r/technology • u/DrJulianBashir • May 16 '12
Pirate Bay Under DDoS Attack From Unknown Enemy
http://torrentfreak.com/pirate-bay-under-ddos-attack-from-unknown-enemy-120516/1.6k
May 16 '12
The "DDOS attack" is people refreshing the page to see if a Diablo 3 server emulator has been released.
461
u/Ulairi May 16 '12
I'm sure it also doesn't help that everytime someone brings up a site being down on reddit we all flood the page to see for ourselves.
→ More replies (1)171
u/thenuge26 May 16 '12
Nothing like a good slashdotting of a site already struggling along, huh?
25
u/jordanovichTH May 16 '12
"Hey I hear Noah has no room on the ark!" "You're kidding...let's check...just to make sure."
8
11
u/borkedhelix May 16 '12 edited May 17 '12
It's so interesting that the term slashdotted is still used. I used it the other day, and realized that it's been who knows how many years it's been since I last read slashdot.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (72)22
37
u/cyferwolf May 16 '12
Shit... byt the time I got to the end of all the comments for this thread I forgot it was actually a discussion about the pirate bay being down.
94
u/Neato May 16 '12
D3 hasn't been cracked yet? I'm surprised. Took only a day or two for SC2, and a week for one of the better groups to realize a better crack was needed.
225
May 16 '12
The crack isn't the problem. Diablo 3 works like an MMO you can't play it without a server. So I guess they're going to release a server emulator to make it pirateable.
161
u/Neato May 16 '12
So there's absolutely no offline game? They essentially made D3 where you were always playing on Bnet in a multiplayer game?
222
u/Mutericator May 16 '12
Yes. Even if you're playing a private, single-player mode.
→ More replies (295)→ More replies (28)39
u/JaxMed May 16 '12
Yeah, there was actually a huge shitstorm because the login servers were down during the first few hours of the game's release. So people bought the game, brought it home, installed it, and then couldn't play it. Not even singleplayer.
→ More replies (77)→ More replies (15)4
u/root88 May 16 '12
Even with an emulator, someone will need to code all the encounters.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
u/ramp_tram May 16 '12
It can't be 'cracked,' because so much of the game relies on the servers.
That being said, there is a group that had a working emulator for the beta, they just never publicly released it.
→ More replies (4)5
149
May 16 '12
It's working fine here in the UK.
24
u/JUST_LOGGED_IN May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
USA reporting in. This link works fine for me.
Update: I've seen this page go down a few times. I can imagine it's not from the TPB being down, but because the internet is friendly dDos-ing all of TPB proxys right now.
→ More replies (2)2
May 16 '12
Maybe it's uk ip's that are being blocked. I understand the link i provided is a proxy but can they still block access to that as well?
38
3
u/rsearle May 16 '12
try it without the https : http://tpb.pirateparty.org.uk/... worked for me :)
→ More replies (1)1
1
May 16 '12
works again at .se - with a nice pirate ship Phoenix design going on - I see what they did there...
→ More replies (3)1
90
u/SuXs May 16 '12
A Mirror version of TPB (new torrents are beeing uploaded & work)
Proxy access(official proxy provided by TBP on FB)
both up works as of 16.05.2012 16:15 CET
50
May 16 '12
I was wondering what was going on. Thanks.
I couldn't get to it normally, then I tried accessing it via Tor to see if I could access it on there, and I could.
→ More replies (7)
106
u/Ozera May 16 '12
Why ddos TPB...
42
u/tedrick111 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
Forgive the pure speculation:
Small Tech company (like one guy who's l33t) approaches hollywood studio (Marvel?) and offers to DDOS pirate bay for a few weeks while they continue to make revenue off of an historic box office smash. They take them up on it. He aims his botnet at pirate bay. The whole deal is concealed in such a way that we're never going to find out why, but the DDOS suddenly lets up after the DVD of Avengers has been released for a few weeks. The DoJ oddly doesn't investigate this anywhere as aggressively as the Paypal incident.
or
The US needs to test cyberwarfare weapons the way they tested nukes back in the day: They pick a target and fire. This is a (snirk) military exercise.
14
u/MathGrunt May 16 '12
Don't know why the downvotes, but since no one knows who is doing it, then your speculation is about a valid as the idea that Anonymous is doing it or anyone else. What about the recent report about Microsoft funded the Pirate Pay startup out of Russia?
Honestly, this doesn't look like Anonymous MO. They may be child-like at times, but they have their own culture and TPB is not one of their targets.
→ More replies (3)4
u/tedrick111 May 16 '12
Apparently they didn't forgive the pure speculation. Hey, maybe it is Anonymous... They don't forgive, right? ;)
I was just having fun, and someone missed the disclaimer.
181
u/iLeikHip May 16 '12
I believe Anonymous is butthurt at TPB for calling them out on being childish pricks. https://forum.suprbay.org/showthread.php?tid=121587&pid=761914
122
May 16 '12
TPB just posted this on their Facebook page:
Just to clarify, we KNOW that it is NOT Anonymous who is behind the ddos attack. Stop spreading rumours like that.
We may not agree with Anonymous in everything, but we both want the internet to be open and free.
There, now carry on with whatever it is you were doing <|:)
→ More replies (5)12
u/macgivor May 16 '12
This makes me feel better. I want those two on the same team.
→ More replies (2)187
May 16 '12
And further confirming their statements? Whoa.
51
u/interkin3tic May 16 '12
For all their mythos, Anonymous is really no different from any other grouping of people. People often aren't logical and suffer from cognitive dissonance.
Their members have pride in their little band. Insult a religion, nation, or company that it's members hold with pride, and you can get behaviors that confirm your insult. Remember those danish cartoons that called Islam violent? The response from a small portion of the Muslim population was... calls for violence.
It would be nice if everyone could be logical and we could dispense with silly group pride.
To be fair to Anonymous, they're not threatening to blow anyone up, and they're not invading an autonomous county, so it's not like they're in the same league as nations or religions.
→ More replies (11)19
u/Ozera May 16 '12
Well, if Anon is behind this, this is liking biting the hand that feeds you. You don't bite the hand that gives you good games/vids/pr0n
→ More replies (5)22
4
→ More replies (25)60
May 16 '12
i dunno.
it's a well-known u.s. military tactic to set their enemies against each other. maybe they waited for a disagreement, and ddos'd in hopes of creating discord.
in any case, people who are for internet freedoms should not be fighting each other. why turn on the guy next to you in this battle, when the other 90% of the world is lobbing missiles at you? fight the other guys.
7
u/bcarlzson May 16 '12
DDos attacks are highly illegal, if the MPAA/RIAA was stupid enough to do this and try to blame Anonymous, they would be in for a world of shit.
→ More replies (7)16
May 16 '12
You have to question if Anonymous is "for internet freedom" if they are going after anyone who criticizes them.
Assuming it is the group behind the ddos, this should call into question the support and legitimacy people attribute them.
→ More replies (27)0
May 16 '12
[deleted]
35
u/Jungle_Is_Massif May 16 '12
Something... something... Julius Caesar... something... something... Divide Et Impera...
→ More replies (5)36
13
4
124
u/refusedzero May 16 '12 edited May 17 '12
Pirate Bay reports Anonymous IS NOT BEHIND THE DDOS ATTACKS! This rumor is stupid Reddit, quit it!
Edit: TPB posted this on their Facebook page:
Just to clarify, we KNOW that it is NOT Anonymous who is behind the ddos attack. Stop spreading rumours like that. We may not agree with Anonymous in everything, but we both want the internet to be open and free.There, now carry on with whatever it is you were doing <|:)
Edit Edit: TPB also posted this on their FB:
Wikileaks.org is also under attack. This sure is the year of the storm... As predicted here: https://thepiratebay.se/blog/204
8
May 17 '12
It may not be the terrorist hacker group "Anonymous," (/foxnews), but it's still an anonymous group of people. Which anonymous they're anonymously a part of is the sticky wicket.
2
9
u/_asterisk May 16 '12
No, the Pirate Bay did no such thing, they said
"We don't know who's behind it but we have our suspicions."
The quote in that article denying involvement is attributed to Anonymous not the pirate bay:
"Yes The Pirate Bay is down. Yes it's under DDoS attack. No we don't know who from. We'll update as we hear more."
7
u/cheechw May 17 '12
Anyone who knows how Anon works will know that it's not Anon. People need to realize that Anonymous is not some coordinated organization with secretive members who organize their attacks internally. The "members" of anon are just random people on the internet who jump aboard for one mission or another. Most of their attacks aren't secret either. It's usually just someone on 4chan who wants to get something done and tells everyone. They then say it's an operation by anonymous, which is fine because anyone can be anonymous, and anyone who wants to be can be a leader. Again, there is no actual group of hackers, like LulzSec, who can claim to be "members". One strike by "Anon" might not have any of the same people as the previous one. 99% of the manpower behind their DDoS attacks are just average joes on 4chan. Point is, this isn't a case of some powerful head of Anon declaring war. The so called "members" of anon would never back this, because the entire internet is anon.
→ More replies (3)2
u/happyscrappy May 17 '12
As the Anonymous people like to point out, Anonymous doesn't have a centralized control. There is literally no one who can disclaim an attack with authority.
2
67
u/InstantAnythingcom May 16 '12
FIRE ALL GUNS! PREPARE TO BE BOARDED!
22
u/HurricaneHugo May 16 '12
AGAIN AND AGAIN!
→ More replies (2)36
6
9
u/rainman_104 May 16 '12
Of course the best attack of them all is to have all of reddit simultaneously testing it too :-)
104
u/Razious May 16 '12
Man, ThePirateBay is like the good guy greg of the internet. Why do they always have to get harassed?
261
u/DanceDanceEvolution May 16 '12
Because they can take it. Because they're not our hero. They're a silent guardian. A watchful protector. A Dark Knight.
5
→ More replies (2)0
7
→ More replies (4)2
17
20
May 16 '12
What is the likelihood that this could be that "Pirate Pay" company leading the DDOS attack?
→ More replies (8)
7
u/wkamp May 16 '12
Prostopleer, a website for downloading music, is also under DDoS attack. Presumably the same.
27
u/pennywinny May 16 '12
This is a good thing and whoever is doing it blew their load too early in the game. Now we know that someone has the power to knock TPB offline and the admins over at the site will find a solution that's heavily distributed and cannot be ddosed in the future. I think the enemy is confused about what type of admins work on TPD. The admins at TPB arent the type of admins to just put a bandaid on it so that it kind of halfway works like an admin at Sony. If they see a problem like this, they fix it, and in a very permanent way.
Now if the attacker had saved his attacks for a time when the admins of the site were being detained, or couldn't do anything to help, it might have had much more success. This could have easily been a kill blow to TPB had it been used at the right time.
This is the equivalent to moving your queen out too early in the game. Or maybe this isn't the queen, maybe heavier attacks are in the future? Either way I think whoever is commanding this anti pirate army is bad at warfare.
→ More replies (17)2
u/chromeextension May 16 '12
How exactly do you suggest they do this? They could over provision their servers or bandwidth, but if they had the resources for that they would have some it already. There is no end to all solution to DDoS.
It sounds like you're talking out of your arse.
→ More replies (9)2
u/reddixmadix May 16 '12
Done it already ... why? What you say is like this:
"Hey, Bob, how many servers to handle our traffic?"
"3"
"Ok, let's buy 300 servers then!"
→ More replies (2)
5
5
u/SomeoneStoleShazbot May 16 '12
thepiratebay.se works fine for me, and i'm in the UK where that site is supposed to be blocked!
→ More replies (2)
29
u/I_POTATO_PEOPLE May 16 '12
The writing on torrentfreak is usually shitty, but this article has a real gem:
Although Pirate Bay downtime happens a handful of times each month, it rarely persists for more than a few hours. When it goes beyond that the steady flow of reader emails to TorrentFreak quickly transforms itself into a torrent.
iseewhatyoudidthere.jpg
3
May 16 '12
Really? I've always found their articles to be surprisingly good (in comparison with other blogs of similar subject matter).
→ More replies (2)
4
4
4
u/nrbartman May 16 '12
"When it goes beyond that the steady flow of reader emails to TorrentFreak quickly transforms itself into a torrent."
Come on.
→ More replies (1)
7
u/lud1120 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
From Facebook:
"We were loling just like you, then we took a ddos to the knee. But now we're getting back up! Stronger than ever!"
3
u/Litagano May 16 '12
ThePirateBay having torrents of Sony Vegas alone is a reason you SHOULDN'T be trying to take down TPB.
3
u/yushi4664 May 17 '12
Turns out it's just a bunch of redditors checking whether or not it actually happened...
8
u/J_Jammer May 16 '12
“We do NOT encourage these actions. We believe in the open and free internets, where anyone can express their views. Even if we strongly disagree with them and even if they hate us,” said TPB in response to the DDoS attack against Virgin.
“So don’t fight them using their ugly methods. DDOS and blocks are both forms of censorship.”
That's so true. I give major respect for this viewpoint.
7
9
4
u/teious May 17 '12
I think we shouldn't jump to conclusions. What if the ddos is coming from an unknown friend?
2
2
2
2
u/reddit_killed_memes May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
I'm calling bullshit, and you should too.
Any organization against both the Pirate Bay and Anonymous could have done this. Anon would never resort to a tactic like this. Simply because TBP denounced their actions would not lead them to DDoS a website they have repeatedly stood behind.
2
u/tobypenter May 16 '12
I may be a in the minority, but I don't actually support anonymous or half of their 'activities'.
1
u/sblinn May 16 '12
I may be in the minority, but I don't actually support TPB commercially hosting trackers for copyrighted content under 20 years old. (Because I more or less agree with the International Pirate Party's 2009 Uppsala Declaration.)
2
u/demo May 16 '12
There was a botnet operator who did an AMA a little bit ago. He didn't talk much about it, but the topic was brought up -- how can you make money from a botnet?
This is how you make money. People will rent botnets just for this purpose.
I would LOVE to make the accusation that the MPAA or RIAA or whoever is behind this, but let's be honest -- that'd just be facetious.
2
2
u/GreyCr0ss May 16 '12
Perhaps Blizzard themselves are spearheading the attack in an attempt to subvert people from cracking it. MINDFUDGED
2
2
2
u/euqinor May 16 '12
You do not understand how I am imagining this in my mind; it's an epic depicting the struggles between Pirate and some hostile modern enemy
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Brushstroke May 17 '12
I really don't think Anonymous is behind this. TPB is one of the sites that I am sure many members of the collective use on a regular basis and the site has been one of the most outspoken critics of censorship and supporters of a free and open internet. Given all this, Anonymous attacking TPB seems very odd.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/g0_west May 17 '12
Oh no, more 4chan children in IRC with their LOIC! Anonymous are really laughable sometimes.
2
2
u/_BurntToast_ May 17 '12
How to access the entirety of TPB's magnets without visiting TPB: In your bittorrent program, click "Add Magnet" and copy paste the following url;
magnet:?xt=urn:btih:938802790a385c49307f34cca4c30f80b03df59c
The file downloaded is an archived 90mb text file snapshot of all the magnets on TPB, as of February the 8th 2012, with each magnet listed in the format;
Piratebay.ID|Name.of.torrent|size.in.bytes|number.of.seeders|number.of.leechers|magnet.link.hash
To add the any of the listed magnets to your bittorrent program, use the format;
magnet:?xt=urn:btih:magnet.link.hash
where "magnet.link.hash" is taken from the text snapshot.
Warning: The text file, unarchived, is roughly 164mb. This can be slow to load with notepad. A program for viewing (and searching) a very large text file may be required. A cross-platform python script with search functions tailored to this archive is located here.
14
May 16 '12
watch, anon attacks reddit next
142
u/mobiduxi May 16 '12
reddit being down is nothing that's newsworthy ...
62
May 16 '12
"In other news today, the popular internet news site 'reddit' has gone down... wait... I've just been informed that reddit is back up and they think the problem was with the... apparently reddit is down again due to a... and up... and down..."
*throws microphone down on the ground*
"Fuck it! I'm done for today! I will not stand for this kind of treatment! I'm a journalist for heaven's sake, not an indicator light!"16
u/yur_mom May 16 '12
There is a twitter page that tweets when Reddit goes up and down and a few days ago it was doing just this.
EDIT: LInk http://twitter.com/#!/IsRedditDown
→ More replies (2)12
3
44
u/Fooza May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
If anon did attack reddit I would never know about it since I always hear about these things on reddit.
16
2
u/uhwuggawuh May 16 '12
Why would Anonymous ever DDoS reddit? For being a watered-down version of /b/ when it comes to Internet memes?
3
u/Met4tr0n May 16 '12
Guys, if you use Tor you can access the site. Plus, since the magnet files are so small you are probably fine to download them without overloading Tor. Hope this helps!
→ More replies (1)3
May 16 '12
Yes, but torrent files are also very small so it wouldn't matter if you were downloading torrents either.
It's when you load the torrent/magnet into a torrent client that there is large downloading. This is what you shouldn't do over Tor.
→ More replies (1)
3
May 17 '12
Business as usual. Corporate run governments attack Pirate Bay, state run media blame Anonymous.
Move along, nothing to see here.
14
u/phattsao May 16 '12
Anonymous, please stick to attacking Sony
→ More replies (1)40
u/darc_oso May 16 '12
I honestly don't feel like this is Anonymous...it could be, but something in me feels like they wouldn't DDoS Pirate Bay.
55
→ More replies (1)4
3
May 16 '12
I was all for Anon DDOSing the crap out of evil people's sites, but when I heard TPB's explanation of how blocking and DDOS attacks are both forms of censorship I totally agreed with them and its really petty of Anon to do this to a fellow internet freedom of information advocate.
2
May 17 '12
Why is everyone automatically blaming Anon? They aren't the only people capable of launching a DDOS attack.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Edward_Berneys May 16 '12
This won't be Anonymous for several reasons.
If they were going to attack TPB it would have happened last week when statement was first published.
It would have been announced and someone on here would have posted the link to said announcement. There has been no announcement.
For Anonymous, attacking TPB would be like taking careful aim at their own foot and then pulling the trigger.
It's probably some organization like the RIAA or MPAA that have paid to have this happen since they are the ones that actually have the motivation to do something like this. Anonymous really doesn't.
2
2
1
u/Hardcorex May 16 '12
I literally just opened the bay, and as I was waiting for it to load I scrolled down reddit and saw this, wen't back, it's down :( Im in US btw
1
1
u/goose2460 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
For anyone wanting to get on using a proxy, you can use this or this. For up to the minute status information visit efnet.org and use IRC Channel #thepiratebay.org.
EDIT: Live updates
1
1
u/Velguarder May 16 '12
Wasn't there some Russian Microsoft group that made soemthing like this that was for DDoS'ing TPB?
1
1
u/jpeters1221 May 16 '12
Seems kind of weird that tpb would receive DDoS attack. I wonder if it's someone (or a group) that was angry, or a professional source.
1
1
u/TSolo315 May 16 '12
http://www.vtunnel.com/index.php/1010110A/9b381968c25ab14b06d46b3f9061cd37f2bb2df8bc17176
The site is still easily accessible.
1
1
u/Teslanaut May 16 '12
Wait, really? I haven't been able to reach TPB lately but I didn't think they were being DDOSed. When I check http://www.thepiratebay.se on isup.me, it shows them being up. But when I try to visit TPB in any browser on any computer via my own connection, it doesn't load at all for me. Me thinks I'm being denied access to TPB?
AT&T user in USA. Anyone else have this problem?
1
1
1
1
May 16 '12
Every time I cant access TPB I fear that AT&T has finally started blocking them or something and every time its just something retarded that no one has any control over anyways and that time will fix. damn internet paranoia.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/e1_duder May 16 '12
This is crazy, no matter who did it, mpaa, riaa, us government, or an offshoot of anon, the next couple of days are going to be interesting...
1
1
u/isomorphZeta May 16 '12
I believe Demonoid.me was under a similar attack a day or two ago... anybody else have an issue accessing their site a little while ago?
1
May 16 '12
Guys this is most defiantly the pirate pay. Remember a while back there was the article about them. Well they said that they had a secret way they would stop the pirate bay....
1
1
1
1
u/unnecessaryCAPS May 16 '12
Pirates V Anarchists. And the winner is: status quo. Waa, wAA, waaaAAah...
1
u/tso May 16 '12
Heh, they should just slap a static file of magnet checksums up somewhere until this rolls over. Anyone for a 100MB text file?
1
1
May 17 '12
Scary... Anon tactics used against TPB. Anon denies responsibility, TPB denies anon involvement. Who could it be?
I'm mostly concerned with the fact that TPB's enemies are using DDOS attacks than anything else. I expected legal maneuvers to be their weapon of choice.
→ More replies (4)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/thelostzelda May 17 '12
The worst part of this was having a friend (who is hopelessly dependant on me for all things that happen on the internet) calling me to "fix the pirate bay". He honestly thought it was a good idea and that as long as the pirate bay was down, all the torrents he was downloading wouldn't work.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/tilleyrw May 17 '12
How can the attacker be unknown? Unless they are doing their DDoS through the Tor network, how can the packet source not be traced?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Lion_Eyes May 16 '12
Good guy Pirate Bay: Gets censored, Doesn't stoop to the Corporations level.
→ More replies (2)
0
1
1
May 16 '12
This pisses me off! (And I barley use TPB... But its something of a beacon in the night for people that fight the good fight)
1
u/Csoltis May 16 '12
why the fuck is every article on reddit that mentions torrent; is submitted from torrentfreak.com
→ More replies (2)
1
1
May 16 '12
i swear that i checked 'is it down for everyone or just me' like 20 times. thanks for posting. I was starting to think my IPS blocked it for some reason
1
1
May 17 '12
Just wait until the conspiracy theories start. Headlines: Anonymous hired by Government to get down and dirty..
-2
u/wild_bill70 May 16 '12
ooh, how does it feel to be on the other end of "internet freedom"
→ More replies (6)
320
u/danielravennest May 16 '12
Fortunately Google has the site cached. In Google search, type:
site:thepiratebay.se
followed by what you are looking for. Select a result and slide to the right over the ">>" tab. A snapshot of the page will appear, and near the top is a link to the "Cached" version from Google's servers.