r/technology • • May 16 '12

Google filed a patent for the ability to eavesdrop on conversations, so that they can deliver better targeted advertising. Not just phone calls, either - any sound that is picked up by the headset mics.

http://theweek.com/article/index/226004/googles-eavesdropping-technology-going-too-far-to-sell-ads
2.0k Upvotes

666 comments sorted by

250

u/Rednys May 16 '12

Consider the number of patents that companies file for regardless of whether or not they plan on using them in todays market. If nothing else they plan on having it just so no one else can. If in the future it becomes something that's acceptable, bam they've already got the patent.
Right now I don't think it would even be legal. Even if the owner of the phone consented to being recorded and having their data being used by google as they see fit, I think it would be illegal. Simply because you would be recording other people around you. The person on the street that walked by you as you are talking to someone and google was recording you, now they may have recorded that persons conversation with someone else entirely without their knowledge or consent.

8

u/HeavyWave May 16 '12 edited Jul 01 '23

I do not consent to my data being used by reddit

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I read about this a while ago, when people were talking about how little they trust Google with the advent of Google Drive. To put this in context, like Rednys said, this patent application is just in case, as Google brainstorms ways in which it can remain relevant in a world that is moving away from desktop web searches and towards mobile searches and web apps, which they can't profit from nearly as well.

So if you're at a train station Google can pick up background train noise or anything else that is situationally relevant if you decide to search for something. They could use everything they know about you at that moment to serve you the most relevant search results. For example, they could use your calendar, geolocation, Google+ posts, and other data to figure out that if you search for "train schedules", you're likely interested in MTA Metro-North in New York, or that if you search for best restaurants, you'll be partial to Italian food.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/oniony May 16 '12

What if your calls were free?

26

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Especially considering the recording isn't limited to phone calls, I wouldn't accept this even if Google straight paid me.

18

u/Neato May 16 '12

I would and then put my sansa clip+ mp3 players in my pocket with headphones playing Ricky Astley whenever I wasn't using it.

37

u/Kaos_pro May 16 '12

Analysing target "Neato"....
Target shows strong commitment tendencies.

8

u/12345hunter2 May 16 '12

Posting on a throwaway for what will soon be an obvious reason, but I work for one of the tech giants trying to do exactly this: continuous listening, along with heavy ties into many other parts of your life (email, facebook, texts, etc). What I'm curious about is if there's ever a point for you where you'd be willing to give up your personal information in exchange for functionality. Your answer is relevant to my job and to privacy in the tech industry in general - others are welcome to chime in.

Let's say for example Jarvis from the Iron Man movies existed - would you give up your personal data in order to have all of the benefits that something like Jarvis would provide?

Another scenario would be a service requesting 24/7 access to your GPS location. In exchange, it will alert you during your morning commute if there's a traffic jam up ahead, and will tell you a route that will save you 30 minutes. It can also remind you that you're two blocks away from a post office, and that you should really mail those legal forms while you're here. Would you value that service more than your location privacy?

The reality of this is that companies like google, microsoft, apple, etc. are very quickly going to start looking for more data to access. This fight between giants will be decided by who has more data to access. More data means we can make more intelligent decisions about what is important to you, but more data also means we're invading on privacy more. It's a very fine line, and I'd love some input on this because it's a hard problem to solve.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (116)

273

u/bamboofries May 16 '12

That's creepy...

183

u/qoou May 16 '12

Google's strategy is to put both feet on the creepy foul line. looks like they crossed it this time. if everyone thinks it's creepy they will back off for a little while until the users either get used to it or forget about it and then start eavesdropping again.

27

u/trollshep May 16 '12

Step closer to futurama style dream advertising

→ More replies (1)

52

u/epitaphevermore May 16 '12

Or just do it without you knowing. Like how they have been secretly keeping log of your mobile tower activity...

61

u/thang1thang2 May 16 '12

If I may play the Devil's Advocate...

I wouldn't mind them spying on whatever I say if it's just a computer analyzing my words and using that to improve itself voice recognition wise so that I could have a 100% accurate voice recognition software that I can talk to like a real person (J.A.R.V.I.S. from Iron man, anyone?).

But targeted advertising? Fuck no. If I wanted everyone to know my conversation, I would post it on Facebook. I don't need google deciding to try and sell me bondage fuzzy handcuffs because of an inside joke from 3 years before with one of my friends that I just happened to say with them.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/AbstractLogic May 16 '12

Googles mantra is 'Don't be evil'. But science shows that Mantra's should not include a negative such as not, stop, don't, none because the brain inheritly skips the negative when it is repeated several times over. Thus 'Don't be evil' quickly becomes 'be evil' when over used.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Part of me hopes they are just patenting it so no one else can do it... but i'm piety sure they would do it. Good reason to go back to land lines.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Neato May 16 '12

If they win the patent, they can back away from it. And then return in 6mo when everyone forgets and go about using their tech.

10

u/dcsquared540 May 16 '12 edited May 17 '12

Actually, if you read the article, the patent issued in March. It was filed back in 2008.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (29)

25

u/yogthos May 16 '12

That seems like a very good reason to run Cyanogen ;)

3

u/animaldoggie May 16 '12

This is the first thing I thought. Good on ya.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/NoWeCant May 16 '12

This means you'll receive ads for toilet paper when taking a crap.

8

u/l82theparty May 16 '12

skynet anyone? when was it supposed to come online again?

25

u/totally_not_SKYNET_ May 16 '12

2:14 am Eastern Time on August 29th, 1997

6

u/l82theparty May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Ok, so this is a bit off target, but filing patents must take up a lot of your time!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I have an Android phone next to me right now. I'm scared.

21

u/Dagon May 16 '12

Don't be too scared. Keeping the mic on all the time chews battery so that you'd notice - and battery life is bad enough without sacrificing this, combined with the fantastically bad PR this would (will) generate.

19

u/exdiggtwit May 16 '12

And judging from the wonderfully hilarious Google Voice transcriptions (from someone speaking clearly into the phone), they have a long long long way to go before I'd worry about anything.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/sandwich_time May 16 '12

I just talked to my phone... "Hi Google. I can feel you listening to me" *moan

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Correction: that WOULD be creepy if Google implements it. There are tons of patents out there that are even creepier that are never even touched. Apple has one that detects if you're at a concert or near a live music performance and shuts off the camera so you can't record copyrighted music.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/grammar_connoisseur May 16 '12

In Soviet America, Google googles you!

36

u/McDestructor May 16 '12

That's a lot of fap recordings.

27

u/damontoo May 16 '12

"5 gallons of lube, 50% off!"

→ More replies (1)

6

u/f8f13be6 May 16 '12

Somewhere a Woman In Black is literally sick to death of listening you rub cream on your dick while moaning to the celebrity du jour.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I will be really pissed if a voice recognition of THAT app will be better than in my voice search.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Zoogy May 16 '12

"Some of those ideas later mature into real products or services, some don't," a Google representative tells CNET.

And lets hope this one doesn't see the light of day.

4

u/Boardies May 16 '12

This may just be a protective patent to prevent the development of something similar.

Imagine if apple had this? Siri tells you were the closest bar is, after you call a buddy to meet up.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/8986 May 16 '12

Google's gonna goog.

13

u/yianni May 16 '12

I think it's time we all go back to the trusty Nokia 3310.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I was just thinking today, I wouldn't mind one of those Nokias that came with Bounce. I loved that damn game.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/nczuma May 16 '12

"Shut up friends! My internet browser heard us saying the word Fry and it found a movie about Philip J. Fry for us. It also opened my calendar to Friday and ordered me some french fries."

24

u/j2thaP May 16 '12

Reposting a month-old piece from DVWLR about this topic:

Google “makes us feel like we’re in a police state.” So reads the lede in this piece on The Next Web. This kind of histrionic fear mongering is all the rage these days and it seems like it can all be traced to people’s discomfort with companies’ knowing what they’re doing.

As DVWLR previously wrote, enough is enough. Google, Amazon, Facebook, Netflix, CNN, Pinterest, etc are not tentacles extending from a centralized, evil government. They’re businesses trying to show you products and ads you’ll like. That’s it.

And yet, the word “creepy” pops up again and again. The Next Web’s piece concerns a patent Google filed that would potentially allow them to serve ads based on background noise your phone picks up. Here’s an excerpt from the hard-hitting, intellectually rigorous piece:

While Google isn’t technically “listening” to your calls, meaning there isn’t someone on the other line listening to your conversation, the fact that the company could unleash technology that monitors our calls in real-time is weird.

Why the author ignores Google’s ability to “unleash” Android and Google Voice a means of monitoring calls is unclear.

The real question is why Google would bother creating this technology, and why people find it “creepy.”

First, the “why:” Google is in the business of selling ads. The more they know about you, the more relevant the ads can be. So if Google “hears” you’re on a train, perhaps they’ll serve you an ad to download a discounted eBook. Or if Google believes you’re watching the Superbowl, they’ll serve an ad that synchs with a TV spot.

The truth is, I don’t know how they’ll use this technology. Nobody does. It’s not commercially available yet. But I do know it won’t be unleashed as a weapon to funnel your darkest secrets to the government. Doing so is not in Google’s interest.

And so we return to this concept of “creepy.” I offer this definition: any action previously unknown to a person that potentially reveals anything about their behavior to anyone is considered creepy.

Note: “creepy” does not relate to a company’s usage of the information or their giving an opt-out option. In Google’s case, you can opt-out of everything (no, really, just go here).

Fear, Uncertainly, and Doubt (FUD) isn’t going away. I quixotically hope tech blogs will stop seeding FUD because it makes it all the more likely Congress will pass a stupid law that ties the hands of innovative companies.

7

u/throwawaybcos May 16 '12

Exactly this.

We use services such as Google and Facebook for free so they have to make their money through advertising. Not only are targeted ads worth more money, they're (imo) better for the people that have to watch them! I would hate TV advertising breaks so much less if instead of sitting through a futile ten minute effort to sell me tampons it was all stuff I was actually interested in! "Hey, throwawaybcos - the new **** albums out! So-and-so are touring, would you like to book tickets for the **** date?" for example would be BRILLIANT.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Thank you for being reasonable.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'm just going to put this out there...just because companies can spy on people doesn't mean that they should. Yes, maybe it will improve their advertising. It that really worth giving up your privacy for?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/MusikLehrer May 16 '12

Okay, somebody provide me with the best, private, non-date collecting, Google alternative/scraper, whatever.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/TheOceanWalker May 16 '12

Whatever happened to "Don't be evil"?

20

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

The actual motto was: "You can make money without doing evil."

Also "evil" can be subjective.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[citation required]
[challenge accepted]
[citation acquired]

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

On Google and others being evil:

"Google maintains a very complex evil portfolio that they need to offset with good assets by the end of the fiscal year. Capitalism and the free market has turned their "do no evil" slogan into "do no net evil." As a result, Google Voice generates rare and coveted benidons that are traded on the moral exchange. One benidon offsets one hedon as a base unit at the end of the year. While Microsoft and Apple executives Scrooge McDuck in their massive hedon reserves and show them off to investors, every year Google struggles more and more to finish in the white."

  • by anonymous

2

u/ChironXII May 16 '12

Maybe it is a net calculation.

They offset the creepiness by giving you awesome stuff like Google Drive, Android, Chrome, and Gmail, all for free.

They do have to make money somehow, and they try to do it in the least evil way possible, including options to disable such features.

I actually find their system helpful. It shows me things I'm interested in, that I might actually want to look at, rather than incessant ads for fertilizer.

If they decided to turn evil, you'd notice. Creating things that could be used for evil, but using them to make cool stuff, does not make them evil.

2

u/PurpleSfinx May 16 '12

Having a patent != using it.

→ More replies (26)

10

u/Shippoyasha May 16 '12

So I can't trust Apple. I can't trust Facebook. I can't trust Google.

Nice. Just great.

21

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Why would you assume that you could trust a for profit company to begin with?

Corporations have a duty to their shareholders collectively. That's it.

9

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It's less a question of "trust". It may be only a semantic difference, but there is a reasonable expectation that a company, whom you pay for a given service or product (which excludes FB and Google free services, obviously, where you are the product) would no go out of their way to act irresponsibly toward you.

There are plenty of companies that have clear pricing structures, clear definitions of services and actions that they will or will no engage in, and clear limitations of how they deal with you as a customer. That's not "trust", that's basic common sense.

Or rather, if I buy service x off a company, it's not that I trust the company, it's that I should be able to trust the integrity and limits of a transaction without going full-tinfoil-hat all the time because I always have to question whether they're out to fuck me.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

This would kill them in the enterprise market. No one would touch an Android phone knowing it could possibly be transmitting conversation back to Google servers.

They are already getting hammered in the BYOD area.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HideAndSeek May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Sometimes a company patents something to keep others from doing it, while they have no intention of doing it themselves.

edit - too many themselves

2

u/krayngerdanger May 16 '12

I don't know if this has been said before, but it's really interesting (timing wise) that google is filing for this patent as they are hyping their augemented reality glasses.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

patent wars, companies frequently patent any and all things they can think of even if they don't plan on using them, just in case they do eventually decide to use it and someone else has already patented it, or so that they can sell the rights to do something to other companies that want to do it.

2

u/hot_coffee May 16 '12

Cool, sounds like a great addition to their WiFi-snooping Street View cars.

2

u/silent_p May 16 '12

They're going to have to hire Morgan Freeman to monitor it, though.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

La la la la la GOOGLE'S NOT EVIL la la la la la.

2

u/timtamboy63 May 16 '12

But don't worry guys, it's only for advertising. We promise we won't use it for anything else. Pinky promise even.

2

u/mastigia May 16 '12

I am getting a little frustrated with these headlines that are so misleading that are becoming more and more common. This one is worse than most and basically a lie, environmental conditions are not conversations. Still creepy, but entirely inaccurate.

2

u/SilverLion May 17 '12

Welcome to reddit, misleading headlines are your best shot at making the front page.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DancesWithNoobs May 16 '12

Is this a step toward a system like the one that Batman used in The Dark Knight... when did Google become a subsidiary of Wayne Industries?

2

u/Jeeraph May 16 '12

Who really speaks anymore anyway?

2

u/whippedxcream May 16 '12

Just because they got the patents doesn't mean they're going to use it. In fact, be glad it was Google that filled it, instead of Microsoft or Apple.

2

u/brennanr May 16 '12

Well, I read the top half of the comments, and it appears nobody has read the article :(

"How would this work? Theoretically, this advertising would "be served on the basis of a sensor that detects temperature, humidity, sound, light, or air composition near a device," says Loek Essers at PC World."

This is a good thing. They're targeting ads. Do people like getting irrelevant ads completely unrelated to anything they'd ever be interested in? I sure don't.

A computer can't think and can't 'eavesdrop'. Are they saving everything they hear from your device's mic then listening to the things you said and laughing about it later in Mountain View? Obviously not. The memory required to do something like that is absurd. Even if they did want to. Targeting ads based on the temperature your device detects is a little different than that.

Obviously (since this keeps coming up) some people find targeted ads creepy. Opt out, it's that simple. Enjoy your completely irrelevant ads, maybe one day someone will be able to target ads at me so well I care about them. That will be a good day.

I'd like to see the actual patent filing, as that article explains a very broad concept. Patenting "advertising on environmental conditions" is a lot different than patenting listening to what people say through the mic.

2

u/walshmandingo May 16 '12

Fuck off Google!

(And i hope your bastard algorithms pick that up, motherfuckers!)

2

u/funke_the_analrapist May 17 '12

Wait, wasn't this technology already patented by Wayne enterprises??

6

u/behindtext May 16 '12

google spying on its users, first time i've seen anything about that :)

when you get stuff for free on the internet remember that you are the product.

i would not be one bit surprised if there is already some clause in an agreement for using android that consents to participation in their "ambient-audio-based ad-optimization program". this does beg an important question: if google, or another company for that matter, adds "features" like this to an open source product, must they obtain consent from the user, e.g. in the form of a T&C?

i know that it is illegal to record audio in the state of Illinois without the consent of all parties involved (or a proper warrant, etc). thanks chicago mafia!

3

u/AnyTwoWillDo May 16 '12

That would suck, I hate porn advertising.

3

u/thermal_shock May 16 '12

shouldn't work on rooted/custom rom phones. it will most likely be something installed by manufacturer or carrier.

3

u/rockinalivecdbitches May 16 '12

Its not installed, its just a patent. But it would be as simple as rolling out an update on your existing google software.

ANY google software. You can probably (without looking up permissions at this present time) be sure its not by only having software on your phone with no permission to access the microphone.

So no google talk, voice, or anything like that.

Also, rooted custom roms, and deleting all non essential stuff from the phone, plus restricting access to what each program you do have can access = real security.

3

u/gorigorigori May 16 '12

This WILL (no fucking doubt what so ever) be implemented into antiterrorist measures as well. If google can listen in on your mic 24/7 to analyse who you are, so will the government.

Luckily this isn't a telescreen so all you tinfoil hats can just shut up about Orwell. It's not like 1984 at all, for starters it's not a screen. And this particular way of oppression won't turn any of our countries into north Korea I say go for it! Safety! Protection! Freedom!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Creepy? Sure. But not nearly as creepy as some of the shit we dream up around here and our 'special' friends at 4chan come up with.

Why don't we just beat them to punch? Let's file patents for all of the scariest, most ridiculous shit we can dream up. That way no company will be able to use that tech on us when it finally comes out.

Any one of us could have thought of this Google idea. Let's think of whatever they are going to think up next and steal it first. We'll have hundreds or thousands of idle patents just as a defensive measure, to make sure certain, stupid shit doesn't get invented.

3

u/aaronstj May 16 '12

There is a world of different between "was awarded a patent on" and "even remotely plans on doing" something. The chance that Google is actively working on this is extremely low.

Here is how parents work my company (a large, top-tier tech company): it's a pure numbers game, we want as many patents as we can generate. Any time I think of something remotely interesting, I'm supposed to put the idea into a web form. A patent lawyer reads all of the ideas. If they think one is patentable, they write it up and submit it. Again, it's purely a numbers game: the idea is to have as many patents as possible, no matter what they're on. The reason is, we use 99.99% of our patents defensively. If someone comes to sue us for patent infringement, we say "we have X thousand patents. You're probably infringing a couple. Want to call it even?"

This means any idea I come up with at work - whether it's what I'm working on, related to what I'm working on, or just a crazy brainstorm - could end up as a patent.

My understanding is that all of the big tech players work similarly. Patents filed should in no way be seen as a reflection of what a company actually plans to do.

So I doubt Google is planning to actually eavesdrop on conversations. Much more likely, some engineer was sitting around working on targeted ads for the web or something and thought "hey, I wonder if it would be possible to target ads based on conversations", wrote it up, and went back to work. Some lawyer wrote it up and bingo! Patent!

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

So the current patent system is totally twisted and has nothing to do with protecting someone's inventions? Not that I didn't knew that already, but it makes me uncomfortable every time I get to think or read about it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/loonatick May 16 '12

Anyone ever read the book Feed by M.T. Anderson? I read it in high school, and it seemed very far-fetched at the time.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wallstr33t May 16 '12

What ever happened to Google's mantra, "do no evil"?
It seems that everything new thing they put out is exactly the opposite

→ More replies (1)

2

u/reasonman May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

I think that'd be a cool thing to do for dynamic billboards or kiosks as the article mentioned, but I wouldn't care for it on my phone.

Edit: Out of curiosity how is having Google serve nonspecific, nonpersonal ads on a billboard more objectionable than having Google serving specific, personal ads on your phone and browser?

I'm not suggesting that it'd be cool to have Google listen to me from a kiosk I'm next to and serve ads based on what I'm saying. I'm suggesting that it'd be interesting to get environmental data like temperature, humidity, ambient noise, etc and serve ads based on that. Like the article mentions on a hot day it might serve ads for a cold drink.

Idiots.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

At this stage i'm pretty much numb to the notion that they're going to knock on my door one day to install a microchip in my brain...

2

u/rockinalivecdbitches May 16 '12

You've got nothing to hide right? Then whats the big deal?

1

u/sweetgreggo May 16 '12

But they're just getting the patent so no one else will do this, right? Because to do this is evil and Google isn't evil, right?

RIGHT???

1

u/Sandvicheater May 16 '12

Man tech companies suck.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

theoretically, some day, maybe.

1

u/GreyFoxSolid May 16 '12

Good. Now if anyone else does it, Google can sue them.

1

u/unbeliever87 May 16 '12

I'm not sure what kind of advertising knowledge they are going to get out of "fap fap fap", but they are welcome to try.

1

u/bryankerr May 16 '12

I'd like to see a Google PRO account similar to Google Apps Premier. Ad free Google products for a subscription.

1

u/corcyra May 16 '12

The only way to combat this sort of thing, is to vote with your wallet and let the advertisers know why you're not going to buy their cold drink or whatever.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Easy. Speak only in Pig Latin.

1

u/textests May 16 '12

How does this past the basic obviousness test for patents?
This idea has been seen in SF for years.

Personally I think it is a great idea but would be ruined by commercialism. Imagine you are on a date and the cute girl (or boy, your preference) mentions how much they love Egon Schiele. You know nothing about Egon Schiele, but your google glasses heard her talking and quickly show a wikipedia entry so you don't look clueless.

The future of dating, and maybe business meetings I suppose.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Dear Google, I don't give a fuck about your ads. Sincerely, everyone.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/oshout May 16 '12 edited May 28 '12

I am 80% sure my droid-x does this already. I've been talking about it for weeks and now I see it in the news.

Seriously, I'll be having conversations and notice that g.news (which I frequent) has articles regarding those conversations -- stuff about plastic in the oceans, battery technology -- nothing i've written about rather i've talked about it with my phone in my pocket... I'd say this has happened 6 times in the past 3 weeks, which is about double what I'd expect on average.

It seems to happen especially when people with multiple droid-vices (droid-vicii?) are next to each other.

1

u/YourMatt May 16 '12

The idea of targeted advertising really doesn't bother that much. My big problem with it is less in privacy concerns and more in false matches. I hate that I might check a price online for a friend and then see ads for that product across the web for the next few months. If my phone is listening in for keywords, it's likely going to hear a lot of words for products I'm not actually interested in.

1

u/silent_p May 16 '12

If we had the technology so that they could instantly deliver whatever it was I wanted when I casually mentioned it while I was near a microphone, then I would be okay with this.

"Man, I could really go for a cheeseburger."

Nothin'.

1

u/ibflaubert May 16 '12

I thought you couldn't patent things that were illegal?

1

u/ElRed_ May 16 '12

Why do they even bother? They are never going to go bankrupt. Their search alone would provide a lot. They should just work on improving existing things. If they want other peoples information to do this then let them do a survey where you get an extra 1GB on your drive account or something.

Well to be honest the owners probably don't bother. They can just bugger off and do whatever they like. Like Bill Gates, he does it for good though and he was once hands on.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I knew it, Google is Skynet.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

That's the reason I didn't buy a droid when I got a new phone last month. Their loss. Of course, apple won't be far behind on this one either probably.

1

u/lowasser May 16 '12

The article doesn't seem to justify the leap from "ambient sound" to "listening in to your phone calls." I'd like to see the wording from the actual patent before I grant its conclusions.

1

u/TruthinessHurts May 16 '12

So Google has shied away from that "don't be evil" about as far as one can shy from something.

Google is going all scumbag.

1

u/Pikabob May 16 '12

I like to think it's so that when someone actually starts doing that, Google can sue them into oblivion and save us all.

1

u/Emperor_Norton_1 May 16 '12

Whatever sound is picked up through the headset? Damn, I can see my ads now....All for tissue, lotion, anal lube...And rodent control (hey, don't judge me, i blame youtube).

1

u/thedude213 May 16 '12

This is one of those situations where we could make google easily regret this. Think of the possibilities.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

it sounds like soon google will be able to beam adverts directly into our dreams

1

u/ct0 May 16 '12

What ever happened to redphone?

1

u/Dr_Eleven May 16 '12

They must be trying to target the Joker

1

u/HarryBlessKnapp May 16 '12

Tbh some of the targetting ads I've been getting lately has been much more productive. I've noticed that many more of the online ads fired in my direction are actually interesting me. I even clicked 2 in the last week.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

In other news, Google announces plans to sue FBI.

1

u/jeffp2662 May 16 '12

Umm did no one see the GIANT reddit post about this when the article came out? Almost two months ago!?

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil

I think I will look to slowly migrate away from Google services. They are becoming too overbearing and intrustive.

1

u/MrGoldenSun May 16 '12

Don't be evil!

1

u/BallsackTBaghard May 16 '12

Future confirmed for being like Minority report.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

do no evil

LMFAO

1

u/urinsan3 May 16 '12

While of course this may not be the case - they could always be doing good and patenting this technology so other's can't use it. Their motto is "Don't be evil". Just an optimist's point of view.

1

u/Deadlyd0g May 16 '12

Well idk the add targeting was kinda helpful when I did not have Adblock. I was looking for a new GPU and it gave me nice results from new egg while I watched YouTube.

1

u/rjnr May 16 '12

Google used to be such a nice company. For shame.

1

u/Bobby_Marks May 16 '12

I feel like Batman did this some time ago: targeted advertising, fighting crime.... What's the difference....

1

u/Chasuk May 16 '12

Except if you read the article, that's not what it actually says.

1

u/Duthos May 16 '12

Can I take out a patent on patents? Seems like it would be a pretty good idea these days.

(obligatory 'yo dawg' here)

1

u/Indon_Dasani May 16 '12

I can't be the only one who thinks we need to rewrite the constitution so that we have our rights guaranteed against private agents as well as public ones.

GTFO of my business, businesses.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/powercow May 16 '12

This is actually mega mega old news, they filed for this years ago.. it was mainly to pick up back ground noise from your tv through a flash or something similar so that they could have the ads on your pc insync with what is on tv.

studies show most people with laptops or other portable devices, sit there and use them in front of the tv.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/flukshun May 16 '12

please tell me the real reason is so they can protect themselves from some money-grubbing startup with little care for privacy and white knight for consumers by giving themselves the ability to sue anyone else that tries to implement such a perverse spying mechanism.

please. please. please. i don't want to have to despise google all of a sudden.

1

u/turd_miner91 May 16 '12

Deliver better targeted advertising? Has anybody told them that we don't want advertising period?

1

u/naasking May 16 '12

I'm not sure I'd classify delivering targeted ads as eavesdropping. It's not like they're recording your convos, or a human is listening to them.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

or activate while everyone else is busy with somehtign else like CISPA being passed at 6:30PM on the friday of the NFL draft.. I'm done with google too if this shit goes through.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Uhh Google? You can stop now. You've got enough of our data...

1

u/jlamothe May 16 '12

Great. We'll all be carrying portable telescreens.

1

u/LoFiSamurai May 16 '12

Blah Blah.. Apple, iOS, Siri!.. yadda yadda.. Big Brother Google... hoobie doobie.. fandriods fragmentation.. skibbledie bibbledie.. anecdotal evidence!

1

u/HRNK May 16 '12

So what happens when Google overhears illegal or questionable sounds, like what sounds domestic abuse, murder, or rape? Will they be required to report those sounds? What happens if it turns out its just a couple into BDSM or rapeplay? Will Google be held responsible for falsely reporting a crime?

1

u/ramp_tram May 16 '12

They can patent whatever they want, it's still illegal in a lot of states.

1

u/Iorah May 16 '12

"It also opened my calendar to Friday and ordered me some french fries" -- farnsworth

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

If I'm going to have an advertisement, I want to to be relevant. I put my information out there for everyone to know, I guess I'm in the minority of internet users when it comes to wanting to remain anonymous at every aspect.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

So that no one else can implement this, right Google? RIGHT!?

1

u/Luxray May 16 '12

Just another reason not to use a smart phone.

1

u/pumpkindog May 16 '12

Good guy google: gets patent on eavesdropping... sues gov't for patent infringement?

1

u/typpeo May 16 '12

I feel like they already do this. Any time I have a conversation with my wife and need to look something up on my GNexus Google search knows what I want in like 3 words. It's kind of creepy.

1

u/Zderzak May 16 '12

I wonder about people doing cybersex or calling sex lines etc.

1

u/spj36 May 16 '12

"Don't be evil."

1

u/CndConnection May 16 '12

No need to freak out.

As if they're going to get any usable data from me gaming from time to time with my mic, swearing my fucking ass off and sometimes speaking in french.

I doubt they will manage to extract any product names from the garbage talk me and my buddies partake in

1

u/Sindertone May 16 '12

If you guys haven't been LEAVING YOUR MICS DISCONNECTED you're obviously not doing anything illegal ;)

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

To be honest, I dont really care... there are so many people out there with conversations just as uninteresting as mine.

On the other hand it is funny to think that somewhere out there, there is a person listening to your cybersex converstations with your significant other 0.o

1

u/dregan May 16 '12

Sorry Google but I'm going to opt out on that one. Also, if your Google Voice text-to-speech performance is any metric you still have a long way to go before you can effectively do this.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I wonder how much of the sound they will pick up will just be "fap fap fap fap fap".

1

u/what_comes_after_q May 16 '12

While the patent itself is creepy as hell, people have to remember that anything and everything that can be patented will be. If Google didn't patent this, someone else would have (Apple, Motorola, Microsoft, or maybe even some guy in his basement), so let's not blame Google for this so much as we should blame the patent system for allowing creepy patents.

As many people have already pointed out, this patent is murky at best in terms of legality, as both sides of the conversation would have to know they're being recorded. While an Android user may have signed off as saying this is okay during registration, the other side of the conversation may not be an android user. Even if the technology were to only record what the mic pics up, things like speaker phone would make recording the conversation potentially illegal. Plus, even if someone were to sign a waver saying it's okay, a court could toss this waiver out in court because there is no real expectation that someone would read fine print in a contract, thus they would need to be very clear making sure that people understood exactly what it was they were signing during registration. In short, it's unlikely Google would use this patent directly, but may use it for derivative technology or to pad it's IP portfolio.

1

u/dregan May 16 '12

I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of batteries suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced.

1

u/r121 May 16 '12

I think I will file a patent for the ability to murder people without going to jail.

A patent doesn't grant abilities.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

They've done this to my dad about a half year ago. He was talking to my mom about a Chinese restaurant that his friend suggested and he picked up his phone to an automatic google voice search about the restaurant. No big news.

1

u/Grand_Theft_Audio May 16 '12

jesus. this is like that scene in The Dark Knight when Bale and Freeman are looking at all those monitors with the cellphone information on them. Too much power.

1

u/kill_terrorist_pigs May 16 '12

Welcome to Android....

1

u/radient May 16 '12

Ridiculously misleading headline. Here's a link to the actual patent in question (filed in 2008), in case anyone actually wants to read it:

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=8,138,930.PN.&OS=PN/8,138,930&RS=PN/8,138,930

1

u/iismatthew May 16 '12

Am I alone in the fact that I've stopped caring if some on listens/watches me? We spend most of our day on camera any way. I'm confident that I look better then most of the schmucks that are going pass by that stop light today any way.

1

u/gambit87 May 16 '12

Went from "Don't be Evil" to becoming one of the evilest companies in the world ... Star Wars 7 ... Google teaching Anikan how to really turn to the dark side.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Google has a close relationship with the US government as well. A DARPA official from the pentagon is not a senior executive at Google.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

That couldn't be misconstrued as doing "evil" at all.

1

u/edisekeed May 16 '12

WTF. I thought Google's whole motto was to not be evil. Now they are storing any information they can get and are willing to hand it over to the US gov't without question. This is fucked up.

1

u/stealthmodeactive May 16 '12

eh... Google, I'm not cool with that...

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Well, at least all my ads will be for superheroes, video games, and porn now.

1

u/thomasluce May 16 '12

Don't be evil. Just creepy as fuck.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

If Google offered a free cell phone service with unlimited voice and data by custom tailoring advertising to me by anonymously listening to what I say, I'd be open to the idea. Keeping it anonymous like they do in to get driving traffic data with Google Maps would be key. Getting a $60+ a month service for free while seeing advertisements based on my conversations isn't a big deal, they already do it for my free gmail service.

1

u/Andrenator May 16 '12

I actually disagree with the hivemind on this one.

I'm bored by any and every football commercial, US Army commercial, blatant action movie commercial, etc. I would rather have this, because it would be like my friends recommending things to me.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Chazman212 May 16 '12

History is our best way to preserve freedom: "First they came for the [googlers] and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a [googler] Then they came for the [microsftians] and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a [microsoftian] Then they came for the [cell phonites] and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a [cell phonite]" And then they came for the interwebbers, security camera's, political voting records, and the rest even slightly connected to technology. They Super Pac-ked a president supporting this surveillance and it was enacted with "quality consumer research" as its pledge... "Then they came for me and there was no one left to speak out for me."

1

u/hnrqoliv182 May 16 '12

So when my web design teacher said Google's trying to take over the world, he was right...

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Well if you're concerned about someone overhearing what you say, maybe you shouldn't be saying that.
/meaningless snark, not to be taken with alcohol

1

u/Narcolepzzzzzzzzzzzz May 16 '12

I am sad that this is even patentable (if it actually is). Speech-to-text exists, scanning written communications (emails) to determine which ads to show exists, this idea can be seen as simply combining the two.

1

u/portnoys_xray May 16 '12

Utter bullshit headline. Read the article.

1

u/CCCPironCurtain May 16 '12

If google really wants to hear me masturbate, they can go for it.

1

u/BiggC May 16 '12

This probably won't be seen, but isn't this a logical extension of Google parsing your GMail inbox for key words to deliver ads?

1

u/LnRon May 16 '12

Google is the big brother. Support Microsoft, they want your money, not your privacy.

1

u/MrToadEsquire May 16 '12

That this is even a possibility, is scary as fuck. How the hell is this even allowable? I don't understand why everyone is trying to destroy our privacy rights. Our government should be defending these rights,not trying to find ways to circumvent them.

1

u/Drawtaru May 16 '12

Welp, that's it. I'm ditching all my technology and moving to a cave in Alaska.

1

u/theomegachrist May 16 '12

I don't have a problem with this. It would be an automatic process, it would be against the law to actually use it against you. People are perfectly happy with free Google products, but not with the ads. Would you be willing to pay to use Google products? I'd rather they deliver specialized ads to me personally.

1

u/phillyharper May 16 '12

I had Google navigation running and was having a conversation with my dad about how I planned on writing a book.

When I got home, Google was advertising 'how to get published ' ads to me. It was the first time I had seen the ads and now you I see them regularly.

Before this was posted I was going to post this story to /r/technology but the mods don't allow self posts.

Before you ask, no I had not emailed anyone else about this.

1

u/Jeembo May 16 '12

The good thing about google is that they won't automatically let the government have the recordings and they'll use this eavesdropping strictly for targeted advertising and no shady shit.

1

u/unnecessaryCAPS May 16 '12

I think it's perfectly acceptable. That being said, I'm deleting all my google accounts and using another service. I hope I'm not the only one who does this, just to make it clear its not something people are comfortable with. Goodbye google, it was a good run...

1

u/theBadgerJew May 16 '12

And the countdown to Skynet continues.

1

u/cpcallen May 16 '12

This does not surprise me at all - in fact, my totally-not-a-conspiracy-theorist girlfriend has for some time been pointing out surprising coincidences between things we've discussed in the presence of her phone (but not mentioned in any email or SMS) and AdWords ads she's later been presented with on Gmail.

We've even taken to having fake conversations about random but advertising-lucrative topics just to see if it will cause related ads to be shown.

1

u/greybyte May 16 '12

They can file a patent, but that won't get them around wiretap laws.

It might be possible in some jurisdictions because only one party need consent and they could force you to consent in the TOS (assuming this would be used on calls placed with google voice, for example). In others though it surely would not be because both parties need to consent.

1

u/10452BGHF May 16 '12

why when companies do something you don't like it's creepy

but when the collective internet users pirate media than the collective response to companies it's adapt or die ?

why not let privacy die OR who don't like it, to disconnect...

1

u/netizen69 May 16 '12

If they're going to monitor me by my inbuilt microphone, they better improve my fucking battery life first!!

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

When greed and tyranny combines.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

So what if I'm working on my music, and the person listening in at Google happens to be a scumbag musician that takes most of my song before I can finish it, and releases it before me? How would I even prove that it was originally mine? Fuck this, Google, leave me the fuck alone, no one really needs this feature.

1

u/kleenur May 16 '12

So much for "Don't be Evil". Time for a change of mission statement Mr. Googleman!

1

u/ricklegend May 16 '12

Google and Facebook companies are using advertising targeting as a bullshit guise to erode privacy protections. They frame the argument as we are doing you a favor by giving you better advertising by spying on you. Fuck that and fuck them it's gone too far.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

So I'm talking to my Mom on GoogleTalk and I mention how this guy at work is being a real dick. Suddenly, her screen starts showing ads for dildos and other "toys." ..... Did I go too far?

1

u/thatusernameisal May 16 '12

Disregarding google being creepy as usual this is a completely ridiculous patent for something completely obvious.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Google, you used to be so awesome, but now you are just a creepy uncle we all know will turn into a serial killer.

All the smart people at Google (and there are a LOT of them there!) should jump ship and start their own companies instead. Do some cool stuff AND be good guys when doing it. It's possible! (Mojang anyone?:))

1

u/CRASNY May 16 '12

Brilliant, in my opinion. AdSense is probably the best targeting online.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

W. t. F.

1

u/sanjay149 May 16 '12

Don't be evil?

1

u/crowonapost May 16 '12

Airplane mode solves almost all problems.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

As long as:

  • does not hinder the standard OS from working

  • does not impact on battery life

  • opt in

The latter is the most important. If this becomes mandatory we'll only see the rise in custom android builds without this and lose market share from the horrendous PR.... and im sure its in their interest to keep android as the main mobile OS of choice.

Google are in a HUGE mobile push investing millions, some could argue billions. But not just in mobiles but also g. glasses.. in fact anything portable... I believe this is an attempt to record not just our search history but well..our life... (think "The Entire History of You" of Charlie Brookers "Black Mirror" series [1]). Essentially they want the "word of mouth" marketing knowledge before anyone else giving Google a huge advantage in terms of statistical data. Getting this from mobile, glasses, "smart" watches and/or other tech doesn't matter to them.

IF given the option of having your conversations recorded with the usual 'you' are 'anonymous'... would you? the average person I believe will say yes if they were given something of value back...

[1] http://www.channel4.com/programmes/black-mirror/4od P.s. Sorry for grammar/spelling

tl;dr: Google want word of mouth to find the most current trends real time giving a huge advantage over any other marketing agency

1

u/Reidmcc May 16 '12

Does anyone have the actual text of the patent?

1

u/digivolve_already May 16 '12

hey Google...whatever happened to "don't be evil"?

1

u/cwfutureboy May 16 '12

Google being evil again.