r/technology • • May 10 '12

AdBlock WARNING "HBO co-president Eric Kessler has said he thinks the move away from traditional television to an internet-based model is just a fad that will pass"

http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/05/09/hbo-has-only-itself-to-blame-for-record-game-of-thrones-piracy/
2.6k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

1.0k

u/bat_guano May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

SEVERAL UPDATES

Most recently, the Forbes writer issued a retraction and apology. See below.

EDIT #1: ERIC KESSLER DIDN'T SAY THE MOVE FROM TRADITIONAL TV TO INTERNET iS A FAD THAT WILL PASS.

Phrasing it that way makes him look like an idiot. It makes Redditors pick up their pitchforks, even. But he simply didn't say that. Since my original post, the journalist (see below, he responded to it) has edited his article and added a link to the original interview, but the original phrase remains intact.

The quote was from a November 2011 interview, and the question was about cord-cutting. What he actually said, with light editing: "We've concluded that cord-cutting is minimal and has primarily been the result of macroeconomic conditions. That's not to say you don't hear anecdotes about people who say, 'I'm not going to do it anymore, I'm not going to pay money to the distributor.' ... Hopefully as the economy improves, if it ever improves, things will get better. But interestingly enough for HBO: HBO subscribers watch 14% more television, 19 hours more a month than non-HBO households. HBO subs love television... We've found that the HBO subscriber, they aren't the first people to cut the cord, they're the last. So we haven't seen any real impact."

I don't necessarily LIKE what he's saying. But two things:

  1. He's not talking about whether TV will move to an internet model generally. He's talking about whether HBO is losing current subscribers to cord-cutting. And according to his figures, the answer is, no, not really. And if that's true, well, it's true.

  2. He didn't say an internet-based model is a "fad that will pass." He said that whatever losses HBO has suffered are attributable to the economic downturn. Big difference.

Don't get me wrong. I want HBO to offer standalone online service, like everybody else here. I would buy it in a heartbeat. I don't subscribe to cable nor do I ever intend to. But everybody's reacting to a phrase he didn't say, which isn't fair.

Here's how I see this: HBO isn't stupid. They know where this industry is heading. They wouldn't build a massive cross-platform streaming service if they didn't think people wanted it. But the unfortunate reality is, they make almost all of their money through the cable companies. Always have. Charging money for a separate online subscription service would drive a stake into the heart of the cable companies and rattle the only business model HBO has ever known. The cable companies might even retaliate. HBO will do it anyway, eventually, when the politics and economics are right. Until then, pony up your cable fees, or fire up your bittorrents.

EDIT #2: THE ORIGINAL FORBES ARTICLE HAS BEEN REVISED.

The journalist responded to my original comment and revised his article. The "fad that will pass" line has been removed.

In the OP's defense, he didn't create the original distortion. It was in the article itself. Here's what the article originally said: "HBO co-president Eric Kessler has said he thinks the move away from traditional television to an internet-based model is just a fad that will pass – a temporary phenomenon."

Notice that it doesn't actually quote Kessler.

Here's what the article now says: "'Kessler explained he thinks cord cutting is more of a temporary phenomenon that will go away when the economy improves,' writes Ross Miller, in regards to comments Kessler made at the VideoShmooze: NYC Online Video Leadership Forum."

What's funny is, this revised version, while less damning than before, is STILL inaccurate. That's because the Forbes journalist now quotes what another journalist said Kessler said, instead of simply LISTENING TO THE INTERVIEW and quoting Kessler directly. Kessler didn't say "cord cutting is a temporary phenomenon that will go away when the economy improves." He said HBO's loss of subscribers is due to the economic downturn, and he HOPES that the change will reverse itself. Which is different.

So basically, a game of telephone happened. The journalist Ross Miller slightly mischaracterized Kessler's comments. The Forbes journalist distorted them even further with the "fad" comment. This line then got picked up by Reddit and held up for general ridicule.

And the cycle of life continues. Or something.

EDIT #3: ANNNNND THE ARTICLE HAS BEEN REVISED. AGAIN.

Just moments ago.

Here's what it now says: "HBO co-president Eric Kessler said that cord-cutting has been 'minimal' and largely the result of 'macroeconomic' conditions in an interview at the VideoShmooze: NYC Online Video Leadership Forum."

Okay, now it's accurate. Sorry if I've ruined your morning, Forbes writer guy.

EDIT #4: THE FORBES AUTHOR JUST POSTED A RETRACTION AND APOLOGY.

It's at the bottom of the article. Here it is in its entirety:

Note: An earlier edition of this piece described comments made by Eric Kessler that described his views of cord-cutting as a fad or “temporary phenomenon.” Kessler said that he viewed cord-cutting as “minimal” and a result of “macroeconomic conditions” indicating that should economic conditions improve cord-cutting will decrease. To me and others who have written about this, those words indicate that cord-cutting is a problem that will eventually go away as the economy improves – hence a fad or temporary phenomenon. It’s important to note that Kessler himself did not say “fad” or “temporary phenomenon” but his words and sentiment in the video do imply that he thinks the problem of cord-cutting is small and will likely go away, and that targeting the cord-cutting audience doesn’t make business sense. I paraphrased and quoted a secondary source. This was a mistake on my part and for that I apologize to both readers and HBO.

ORIGINAL POST:

Well, that's obviously a load of crap.

But one important point: Where's the actual quote? I can't find it anywhere in the article or elsewhere online. The article just says "Eric Kessler has said that he thinks..." but it doesn't quote his actual words or give any context.

The quote is so obviously, embarrassingly wrong, I'd like to verify that he actually said it, and if he did, whether he was in the middle of mollifying his large-scale cable provider partners or whatever.

Again, I'm not defending him, but before we make him an example of old school media stupidity, I'd like to know what he actually said.

41

u/Chboddis May 10 '12

Excellent point. The author seems to be referring to this interview here from November 2011 at the Videoschmooze conference in New York.

It's also cited in similar stories by The Verge and PaidContent.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/facecloud May 11 '12

"Until then, pony up your cable fees, or fire up your bittorrents." or go read a book! I'm anti PIPA, SOPA< CISPA, etc., but just because you can get something for free doesn't mean you have the right to. I'm kind of saddened by this mentality. There are lots of other options. Why not protest by reading some books, instead of implicitly endorsing the system that produces the kind of content (and legislation) that Hollywood does?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Charging money for a separate online subscription service would drive a stake into the heart of the cable companies and rattle the only business model HBO has ever known. The cable companies might even retaliate.

This. Unlike network television shows, whose revenue comes from advertising, HBO programming is commercial free premium content. There is a compelling argument to make that quality of their shows, the risks they are willing to take, the massive budgets for their series, etc. are the result of their subscription based business model. Rather than being beholden to sponsors, they are at the mercy of a loyal subscriber base.

The author of this article complains at one point about HBO shows not being available in Hulu or on Netflix. Prior to the advent of the internet and the proliferation of bandwidth, people complained that they couldn't watch HBO shows if they didn't have HBO (I know because I was one of those people). Now we are in the same place, only with more technology - HBO serves current content as a premium service online, but not on the "networks" (Netflix and Hulu). Some content is available elsewhere, but it is more limited - past seasons, old shows, etc. This is the same on television - you can watch HBO shows on other networks, but from past seasons and tailored to the platform (think Sopranos on A&E).

I think what frightens the cable companies more than getting content online is this idea that said content needs to be widely available on multiple platforms. This is what I believe must be reconciled in order for a comfortable transition from the existing television model to one which is web based. The notion that everything should be available to everyone all the time I'm sure is pretty terrifying to paid content providers. As long as we, as consumers, are uncompromising in the expectation that premium content should be widely available on the net, providers will knee-jerk in the opposite direction, and that is bad for everyone.

And it's not TV. It's HBO.

19

u/soulcakeduck May 11 '12

HBO subscribers watch 14% more television, 19 hours more a month

That statistic blew my mind. 14% more than average adds 19 hours a month!? That means on average people are watching 135 hours a month, 4.5 hours a day!

I knew I was an anomaly (probably closer to 8 hours a month overall, long stretches with none at all). And I always thought I used most of that time playing video games instead--nothing wrong with that.

But holy shit, I wish I could fit 135 hours of gaming into my month. I am insanely envious.

That explains a lot, too. Maybe if I got 135 hours of value out of it a month, my cable provider's prices would not seem so hilariously outrageous.

23

u/demotu May 11 '12

I'd love to know the difference in statistics between "the TV is on in the room I'm in" and "I am sitting down facing the television" hours, because I've definitely known households where the TV goes on when you get home and off when you go to bed, but only a fraction of that time is spent passively sitting in front of it.

That said, I am not a TV person but I'd hate to add up how many hours I spend doing non-work things online. I think I might hate myself a little bit if I knew that number.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (31)

2.2k

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Thank you Eric Kessler, for being a shining example of how media companies are out of touch with technology.

1.1k

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

HBO GO? Wow! Now I can watch HBO shows on demand, from my PC or Roku!!!

......reads fine print......

WTF!?! I have to have a subscription to HBO through an approved cable provider? I can't just pay $10-15/mo. or something? Screw you HBO.

304

u/maximumdownvote May 10 '12

And the hilarious thing is, HBO is one of the few cable channels that benefits most from an al la carte internet delivery of content. HBO makes shows that fucking rock. They are tied to the shitty channels by the current delivery channels, and are sometimes cut from the package because people cant afford to pay for "Basic" + HBO.

→ More replies (228)

1.4k

u/repete May 10 '12

I watch HBO Go via TPB.

→ More replies (129)

118

u/MinionOfDoom May 10 '12

This. I would have absolutely been willing to pay for the right to watch HBO Go. They won't let me because I don't want cable television. Screw them. They're losing out on thousands of dollars they could be making from a setup like that.

→ More replies (109)
→ More replies (106)

249

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

torrenting Game of Thrones right now in Eric Kessler's honor

64

u/ElectricPickpocket May 10 '12

I'm doing the mental calculations of how much beer I need to send Peter Dinklage as recompense for downloading. Anyone have a spare oil tanker?

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

118

u/cweaver May 10 '12

It's funny, because the actual cable companies think the exact opposite way.

I was at a 'cable television' conference a few years ago and everybody was already talking about how they need to stop calling themselves 'cable television' companies, because in a few years the only reason anyone will want cable is for the cable internet connection.

(also, sidenote, imagine how ridiculously fast your internet speeds would be if they used that entire pipe for data and got rid of the 500 tv channels wasting all the bandwidth)

112

u/ratlater May 10 '12

The existing DOCSIS3 spectrum is massively underutilised as it is, mostly because the big cablecos skimp on their NSP connections and try to screw everyone they peer with.

That isn't unique to cable, of course; the delta between what our telecommunications network is and what it could (and should) be is staggering, and it boils down to corruption-abetted incumbent greed, pure and simple.

→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (28)

33

u/rum_rum May 11 '12

Poor guy probably thinks MTV still has music videos.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/classiclantern May 10 '12

Yes it will pass... when something better comes along. The only thing we know for sure is it won't be any of the old technologies like crappy HBO programming.

19

u/No_Time_For_BS May 10 '12

It will pass when HBO lobbies more to have laws passed which stiffle online media services and essentially shut them down. This is PR so that when it happens they're not suspected by the masses, because as we all know "They thought it was just a fad that passed". The ignorant will think they were right, and those who follow politics won't take a look in their direction.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/unrealious May 10 '12

If you think about it, everything is a fad that will pass.

Eric Kessler - his entire life, HBO, you, me, the Internet, possibly even Game of Thrones.

But for now most of us would like access to the show despite having limited funds to pay more for it. Perhaps Eric can think of a business model that includes us. Or he can pretend we don't exist and wait till we don't.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (51)

474

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Ken Olsen, then president of DEC (Digital Equipment Corporation) said in 1977, at the beginning of the home computer revolution, that he could see no reason why anyone would ever have a computer at home.

For those of you too young to remember, DEC made a lot of very good computers for a very long time (relatively speaking.)

360

u/LaGrrrande May 10 '12

"I predict that within 100 years, computers will be twice as powerful, 10,000 times larger, and so expensive that only the five richest kings of Europe will own them." -Professor John Frink

77

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Man why would you want one that was twice as powerful but ten thousand times larger? Why wouldn't you just get two regular-sized ones?

→ More replies (9)

151

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Was going to reply with the famous 640k Bill Gates quote while we were on this trend, but when I googled it for exact wording, I learned i'd been duped

→ More replies (27)

20

u/opiv May 10 '12

Hahaha, my dad grew up with John Frink (the writer) and they joined a frat in college together where they spent a few hours locked in a trunk. John Frink is also the reason my dad didn't run away when he got into a fight with his dad (my granddad)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

46

u/criticismguy May 10 '12

To be fair, the kind of computers DEC sold in 1977, nobody has in their home today. Even if they cost $1 back then, consumers wouldn't have bought them for their house. And while it's definitely silly for anyone in technology to make a prediction with "ever" (which is a really long time), this is a magnitude of change which he might not have seen before.

The telephone in your ass-pocket probably puts to shame the computing power of all the processors DEC had sold to date in 1977. That was the year they first shipped a VAX, which was still refrigerator-sized, so the emphasis was still on performance in the same space, not similar performance in a smaller space.

To me, it sounds roughly like saying, today, "I see no reason why anyone would ever want to have a refrigerator in their pocket". Refrigerator manufacturers aren't really trying to make them smaller, and who needs a refrigerator in their pocket, anyway? And yet, if there were enough R&D done in this area, it's not totally inconceivable. I can imagine a future where this exists: the sweet new Levi's model has a pocket with a built-in fridge so you can keep your drink cool, or something. (Heated gloves are a thing, so why not cooled gloves?)

There are lots of things today which we don't think of as things that anybody would ever want to personally own, but which could have actual benefit if they became 5 or 10 orders-of-magnitude smaller, cheaper, and easier to use. Think nuclear reactors (or other power plants), satellites, or the "jaws of life". Movie cameras are pretty much just finishing this transition (again, check your ass-pocket), and I think 3d printers are right on the verge of making it.

63

u/gysterz May 10 '12

shut up and sell me refrigerator pants!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

8

u/dropkickninja May 10 '12

First computer I bought was a DEC. good machines.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

262

u/adrianmonk May 10 '12 edited May 11 '12

HBO's brilliant strategy, in a nutshell:

  • Create a highly regarded show.

  • Make sure it's targeted squarely and directly at the cord-cutter demographic.

  • Give no option for cord-cutters to legally get it.

  • Act like the inevitable result is an anomaly.

EDIT: "cord-cutters" means people who've decided to ditch cable and get TV/entertainment video programming other ways, like Netflix, Hulu, iTunes, or whatever else.

48

u/traphicone May 11 '12

Even calling these people "cord-cutters" really misses the mark. At this point, we're not only talking about people who have given up on television and cable. We're talking about a growing population of consumers who have never had either.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (12)

860

u/dropkickninja May 10 '12

Hes going to be proven wrong.

164

u/gamblekat May 10 '12

No one could reasonably believe what he's saying. An industry is disrupted by a cheaper, technologically superior, and more customer friendly delivery method, and then things magically go back to the way they were twenty years ago? If he believes that, I have some buggy whips to sell him.

But what else is he going to say? The truth? "We know cable is fucked, but they threatened to stop marketing HBO if we offered a streaming service that doesn't require cable."

It's going to play out just like PC game publishing. For the longest time everyone was too afraid of retaliation from retail distributors to support a system like Steam, but eventually the customers moved away and the game publishers weren't making enough money from retail to worry about pissing them off, and they all migrated to digital distribution.

→ More replies (17)

468

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He was, even before he opened his mouth.

179

u/XZlayeD May 10 '12

I really like a lot of the shows HBO creates, so i really hope he changes his mind, because they will lose revenue if they don't follow with the times.

→ More replies (92)

48

u/Delheru May 10 '12

It's tough to know if he really believes that. The implications of him saying that he thinks it's there to stay with HBO's relationship with cable providers would be... momentous, to say the least, and probably quite dangerous.

Until HBO knows what it has in mind, as a board member I would murder the CEO that said "we think this internet thing will win the day" without having a plan for what to do with the cable companies freak the fuck out.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (63)

29

u/P1h3r1e3d13 May 10 '12

This 'telephone' has too many shortcomings to be seriously considered as ameans of communication. The device is inherently of no value to us.

Western Union internal memo, 1876.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/rocknameded May 10 '12

With the right legislation, this very well could just be a fad.

9

u/burrito_fucker May 10 '12

scary but true

201

u/faultlessjoint May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I would pay $8/month to have access to HBO streaming online. HBO, if you're listening, I will stop pirating all of your content if you can provide it to me streaming for around $8/month (I'm flexible, willing to negotiate).

That's my $8 straight into your pocket. No worrying about negotiations with dickhead telecoms. And you will be getting a ton of page visits from me, so be sure to load up your page with ads.

EDIT: I realize $8 might be a little low. As I said, I'd be willing to negotiate. Since I don't watch all of their shows, just some, I'd do a per episode or per season plan. Maybe $2 per episode or perhaps $20-$30 for a season (depending on # of episodes, video quality, and whether or not I could download and save it).

236

u/gotnate May 10 '12

HBO, if you're listening

I found your problem right here. HBO isn't listening.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/zmann May 10 '12 edited May 11 '12

$8 a month? It costs like $15 WITH your cable subscription (meaning it might even be subsidized at that price).

Edit: Here's the actual interview: http://videonuze.com/article/video-interview-hbo-co-president-eric-kessler-at-videoschmooze

At least they have a reason for keeping it bundled with cable.

→ More replies (25)

15

u/adrianmonk May 10 '12

Actually they do have to worry about negotiations with dickhead telecoms. Dickhead telecoms who may be unhappy about not being the exclusive source for this content.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

71

u/Nicebirdie May 10 '12

He does not know that Winter is Coming.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

HBO: they cannot lose if they do not play.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

124

u/Boxcore May 10 '12

I remember when old people said the same thing about the internet itself.

28

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Not even old people. Less then two decades ago the idea of a PC in every home, phones that were computers, and tablets that were portable computers, were looked at as out of the range of the everyday person.

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (6)

157

u/bobjohnsonmilw May 10 '12

So apparently this is why I'd be forced into having cable in order to watch it online. Idiots like this in charge.

Hey HBO! You want another subscriber? Drop the cable requirement. Until you do, I'll just wait for it to be available via netflix and then I'll rip the discs, just to deprive you of the monthly subscription, and to avoid getting sued by you assholes for downloading it.

14

u/stash600 May 10 '12

You might have to keep waiting. Netflix won't get the same sweetheart deals on the premium channels like they did the first time around.

40

u/ac_slat3r May 10 '12

That's why i just download the shit for free....

If t was easy and convenient I would pay for it, but they make is so I have to sign a contract with Comcast to watch their shows.

It's just like the record and movie industry where they are using outdated and archaic means of delivering their product to their consumers. Just as DRM is doing to PC gamers, this will only increase piracy.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Jesus. Is this guy 100? "Traditional television" is next decade's Blockbuster.

News flash for you old farts: if it's digital, we want instant access to it from any place with a Net connection on any device with a screen. That's the level of convenience we want, and we'll pay for it. If you don't give it to us, the pirates will.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/natemc May 10 '12

Hey HBO, I would subscribe directly on the internet, I will not sign up for a TV cable package though.

Get with it!

16

u/Havok310 May 11 '12

Knock knock

Who's there?

Blockbuster

Blockbuster who?

EXACTLY!

I'm sure the movie rental industry execs said the same thing at some point

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Londron May 10 '12

I'm a 21 year old living on my own and I don't own a tv.

Pc>tv. Sorry.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/not_the_droids May 10 '12

"I believe in the horse. The automobile is only a temporary phenomenon."

           - Kaiser Wilhelm II.

Steve Ballmer on the iPhone

→ More replies (8)

12

u/pillage May 10 '12

So we'll be laughing at this like the "Online shopping will never catch on" article?

23

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Dear HBO:

Please let me give you my money. Please, please, please, please, please, please. I want to give you money for your product. I am begging you to let me purchase it. Allow me access to what you're selling for I am a consumer.

It boggles my mind that you refuse to let me pay you for your product.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/whiskyyy May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I do not understand idiots like this in huge businesses. How did they get this far being closed minded morons? HBO would make so much money if they offered an online subscription service. Or maybe even cheap subscriptions to single shows if you didn't want the whole package. How is capitalism failing to work here? Does he not like money? Help us increase our fucking utility dumb ass. We will GIVE YOU MONEY.

EDIT: Thanks to bat_guano's enlightening comment I realize I was a little harsh on poor Mr. Kessler. Although, as Redditor, I defend my right to get really uppity and pissed off after reading a poorly written article, taking it as complete fact, and doing no research of my own.

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Its called the Peter Principle:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Principle

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/JrMint May 10 '12

The Internet: it's not TV, it's downloadable HBO.

25

u/ArrogantGod May 10 '12

If you own stock in HBO it's time to demand this idiot is fired.

11

u/plinysheir May 11 '12

If you own stock in HBO TimeWarner it's time to demand this idiot is fired.

FTFY

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

55

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

forbes' site sucks. tfa.

HBO Has Only Itself To Blame For Record 'Game Of Thrones' Piracy*

Andy Greenberg has some troubling numbers on HBO’s Game of Thrones. Turns out the show is not only really popular with HBO subscribers, it’s also really popular with pirates who are well on their way to making this the most-pirated show ever.

According to Greenberg, “the second season of the show has been downloaded more than 25 million times from public torrent trackers since it began in early April, and its piracy hit a new peak following April 30th’s episode, with more than 2.5 million downloads in a day.”

Meanwhile, season one of the show was the second-most-pirated season of all time, right behind the sixth season of Dexter.

Now, it’s important to note the reason for all this piracy: lack of access to the show for people who can’t afford, or choose not to purchase, a cable-TV subscription.

“HBO hasn’t helped the problem by making the show tough to watch online for the young and cable-less,” notes Greenberg. “The show isn’t available through Hulu or Netflix, iTunes offers only Season 1, and using HBO’s own streaming site HBO Go requires a cable subscription.”

For the millions of Americans who don’t subscribe to HBO, or who may not even watch shows on a television, this means there is no legal way to watch Game of Thrones. If you only watch TV on your laptop, there’s no way you’re going to pay $50/month for cable and another $15/month for HBO.

For people like me who wish HBO would sever ties with cable television and offer its own streaming service that didn’t require a cable subscription, that doesn’t look at all likely. HBO GO will remain available only to cable television subscribers rather than as a stand-alone service. HBO co-president Eric Kessler has said he thinks the move away from traditional television to an internet-based model is just a fad that will pass – a temporary phenomenon.

But HBO is missing out on a huge potential audience by limiting themselves to cable TV subscribers. I don’t blame the company for keeping their shows off of Hulu or Netflix, but offering HBO GO as a stand-alone service could put a serious dent in these piracy numbers, and bring in a lot more legitimate viewers to shows like Game of Thrones.

Of course, on the one hand I hate to see a show that I love getting pirated. I want the show to succeed, and for it to do that it needs to prove that it draws a large audience. But HBO has only themselves to blame at this point. Cord-cutting is not a fad. It’s a trend. Kessler may talk tough when he says that cord-cutters will never see HBO shows, but unless he can take on the torrents single-handedly, then these are just words.

This underscores the larger problem with how so many companies in the entertainment industry think about piracy. Instead of thinking about the ways lack of access to media creates opportunity for piracy, and how increasing the access to products could help stave off illegal downloads, too often people want to take legal measures or implement digital protection on their products. These “fixes” always have easy work-arounds.

Meanwhile, the millions of pirated Game of Thrones episodes show that it’s not difficult at all for non-subscribers to enjoy the show. I’m willing to bet that a stand-alone HBO GO service would largely fix this problem, though nothing will stop piracy altogether.

P.S. I personally don’t condone piracy, but I think it’s very important to see why people do it in the first place. We subscribe to cable-TV for only a few months of the year – just so we can watch Game of Thrones. But I would happily pay more for a stand-alone HBO GO service year round than the $15 (I think) it costs to tack on HBO to our cable. This would net HBO even more revenue over the course of a year. Quite a bit more, actually.

65

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

They got angry crowds shouting "SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY!" and they stick their fingers in their ears and pretend it's 1980. It would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/zpkmook May 11 '12

I would also mention HBO to GO offers no quality controls and is terribly slow on my connection (1.5MBps ,yes also slow I admit) and I can't reliably buffer or download the show in decent quality. I would wait a few hours but the service basically starts streaming it in 1080p and would take all day if I manually paused it. I basically get 240p and it still takes 2 hours to watch a one hour show. Also HBO to go was down after a new premiere giving more incentive to pirate it despite paying plenty for it already.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

21

u/maxd May 11 '12

I sent Eric Kessler a letter; both by email (to what I guessed his email address to be), and to their corporate headquarters.

Dear Mr Kessler,

I wanted to write to you in reference to the supposed quote of you saying that the shift away from traditional television to an internet based model being just a temporary phenomenon. I'm a 30 year old professional, resident in California, and I have a good deal of disposable income. As a single parent and with a time consuming job I don't have a lot of disposable time, so I am discerning about how I spend it.

HBO creates some of the best entertainment out there; I would definitely choose to watch such high quality programming over the drivel that other cable channels have to present. And yet, you make the bar for entry unnecessarily high. I am required to pay for a full cable subscription, with literally hundreds of channels I have no interest in seeing, and then I'm still not allowed to watch HBO content on the device that I want; DirecTV prevents me from watching HBO Go on my Roku devices around the house.

And so, I cancelled my cable subscription. I even ate the early cancellation fee, I just wasn't happy having such an inefficient model in my life. And now my money will go elsewhere. I'll buy the Blu-rays of Game of Thrones because it's a great show, and you'll get $40ish a year from me (less manufacturing, marketing, stocking, etc costs). But I won't be seeing trailers for your other shows, I won't be invested in your station, I won't be watching the movies you have available or the (excellent) additional content you produce. I no longer am invested in your brand, I'm invested in a single show that you produce.

And yet here I am, with all this disposable income. Why can I not pay it directly into your bank account? Mr Kessler, I would love to direct debit $20 straight to you every month for the privilege of watching HBO shows on my iPad and my Roku when and where I want. I'd even still buy the Blu-rays, and you'd have turned me into an HBO fan. And there are millions like me; millions who are cutting their cable subscriptions because they are tired of the inconvenience; there are those who can't afford the approximately $80 necessary to get HBO at present; there are those who never even considered getting a cable subscription because it doesn't fit their life style.

So please, embrace the internet, and we'll welcome you into our lives. You have no competition at present, but that won't last for long.

Sincerely,

(My Name)

7

u/runningformylife May 10 '12

It's also worth noting that many cable companies will offer HBO or other premium channels for free when their customers threaten to terminate their service.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Chboddis May 10 '12

Bigger picture here: HBO is owned by Time Warner. Verily, a third of Time Warner's annual revenue is from "Subscriptions." They are heavily vested in the current cable model.

Any change to that model (e.g. spinning off HBO into a non-cable subscription service) is going to come slowly at best, never at worst, which is unfortunate for HBO. A network that produces such quality content deserves a management team that can producer both quality distribution and revenue, not the myopia that Kessler is demonstrating.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If the internet is so irrelevant, why bother fighting online piracy? All those morons will just go back to watching TV after the "fad" is over... right?

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

"After taking another massive bong hit, Kessler continued by explaining how TV was totally like in our heads, and in the future the government would just like beam it directly into our brains."

16

u/btech1138 May 10 '12

Unfortunately for him, his generation is a fad that will pass - and with it, their notions of how things are 'supposed' to work.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

But not before they fuck everything up with their foolish meddling.

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

HBO airs (or aired in the past) many of my current favorite shows: boardwalk empire, bored to death, curb your enthusiasm, summer heights high, the wire, etc.) Ironically enough I hadnt really watched many if any of these shows before 2011 and the sole reason I have been able to do so and have learned about other excellent HBO shows has been through the Internet and torrenting more specifically. HBO keeps it up, I keep pirating. If HBO offers a streaming service than I will gladly subscribe

16

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

To my surprise they introduced their HBO Go platform also in my country. When I heard that and read that it costs like just 10 PLN /month I wanted to instantly buy year long subscription. But no... they tied it to cable/satellite subscription. This... is so stupid I cannot even comprehend that. HBO - I want to give you my money. Just take it for christ's sake. I feel you deserve it, you feel you deserve it. Stop putting road blocks like a technological illiterate grandpa with schizophrenia...

→ More replies (1)

7

u/stash600 May 10 '12

The cable contracts are much more profitable than any subscription based model.

If they offered competing models, of course there would be tons of people who just want HBO's online service, which would then mean less people subscribing to cable's premium packages. It's in the cable company's best interest to keep all the channels together rather than letting you say "screw it I already have HBO, what do I need the cable version for"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/baalroo May 11 '12

These idiots are shooting themselves in the foot.

If they just charged a buck or two for a DRM free download of the show in my preferred format the moment the show airs, I would stop pirating... but you've gotta be out of your fucking mind if you think I'm going to pay $80+ A MONTH to watch one fucking show.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

"Boy Bands are going out of style" -- told to the Beatles before they became big.

"Apple II forever" -- Apple campaign in 1985 after the Macintosh was released.

"This new rebellious, raw, so-called music will not last a year" -- A review about Elvis' performance on Milton Berle's TV show.

The world is full of missed predictions like this. They make the world a far more humorous place to live.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

AT&T said the same thing about VoIP telephony back when everyone had a land line through them or someone similar.

I believe they wound up getting out of the POTS business and focusing on newer technologies...

4

u/leif777 May 11 '12

Hey Eric... have you taken a look at how many downloads Game of Thrones is getting on the torrents?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/whoderpsmost May 10 '12

This guys crazy he should know that the shift from traditional radio broadcasts to television is just a fad that will pass.

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

wow, co-president of HBO and a comedian too!

11

u/aghrivaine May 10 '12

This isn't as crazy as it sounds. There's a lot of talk - especially in this thread - about wanting to just pay a content-provider directly and not have to have cable TV. But think about how that proposition scales.

First - how are you getting your data? If you're getting all your entertainment over the internet, and so are all your neighbors, the price of that data pipe is going to go up. Partly because ISPs are profit-seeking companies, but partly because when demand increases, supply must increase to meet that demand, and that increase in supply requires capital to acquire.

Second - who is paying the content creators? Right now studios (generally but not universally) make movies, shows, mini-series, you name it, on an independent basis, and then sell it to a network. When the content proves popular, they have leverage to get more money from the network in the future. If it doesn't, it gets cancelled.

The networks aggregate content. How do they make money? It's principally through advertising, or in the example of HBO, which so many of you are using as your prime example, through subscription. But there's a lot of networks out there, and a very, very small fraction of them have the market share that HBO does, so a pure subscription budget is not likely to work.

You'd better believe that an "over the top" provider of content is coming - I know, I'm working on it. But I have grave misgivings about its viability. Yes, the company that provides this OTT service is likely to make a fast profit - but it will be at the expense of other people in the chain. Without subscription and advertising, there will be much less money in the system to pay content creators - the ultimate outcome will be less content, of lower quality.

I suspect the near future, and for a good long time to come, will continue to be a hybrid of subscription to a provider, buying internet access from an ISP (sometimes the same person) and additional cost for either premium content, or additional income from advertising. The proportion of one to the other may sway in a different direction - but I really doubt that the market as it currently exists can support a model where you don't need to pay a provider - just buy the content you want.

Or if it did, it would represent access to a lot LESS content than you currently enjoy, because the cost to produce stuff isn't going to go down, so if you can't spread the cost across a lot of consumers, you have to charge a premium. For people who are picky, and just watch a few things here and there - that model would be great. For anyone who likes to have a lot of choice, though, it will be not so great.

Buying content directly from creators isn't anything like the panacea most of you seem to think it is. It would have seismic effects on the entire industry. But it IS coming, believe me.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Clbull May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

As a Brit, I would willingly pay between £15 - £30 per month if a service similar to Netflix or Hulu were made available where:

  • All US TV shows and their entire back catalogs from major networks/organisations such as HBO, ABC, NBC, FOX, ESPN, Comedy Central, Cartoon Network, Nickelodeon, MTV, Adult Swim etc were made available.

  • You can watch major US TV channels on a livestream with 720p/1080p support.

  • With each episode available immediately after it was first broadcasted in the United States. None of this "You have to wait 3 days/3 months/6 months" bullshit due to overly shitty licensing terms. In the internet age where we can transmit information across the world literally within minutes, we should not be waiting six fucking months to (through legal means) watch a television show from the United States.

  • No subscriber exclusivity. I stopped watching many shows because they became exclusive to a digital service that I did not have (cough Sky cough)

  • In VOD format. That's right. Videos on Demand. Watch the episodes when you like after they've been broadcasted in the States, not when they're next syndicated on a channel or anything like that.

  • With 720p/1080p high definition settings whereever possible.

  • Xbox 360/PS3/Wii-U/iOS/Android integration via downloadable apps.

  • Ad free.

If such a service were made available in the United Kingdom, I would yell "SHUT THE FUCK UP AND TAKE MY GODDAMN BRITISH POUNDS" and sign the hell up immediately.

Sadly, the closest service to have even remotely come close to this has been the Pirate Bay. And that is why piracy currently seems like a winning option for a lot of people, because despite being illegal, free, technically stealing and there being a minute chance of you getting caught and sued to fucking oblivion, it's the only way Brits can get service on the level of what many US residents currently get for a lot of shows..... for free. Yes, Netflix exists and is £5.99 a month but it seems like they spent all their budget on getting the back catalog of Heroes, 24, Mythbusters and Prison Break on the service, managed to get a few good BBC/Channel 4 shows on there too but everything else just falls flat. If anime is theoretically quite cheap to licence compared to a lot of other shows, then it shows how lacking Netflix really is in the UK budget department when 95% of the anime they have is obscure even to anime-freak standards.

When watching ad supported free episodes of major TV shows like South Park, the OC, Glee, Family Guy, The Simpsons etc online becomes a luxury that only the United States and her citizens can enjoy, you know these television networks have dun goofed, in a major fucking way.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/KingMordy2011 May 10 '12

I will try to remember that as I download each and every episode of my favorite HBO series.

6

u/faptastics May 10 '12

Ladies and Gentlemen, WE HAVE A DUMB ASS!

3

u/belialadin May 10 '12

how come they don't double their profits by providing content on the internet and television? i'm just curious. seems logical.

3

u/SoCo_cpp May 10 '12

I just sat in on my local county co-op's update meeting today on their progress of laying redundant fiber in rural IL. They mentioned the IP TV service they will be rolling out. Me thinks Eric Kessler missed the memo. If this super rural area will be tech'd up shortly, then the rest of the country will be following suit if they aren't there all ready. Gotta love those rural communication grants.

3

u/huskarx2 May 10 '12

HBO is taking a stance for short term profit.

If they offer shit online, then there is little reason for anyone to subscribe (in the future) - their current income base would lessen significantly. Which is why I imagine that there isn't a pay-per-episode sort of thing. They are doing this idiotic thing that blockbuster did, crazy how CEOs get paid so much. So many of them are just complete morons.

3$ a pop on their own website or youtube even would greatly increase their revenue and exposure. Why would you not want to offer your product for less but to a base many many times greater? Fire the guy now.

AMC really showed how it is done by offering extremely high quality shows to a basic cable audience. It went from an obscure channel to THE channel on cable.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ItsARealThing May 10 '12

So right, I can't wait for the days to pay an exuberantly higher sum to be able to have dozens of channels in subscription so I can watch the 3 I enjoy a fraction of the programming on.

So spot on, why I actually really wish I could subscribe to programming packages that play serial television with 30% more advertising. Advertising and excess cost are what I love the most about television and I can't WAIT to just pay for more of it. Having been called out on just being part of a more cost-friendly, on-demand service fad I now see the light. I think I'll get a 200 channel package... Because I want to make sure I can watch the things I'm not whatsoever interested in, just in case.

3

u/fleagle66 May 10 '12

"I know this because, with help from Comcast, we're doing everything in our power to ensure no one can get content via the Internet."

3

u/DrellAssassin May 10 '12

Weird, I watch all of HBO's shows on their internet service, HBO...

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

if I were a share holder I'd demand his termination.

3

u/Champ-Kind May 10 '12

In other news, Eric Kessler will be unemployed in six months

3

u/bob-fossil May 10 '12

"Television won't last because people will soon get tired of staring at a plywood box every night." Darryl Zanuck, a movie producer at 20th century fox in 1946.

3

u/alexjp3 May 10 '12

Just like that whole new fangled "digital music" thing

→ More replies (1)

3

u/apullin May 10 '12

He's partly right. There is going to be a "bandwidth crisis", a lot like the Enron/California energy crisis; that is, it's going to be faked, to create a market wherein people can make boatloads of money. It's already happened in Canada, with their 2GB caps. It's happened on mobile networks, where unlimited == limited. It's going to happen. It'll be like that episode of South Park, "there just ain't enough internet to go around".

Also, HBO Go sucks. Can't watch a show like Game of Thrones when it airs, since the servers are hit so hard that the quality is low. Of course, a torrent can bring it down at 6MB/s ...

HBO Go might works OK if they preloaded the episodes in an encrypted format throughout the day, especially if they used a swarming network, and then release a player decryption key at airtime.

3

u/Eternal2071 May 11 '12

He is most likely correct in regards to it being a fad that will pass. What he does not realize or has failed to mention is that the television "fad" will pass way before the internet "fad" does. Something will replace the net. Rest assured it will not be antiquated technology.

3

u/Tommymonster May 11 '12

I used to work for HBo, and interacted with Eric's office several times over my nearly four years there. The man is brilliant when it comes to empowering his people with viral marketing and maintaining the aura of HBO's programming. That said, he - and the rest of the HBO executive family - definitely have made some poor decisions when it comes to moving HBO forward.

3

u/b00ks May 11 '12

He might be right, if the ISPs keep throttling traffic.

3

u/AutonomousRobot May 11 '12

Tell that to Blockbuster.

3

u/marriage_iguana May 11 '12

Geez, if only HBO shows were targeted at a relatively young, somewhat affluent and tech-savvy audience that appreciates good quality content and is willing to pay for it as long as they're not being tied down to an antiquated model that requires them to pay for services they don't want or need...
A MAN CAN DREAM... A MAN CAN GODDAMMIT.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Tomorrow's headline: Man is Idiot.

3

u/MMBK May 11 '12

Eric Kessler buys CD singles.

3

u/Master_Wizard_ May 11 '12

He must know something that we don't know..

maybe it's not a fad that will pass, but a fad that will be demonized by the government.

CISPA anyone?

3

u/Bittebitte May 11 '12

Yep. That internet based model is a FAD. Like the wheel, or books, or tv, or the internet. Yep, just another silly little fad that won't profoundly affect the way we think and live our lives at all. Good call Kessler.

3

u/Altair1371 May 11 '12

Right, right. And in the early 1900's they said horseless carriages would never catch on.

3

u/dfassna1 May 11 '12

Throw out your smartphones. Landlines are coming back, baby!

3

u/ass-moe May 11 '12

Actually, not. Someone actually read more than the article: http://dcurt.is/hbo-forbes-journalism

TLDR: Eric Kessler never said that.

3

u/veddy_interesting May 11 '12

In fairness, Kessler may not be entirely nuts. "According to a new report from Nielsen, the number of U.S. homes that have broadband Internet, but only free, broadcast TV, is on the rise. Although representing less than 5% of TV households, the number has grown 22.8% over the past year."

The growth of this trend is impressive, but it's from a relatively tiny base. Creating great content is expensive, and you have a business model to protect. What should you do?

IMHO, the place to experiment is HBO Go. It's probably possible to test multiple pricing scenarios based on location, and figure out what will work.

Redditors may feel that "everyone who's not an idiot is cutting the cord", but 1) Redditors are exceptionally smart and good-looking (not to mention susceptible to flattery) and 2) Idiots (and the can't-be-bothered, and the too-busy, and the don't-care groups) outnumber the rest of us by a significant margin.

3

u/rudeboyrave May 11 '12

whos that stealin up all your shows? scumbag steve! scumbag steve! torrents all day makin it rain on hoes! scumbag steve! scumbag steve!

3

u/FashionSense May 11 '12

reminds me of the record producer who told the Beatles he wouldn't sign them because guitar-based bands were just a fad that was going to die out really soon.

5

u/runtothesun May 10 '12

He sounds like Blockbuster when they told Reed Hastings of Netflix to fuck off and laughed him out of the board room.

Now look at Blockbuster...

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A Wharton MBA doesn't mean that you're intelligent.

Trust me.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

First of all, this is stupid. I haven't had cable for almost 2 years and don't miss it at all. I have an antenna so I can get quite a few channels OTA but I rarely use it. I have my own netflix account, use my sister's hulu plus account, and use my parents hbo go account. I pay 8 dollars a month and have more tv than I can watch...and I watch a lot.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Another passing fad: HBO.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I have a feeling that this might have something to do with the cable and satellite companies not wanting HBO to have their own streaming option. It might hurt them.

2

u/Summus May 10 '12

It's good to have friends who subscribe, have no use for HBOGO and are willing to share their password.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Digital332006 May 10 '12

So I tried to send them an email, suggesting that creating a poll to view how much interest there would be in an online option, turns out you need to be a registered HBO customer to contact them. I assume they have strict contracts with the cable providers but it's still a shame to not see them on the internet. I hope they don't die off in the future because of their lack of innovation but they need to learn.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/deanwormser May 10 '12

Thats too bad. I was really looking forward to HBO's "internet station". I would have paid a reasonable price for it. High def streams are easily accessible now. Sometimes people say things they are not sure of to gage peoples opinions. His statement is not that surprising given his loyalties to the, "greater good" of the industry.

2

u/zeruch May 10 '12

He's not in the minority in that sector. It's all a bit deluded in LA and NYC in terms of them being completely boggled at the fact that the TVs limited functionality isn't wooing people back to it.

I honestly think its the weirdest, surreal kind of group psychosis.

2

u/Sevii May 10 '12

Well, that is going to prevent me from spending any money on HBO products.

2

u/antman100 May 10 '12

Just recently, watching shows on the internet has gotten way better. Less commercials. Only 15-30 seconds between segments. And having the player remember where you left off! OMG! Too bad the players don't let you "resize." Full screen is just too big and the low rez feed is terrible for a bigger view.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I would gladly pay per episode to watch my favorite HBO shows (Game of Thrones and Boardwalk Empire) if they were available to stream online. Because they are not, I just stream them from illegal sites instead, as I'm definitely not paying the $50/mo for premium cable just to watch two shows.

2

u/mapoftasmania May 10 '12

He's forgetting that TVs are now Internet enabled. Watching on small computer screens may be a fad that will pass as more big screens go online, but the internet is here to stay.

2

u/OneArmedNoodler May 10 '12

"Television won't last. It's a flash in the pan." - Mary Somerville

2

u/ahnold11 May 10 '12

Seeing this sentiment still irks me some:

Forbes Author: Of course, on the one hand I hate to see a show that I love getting > pirated. I want the show to succeed...

Yes because Game of Thrones being Pirated has stopped it from being a success. Yes it has certainly caused the show to make less money, but it already makes buckets and is admitted in the article has extremely successful. So shouldn't the correct answer of a fan be "meh, who cares, as long as they keep making the show".

If the main argument against piracy is that it can cause things to fail (ie." if no one buys music then we will have no music!", then as long as the pirated content is successful enough to still be produced, we should be fine.

He is a fan, and so he hates to see piracy, even though admittedly it doesn't affect him in any way shape or form (he won't lose the show he likes).

I'm not arguing for or against piracy, merely just pointing out how this particular line of reasoning always bugs me for it's inconsistency.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

HBO co-president Eric Kessler is a fucking moron.

2

u/Apositivebalance May 10 '12

I've told a bunch of my friends at work how awesome this show is. Their responses have all been "ok, I'll check it out on nextflix".

I have Time Warner cable and can't even watch it on HBO GO because TW isn't an approved cable company.

If you could pay $15 a month for HBO on the web I'm sure tons of ppl would do it. The only reason that wouldn't work is because they're probably under contract with the cable companies.

In 5 years it will be much different I bet.

2

u/TheDebaser May 10 '12

Yeah, because things that are more convenient always eventually succumb to the traditional way of doing things. Right Ipods? Right fast food? Right E-mail?

2

u/The_Painted_Man May 10 '12

Good luck with that.

2

u/Ofthedoor May 10 '12

R.I.P HBO

2

u/TYPE_FASTER May 10 '12

He's a fool. I would pay him for access to HBO content. But I will not pay the cable providers for their content plus HBO. I am not alone.

Edit to say we actually used to have cable, but dropped it for Netflix. $140 -> $65/mo. About $1k/yr. HBO is good but not $1k/yr good.

2

u/hakushonan May 10 '12

Email is just a fad. People will go back to letters and post cards any day now

2

u/frostymoose May 10 '12

Alternate headline: "Internet user frostymoose has said he thinks if HBO doesn't see some change in management soon, they will soon be out of business"

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A fad, as in the profits aren't as much as the television model. They could easily set up a Internet model, but they've done the research and know it isn't as profitable. It's a dying model, but it's still better to make as much now as you can. HBO may be dead in 10 years anyway, with or without a Internet site.

I download Game of Thrones and purchase merchandise to support the show. Still, shows like that are loss leaders designed to get people to sign up for yearly contracts. The profits are in the bundling.

2

u/FlapjackOmalley May 10 '12

"We don't like their sound, and guitar music is on the way out."

-Decca Records -1962 (Regarding "The Beatles")

2

u/powercorruption May 10 '12

Sorry, but technology doesn't work like that. Things are only going to move forward, we don't move backward.

I know our political leaders are desperately trying to put the internet to a halt, but it's just not going to happen.

2

u/AntiTheory May 10 '12

this is why I don't feel bad about torrenting this show. If I could just pay 15 bucks and watch just Game of Thrones, I'd do it in a heartbeat because that's honestly far easier than downloading each individual episode with varying quality each week, risking a cease-and-desist notice from Time Warner and having my internet shut off because I don't have control over my television subscription.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Awkward_Man_Hugs May 10 '12

"Airplanes are interesting toys but of no military value" -Marshal Ferdinand Foch, French military strategist, 1911 These two have very similar insight on the future of technologies in their respective points in time.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

here, let me smoke all of this crack before I go to work today.

2

u/darkhunt3r May 10 '12

Seems like the modern version of "The car will never replace the horse"

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

How do people that stupid get to be in such high places.

Either that, or he's got some inside info that the internet is about to get slain.

2

u/lask001 May 10 '12

So what your saying is, he's retarded.

2

u/cory299e8 May 10 '12

Dear HBO: Fire that guy now. Right now. You make great shows, and I'd like you to still be around in 10 years.

2

u/P3chorin May 11 '12

Corporate leaders who don't understand huge trends like this should lose their jobs immediately.

2

u/epic_neckbeard_man May 11 '12

A record company decided not to sign The Beatles saying guitar bands were a fad that would pass.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Just like the internet is a fad. And eventually we'll all go back to paying our bills through snail mail.

Suit yourself. You're just missing out on profit.

If I could get HBO Go for like $10-15 a month, high quality streaming with no ads, I'd get it in a heartbeat.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Just like how music will be listen cassette again, right?

2

u/Luckycheater May 11 '12

I live in Rochester ny. Both my grandfathers and my father worked for Kodak. Kodak thought digital technology would never overtake film.

2

u/sinarb May 11 '12

Oh noes, I'm one of the piraters

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, that settles it then, I'll just cancel my Hulu and Netflix subscribtions right now and sign up for the most expensive cable package I can find. Eric Kessler has spoken!

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Thankfully the creative talent under your employ are far more intelligent, because that is what is keeping your channel afloat.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yea, because the past 10 years I've spent without a TV have been awful. I'm totally going to get over this phase. Haha, just kidding, fuck that shit.

2

u/dfawdjskf May 11 '12

That's a shame, I liked HBO...

2

u/skytro May 11 '12

So... basically he thinks the internet will die out?

2

u/alien8r May 11 '12

I can understand thinking that, but saying it just sounds ignorant.

2

u/haddock420 May 11 '12

Yeah, I'll totally abandon the fad of getting TV shows in high quality whenever I want, completely free, without ads.

Why would I want to stick with that fad anyway, when I can pay a monthly fee to see my favourite show once a week, amongst a bunch of shows I don't like, with ad breaks every 15 minutes?

This silly fad will go the way of the dinosaur.

2

u/Thefriendlyfaceplant May 11 '12

I'd definitely be willing to pay a few bucks per GoT episode online but piracy is my only access to the show.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

i made the move to downvote, but then realizing downvoting the subjects idiocy is not the proper way to express bemusement, so an upvote to the poster instead!

2

u/grantai May 11 '12

Have you seen the quality on HBO Go? It's pretty horrendous. I doubt any one of you would pay more than $10/mo for this.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

redditor bwillb has said he thinks HBO co-president Eric Kessler is off his rocker.

2

u/TwwIX May 11 '12

And this guy is the co-president of HBO? Wow! Just wow! HBO, you have a lot of great artists working on your many wonderfully entertaining and award winning shows. However, the people that are running your company are short sighted fools and they are completely out of touch with its audience and today's technology.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/funkgerm May 11 '12

In the time it took me to read that article I downloaded the latest episode of Game of Thrones in 720p. But I guess this whole digital distribution thing is just a fad, right Eric?

2

u/cran May 11 '12

AMC begs to differ.

2

u/funk_monk May 11 '12

To some extent I agree with him. All the internet based offerings I've used haven't had the same just-sit-back-and-watch effect as normal TV.

This could simply be the way it's implimented at the moment, though.

2

u/colin8651 May 11 '12

He might be out of touch with technology, but he did invest in HBO go and all of HBO's content in on it.

He can say what he wants, he is not going to be left behind.

2

u/deadcat May 11 '12

HAHAHA YOUR INTERWEBS WILL NEVER SHUT DOWN OUR ADVANCED TELEGRAPH SERVICE!

..now, I wonder what is playing on the wireless? ..Oh look, one of those auto-mobile thingies! ...where did I leave my oatmeal..?.. there are kids on my lawn again!...

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm not going to watch the video (because it's 40 minutes long and I don't care about anything else he says), but the way the Forbes article explains it - particularly the line "tied to the down economy" - implies that what he's actually saying is that people are getting rid of their cable subscription simply because they can't afford it. I'm not sure he's characterizing the entire idea of internet TV as a fad; if he is, then of course he's retarded. Furthermore, I think most people who got rid of their cable subscription aren't coming back unless they are big sports fans and truly got rid of it out of necessity. So he's pretty much wrong regardless, but the degree of his stupidity is very much up in the air.

2

u/PEW_PEW_lasers_n_you May 11 '12

yea...that's exactly what Blockbuster said about Netflix and why they didn't buy them...just a fad. Get with the times, Kessler!

2

u/atheisthindu May 11 '12

Let me add my voice to this clarion call for HBO to change the way it does business in the internet world. I have cut my cord and I have the HBOGo app on Roku, but it's useless, because I don't have a cable subscription too.

Hey HBO, make it $10/month and I will sign up - TODAY!

2

u/DrDebG May 11 '12

Funny, that's what the newspaper biz said.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

HBO gets money every month from people who subscribe to it

HBO also gets TONS of money from the satellite and cable companies because having HBO available as a channel attracts a lot of subscribers

If HBO started offering their shows on the internet the cable and satellite companies would drop the channel.

To make up for this HBO, now a company whose only customers are from the internet will need to charge a shit ton more per month.

So now all the people that are unwilling to $60+ per month on cable to get hbo will need to spend 60+ bucks per month for HBO internet to be viable. The fact is if HBO tries to sell their shows on the internet then they will go out of business.

2

u/zrag123 May 11 '12

Surely i must speak for every Australian on reddit when i say we will go pirate that shit and maybe buy the seasons on disc when it comes out because regardless we still can't watch it here.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Famous last words, if you ask me.

2

u/Pedobear_Slayer May 11 '12

"The internet is just a passing fad" - Disgraced Borders books CEO

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That is going to be one of those quotes people read 20 years from now and laugh at how ridiculous it is.

2

u/terdwrassler May 11 '12

Be right back, applying for HBO upper level management! Seriously what an idiot.

2

u/definiteangel May 11 '12

In future news, HBO has declared bankruptcy all thanks to Eric Kessler.

2

u/xanthrax33 May 11 '12
  1. Eric Kessler refuses to change business strategy.

  2. GoT becomes less profitable.

  3. HBO assume less viewers/fans.

  4. Cancel GoT.

It'll be like Firefly all over again :(. Someone fire Eric!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Agent9262 May 11 '12

With this type of thinking Kessler's job will be a fad that will pass.

2

u/argv_minus_one May 11 '12

Funny. I think HBO is just a fad that will pass.

2

u/labrutued May 11 '12

Additionally, I doubt this silly infatuation with the motor-car will last much longer. Something as timeless as the horse won't vanish overnight.

2

u/jesse_h May 11 '12

If my tv would seamlessly let me watch Internet shows with absolute ease, then i would disagree with him.

2

u/carebeartears May 11 '12

Hmm, I haven't sat in front of a television in years..yet, I watch my shows daily. That's pretty long for a fad.

2

u/papajohn56 May 11 '12

Remember when Borders and Barnes and Noble said Internet sales were a fad, then Amazon came and started crushing them?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

And yet hd boxes have ip addresses.

2

u/bingaman May 11 '12

Here Lies Eric Kessler

He could not understand what he was paid not to understand

2

u/alphadogkp May 11 '12

I smell another Kodak film. You know, the camera and film company that used to be relevant that said digital photography was a fad and stuck to film. Or maybe that old movie rental place Blockbuster, that said that people still enjoy going to a video store...so they can drive 10 minutes to find out the movie they wanted was not there and the alternative choice was going to cost them $20 in backlogged late fees...

2

u/thatguy1056 May 11 '12

Yeah this whole "internet" thing will blow over soon.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Like those damn horseless carriages and talkies! Flashes in the pan!

And also, get off my lawn!!!

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Talkies will be out soon too. And that newfangled color film, too.

2

u/Twiny May 11 '12

If he is too blind and too dumb to see that 25 million downloads is more than a fad... Well, HBO ought to be looking for someone who can recognize the growing failure of their business model, and fix it.

2

u/RobReynalds May 11 '12

And we will use the blood of these dinosaurs for sustenance as our fathers did before us.

2

u/Bitterfish May 11 '12

In other news, Eric Kessler spends 75% of his salary on crack, which he smokes constantly.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

How can a company that produces some of the best TV shows out there be so backward?

It also cancels all the good TV shows it produces.

→ More replies (1)