r/technology • • May 19 '12

This is how easy it is for thieves to steal from your wallet wirelessly.

http://www.businessinsider.com/watch-this-is-how-easy-it-is-for-thieves-to-steal-everything-in-your-wallet-2012-5
1.1k Upvotes

528 comments sorted by

142

u/xrthrowaway May 20 '12

Knowledge on how to use high strength/long distance RFID readers to read CC data from a distance has been around for years.

148

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited Jun 30 '23

After 11 years, I'm out.

Join me over on the Fediverse to escape this central authority nightmare.

119

u/xrthrowaway May 20 '12

There's an easier way: you can also microwave your card for a few seconds; it melts the RFID antenna, ensuring it can't be read from ever again.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

wouldn't that melt the card and destroy the mag strip?

229

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited Jun 30 '23

After 11 years, I'm out.

Join me over on the Fediverse to escape this central authority nightmare.

90

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

If we wanna go by how awesome the method is, you could always pass it through a plasma arc speaker. You can make one for $30. Definitely puts a camera tazer to shame.

→ More replies (21)

36

u/Deadlyd0g May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

If you break the RFID is the card still usable? I know it's a dumb question.

52

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Swiping: Yes

Waving: No

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (24)

5

u/wolever May 20 '12

There's an easier way: you can also hammer your card for a few seconds; it smashes the RFID antenna, ensuring it can't be read from ever again.

(ref)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

As someone who has discharged a flash capacitor with his thumb I can confirm the "be careful" part.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Congrats now your credit card is useless depending on what country you are in.

In Ireland they will either refuse to take the card, or you have to jump through further loops to get your signature accepted.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Yeah, I hadn't considered that in europe most cards contain a chip in addition to the RFID. In the US most debit or credit cards only contain the RFID chip, if anything.

→ More replies (20)

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I thought you could just put foil round it?

2

u/CoolerRon May 20 '12

Awesome! Now I just need to find where I can buy a disposable camera for a dollar. Can I also use my EMP against my opponents' cars when we do our R/C demolition derbies? maniacal laugh, maniacal laugh

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/FANGO May 20 '12

Well we better stop talking about it then since everyone already knows about it!

→ More replies (6)

249

u/NikoKun May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

Unlike a regular RFID card which stores all your info on a magnetic strip

lol, They never get these things right.. Magnetic strips are the black bar on the back of the card, which is what's used when you swipe the card in traditional readers. An RFID chip uses a hidden coil/antenna which transmits an ID number or string of characters wirelessly when an external signal hits it.

Or at least that is my understanding..

43

u/MertsA May 20 '12

That is more or less correct, it's a bit more complicated than a hidden coil though.

34

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Still made a great ELI5 for non-techies. And for Mandi Woodruff, who has no idea what she's talking about, but she's so good at playing journalist that she gets to keep her job. Yay!

40

u/FunnyMan3595 May 20 '12

I hit the same quote and copied it out for friends. Here's what the clipboard looked like after:

Unlike a regular RFID card which stores all your info on a magnetic strip

Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/watch-this-is-how-easy-it-is-for-thieves-to-steal-everything-in-your-wallet-2012-5#ixzz1vPmTlHh6

So not only are their writers incompetent, the website itself is an asshole that tampers with your clipboard.

10

u/consonaut May 20 '12 edited Feb 17 '24

growth impolite light bored steer ring physical tap pet spark

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (8)

4

u/vegetaman May 20 '12

God I hate that shit.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

The daily mail website used to do that.

How does it do it? Is it some hidden text somewhere?

→ More replies (9)

2

u/PrettyBoyFloyd May 20 '12

I see more and more websites using this these days. It's a big pain in the ass.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/iwan_w May 20 '12

It seams they ment to write "regular credit card" instead of "regular RFID card". At least that way it makes sense. More like a proofreading failure than a lack of understanding probably.

12

u/Shaper_pmp May 20 '12

Except you can't remotely scan a regular mag-strip card, which would render the whole sentence meaningless.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/cs4evr May 20 '12

I see this security expert sells sleeves to place credit cards in and does not mention RFID blocking wallets which have been around for a while. Here is one from ThinkGeek others exist as well. http://www.thinkgeek.com/gadgets/security/8cdd/

15

u/Primeribsteak May 20 '12

well no, how do you think he would make any money like that?

3

u/H5Mind May 20 '12

The US Passport Card comes with an RFID sleeve and instructions to safeguard against RFID snooping.

2

u/Hellman109 May 20 '12

1:15 they say wallets and security sleeves.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

33

u/snapcase May 20 '12

Unlike a regular RFID card which stores all your info on a magnetic strip

Sounds like someone doesn't really understand what the hell they're talking about.

2

u/paffle May 20 '12 edited Aug 17 '26

Heavy hammock full slim meeting badge

This post was anonymized with Redact

4

u/McCrackenYouUp May 20 '12

Come on folks, this is nothing but manufactured fear. The business man is just selling a product. I know his type. How many pickpockets or purse snatchers do you think are going to have the technical know-how to do all this? Seems like a minimal threat at best.

Also, it's not generally hard to cancel transactions you never made and get your money back. Perhaps some banks/ credit companies are worse than others in this regard, though.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Why are you minimizing the threat as if it doesnt exist?

It does.

Its not a fantasy. In fact, a vast majority of citizens don't commit crimes on any scale.

Its always the few that make it bad for the many. In that case, this is a real threat and can be seen as a credible notion to look into.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

27

u/muddywaiter May 20 '12

Obligatory Snopes reference:

"The data streams emitted by contactless cards don't include such information as PINs and CVV (Card Verification Value) security codes

  • or, in newer cards, customer names - and without those pieces of information a card skimmer should not be able to utilize the stolen card numbers to print up counterfeit cards or engage in Card Not Present (CNP) transactions."

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Yeah, but that's still a major chunk of valuable information--the primary piece of the puzzle if you will--if you're a thief trying to steal someone's credit card info. I mean, the friggin' number is the most important bit of information, and that's the one that they decide to put out in the open nearly unprotected?! Stupid. No, I definitely would not be cool with that if I were given the option of a RFID card. No fucking way do I want one of those and I hate that they're used in passports (when I renew mine and get the new one with the RFID chip that fucker's getting the hammer treatment straight away).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

51

u/WestEndStench May 20 '12

As a non-owner of an RFID CC, I always found the concept completely unnecessary anyways. It takes the same amount of time to swipe a card. While it's still not practical to just have a CC# for theft purposes, I guess I now have another reason not to get a card with RFID.

21

u/Amablue May 20 '12

You can actually see where the RFID chip is if you hold your card up to the light. I don't mind if I get a card with a chip, I just smash a hammer on the right spot to destroy the chip :)

I had a friend microwave his card to destroy the chip. It was effective in destroying the chip, but is also destroyed the rest of the card...

10

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I just did that after watching 10 seconds of this video. The hammer method, that is. New US passports now have RFID chips as well FYI

20

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

RFID chips are not insecure by definition, they simply mean that contact to the card can be established over a (small) distance.

For CC RFID is ridiculous, since the CC information is pretty much transmitted in plaintext, allowing for the scenario in the video, but a passport should be using encryption and a PIN. I'm not actually familiar with US passports, hence the "should", but I'd be really surprised if they didn't have it.

13

u/take_924 May 20 '12

To be able to decode the information on a US passport you need a key. The key is printed on the inside of the passport. So, a contactless reader needs to see the opened passport and scan the code from the passport before it can decode the RFID-data.

It makes stealing data from your passport quite a bit harder but not impossible.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/hated_dil May 20 '12

I wouldn't be so sure of the hammer trick in the future, a relative of mine has a job where he is working on those, I have seen them and they vary from the size of a thumb nail to the size of you're smallest pinkie toe and flat like a sticker....in fact, they come on sticker sheets and carry real info. (small bits, but enough)

what is eery about these?

they have already made one inside a glass tube that you can put under human skin. I saw it, its tiny and about the size of a small Christmas light.

how obnoxious would that be to hide?

7

u/take_924 May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

they have already made one inside a glass tube that you can put under human skin.

Grain of rice and RFID transponder

It's what is used when you get your pet 'chipped'. It's not FDA-approved for use in humans, but a few people have one. There was a bar here in Holland which used these tags so people could identify themselfs quickly to pay for drinks. About fifty people liked the idea so much they got one.

And how could I forget the madman/Cyborg Professor Kevin Warwick?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

For some, it's more convenient to not have to take out the card but to be able to just swipe your whole wallet over the scanner. It's more useful in places where high concentrations of transactions need to be made(some subway stations utilize this).

17

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

What stops it from scanning multiple RFID enabled cards in your wallet? It seems like it would just be random at that point, or worst case scenario, get charged multiple times.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/biznatch11 May 20 '12

This doesn't work for all cards/readers. I have two RFID cards for work and one of them always works in my wallet even with the second card and my credit card (which has RFID) in there, the other ID card for work has to be removed from my wallet to use it. It's not that it doesn't work through the wallet, it's that the other cards are interfering with it. They are on two different systems with two different brands of cards and readers, maybe one of the readers is more powerful or more sensitive. Fortunately the one I use 95% of the time is the one that works from my wallet and yes it's extremely convenient to just pull my wallet out of my pocket and wave it by the reader.

6

u/TheKesselRun May 20 '12

What I've noticed (in Australia), is that Paypass transactions are approved by the machines instantly (so there is no actual contact with the bank happening). Presumably they are then proceed later on. Using debit, approval is sought from the bank at the point of sale. If you are paying for something and leaving the store straight away (not waiting for a receipt for example), then it is definitely quicker. Sure it might only save a few seconds, but if you are like me and rarely carry cash around it's very convenient.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

This. I recently got a contactless debit card (I'm in the UK) and it's remarkably quick to do transactions. The main issue is the uptake - the only places I've seen them accepted are McDonald's, Subway and Greggs the Bakers. I'm hoping more supermarkets and such will start taking them soon.

Personally I think there's far, far too much paranoia about these things. The chances of someone stealing your card wirelessly are an order of magnitude lower than the chances of someone stealing your wallet, phone and anything else you have on you physically.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Franholio May 20 '12

Adam Savage on RFID

Basically, the Mythbusters were going to test how easy it is to steal CC info using this method, but the legal departments at Visa, MC, Amex et al shut them down in a hurry.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/decavolt May 20 '12 edited Oct 22 '24

sort safe impolite grandfather recognise weary juggle kiss steer grey

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

26

u/dtwhitecp May 20 '12

I don't really understand why they put the RFID stuff in those cards anyway. How is waving the card any easier than swiping it?

18

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

If you only have one RFID card in your wallet, then it is not necessary to even take it out. Just tap your wallet on the scanner. As long as the card is within about 1 or 2 cm it can be read. If there are multiple cards though, it probably will not work.

For magnetic stripe credit card machine, the card has to be oriented a certain way to work. There are two long edges on the card and the stripe can face one way or another. That is four possible ways to slide the card through the machine and only one will work in most cases. The RFID cards work in any orientation.

In areas where transit uses RFID cards, for example Hong Kong, it is common to see women just plop their purses on top of the scanner and proceed through the turnstile into the ferry terminal or subway.

16

u/bricksoup May 20 '12

If RFID takes off, won't most people NOT have just one type of RFID card in their wallets?

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Cards that only work in specific circumstances would still work fine. I use one for the bus (Seattle), and another to get into my college, and they both work just fine stacked up with my other cards.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/ThePhantomTrollbooth May 20 '12

If it takes off, it will probably be in the form of NFC in cell phones. There's not enough added convenience to an RFID card to justify most people even using it over just swiping the card.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MyPetHamster May 20 '12

This is already the case in cities where the public transport system uses RFID cards. I'm in London and until recently I could just tap my wallet to go in and out of the tube. Now I've got an RFID debit card in the wallet I can no longer do this. It's a small thing, but its VERY annoying!

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

As a cashier that swipes tons of cards every day it makes me feel bad that people are complaining about the difficulty and time requirement of swiping a fucking card. You can determine to needed orientation of a card within a second if you're not a complete idiot.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

48

u/MrDoomBringer May 20 '12

Stop stop stop. Back the hell up.

When you install an application on an Android phone it explicitly states the requirements for that app, such as text messages, internet data, etc.

If a tic-tac-toe app is asking for access to the NFC radio, then I'm not going to download that app, period. NFC is a specific permission listed when you install the app.

Furthermore, there's been a large movement towards encrypted data transmission from RFID enabled cards.

21

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You're not a moron though. There are many, many people who would tap accept without a second thought. I mean, weren't technologically impaired parents the number one cause of viruses in the 90's?

12

u/snapcase May 20 '12

I swear to god I should have gotten paid all the times I had to fix an infected machine my parents fucked up. And now they get all pissed at the incredibly basic security measures I set up on their computers (like script whitelisting in browsers) and try to go around it rather than taking two seconds to learn how to whitelist just the sites you know you can trust. Not like they can't grasp tech either, they just don't care to learn it because it's too much of an inconvenience for them to not infect the freaking computer.

/rantoff

12

u/-jackschitt- May 20 '12

I once had a customer call me up with the typical "I clicked on a bunch of stupid shit" virus/malware infection. Pretty easy stuff....was in and out in 45 minutes. Installed free AV on her computer (avast, I think. Can't remember).

A month later, she called me back. Her computer was infected again. Went over to her house -- she removed the AV. So I asked why. "It kept on popping up with all these annoying warnings about viruses, so I uninstalled it."

me: "Ma'am, you do realize that the purpose of the software was to do exactly that -- so you wouldn't have to continue calling and paying me to remove them"

her: "Yeah, but I don't want anything interfering with what I'm doing online. It's just more convenient for me to pay someone to fix it every once in a while than have to click through all those annoying warnings"

Me: <blink, blink>

I must have made easily a thousand bucks off her in the course of a year before the calls stopped. 'Twas a sad, sad day when I realized she was probably not going to call any more.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/guiriguiri May 20 '12

i had no idea what an nfc radio was until now, so there's no doubt in my mind i would have just thought it was technological mumbo-jumbo that i didn't need to concern myself with and click accept. now i'm going to be picking apart every noun and verb i find on those terms and conditions.

39

u/figpetus May 20 '12

Furthermore, there's been a large movement towards encrypted data transmission from RFID enabled cards.

You mean like they have in the new passports? The new "unforgeable" passports that were cracked and cloned before they even were distributed to the general population?

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted]

22

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Can anyone explain why this is downvoted? Because downvotes = wrong information usually and I thought this was true.

43

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Because everyone on reddit is an asshole.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Generally, people aren't that savvy.

4

u/MrDoomBringer May 20 '12

And I work in a data backup company making money off of people who aren't that savvy. If you spend the extra 15 seconds scanning through the permissions you can see what's up. If you don't, you can pay someone a large sum of money to undo your problems.

6

u/patrik667 May 20 '12

For the normal user it usually goes like this:

"Why does tic tac toe needs to use wifi and email?.... The fuck if I care! I'm gonna have tic tac toe on MY PHONE!"

5

u/-jackschitt- May 20 '12

This is exactly it. 9 out of 10 people are going to click right through the warnings without even reading them. Of those 9, I'd say a good 5-6 will either ignore your warnings or actively get pissed at you for trying to warn them.

4

u/throwaway_for_keeps May 20 '12

My phone doesn't have NFC, but most of the time, I don't read what those permissions are. I mean, I don't care if facebook wants access to my contact list, I want to use the mobile app (not really, just an example).

Granted, I have LBE on my phone now, so it gives me a popup every time an app is requesting to use a permission unless I have previously marked it as trusted. If I don't accept in 10 seconds or so, it automatically denies.

But who's to say that evil tic tac toe dev isn't saying that the NFC permission is so you can play locally against people without swapping phones? You have the game on your screen and they have it on their screen, communicating via NFC.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/brantyr May 20 '12

Yeah but most people don't give a fuck. I can barely be bothered going through what apps want to access myself and I've hacked around with the phone quite a bit. Even users who can be bothered checking before they install the app won't even know what NFC is. You just have to hope google is good at pulling malicious apps from the market (and force removing them from phones) when they're found.

→ More replies (21)

11

u/readingcarrot May 20 '12

Good thing I have no money to steal u_u

11

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

No, but their attempted transactions could reward you with insufficient funds charges if it is a debit card.

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Which I would dispute the charges and my bank would reimburse me within the hour.

Been there. Done that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/edud May 20 '12

Do credit card companies give an option of not having RFID on card?

3

u/turmacar May 20 '12

Yes. But by default they are now issuing the cards with RFID. If you don't know/don't ask you get one.

→ More replies (8)

19

u/willpower101 May 20 '12

o.O Seriously, any credit/debit card worth having includes fraud protection/forgiveness.

I've never understood this kind of fear mongering. If my card randomly charges hundreds of dollars three states (or countries) over, I call the issuing bank, tell them I didn't do it, and am not held liable. No need for a tinfoil hat.

2

u/darknavi May 20 '12

Just a tinfoil card case.

2

u/dark_roast May 20 '12

But that money has to come from somewhere. If someone steals from you, and the bank reimburses you, the bank now has to figure out some way of making that money back.

It's better for all involved if fraud is kept to a minimum. No need for tinfoil, but good to understand the risks.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/DMercenary May 20 '12

|The worst part is there's virtually no way to protect yourself from scanners other than investing in a special wallet or credit card sleeves that block them.

|(our hats go off to the guy who found a DIY way to prevent theft – wrapping his cards up in aluminum foil).

lolwut.

"Omg there's no way to protect yourself.

Btw this guy found out you can protect yourself by using aluminum foil"

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bloodnutatthehelm May 20 '12

Honestly, when I first saw the RFID cards I thought to my self: "this is an awful idea." To me the idea of broadcasting information is essentially setting it out there on a silver platter for whoever to pick up. On top of it all, how is RFID any easier/faster than running your card through a slot?

34

u/crypticXJ88 May 20 '12

Sensationalist horseshit. They don't even have their definitions down, as many have pointed out.

6

u/Sec_Henry_Paulson May 20 '12

No No No.

So what if the people that made the article aren't tech savvy? This needs to be made a bigger deal out of.

This has been going on for like 6 or 7 years now, and the fact that people can read your credit cards right by just being near them is a huge deal.

The mythbusters tried to do a show about this, but the credit card companies made them pull it before it was aired.

I was at a hacker convention 5 years ago where a group of people were giving demonstrations on how to do this to anyone that wanted to listen. I'm surprised this crap is still around.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

And it can all be reversed via your bank. Well, good banks at least. Ive had this happen to me. Bank cleared all charges and got me a new card. All in about 10 minutes. Pretty painless.

2

u/SilverSeven May 20 '12

THIS. I dont get the insane fear people have. It takes maybe 30 minutes to call your CC and bank and have everything reversed and a new card sent out.

4

u/ninety6days May 20 '12

Dear USA

CHIP AND PIN CREDIT CARDS

Yours, European retail.

1

u/bloodisblue May 20 '12

popular science did an article about this several months ago and said that having multiple credit cards made it impossible for the readers to correctly identify a single card.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Impossible or unlikely?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

The worst part is there's virtually no way to protect yourself from scanners other than investing in a special wallet or credit card sleeves that block them.

Here's one way: call the bank and request cards without RFID. Works every time! (I even did this with my snazzy Amex blue square thingie card.

4

u/whirliscope May 20 '12

You do realize that the reason you're paying amex is for them to worry about your money getting stolen right? If this happens enough they'll just increase the security on the card.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/toychristopher May 20 '12

I don't understand how people utilize the data they steal in this way to make money without getting caught.

11

u/ameoba May 20 '12

Their "next door neighbor" who happens to be out of town decides to buy large quantities of easily sold, high-dollar items.

5

u/paulwal May 20 '12

Make a convincing fake card with the real card's number on it. Walk into a store, make a big purchase and hope the cashier doesn't ask to see ID.

Or, buy something online with the card number if they also have the security code printed on the back of the card.

In both of these cases, the fraudster walks away with the merchandise, the bank refunds the money to the real card holder, and the merchant eats the cost. Happens all the time, every day. No one really seems to care.

11

u/FeltRaptor May 20 '12

Merchants can't actually ask for ID. From Mastercard's Merchant Agreement (a similar clause can be found in the agreements for all of the major credit cards):

5.8.4

Additional Cardholder Identification

A Merchant must not refuse to complete a Transaction solely because a Cardholder who has complied with the conditions for presentment of a Card at the POI refuses to provide additional identification information, except as specifically permitted or required by the Standards. A Merchant may require additional identification from the Cardholder if the information is required to complete the Transaction, such as for shipping purposes. A Merchant in a country or region that supports use of the MasterCard Address Verification Service (AVS) may require the Cardholder’s ZIP or postal code to complete a Cardholder-Activated Terminal (CAT) Transaction, or the Cardholder’s address and ZIP or postal code to complete a mail order, phone order, or e-commerce Transaction.

3

u/Run4way May 20 '12

Maybe I don't know computer/cellphone tech. as well as I think I do, but isn't that last bit about downloading an app that steals your credit card info a little far fetched considering there are very few phones that have an RFID reader?

2

u/turmacar May 20 '12

Maybe, most of the newer smartphones are getting them though. IIRC the NFC tech is basically the same thing, just it can store/respond to more than one thing.

3

u/blueblast88 May 20 '12

go to the bank and ask for a credit card that isn't RFID compatible works fine too, most of the time they don't charge you.

3

u/IHopeYouStepOnALego May 20 '12

I don't understand how people are just realizing this. I remember thinking that's the dumbest thing you could do back when they first came out. It is such an obvious easy target. This is why I've never had and never will have an RFID card.

10

u/texxmix May 20 '12

While this is pretty freaky at how exposed we are, but most of these readers can't pick up pins, security codes and customer names in newer cards.

10

u/TheLobotomizer May 20 '12

That's becoming irrelevant with pin-less transactions. For example, I've seen someone have nearly $1500 stolen from their bank account through $125 charges at gas stations. Even though the bank returned the money, the thief still got away with that money.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Dutch person here. For us, it's already irrelevant. I was quite surprised when I went to Belgium, and I had to pay for dinner, and they just accepted my bank card as a creditcard (which it is most definitely not). I did not have to sign anything, I did not have to enter my pin code (and it's not stored on the chip). All they needed was my bank number.

I asked my bank about it, and they didn't even know that could be done.

My conclusion, also based on some skimming research I did, is that banking is extremely insecure (at least here in the Netherlands). Always has been, and probably always will. The costs of making it secure just don't outweigh the costs incurred from electronic theft. So I'm taking the whole remote electronic stealing of any information, regardless of how insignificant that information may seem, very serious.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Couldn't one just put the card in a microwave for a second or two to destroy the electronics? I have done that with smart cards before but they were not RFID.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Luckily, I don't have any money. Otherwise, I'd need some aluminum foil.

2

u/MrJuwi May 20 '12

Good luck stealing from me, I have a wallet made of stainless steal thread.

2

u/Zsem_le May 20 '12

It's stunning that such payment methods exist at all. Where you don't have to confirm how much, and when do you pay, with a password or something similar.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Isn't this old news? Correct me if i'm wrong but hasn't this flaw already been proven to work on a certain nintendo device with a plug in?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

QUESTIONS!!

  • How do I know my CC has an RFID or not?

  • Why do (US) Passports have RFIDs?

  • If I destroyed the RFID in a passport, wouldn't I be unable to cross country lines (don't they scan passports in customs)?

3

u/blueskin May 20 '12
  1. It usually has a symbol on it. If you don't know, it likely doesn't though.

  2. They're used to read your data electronically.

  3. Yes. Get a shielded passport case.

2

u/GODZiGGA May 20 '12

The shielded passport case is a little bit of overkill. The RFID passports can only be read when the passport is open which would require physical access to the passport in the first place making a shielded case irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/whirliscope May 20 '12

TIL all smartphones have RFID readers built in...

Only half of the stuff in that was true.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Grrbam May 20 '12

Gladly that i live in Europe with a good o'l micro chip and a strip for creditcard/bankcard. But.. I do might worried for a chipcard for travel transport..

2

u/blueskin May 20 '12

Did people not know this? /facepalm

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Rubbish. I'm excited to get rid of my wallet. I want my phone to do everything for me.

2

u/elroy_jetson May 20 '12

is it just me, or does it seem like all these stories about "CRIMINAL GANGS STEALING YOUR MONEY VIA INTERNET/WIRELESS TECHNOLOGY/CARD SKIMMING/ETC!!" are just carefully crafted PR by credit card processing companies??

if someone steals my credit card number and spends up big then i don't lose any money. so long as i can prove that i didn't make the transactions (which is pretty easy), it is the bank that loses the money. so really, i don't particularly care if someone walks past me and RFID-rapes me. it'll be a little inconvenient, sure, but costly? no - not for me. so why should i care?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MagicMurderBean May 20 '12

Funny how they say "thieves half way around the world" then spin the globe to Russia...

2

u/eorld May 20 '12

Its like in that awesome book little brother, where he totally screws tons of shit up with an RFID readers... That book is amazing!

2

u/Luke2001 May 20 '12

In Denmark we use cards with chips :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/littlegreenrock May 20 '12

For permanent results:

You will need a drill, and a 3mm drill bit; something to lean on. See picture. Drill hole. Done. The RFID aerial in the card has been disconnected from the chip. The card still works. the mag strip is not damaged. The chip functions normally. The card will go through an ATM, or any other machine flawlessly, but the RFID will no longer function.

Security with no loss of card function. Bank does not care. EFTPOS outlets do not care.

2

u/Daemonicus May 20 '12

Google "faraday cage wallet".

Follow instructions.

Alter to suit your aesthetic needs.

Enjoy a little piece of mind.

2

u/shaolinpunks May 20 '12

Do passports have rfid in them? I remember that they were pushing them in them a few years ago.

2

u/jamar0303 May 20 '12

All US passports issued after '05, I think, have them. You'll know because the outer cover is thicker and less flexible than chip-less ones.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jimmyx18 May 20 '12

Thank you kind sir, ordering this now.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Would a password-protected phone with Google Wallet (for example) be more secure? Someday I just want everything on my cellphone... I hate carrying around a physical wallet :/

→ More replies (1)

1

u/teflonpepe May 20 '12

Really weird seeing this, my friend actually was talking about this a while back but I thought he was bullshitting me. Crazy to find out it's real.

1

u/WestonP May 20 '12

This is nothing new, and it's incredibly stupidity that they had put this stuff into use to begin with. None of my cards have, or have ever had, this crap in it, for obvious reasons.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I feel like I missed out on a wave of fail technology because both my debit and my credit card are just plain old mag-strip. Although I want to move to using google wallet next.

1

u/siglug May 20 '12

Okay so they don't get the security number, so actually they get a bunch of meaningless numbers?

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I have a Visa card with an RFID chip inside. It's a few years old so there was a small outline of the chip on the right side. The first thing I did after watching this video was smash that chip with a hammer.

I've never used the RFID chip, and I never expect to. I can't see it saving me any time.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

Just so happen to have just bought an RFID blocking wallet about a week ago. Not a bad price at the standard 20$ wallet price. Surprisingly, it's actually an awesome wallet in itself, it's built well, has great design and capacity of card slots, 2 cash pockets, 2 ID screen things, design makes sense, etc. First wallet i've bought in a long time that i actually am 100% satisfied with.

I highly recommend, this type of scam is going to be more and more of a threat as time goes by, might as well invest in one of these. They also have Passport Billfolds too.

1

u/flea79 May 20 '12

Technology, pfft.

1

u/deepwaterhippy May 20 '12

m "coworker" was fired and info turned over to police due to this just the other day She had been accused of stealing a customers credit card and using the ATM, we actually had video evidence, her argument in defense was that she wasn't dumb enough to do that because she had a reader secreted in her purse she steal it with instead like she usually did, (obviously a high IQ isn't a qualification for being a stripper).

1

u/Flimsyfishy May 20 '12

And this is why i won't use RFIDs.

1

u/Emiel000 May 20 '12

This is fucked up

1

u/dustyfoot May 20 '12

This wouldn't work in Austria (or likely Germany or even the rest of Europe) where ALL cards are equipped with this chip from day one - no one has RFID chips in their cards.

1

u/jigglesv May 20 '12

Can someone explain what RFID chips on credit cards do as well as what happens when you disable it? Does the credit card still work? If so, why does it have the chip in the first place? Thanks! :D

→ More replies (1)

1

u/makedamsure May 20 '12

Any links for the product in question? I'd like to test this out. For science!

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Easy, just take the money out of the wallet. no wires needed.

1

u/kilamumster May 20 '12

I've been watching this situation for work but also for personal reasons. As the paranoid techie-type of the family, I bought several Travelon RFID-blocking wallets and bags for Christmas gifts from eBags.com searching "RFID".

I got one for me, others for family and some close friends, who travel internationally; a couple are in the security business. Even my tech-challenged mum appreciated the thought, once I explained it to her.

Also picked up a couple at thrift shops as I recognized the style. They aren't the most stylish but they supposedly do the job. Some have a special card pouch on a short tether for those cards that need to be pulled out for swipe readers; tucked back in, they are protected again.

1

u/moddie May 20 '12

I have a stainless steel wallet that prevents this!

1

u/almostjesus May 20 '12

I really don't see the point of this fight against this type of crime. No matter what you do the criminals are always going to be one step ahead and it's just more money being burned by the credit card companies and banks to give customers that false security blanket (despite zero liability for fraud) the banks and credit card companies will never win.

This is where higher fees come in :)

1

u/throwaway_for_keeps May 20 '12

What I'm curious about is the guy who just wrapped his cards in foil. Does that actually work? My debit card has paypass, and I use it often. Sure, I could just swipe my card, but I don't. I just skweep it on the machine instead. I'm not going to spend $70 on a special wallet or $10 on a special sleeve if I don't have to.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Admiral_Cheese_Balls May 20 '12

This is why I use a CC that doesn't have RFID

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Good to live in Europe! No RFID.

1

u/randomb0y May 20 '12

Wow, who uses these? I haven't seen RFID POSes or cards in Europe.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Furah May 20 '12

Thank fuck my bank is stingy and gave me a card that doesn't have RFID, or that other chip they've had for years. The one where you insert your card at terminals instead of swiping it.

1

u/dark_arts87 May 20 '12

After watching this, I'm glad the technology has yet to catch on in the UK.

1

u/RoscoeMG May 20 '12

Where can I get a lead lined wallet then?

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

1:09 Steve Irwin is alive!!

1

u/SellMeSteve May 20 '12

Look for the prick trying to poke you with an iPad. Next, kick him in the balls.

1

u/formation May 20 '12

I have paypass on my master card, never seen a store except for k-mart that uses the system.

1

u/Adroite May 20 '12

A corn field in Iowa eh... I'm only a few blocks from one... hrmmm.

1

u/guiriguiri May 20 '12

shh, don't tell /r/Barcelona! the pickpockets here are crafty enough as it is.

1

u/jlamothe May 20 '12

This is exactly why I have an RFID blocking wallet.

1

u/Glader May 20 '12

I fucking hate these odd-job video players... The volume is on max per default which guess what? It's really fucking loud. Then the volume bar is really just a mute button if you can manage to find it before you throw your headphones on the floor due to the ear-piercing pain, and once you've lowered the master volume on your system you're just left with a low-resolution video which the servers still can't manage to serve you without buffering breaks all the time.

1

u/ILoveHate May 20 '12

I was under the impression that's what (miscalculated) inflation was all about.

1

u/Schrikbarend May 20 '12

great missed opportunity for the last lady: "technology... You Scary!"

1

u/The_final_chapter May 20 '12

Anyone with even half a brain saw this coming when it (Swipe and pay)was first discussed. So now the cards that were designed to make payments easy have to be wrapped in material which prevents them from working.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

"Oh my gosh that is incredible"

KILL IT! KILL IT NOW!

1

u/gluino May 20 '12

What exactly is the scanner able to read? The entire credit card number? The issuing bank? What else?

Is the scanner able to make charges?

I was under the impression that all RF-readers that are able to make charges are registered with some authority, such that for any fraudulent charge, one can track down someone to be accountable.

1

u/spartom007 May 20 '12

RFID cards were always a bad idea imo. Now thieves can steal your card and go on spending sprees of mini transactions without needing to know your PIN. Petty theft was made near impossible thanks to most shops taking debit/credit card for small transactions so we don't have to carry cash. Now thieves can steal your card and do the same.

Solution: Ask your bank for a regular chip and pin card or move banks. Simple

1

u/fsacb3 May 20 '12

Just listen for the loud buzzing noise and then see who's holding an iPad up to your ass

1

u/m1kepro May 20 '12

My understanding has been that you can disable the RFID chip inside by placing your card (or passport) on a flat surface, and slamming the RFID chip repeatedly with a hammer. That's provided you never want to use the RFID again, which I don't. Taking the extra 0.6 seconds to swipe is fine with me.

True? False? Somebody help me out here.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/_gmanual_ May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

cracked some time ago.

/EDIT: "...The most critical attack recovers ANY secret key requiring wireless access to just the card only in less than five minutes on inexpensive commercial off -the-shelf hardware and without any pre-computation. Using our attacks, we expose the vulnerabilities of the Imperial College's access control system and show our ability to masquerade as any valid Imperial College personnel. Most importantly, we crack the internal structure of the Oyster card and locate the exact data bytes that represent the current credit and past transaction records. The impact of our findings are so severe that London's transport operators stand to lose millions of pounds if our findings were made public..." Source

1

u/Rulebook_Lawyer May 20 '12

I always assumed that the information of a card of mine can always be acquired. Typically by a waiter or a waitress. They do not earn much and have complete control over the card when given. That is a large trust factor there.

Fortunately, that has yet to happen... besides most people being good nature (I assume), maybe the tips help out.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I use a duct tape (because I'm an adult!) wallet that I made with a layer of tin foil. I thought the foil would help me with this sort of theft, but I never actually did any research to verify that idea. Does anybody know if it's actually helping me?

1

u/chunky_bacon May 20 '12

This is a huge problem, what with all the meth-head electrical engineers, hackers, and computer scientists running around.

1

u/silentseba May 20 '12

This is just a video for that guy to sell his special wallets >.>

1

u/Wolf_Farts May 20 '12

We Americans are so fat, swiping a card is now too exhausting for us.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

More RFID woo-woo. You can't scan a normal credit card remotely.

1

u/silentseba May 20 '12

Next up, thieves use cameras to steal your CC number.

1

u/ericishere May 20 '12

Where can I buy one? You know... for science!

1

u/CthulhuCompanionCube May 20 '12

The easiest way to counter this is just to have two RFID cards in your wallet. The signals get confused and the data can't be stolen. Problem solved.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/acommenter May 20 '12

Now we just need to invent a wallet that repels the wireless signal.

1

u/goodathiestyosef May 20 '12

Don't know about you guys, but that video kinda made me wanna become an identity thief

1

u/Pertinacious May 20 '12

There are instructions online for making duct tape wallets with aluminum foil lining.

It's a nice DIY solution without having to wrap your cards.

1

u/Daprotagonist May 20 '12

I would get suspicious when some guy wipes his iPad across my ass

→ More replies (1)

1

u/animousity692 May 20 '12

This was a bit too much of a how-to for me.

1

u/gadelat May 20 '12

Just put two or more cards in your wallet behind each other. It will interference with each other.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Is this like the chinese guy in Prison Break and his electronic blackhole?

1

u/gingerkid427 May 20 '12

How long have we known this, and how long have we had RFID proof wallets available to prevent this? This is nothing new.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

My wallet is an rfid blocker. It works and cost me 13 bucks. So, I'm good.

1

u/kplee May 20 '12

Little do they know, those sleeves transmit all the information to the creator! MUAHAH

1

u/Kdnce May 20 '12

Everyone should think about buying an RFID blocking wallet. They have them for passports as well so your passport cannot be tracked.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Radio frequencies are great - in fact superb - for transmitting/receiving cheezy pop and corny country songs. And astronomy. That is all.

I'm posting this from a wifi net and I know absolutely my mac address is hacked by a local zoo-cage of 4chan 'anonymous' faggy-boys.

1

u/IonOtter May 20 '12

To all those who are saying this is an "instructables for thieves", it's not.

The thieves knew about this the moment the patent/idea for using RFID chips was published. And even back in 2008, MythBusters tried to do it? But the entire sewage treatment plant hit the fan, and they didn't do it.

If MythBusters tried to cover it, then it'd been around for a long time already.

But this sort of thing is good for forcing the hand of the industry to improve their security. Not because it exposes the vulnerability, no. They don't give a crap about that, because it's in their best interests to let you get robbed this way. The CCC has insurance, you still have to pay $50, and if they can do a chargeback, then they get to keep the money on top of it all.

But when a story like this comes out, and 10, 20 or 50,000 people all start talking to each other on Facebook, Twitter and Reddit to compare notes and say, "Hey, let's start a class-action!"???

THAT is what forces the industry to improve their security.

1

u/BunnyPoppit May 20 '12

Technology man....

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

At last, an effective use for tinfoil hats!

1

u/elizabethmeredith May 20 '12

Does this ever actually happen? I feel like putting tin foil around your credit cards is just neurotic. One step away from a tin foil hat.

1

u/ebski94 May 20 '12

hate that accent...

1

u/Zagarth May 20 '12

nfc wireless is in my smart phones battery... don't need a scanner that way

1

u/honeyfage May 20 '12

Here's a question: I have 4 cards with RFID chips in them (bus pass, credit card, and two passkeys for work) in my wallet. If I try and scan the whole wallet at a reader, they seem to interfere with one another enough such that the scanners can't read it, so I have to take the relevant card out of the wallet and scan it. Does that mean one of these scanners a thief might use would also be unable to read them, or are they more sophisticated than the RFID scanners you find on buses and as locks on doors?

1

u/laikalost May 20 '12

"Oh my gawsh, dat is increduhble."

1

u/AnythingApplied May 20 '12

There are a number of ways for thieves to steal your credit card information and the only way you have to protect yourself is monitoring your account for fraudulent activity and notifying your credit card company in a timely fashion.

Even if you don't have RFID, a waitress you give your card to could swipe it in her own machine to record information. A conman could set up a fake til at a store. A shady vendor could just directly sell the information you provided to them.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

That 'security specialist' is going to make a fortune from this report.

1

u/Canada911 May 21 '12 edited Nov 04 '14

We just received our latest credit card with this "feature" this past week.

We asked for it to be "disabled" and they stated they couldn't.

What they (Credit Card Services) said was that they couldn't "disable" the feature but would send out a card without the RFID aspect.

Thank goodness!

1

u/frankhorriganlovesto May 21 '12

Unrelated I think all credit card swipes need to manually be in control of the users. It is time to stop having the card being taken from your sight or even be handled by employees. Sometimes when I was using my card at a reputable business the cashier was texting, and I was wondering if she was adept enough to capture my numbers per day.

1

u/kklusmeier May 20 '12

People can actually have this happen to them from hundreds of feet away if the setup is right.

(I saw an article on it, don't know where it went- somebody help me find it?)

→ More replies (3)