r/technology • u/Mind_Virus • May 19 '12
TED Talks: The Great Porn Experiment - Have our brains evolved to handle the hyperstimulation of today’s Internet enticements? Gary Wilson discusses the disturbing symptoms showing up in some heavy Internet users
http://www.youtube.com/watch?annotation_id=annotation_263672&src_vid=zif0_60b3WU&feature=iv&v=wSF82AwSDiU63
u/Dashukta May 19 '12
"endless novelty at a click"
That's one of the reasons I browse Reddit, actually--every page brings stuff I haven't seen before
5
May 20 '12
Internet addiction Is real. Very little research on this relatively new change in our enciornment.
7
u/lalalava May 20 '12
I dunno - where do you draw the line for where "endless novelty at a click" lies though? People have been saying the same thing about video games and TV way before the internet came around. Perhaps people were saying the same for radio and books too.
9
May 20 '12
They have been saying that and few studies have explored these as addictions.
I think that a more in depth look at porn addiction is warranted. There ARE young men suffering from erectile dysfunction in their 20's which is unheard of. Strange thing is these men can masturbate for hours but can't get off in actual sex. So the penis is fine but there's something going on in the brain.
WHAT?
I'm not knowledgeable enough in biology to say if dopamine is all that's involved in watching porn or definitively effected by habitual porn usage. judging from other posters validating that dopamine does work as stated porn usage could lead to addiction leading to erectile dysfunction.
The "novelty" aspect is simple. Men start with innocent enough porn until it loses the novelty factor and gradually escalate to harder more novel forms of porn. Anal, gangbang, bukkake, interracial, rape, bdsm, transgender, public.
This is not definitive as some people watch a lot of porn and do not show signs of copulatory impotence. I think it does hint at a reason for young men's sex problems and potentially set off a warning that porn can POSSIBLY be harmful to some.
I think your comparision to radio and books are not relevant.
→ More replies (6)6
u/Dashukta May 20 '12
Oh, yes. Certainly. And if we can get addicted to novelty--as the video implies--the endless novelty of Reddit means this site can be addictive.
I know I've seen some symptoms in my own behavior.
1
May 20 '12
This makes me want to get off the internet... But, I am on a 24 hour shift with nothing else to do...
I guess I can take a short break.
2
0
30
May 20 '12
Reddit is WAY more addicting than porn.
9
u/Thameus May 20 '12
I used to hit the porn tubes regularly. Then I discovered Reddit. Now I find that I have very little time for porn, or even porn on Reddit.
4
u/Asshole_Nord May 20 '12
I don't know whether to think reddit is great for getting rid of porn addictions, or even worse because it's more addicting than porn.
154
u/oshout May 19 '12
I feel less sexualized due to porn: "Oh, you want to hookup? NSA you say? No thanks, I get off all the time, I'm looking for a relationship with substance"
18
May 20 '12
That is an interesting way to see things, and actually quite healthy if you ask me.
2
May 20 '12
As a homo it kinda sucks. The sex option almost always comes before you even know if you like the guy enough to see him again.
The non-porn demo ends up treating actual people like porn; a method to get off and never see again.
→ More replies (1)1
May 21 '12
Me too. I'd end up in all sorts of situations with the predictable outcome of washing my cock in some randoms sink and sneaking out whilst
1
→ More replies (1)-57
May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
You lose an incentive to socialize with girls, i dont see what's good about that. After all the main reason men go after women is sexual, and if you remove the sexual, whats left is just what you think you should do. And then the only real incentive is what others think about you, ergo what society imposes upon you. And if you figure that out, apathy starts.
You really shouldnt kill something that basic about yourself, because of something "intellectual". Fuck, if i'd be in charge we'd all quit masturbating, and start burning that fire within us, that is sexual urges. It's a prime motivator to socialize, to compete, which directly leads to self-improvement.
Or you could just masturbate, and look at reddit all day
42
u/garja May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
Naturalistic fallacy! Just because something is natural, or "basic", or however you want to label it, does not mean it is necessarily good.
From my point of view, socialisation with girls is potentially improved by desexualisation. The primal motive can be replaced by a more intellectual one.
You have to bear in mind that sexuality "just kinda worked" for the human race. It isn't the optimal way to do something, just like any other evolved behaviour. The overall evolution of the human race has rapidly increased because we have taken over control of ourselves, and have been able to consciously optimise. Evolution is blind in comparison. We do not wait for evolution to slowly and haphazardly conquer a disease, we quarantine, we immunise, etc.
In the same way, a sexual motive is not necessarily the optimal motive for socialisation. Once our higher functions are more fully in control, we can be motivated to talk with people purely because they are interesting, worthwhile, productive, intelligent, etc. - we can focus on what is genuinely good about someone without the distracting sexual factor.
EDIT: My apologies in advance to the biologists/sociologists/historians/etc. out there if my generalisations have crossed the line. I don't think they have, but if that is the case, please correct me.
11
May 19 '12 edited May 20 '12
Naturalistic fallacy! Just because something is natural, or "basic", or however you want to label it, does not mean it is necessarily good.
right... technically, catholic Irish families that had dozens of children during the potato famine were "naturally good" even though life was harsh and short during that time because they eventually scattered to places like North America. Nature doesn't give a fuck about your quality of life; it only cares that you live well enough to reproduce.
I've often wondered if the massive fecundity exhibited by certain natural reproduction cycles are an external manifestation of some other larger meta pattern that guarantees reproduction... that is to say, massive quantities of offspring are expressed to simply serve as food to attract vectors.
48
u/oshout May 19 '12 edited May 20 '12
Those sound like some very ingrained opinions. You've also used some assumed generalizations to validate your argument.
After all the main reason men go after women is sexual
So how do gay men and straight women become friends? Are all women objects? Even the ones you hire? So if I'm a women, and a man hire's me, I can assume the possition I'm filling is sexual?
And the only reason left, after sexual, is that I care what others think of me? I strongly disagree with that. My life has been one of doing what I want and it being just. I'm successful when I'm truest to myself and the only time I fail is when I succumb to temptation or sacrifice myself in ways that I know shouldn't.
I agree that there is less incentive to socialize: I'm not so horned up that I'm willing to drink a beer and fuck with whatever will lay with me.
There is next to zero drama in my life. I went on a date the other day and found they are of schooling age but no desire to go to school, live with their parents, no job, no car, no prospects, or hobbies "just browse the internet on my iphone and watch tv" but they were sure to offer "I give great head!" and "you know what I want...". Fuck that!
I date, often. I get laid, next to never! I can count the number of people I've dated and liked on one hand. I haven't killed that basic part of myself: I am in control of my emotions and my time. I have so many hobbies, things to practice, read, and create. I'm out so often and coincidentally meeting people -- the kind you don't find waiting in a bar- I don't have time to bang every idiot that pats me on the shoulder and calls me baby.
And I do just masturbate and look at reddit all day, because I have a smart phone, buddy, and I'm able to read reddit anywhere!!!
→ More replies (6)9
u/warhead71 May 19 '12
People that don't have sex - still treat unattractive people like shit.
→ More replies (1)4
May 20 '12
You really shouldn't kill something that basic about yourself
Wants to abolish masturbation
→ More replies (6)6
u/pemboa May 19 '12
You lose an incentive to socialize with girls
I am not sure that that was the intent. I think the original intent of the incentive was to reproduce.
→ More replies (5)
99
May 19 '12
This is it. Now I'm gonna try that "try something new for 30 days". I don't really use porn, but i feel that the internet has fucked up my brain. I used to be creative. Write stuff, compose, write programs. Now I do nothing of the kind.
Good bye, pointless part of the internet.
6
May 20 '12
I won't go that far, but from now on I won't watch porn. This video has made me realize many things about myself.
12
19
u/noveltylife May 19 '12
Fuck it, I'm with this guy. This isn't doing anything for me as a person. I will however not go the distance like him and delete my account, I'd like to read those comments when I get old and wrinkly to see how I was.
9
u/DGIce May 20 '12
reddit is actually a great tool to see alot of things people are thinking about, and alot of new ideas. That said you get greatly diminishing returns. "everything is better in moderation" I hesitate to use this saying as it has an absolute in it, but it seems relevant. Some things are difficult to moderate.
2
u/noveltylife May 31 '12
I just thought I'd update someone on my progress. I sometimes feel a bad itch because I don't know what going on in the world around me as much. But on a personal level this was a great decision, met a girl, things are looking up, got extra hours at work, got to know my coworkers much better, fell in love with my job. For the first time in a long time I actually would care if I would die. I didn't have a death wish before but I just didn't care, now I do. Well, I'm off again.
→ More replies (2)8
1
0
May 19 '12
[deleted]
7
u/HathNoro May 20 '12
I took a reddit break last month. It actually wasn't that hard, despite the fact that I've been a daily visitor for years.
2
27
6
u/SpineBuster May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Hold on a second. The college kid around 13:00 was talking about he had been diagnosed with ADD, social anxiety, poor memory, etc because of his porn addiction? I don't ever look at poor but I have been diagnosed with these same exact things. Maybe its because I'm addicted to something else. Edit: Oh god it dawned on me... Too much gaming and senseless internet browsing for the past 20 years has ruined my brain. I am fixing this RIGHT NOW..
49
u/jmnugent May 19 '12
I realize my own personal experience is anecdotal,.. but i"m not sure I agree with Gary Wilson's causation/correlation. I've been consuming porn in various mediums for decades,.. and I'm not having any trouble getting an erection. It doesn't negatively interfere with my social relationships.
Watching the video, I get the uneasy feeling that the research got short-sighted and fell to easy to confirming results they expected to see,.. instead of simply presenting data and avoiding implying any causation/connections. (IE = how do you scientifically prove that an increase in Internet-Porn is THE ONLY reason a person can't get an erection ?... maybe the reason is they spend to much time in a chair (reduced bloodflow) and not enough time exercising. )
10
u/cold_water May 20 '12
I have been a huge fan of porn since about age 8 or so and have progressively engaged in more and more porn until this current 'golden age' where we have all the free, streaming porn we could desire. I have masturbated heavily from grade 1 onwards. Zero problems with erections. I have been with the same chick for about 2 years and will get an erection when I'm on the phone with her despite already having masturbated that day. If there is an attractive girl near me or even simply within vision, I will probably get hard. This problem is not caused by porn.
All that said, I am going to go cold-turkey. He's right - it's pretty unnatural. I don't need it to get myself off and I suspect it really does have undesired consequences. All the most high-energy times of my life have been when I have tried avoiding it. I am going to pursue that energy. Wish me luck!
3
18
u/mariox19 May 20 '12
Well, there's two things I would like to comment on. First, by "decades," if you mean more than two, then you fall into the group he talked about when he talked about the experience of older men when they quit porn. Of course, I'm going to assume you're not suffering from erectile dysfunction, so I don't mean to say that you fall into that group directly. But that brings me to my second point. You talk about "various mediums." He stressed that the Internet as a medium for porn consumption is qualitatively different. It is much more likely to cause addiction. And that brings me back to my first point.
Young guys' brains are forming. If you're watching Internet porn during your formative years, it's going to have a different effect on your brain. That's what you (and I—I'm 45, by the way) missed. I don't think he's saying that porn's effect is the same over 100% of a population, even if you restrict that population to a single generation. Not everyone becomes an alcoholic from drinking, nor a stoner from using pot. But some people will. I listened to the talk and took from it that Internet porn is statistically more harmful for everyone, and particularly more harmful for those who begin watching it when they're young.
8
u/jmnugent May 20 '12
"Internet porn is statistically more harmful for everyone,.. particularly the young"
I'm still not sure I buy it. (not without some seriously peer-reviewed and cross-blind confirmed scientifically proven data).
In my mind,.. there's far to many random variables to conclude any outcome with predictability.
If a 13yr old male watches 2 minutes of porn a day.. is that "to much" ? Does it depend on what kind of porn it is ? (softcore, hardcore, human actors? animation/CGI ? )
Does it matter what culture/background he comes from ? What upbringing/social-status he's from ? What kind of education or amount of non-computer activities he's involved in ?
You could make an argument that alcohol is statistically more harmful to the young,.. but the end-result/effect on particular individuals is going to vary wildly by some of the factors I listed.
6
u/psiphre May 20 '12
replace porn with cigarettes and see if the sentiment changes.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Malician May 20 '12
This is all very nice (in the sense that it's a cool story, though not as good as Game of Thrones), but I'd rather prefer he provided some scientific backing or other empirical evidence which extends past his ability to compose yarns.
5
May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I think it really depends on the person.
Some people can eat something delicious but stop when they had enough. Others don't until they've gorged themselves too full to walk.
Likewise, there are some people who are always on time, while others always seem to procrastinate no matter what.
Night owls vs. Larks, alcoholics vs. social drinkers, etc... some folks are affected by too much porn while others aren't.
→ More replies (6)7
May 20 '12
I think it's less "porn causes kills erections" and more "jerking off too much kills erections." Porn just makes jerking off easier.
5
May 20 '12
Also perhaps the level of arousal you need to get an erection increases as your exposure to porn becomes greater.
→ More replies (1)3
u/wazoox May 20 '12
I've jerked off nearly every day since I was 9 more than 30 years ago, and it certainly didn't kill anything but sperms.
Back then, when all roads were uphill both ways, we had to fap to boring stuff such as magazines (they didn't even move, for chrissake!), I fapped to the memories of my naked aunts at the beach. I even fapped to scantily clothed girls in comics or art books. Yes your Honour, I fapped to Rubens masterpieces when I was 12. It was that bad.
To get back into subject, think we must make a difference between the guy who faps (i.e. absolutely everyone) and the one who spends 3 hours a day watching at porn. The psychological impact probably differs.
1
May 20 '12
it's a bit of both. Jerking off too much causes a lower sex drive, but also, watching lots of porn can cause that arousal addiction which leads you to want newer material..
how often do you watch the same porn video? how often do you have sex with the same girl?
if you get used to getting sexually aroused by something new every single time you do it, it becomes harder to get as sexually aroused by something you've already seen, the more you see it the more predictable it gets, the less interesting it becomes etc etc. Same thing ends up happening with real sex, if you're in a relationship etc
9
2
3
May 19 '12
Interesting. Always keep in mind that one person is not a sufficient sample to say anything other than ____ is possible.
I dont think this talk is suggesting it is universally true.
5
u/jmnugent May 19 '12
"I dont think this talk is suggesting it is universally true. "
No.. but the presentation seems a little "1-sided" .. and the YBOP website seems written in a style that seems predicated on the belief that porn-addiction is some unavoidable eventuality.
6
May 19 '12
Maybe we are just so addicted that we won't admit it ;)
I'll admit that I watch an average of 1.2GB of Mario Kart themed midget pornography per week but I can stop any time I want to!!!
1
May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I think it's more the, you get addicted to getting (psychological) arousal so you seek it everywhere, things that you're used too (such as having sex with your partner) can become old and boring, almost like watching an episode of simpsons over and over, so you prefer the alternative, in this case the alternative to actually having sex with your SO is watching porn you've never seen before.
that sort of arousal addiction can make social situations feel awkward not because you are socially awkward, but because the amount of people in one setting and, unless you're all in a large group you can only really partake with a few people at a time
I for one jump around between various groups and can't find any coherent way to stick to one or another when i'm in those sort of situations, the awkwardness is caused by trying to be involved with everything at once, the problem is then you're not actually connected with the situation you're more just observing, which feels really awkward; if that makes sense. I used to think I was just socially awkward, but this talk makes me think it could be caused by arousal addiction in general, but i'm not going to jump to that conclusion until I test it out.
I don't think he's implying "if you watch porn every day you're going to lose your ability to gain an erection", obviously the syptoms of addiction will vary greatly between person to person, but I personally notice that I have an unusually low libido myself, if my girlfriend offered me sex right now i'd probably turn it down
1
u/jmnugent May 20 '12
That's funny,.. because I don't look at it from an "arousal" perspective at all.
I look at it from a information-richness perspective.
The thing that spoils me about the internet is it's granular nature.. and that I can search/sort/filter and remix the information I'm looking for into a rich and contextually useful result(s) that help me achieve whatever goal I'm trying to achieve.
The same cannot be said for social interactions. You have to deal with all the inefficiencies of human-interaction.
The social/polite expectations (introductions, shaking hands, small talk, etc,etc... IE = pointless bullshit that doesn't get me any closer to my goal).
You have to deal with slowness, mistakes, oversights, people being uncooperative (or outright working against my goals)
You have to deal with politics, drama, coworkers missing due to sickness, pregnancy, etc.
I hate all that shit. I really do. It's a rare but delightful thing to randomly meet a stranger who's intelligent, resourceful, efficient and pleasureable to be around because they cut out all the bullshit and get down to accomplishing things.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)1
u/hated_dil May 20 '12
the purpose of these studies are more to show that excessive use does these things....like 12hrs a day of watching porn straight and watching all videos end-to-end.
Im ashamed to say I dated a guy like this and I hated his guts, so naturally I stole his weed and...well...his friends only hung out with him because he had a house to smoke at.
→ More replies (1)
5
153
u/EagleFalconn May 19 '12
There is no science in this talk.
The correct response to not having a control group is to shrug your shoulders and say "Huh. I have no idea how big the effect I'm seeing is." Not "OH MY GOD PORN IS RUINING OUR CHILDREN."
104
u/kru5h May 20 '12
To be fair, it's not attempting to be a scientific stance. It's a case study to determine if real studies are merited. He comes to the conclusion that there seems to be some merit, develops a hypothesis, and would like to see some actual studies done.
→ More replies (1)78
u/EagleFalconn May 20 '12
Then he should really choose his words more carefully and not be so cavalier about what studies and controls do and don't exist.
→ More replies (2)21
55
u/i-hate-digg May 20 '12
I will freely admit that watching porn has changed me in ways I probably don't know, but this talk is nothing but alarmism. He cites multiple studies and none of them support his claims - especially his claims about porn addiction causing depression and anxiety. His appeals to evolution should set off the bullshit detectors of any serious scientist.
I'm not saying there's nothing to worry about. It might turn out that he's right! I'm just saying his claims are unsupported.
There was a similar scenario when 'reefer madness' came out. Lots of alarmism and unsubstantiated claims, appealing to people's emotions. What inevitably happens is that you get a backlash when people realize that it's not true, hurting your cause.
18
u/Nucleonic May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Agreed. The correlation of depression and anxiety to internet porn usage may simply be a manifestation of the average heavy porn consumer being single and at least somewhat socially isolated. Porn may be providing an artificial release that dampens the urge to rectify the parent problem, hence the whole "I gave up internet porn and it saved my life" mumbo-jumbo. For a person in that situation internet porn could become a sort of self-medication that perpetuates unhealthy social habits for that person, while the porn if consumed by someone in a healthier social situation would not have much or any negative effects.
This is a topic that deserves more research though, undeniably internet porn does provide stimuli the brain historically has not dealt with. I know that for myself it has seemed to have made me more discriminating about women I'm considering a long-term relationship with (an observation raised by a female friend that I would tend to agree with.) Put simply, I'm more willing to pass up opportunities in that regard for faults that without the "backup" of internet porn I would be more willing to compromise.
8
May 20 '12
Did you watch the video? Fast forward to 10:07
40
u/EagleFalconn May 20 '12
I did watch the video. The "Survey by the Italian Society of Andrology and Sexual Medicine" hardly qualifies as a scientific evaluation.
Notice his language at 10:42 "This study confirms what we've seen for years"...he's got a bias built in. He's got a really strong hypothesis about dopamine acclimation but seemingly very little actual data.
Why is internet porn fundamentally different from Playboy? 11:40 "Because we've never seen ED is young men before." That's a hell of an assumption.
I think his anecdote about how a guy quitting porn took care of his psychological issues is adorable (and dumb), but also not science.
"All these guys are trying to quit porn! There must be something wrong!"
"Older guys get their hard-on back faster. Must be causation because they started fapping to internet porn later in life!"
→ More replies (3)3
u/hisham_hm May 20 '12
The "Survey by the Italian Society of Andrology and Sexual Medicine" hardly qualifies as a scientific evaluation
Why not?
10
u/deathadder99 May 20 '12
A survey does not have a control group. It's useful evidence yes, but it doesn't account for other factors in the people's lives that a full blown experiment would. E.G if you had a survey that asked how happy you were and how much you looked at porn, if for example you'd had your heart broken by someone then you'd be sad and probably look at more porn than usual, and they would look at that and go, oh, that guy is sad BECAUSE of porn.
20
u/rook2pawn May 20 '12
why are people faulting this presentation? A TED talk is not given like a math proof. What sort of TED talks qualify as "science" to you?
Precisely what was incorrect to you? I can claim light is both a wave and a particle without having to explain it and it can still be a science based talk.
Not having a control group and still trying to find meaningful answers isn't "not science", and the correct response isn't "OH WE CANT DO ANYTHING BECAUSE WE DONT HAVE A CONTROL GROUP." In fact, he finds a pseduo control group later on in the video.
Anyways, I feel like im responding to a troll.
→ More replies (2)9
u/EagleFalconn May 20 '12
Not having a control group and still trying to find meaningful answers isn't "not science"
No control = Not science. Its, like, in the definition.
6
u/yqx May 20 '12
No control = Not science. Its, like, in the definition.
I'm late to the party but I feel like there is a misunderstanging of science among redditors.
The guy that gives the talk makes a number of observations about internet porn. He presents a reasonable hypothesis about the observations (internet porn is addictive) that he proceeds to back up by solid argumentation, every step of his argument is falsifiable. Perhaps the slightly sensationalist rhetorics he uses is a bit distracting but it's ignorant to say this isn't science.
If you don't agree with his argument you are free to try and reproduce and falsify any step of his argument and prove him wrong, because that is what science is all about: having discussions, backing up your claims by arguments and proving each other wrong.
EDIT: wording
6
u/Omikron May 20 '12
Just because the talk has "experiment" in the title, doesn't mean it was a rigorous scientific endeavor. Doesn't make it any less interesting.
→ More replies (1)2
u/blahblahbro May 20 '12
know how i know you're not a scientists?
brb telling astrophysicists they're not scientists
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (3)14
u/rook2pawn May 20 '12
A control group is for the purpose of validating an experiment conducted by the experimenters. The phrase "The Great Porn Experiment" ... sigh i cant believe im having to explain this....... Is simply a study on a social phenomena, not an ACTUAL EXPERIMENT. You're hung up on the wording of the TITLE OF THE TALK and your logic chips have completely misfired.
Its a turn of phrase!!!! For fucks sake.
24
u/EagleFalconn May 20 '12
He makes scientific claims in the talk that are not backed by science. Much of the talk is his (or someone's) hypothesis that dopamine acclimation caused by rapid-fire porn etc etc. He's not a scientist, he's a gym teacher. The only data he has to support his hypothesis, which he makes no attempt to state as a hypothesis but only as fact, is all anecdote, which is not scientifically admissable.
I'm all for doing a study. Lets do a study about the effects of porn on the brain. But misrepresenting what we already know doesn't serve any benefits.
→ More replies (4)2
u/Biskwikman May 20 '12
I agree, he's being pretty biased and overtly hinting that porn is bad considering that there's no evidence of that anywhere.
→ More replies (2)1
u/tcquad May 20 '12
You're saying that highlighting the benefits experienced by a self-selected group of addicts who quit something that was disrupting their lives... isn't science?
Darn it. I was going to submit a TED talk with alcohol substituted for porn. Then another one with food. Then I was just going to start going down a list of "everything in the universe" until I'm giving all the TED talks everywhere.
14
11
4
u/BoredandIrritable May 20 '12 edited Aug 28 '24
squeamish busy fuel employ snatch pie scary versed ring squalid
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
14
May 19 '12
Hardcore user of porn for the past 12 years here. I have never had Erectile Disfunction or something that comes close to that. I have however had a hard time cumming, and only after 1~ year with the with the same partner I could cum in less than 15 minutes (while still using porn when I was alone). Yeah sure, this is all anectdotal, I just don't think ED will ever become a problem for me even though I masturbate 3 times a day.
It does however exhaust me. I'm tired and work bores me. I think this video made me want to stop masturbating. Not saying I'm a prodigy with lots of untapped potential, but I definitely have tones more potential than my current lifestyle allows. Tere's so much I want to do with my life. Alright, just signed up for /r/NoFap. Let's see where this takes me.
5
8
16
u/blahblah1984 May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Im confused, how can looking at porn be any different than imagining naked women doing sexual acts? When I was growing up, if I didnt have access to the internets, I would simply use my imagination, I mean, the little mermaid did inconceivable things in my head that I have yet to find online.
I am more inclined to believe that people who spend prolonged time on the internets, especially with sites that have quick reward mechanisms are likely to suffer from the same effects he described rather than attributing it to porn.
clicks on to the next topic
14
u/jmnugent May 20 '12
"I mean, the little mermaid did inconceivable things in my head that I have yet to find online."
Google Image Search (safesearch turned OFF) for "Little Mermaid porn" returns about 1,380,000 results (0.12 seconds).
Rule 34 in effect.
3
u/hated_dil May 20 '12
the men they refer to watch the long half hour videos end-to-end and don't stop watching after cumming. they just watch it all day long.
these people exist, I have met them, they suck. they hate women.
3
2
u/omnomtom May 20 '12
I think the assumption is that in a given fap session powered by imagination, a guy will probably only imagine one or two females, but that in a porn fap session he'll see more... The focus is on the variety of mates the brain is thinking it's getting. And I can see that being an argument, but speaking for myself, once I discovered high quality free long form videos, my average porn fap session only involves one or two women too, so the validity of that assumption as applying to all internet porn is strained.
4
u/pcgamer4life May 20 '12
"constant novelty to click can cause addiction" This explains reddit addiction.
4
4
2
u/Zarutian May 20 '12
Hmm.. so there might be more yet to be classified addictions.
One that comes to mind is sports and or approval addiction. I have seen in various articles on straight-edge guys fall into substance abuse be it alcahol, marjuana, nicotine, cocaine and so on. Now, I have an untested hypothesis that such guys arent falling into addiction but merely changing how they satisfy the urge to exult or get high to a mechanism that short circuits the effort needed.
2
2
2
2
u/WatdeeKhrap May 20 '12
well i think that explains my problems pretty well. Time to make a life change.
2
u/spiz May 20 '12
He thinks internet porn is the most likely thing to cause addiction. He has yet to visit reddit.
2
u/machete234 May 20 '12
Do you have to quit only internet porn or also masturbation? The thing with no fap is that Im not convinced its really good for you or that this is your normal state etc...
Im thinking of not watching or seeking porn for a month or two and this is also the phase of my exams so this could boost my energy a little.
If I have to fap I will do it like 15 years ago using (OMG!!!) my mind.
6
May 20 '12
As an avid porn-watching female, I'm not sure how to feel about this talk. In general, women have a much harder time learning how to make themselves orgasm (something like even only 30% can during sex?), and I feel like porn + masturbation really helped me learn about myself and what I like. In a way, I think internet porn gives people a lot of freedom - not only do you learn a lot about yourself, but it also helps people explore who wouldn't otherwise (people living in isolated places, people of different cultures, women, etc).
I do suffer from much of what he says - multiple tab syndrome, always wanting new, shocking, novel material, etc. I have a healthy sexual relationship though. He makes it out to be a solely young male issue. So what am I supposed to take away from this talk...?
4
u/planarshift May 20 '12
I thought the same thing... The talk was focused solely on heterosexual males, which really limited its effectiveness. Some of the information was interesting, and I'm sure that the internet IS changing how our brains are wired, but unfortunately there was little substance in what was basically an anti-porn talk.
7
4
3
May 20 '12
All of those symptoms describe me dead-on. Been watching porn for 10 years now:
Can't remember shit
Low attention span
Always depressed or numb except when watching porn
Fuck I need to stop.
1
May 20 '12
Seriously, same here. This shit has me convinced. I know it'll be difficult and I probably won't stop all together, but I'm going to stop.
5
u/Someguy7723 May 19 '12
I started consuming Porn at age 15. Before that time I was class president in middle school and got extremely high grades.Since age 15 I don't think I went without masturbating for more than 3 weeks at a time. I find I am the least productive when I have high speed internet access to look at video porn, and in general since age 15 and the realization of my penis I have not been very productive. Hmmm...Maybe I'll quit porn
→ More replies (6)12
3
u/skynetadmin May 19 '12
He mentions reddit! http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=wSF82AwSDiU#t=813s
2
u/Turil May 19 '12
6
u/Taenk May 19 '12
I am not sure why he mentions NoFap, since there is a seperate subreddit for quitting porn. In his talk, too, he does not talk about masturbation, only porn,
3
u/Jakeypoos May 19 '12
Porn is only a visual aphodisiac. It's like food. There are lots of different types and different ways to use it with different results. There's junk and stuff that's awesome. If porn exites your imagination to produce fantasies then it's good. If your just watching you might need more and more intense stimuli but you might not. Everyones different. Masturbation isn't shameful it's awsome, solo or partnered with or without various types of porn across all sexes and genders. A talk on the positive effects of awesome porn is what we need.
→ More replies (5)
2
u/dantethepilgrim May 20 '12
Holy shit. I never thought I'd say this...but I'm quitting porn.
Starting in 15 minutes.
2
2
u/fattyBoombalattie May 20 '12
After finding info like this through research into my own "bedroom problems", I am in the process of a brain "reboot". No porn, No masturbation, and as little fantasy as possible. I had gotten so used to internet porn that I was unable to perform when I found my current girlfriend. The secondary effect of my constant dependence on porn for gratification is that I didn't realize my porn tastes had gotten more and more extreme and my need for extreme porn to orgasm had taken away any non internet masturbation. It is not easy and I still feel the need to fall back to internet porn but in the time that I have been off porn I have increased my sexual performance with my girlfriend exponentially. It was not easy but it has payed off already and prompted me to continue down the road to freedom from porn.
2
1
u/batsies May 20 '12
As a woman in the dating world I would completely agree with this video. Sometimes I wonder, is it me? But honestly so many guys I run into don't know how to handle relationships, and once your sex lives evolve its obvious he is addicted to internet porn. When they start asking you to do harder and harder things, you start to wonder if there was ever any attraction or are you just there to fulfill the fantasy. I have hope that some guys are different, but until I find one........
8
u/jmnugent May 20 '12
I think you're probably just falling for confirmation-bias. (the video proves what you already believe.)
You don't say what you're age is,.. but I'm gonna guess late teens or somewhere-20's. (fairly safe bet since that's the demographic of Reddit).
The type of relationship struggles you describe (people not knowing how to have healthy relationships) is fairly typical for that age,.. and you're going to find a higher sample size of humans who aren't yet fully sexually mature/experienced enough to know what's appropriate sexual behavior.
TL;DR... don't be so quick to jump to the conclusion that "its Porns fault".
→ More replies (9)2
May 20 '12
Wow you sound like a barrel of laughs.
Ever thought that maybe the problem was you instead of trying to find something bigger to blame your own relationship failings on.
→ More replies (2)3
May 20 '12
So because guys you date are into kinky shit they are addicted to porn?
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (9)1
u/I_Am_Treebeard May 20 '12
There's a lot of psychology behind why we are attracted the kinds of people we are attracted to. It says more about you that you date people like that than it says about men in general. I watch porn almost everyday, I'm conservative in the bedroom and not bored or unsatisfied with regular everyday sex.
2
u/brutallyhonest1 May 20 '12
Lots of comments about how porn is ruining dating/relationships. I'm reminded of the Futurama edutainment film "don't date robots".
When I was in the dating scene my lack of success was legendary. As if I was unable to get a date to save my life. Came close once, but then about 30 minutes before I was to pick her up she called and just said she changed her mind. Not that something came up, just that she didn't want to go out on a date with my anymore.
I was miserable. If I had unlimited access to porn I would have just given up and been much happier. If there had been a pill that I could have taken that would have eliminated all urges in me forever I would have taken it in a heartbeat because as a misfit loser reject from society wanting to score with some hot babe was a daily misery.
So porn gets men to lock themselves in their rooms and not go out and date. So NSA self satisfaction prevents girls from using and abusing the guys for free dinners, leading guys on or worse. So what? Don't really care and all of those girls out there who revel in their cruelty and laugh amongst their friends. Let them go without picking up some future child support donor. They don't respect guys anyway - nobody really does, that's why almost every single commercial you see portrays the guy as some stupid oaf and the girl as the heroine of every situation.
→ More replies (4)1
May 20 '12
If there had been a pill that I could have taken that would have eliminated all urges in me forever I would have taken it in a heartbeat because as a misfit loser reject from society wanting to score with some hot babe was a daily misery.
It's called castration
1
u/BloodyNobody May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I went five days without masturbating last week and definitely noticed a difference. For one thing I was actually excited about things for a change (I'm usually indifferent). I even felt like working out more.
Maybe I'm just getting old at 24?
1
u/abcruz52 May 20 '12
im not goin to lie i watch a whole lot of porn but after watching this im going to cut back until i can quit
1
1
u/stox May 20 '12
As predicted in Videodrome:
Nicki Brand: Well, I think we live in overstimulated times. We crave stimulation for its own sake. We gorge ourselves on it. We always want more, whether it's tactile, emotional or sexual. And I think that's bad.
Max Renn: Then why did you wear that dress?
Nicki Brand: Sorry?
Max Renn: That dress. It's very stimulating.
[looks at Rena]
Max Renn: And it's red. You know what Freud would've said about that dress.
Nicki Brand: And he would've been right. I admit it. I live in a highly excited state of overstimulation.
Max Renn: Listen, I'd really like to take you out to dinner tonight
1
1
1
1
1
u/CalebEX May 20 '12
"a Dutch study claims that out of all the things on the Internet, porn has the greatest potential to become an addiction"
..... Obviously never heard of reddit.
1
May 20 '12
Porn is not "evil" in and of itself, but it can be addicting. All things being equal, people have a causal relationship with their own addictions, and a corresponding responsibility to overcome them. Like I did with mine.
I'd find this even more disturbing if I were involved in the production of adult material. Imagine being a tobacco farmer right around the time researchers initially published data linking smoking to lung cancer. ED is certainly not cancer, but neither is this good PR for a struggling industry.
1
May 20 '12
Does this research have validity? If so then I know why I'm so bad with women even though my friends think I'm a chick magnet. I'm always pretty awkward around girls and avoid eye contact, but when I actually have nights of confidence I can get laid easily. I've always wondered why I couldn't pick up women consistently. I watch porn once a day, but now I'm gonna stop. This now gives me some hope for future success! Sweet!
I really hope this isnt just some bogus religious crap.
1
1
u/ScratchfeverII May 21 '12
I watched until
Obese ie addicted to food
and I stopped. Even if he's right about everything else, lumping in fat with an addiction or disruptive compulsive behavior (think gambling addittion or eating disorders, not cleaning your plate) isn't A> Scientific B> helpful C> furthering his point.
Oh well, Still got my ice cream.
1
u/blackpanther6389 Jul 25 '12
Could someone tell me if the focus was on masturbating less or watching porn less, or both?
1
u/confusing_alanogy May 20 '12
Wait wait wait. WAIT. TED thinks this guy is worth airing and the income inequality guy isn't? Well fuck this shit.
→ More replies (1)1
1
u/frankhorriganlovesto May 20 '12
Hyperstimulation seems like an invented word, but Hypersexuality is a somewhat clinically accepted term, see DSM-V provided.
1
u/bigmike00831 May 20 '12
wouldn't hurt to try to stop. i do notice nights i dont fap the next day i feel more confident and over all happier. though iam not on any pills or anything i feel like i suffer from anxiety. i think i rather quit then die alone.
1
u/LouisCKsDarkHalf May 20 '12
Dear Mind_Virus,
Can you tell me if my pretty continual urge to have anal sex with my SO is based on my being essentially brainwashed by modern day's easy access to niche porn, or if it's just because I'm a dirty bastard.
Sincerly,
LouisCksDarkHalf
PS - I've been loving your posts for the better part of a year now, keep up the good work.
1
1
u/deargodimbored May 20 '12
I watch allot of porn( five days out of six, sometimes three videos in one day). I still like chicks that aren't tens, and prefer real women to fake.
Porn just makes getting one out, once a day to clear the head, or get to sleep easier, Sometimes I prefer to do the old grip exercises with just my imagination.
I've had times with broken latops, where I couldn't watch porn and I was fine. What I think could be bad, is the next generation may not learn how to self release without media.
1
u/Silverkarn May 20 '12
I am done with internet porn....
I am actually starting to get some of the symptoms he is describing. No ED yet, but i'm gonna quit before its too late.
-3
-1
u/blackpanther6389 May 20 '12
Eh I don't know how much of that I could agree with. It's an interesting thought. I find my unluckiness with women due to the things I talk about which isn't typical for the average woman, or man for that matter. Most people are involved in their own self-centered goals that has nothing to do with the natural order of things and so when people don't want to talk about that stuff, I tend to get wrote off.
I've noticed that I'm still highly attracted to women when I'm attempting to hide my boner. And I make every attempt at hitting on women but as I've said, I'm attractive, but I talk about things that no women, that I've met so far, wants to get into, ever.
Perhaps my slight addiction to internet porn has led to a slow down of activity, but I also attribute my lack of motivation in certain areas due to the rapid decline of humanity that I make every attempt at letting my friends and family know about @_@.
People seem to want sex for a price and I'm not down with that shit, until then, my incredibly high libido will be saved for the novelty hot chicks on the screen...
-5
May 20 '12
A few responses:
I'm an amoral atheist. I don't believe in right or wrong, really. I believe in "beneficial to the species" and "not beneficial to the species." And you know what? I concluded that the pornification of the developed world was really, really bad for the species a few years ago, and I think it's only getting worse as I see more guys (especially, but girls too) who grew up with high-speed internet access entering adulthood. We are playing around with the fundamental mechanism by which we continue as a species, and although I don't think that people are going to go extinct, I also don't think that the saturation of society with porn is helpful, either. --And this video puts all of my specific concerns out there in an authoritative and well-cited way. Bravo.
The biggest change that I see, as a guy who was in his 20s when broadband finally took off, is that people younger than me have what I consider very strange ideas about sex. I'm not saying "wrong" or "bad," but to someone who stands on the border between pre-porn society (of course it existed, but as this video shows, nothing like it is now), definitely "weird." The choices of porn producers have influenced real-world sex, because a lot of people entering adulthood these days were first introduced to sex by way of porn--and not like people in my generation were, with porno mags smuggled out of someone's dad's stash or the occasional dumpster dive jackpot, but with hardcore video--harder and weirder all the time. I see these things come up on Reddit all the time, and I and other people my age or older are routinely shouted down for pointing out things like the following:
Shaved pubes are not normal. They are not "clean" (in fact, they're dirty and prone to infection). The idea that people--especially women--should be bald down there is a porn idea. That's where it came from. Specifically, it came from Penthouse magazine, which needed something to differentiate themselves from the much-classier and more-established Playboy, and the shock-porn rag Hustler. It gives a better view of the vulva, etc., and it's weird and kinky, so it worked. A dumpster dive that turned up a Penthouse was cause for neighborhood-wide celebration, because 10-year-olds hiding in the bushes at the park could finally get an idea of what was actually going on down there. It was a kink, and a way to sell magazines. No one really expected people to actually do that. Fast forward to the age of internet porn, where the race for novelty happens at breakneck speed, and girls lost their pubes within years of the medium getting really started, and in recent years, the guys have followed suit... And so have otherwise normal people, to the extent that when people come over her to Japan and go to an onsen (hot springs baths), they are shocked to see pubes--unshaven, unwaxed, usually un-trimmed. I.e. they are shocked to see what, until very recently, was the default condition of everyone's genitalia. Now, if you like it, more power to you, but it is weird. It is not normal. It is just something that porn producers started doing to get better shots of the equipment.
Talking during sex, announcing what you're doing, and going through a set of predetermined phrases is not normal. It's just something porn producers do so that you don't get bored watching the same stupid shit over and over, and to drive home the point that these people are fucking. Never in my life have I heard anything but moaning, whimpering, grunting, and other non-linguistic orations during sex. Maybe some whispered instructions or sweet nothings. Again, I don't think it's wrong or anything; I just think it's something that people learned from porn and thought was normal, like it was just something that happened during sex. I don't even understand what's supposed to be sexy about it. If you can still string together a fully-formed, grammatically-correct sentence, well, I'm not doing my job very well, am I? Like Gary Wilson says in the video, asking someone who grew up with porn if it has affected his sexual behavior is like asking a fish what he thinks about water. Again, standing on the border between pre-porn and post-porn, the difference in what is considered normal sexual behavior is striking.
Rough, misogynistic sex is not normal. I don't care how anyone tries to rationalize it; the vast, vast majority of porn is virulently misogynistic. But because we now have a generation who was first introduced to sex via porn, and who has become sexualized under its influence, sex that no woman would agree to 10 years ago is viewed as normal sexual behavior now. Again, I'm not saying it's wrong, and I'm all for consenting adults doing whatever they like, but the difference is striking.
Throughout this post, I have used the word "normal," but that is not intended to imply that what is not "normal" is "wrong." When I say "normal," I'm talking about historically, specifically as it has been at least since the sexual revolution. Growing up before the internet and before broadband and before the ubiquity of porn, and seeing the changes that those things have made to society and to individuals' behavior, the difference is hard to overstate.
Ladies and (especially) gentlemen: Porn is not real. It's a product designed to get you hooked. Step away from it for awhile and explore the real world. It's cool and fun and beautiful in ways you can't imagine. You don't have to act or think like the human mannequins in the vids.
→ More replies (1)10
u/psiphre May 20 '12
what you say about pubic hair is simply untrue. the shaving of pubic hair has been in and out of style in nearly every culture in history.
1
0
May 20 '12
I do several things to prevent such addictions...
First, I have sex with someone at least once as week. Usually more.
Second, I read erotic fiction instead of viewing porn most of the time.
Third, I utilize softcore images/videos sometimes.
Fourth, I explore fetishes, both with others and by myself.
Fifth, I utilize sex toys.
Sixth, I utilize a variety of porn from various sources.
Seventh, I abstain from all sexual activity for several days.
Eighth, I actively rotate as to what I do to get off, utilizing the above.
TL;DR I'm addicted.
0
0
May 20 '12
I came here (no pun intended) searching for an excuse to continue fapping. Reddit did not disappoint, apprently this is bullshit and I can continue fapping twice a day!
335
u/ilovebeats365 May 20 '12
"Constant novelty in a click can cause addiction." I've never heard Reddit be explained so well!