be fine still, correct?
1
u/rexdeaz May 20 '12
I'm in California and Time Warner is already doing something like this. I've received two warnings in the last 8 months, both resulting in disconnection until I called a certain number and basically promised to stop torrenting. If I get caught again they say they will terminate my service all together. I was able to glean some info from the woman I spoke with and it appears she was able to track me based on copies of films that I let seed for more than half a year. It was not because of anything I was actually in the process of downloading. Like I said, this is just my experience with Time Warner in California, I'm not sure how anyone else does it.
1
1
u/druid_king9884 May 20 '12
What if a person uses a public WiFi connection to download torrents? Is there any way to track down the user?
1
1
u/Silverkarn May 20 '12
This is what i will be doing for torrents if i start getting letters.
Drive into Mcdonalds Parking lot and download. Or use my high gain Wifi Antenna and download from someone elses connection.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/MaxJohnson15 May 20 '12
They already slow down and throttle connections now after zero warnings. What's the difference? They'll just be admitting to it then.
1
u/smoothmann May 20 '12
That's funny. Comcast has metered my rapidshare downloads for about 4 months now.
1
May 20 '12
This isn't already happening? After years of pirating, my connection is slow as shit, and goes out constantly. Fucking brighthouse.
1
u/awrhaernnare May 20 '12
I'm 25 and I've been doing this since I was 10. At this point, I'm pretty sure that these "warnings" are a myth.
1
u/argv_minus_one May 20 '12
That would be because they haven't started sending them out yet. RTFA.
1
1
u/Turtlenips May 20 '12
Woh. I thought it was six seasons and a movie according to Abed. He is always right.
1
1
1
1
u/nefrina May 21 '12
The day Verizon slows down my Fiber connection is the day I stop giving them my money.
1
u/DiaDeLosMuertos May 21 '12
wth, I think I've experienced these repressive measures. Lame. Time Warner Cable SoCal fyi.
1
May 21 '12
I think that this is going to be horribly abused once it is implemented. US ISPs have this thing about conserving bits like they are a finite resource.
1
May 21 '12
There is no way in hell I believe that ISP's will monitor every single one of its users, theres just no way to do it.
1
u/Lord_Vectron May 21 '12
Speed lowering and temporary connection cut offs absolutely screams of ISPs trying to give a shittier cheaper service for maximum price while acting morally superior. Why not just kick them off your service, and stop charging them the money for the remaining months you made them sign for, it isn't your job to punish "criminals".
I don't see how this can be legal. Money truly is power.
1
u/hierocles May 21 '12
I thought most ISPs used a three-strike scheme anyways? That's what all the letters I've gotten (from multiple ISPs) have always said.
1
1
1
u/Quailificus May 20 '12
Well that's better than 15 years in federal prison I guess.
4
u/orphanitis May 20 '12
I mean... If I was going to federal prison for 15 years because of SHARING FILES, I'd probably just do suicide. -_-
119
u/Picardy May 20 '12
Oh... I didn't realize Comcast was ahead of the curve.